10 simple rules that make good games great
Transcript
this video is brought to you by the three minute board game patrons keep us Independent by supporting us on patreon kyota Koto welcome all I'm Jake from three minute board games and this list is all about those individual rules and board games that tip a game over from good to great now every single one of these games I'm going to mention are games I personally really dig and the bit I'm going to zero in on is the specific rule in the game that flip the game from me going this is a really cool game too oh wow this game's amazing I love it and I'm going to talk about the implications of not necessarily having that rule in the game how that game would feel if that role didn't exist because there's a ton of moving parts and board games and drilling down to find out that individual little spark that turned the game from good to great sounds like a fascinating experience for me and we're going to be looking directly at the rule books right at the source material and pulling up the passage and going that's the moment the game became great and we're going to kick it off with the game I have played a disturbing amount of time number one that's right it's akamara's second edition a game whose inclusion on the channel will surprise absolutely no one now Arkham is a great Cooperative game it's a game that's hit the template for a lot of co-op games that came after it there's a lot to do in Arkham moving around the board fighting monsters gaining Clues ceiling Gates it creates an emergent narrative and every time you replant something different happens it's a Neato game but here's the bit of the rule book where it goes from good to great
spin include tokens on skill checks clue tokens represent information about the Mythos threat that an investigator May acquire a player may spend clue tokens one at a time after any skill check failed or not each spent clue token allows the player to roll one additional die and the result is a success it is added to the total from the original role now that might sound innocuous but Clues are used to seal gates in the game which is one of the main ways of winning and you need five of them to seal a gate it's a serious investment but because you can spend this important resource on say desperately trying to pass a role sometimes you get in the situation where you're like ah well I've got six Clues I can spin one and then you roll the die and then you still fail and you're like oh I guess I can go back around get another clue I don't really want to like get knocked unconscious and lose all my Clues so you roll again and again and you end up in the cycle of following a sunk cost fallacy we're like well I've spent three Clues already I really have to pass this test it's already cost me this amount of Clues and that's where Arkham Horror is really brilliant where you trick yourself into spending your important resource Clues into passing uh a check out of desperation and this cool economy is a really important part of the game how you manage that acquiring of Clues because at the start of the game they're quite easy to get but they become a lot harder as the game progresses and you have to be clear about how you farm extra Clues how you get extra Clues how much the particular character you're playing can afford to spin Clues instead of closing gates with them and there's a
lot of great decision points in there and it's one of the reasons why Eldritch Horror in particular didn't work for me because it didn't have this clue economy later on with some of the expansions they introduced the ability of the focus that gave you more re-rolls but it didn't have this I've got eight re-rolls I need to keep five can I afford to just keep burning them on this roll none of that happens in eldrachara and that is I think the primary reason why I bounced off that game so game number one that I think is great because of a single rule is Arkham Horror second edition
number two the second game on this list is actually two games one of which I reviewed very recently that game is archaeus society and the other game is ethnos which archaeus society is based off now both games are hand management games we are trying to collect sets in your hands and play them the difference is Akio Society is a bit of a point salad game that's low conflict and ethnos is area control game that is high conflict but I think the rule that makes the game great is this one and it's the last step in the procedure when you've played a collection out of your hand and it says finally you must return all cards still in your hand to the display so that means if you've got a big hand of cards and you play down a set that uses up only two of say the five cards you've got in your hand those other five cards have to go back into the central display for everyone else to pick over it means you can't hoard cards it means every time you're drawing a card you're trying to match a set it's a real real risk that you're going to have to discard a whole bunch of meaningless cards later on in the game and I think it's this key decision Point inside both ethnos and archaeus Society then make those games really really good
toru number three now the third game has three distinct rules but they're very much variations on the same core concept and each of these rules is about how you consume three different resources and those resources are coal iron and beer and of course the game is brass Birmingham now we're not going to read through the whole rules for this but the essence of it is that when you go to spend coal iron or beer if there is an available Supply from another player you can use their resources and if you do use all their resources that flips their building over and that normally gives them a huge boost in both victory points and potential income and it's this interconnected nature of brass Birmingham that makes it such a great game you can see that someone's going to expand out to a certain part of the map and you build a coal mine right there and of course they want to use coal to extend their Network so they end up buying coal off you which advantages you so if there's a real opportunistic style of play here and that's what brings brass Birmingham to life if it wasn't a game where you could use other people's resources and that Advantage them people would start building their assets away from people or if you had to just build your own infrastructure it would be a very traditional well I'm just building up My Little Empire here well you do your own damn thing over here because you can use each other's resources and because it's advantageous to do so the game is really interconnected and the players are really interconnected and you care about what other people are building and I think ultimately that's what elevates brass from being a run-of-the-mill type game to what is currently board game geek's number one
game far number four the next game on our list is Twilight Struggle a game published by GMT games the same company that is producing my game Red Dust Rebellion now with that disclaimer out of the way Twilight Struggle is a brilliant game that revolves around card play and when it's your turn you can choose to play a card for either its operations value to take actions on the board or as an event that is unless it's a card that has your opponent's event on it in which case this rule comes into play events associated with your opponent if a player plays a card as an operation and that cards event is associated only with his opponent the event still occurs and the card of it has an asterisk after the event tile is removed now you can choose to resolve your operation first before the event goes off or have the event go off and then do your operation so you can mitigate some of the damage you can also choose to play the card possibly late in the round to minimize its impact or early in the ground so that you can deal with the damage it's done but if you draw a hand like the one I've got here which is almost entirely red cards and you are playing the American well you're going to have a pretty grisly turn with some tough decisions on what you're going to play and how you're going to mitigate that damage but because these are balanced um across the decks if you've got a hand of their cards they'll almost certainly got a hand of yours and that makes for an interesting game so yeah if you just played from two different Decks that had their own events Twilight Struggle would be a very different game but it's the
fact that the game is based around mitigating all of these events from your opponents so you draw Fidel um you do not want early in the game a bunch of Russian influence popping up in Cuba you want that as far away from America as possible so what do you do you you've got to either fire it to the space race or hold it and hide it or play it and just deal with the consequences and I think that's really at its core what makes Twilight Struggle the barnstorming mega hit game that it was and the very popular title it still is
Rima number five sometimes I look at a board game and I go oh yeah I could probably have pulled that together that's some pretty clever ideas but you know it's not really pushing the envelope too much and other times look at a game and go how the fudge should they come up with that and one of those games is sidereal Confluence this mad mad asymmetric trading game uh with up to nine players and just how this game is pulled together and the complexities within it and the interactions with it it's one of those games that you could spend a long long time analyzing just how deep and Rich and experienced sidereal Confluence is but for me there's one aspect to it aside from the the great asymmetry and the real-time trading and all that stuff in it that tips it over from being a good game to a great game and it's this rule during the trade phase you may freely exchange resources ships cards and promises you may not trade victory points all Agreements are binding trading players must agree to what is being traded before it happens neither can cheat the other by withholding what has been agreed upon trains that involve action later in the turn or on future turns are still binding so a lot of that's pretty normal the fact that trades are binding and you can't lie that's all good the bit that sticks out to me is trading on later turns that you can say can I have one resource and I'll pay you back to next term or I'll pay you back three on turn four and by one of the factions the the imdrill in the uh guidebook where they're talking about how to get this faction going they say
that you you need nine turns to get their economy up to full speed uh but the game only lasts six so you have to Big burrow and steal in those early rounds and go I can produce lots of stuff later on please loan me two things I will give you four things in two turns and that's fascinating I think it showcases just how different the player powers and different factions are within this game and just how deep you can get into the economy within sidereal Confluence that there's Wheels within wheels and so much clever trading and clever thinking both within the game and and playing the game because it doesn't play the same time each time you play it either it's really clever and I think it's that fact that the trades are fixed that trades are solid and you have to abide by them but that you can trade across multiple turns it just opens up a world of possibilities and I think if you've got to do a trading game and you're going to do one as complex and involved as sidereal Confluence having this particular role just is the icing on the cake that makes it a brilliant game
onu number six the next game up is when we have it actually reviewed on the channel well we kind of have we've reviewed a version of the game but not the original game itself and the game we've reviewed as Kayla 1303 and the game itself is careless so for those of you aren't aware kalis is one of the games that really made worker placement a big deal when it came out and is generally considered an incredibly influential worker placement game to this very day but the single rule that makes it really great for me is there's this marker on the board called the Provost and the Provost can be moved up and down the board and so you say well what's the big deal about this Provost moving up and down the board what does that mean well let's look at the rule book for Kayla's 1303 buildings placed after the Provost these buildings are not activated workers that are placed there are returned to the camp so in most worker placement games you place a worker you get to do something with them in Kaylas that is not necessarily true the further you are along the path the less likely you are to be able to use that worker because players will conspire against you if they see you getting a whole bunch of resources or points from using buildings at the end of the line they will move the Provost forward and you have to do everything in your power to ensure that doesn't happen and it's the fact that players can work together to cancel other players actions and that the lower resource generating and lower Point scoring buildings tend to be towards the safe end of the line which creates just a really fascinating Dynamic how much do I push my luck out in order to use the best buildings knowing that there's a
chance that I won't get anything from them I think that's what makes Kayla's a really great game and I'm glad that they kept that feature when they remade Kaylas as Kayla's 1303 number seven another game I talk about a lot is leaving Earth and leaving Earth has an awful lot going forward it's a fantastic Space Race game but it's also quite a heavy game with a lot of math and calculations and I really dig that it's not for everyone it is an acquired taste of a game but it's still a great game and the single most important thing in the game the single best feature is the following rule you see every time you use a new piece of technology in this game you have to do a check to see if it's working and you're dealt three cards and these three cards are you will shuffle them up and every time you use that piece you will reveal one and if it's a success it costs 10 money to remove but if it's a failure it only costs five money to remove so a failure is obvious you correct that failure it cost you five now you're down to only two cards in hand but if you draw a success do you actually want to pay the 10 bucks to remove it go down to two cards these can all be successes you don't know you're not sure and in some games you
can go oh I've tested this multiple times and never had a problem but inside the successes you actually got a major failure in there and it blows up when you first go to use it properly and it's just such a great system that success is harder to move forward from than failure and most people I know who play this game would prefer to get two or three failures in their um outcomes deck rather than three successes Even though three successes means that piece is never going to fail you just don't know that you're just not sure of that and you can easily spend 20 bucks which is a lot of money in game figuring out that Yes actually this piece Works 100 all the time and I just find that a fascinating gameplay Loop because if a player has tested their stuff quite well and they're just about to launch a mission you can actually sometimes times jumped the gun on someone and just fire a mission together to try to land on Mars first just using kit that hasn't been tested properly and just hope that the oxygen system works and hope that the landing gears work and that's part of what makes the game really really fun for me is the risk element in there and the fact that success is way harder to move forward from than failure
thank you number eight now the next game is one I don't hear a lot of people talking about it's a Cooperative game and it's called the reckoners it looks like your typical big bloated over-the-top Kickstarter trash and in some ways it is exactly that it is a big bloated over-the-top Kickstarter game but I really dig it I really dig what it does specifically it's rule with how Cooperative gameplay works in the game because so many games like Arkham Horror pandemic they have a thing where you take your turn then stuff happens and the reckon is everyone's turns happen at the same time let's have a look at the specific rule use dice once all players have finished rolling their dice all players will simultaneously use their dice players work together to decide the order and the way in which their dice are used so what this means is if you're rolling six dice each for each player you can mix and match your actions back and forth you can have one player take two actions in a run then the next player takes something and then third player jump in and do stuff so you can have players move to a location and do teamwork and then move off together it's really clever and I guess it's probably prone to Alpha gaming maybe but with a great group you just get this Buzz going of oh we need to knock three off there I've got two of you got one called let's both move over there we'll do that okay now it's open we need the big heavy hitter
guy to come in and he's going to do the damage to knock this guy down and a lot of co-op games you do get some of that aspects but I've never played one like the reckoners where every action you are all just piling and allocating this big part of resource of what you're gonna do and I think more co-op games should get away from the my turn bad guy's turn your turn bad guys turn third player's turn bad guys turn kind of model and move to a more actually we're a group here we can collectively act we can decide on a collective course of action and the reckoners does it really really well and if you are designing a Cooperative game and you are looking at something that makes it feel really Cooperative uh the recognize dice system where everyone can take their actions in any damn order and that's all up to how the players decide it it's really really neat and a very different experience and the reason why I keep the reckoners in my collection number nine now the second the last game is pandemic The Cure the dice version of pandemic and then pandemic with you each character has their own special set of custom dice now in a normal game like this you would get the Yahtzee system which is that you can roll the dice three times in fact the record is the previous game uses the Yahtzee system as well roll the set of dice choose some to keep roll them again roll the others again choose some to keep and enroll a third time keeping the final result that's the standard sort of Yahtzee Cooperative dice system in pandemic the
Q follow that system in fact they do something quite bizarre and quite different and I really dig it and here's the rule role player Dyson do actions roll all of your player dice each die will show either an action or a biohazard symbol action results are good biohazard results are bad actions an action can be spent to do that action or it can be re-rolled you may re-roll a die showing an action result any number of times but once it is spent you cannot re-roll it or spin the game this turn now biohazard results are bad and there is one on every single die but you can keep re-rolling your action dice as many times as you want until they turn up a biohazard die then they're locked that means you can push your luck if you desperately need a specific symbol you can keep rolling that die until either it pops up or The Biohazard pops up and that to me is really really clever it's just a really clever push-uluck mechanic it adds a crap load of tension to the game when you're playing it because Biohazard are really bad you do not want to be rolling five biohazards but if you need those cures and you need them right then and there you keep rolling the dice until good result or bad result and that's why pandemic liqueur is actually a game I enjoy more than the original pandemic because of this one particular dice mechanic I think it's really neat and a lot of fun and very stressful number 10.
and the follow one on this list is the silly one to close it off and I'm including this because it does actually Elevate the game that game is roll camera and in the rule book there's this wacky little weird Rule and it goes a little something like this player boards also feature a player privilege a unique persistent metagame Authority or benefit which you may choose to use at any time they have no direct effect on gameplay and are just meant to facilitate a bit of role-playing and silliness you can agree at the game start to play with these or ignore these privileges if you agree you must honor and abide by the Privileges of other players some of the player privileges include things like the cinematographer you may adjust the lighting in the room however you wish the sound guy you may make sound effects while other players do things on their turn the director you may request that other players especially their emotions more theatrically the star you may request Applause from the audience at any time and the composer You may hum or sing songs of your choice during the game these things they don't directly impact the gameplay uh as such but they create such a fantastic atmosphere at the table it takes what's reasonably okay Cooperative game and turns it into a very very special experience here's a picture of me and my friends being absolute idiots uh our prop manager has made us wear Christmas hats and I'm conducting along some music as I'm trying to think what my action is
just makes the game a lot of fun and when it comes down to it the greatness in games is that they're fun and enjoyable um and roll camera again I've said this before might not be the greatest game when it comes to sheer mechanical Brilliance but it's one of those games that every time I put it on the table it makes people laugh and it makes people smile and it makes people tell stories about the time they played roll camera and for me that's what really matters in a board game not that it's an intellectually satisfying experience but that it generates a story and that that story is fun and that story is something that you and your friends reflect back on and go remember the time we had to do that stupid thing that's why roll cameras are a really neat game and that's why that particular rule makes it a great game now this list was in no a particular order I just kind of picked the games as we went so this isn't rated from top 10 to bottom 10. it's just 10 games that go from good to great because of a single rule and if you enjoyed this video a reminder the three minute board games does not do paid content we are not hype men we do not do Kickstarter videos we make fun videos about board games for the sake of it and we're entirely kept financially going by patreon and YouTube Revenue so if you do want to see more real content and board gaming and a lot less hype consider backing a channel like three minute board games and until next time I've been Jay from three minute board games got you down or take care
thank you