Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 7

Transcript 16:04

hi everyone today i'll be talking about another 10 games that have left my collection and i'll be explaining the reasons for that so let's get started with the first game so the first game i'm going to be talking about is lord of the rings the confrontation now this is an extremely rare two-player only game where one person takes the role of the shadow player one person takes control of the fellowship and it almost has this stratego vibe where all your player pieces are kind of faced away from your opponent where only you can see which where each character is there is kind of two sides of the board where one side is like the mordor side one is the kind of shire side and you are moving your player pieces kind of one space at a time into the adjacent regions i'm trying to basically or if you're the good player you're trying to get the ring to uh to mount doom and if you are the the evil player you are trying to find the ring bearer or basically uh eliminate all your opponents or get all your pieces to the other side of the board and destroy the shire um so quite thematic in that sense all the different characters in the game have different powers um such as you know being able to move sideways where that's not normally a rule and you know if certain pieces are in certain spots and you go somewhere then that can automatically eliminate things um so you have lots of different unique player powers between all those different pieces and but on top of that whatever these two pieces would collide or from each side that is they'll be revealed and then there'll be basically a face-off and a fight and that would be that would consist of people playing a card from their hand and simultaneously revealing their straight values or special powers and deciphering who is the winner and

deciphering who will be eliminated from the board so this is a very tense game i'm extremely confrontational as you'd expect by the name but it works very well the only reason this one left my collection was because of that simultaneous card player i found that a bit too paper rock scissors-like and a bit too swingy and i would have liked it if the if the gameplay would have been just left to the um just just the player pieces and on top of that i went through a bit of a phase where i didn't really enjoy these kind of head-to-head um you know brutal games like this but i've started to kind of adopt them again back into my collection and annoyingly i probably could have kept hold of this one because it is so valuable now but a really solid two-player game but was just a little bit too swingy in the card play for me and um just left me a little bit i'm satisfied but a really good game i'd recommend that is lord of the rings the confrontation uh the next game i'm going to be talking about is immensely popular this is lords of water deep so this is a dungeons and dragons themed worker placement game but don't let that put you off this is very um accessible one regarded as one of the um most welcoming and uh introductory gateway worker placement games out there and it does that very well so simple and clean mechanically just placing workers on these different locations collecting the resources which are supposed to represent different adventurers and cashing them in to fulfill contracts i have a bit of a strange relationship with worker placement games and

particularly ones that don't do anything special because i think there's a lot of them out there um so so many kind of uh just different rethemes or different skins or a very similar game lots of water steep i think was one of the stronger examples because on this one you could go to certain spots and invest in these buildings which would make new work placement spots where people could go to and could get you a resource if someone went there so i really like that has some good card playing this one as well and but i think this game had a bit of a ceiling for me um i think once you start playing more heavier and more involved work placement games then the need for this one kind of disappeared um and on top of all that um i found that the some of the cards in the game called mandatory quests really left me quite annoyed i didn't like that mechanism at all where you could force cards on other players and basically draw them to a halt by having to complete a mission before they were going to do what they planned on doing and that that i didn't quite like that take that mechanism i thought it was just a bit a bit annoying um but still a really solid game one that i'd recommend as an introductory game into kind of euro mechanisms and the next game i'm going to be talking about is lords of zidic now lords of zida is quite an interesting game it's a programming game as you have these player boards you are programming your actions what you're going to do from turn to turn by traveling around the map picking up different adventurers going to slay these monsters that was all pretty cool i mean if people could kind of jump in the spaces before you if they program their balls in a certain way so you have to kind of get into into the

head of your opponent and think what they would do and uh to kind of divert your course of action accordingly so that was really cool looks of looks very nice a very beautiful looking game and the the reason i this one to stay in my collection was number one uh we played it quite a bit in a short space of time so i kind of got a bit fatigued with it and i think it will it did have a shelf life as well uh there wasn't a tremendous amount of kind of variability and replayability here but something i really did like about this game was the scoring mechanism where you would basically be graded on three different criteria in three different orders or in different orders from round to round or game to game and you basically just have to scrape through not being bottom on the first two criteria and then win the third criteria and i thought that was really interesting as you're trying to control these regions you're trying to build these towers so that scoring mechanism really did make it stand you know stand on its own and i did like that a solid game again quite an entry level game but one that worked well but ultimately for me i just i just had my time with it i had my fun with it and it was time to move it on next game i'm going to be talking about is magic maze now this is a cooperative real-time game as you are moving around this mall trying to pick up all these different um artifacts with these different adventures and then get out you've got a time limit on this game if you're trying to work against these sounds against these sound timers and the kind of unique thing about this game is that you don't have your own player piece everybody is controlling all the player pieces together um but one person would be moving them kind of north one would be moving them south or east or west

and you have to move them by just moving around this board and uh another kind of wrinkle to the game was you cannot communicate with your teammates at all and one of the pieces in the game is that you if you believe your opponent or your sorry your co-workers or your colleagues um how to do something to move all your pieces you have to put this big red token in front of them just say like you need to move this player piece otherwise we're stuck and we can't do anything a really fun game really novel very innovative and i did enjoy my time with this one it had a kind of a mission-based thing where you'd kind of ramp up the complexity as you went through it um but i think you know the more i played this one i did get i did get it to the table quite a few times i think the novelty wore off it was time to move it on and try something different but one that i really enjoyed having the collection for a long time and i've had some fun with this one the next game i'm going to be talking about is masquerade now masquerade is a rather simple bluffing and hidden roll style game which you are activating these powers on these cards um and trying to basically race to get a certain amount of money uh the powers are going to do things such as shifting your money with someone else's stealing money with other players using top decking cards from a deck and trying to use their powers so lots of different things these rollers would do one of the most beautiful looking games i've ever played probably my favorite artwork actually ever used in a card game i think it's absolutely stunning um but the gameplay itself was fairly limp but there wasn't a lot this game offered and it was pretty deflating at times or or somewhat

um almost anticlimactic i would say um when the game ended because sometimes someone would kind of fly under the radar activate a certain card and just win instantly um there's a lot of memory in this game as well which i tend to tend not to really like um as and it boiled down to very simple action such as activating a certain power looking at your card or kind of calling the bluff of another player if you don't believe he was acting activating a power that he claimed to have had but some good some good moments here some funny moments as you're swapping cards around and things and i'm just trying to call the bluff of other players but that's all it was it did have a glass ceiling of what this could do and um it was pretty you know pretty standard and nothing amazing here which is a shame because the artwork itself is phenomenal the next game i'm going to be talking about is another really good looking game this one is mask of the red death now this is a game actually really do enjoy it's a deduction game another programming game as you're trying to work out these different locations that the red death is going to attack at when it when the clock hits midnight and you are basically going to program your individual player board accordingly to try and avoid that death as well as being trying to gain your popularity as the game goes on by um you know by schmoozing at these parties um and the winner would be the person with the most popularity who survives by the end of the night some really cool ideas here a good meshing of quite unique mechanisms in terms of the deduction and the programming i think that worked really well again another beautiful looking game absolutely stunning and i think this is a game that would

would have hit more popularity and should maybe be more popular than it is because it is very accessible um again it looks lovely and i think it kind of takes all those boxes which usually make popular games um but i think it just flew somewhat under the radar and again i i tend not to have well this game does really peak at those higher play accounts and um getting higher play accounts for me nowadays isn't um isn't that doesn't happen very often so uh that's why it left my collection uh the next game i'm going to be talking about is medium which is a party game a word-based one as you are working with somebody else by playing these word cards and you're trying to find the medium in between those two word cards so for example someone might say play a card that says animal someone might one say play a card that says uh the ocean and then you've got a kind of make a middle word out of those on the count of three should go three two one and then say your word and maybe you both say fish and if you both said the same word on the first opportunity then you'd get the maximum amount of points if you didn't then you'd work again on the two words you've just said and try and reach the medium between those two words and on the third attempt if you still failed then your time would be over a really simple game that you thought would have been kind of released a long long time ago but it actually only came out in the last couple of years it works well the only thing for me was that i thought the game dragged on a bit too long and yeah just slightly outstanding welcome and additionally because you were only

ever working with one player at a time there would always be some down time for the other players whilst the other players were taking their turns i thought that did kind of bring the energy down in a in a party style game which um still a really solid party game one that i did enjoy but with so many great party games out there this one wouldn't be hitting the table so that's why medium left my collection the next game i'm going to be talking about is meeple war now this is a game that i didn't enjoy this one is a a game or first off i really hate games when you when when they use the word meeple in the title i think it's really cheesy and it doesn't work um but you know irrespective of that the gameplay itself i didn't like either this is a kind of well i suppose you presumed by the name it's a very confrontational another war style game as you are trying to eliminate your players meeples building these buildings putting your workers down on there and moving around the map having big fights um has some good ideas in this one almost this kind of age of empire style game where you'd have these cool downs when you use your buildings when you'd activate a certain build or for example at the start of each round um there'd be these kind of progression tracks on each of the buildings where they would go down these tracks and when they hit certain spots they'll do certain things such as maybe find trebuchets and things like that which was quite cool um but for me the reason i didn't like this game was it had a very much jarring start and stop uh almost tempo to it where you'd build something up then it would stop you'd build something up and then it would stop again by because you'd constantly be killing each

other and it just it just felt a bit i didn't the flow wasn't very good and again it just felt jarring it felt a bit sluggish and it felt a little bit underdeveloped to me um and it just maybe on top of that it just wasn't my style of game so you know naturally it left my collection because i just didn't enjoy it to be fair uh the next game i'm going to be talking about is merchants of maziris this is a really nice little card game something in the vein of jaipur where you are trying to collect these different cars trying to sell them off to get profit this one was had quite a nice um almost multi-use card mechanism to it where not only could you use it to sell but you could use it for the powers themselves on the cards um and it worked really well i think somewhat of a hidden gem here and i think this one did actually um hit my hidden gem list um because it's a really solid game i actually prefer this to jaipur uh simply this game wasn't getting played i'd always go to certain card games if i was to bring out a quick card game this one was on the slighter longer scale i think so normally hitting that 30 to 45 minute mark um really really replayable game lots of variation loads of different scoring criteria and things but i really do struggle to get these games that last this amount of time to the table because i either normally want to play something fast and filler-like or the more involved euro strategy game so those games that kind of fit in that 30 to 45 minute mark do struggle to get the table at least for me because they're not normally the

games i'd suggest to play but no fault of the game on this one it just simply was just sitting in my shelf not being played but a really solid design and one that i still enjoy today and the final game i'm going to be talking about is a game i actually love this one is mombasa by one of my favorite designers alexander fister this one is an amazing game about colonizing africa you are basically going into new land you're trying to control these regions you're trying to increase your shares in these different companies um great worker placement aspect to it as well loads going on here some amazing card play in this game as you are playing these cards these different um discard piles and that kind of dilutes your deck into different piles and at the end of the round you only get to take one of those decks back which can increase or make some really strategic decisions in this one the the reason this one left my collection um was simply because maracaibo came out so maracaibo is very similar to mombasa has a lot of um very comparable mechanisms in that one um such as the uh the shareholding and things almost identical to mombasa and i do prefer maracaibo to one basser and they're both pretty long pretty involved games with big rule sets and i thought that if i had mombasa and maracaibo in my collection then i was just diluting the amount of time that i play either of them i'm always trying to keep a streamlined collection and having two games that are very similar to each other is not optimal for me i would really love to have this game in my collection but i think it just isn't logical for me to have both of

them so maybe one day i will get this one back because the game itself is absolutely incredible you know a fantastic euro game that still stands really high in my top 50. but simply maracaibu i think is is better in every single way and um hence why i'd always go to that one and this one would just be sat on my shelf collecting dust so um it's a shame because it's a solid game way better than most of the things out there on the market but again just something too similar out there on my collection or in my collection so that's another 10 games that i've got rid of and given the reasons why um the reasons why i did that so hopefully you've enjoyed the video and we'll give you an impression about you know whether these games are going to be for you whether they're going to have the staying power so if you have enjoyed the video please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved