Skip to main content
Loading video...

Our Top Board Game SURPRISES of 2022

Transcript 32:44

foreign how's it going everyone I am Dylan this is my cousin Carla this is all you can board uh today we're talking about our some of our top surprises from uh been the board gaming World in 2022. uh we have not played a lot of games for 2022 yet that's the one of the reasons we're not doing our top 10 games of 2022 yeah we have tons of games on our Shelf tons of games we still want to buy that we think would probably crock that list crack that list uh so we can't do it uh in good conscience quite yet but there are some standard surprises so I just want to preface this by saying there's probably even more surprises that we'll eventually discover as we play more games this is based off the games we have played some things that's uh stuck out to us and things that we were already talking about you know as we've discussed things from 2022 being like yeah that was shocking or I didn't expect this and we thought it would be a fun thing to sort of highlight I think we have five of them in total here uh highlight some things that you know stood out to us that surprised us some good some bad and you guys can wait and let us know if you agree with us disagree with us or what you think in general yeah I'm only talking about games that were actually released in 2022 yeah in North America specifically so so the first one I'm going to bring up is the game I recently covered in an owner plate skip it and it's a newer game that I purchased and that is Evergreen uh so Evergreen is on components just went everywhere uh so Evergreen is a game that uh I talked about in a new games video um and I wasn't anticipating a lot and I was expecting to like it the reason it's a surprise for me and you can let me know if this lines up with you or if yours is a little bit different is

photosynthesis is already a game I really like so I wanted to get Evergreen for many of the same reasons I had wanted to originally get photosynthesis but I think there's a part of me that thought I'm gonna get Evergreen I'm going to enjoy it and then it's going to be like a castle of Tuscany castle of Bergen type thing where it's like I'm never gonna appreciate that the same way because my experience at the first game and it's both games aren't gonna maybe live in my collection long term and so I I kind of had a I had expectations but I would say they're a little bit more muted just because I thought well yeah I might like it but I've seen this before the surprise for me came in the fact that Evergreen is a game that I'm fairly certain I'm going to like over time even the more I play it more than photosynthesis I might keep both of my collection for a while because they do play pretty differently which is kind of another surprise they they there's a different aspect to them but I didn't expect to like Evergreen as much as I did there's a lot more games in 2022 I need to play but I think that Evergreen has a decent chance of being a game that's like well definitely in the top five of my games from 2022 and maybe it ends up being like a top three game from 2022 like I've really enjoyed both players I played it at two and three I thought both were solid and it it just it shocked me how satisfying it was to play with the components how nice the game was overall and how it found a way to differentiate itself yeah no I agree honestly it came as a pretty big surprise to me too I don't own photosynthesis um I haven't and I don't like it quite as much as you but I've had every time we've played photosynthesis in the past I really enjoyed it but haven't had that kind of like when I see it on your shelf

when you come over to the game I haven't had that burning desire to say like let's play it again and when I heard about Evergreen I saw the Box saw that all the artwork components I was reading about it I also thought it was going to be way more similar and I almost felt when you told me you bought it at first there was like a oh no kind of feeling because I thought it was going to be so similar and then when you showed it to me we played it I had this feeling of like this might be better than photosynthesis and even if you said like you said even if you do end up getting rid of one or the other I would bet that you'll you're more likely to keep this than photosynthesis even if you're close on your opinion of both just because this one is going to land with more uh with more people like this will be easier to show other people and be more inviting yeah whereas I feel like photosynthesis has a higher chance of being maybe too mean for some people or or whatnot and this one just feels a little more like polished which you mentioned when you reviewed it just feels like they've really taken their time to develop everything well and it's just yeah yeah I think I expected there to be polish based on like things I had seen about the components but I still didn't expect it to be as satisfying to play with all the components and like and with the Dual layer player board and everything fits together and I just I didn't I wasn't as convinced that they were going to find a way to take this formula from photosynthesis and say we're going to repackage this and it's going to feel like it's going to feel like it has it carves its own spot yeah and it you know is different enough and even different enough that you could own both and it wouldn't be ridiculous like I could have both and I could see the two situations I'd want to bring each one out in yeah and it's it's because if you were to ask someone like hey give me a couple sentence recap of what you do in Evergreen versus photosynthesis the

recap would be almost identical yeah oh the trees block the you know all that stuff is almost the same so you're like so what's different about them and then you play them and they're like very different somehow have that Common Thread still yeah Evergreen is is your focus on your own player board and the cards is what is causing you to have player to interaction whereas in photosynthesis where you're actually placing the trees and the light and everything is where everyone is placing so it becomes more competitive for space that way and yet somehow but you don't lose all the internet even though they say hey you're going on your own board now we're not fighting in this thing like I would have expected that to lose way more than your action and it's maybe a little less interactive than photosynthesis not by much and in a way that I think works really well because of you don't want people messing with you the entire game when you're trying to plan for these scoring conditions and stuff like it just strikes that balance really well yeah surprise hit uh Evergreen for me and I think for both of us in different ways and can't wait to play it more and see exactly where it uh lands yeah I especially want to try it with four players yeah yeah me too that's Evergreen our first surprise yep okay now uh I'm gonna talk so one of my biggest surprises of the year and this was an unfortunate surprise this has so far been a bit disappointing uh that is fire and stone so this is from Pegasus Spiel uh this is designed by Klaus Jurgen Verde who designed Carcassonne which was my Gateway game one of still my favorite games of all time especially as a two-player game um we did get this sent to us as a review copy from Pegasus Spiel this was actually when we did our top anticipated most anticipated games for 2021 or I guess it would have been for 2022.

um this was I think my number two remote or three most anticipated game not only because of the pedigree of the designer and the fact that he was responsible for Carcassonne but I had read through the entire rule book before we did that most anticipated games video and the game had a lot of Promise the rules sounded so interesting to me this game where you uh are basically spreading it over the map um you it's sort of like there's these hidden tokens that are face down and you're kind of exploring when you get to a spot you get to flip over the token and see what's there you can discover campfires you can find uh you can get like animals to cook you can find find little like berries and things to collect that lead to little upgrades on your board you can find um I'm forgetting what else you can find now there's all kinds of stuff that you can do throughout the game though and every you know there's like you can quit when you cook animals at a fire you go back to a certain spot on the map and as the game goes on you can reach new parts of the of the map that weren't uh accessible before as the game goes on there's these like uh Cave tiles like every game there's one single cave and no one knows where it is at first and once you discover the cave it reveals this kind of unique ability and there's a big deck of these cave cards all these things sounded interesting and we've played the game twice so far with two players and with three players and I'll just say right now like this is definitely by no means uh an official review or final thoughts like we will be covering this probably in an Own It plate or skip it video on the channel in the next hopefully a couple months um but so far it has felt like all the things to me that sounded promising or interesting fell short of what my expectations were whether it's the caves whether it's the flipping over the tokens whether it's the things that you're collecting that have the Bonanza style where you're trying to collect

multiple of these to get these rewards like everything just felt like oh I was expecting a little more from that and I think the reason why it shocked me is that so Pegasus Spiel we we like a lot of their games like we've reviewed uh both the micromat first micro macro games on the channel uh we recently played hanza dotonica which made it into my top 10 um yeah and so like and they do a lot of balance like Honda is not a family game micromacro is this is a family game this was my most again my most anticipated game from pegasuspiel of the year and we're going to talk about two other games shortly one Associated this and one is one of your surprises that actually as a family game surprised me and I like those both more than Firestone so far yeah and this is just weird because it just it feels like who's this game being marketed to because as a family game I feel like the theme team isn't an artwork aren't super exciting if you're like playing parents and kids together but it doesn't feel like a sort of like Gamers game it feels like the mechanics of it are made to be a family game but the theme isn't so it sits in this weird the theme like matches the aspect of like Discovery like yes like early ages of the world and stuff like that and discovering things like that I understand but I I hear what you're saying like but maybe they needed to go with a more cartoonish artwork again or something yeah instead of it like the way it looks in like endless winter or something you know yeah I think you're right and especially after the family is like the target yeah for me I just like the biggest thing in this is like might seem like vager generalized but like it's important for board games is I didn't leave any that any of the games I played a fire in stone feeling like super excited by the

experience or like that it was that there was moments where I was having tons of fun and and that's like obviously what you look for when you're playing games and it just didn't have that and one of the biggest stand-up things for me that I remember I I said it both times we played that just seemed odd to me and you're gonna have to fill in a couple gaps if you remember it's been a while since I I played for the exact rules but when it comes to the majority when with having your uh the little Huts or whatever and like it becomes like a bit of an area control type thing like Whoever has the most Huts like we'll get the points associated that where that those were going to take place was very random based on what tiles got flipped like you couldn't just be like I'm gonna go and place one here you have to have there's specific conditions where you could place these huts and it meant that it ended up being less competitive and interesting to compete for spots and and also your private objective uh like was also kind of like random depending on where things flipped that like there yeah you just there was less planning more luck in that sense that I would like more unsatisfying luck than I was expecting right and just like for how much Discovery should be fun and should be this thing of like what's under here what's under here it just it never really there's some moments where you've listened over and you're like oh that is a big deal but it just felt like a lot of it was just like and there's that under there yeah it's like these little incremental like you flip you're like oh cool I'll collect this and then you're like okay but like you said there's no big turns there's no exciting moments in the game it's just this like slow slow build yeah and then ends and you count points and you just kind of feel like I don't know I was just expecting more from it and the k card I think and I

don't get too specific but like the cave card I I in my opinion those cards need to be like drastic yeah well that's that was the thing that excited me most about the game and that so far has been the biggest letdown I looked through a couple of the other ones but I try not to look through too many because I want them to be a surprise when they came come up in the game but again we will play a lot more of this uh and especially at four because I can imagine that four is probably the best player count so again by no means final thoughts on this or anything but on this note I want to really quickly mention because there was a game that at the time that I got this game and when I was talking about his most anticipated or whatever there were two other games from Pegasus Spiel one in particular that I'm going to talk about that I didn't even know existed at the time found out about this one recently picked it up I've only played the solo mode which is definitely not even going to be where it's best and this already I like more than fire and stone and it's from the same company Pegasus Spiel and that is first rat so this is another kind of family weight game and this is the same entry in my surprise thing check the times down below we're not talking about a separate surprise but because I've only again played this once but theme and gameplay like right away as a family weight game if you just look at these boxes yeah what like excites you more to play with your kids or if your kids to play with your parents like no doubt it's the game where you're a rat building a rocket ship out of scrap pieces at the scrap yard going to fly to the cheese moon like of course this theme is going to be more exciting and then the gameplay itself even as a solo game where you're just activating one single bot was way more interesting so I'm not going to get too into the mechanics of this or anything because again I've only played it once we'll play it a bunch more we'll cover this in review on the channel but that was that

me playing this recently made me even more surprised by fire and stone in my impressions of it so yeah we're gonna play more of these and cover them both in the channel and I know this is sort of a two-in-one slot here but uh yeah I'll leave it if there's anything you want to add about this one I know you haven't had a chance to try first rat yet no I think the cover doll yeah just it's a prize I think the biggest part of the surprise is that for a game that was number two on your list of most anticipated yeah to quickly be replaced by a game that like like first rather it wasn't even really on our radar and I would say so far I like first rat like a lot more than fire and stone and there's another family weight game from Pegasus that I also like a lot more than fire and stone so far which Dylan is going to talk about which is my surprise and that is a game called Fife so this is our other big surprise for 2022 uh positive surprise with this one this is a really simple family weight game that I really the reason and we requested a review copy for this and and were sent one and thanks to Pegasus Spiel for sending this um the main reason I wanted to play was it looked beautiful like the the colors the artwork the the the the board and the fact that it's dual layered and the way you insert these pieces like I was just like hey like at the very least having a family weekend that's this beautiful I can see opportunities to get to the stable I'd be curious to see if the gameplay holds up I don't think I think I came in with expectations that were painted a little bit by games that we had recently played in the family region like Savannah Park which I like Savannah Park and I played him multiple times I with people that also ends up liking it but I never left a session of

Savannah park being like I'll ever suggest that or that like it really resonated for me in a big way where so I kind of had that same expectation with Fife and I've compared the two games a lot Fife for some reason for a game that is just about placing you know you have two options of of tiles that are that you can choose from and you're replacing whichever one you you place you just have to place on your board somewhere but they come in five different symbols and five different numbers and five different colors and there's different combinations that it'll end up in and you have these objectives that you have to slot into the these different insets on the side of your board to determine how that that horizontal diagonal line horizontal line or vertical line art would I think it did then the reverse um how each of those is going to score and so you're gonna score different rows different columns and everything differently every game game you play depending where you insert those objectives so you have to kind of say where am I going to place these tiles to you know get those points or after I place these certain amount of tiles what can I still score that I haven't placed yet so that I don't like lose a bunch of progress I've done then you use you slot that in sometimes you're required to slot those objectives in signs you you don't have to depending where you place your your tiles and there's a bit of a race because the first person to complete an objective from everyone at the table gets bonus points so even though there's not a lot of player interaction because everyone's working on their own board that race element and seeing how close everyone is is a big deal and does the bonus points do end up mattering the final score so that whole combination of everything somehow works it just it just it feels satisfying it's different enough every game it is

endlessly satisfying to take the the pieces feel really really good and putting them into the into your board and just like everything looking as beautiful as it does it's a combination of all those things that just made Fife one of the underdog surprises 2022 because this is not not a game like this was not my top 50 of all time or either of ours like it's not a game that's going to be one of our favorites of all time and yet I could see this and I think I said this before I think I said it when I reviewed it I want to play it skip it as a game that gets played a lot in in our collection just because it's really easy to play with with almost any group of people and and the first time I introduced this to two of my friends that don't play board games all that often it was a huge hit and it reminded me that like there are people out there that if they don't play a lot of board games they play one like this this is it's wild to them like the amount of decision making well it feels like we I think we talked about this before too this feels like something that could have been an app or like some online puzzle game that you get addicted to playing the way that you're just like moving things around like there's something kind of traditional and an old school feel about it but it has this really kind of newer uh really vibrant presentation and the artwork and stuff and I really like how early on it you get the feeling of kind of a relaxing um easy going like family weight game in the first like half or even two thirds three quarters of the game kind of thing and and then at the end you feel a bit of this squeeze where you're like oh shoot I really have fewer options or if I put something here I'm not going to score any points for this tile and but it still works for a family game and so it's not the same feeling all the way through but it's also not punishing the whole time it just yeah it does it does

a really good thing with that game Mark I really like it and it feels like Calico with the yeah the the conditions with the car the the colors and the the symbols on them and stuff and I didn't mention your favorite part or I think you've said it's your favorite part which is the seashells the powers right yeah I do like those a lot but like you get all those points like you start the game with all the points from the seashells each seashell is worth a certain amount of points you will score those at the end of the game but every time you use a seashell you're abandoning those points so something that's a really powerful ability might lose you six points for using this you have to weigh how badly do I want that how much do I want to do that to be able to gain more points by it allowing me to like move tiles on my board or whatever and it plays up to five which for a game that has simultaneous play is a big deal because it's not really slowing down the game all that much maybe like marginally but it's a lot line from like a family that now has three kids can play this game that's what I was gonna say a lot of family games cap out at four so like people underestimate the value of having a family game play up to a fifth player because there are a lot of families out there with three kids right might be one parent and four kids or whatnot right so yeah it might be the biggest Underdog surprise from 2022 I think it it is for me like I don't know another game that I went in with such like really no expectations just aside from this beautiful I think the way I think of games like this is if we didn't have a YouTube channel and we weren't reviewing games if we were just like average Gamers like we would have probably never played this because like we would have never been interested enough to you know stop playing our favorite games to stop and check something out like this but yeah yeah it's been a really really big surprise especially I'm pretty sure it's a first time designer too and that's another thing it's like first time designer family weight game another one

of these kind of sand beach themes or like how much interesting stuff is there going to be but like it's a solid game yeah that is Fife our third surprising yeah third surprise okay our fourth surprise from 2022 and this I guess technically if you look on BGG it's marked as a 2021 release but it was only released in Europe at the very end of 2021 this might be a controversial one this month well I think it is yeah yeah well I mean we have some people might agree with one of the reasons we're surprised yeah but yeah anyways should we keep it off camera a while longer I think I can already see it on there that is Arc Nova and quick special shout out because I don't think we mentioned this one of our videos I think he wanted to remain an honest but shout out to one of our patrons I won't name his name because I think he wants remain honest but uh for sending us this game along with another one recently we really appreciate that um yeah it's obviously not a not an inexpensive game but uh this has given us the ability to cover it on the channel so yeah we've spoken about this a couple times uh in other videos if you want to go look back on our thoughts there was one we talked about when we went to a cabin uh together and we played it with two players and I also mentioned a different uh solo uh games uh video where I played I think six solo games at a cabin so I played the solo and the two players only haven't played with three or four the biggest surprise first there's a couple things that surprised me about Arc Nova in 2022 the biggest surprise for sure and the reason why I've chosen for this list or we chose it is the fact that this game shot up the BGG rankings as quickly as it did and got as high as it did yeah um we've been in the hobby for a long time the first however many years I was in the hobby I didn't really use Board Game Geek locks a lot so I'm not one of those people people have always been looking at the rankings so maybe for

other people this isn't as much of a shock but as like from what I can remember since I've been monitoring BG and looking at stuff closely even especially since we've started the channel a few years ago I've never seen the game shoot up the list this high this quickly um while it's like I think it was in the top 50 when the game like within like two months of the game's release or something or three months like absolutely ridiculous and I remember there was a point right around whatever I think it was Essen where you know when they had announced the new games and they're asking people what they're most excited for and you see the BGG top the hot games yeah all goes up to unreleased games there's that part of the Year near the end of the year and I remember this and bitoku were the two big games that like everyone was talking about and for some reason I like I wasn't particularly interested in either one and I remember thinking I don't think either one is going to be all that successful necessarily I was wrong about Arc Nova people ask me like aren't you super excited it's like terraforming Mars and like look at the rule book and all this stuff and I was like nothing about the game excited me all that much it seemed like a really long like big rule book first time designer uh the fact comparisons to terraforming Mars which I don't really love and all this stuff um and then I ended up playing it solo and I was a bit surprised because I did enjoy it more than I expected on that first place solo but maybe that was part of the feeling of like hey here's this big game and I'm at a cabin by myself playing the solo game and there's something a good feeling about kind of like conquering this game learning this game on my own and playing it solo and there's a lot of of cool stuff in the game but then when we played it when I showed it to you we played as a two-player game I enjoyed it a lot less than the solo play so that also

surprised me so the surprise is not only how quickly it shot up the ranks but it's also the surprise of the difference in my enjoyment from the two plays and the fact that like how is this number four right now on the top games of all time like I I understand there's a lot of things to like and I know we need to play it a lot more still but I'm just surprised that the difference between the general public's opinion and our opinion on this so far and to be fair like I have not neither of us have played this enough to have a definitive opinion like that's not it's not us saying we're surprised we think it's a bad game or we think it's a good game or whatever like we can't really make that verdict right now it's at least well I'll say it's at least good minimum oh yeah definitely definitely better than good we just don't know where in that range yet yeah this is not about like arcanova's a bad game and that surprises the surprise for me is just that like it's not that the board game geek list needs to be like oh if it's an if it's a game that's in the top ten clearly I'm gonna like it like that's not that's not what I'm saying but for a game to be the if it is truly the quickest Rising Game to ever get into the top five and it's now sitting at number four and it's been out for like a year and a bit or whatever it is like that all that should be a formula that playing the game shouldn't have like left me with a slightly disappointed feeling because all that is going to create hype it's impossible for that mod to and I think the combination of it rising and I think a lot of it Rising is probably that Tom Basel put it as the number one game number one of all yeah someone's been reviewing games for like decades putting it ahead of games that have been Staples of his for so long and there's a lot of other people who have put it in their number one or in their

top 10 of all time already too really we've seen it a lot so I feel like the combination of all that had it rise like all of that hype is going to create expectations and I guess there was part of me that thought is it it's going to live up to those because look at all these reasons like it's going to live up to the expectations even if it's not my favorite game of all time I'm gonna play it and be like wow yeah this is a phenomenal game and and I just didn't have that I I thought it was good I thought there was a lot of things I liked about it but I don't in personal opinion I just don't see how a game that's this new can be the number four game of all time based on what I played a bit but at the same time if with the comparisons to terraforming Mars I like terrifying Mars I've never played that game and had the experience that some people have with it like where I think terraformers at one point it was like number two or three and it still is like super high on the list right it's in the top ten somewhere yeah so yeah the surprise is that you're right it's the combination of how quickly it Rose and then playing in realizing it just it's maybe it was impossible to live up to that hype but it just I was guess I was expecting it to somehow live up to it on some level right so you need to plant more for sure but I I don't think I'm ever going to play it and be like okay I see now why it's number four of all time I'm always we're going to always be the outliers if maybe not the only outliers but like in terms of the general consensus it seems like we're gonna this is gonna be one of those ones that we just have different opinions right general public another thing I want to point out real quick that's that is a surprise about this game is because of all the comparisons to terraforming Mars I expect it to feel more similarly as I

do to terraforming Mars but in terraforming Mars there there are I can't think of anything in that game that I like love and there are things that I like you know it's kind of more like middling across the pack Arc Nova has two or three things that I like absolutely love some of them I haven't seen in other games but then there's other things that just like drive me crazy about it that make me feel like it's such a missed opportunity and it I guess I sort of feel so far about it that it needed more time like more play testing more development it's a massive deck of over 200 cards so many of the cards that I've seen so far are either just like uninteresting or it's pretty similar to another card and like ultimately a game like this will usually live and die by like if it's a card based game almost all your ways are getting points like you have to be playing cards you're digging through a giant deck for cards if that deck of cards doesn't work or they're cards that are not interesting or there's something off about it that has the the potential to like really detract in the experience and I think that's what happened to me in that second game is I think the kind of like rose-colored glasses were on a bit for the first game and I was like whoa this is cool whoa this is cool and I was getting all those kind of endorphin rushes and then in the second game once I knew what I was doing I think I was bumping up against all these things that were frustrating me a little more and I still really enjoy like the scoring track and the way that works and the action selection system rotating things and upgrading your actions like those things are just amazing and really fun but there's so many other things that get in the way of me really enjoying the game as a whole yeah so I'll be really interested to see in like you know four or five years time like really removed from when this came out and by the time then have expansions of

and stuff have come out yeah I'll be interested to see not on the board game list working geek list where it is but just on people's General like top 50 of all all-time top 10 games of all time I'm just curious where it is how much does it show up because that I think that'll be more of a testament than like what the ranking is on board game geek um just like how many people are actually still talking about it regular or it does an expansion come out that all of a sudden like makes it a like this is the definitive way to play it and that changes people's opinions right I'm just curious how this game evolves yeah and you know what's something I want to mention also about the BGG rankings is that they're obviously skewed towards heavier games we've talked about this before because let's say let's talk about a very light game in a heavy game for example people who aren't interested in Arc Nova are people who don't play a lot of board games or whatever aren't gonna go try this at a convention some two to three hour game and then go online to BGG and give it a negative rating so a lot of the ratings are people who are already interested in the game and who are used to playing heavier games so it tends to lean towards this bias of it's going to be played by people who are expecting to like it a lot more whereas lighter games you might have thousands of heavyweight Gamers to go to these conventions try this 10 minute light game and go Raider to six so there's more people who are who don't like the game who are actually having the chance to play it and rate it so the ratings get skewed and I think that's why this is so high up too is like there's a lot of people who if they played it wouldn't love it but people who like three hour games are liking this a lot so I don't know yeah that is uh our fourth surprise yeah we'll have a lot more to say on that we're gonna do an actual full length review on the

channel at some point but we just need to play it a lot more in across player counts so but yeah that is Arc Nova all right our last surprise from 2022 is a little game called Caesar sees Roman 20 minutes we've spoken about this in one or two videos at this point in the past six months right uh and I think that's because it's like yeah it's come up a lot because we both love love it and it's that is the biggest surprise and one of the reasons it's not just oh we didn't expect to like this much when we did it's also that a game that has a war theme in general is always going to have a bit of an uphill battle with us because it's not something we gravitate towards as a theme and in general I would say theme does like it's not the theme plays a huge role for me in whether I'm gonna like or dislike a game but like using like battle line as an example so much if I think about my enjoyment of that is unfortunately because of like the artwork and the theme and stuff and Caesar had much of the same uh problem me coming in is like I got it mostly because I had heard so much good stuff about it I like two player only games and I thought you know I've heard there's too much I'm making placing in order anyways it's not that very expensive let's add it on and let's see what the fuss is all about more to be able to review it and and say I played it less to be like this is going to be a game that stays in my collection yeah not quite at the same extent of Fife but another one that if we didn't run a YouTube channel we might have missed this because of the war theme like I wouldn't have been looking into buying this game yeah and then this is now this Not only was this on my top 50 of all time it's one of my favorite two-player games of all time right now and that's because it is just a really

solid two-player game um and really quickly before I get your thoughts on the others like co-surprise with this is I think this is just the point where I started to realize and maybe you did too or maybe was a different game for you uh how much I love Paulo Mori as a designer like if Halloween between this ethnos and libertalia those are three of my favorite uh all my top 50 through my favorite games um I will talk about UV Rosenberg a lot we talk about rander can you see a lot suddenly out of even Tom Lehman for you like suddenly out of nowhere Paolo Mori is now my list of favorite designers and I'm going to be very eager anytime another against you know to play it like yeah well in Dogs of War is another one of this is one of my Grail games that I've been dying to try for a long time and he hasn't been around anywhere near as long as Konichi and Rosenberg yeah so maybe not like not say you were comparing them but I was gonna say it's not yeah yeah I don't want to lump them into the the same category or anything but yeah yeah this has been a huge surprise for me too for a lot of the reasons you mentioned the fact that it's the kind of War theme and there's like there's just there's so many two-player games out there and there's always more two-player games being released every year and a lot of them come out and you go like oh that's good but it's like we play so many and a lot of the ones we've covered on the channel like even thinking about something like so back two players like not a comparable game it's just it's a two-player game that came out recently that's all the comparison is here yeah is that a lot of the time we cover these games we say it's a really good two-player game but there's already so many good two-player games that we play that it's not gonna crack in that into that you know Echelon of my top ones like we said this I said the same thing about uh uh parisite La Lumia when we covered it like amazing two-player game but is it gonna crack

into that upper echelon of games and like this is one of those rare ones along with like Great Planes in mandala those rare kind of two-player games over the last few years that are like actually yes one of my old two-player favorites might leave my collection now because this is actually jumped into there and I really did not expect that from this game and even the kind of Roman Caesar theme like we had not that that's necessarily like an off-putting theme for me but any games that I've played that have had that theme like I think a forum trajana by Stefan fell down felt kind of flat for me so and what you said about theme like not that the theme should determine everything but like we do live in a day and age where there are over a thousand new board game releases worldwide every single year like we're spoiled as Gamers we should have the right to pick themes that appeal to us so like if a war thing doesn't appeal to you shouldn't that that should be fine you should be able to go look for other games but that speaks extra highly to how big of a surprise this was yeah agreed it's uh it's a phenomenal if you haven't played it I would highly recommend checking it out we also this makes me want to play Blitzkrieg even more just because I know they're similar I don't know the rules for blitzkridge I don't know how similar but I've heard them compared a lot yeah that that came before Caesar so I'm very I might pick that one up at some point maybe we'll try it at a cafe if we can find a cop here that's even more of a straight War theme I think than Caesar yeah I think so I think so but regardless it's just yeah big big positive surprise um in not only the game but also the designer for both of us and I'm really interested to see what he designs next and how long this game or how much this game climbs on my list as we go forward and as I play more because this is us talking about it having played it I think I played well technically the best the best of three yeah so I played it a

bunch but we I feel like in many ways we've still only scratched the surface oh yeah there's all kinds of strategies we've thought of during the game been like next time we'll try this yeah try this yeah yeah great game awesome game those are five surprises uh positive and negative I shouldn't say negative but like you know less less positive um from 2022 uh let us know in the comments what you think about the the ones we picked here if you agree or disagree with how we've uh thought about these games and our experiences from last year and I would absolutely love to hear what your surprises are from last year because there's so many games we haven't played and there's so many things that can surprise people for different reasons than us I'm just really curious to find like the games that you know hit that you didn't expect to or the games that you were super anticipating and to realize oh this is actually just like an okay game or whatever let us know in the comments we'd love to be able to talk to you in there and just uh you know hear what your surprises were from last year so otherwise thank you so much for watching and we will see you next time

Progress saved