Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Board Wargames of All-Time | Legendary Tactics Guest

Transcript 26:36

hi everybody I'm Zilla Blitz and welcome today we have a very special guest on the channel Nathan from legendary tactics is going to join us to talk about his top 10 war games of all time now if you're not familiar with legendary tactics I'll put a link to their YouTube channel down below Nathan is one of three members on the channel they have nearly 60,000 subscribers fantastic board gaming channel that I highly recommend additionally in Nathan's top 10 are a lot of older and outof print war games and a great source for picking up those games is one of our Channel sponsors Noble KN games in wion Wisconsin who ships all across the planet so if you're looking for some of the games that naate mentions or just want to look for some war games in general Noble Knight games is a great source to pick those up links are down below to the games that Nathan mentions and if you do happen to use one of those links to buy something from Noble Knight games thank you very much as those links do help support what goes on at the channel and with that let's talk to Nate so joined here today by Nathan from legendary tactics which has a YouTube channel with two other partners and they are approaching the 60,000 subscriber Mark they do a lot of videos on crunchy games on a variety of different games and also have a very strong component of War Games invited Nathan here thank you so much for joining today thank you so much for having me and we are here today to talk not about your 10 General board games across thing but a very specific topic that I think our viewers will be very interested in which is your 10 favorite war games is this for 2024 or

just in general um I made it more of an alltime list and I made it EXC you know yeah so if if people have watched our Channel they may see a few repeats but I've also I thought you know I've kind of mixed it up maybe a little bit um because there's so many great war games out there it's hard to narrow it down yeah and I know from our conversations we met in person in circle DC last year I know from our conversations that you are a big board gamer and love historical board games although it's not the sole focus of your channel so really curious to see what your top 10 list is shall we jump right in and get started with the okay so I will just give you an isue number 10 let you go and run with it here so number 10 is the Quebec 1759 I hope that's working all right there um this is a is an old title from Columbia games um and um it is brilliant in its Simplicity uh there's only a a handful of turns that you have in the entire game basically and you can only each turn you only move one group of troops from one spot to another and that's your move and it's all hidden uh movement you reveal simultaneously it's a block game right it's a block game so there's all the bluffing and so forth that uh you would enjoy from a a typical block game um but it's super simple to learn it's simple to to play but there's a lot of strategy that goes on um and there and it does tell The Narrative of the fall of uh Quebec City in 1759 and as a Canadian it

it resonates with me actually I bought it uh in when I was in Quebec City uh I'm one of part of my honeymoon actually and I found that I'm like oh that's great I gotta get this I remember playing it as a kid so I feel like there's a story in here that you're off buying board games on your honeymoon but I'll leave that one for now and for people that may be interested I I've just received word that there is a new addition of that game I think it's almost 50 years old and so there's new game a new version of this game coming to Kickstarter from Columbia games I'll put a link down below if people are interested in that yeah so we go to number nine number nine now this one I don't know if technically it's in my mind it's a war game even though it's a little bit of of a different take on war games and that is Churchill um by Markman now it's definitely a war game in in many senses of the word you're trying to advance into you know an end World War II but the the part of the game is the the card play um where you're you're trying to pull issues towards your uh side of the you're essentially trying to convince you're you know one of the other world leaders you're either Churchill Stalin or Roosevelt uh and later Truman I guess but you have to you know uh pull all the issues as best you can towards you the issues that matter the most and depending on how those negotiations go that's how the war plays out and I've always played this I I really have to mix up my crowds because I always play this with my legendary tactics uh creators and we always get so petty and

we always like we never finish the war because we always end up just arguing over who took what issue it's so but we have so much fun doing it it's just it's just great it's a great game and I love the whole coopertition aspect of it it's really an excellent uh game well I know that's a classic in the field too because you always see that one at any historical board gaming convention there's always always Churchill being played some place usually multiple times so great all right shall we slide on to number eight all right here we go this one um I was really kind of Blown Away by skies above the Reich um by GMT um this game really impressed me because um number one as a you know someone who plays games of various kinds I was blown away at how easy it was to learn and how uh the narrative develops over the course of the game and the board is basically like a fixed formation or formations of bombers or or whatever or you know so it's it's not a uh you know it doesn't seem very Dynamic when you look at it but it's just so neat how it all plays out uh and you it's a you play with the the wooden blocks but they're not hidden it's a solitire game you're moving them around and sending your your Fighters into try and you know get get in with good position and try not to get shot down um but you're you're essentially it's the German ltwa at the end of the war when things were going badly anyway and so it's a it's a really

challenging game from the perspective of uh trying to win and to you're you're not dominating you're as as time goes on it gets harder and harder to win so and I know we were I know we were chatting earlier off camera about Advanced squad leader and you mentioned the campaign games you know games that have Legacy so you spend two hours with the game and then that game State carries over to the next session and the campaigns in those games are fantastic too yes yeah absolutely and for me I was just I didn't have any expectations going in but it has become one of my favorite war games um I love to teach others and it's just but it you know play as a team but it's also great as a solitire experience as well that's such a great choice for number eight with that at number eight I'm kind of curious to see where we go with the next seven shall we jump up to number seven this one is kind of a revitalized title for me and it's the original title bismar this is we going classic here now oh this is classic so this I know not to interrupt you but I know your channel covers I mean if people like Avalon Hill and the traditional game that's a big component of your war game coverage on your channel so if people are interested that they should check out your channel for that too because you do a lot of stuff onon Hill thank you yeah so bismar that copy is the the game that originally got me into really board gaming of any sort of historical War gaming or anything like that I I remember I was we were coming back from Florida we went in I think it was Bowling Green uh Ohio I believe we

stopped in a mall there and in one of the stores they had bismar and I'd never seen anything like it on and I I bought I think if I remember correctly I think it was like $12 at the time and I bought it and I would just I would be reading the rules and setting up scenarios and stuff and making my dad play it even though he wasn't a gamer of any kind but um the reason why it's revitalized is because we've started a sort of a a play by email so I've got my other two legendary tactics creators I'm refereeing a game between them yeah but here the way where I'm doing it is I never I don't teach them any of the rules they just go in purely from a narrative experience basically like we use the map they're kind of telling you what they're trying to do and then you execute it within the framework of the rules and then and I and I make recommendations as their advisor it's like oh this plane is short of fuel we should probably send them back you know that kind of thing but the idea is they they don't actually learn any of the official rules it it's all being told as a narrative and that's been really a fun experience we've you know we've uh but it's bit of a timec consuming one I'm not sure when that video will be coming out but we'll be chatting about that you know because it back and forth takes some time and and that sort of thing but it's the original way of like you know play by mail you know the way they used to do it so this is a version of that that we thought would oh that a fantastic idea greated on my top 10 list now all right one yeah let's go number six on your

list D-Day at Omaha Beach one of the hardest solitire games you will ever play in your life I I can relate it's it's actually that game is number one on my top soliter game list my previous one I might change it in the next version but yeah no go ahead I'll let you talk about it though yeah well no it's just it's so hard but it's so fun I don't know how to describe it why it's it and the way the The Mechanics Work the way the map with all it's like almost looks like someone spilled a bag of Skittles on on the uh on the map and uh but it's just so well done and although as I said it is hard and you gotta love that about it um I'm Cur game that makes it it's like it's fun to lose though right because I think every time you lose you feel like you've learned a few things and so as you're done getting your butt kicked you're like oh I think I can do better next time and you do you know and and at some point I've not I've not beaten the game yet have you beaten the game yet no no I haven't no and in fact I'm currently in the middle of a game right now where uh I'm right up to the the gun and placement there and I'm just missing the one weapon you know how you need the the requirement of the weapons to like take it out and I'm missing just the one guy and he's halfway across the map like it's just like the frustration I think I just need to restart because I just the whole idea of getting that guy across the beach is going to be it captures that chaos so well you know like you got the Sherman tanks that come in at the beginning and like half of them get sunk and you're like well yes I

got like two tanks now it's like what do I do and you've got I love the problems the game throws at you and it feels like in a way it captures I think the essence of a lot of the the heroic struggle on the beach in that on that day oh yes and you just you realize it feels so hopeless and yet you have to keep moving forward yeah and it it's such a brilliant game yeah yeah it's so good it's so good sotally so yeah I just really enjoyed it but I I do want to beat it at some point it's on my bucket list to beat as well yeah well there's levels too because there's like the full game and then there's the half like the the halfway game you know sides there's only one game it's the full one I'm leveling up as I go yeah so yeah yeah okay well we could almost I should we could make a video on this one alone but let's carry on to are we up to number six five now uh five uh sorry we did uh yeah this is number five okay number five yep all right another GMT game no retreat the Russian front and I'm I have the other four as well the No Retreat series it seems like the fifth one actually just dropped off the p500 uh with GMT which is terrible news but hopefully um you know it gets picked up by another publisher or something um I suspect there are plans for that yes I I imagine um but what I love about the Russian front in particular is I just find that uh the way it recreates history without forcing it you know you

you make a lot of the same decisions that the commanders of that time made because just makes the most sense based on the board situation and it's just I find it so instructive but it's so um compelling the way it all comes together the event cards that kind of throw uh a spanner in the works when you're you know you when you're doing combat you know it's not just straight up die rolls it's like oh but then I got this card and it does this and there's a lot of fun uh variation there uh I love the low counter density it doesn't feel too much on the board um and just the again the story it tells of you know the German advance and eventually the Russians slowly pushing back and uh I just think it's a great great version of uh you know great telling of the the war and the the battle and the battles on the Eastern Front yeah and I think what you one of the there's there's a theme here to all your games in case I'm not sure if we're all aware of it but there's that accessibility and yes you know I call it like table ability can you is this a game that's going to get to the table and get played and I feel like with the no retreat rushian front that's a super accessible game it's playable in a in a in a time frame that you can play in an evening very replayable and just ton of different strategies you can explore I think it's the Highlight in the series I think it's the best one in the series by far not by far but it's the best one in the series but it's yeah it's just some great gameplay so great choice a lot of fun all right next up and kind of again along the playability lines um Thunderbolt Apache leader now this is Dan verson games um and it's

interesting because I just uh got Phantom leader and I just got it to the table um few days ago for the first time and that one I don't know if that one's going to viy for to compete with this one but so far I don't have enough experience with Phantom leader to say whether it's better or or worse but um but at the at the bottom of all these leader games I find it's all about the choices and the all the the millions of decisions that you make over the course of a single campaign and they all matter and they all play into the larger narrative and it's uh they they just leave a lot of choice with the players um and even though you're you're following a certain format within that framework you have so much to do um so leader games it's great leader games are special Play Because when I got back into board War gaming about three and a half years ago that was the first game I bought was not that one but Sherman leader and I thought am I gonna like it and play it out and I played a campaign like three or four campaigns with Sherman leader because it was literally the only new game that I had and I just ABS because it gets into that you know we talked a little bit before the same game with like skies above the Reich it gets into this idea of games with a campaign and a legacy element so building leveling up your characters leveling up your Pilots leveling up all these different aspects and you never have enough resources and what you do in battle one carries over to battle two and that's a fantastic strength of the leader series I think yeah and it's just managing that managing your your your your team you know it's like yeah it's

like uh I played a great game um by Compass games this year called Stuka um storm storm of Steel stor steel yeah which is a Stuka dive bar but a lot of it is the fun is in managing your team who's who's stressed and unfit to fly you know how many planes are you know undamaged or what like how what can we send out and it begins to be that management is really the heart of the game I think yeah for sure you know but but with with the with Thunderbolt a pachy leader I think what elevates it is it's not just managing your your guys it's also actually tactically how are you going to take out that Sam site how are you going to take out those troops in the hill and that's what I think you you know it just elevates it because you have so much Agency on what otherwise could be a very procedural game yes for sure yeah and I know that within that leader genre there are people that have uh their favorite leader games you know and that one comes up often on the list for sure yes yeah although now I'm I'm having people telling me I should get Corsair leader now so we'll see that's like and you're going to get corset leader and someone should say you should get this leader and that oh yeah it's going to be endless goes on B7 leader is a really good one too so yeah yeah that's good all right so we're gonna go with some Classics for the last three here so my number three is upfront now I wish got that one up front is um it's not a perfect

game in many ways but it is so good at what it's trying to do um I find that sometimes the rules are maybe a little more fiddly than they should be it comes from that era where you know um of advanced squad leader and so where you know the rules were all about how adding as much Chrome as possible but if you if you play Just a basic game with just the soldiers don't involve any vehicles or artillery or whatever but just play the it is such an amazing amazing game um and I love the fact that afterwards even though the whole thing is drawn out essentially with cards and your imagination the whole map is you could actually draw it out if you want want to you could actually if you recorded everything you could literally show what that that map board actually ended up looking like at the end um and yeah but it's just such a great uh thing with fog of war and everything I think they did such a great job with it yeah yeah I'm gonna make mention two quick things here too one is I just bought that game because I was playing um Lock and Load Publications has lock and lo publishing has one called point blank which is a newer modern take on that I really like that game and as I was playing that everyone said oh you should check out front so I want to go just for legacy reasons I want to go back and play one so I just bought that game from Noble Knight which quick plug they are the channel sponsor and if you're looking for a game like upfront and finding it hard to find Noble KN games in Wisconsin they ship all over the world they're a great place to look so there's a link down below to them for this awesome yes I love Noble Knight however they are out of stock of Corsair leader just

if I did take a look I think I could probably tell you like I have a want list that's got like 30 things on it of which about half for out of stock and I have the notifications enabled and I can tell you exactly what they're in stock for that list as well that's funny I I have it flagged to notify me when it comes in and then I'll have that decision of like do I don't I how to anyway sometimes you don't have a lot of time it's like they can go fast you get that email you gotta move yeah if it's one copy absolutely all right so we move on to number two my number two is again a classic Ambush by Victory Games and I don't know if you've played this one Zill have you tried it I it is it's on my shelf of opportunity is it okay I like that because it goes back again kind of go back I missed like 25 years of war gaming and I'm so I still have like that you know so game new many games come up I have some games that I went I said okay I'm gonna get this game and I'm gonna play it I just haven't gotten to it yet but I've heard such good things Yeah you mentioned you're interested in in Dungeons and Dragons now you're started playing that Ambush came out at a time when dungeons and Dragons was The game everyone was playing and you can see that in its its roots like you you you roll for your starting characters and they started with different abilities now you don't have strength Charisma in intelligence whatever you have driving skill weapon skill and you know a few other traits like that uh leader initiative that kind of thing but it's kind of that

combination of role playing game and war game and I have not heard that spoken about it that's a really interesting angle on this kind going my you can really see the roots of it when you play like that it's really great um but it's and it's all it's it's war game but it's very narrative based you know you're you're it's they have this weird you know slidy thing that as you advance your troops through it tells you what happens and then when you have encounters the German troops pop up and you have to attack them and try and keep your guys alive there's and there's an amazing article from years ago in the general magazine where they talk about this there's a lot of campaign games where you'll like Phantom leader being one of them you know there's you've got the cards and they level up in experience and so forth but Ambush is a game where if a soldier gets shot and killed that that's it that guy is no longer you know because you're writing down his name and you're saying hey this is Joe Joe Smith and this is his traits and you walk him through all these missions and then he gets killed by a sniper in Mission four and you're like I can't that original guy like you feel that actual loss yeah because this is I I have I know of its greatness um and it's also a Butterfield design which the same as D-Day at Omaha Beach so you've got some there's some similarity going on across here I didn't realize there was that strong of a campaign element in it oh it's all about the campaign they're not single missions you have to take your squad through all these missions that get harder and

harder and harder and then when you complete that then you can get heart or or move out the additional missions to and carry those over the same yeah pure campaign it was it was the very first campaign game I think it ever come across where it actually you carried forward the soldiers into the next mission and I had heard about it when I was doing like the top soliter games because people put that in say Ambush Ambush Ambush I was like okay I got to check this out but that I I haven't gone to this level of depth with it before so this is really but don't get too attached cuz when those guys get run over by a panther tank or something you're like no not Hollywood he was my favorite oh that's cool and I we are oh sorry they get replaced by sorry just last thing they get replaced by Greenies who suck you know oh well those are the guys you put up front right it's like yeah you go first you know you're the you're the point position but then they panic and they hit the dirt they're they're kind of useless you they have to be attached to your squad leader at all times otherwise they yeah they're not very effective so yeah it's it's very good it's very neat how they oh yeah no I've heard fantastic things about it it's it's more like so many games is the only reason that I haven't had a chance to dig into it yet so I'm gonna add it to my shelf of Shame challenge for 2025 so yeah we're up to are we up to number one now number one and I feel like I it's kind of obligatory but welld deserved at the same time okay squad

leader we were just talking about this so you're going squad leader not Advanced squad leader well for me advanced squad leader always seemed to be so intimidating and to be honest I only have the base game of squad leader I didn't get into all the the crazy expansions although I've I've been interested in getting Cross of iron which is the first expansion that really upgraded the vehicle rules and everyone says is amazing that one I'd be interested in trying but uh you know maybe well you know you've you've talked to me a little bit Advanced squad leader maybe I'll I'll give it a try maybe you and I can fire up a game sometime but but the original squad leader I think is just the way it models the The Human Side of conflict so many times you're bashing cardboard armies against each other and they Retreat and they advance and but to have squads break and panic and Route and hide in a building for the rest of the scenario not doing anything completely useless you know that's more sort of true to life and I feel like that aspect of it was was uh captured in a really interesting and fun way with squad leader yeah and I think the issues it ran into are the the later editions when you got rules conflicts and it was kind it got a little bit convoluted so they sorted it out with ASL but I think that when you're looking at that squad leader game in and of itself it's a it's a true classic and it's hard to go wrong for sure it's a great joy yeah it's just the scenarios are fun they're you know they're challenging it's it's just an amazing uh experience and uh yeah and

like the Stalingrad map is probably burned in my head I think I if you put me down I could walk around I could tell you where all the buildings are yeah yeah the tractor Factory and everything you know get those the flamethrowers up up and running on you know yeah yeah fantastic so for me I just find like it's just such a compelling uh gaming experience and really is in many ways it represents certainly of that era the height of War gaming and there's been a lot of reolution the genre too I mean if we think on wargaming that's a game that I think opened up there are a number of games that came along that opened up what it could be and kind of back like armies banging against each other this was something that said no we can we can play at a completely different level we can explore a whole different tactical level we can capture that human element with morale and panic like you say that's saying these are real people in a physical space trying their best to survive and not get killed you know um and I think that there's so many revolutionary aspects to Squad leaders that changed the way we think about historical board game yeah no absolutely so that's that's has I just figured it has to be my number one I'd probably get a lot of flak if I didn't choose it as my number one so oh yeah War gamers are very forgiving you know yeah there there is the squad Le element there that you you made the squad leader element for sure but it's such a great choice you know it's like we play what we like and this is really interesting to hear your top 10 and ending with squad leader like that when it's clear that you like the game and enjoy the game so much is just a it's a

perfectly fitting number one so yes absolutely thank you so much for joining uh it's been I've learned a lot about you listening to your top 10 because I had no idea it was going to be in here you we didn't talk about anything beforehand so this was a complete surprise to me but um and it's re in particular like Ambush and upfront which are two games that I you're on my shelf of opportunity I'm work up based on this conversation so thank you so much for sharing all of your wisdom and insight and experience with the John anytime anytime thanks for having me absolutely bye everybody thank you

Progress saved