Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 19
Transcript
hey everyone and welcome to another installment of board games i got rid of and why so this is a series where i talk about all the ball games that i've kicked out of my collection and tried to give some rationale as to why i came to that decision uh before i get into this episode's 10 games i want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kianda dot co uk who are a great online retailer here in the uk and if you use my discount code in the show notes then you can get five percent off your first order but without further ado let's get started on the episode the first game i'm talking about this episode is tinker taylor which is a small box hidden rolls drafting game and think of something like citadels so this one works very much in that vein as you are using these powers to collect these different cars to give you set collection bonuses that's pretty much the extent of the game it worked for what it was um i think one of the lasting impressions i had on this game was how annoying and how drawn out the kind of housekeeping process was as you have to go through all these different roles every single round and activate them in order it just became a bit tedious after a while and just become a bit as i said annoying um but the game worked i thought it was fine but ultimately nothing that really made you come back to it anymore and to be honest i don't think it is as good as the classic citadels so hence why tinker taylor left the collection so the second game i'm talking about is not alone which is a hide and seek one versus all style game that was actually in my collection for quite some time so we did actually play this one quite a
few times over the years i actually prefer this game at the lower play account either one versus one or one versus two with two two people being the marines or whatever they are and basically this game you have a display of these cards out all representing a different location and then secretly both um or all the players who are the marines and ever and the alien themselves are going to select a card um and try to or the aliens trying to guess where the marines are going to go to and the marines are trying to evade where the alien is going because every time either party is successful then they go climb up this track and the first person to reach the goal or the destination spot on that track will be the winner um i thought the game was fine i thought it was one of those games that suffered from the whole you know i know that you know that i know that you know kind of thing and i come to a point where it was pretty much random and you could just do a lucky dip and maybe get lucky and maybe not get lucky so i thought that was quite frustrating at times i also thought that some of these action cards that the alien could use were a bit swingy sometimes they were ultra powerful and there was nothing that the other players could do about it and then sometimes vice versa it would kind of spiral out control there would be so many locations on the board that you were pretty much just you know hoping or just selecting one hoping it would work out so a little bit too random for me but it did have its upside i think if you like these stellar games this is a good example of a pretty interactive a pretty tense game that you could get some fun from the next two games on this list are kind of tied in hand in hand and the reasons
are similar as to why i um i called both of them so these games are watergate and blitzkrieg so these are both tug of war style games as you are dragging kind of a piece up and down this track trying to get it on your side and to beat your opponent by doing so i'm in watergate which i think is the better of the two games at least in terms of kind of mechanical experience in the way um the way it's designed as one player is going to take control of the press one person's gonna be president nixon and through clever card play you're gonna be manipulating these different tokens on this track and then laying down a kind of a network to try and connect and expose the scandal if you are the um the press player or if you're president nixon you're trying to cut off this network and um block off any route you can and just try to stay in the game as long as you can so i love the victory condition in this game i love the level of card play and how to sacrifice cars get more powerful abilities but lose them from your deck there was just some a lot to um a lot to be appreciated here from a great designer um i just kind of got to a point where i'd never pulled this one off the shelf i thought this was kind of more mechanical than it was fun for me now i still do give this one a 7 out of 10 which is enough for a show the quality because i think the game design is that good it just wasn't one that i was looking to experience very often and i kind of want games in my collection that i play regularly or at least have that urge to play regularly but i think if you love club of war games this one is pretty much as good as
it gets but yeah unfortunately not just be um not quite right for my personal collection because i have quite a few two-player games and i i'd like to pull a lot more of them out before i would get to watergate um blitzkrieg is very similar in terms of my reasoning this one i think is slightly weaker mechanically but probably has a higher fun factor as you are drawing tokens out of a bag and then using those tokens to climb up different tracks some of them have special abilities it has this kind of bonus actions you can get when you place these discs down all these tokens down and i had a good degree of kind of bottlenecking you into doing certain things without giving you too many options but giving you enough options to to mult over um and there was two different versions of this game as well a kind of simplified version and a more kind of interconnected version which i too much i thought i preferred the basic version more than the advanced version but very much similar to um to watergate there's just a ton of other two-player games in my collection and i rarely get to play two of the two-player games so this one was kind of not really seeing any or showing any sign of seeing the lights anytime soon but still both recommendations from me if you enjoy that type of war experience and you regularly get two player games to the table the next game i'm talking about is mikarinos which is actually a near-miss for me and i thought this game has a another game with a lot of upside to it so this is a very abstract aerial majority style game as you're simply
placing these cubes down on these different tiles which are basically grids and then spreading out and trying to get majority on these tiles because at the end of the round if you have the most coverage on these tiles you're going to collect those tiles which will give you bonus powers for the rest of the game but additionally that'll tie hand in hand with the main board where you could invest in which will kind of correlate to the titles you've collected so they would multiply in their scores it was very clever as dry as it gets and to be honest the artwork as well and the visual design and graphic design for the mikarinos version of this game we're not exactly going to draw people in and no one's going to come around your house look at your collection and say let's play mickerinos because that looks fun so i thought that did work against it somewhat but again mechanically the game is very well designed this game has also been released in a much more visually appealing version called rome um which i could see more people being drawn to just because of that visual appeal but in this game i played it a few times i did enjoy every single play but it did get to that point where you know what i'm content with it now i've tried all the different powers i've tried the different strategies you can go for and every kind of play from now on i'd probably do the same thing so when i get to that point with the game i'm ready to pass on from it but still if you see a version of this game out in the wild and you find it a good price i do think it's worth your time and i think you could enjoy it so that is mika renos the next game i'm talking about is a matched cobble and fog so this is a skirmish dueling style game where you
are taking control of these characters all with very distinct unique abilities this version has characters such as sherlock holmes it has the invisible man it has count dracula and i forget who the other one is but basically you are navigating around this map playing cards and basically beating the snot out of each other now i must admit going into this game i was pretty sure that it wasn't going to be for me because to be honest that kind of gameplay doesn't work for me i don't tend to like dueling or skirmish style games where y'all where you are beating the snot out of each other um and yeah my concerns were certainly um it certainly did come true however thinking from a more objective standpoint i can see why people would enjoy these games much like games like i mentioned watergate and blitzkrieg being great examples of tug of war style games unmatched is a great system for fans who enjoy um those dueling style games but yeah ultimately it's just not a good gel with my own personality on my own style of games so it was never going to get played um i had a few games with that i kind of embraced the chaos nature of them but i did have my limit and i was ready to move on pretty quickly from unmatched the next game i'm talking about is gloomhaven jaws of the lion so the reason i picked this game up was because i thought i had to experience what the hype was all about um this is regarded as one of the best games of all time not only this version but also the original glean haven this is a dungeon crawling style game where you have control of your own character you are leveling up
as you go throughout the game you have this really interesting card system as you are picking a pair of cards which also represents your health and then on one of these cards you're using the ability from the top half and on the other card you're using the ability from the bottom half and they can be things such as moving around the map attacking characters and you know and the like so i did actually appreciate the way this game worked i thought it was very clever the scope was massive it has pretty much everything you'd expect and want from a dungeon crawling style game and to be honest if you like stuff like dungeons and dragons but you think the actual gameplay side of things in relation to dungeons dungeons and dragons is weak then gleam haven is a great substitute for that because the actual gameplay is quite you know has a euro nature to it and it's quite gamey so i did quite like that blend of things that kind of dungeon crawling narrative mixed with a solid gameplay experience now the reason this game left my collection was because generally um narrative games games with a campaign or legacy style games don't work for me because i like variety i like dipping in and out of games rather than committing to one game and having a you know a lifestyle experience so for that reason the very nature of greenhaven wasn't going to work for me but i did know that going into the game but i did want to experience it anyway we played quite a few missions back to back all in all in one night and i got to a point where i i was like i know i know what groomhaven is about now i understand how the system works
and to be honest i've increased my knowledge of the board game world because i thought it was a bit of a it was a bit of a gray area for me that i i felt like i needed to at least experience green haven to have that kind of knowledge in my system to compare it to other games so yeah ultimately one that's not right for me it was a little bit too rules heavy a little bit too um yeah a little bit too fiddly for me too many exceptions too many you know situational rules and also i thought that the narrative side of the game was quite weak it was quite cliche and it felt like um you know the most generic fantasy story you could think of but that being said the gameplay itself was certainly um well polished and um you know if you like more or kind of a hybrid of a narrative and eurostar game this one is going to be um well it's quite remarkable but not quite right for my personal tastes so that is gloomhaven jaws of the line the next game i'm talking about is broom service which is one of the original alexander fister games so this is actually a much lighter system and it's a pick up and deliver style game as you take control of these witches and you are moving around this board picking up potions um and dropping them off at these different towers to get points but the thing that was unique about this game was this card system as everyone would have a an identical set of cards or deck of cards and then in turn order you'll be selecting these cards secretly and then revealing them and then you choose to either choose the brave version of these actions or the kind of
cowardly version and the cowardly version would relate to you thinking that another player would have chosen that card and if they had you'd all get the cowardly action but if you chose the brave action you're basically saying that nobody else has selected that card and then you get a stronger almost like a double action to be a lot more efficient but if somebody else does select that card then you get nothing so i did like that kind of pushy like bluffing and guessing mechanism and it did work well for this and it made the the gameplay vary as you went on you know you weren't all playing from a level footing all the time so i thought this game had a lot going on for it i did like the way it worked and it did take a few turns to get it out your system and understand how it works but once you did did understand it and it clicks the game started to flow quite smoothly and was a decent amount of fun now i do think this game was quite one note i thought that once you played a couple of times there was no real reason to go back to it um i thought that there's better pickup and delivery games out there and i even have ones in my collection i rarely get to play because i do play so many games that i just know that if i wanted to play a pickup and deliver game i was going to play something like the oracle of delphi before i would even think about playing a broom surface but in its own right broom service was a solid game uh plays in a pretty succinct amount of time you're talking about 45 minutes to an hour to play and the level of decisions there is quite interesting and i'd love to see that cowardly and brave mechanism be used again in another game because i've not seen it before and you know finding
unique mechanisms is becoming tougher and tougher nowadays so yeah i did like that about broome service but ultimately it wasn't the best of its genre the next game i'm talking about is in the hall of the mountain king so this is a game that still holds my shield of quality i think this is a very well designed game um as you are building up this pyramid of cards um which is going to be this awesome way to gather and manage your resources because every time you build um or add a new car to this pyramid everything below it is going to restock on resources and then you're going to use those resources to buy new abilities you're going to use them to basically dig out different pathways on this big board to build this network of tunnels which works basically in a polyamino style way then you are finding these statues you're dragging these statues onto these kind of um platforms to get other victory points a lot going on here and actually remarkably easy to teach and to understand and to be honest it was a lot of fun now this game certainly did get lost in my collection for a long time i went through that initial burst and playing it quite regularly then all of a sudden it just never got played it was just sat there on my shelf collecting dust and the queue of games before i was thinking of getting some back to the table just started building and building and building to the point where i just knew it wasn't getting played it'd be sat there for like a year or so that i thought you know what this is still a fantastic game but i have to be realistic here i have to create space to something that i've got a bigger desire to play sooner so hence
why ma in the hall of the mountain king left my collection but i still love that resource system and the final game i'm talking about this episode is acro theory which is one of those games where on paper and visually i thought this game was going to be a smash hit for me i was very impressed from reading the rule book about how streamlined the game was and how well it seemed ironed out this is a pick up and deliver tile placement style game as you're building up this map and which is going to make up different islands and different routes connecting those islands and the supply and demand aspect of the game relating to the pickup deliver really did appeal to me as you would sail around these islands collect them in your little boat bring them back to the main island and collect money for doing so you'd use that money to buy contracts and then use those contracts to complete to build your temples on these islands based on arrangements of symbols around those islands so some might say to complete this contract you might need a mountain to the north of it or a volcano to the south of it and so on and once you find that perfect island you can put your temple on it and unlock more actions as you go so very smooth and streamlined set of rules there now that being said i thought the game did lack a certain amount of fun i just seemed to be underwhelmed after every game of this i played and i couldn't quite put my finger on why and much like um broom service i have my favorite pick up instead of the games and if i was to keep this in my collection and i must admit this was a very near miss because i loved the way it worked
um this would be again pushed further down on that list and it was never gonna get played this is relatively quick you're talking 30 to 45 minutes but i would rather spend you know an extra half an hour or so to play something more meaty and more engaging like as i mentioned oracle of delphi so whenever i pick up a pick up of the game i automatically compare it to oracle adelphi which is one of my favorites and no game has yet to compare or stand shoulder to shoulder with that game so hence why akrotiri left the collection so there we go there's another 10 games that have left my collection hopefully this video has been somewhat informative for you i mean if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like and subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too and particularly if you enjoy this kind of content i have got you know a multitude of different videos um talking about games i've curled from the collection so check out that playlist and also be sure to check out the show sponsorkienda.com and if you want to go that extra step then you can also check out my patreon page but for everybody else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye now