Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ask The Chairman - Board Game Q&A 1

Transcript 23:27

hey everybody and welcome to the first episode of ask the chairman so this is a board game related queue and a session where you guys can ask me anything you like I thank you so much for submitting these questions I've got some really good ones uh to answer here now I'm obviously going to need a consistent flow of new questions to keep this com um keep this content going so if you have a question for me for episode two then please leave them in the comments to this video and I'll be sure uh to answer them so let's get cracking on the questions the first of which come from Mike and his first question is asking uh in an average week how often do you play games with friends family and your gaming group so Mike I'm actually quite fortunate to um have plenty of options where I play games with my family um probably at least one game session per week um I play with friends probably two times per week I do have a local games group as well where if I have the opportunity to go which I don't always do because I do work shift work I'll get down there and play another evening per week as well so it's normally probably two evenings per week and one day session per week um on average so I am really spoiled and I get to play quite um a lot hence why I get to talk to you about so many games uh the second question is asking how do I get the balance right between being a content creator and enjoying my hobby so for me those two things go hand in hand um I've never found it an obligation to record content and talk about games for me it

is part of my hobby it's not again it's not a chore for me um I've never played games that I feel obligated to play you know if I have um say a publisher offer me a game to review on the channel and I don't like the look of it I'll just say no I'm not interested and this for me is not work it's fun and I intend to keep it that way now I do keep things quite simple in terms of how I edit content Etc it's all done through an app on my phone so that's why I don't have like professional visuals or professional sound it's all done on my phone that way it keeps me motivated and it means that it's not going to be a slog and a chore for me to edit videos um Etc so yeah generally speaking um the two are the same for me um it's not a chore I've never felt stressed or obligated to play anything and um yeah it's all fun so yeah no no issue for there for me personally next questions then um come from John the first which is what board game Trend harms the hobby uh the most so I think this generally boils down to one key talking point and that is quantity over quality so you guys know that recent years maybe even the last 10 years there has been so many games released year upon year that there is no chat in hell that all of them can be to an adequate degree of quality back in the olden days um there was you know Publishers were very picky about what they put out yes the hobby was smaller but the general yield of quarter games

was much higher most things now just come and go they have their five seconds in the Sun and then it's on to the next thing so I think sometimes a shame that it's a bit a bit consumerist in terms of things coming and going on a conveyor belt but it also means that sometimes great games get lost in a shuffle because there's just so much out there to filter through um I suppose another easy thing to say would be the whole Kickstarter culture but personally I've never really dabbled in that too heavily um because again it's so expensive and the kind of games that blow up on Kickstarter aren't my thing anyway you know I don't play The Big Adventure mini games so yeah I kind of managed to I'm happily have managed to avoid those style of games and that kind of area um of the hobby so yeah if I could change anything it would be to release fewer games per year so we have more time to you know just just to enjoy the games that are out there and you know maybe Explore More nooks and crannies of those games um from a different perspective on that question I always wanted to mention that I think uh something that harms The Hobby in terms of getting new people involved in the hobby is when really enthusiastic Gamers pressure people to play their games um even if they're Ultra casual fans they want to try and make them as enthusiastic about the games as they are which is probably not going to happen and it's going to have an adverse effect but I've always found that the best way to get people into the hobby is to enjoy as much as possible yourself to the point where they want to join in themselves and that's always been the philosophy or more recently being the philosophy that I tend to adopt

so hopefully that answers your question um John the next one is how many times do you play a game before you review it at this one regularly asked questions the answer is is as many times as it takes no I'm very experienced I play tons of games and it's very easy for me to solidify my thoughts about what I think about a game and I very rarely um been rolling it whether I play it one time or whether I play it ten times my thoughts are generally the same um regardless of how many times I play it and again I think I think experience is a big um part of that now there are exceptions like for example I've played some games where I just cannot quite pull my thoughts together and can't quite put my finger on what I want to say and then I usually have to play a few more times to again get my thoughts in order um but yeah uh I suppose this relates back to if I don't like a game how many times they're going to play out to guarantee that I don't like a game the answer to that is not many because there's so much stuff out there kind of going back to the odd question um I haven't got the time to reinforce my opinion that a game is rubbish so why would I play it again just so yeah I was right the first time it is rubbish I've wasted another hour and a half which I could have been playing a game that I enjoy so yeah if I don't like a game it won't be many um if I do like a game it depends on how quickly I can solidify my thoughts uh next question is what game mechanism would you like to see more of um this is a difficult question to

answer um I did write down a couple um the first of which is the I split you choose mechanism because it's not actually used that often and you know when I played in games like Hannah makoji I really do enjoy that conundrum of offering things to your opponent and you getting what's left really cool mechanism there but again very seldom used another thing I really like which isn't terribly popular is the classic Puerto Rico system where you have an action you'll get a strong Version of action but everybody else will get a um kind of a weaker version of it or some kind of tag along action and games like um you know uh Twilight Imperium use that games like Boone Lake use that and I really enjoyed that one it's a great way to keep people engaged when it's not their turn and generally I like I like negotiation there aren't that many good negotiation games out there and I'd like to see more um off them so yeah those are my answers so I've got ice but you choose negotiations games and that kind of Puerto Rico action selection system and that kind of leads into the next question actually because the question was um what do I prefer tug of war games or ice that you choose games so I've actually got a very small sample size when it comes to ice but you choose games um but because I haven't seen much more much of those I might choose that as my answer to this question but there are some great tug of war games out there as well and depending on how you want to Define that mechanism the kind of games where you push and pull things on a track you and the other player I tend to not like but games where you are maybe got some card play and competing over

something with cards I do tend to like those games like you know lost cities or games like um uh District Noir those are really cool games but the kind of traditional pool things up and down on the track I don't like as much but yeah there's my answer um I would go for ice but you choose because there aren't many of them and I want to see uh more of it let's move on then to questions from Brett um really interesting question here Brett so he says do you Advocate this is me paraphrasing this question by the way okay so do you Advocate older style games to attract views or are these types of games what you truly prefer and first off I want to clarify that the older games that I review do not attract views nobody is typing in um you know spirium on YouTube and asking or looking for opinions on it people aren't looking for that now more my already subscribed viewers subscribers will check out those videos more but it's not like I'm I'm getting new viewers because of that it's more kind of harvesting the people I already have on my channel who know the games um I like um so yeah I'm not actually using them to attract views because generally speaking older games don't get viewed as much if I covered the hotness all the time games like if I was talking about Frost Haven and frostpunk I'm sure my channel will be four times as big already but the truth is I don't like those games I'm not going to talk about them I'm going to talk about the older games that I do like and again all these type of games what I truly prefer

absolutely yes um I've really come to notice especially over the last year or two that most of the new games that come out now are kind of subpar versions of existing games that are usually a bit more convoluted and not as elegant not as engaging to me personally now I understand that the trend of making games more beautiful and more appealing from a visual standpoint is really changed from when these games were released which is actually a huge detriment to these original games um but the gameplay itself for me which is my priority is um is where my you know my priorities lie you know I'd much rather have an uglier beige game and the gameplay is amazing to a really lavish new game that everyone's talking about that is kind of not as good as those games I've already mentioned it really I mean I certainly don't do it to attract views I love those types of games you've seen my collection video most of them are older games now and that's what I enjoy this kind of old school minimalist rules old Euros um you know from Germany those are these games are just brilliant and hit the sweet spot for me so hopefully that answers your question um Brett thank you for the question um next up from Tom um he's asked why have designers trended away from simpler more focused Euros to more convoluted experiences and that kind of leads into what Brett asked is actually extremely difficult to make a game with depth and Nuance with fewer

rules as it is to making games with more rules I think that might be a misconception to a lot of you know people who engage in the hobby um creating games with loads of rules is actually pretty easy to do because it's just bought more on to fix a problem and so on Boiling games down to a core experience with as few rules getting in the way as possible is actually um extremely hard to achieve and doing that is is even more difficult now because of of the hobby being so saturated so that most of those boiled down mechanisms have been explored already meaning that in order to create anything new you have to add more on and kind of create a bit of a Frankenstein's monster of cherry picking bits from different games to put into a new game and hopefully sell that as a new product which sometimes works sometimes it doesn't yeah I think it's just a simple matter of number one those games being exhausted and being very difficult to find anything new to do um and yeah that's it really so yeah um well that's why I give you know full respect to the the writer Committees of the world which always you know his school of design is less is more if I can get rid of something I will and that's what I appreciate in game design though is that perfectly engineered balance of um you know having just enough so it's engaging but nothing extra that it detracts from the experience and um that's where you know that's what I look for in games and it's what separates the good designers from the great designers

um B has asked what game is the least likely to be in your collection yet remains and why so you know you guys probably know that my my channel is mostly known for the old school Euro games uh maybe clever card games that kind of thing don't fit that Niche at all um games like Cabo um I talked about quite a lot I really enjoy it it's a very silly kind of a check-in memory Style game a very simple stuff but it works there's something there's some magical ingredient about it that I always enjoy and again I teach this the very experienced Gamers and we always have a good time with Cabo so check that one out if you don't know um and I don't even like memory games and that's another surprise as to and why I like Cabo so much um I also have some very simple kinesia dice rolling games games like Age of War which is basically a yahtzee variant um and I suppose a big anomaly is something like unusual suspects which is like a very silly kind of a party game as you're trying to give Clues as to what a character would do or what a certain cartoon character would his personality traits would be again game mechanisms wise terrible the gameplay itself is or the actual game experience itself is a hell of a lot of fun and I always enjoy playing that one so yeah those are just three examples of um games that wouldn't traditionally fit what I look for but managed to hold their own and stay in my collection the next question is what is my favorite

game with an amera trash style miniature in it or at least one miniature um I don't think I have any games in my collection with Miniatures in them but if I was to choose one it would be something like the Council of four when um come on reprinted that one so it's actually an older Euro game which used to have wood components but come on printed it with plastic Miniatures which was completely Superfluous and was a bit Overkill but they were very nice Miniatures and they looked quite cool when it was on the table so maybe something like um like Council of four I also did like rising sun when it came out it was actually my favorite game for a while um has definitely plummeted since then but I still like the game and um I had me interested in it as well of course see those are two choices there Council of four or writing uh sun and he's also asked some of my thoughts on the new deluxe edition of the castles of burgundy so I'm a huge fan of the castles of burgundy I have the original version in my collection the production is absolutely terrible but for me that's part of the charm of it it's very easy for me to pull this one off my shelf and get it played and in fact I only played it maybe last week or so and had a great time with it I would I was very keen on the concept of getting a deluxe version of it with nice tiles you know nice polish product but I don't think that they pulled the plug at the right time I think they went too far on it and didn't know when to stop not just in terms of the Miniatures

Etc which just seems ridiculous to me this game does not need Miniatures um that's just me trying to be objective about the um about the issue but obviously I'm in the minority because they're sold very well um but I also think that it might add too much actual content into the box as well and something I've really learned over the years is that more content even though that content might be great it's not a good thing thing for the overall game because it makes it a lot harder to get the game onto the table and get it played which is why we do this in the first place and because there's so much more to sort through and you've got to pick and choose which you want to add in remember remember rules remember how rules link with other rules and all that stuff is a big No-No for me at this kind of time in my in my life really so um yeah I I might regret not getting this one but at the moment I'm happy with my original version I don't really see that changing and um maybe I'll get a secondhand copy or something down the line but I think it's too much a bit overkill for what I'm looking for when I've got a perfectly decent version in my collection I'm already so there's my thoughts on the deluxe version of the castles of burgundy that the Harry gnome has asked for do I prefer to teach a game or do I prefer to be taught a game this is a no-brainer for me I love teaching games um I would 100 choose to teach a game over over being taught to the game I actually really struggle to digest information when being taught games because I'm so used to teaching them um and sometimes my mind runs ahead of

itself because I'm always comparing with games we've already played I assume it's played one way and then the teacher will come out and say it's played in a different way and sometimes that doesn't quite look into places quickly as if I was to teach a game so yeah despite me teaching hundreds and hundreds of games over the year and I like to think I'm pretty good at it um I've not tired of it slightly I enjoy teaching games especially um you know to enthusiastic Gamers and again another thing that I'm very lucky with is that people who I play games with absorb rules like a sponge you know I can teach at one time everything's locked into place and we're good to go without you know Annoying questions being asked again and again when I've already I've already um explained the rules so yeah I'm very fortunate to have a bunch of people around me who are very smart and can learn games on Ultra quickly so on to the last few questions now so we have a question here from per asking how important is it that everyone has a chance of winning a game now I would say that's fairly important for me I actually really hate it when uh games reward experience and at least give a player who's played a game before a drastic advantage over somebody who doesn't know the game like I've had so many bad experiences when I've been taught a game that player knows all the intricacies I know which cars cards and stuff synergize with each other they know what to look out for and they don't relay that information to the other players and then they catch them off guard and basically pull them all over the rise and trick them now I know sometimes this is unavoidable and sometimes if I'm teaching games that I'm

very familiar with and I know some tricks with I will make sure and make it overtly clear what is in my scope of opportunity to do so I'll say hello be careful there is this card in this deck if it comes out I will buy it and I will use it against you so um I make it again I make things like that very clear to make sure that no player is going to leave the game feeling disgruntled or hard done bias simply because they don't know the rules and um yeah generally speak now I love going into a game on a Level Playing Field um hence why I play so many different games all the time because I don't like being really good at something and again giving me that Advantage I like always going in with a with a clean sheet everybody's got a fair chance of winning and um yeah everybody's got at least got the opportunity um to win um next up the question is how important is it for you that smart choices get rewarded so this is probably the strongest metric that I rate games on um I value those meaningful decisions more than anything even if there are you know even if it's a simple game I want consequences to my actions and that's kind of what I kind of a sentence I keep in my mind when I'm reviewing games is what is the consequence to my actions here so yeah I I think it's a very important part of the game if I feel like a game's playing me I'll lose interest straight away um you know if there's a very simple pushy luck game I want it to be my choice whether I go Bust or not you know or you know am I going to put myself out there to go Bust or not um again very very important to me and definitely the most important metric that I um I grade

games on Brad has asked do you ever go to U.S conventions no no I don't I never have done maybe one day I will it's gonna be very difficult for me it's extremely expensive to get flights from the UK to to America and it's going to be even more expensive to get back with the games with me so I think it's going to be a logistical nightmare um it's going to be very expensive but who knows maybe one day when the Channel's big if it gets big then I'll do that just as an event to say I've done it because I would like to do it but it's going to be pretty difficult but hey maybe one day and Tony has asked uh what is a reasonable Max oh Max mouse cut up for a game collection that provides an adequate blend of designers play accounts mechanisms and game lengths all those kind of things you're looking for um is it okay it's this it's like how long is a piece of string really how many different things do you want but I'm pretty sure you could get 50 games as a as a Enthusiast and have a good blend of mechanisms good blend of play accounts you want to be looking at games that kind of fit many of those metrics so very flexible games um that's what I would look for if you want to keep a nice concise um concise collection and it is doable you know I'm very guilty of having tons of dice drafting games do I need them all probably not but one might have a certain difference or something special about it that makes me want to keep it when you know if I'm being objective I might want to be brutal and say they roughly do the same thing I probably don't need them both but you know this

is my main hobby I like to have variety so um but yeah I reckon you could boil it down to around 50 games to have a good blend of you know card games filler games longer games area control games you know simple pushy luck games all these things you can boil down into quite a nice collection because again there are so many versatile games out there um and the final question from Tony is can a collection ever reach a stable state where new releases are no longer desired um or is the search for new material and unsatiable really um well again it goes back this is our hobby you know we look forward to the new stuff and it will become pretty stagnant if we didn't always look forward to something new now I don't mean that has to be the key Focus or the you know the main focus of the hobby always looking for the next thing but I think it is important that we always move forward and have something to look forward to otherwise or at least talk with myself personally I would lose interest quite quickly but I do feel like you can have a stable collection where it's very difficult for a game to kind of find its way in to find a niche in your collection um and to be honest I'm nearly there I I more and or kind of less and less often am I enthused about new games because I think you know what this game looks cool but I've got this game in my collection which is very similar and I'm more than happy with that one so um yeah I think I think it is achievable maybe in a kind of one in one out system but um but yeah I think ingrained in us to always want something new and um to always at least keep one

eye opener about what's coming out there because there could be something that um is going to be fantastic and I think we would like to say we've never played our perfect game yet that's why we're always in the in the uh in the mood to buy something new so that's it ready um hopefully you've enjoyed the video we have lots of different um questions here I really do appreciate you um submitting them again please please please leave new questions in the comments of this video and I will answer them in the next one um as usual be sure to check out the show's sponsor at keyienda dot Co dot UK always do a great job of supporting the channel so thank you to them and also check out my other content and that good stuff but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved