Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 19:16

Hi everybody.

Hello. I'm Ryan. I'm Bethany.

And we are Ryan and Bethany board game reviews.

And today we're not reviewing a game.

No,

we're not doing a top 10.

What?

We are going to have a conversation.

Oh, no. Are we in trouble?

No, we're not in trouble. We're not in trouble at all. We kind of want to talk about how we manage our collection with limited space. intentionally. We intentionally um don't want to expand and so we mentioned in a video if anybody would be interested in hearing that and one of you would be interested in hearing that. So we're making this video for you.

It's for us, too. It's fun to talk about.

Yeah, it is fun to talk about.

All right. So, uh I think that some people would say that we have a huge collection. People come over and they're like, "You have so many games." And other people even within our gaming group are just like, "You have just a little baby collection. Just a wee little baby collection."

But just wait. Give it a couple of years, you can grow. Yeah, you can grow your collection.

So, yeah. So, what we really have is on our actual shelves, we have about 250 games

uh that we kind of have as our games, right?

Then we've got in another pile off to this side, we've got about 50 games that are in our trade pile, things that are no longer stuff that we're going to be keeping. And then in another pile, we've got about 50 or so games that are things that are on our uh review backlog, things that we have to be reviewing or want to be reviewing uh in the near future. So all together, we have about 350 games in our house at any given time. Um we'd like it to be smaller. Maybe if we could get it down to like 300, that would be even more ideal. Great.

Uh especially given those kind of two very very fluid categories of incoming and outgoing games. But if we could float around 300, that would be even better. Um, we have two 5x5 kixes and that's our gaming wall.

Yeah.

Um,

and four of them aren't being used.

Yeah. This is a fun little background.

And then one grid is actually just for our kids and their games.

Yeah. And then we get we have the piles on the floors as well and just various other things in various states of disarray. A lot of games in and out of our collection. Probably probably a very fluid collection as the nature of a lot of reviewers. Yeah, I would I would expect

um we are not collectors.

No,

when we very first started playing board games, we kind of had a little bit of that mindset like let's say Dominion, you know, was big when we were kind of collecting our hobby and we were we wanted every expansion,

every promo card, every everything they came with the second edition. We need to have all upgrade kits and stuff like that.

And we quickly realized that's fun. We like that. Six years ago is when we were like it's Yeah. It is fun to have everything, but we

we have like variety, too.

Yeah. And we're not collectors. We don't want to just buy more kaixes. We don't want to just get more shelves. We we want to only have games we play.

Right. So, that's kind of the core of what we want. We have we want 250 games that are actually games that we're going to use regularly and and ask for regularly and enjoy or they fill some special part of our you know hole in our collection for some reason or another.

So that's kind of what we're working with. Um why do we how do we get all these different games? What's one of the sources why we get some of these games?

So the source where we get the least amount of our games um is Kickstarter. We do not back a lot of games. However, early on in our board him hobby, we probably backed a lot more than we do now. We're very specific about what we do back. Um, unfortunately, when we back now, we we back big. So, those take up a lot of space. We don't back up. We don't back a lot, but they just like

they're usually the big boxes.

Yeah. And because of that limited space, you know, that might eventually help drive down the quantity of games because that would take up two or three other games as boxes. Also, we thrift for games. We like going to garage sales and and Goodwill, things like that, and just seeing if we can find a cool game, usually hobby games, you know, and every once in a while, you'll find some gem for for a decent price, and that's fun to pick up and try out or give away or whatever, too. So, we pick up some games on thrift.

Yeah. Yeah. And if we're ever traveling and then of course here locally, we like to visit our FLGS and we like if we're in a different city to just see what they have, see what they have to offer and support an entity like that existing.

And then of course as reviewers, we get we get some review copies of games which is really which is really awesome. We're blessed to be able to have that. So because of all those sources and probably some more that we're not thinking of gifts or whatever, we we we have a big influx of games and even the ones that we thrift we still put in the pile of ones that we would like to review eventually. So, uh, that's we got that big pile over there. Um, what are some of the ways that we get rid of games?

Okay, so first of all, our collection is very fluid. It's always changing at any given time. Um, the one of the big things we do is our um, FLGS does a huge board game sale every November. And so that's a good time for us to just kind of go through our collection and colell some things to put in to be a part of that um FLG not FLGS to be part of that big game used game sale. Yeah.

Um we have the board game geek. There's a geek market where you can uh list games for sale. That's a great way to for people who are looking for very specific games to be able to find specific games.

So I like listing games on there as well. BG gets a cut of your sale which is cool because we love that site and we use it so often. We like even if

you you like you're like yes please. I you you're such a huge resource for me.

We're okay with taking that little cut of it or whatever.

Yeah. We also give away a lot of our games. Um we do them as prizes at different events that we've done before. Uh different events that we run. So we just give away games as well

or if there's someone who like uh is interested in a game but it's something we're kind of ready to pass on anyways. We're just like

sounds good. Take it, you know, enjoy. um uh Facebook groups that's kind of like BGG where you can kind of there's used games uh that you can list on there and and different marketplaces and different groups and that's kind of fun. Um I used to do some math trades like there was a Gen Con math trade, there was a a a Geekway used to have a math trade. They've kind of changed what they do for that as well. And it is uh a little bit more work, but it's kind of fun because you can put up uh a cool game that someone else might want. In exchange, you get from someone else entirely a cool game. So, it's like

I give my game to person A, A gives it to B, B gives it to C gives C gives it to C and I get I get a game from E or whatever. So, but math races are are very cool. Yeah, we probably don't do a lot of those now just because we have so many games to review that we're not actually seeking out. There's a few titles that I know both Ryan and I would love to get our hands on, but because we have other things to occupy our time, it's not like we're desperate for any of those.

That's the kind of thing we can hunt for on other places, but it's just Yeah, it's hard to do. Um, also this is going to sound weird, but we don't like playing one-time use games and we don't we hate throwing away the components because it's like, you know, it's like throwing away a a memory and b uh components. It's just filling up landfills and whatever else. I think it's something we all kind of struggle with as board game hobbyists, but at the same time, there's a small part of us that's kind of like, uh, I have to figure out where to store this.

Like every time you play an exit game, you can't pass that on. you're tearing stuff up and you're like, well,

can't stay on my shelf.

Guess I have to pitch it. So, there's uh there's that idea as well of of one time use games which kind of help. We get to play have a game, get have a great experience. It goes in through our process and then doesn't have to ever go to the

we have to deal with it process.

Yeah.

Which is kind of nice.

Okay. So, all that's great, but what you really want to know is how do we choose which games we're keeping and which games we're getting rid of? We got you all the background, all that information, and now is when we get into the nitty-gritty of what we do. Um, a very simple one is it just replaces something. So, like we backed Castles of Burgundy, so we're not going to have two copies of Castles of Burgundy. It like literally replaced our old copy. So, it literally like takes a spot of something we already have.

Another thing might be if there's a a a direct better version of something. Yeah. So, for instance, Wingspan, uh, we love Wingspan and we've had some expansions for it and but those expansions take up space and Finsspan came out and it's does a it scratches a whole lot of the same itch. It's, you know, 80% the same game or whatever. Uh, and takes up less space because there's no expansions for it yet.

We're okay with Pac Wingspan because we like to win fins span that much more.

Yeah. And they're similar

and there's lots of people in our in our game group that have wingspan. So, if we really needed to play it, we could find a way to make that happen. Yeah. Um, so like another thing and these sometimes games don't replace perfectly. Like they don't replace the exact same game. Like those were really specific things. But let's just say for like a party game. I actually we don't have a lot of party games. We're not huge party gamers, but my family loves party games. So I'm only going to keep a party game if it's going to replace something we already have and my family's going to get more enjoyment from it. So that's happened a few times. I think landmarks might have been and that's kind of partyish. It's party like

we use like a party game whether it is.

Yeah, we use it like we use it like a party game. Um so like if it has the same feeling type of thing. So with party games, we're looking for really fun interactions and games that are going to make us laugh. And so if there's a game that does that, has fun interactions and it's going to make us laugh even though it doesn't play like another party game. If we know, oh my gosh, my family's absolutely going to love this. We're definitely bringing this to every Thanksgiving and every Christmas more so than this other game. We're going to cycle that out.

Uh something that's very unique. It has nothing else like it in our collection. We're going to we're going to keep that just because it's like oh that's cool. We just played one recently. Valconia. It's like that's such a weird unique cool thing. Um

I want to hang on to something like that. So

I've got to find something else to get rid of even though there's nothing else like it. So then in that case, we'll just go to whatever is not being asked for, whatever is taking up space, um, whatever that game might be and replace something like that. So we can have a cool, unique game that fills that hole.

And I think with a lot of people who are in any hobby, there's going to be a few of those items that are sentimental and even if they don't get like with board games, even if they don't get to the table a lot, you're you're going to keep them because of the sentimental value. We do, of course, have a few games like that. A few of our kids games are like that. It's really funny. We um we even make our our girls call their board games as well. And there was one that they wanted to get rid of that I said they couldn't because I was like it just like I have sentimental value with it. I'm going to keep it and I'm going to play with your kids. Trust me, I do not do that for the majority of things we have. I'm not that person that thinks I'm going to be able to hoard all of my children's stuff so that I could share it with their children. I I'm we're not those people. But this one particular game, if you're curious, is Dragon Domino. I just I absolutely loved it. But um I like want to carry that on. So I'm I'm hoarding that for them.

Hey, whatever works. Yeah. So that's kind of how things might um super, you know, superimpose something else. But also, why would we get rid of something? How would we choose to get rid of something? So we actually have a rule in our house that if something has not been asked for for in over a year we move on even if we like it if not played because sometimes you're going to you pull out a couple of games you have free time. Oh these are the three we want to play and you only get one to the table. You actually only play one. So we're not talking about that. But if a game has not been asked for or talked about in over a year that's a good sign for us we're not wanting this game anymore. We liked it. It has a really cool system we think is cool. But at this time, that's a collecting item. That's not a hobby item. That's not something we're actively getting use from, so we need to pass it on.

So, speaking of collecting items, if we find out that a game that we have that we're just like, we're good on, you know,

is randomly has become worth a lot of money because of scarcity or demand or whatever,

we're going to sell it.

We're going to sell it. So, Batman Love Letter, it's a game that we um

really liked. It's one of our favorite love letters. We've got other love letters, right? And they don't have a bunch of a lot of space. But for a while there, they were going for like 80 bucks or something because of the scarcity of them.

And I was like,

are you telling me that this game that I paid five bucks for is going for 80?

Yeah.

I'm willing to play other versions of Love Letter to get $80 a profit of $75.

Heck yeah, man. Heck yeah. Yeah. So, yeah, that's um just every once in a while games will, you know, we follow a lot of that kind of market stuff on the used games and uh what happened recently with merchandise, you know, if

yes,

we had never played the original merchandise, but because the secondary market was growing so much on it,

we never were going to play that game.

But then they were like, "Okay, so if this going for that much on the secondary market used, we probably need to do another print run of it."

Yeah, that's a good call. And it's fun because like I said earlier, we have the um our game store does that huge sale in November. So, it's actually a good our year is basically November to November. Um because that's when we can judge our collection of of that. Have we even asked for this? Have we even pulled it out? Would it be worth relearning the rule book to play this game again? Um so, that's probably a good like that's probably where our cycle our year cycle goes from. And there's some games that immediately when I'm done playing it and reviewing it, we're like, "That wasn't a keeper." You know, it was fun. It was cool, you know, but it's not a keeper. It doesn't replace anything. Didn't do a good enough job.

So, if you hear us saying in one of our videos, "Oh, this was a keeper." That means it actually means something to us. That means we booted out a game that we previously said was a keeper. You know, we only have a limited amount of space. So, if we say this is a keeper,

it must be pretty dang fun

for our taste,

right? For our within our system. Yeah. It's a pretty cool thing. Um, so does the do we have any regrets coloring stuff?

Okay, so this is like a great question and I think this is an important question. So we've been intentional about our collection for about six years now. I'd say 18, 19 is when we decided we weren't going to

buy more shelves. We were just going to work with what we have. And there have been in that time only two games we've regretted and only one game we've rebought.

Yeah. I mean that's a pretty decent, you know, testimony. I guess it's a pretty decent uh case study on that. I don't think Yeah, a game has to be pretty spectacular for us to be like, "Oh, wow." Like that did something that we've never ever come across again. So,

and it's funny cuz the game we rebought, I don't even know if we'll play it again. It was just so unique. It was such a unique game and I thought about it that I mean that's a big thing for for board games is if you think about the game when you're done with the game and I did I did think about this game quite a lot and it made it onto a lot of my top 10 list and I was like maybe we should just have that game.

I think it was one of those ones too that I was like I think we can get a good price of this because the demand you know structure of it is is weird versus the supply.

Yeah. So, I mean, it's it's hard managing a collection. Coloring things is not fun. We don't like getting rid of games. It's it's a lot of work actually to sell and and trade and give away and all the different stuff. It it takes time to manage all that,

especially we I'd say we get between 75 and 100 games a year,

probably.

And we get rid of 75 to 100 games a year because of how the nature of things work.

Uh, so it's it's uh it's a lot of work, but it's worth it to not just have

stuff. I mean, if we kept every game that we ever got, we would need rooms and rooms and rooms and rooms full of stuff, shelves everywhere.

We'd never touch these games. We'd never think about them. And in fact, it would be a burden to get to the games that we liked. We'd have to sift through things.

Um,

and then it's one of those things where I mean, I know it's morbid, but eventually you're going to be dead and then your family has to deal with all of that. Or if you need help and you have to move be moved into a home or something and they have to deal with all of your crap. I mean, as it is, Jul is going to be a nightmare. Imagine if it was 5,000 games or, you know, whatever. So, and I think as we get older, as we maybe get into our 60s or 70s or whatever, I imagine we're going to get down to 100 games.

Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. I think that as we that's easily going to happen because a lot of them will be rare and we'll fill them.

Well, I think that and just, you know, we we just we're going to time will be more valuable to us. Yeah. You know, time is valuable no matter what age you are, but we think about it a little bit more, I suppose.

Yeah. And we probably there might be games we can't like physically play or the text is too tiny now we can't read it

or like memory games. We're like, I don't remember.

That'll be really interesting to see what our collection looks like when we're in our 50s.

We find dexterity games and I'm just like,

yeah. Yeah, they'll be Oh gosh, that'll be so interesting.

We'll do another video about that when it's time to call games based off of our age.

Yeah. Oh gosh, man. That would be so awesome.

Subscribe and stay tuned for that video.

That would be so awesome if we're like we're still like doing stuff and people still care about what we're doing and that lag. But we're just curious. Do any of you um guys, how do you manage your collection? Are you collectors? You just like owning a lot of games? Totally fine because people like us borrow games from you. So, we do not mind the collectors out there whatsoever. or do you have limited space so you actually can't have a great collection? H how do you handle that? Um do you find anything that we said helpful? Or do you actually follow some of the same thing the same rules that we follow without even meaning to? Let us know in the comments below.

Yeah, I agree. I think I've heard some really cool anecdotal stories people who are like I've got to find, you know, just 20 games. what are the what 20 games would cover the biggest you know amount of mechanisms and situations and that's the 20 games I want and that's unless something replaces something that's what I'm going to keep and I love that idea I know people who are just I want 10,000 games I want to I want a library a legitimate library and that's cool too as long as you have a plan for it so uh we love hearing all those stories be sure to keep us posted in the comments below we want to hear modern mall

well everybody don't forget to subscribe so you can see our videos as they come out until then you can find us in all of these places.

Thanks for watching and we will see you next time.

Bye

bye everybody.

You guys, thanks for watching our shenanigans. As always, we appreciate it. Over here, if you follow this link, you're going to find a playlist that we've hand selected, handcrafted just for you, uh, because you watch this video.

And if you check over here, this is a video that YouTube thinks you might like. So, you can check that out if you want as well.

All right, we appreciate it, guys. Thanks so much for watching, and we will see you next time. Bye.

Progress saved