Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 9:44

worker placement is a board game mechanic with four basic elements first each player has a number of workers to allocate secondly the workers are used to gain an action or resource the third aspect is that the players compete for a limited number of spaces and finally all workers are usually returned at the end of the turn what do you think is the biggest worker placement game the biggest as in the one I like the most are the most father that's obviously agricola oh really yeah I think so yeah it's not the one I think is the best but it's certainly the most popular or it seems to me you have a mom and dad to start do send them out every day they work on their farm and then they get stuff and you're competing with other players to get goods and yeah I think maybe that's one of the things that what worker placement is as limited places in which to put them so you're sure competing with other people to get it you know to pick the ones you want before someone else picks that's a particular spot you have a strategy and you need to get certain things strategy there's lots of different things you can do in lots of different ways of completing certain things you never really sure what the best route to take us by message you're familiar with it which I'm not I haven't played it enough having only played it once i can

say that the one time I did plate I was confused ninety percent of the time didn't really know why I was doing or why I was doing it Stone Age I like it along with you yeah i think is a very good you some people don't like the round in this my new the dice rolling when you because you're basically using your workers to get dice yeah true you roll the dice to get goods so there's a bit of a gambling element but it really heightens the fun why haven't found to make that big of a difference is i mean you because you're rolling generally you're rolling several dice and they tend to average out and yeah you can get a lucky roll every once in a while but that doesn't it's like it turns and you have the tools which kind of yeah the jewels i find yet tools are really quite so the use of it yeah now the what i like about it is that specific strategies unlike agricola because you don't have so many different cards and so many different things that much easier to pick a strategy and to stick with and then if that's not working you can change my game and it doesn't only destroy your chances with it because it's you know it's it's it's open enough and yet your choices are limited enough that you're not sitting there wondering okay without weighing on what of these 15 different choices do I take roses and it's it's not so stressful to know exactly some people like a curriculum because it's so tight because it is straight out yeah but if

Xander winds down so H turned gets more and more stressful right it's only just nice and light and you can play with newbies and they'll even have a chance to win practically under strategies yeah pillars of the earth i realize thats one of my favorites as well at one of them a messy need for what replacement is definitely say it's work these resources yeah but also the the big guys they call the master-builders yeah yeah i mean that's definitely as you're taking a kind extending amount to a specific spot in order to do a specific thing i've heard a lot of people complain about the luck factor is drawing of those out of the bag but the expansion i think really helps that and even without it it's not that big of a deal because it's not like ever return you're going to become applause Andy and if you do or even if you are the last me to come out sometimes that's beneficial because you then you get all your choices for free yeah I think the part where you're putting up the workers is working placement with the master builder part its role selection pretty much yeah because well when I think of work replacement games I usually think of the workers getting resources specifically because otherwise it's it's like you said they they do they do a role for any more like Puerto Rico where you have different ones that you do but we're up port right here yeah you do

roles each turn but there's also an element where you have buildings that you need workers to activate set them out to the field theory sources and you also send them out to work in the buildings right I think that element is worker placement but the element of doing roles i think is similar to the part of pillars of the earth where you're master-builders go on doing what's now I see what you're saying about colors and with how it is definitely it's like you're doing well selection whereas with the workers you're definitely just placing the workers but that's not so much placing workers it's just committing them to think that you've chosen already Cuba it's not a worker placement get 0 by defining them now yeah I think you could say because you do have to pick well that's what I'm saying because you use roles but but then you actually have any worker placement it has one worker who gets resources for real but you place them in different spots to get different resources yeah no I wanted no sitter Cuba or the blazer they're not competing with other people for CA s cube is definitely more full selection technically you are placing a worker here resources by here I think you have to compete with other people for space for it to be a working place yeah that would think that that would be one of the criteria age of

empires three that's definitely each turn you're competing for space and any of the areas like Colin is don't trade goods are on the ships then you're competing for space in the area control yeah what I really like about this one is that you all you always feel as though you have to get your workers on the spots that you really want to do this round but you have to make sure that you pick them in the order that somebody else before someone else is going to look like the order in which you choose your the where to place them is very important yes it's always I find it's agonizing as to which choosing which one to pick first because they're always more than you definitely want it was more than one that you never want and i don't think i've ever played around where I've got them to put a worker everywhere that I want what there's always somebody gets something I'm always having to stick oh well I have some leftover I might as well put them in the discovery that's very sad what about to call me think that's a little placement game I have no idea because I've never played played this yes

yeah workers you have buildings but you're not really competing for other places with it I mean you are kind of well there's an area control yeah it's more area control I think than the worker placement in that aspect that you have workers that you use to activate your own buildings but it's not like you're going to run out of your own buildings activate their places for your workers to go knowing you're not just like a worker commitment you're not you're not getting resources you're not yeah like you said competing with your own buildings yeah yeah nope next this about homesteaders that's home is that a worker placement it's definitely have workers and you definitely place them but you're not competing with other players to put them out before the places all get filled up because you can only place them in your own buildings homestead is more of an auction game to anything else that seems to be the main plus it has another element of worker placement games might be that you have to them or is this what reside pay yeah The Pillars of the Earth you don't have to pay them anything like that no they just all automatically come back to you so many nights at Stone Age you have to feed them same with agricole and I have to feed them and every phase or else but

not ages of empires age the vampires you just get them all back true enough except well actually don't really get them back you just get a certain amount because you have them out they go out and now hit it so it's not like and then you can buy new one so so I think the problem is with trying to categorize or pigeonhole everything into work replacement idea when it actually even that concept to cover several different mechanisms in them itself sub mechanism exactly sub mechanisms oh my god now are we

Progress saved