Top 10 Board Games That Exceeded My Expectations
Transcript
hi everybody today i'm talking about my top 10 board games that exceeded my expectations so all these games i went into my first theme and you know expecting to like them somewhat because i'd heard other good things or they just seemed like they'd appealed me to some you know to some level but even from that point i left the game feeling you know what that was pretty damn excellent and even better than i thought they were going to be so i've ranked these games in order of what i was expecting to how good they actually were in my in my opinion so they're not necessarily in my um in the order of my least favorite to my most favorite however that i think they loosely are um just by coincidence and before i get into the video i want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor kianda dot co dot uk who are my go-to online retailer here in the uk and if you use my link in the show notes you can get five percent off your first order but let's get on with the video at number 10 i have the lost ruins of arnac which is like a hybrid deck building worker placement game which to be honest are things that normally don't terribly excite me um however because i was a little bit late to the party with this one it already reached a level of popularity and just just success really i mean a lot of people love this game so i thought you know it's got to be good so i'll go into it with her you know with her with an idea that it's going to be good but it even worked better than i thought it was going to because it's a very smooth game and very little complication and i think one of the things i like most about this game is the fact that the the game arc works really well because there's only a few rounds in this game the first time or the first
round you're not achieving too much but by the end of it you're pulling off a lot more and taking much juicier turns you're playing through a lot more cars your cars are getting better as you're collecting resources you're visiting different locations to try and slay these animals i'm getting points and climbing tracks and it's just a really well-rounded game that i can certainly see why people have latched on to because you know a lot of people want to um you know stop at this level because they're happy with this level of complexity where there's still a good degree of options but they don't want all that extra rules complexity or you know really get into those heavier games where this game is just a lovely example of catering to a wide and versatile audience where again relatively inexperienced games can enjoy it but still more experienced gamers can get some enjoyment and some satisfaction from the gameplay mechanisms as well so you know what i can certainly see why it was good and it was even better than i thought it was going to be so that is the lost runes of arnak at number 10.
at number 9 i have rajas of the ganges the dice charmers so this is the roll and right version of raja's of the gang which is a more involved worker placement game that i actually used to have in my collection but i did end up removing it because i tend to lean towards heavier more involved work placement games as a preference but i thought if i could get a smaller more concise faster version of raj of the gun used then i'd at least give it the benefit of the dial and give it a go um because i thought it might encapture some of the feel of the main board game and i'm glad to say this game certainly does do that you have that river mechanism you even have that awesome endgame trigger where if you meet your points with your money then it's going to um you know signify the winner so it's that race aspect where you're balancing your two currencies love the way that works and on top of that this game has all the hallmarks of a great role and right game where you can string actions together get those huge domino effect combos um and just take massive turns and um yeah so so impressed with this one lots of different things to manage it has a good dice draft a good tension um kind of resource management as you're trying to collect different types um you know a bit of root building a bit of a kind of ratchet system as you can go down this river just a lot of things in a very simple package that has definitely become one of my favorite roll and right games and i've definitely exceeded my expectations on what a roll and write game can be when it's based on an original design at number eight i have long shot the
dice game which is a bidding and betting style game as you're trying to pick a winning horse and invest as much money as you can in that horse to get massive multipliers when it comes to end game scoring you can also buy horses yourself and if you own that winning horse you're gonna get additional money you're collecting helmets and jerseys for additional points um lots of different things you can do here considering it is a rather simple um you know betting game as you're you know rolling dice and moving horses along um and this game when it was on kickstarter i was really on the fence whether to back this one or not because i do tend to like these style games but i thought do i need another one because i already had a camel up in my collection at the time i hope this looks somewhat similar do i need it essentially but i was very fortunate to go to a convention where somebody brought this one out to the table we played an eight-player game i believe and i was absolutely enamored with i was just infatuated and i thought it was so exciting and i had to immediately own it because i enjoyed it that much so yeah definitely had that kind of initial backers removed but i'm glad it's more available now at retail and i have it in my collection definitely a party vibe gay style game but people are going to understand it and it still does have some good tension you have that kind of ruckus um you know cheering along your horses trying to get into the finish line you even have a bit of tomfoolery when it comes to kind of moving horses backwards and forwards and if you if a horse that you're not bidding on is winning you can pull it back if you if you want to and which might really mess with other players so you do have a little bit of take out and things but it still manages to pull it
off to a very high standard and i think it's a fantastic example of a bidding game and a racing game at that so that is a long shot the dice game at number seven i have air land and sea which is a two-player head-to-head card game um as you're trying to compete over three theaters of war in london c of course and you're gonna do that by playing these cards from your hand and these cards are going to have kind of two different pieces of information on them the first of which is going to be the theater of war that you can compete in like the obviously the airplanes are only going to be able to compete in the air area or the tanks are going to be in the land area and of course the ships in the sea area but they're also going to have a number assigned to them and that number is going to show the influence that it can control that region so the value of sixes are very powerful however the higher cards have weaker abilities on them so if you play like a level one card it might not be worth so much influence but it has a very powerful ability on them which can really mess with your opponent by flipping their cards over making them like weaker or even helping yourself by kind of breaking rules that you wouldn't normally be able to do i think this game might be one of the best examples of a a very delicately balanced game where every card is being meticulously designed and how it interacts and synergizes with the other cards is just genius so not only do you have to think about you know where are you playing these cards are you going to play them face down but also the order in which you play the cards because that is going to massively impact on the way these abilities are triggered so
sometimes you have to kind of sit back and let your opponents display what they're going to do before you play your cards or sometimes you have to get them down early um but the thing i like most about this game is the end game or the way that the um the points are divided because if you feel like the battles are not going your way you think you're going to lose you can choose to retreat from that battle and the earlier you retreat it means you're going to give fewer points to your opponent whereas if you fight to the better end and then lose that way you're going to give a lot more points to your opponent and it's basically going to be a race to get to 12 points and i think that's a brilliant mechanism it's definitely one of the kind of outstanding features from airline and c and i think this is just an exquisitely designed a game i'd highly recommend at number six i have another two player game with caesar sees rome in 20 minutes so this game is actually a follow-up to a game called blitzkrieg which is very popular and successful tug of war game and i like that game but i didn't love it you know i'm not the biggest fan of tug of war but when i heard that caesar was coming out it uses a lot of the same mechanisms i.e in drawing these tokens from your bag and those being the ones you can play with but this one is more of an area control style game and considering this is two players and two players only i thought how is this going to work because normally area control games don't work that well with two players however this game completely blows that theory out of the water as this game is one of the most tense games i think i've ever played as you're placing these tokens on these different
regions however these tokens have two different numbers on them and you have to place them on a border between these different regions meaning that one number is going to go in one region and the other is going to go on the other so you have to be very careful what you want to bid and kind of you know influence in each region however you have to be additionally careful because if anybody closes off a region whether they can whether they are winning the bid or not or winning the influence or not then they are going to get this very powerful token which means that they can maybe um you know eliminate one of your tokens already on the board or they can place um place a lot more that influence circles down faster which is the you know the end game winning criteria um so every single one of these tokens is highly sought after you have to be very careful careful with every single placement you make in this game it has that perfect degree of having a strategy but almost tunnel visioning that strategy by you know giving you only a few options to place at any time where if you have too many options i think it could be a bit overwhelming and almost steer away from the fun and restrictiveness of the game so yeah if you want a very um a very tense game that you can play at two players that only takes about 20 minutes to play um it really does not get better than caesar definitely one of the best depth to time ratios that i have in my collection and again another game that massively exceeded my expectations at number five i have viceroy which is a game quite unlike anything else in my collection and in this game you
are essentially building up a pyramid of cards the higher you build these cards in the pyramid the bigger rewards you're going to get however the more expensive it's going to be by spending these rooms but you also need these rooms in order to acquire the cars in the first place using this blind bidding system where you can only select one one rune um they're coming i think it's four or five different colors and you're going to simultaneously reveal those rooms and if you are the only person to choose that color then you get to draft the card that you bid for however if more than one person has been the same color then they're going to cancel each other out and you're going to have to bid again meaning that if you keep doing the same thing again and again you're going to keep bleeding those rooms which is going to be hugely inefficient so sometimes you need to know to you know know when to stop and go for plan b instead but i love the um pure variety of different ways you can score in this game a ton of different strategies you can go down um great artwork on the cards i'm just a really fun game that feels different each time because again there are so many different cards in this game another game that's not very complicated but complicated enough to keep you coming back to it and yeah massively exceeded my expectations that is viceroy at number four i have nova luna by oovey rosenberg so rosenberg generally is a designer i don't gel terribly well with but that normally applies to his heavier games nova luna is of the lighter variety and actually shares a lot of dna with a game called patchwork which is a game i do have my collection that i've enjoyed
a lot over the years however patchwork is more of a polyamino style game this one uses tiles in a completely different way even though you are drafting them in the same way using this time track system where you can kind of select one you can go one to three spots around this rondelle uh when you draft a tile you're gonna move your player piece a number of time spaces i'm equal to the value on that tile meaning that you will not get another go until everybody else has exceeded you on that rondelle which i really do love that system um but understand you're trying to place these different colored tiles in a way where they're touching other colors or you can trace a root through other colors and once you've achieved all these different criteria on that tile you get to put these tokens on it to show that those tiles are complete but when sometimes when you place these tiles it will trigger a bunch of tiles because everything will line up perfectly where you know this tile needs to touch a yellow and yellow this time needs to touch a red and a blue this one needs to touch you know three yellows and so on and if you do things very carefully and map things out you can get these huge satisfying tones where with a single placement you can basically discard a bunch of tokens which you need to win the game so yeah really love the flow of this one love the different nature of the puzzle and this one keeps getting better and better for me and you know i was expecting to to like it because you know generally lighter weight puzzle games i tend to get some enjoyment from and they do have a shelf life for me but this one has been uh going from strength to strength i think it's a solid design and it almost feels timeless in the way it plays because it is so streamlined and just so
so pure the way it works so that is nova luna at number four at number three i have condottiere which is a card driven area control game where you're trying to place three tokens of your color in adjacent regions to each other or five pieces of your color anywhere on the map um and you're gonna do that by again very clever hand management and card play and these cards are gonna consist of two different types there's going to be mercenary cards which are your you know general strength troops i'm ranging from one all the way up to value 10 i believe um and you're also going to get a bunch of these special cards which can completely mess with the game in a bunch of different ways such as making all cards value one or you know strengthening all your highest value cards um by an additional three points or maybe canceling out all the strongest cards and the way an order you play these cards is so so important because you do not actually replenish your hand of cards until certain things happen or until everybody has run out of cards essentially so this hand of cards has to last you multiple battles so that means that the almost the importance of mapping these cards out is is just increased exponentially because you need to pick your battles you know when am i going to invest these cars which are such a valuable resource or when am i prepared to just sit back and let the other players compete over these regions and hopefully bleed and exhaust all their cars leaving me in a stronger position for the next battle and i love that i love the interaction between the cars
when to play things at the right time as i said knowing when to when to partake in the battles and know where to set out and it all comes together in just a genius designer now the reason this excluded expectations for me is because i was really concerned about the randomness of the card floors you know are you going to have a brilliant hand of cards or are you going to get given a bunch of cars that are just subpar and while that could be argued it is the case i do really feel that you can do a lot with any hand of cards here should the circumstances be right and if you're looking for a game that scales well i think it's three up to six players this one works tremendously um has relatively easy rules and considering there are a bunch of different powers in that it's not difficult to remember and um yeah just a wonderfully put together game that just impressed me massively uh that is condottiere at number two i have mandala which is another two player only game this one is of the lighter variety however there is a ton of depth here into the decisions you have to make so in this game you are essentially playing cards either into the center of these two mandalas which will allow you to draw cards back into your hands you know to replenish your hand up cards but it'll also mean that those cards that you've placed in the center are going to be up for bids by each player and you're trying to collect these cards because that's going to be your victory points however the order in which you collect these cards is so important because the first card you
collected are only going to be worth one point each however as you collect different types of cards the one you know subsequently each card's gonna be worth an additional point so some cards might be worth only one point to you but they could be worth say four points to your opponent that meaning that when you are bidding to collect these cards you might want to use the cards that are worth a lot to your opponent to know that they're going to get out of the game so that your opponent can't have access to them so it sounds a bit more difficult than what it is in actuality but the flow of this game is fantastic takes about 15 to 20 minutes to play uh the nuances and the just the sophistication of the game design really did blow me away so i wasn't quite sure what to expect going into this one i had heard you know rumblings that this game was very well designed um pleasant but i never really heard a lot of people say that this was like up there with the great two-player games and i left this game feeling like this game is pretty much perfection when it comes to a two-player game i play this game very regularly i always have done since i've had this one in my collection and i love introducing this game to new gamers because they initially think that yeah this is a simple card game um you know a bit of back and forth a bit of hand management um but by the end of it think you know what there's something special about this one and i really do feel that way so that is mandala at number two and finally at number one i have capital lux two generations which is another card driven game however this one is multiplayer and i think it even has a solo mode so i
often call capital lux a game of blackjack with a moving target because what you're trying to do is you are trying to match cards in front of you to cards in the city which in the center of the board as closely as you can without going over that limit because if you go over that limit you're gonna wipe off all your cards when it comes to scoring and not score anything for them however when you play a card in the middle you get a pretty special ability and those abilities are going to vary massively depending on the setup that you've chosen at the beginning of the game so it has massive modularity in this game for a ton of replayability and all those abilities are absolutely fantastic and fascinating in the way they work and synergize with each other but i love the hand management of this one now when am i going to play cards in front of myself when am i going to add them to the capital when i'm adding to the capital i might be helping other players because um they they might be waiting for that to happen because then then they know they've got the green light to play cards in front of themselves however there's always that option to manipulate the board state and take cards away from the capital in order to mess with their plans and it's always on a knife edge with this game in terms of balancing things so carefully um love everything about this game it takes about 30 minutes to play ton of depth literally on the edge of your seat from start to finish the hand management is great um the modularity is fantastic you know every single pre-planned game mode in this game is right up there um and there's definitely no subpar version to play the game i know even the bear basics version
of the game i would have been more than content with if that was the only version in the box but the fact you get so much more content is just amazing i cannot praise this game enough it's amongst my favorite games of all time and if you want very clever or want a very clever card game experience that it does not get much better than capital lux 2 generations so there we go that is my top 10 board games that exceeded my expectations hopefully you enjoyed this video if you have please be sure to hit like and subscribe to my channel and let me know what games exceeded your expectations but for everybody else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye