Day 2 Live at Spiel 2025! with special guest Matthew Dunstan
Transcript
And we're live.
And we're live. Here we are.
Good morning. You can't really know where we are. Camera's in a better position.
Uh, yeah.
Okay. Good morning. I should probably
Oh, you're the host now.
Host today. Yesterday, Matthew was host. Um, so we did a live stream yesterday. We're We're in Essen. Uh, we're not at the Spiel convention yet. We're in Matthew's um hotel room, but we did a live stream yesterday morning talking about the day one. So, we had day two yesterday and uh we're going to do a little bit of a debrief on that. We haven't actually debriefed before this. So, it's um
got to keep winging it a little bit, aren't we?
Yeah.
So, um so uh this is Matthew Dunston. Matthew, you you probably know Matthew from his his own channel. So, Matthew also has a YouTube channel uh where he talks about board game design. Matthew is also a very prolific designer. Um has far more games than me, although we've been designing games for a similar number of years, haven't we? and we've known each other all those years and 11 12 years something like that. But Matthew designed um the adventure game series for Cosmos and Echo for Ravensburgger and Next Station for Blue Orange and uh Relic Runners and Alisium and so many more. Um Pioneer Days is one of my favorites.
Oh, thank you. It's coming back.
Days, is it?
It's gonna be
I heard it was going to come back. Who's
with an expansion? Uh I mean,
what can you not say? Uh, I don't think it's a huge thing, but no, they said, yeah, so it's with a company called Fantasy Games, um, which is a newish publisher in France. Um, so they were the original French uh, localizers of Pioneer Days.
Okay.
Well, they really like it and uh, yeah, so they're going to it's at some point it'll be republished with an expansion.
Uh, yeah, you had an expansion ready for the previous, didn't you? I remember you talking about that.
Great. Yeah, it's a good game.
You got it here.
Yeah. Lovely. So, um, yeah. Yeah. So, we're just going to talk about what our day was like yesterday. Um, I don't know if anybody's watching. If you're not, I'm sure you can catch up with us later. You can watch it later on.
If you're not, then you don't know that you're not watching because you
I'll find it later, I'm sure. Um, so yeah. How how was your day yesterday?
It was good. It was good. I thankfully did not have to go into hall three at all. So, for those, you know, if you've never been to Spiel, there's um the convention center is made up of uh seven or eight large halls, and they use seven of them. Uh and this year, actually, they added a hall, I'm pretty sure, because I think all seven is sort of
Yeah, they're all full. Yeah.
Yeah. And uh Hall three is where most of the kind of hobby hobby publishers that you would think. So, you've got Pegasus there. You've got uh Czech Games Edition. You've got a lot of like kind of the bigger Kickstarter publishers. Uh Mighty Board. Uh Mighty Boards and No Mighty Boards.
Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. My I mean I mean it's full. It's It's the largest hall I think actually. Probably.
Do you think I feel like they're all similar size? It's just that one's rammed with people. feels.
It's also very like narrow and long. So, you've got to But anyway, and it was it was I think it was clearly agreed upon that it was the worst pool to be in.
And yet, that's where all three of my games are. So, Gartfield are in there and Mind Clashes in there and Osprey games are in there. So, yeah, getting between my my releases is um quite hardgoing.
So, it was a bit of a harder harder trick for you yesterday through the halls. Well, I mean, it's nice they're all in the same place so that I can, you know, I'm not I'm not having to go back and forth too much, but um but it is a Yeah, it's hard getting through the crowds in that one.
But, but despite despite that, uh it was actually a really nice day. I had uh a few pitches which went well and a I'm only pitching one game, so it's a little bit easier for me this year. Not too much to kind of focus on.
What sort of game is it?
It is a multi multi multi-use card game. Uh
okay. Multi multi multi.
No. Well, that's a it's a slight exaggeration.
Are they hexagonal cards?
No, no, no, no, no. Well, that's that's an idea. Well, it's hard to shuffle. Uh, no. They are double-sided cards where every every side back and front are unique,
and you use the backs of the cards, which are islands, to every every game you randomly select 15 of them and make a board uh which is sort of an after Lego that all the players going to play on. And of course, all the islands have different effects and sort of thing. And then then during the game, you use the other side of the card, which is sort of crew uh that you can put in your ship or their goods that you can sell and load. And it's kind of your your typical, you know, engine building combo kind of game. Um pretty quick, pretty fast, and obviously lots of variety from from this sort of random setup every game. And I'm actually it's probably one of the games I like the most of my designs for quite a while. Um, not not that I hate my previous games, but this one is like really the type of game I really enjoy. Um, Race of the Galaxy is one of my favorite games and it's probably getting a lot like close to that kind of style of things. So,
good.
So, yeah. No, it's it's a it's a it's it's been good to pitch that. And I also had the chance to catch up with uh some friends um you know, who you don't get to see. So, like Amanda Panda, who is the newest, she isn't new, but uh she has just taken over the board game geek uh vlog or blog. Sorry if I got that wrong. The that Candace Owens used to do.
Okay.
So, um Amanda's doing that now. and we've only I've been on her stream a bit before, but she's from the States, so it was really great to to catch up with her and yeah, just generally, you know, see some friends and left I left the Messa for lunch, which is is a new uh initiative for me this year. I've
went out
I went outside like for a whole two hours.
Oh gosh.
It was uh it was it was very nice. I can recommend if you uh
I didn't do that. I queued at one of the food
Yeah. Yeah.
Trucks in the busy galleria.
Was the Was the food good?
It was nice. Yeah.
I think they've got more choice.
And you're also outside. It should be clear. Like
I wasn't outside. I was in the
Oh, the food truck
gallery bit. Yeah, there are lots of food trucks outside now. That didn't used to be the case. It's got better, I think.
Yeah. Yeah. It's expended. It's expanded. So, how was your day then, Adam?
Um, yeah, it was good. I had four pitch meetings. I spent an hour or so demoing Flip Pick Towers with Osprey.
Oh, it looks amazing, by the way. I saw it in the case at Osprey. Yeah.
Yeah, it is. It does. It's really nice. Yeah, it's they've done a lovely job of it and the artist is great. Beatrix Pap. Um, she's she's really good. Uh, it's so much fun to demo that game. I just, you know, I was just playing it with people and every time you flip over, you flip over cards and then you pick one of the cards and then you draw towers. That's why it's flip pick towers. Um, but every time you flip over the cards, you know, you're kind of revealing new stuff. And because it's like this fairy tale world, you know, suddenly a fairy pops up or a witch pops up or a dragon pops up and there's, oh, what what do we do with this? How does that work? Or you put a roof a roof pops up to put onto your towers or a bridge. How do we use bridges? You know, it's just everything's a new reveal in certainly in that first game. Um, and so it's it's just really fun to demo really.
It sounds like a game that you can also learn kind of while playing. Yeah, definitely. You can learn it while you're playing it. And then you're drawing these towers and and it's they're really easy to draw, but they look quite nice at the end, you know. Um because basically a tow, you know, it's just a series of squares, isn't it, on top of each other and a little triangle at the top for the
Don't don't break the dream for everyone,
but it ends up looking really. And if you're more artistic, you can make it all the more sort of lavish, you know. Um, so you know, people were talking to me comparing it to like ctographers where you can make those really sort of artistic things and that was a big inspiration for it. So yeah, that was really fun to demo. Um, uh, and I got a good good engaged group with that. And then I spent an hour or so at the G Hutchfield booth with Surikata. Um,
I heard you were defacing a lot of boards.
Defacing a lot of boards. That was amazing to me. these boards that I mean the games that um Gartfield make they're so beautifully made these beautiful handcrafted wooden um boards um you know and they're quite an investment as well really um and yet people were asking me to write on them with marker pen you know write uh my signature on the back of them and things I would I wouldn't write on marker pen on one of these if this was if I was you but you know if that makes them happy I'm very happy to do it
I think I was suggesting later that night that you should have you should be pyographer and use the kind of burning on the wood like and do your signature that way.
Yeah, that's right. Yeah. Yeah, that would be that would be nice. That would be fancy.
But you'd only be able to make games out of wood then. That's a That's a tricky thing.
Yeah. Yeah. You don't want to do it in a cardboard box. That's true.
And you don't have a game anymore. But then that's
Yeah. Yeah. My favorite moment yesterday was there was this really really nice guy who came over and he was a fan of the channel. He was talking to me. So we were talking about Flip Towers and we we spoke for quite a long time and then he said, "Oh, I've got something for you to sign." and he pulled out this um this uh it was a bit from Throne, my game Throne, and it was a flimsy bit of paper from the base of the insert, like the worst component of any of my games. Uh
was it specifically chosen to be the worst bit?
So, no, but I sort of He said, "Could you sign this for my friend?" So, I signed the back of it, a nice message for him, and then he said, "Yeah, we played Throne the other day. We didn't like it." I said, "Well, you're not the only one." But I just thought it was a funny you signed my game, but I didn't like it.
And and so now you've signed it and what are they going to do with it? This game they don't like that
presumably it makes it more valuable.
Well, maybe maybe or or maybe less valuable. I don't know. It's like you got the one that's
No, I think I think I think it was a genuine, you know, oh, this is a nice thing to have a signature on a piece from it. But it did. It was funny that it turned into the worst the worst component from my least popular game.
But how? Yeah. But do you still like the game you think thrown? Have you played?
I I really like it. I haven't played it recently. I really like it personally. Um but I have a feeling it's only fun if I'm playing it. I think probably because I'm enjoying it. Maybe that.
Um
but yeah, somebody's commented. Hello. Uh, so this survivors quest hoping to run into you at the com. Well, good. If you do, please say hello. Yeah, I've I've really enjoyed lots of people said hello to me yesterday. Um, that was really nice. Uh, and and most of them designers, a lot of them new designers, like people who've got their first game just coming out or they've just licensed their first game, they're waiting for it to come out and, you know, talking to me about the channel and how it's been helpful for them and things like that. So, that's that's really nice, you know. Um
yeah, you don't get that kind of face to face feedback very much on on this kind of thing. So
No, no, absolutely. Um I get nice comments of course on the videos and stuff like that, but you don't see the person and meet them face to face.
I had actually a really nice meeting. I sat with um yeah, a viewer on my channel who just reached out and said, you know, are you going to be at us? And and you know, we just sat and chatted about game design and he's um you know, pitching his first game. actually from the video game industry and kind of you know dabbling not dabbling making games in in the tabletop space as well and that was just yeah it was just also really nice kind of yeah it's it's I think that you know design it's and I think both of what we do you know we we got to where we were on the back of other people helping us out or giving us advice or contacts or or whatever and it's nice to be part of the cycle again. Yeah, definitely. And I think in the UK particularly, there's that nice play test network which pretty much all the designers come through. There's very few UK designers who haven't come through that play test UK network. Um because there's different groups in different cities around the country. Um and it's kind of an ethos that's built into that I suppose really, isn't it? To help everybody help everybody else out and then the people who've got a little bit more experience kind of share that experience and other people come up through that group. Um, I I think actually that does seem to be a global sort of attitude as well, though. I don't think that's unique to the UK. Um, but it does make you feel a bit responsible to do the same, you know, when you've uh, you know, you've gone through that. I remember one of my very first games.
I had a game called Sunburn. It was a which sounds like it's set on a beach, but it's not. It's in space. Uh, and you're using sun.
It should be called Solar Burn then.
That's not as catchy, is it? Oh,
it's a bit more spacey though, isn't it?
So, but you're placing planets and then if you place suns next to them, then then populations grow on these planets, but you don't want to overpop populate them and so on. But I played it with you. It was obviously very memorable.
I can't remember it at all.
It was the first time I met you, so it was probably
I hope I was nice about it.
It was probably 2012, 2013 something.
Wow. Okay. You've got you. So, what was my Was I about it?
Yeah. You had some criticisms, but you were nice. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah.
I thought you going to reveal and this was the day I decided that you were a you you know, like
No, no, no, no, no, no. You were very nice about it. Um I think I also played it with Brett at some point. I'm not sure he was quite as nice about it.
It's a bit more direct.
Brett Gilbert. He's very direct when he play tests games. It's very useful though, very insightful feedback, but it can be quite cutting straight through to cut out the rubbish. Right. We're getting straight to the point.
Yeah. Yeah.
So, um, uh, yeah, I remember playing that with you and you giving me feedback on that. I think you'd probably signed Relic Runners or Relic Runners had just come out at that point. Um,
so you were fairly new and I think Brett had just got
Yeah. I mean, he'd only had David. Yeah. So, we we each had maybe had a game each and and and I hadn't even really maybe pitched to many publishers or anything like that. Um, because
Relic Corners was signed without me pitching it. So, yeah, exactly. I had a tiny little bit of experience, but but not really anything much. And I'd made one game that I'd finished, so it's it's not like I'd sort of had so much experience making a whole bunch of
It was funny that game. I remember pitching Sunburn around to some publishers um probably about 2014, 2015, and all the publishers were just saying, "No, you can't make a Euro game set in space." Like, it's not in in in in the Euro sort of world. It doesn't happen. And then of course Terraforming Mars came out a few years later and now there's just loads of Euro games set in space.
Well, of course Eddie as well as another kind of
10 pole kind of.
Yeah. Yeah. But at the time there was this kind of group think that it wasn't possible. It just would not sell in Europe a European um a space game. Um so it's interesting how that group think sort of works. Like I bought yesterday a football game like a soccer game. Um and again there's this sort of idea that you cannot make a sports game. they do not sell and so on and most of the publishers won't look at a sports game, won't consider it. Um, and I do just wonder if at some point that'll change because I there must be a massive crossover of those fans and I just think maybe it's a bit of group think in the industry. You've made a football game before.
I have soccer game.
Yeah, exactly. Football jewel. It only came out in German but no, I quite liked it. Although I have to admit I don't know whether we were the best design. Uh I mean I think we delivered a great product but neither it was designed by Brett and myself and neither I or Brett particular football fans. I mean I know how it works. I can't speak for Brett but uh yeah I think I think if you get the the the crossover also of a designer who's really into the because I think you you know you get so much if you're designing about a topic or a theme that you are yourself are so into as well and you can bring that into the design and know which bits that you want to explore and
and highlight. Uh so yeah well actually the football game looked quite good though. What do you know it was called? I think it was the magic 11 or the magic number 11, something like that. It was from Plato. We were talking about Plato yesterday, weren't we? If you haven't watched yesterday's live stream, right, it's on Matthew's channel. Matthew's channel below.
Um, and uh, we talked about quite a lot yesterday, didn't we, about how Essen works and what sort of things we were going to be doing and and our past experiences at Essen and things like that. And we'll probably do another live stream tomorrow, I would imagine. Um, assuming that we're happy with how this one went after after today. Um, but uh,
what did you play any games yesterday?
No.
No. Apart from demoing Euro games, of course, but
I don't think I did.
You did? Otherwise, okay. Not not a memorable experience if you if you did. I I didn't either. So, yeah, for those who haven't been to Essen, it it is not exactly a playing convention really. You can demo games and at some booths you can demo the whole game actually. So you could, but there's so many people that being able to often you have to be able to queue up for a certain amount of time to
for a big game, but for a little game like I've only really been spending time in the um in the sort of halls with a lot of the Asian games and games from smaller publishers because I was trying to pick up things that I couldn't get at home.
Um and there you can get a demo immediately and you can play a whole game.
That's true. Of course, a lot of games. Yeah. So, I I you know, I certainly got some games shown to me yesterday, I think, but I didn't sit down and actually play one from start to finish, I don't think.
And do you think you'll fit that in at some point, or are you more just pitching in?
Can't imagine I'll fit it in. I don't think so.
It's a sad part of getting as part of a designer as an industry, you slowly play less and less games.
I know. I know. No, I don't think I'll fit it in. I'll buy some and then take them home and then
I might get round to play them at some point, I would imagine.
Yeah. this the shelf of shelf of opportunity I suppos
but uh no it's uh and and what kind of games which game do you think you're most excited or that was doing the best in your pitching of yours?
Well, I'm only pitching two.
Okay.
Uh
have you talked about them on your channel before?
I haven't. I don't talk about my games quite as free my prototype games quite as freely as some other designers. Like you just explained exactly what your game is, you know, and and so on. I'm always a little bit more cy than that. I fully subscribe to that like the idea that you should share your games, you know, in the public.
You're not allowed to trademark it or something.
No, no, I'm not looking to patent and trademark and copyright and those sorts of things, but I also sort of feel like you only really need to share it when you need to, you know? So, like I I'm very happy to take them to play test groups and play test them with people at the the UK Games Expo and this sort of thing, but I don't feel I feel like there's no need to kind of tell the world what I'm working on. So, like when Emberart came out, you know, I've been working on that for 10 years and I'd shared a few sort of shots of the prototypes and things like that over the years, but I'd never really talked about how it works or what it's all about or anything like that other than saying I was working on a Euro game. um just because I think although that the risk is tiny but I do think there's a risk of of you know somebody going oh that's a good idea and and and and going with it not a publisher but you know another designer or something like and probably the product they produce would be very very different to anything you've made.
So I think it's a minimal risk but also just for the surprise of like revealing this is what I've been working on. I think it's nicer.
Yeah. It's just I mean there's two things. One thing is that I I made a video about games that I couldn't sell. I'm not sure if you saw it where Yeah. Yeah. No, I did
made details of of So, these were finished prototypes, but they hadn't been signed to a publisher. In some cases, they had been signed to a publisher and then hadn't been released.
And interestingly, one reaction to that video is I had a publisher reach out or a person from someone who worked at a publisher who said they were interested in one of the games and they were going to unfortunately then they promptly left the company about a month later.
So, nothing happened. So I mean that's one instance where you know there was a tangible benefit to sharing and that you know that was a finished game that somebody could have gone off and you know maybe reverse engineer. They weren't particularly complicated games.
Well if anyone wants to make a um Euro style space game
that Matthew Denon didn't particularly enjoy. Um you know get in touch
and you could call it Solar Burn so it won't be overlapping. No but the other the other thing I was think I get asked I don't know if you get asked a lot on your channel. One thing that's been popping up quite frequently recently is that um people want to see the kind of start to end process of making a game like a real game like one of my games effectively.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Um you know and obviously to do that would require you being pretty much open about everything about the is it something you've ever thought of doing or you heard people ask for or
I think people probably have asked for it once or twice. Um, I don't I don't know. I don't think my process is that interesting on the on a on the the minutia of that granular level. Like, okay, it's it's good to look at the broad arc of like how a game went from this to this, but the individual decisions I make along the way
that a lot of them are pretty rotten decisions, you know, and you know, and most of my games go nowhere, you know, the vast majority of them I start designing them and then after a few play tests, I never do anything more with them. Um, so that's not going to be fun watching, you know, four or five videos of me making a game and then we go, "Well, this is rubbish."
Well, it's interesting. I I because I mentioned exactly the same thing. So, this has happened. Some people have made this comment and I started I actually made one video. I I had had a new idea about two weeks ago uh for a fairly simple dice game. And I thought, okay, this is not I I don't think I'd want to do something like this for a very complicated game because it's just too much to explain. And
so, I thought and I had had one play test of it and it it had actually gone quite well for a first play test. And so I thought, okay, maybe I'll try and do this series where I, you know, from from go to wo of of a game. And I recorded a video with the idea that I would kind of stitch them all together as maybe one long video or a few few kind of compilations or something. And then I took it to a play test the next day and it was terrible.
Okay. Yeah.
And then I was like, well, what am I going to do? Because my reaction to that play test, it was so bad that you had the videos stuff not been happening, I would have just either binned it or like put it on the shelf and not had any plan to revisit it as as it's quite normal.
Yeah.
Uh and but now the video thing I'm like, "Oh gosh, have I wasted time?" And I mentioned it to somebody else and they said, "Well, actually, you know, it might actually be quite refreshing for people to see that even I mean, not that we're hallowed game designers, but you know, game designers have had a lot of experience still make stuff that's terrible." Yeah.
Even when they think, you know, I talk a lot about, you know, filtering ideas and trying to figure out what's good before you work on them and all these sort of things. And and even I still don't get that right. You know, you you you think an idea is good and you put the time in to make a prototype and then and then it does bomb. So I guess my point is that showing it even though to us it feels very like how could that possibly be interesting. I think that something about reminding everyone that
I did show on one of my videos um a few months ago uh something like that two prototypes that I'd made that I decided I wasn't going to pitch even though I quite like the games uh and I went into a lot of detail with those. One was like a chess type game but you well it's basically chess but you're using cubes that rotate as you play. the chess pieces are constantly changing as you play. Um, which I couldn't I really enjoy it, but I couldn't really picture a home for it as a as a product. Um, because I think chess variants are very hard to find an audience for. And the other one was a which I really like the idea, but I couldn't quite get to work. It was a wrestling game using discs and you're flicking the discs and you got different size discs for different wrestling and you got different powers which mean you have to flick them in different ways and and so on and and I really like that idea but I couldn't really get it to work. Um so yeah, I think I made a video where we were I was talking about how how you assess your prototypes and work out which ones are worth pitching and which ones are not worth pitching and so on. And so that I use those two as examples
because those games were finished. So, you could have pitched them potentially.
Well, they weren't finished, but I think I they were they'd come to a resolution. I think I'd got to a point where I knew that, okay, these are probably going no further. So, at this point, I feel like there's no harm in talking about, you know, what's what's uh what I've done with them and so on. What do you think your percentages are these days of sort of you know if you think of if you start with say hundred ideas and then how many in terms of numbers that correspond to like a first prototype to a well iterated prototype and to something that you pitch do you think
these days I have very few ideas because I play so many games
so 10 ideas I would say 100
so if I have uh I used to have loads of ideas because I was playing loads and loads of games now I don't have so many ideas. Um but when an idea comes, I suppose I only really um uh indulge that idea if I see a product at the end of it. So I don't really make things just for fun anymore. I I look at that initial idea and I think is there a product at the end of this that could be a something that a publisher would pick up, could be something that would be commercial and so on. Now that's my own personal preference. I have you know absolute full respect for people who design for the pleasure of designing and make the things they want to make and so on. But I do look at it as a product from the very earliest stage. If I see promise at that early stage then I would say the majority of them I can probably get to the point where majority is probably wrong. 50/50 I can probably get to a point where I'm happy eventually to pitch it. Um,
I mean that's that's pretty good. I mean, do you and you don't think you're really but you are but you are filtering things at the idea stage because you're like if this can't make a product you
I'm sure but most of them go no further than a few notes in I I write notes on my uh on my phone you know if I wake up with an idea that's often what happens I wake up with an idea or I write it on my notes app and then later on I look at it and just think oh no that's no good. Um, but uh
speaking of ideas you get when you I'm not sure if I've overtold this story, but I once had a dream that Antoine Bowser was explaining his latest game to me in a dream.
Okay.
And it turned out to be not like a new game. It was not something that existed. Okay.
And I remembered enough of it in the morning. So I was like, "Oh, I've got a new game." No, it wasn't.
Oh, okay. Oh, that's
Antoine betrayed me. But you know, he
That's how my chess cubes game came about.
Oh, was it also Anti Bowser?
No, it wasn't. But I had a dream that I had seen a game at a convention and it I was like, "This is an incredible idea in the dream. I I can't believe I wish id invented this." You know, this is just the most amazing idea. And then I woke up and I thought, "Oh, that game doesn't exist." And I know all the rules. Uh and you know, I I just Yeah. made it, played it. It was really fun. But it is a chess variant and so it's it's not really a go. Do you think you would ever just release the rules sort of publicly as a print and play sort of rule set or something?
Probably not. That's just seems like a lot of effort really. I'll probably at some point get round to actually showing it to a publisher just not as the thing I'm meeting them for, but if I'm meeting them anyway and just say, "What do you think I could do with this? Can you think of anything I could do with this? Anybody I can show this to?"
Oh, well, if any publishers are watching and you want a chess variant, you know,
Yeah.
Okay. and watch the video because you described the game in this previous video.
Yeah.
And we'll put a link link below or something.
We've got some comments, haven't we?
Joy [snorts] the Spiel. Uh, I'm going to play Emberart this weekend. So, someone's already got copies.
Great.
Somewhere somewhere else in the world.
Great. That's good to know.
Failed examples seems like a good video content to do. Well, we could that could keep us both busy for a while, I guess, if you went back through your
Oh gosh, I don't even keep most of them. No, I had to I had to do a great purge when I moved back to Australia.
A lot of space.
Yeah. Yeah. But it is it is interesting because I am happy that I've kept so I have the original prototype of my first published game still.
Okay. Yeah.
Uh or at least the for the not the very first like the pitched prototype.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And I'm very happy I have that.
Yeah.
I'm not sure if I need to have it for all my games for posterity. Although I know, you know, I was think I was talking to Matt Leok and he's donated a whole bunch of stuff to the Strong Museum of Play, the the museum in I think it's in Rochester maybe
that contains the Sid Saxon archives and
yeah and of course that's kind of archival but I mean I'm not you know maybe it works for Matt because he's you know he's an important contributor to game design. We're just merely um you know we'll be forgotten in the annals of history probably.
Oh come on.
But it is an interesting an interesting point. But I also learned in that conversation, anyone out there might be interested, is that so what do you try and keep a copy of each of your published games like in shrink?
I I have multiple. Yeah.
Yeah. But so I like you kind of keep a few copies like you don't open them all up and No. So yeah, I have the same I try and keep at least one sealed copy of each of my games sort of as a kind of archive thing. Apparently, that's actually not a very good idea because it's much better to take the shrink off because you're much likely more likely to get mold and mildew if it's shrink wrapped.
I didn't know that.
So, and that came from the curator at the um Strong Museum of Play.
Okay. Well, I will I will I'll think about that.
And it's a much bigger problem in the UK, I think, than in Although actually in Australia, we have plenty of mold, too.
I need to start getting rid of my like I I because I keep multiple copies. I keep maybe three or four copies of each game. Okay.
Just in case I need them in the future to give to somebody. Um, and I very rarely do end up because I want to keep three or four. And so like that becomes just like what I've kept. Um, and some of the kids games I I sort of I want to keep them for when Nico's older so I can give them to his friends and things like that. Um, sorry that's my that's my baby. Um, so I can give them to uh to his friends and things. But um but that's going to be a few years of keeping and they're big boxes, you know, things like Happy Hoppers is really big. That's for like six year olds, you know, and it's a really big box and I could keep that for five years and there's multiple copies just to give away a birthday party. Do
you think is the story going to be accompanied with? You're going to be like, "Oh, thank God I could get rid of this thing." Like,
do you know, Nick, how lucky you are that I get this
and and you know, and I I don't know how much six-year-olds really appreciate about They're only going to trash it anyway, aren't they? think it is.
I think they'd appreciate it. Well, it's not meant to be precious, is it? It's a It's a game that's going to be played by kids.
I can tell you. So, I made a game, Bubble Stories, which you might know, which is a
o ostensibly a four plus game. Uh, but my daughter Zoe, uh, who isn't two yet, has been playing it for quite a while. I mean, she doesn't play it right. It's just cards and those cards are in a pretty bad state by now. Like, but she loves it. And so,
yeah,
I think she has no connection that it's my game, of course, but uh or maybe she does. I'm not sure. Uh I think they'll appreciate it. I think I think I I think that will be a pretty nice
My sister had been showing her um two-year-old uh recently the the little trailer for Emberart because it's got like a little cartoon at the start of it all about the dragons coming to the island stuff and she'd watch this over and over again, this trailer for this game. Um, and my sister was saying to her, "Oh, your your uncle Adam made this." Um, and then a week or so later, she took her to the dentist and she said, "Oh, your uncle Adam's a dentist." And my niece was just looked at her and said, "Dragons? What are dragons? Surely that's what my uncle Adam does. Dragons, doesn't he's not a dentist."
Oh, that's very cute. I think that's a much better fantasy to have that you fight dragons rather than you're a dentist. Not that there's a dentist, of course. Uh so, oh, Matt, Matt's a fellow game designer from Australia, part of my play testing, not my play test group, our play test group. In fact, Matt organizes it. I don't have any published games, but I'd better take the shrink off my mini shelf of shame games then. Uh yeah, I I I mean I think this is probably on the time scale of years rather than you know if you I don't know how many games how long the games have been on the shelf of opportunity. But
do you ever keep any foreign editions of your games? I've got like six different language versions of Doodle Rush that can't be I can't play them because Lithuanian, Latvian, um uh Polish, I've got French. I can't play any of these. So but I don't know why I've got them. They're quite big boxes. I've stopped asking publishers for them because in the contract it says you get an in one copy of each international edition. Often that's in there and I used to chase these down and say to the publisher, can I have it? Can I have it? Because I always thought, oh, this is such a nice thing to have, but they take up so much space and I can't do anything with them.
Yeah, I I know the I know the feel. It's a it's a tough problem to have. But yes, I think early on I was also the same that I probably wanted a few. I I remember actually there was a really beautiful
I had a game fairy tile from yellow which was a really beautiful box and I remember I really wanted the Russian version of it because it just the characters of Russian on that box looked amazing.
Okay. Um, I never got it. But, uh, yeah, I'm at the stage where, well, I mean, I have to, it's like, oh, wo is me. But I, you know, I have a considerable number of games, even even keeping one copy or two copies, you know, uh, I have, so I have a garden shed, a reasonably large garden shed. Um, and a good proportion of it are my games in shrink. either, you know, to keep in an archive or I have a whole bunch to give away. You know, I go and grab whenever, you know, someone comes or I give away for kids.
If I kept them in a garden shed, I definitely have them in rat in shrink wrap.
Well, they're in boxes in a garden shed.
Unless you're in Australia, it's not raining too much.
Oh, yeah. No, no. And it's it's it's watertight gun shed. Yeah, I think Gshen in the UK is in the UK where you're going to keep your board.
It's a less like the standard building I think is lower than in Australian gun. barely call it a building really.
Yeah, it's like a shack or shack.
Uh but yeah, I don't but I have so many foreign language edition, especially the adventure games actually, which are also completely unplayable because they're narrative books effectively. And I remember posting on Twitter, I think, asking like, "Do any Bulgarians want a copy of the game? I'll ship it to you in Bulgaria." Had no responses. So, uh I think I'll just find some way to repurpose them or mostly those games are all cardboard basic. Yeah, you can often strip out the components for um
they're quite good boxes actually. Good size box that kind of exit size box for prototype.
But uh no, I haven't I'm not at critical space issue. So I haven't had to kind of face this purge yet. But I have also started asking for fewer uh language edition copies. But of course I have a problem sometimes. Some of my games don't come out in English now. So uh like some of the later Echo games aren't being published in English anymore. So, I have, you know, I've got these games that I would like to have because I made them, but I can't play them. So, it's a it's a
We probably got to check check our privilege here a little bit talking about we've got we you know, we've got publish and I'm aware that lots of people who watch both our channels really are trying to get that first published game, trying to get that first license game. And here we are moaning about we got too many.
I don't think we're moaning. I don't think we're voting. It's just it's just a practicality.
Very very fortunate to be in that position, aren't we?
Absolutely. No, it's it's bit although moving your game collection your own games or not across the world is another like is a is quite a task which I had to do. So,
but so what looking forward to today? What is what's on the books?
Um I've only got three meetings today. Um and same two games that I've been showing previously. And then I'm spending I think two two hours two and a half hours this afternoon at the Emberart booth. So, I don't know what they'll have me doing, whether it's demoing or doing interviews or media or I'm not sure what it will be. Um,
signing some copies.
Signing some copies, that sort of thing. Uh, so yeah, I think today is sort of Ember Day.
Okay.
And then tomorrow I think is Surakata.
Oh, that worked out quite nice.
Yeah, that's kind of how a bit of flip it out yesterday. Ember today, Surata tomorrow. That's kind of the plan.
And I didn't did I ask, have your prototypes been getting good reception in your meetings?
They've all taken I So I had four meetings yesterday. They all took a prototype. Okay.
Uh each one of the game. So yeah, that's that I was I was happy with that. Um I had a uh I made a mistake in the very first pitch of the day. I didn't follow my own advice. I didn't stack the deck. Uh so as a result, I hadn't even shuffled it. And so I d out the cards and uh the guy I was pitching to had a particularly dud hand of cards, you know, and and so he played very politely played it and then said, "I didn't really feel like I had any choices there." And I didn't feel able to say to him, well, you know, you were unlucky. You know, let's let's try again. Because then it just sounds like an excuse. I just had to kind of suck it up and go, well, you know, yeah, but that's fine. You know, thank thank you for your feedback. But I did come out of there kicking myself thinking if I had just stacked the deck to make sure that he got a nice mix of cards with some nice options in there, then I think maybe the meeting would have gone a different way.
But I might be kidding myself. You might not have liked it anyway.
But you would have he would have given you a better chance.
Yeah. and and it just proved to me that that advice is right. You know, I've always said stack the deck. And actually, I've noticed that that's what Osprey have done with Flip Pick Towers. You know, that we haven't even got the full deck there. We've got, you know, a portion of the deck and it's got a good mix of cards so that in that, you know, if you give a 10-minute demo, they're seeing all the nice moments that they might have in the game. Um, and it's it I think it's a good way of of pitching something.
Matt says, "Definitely not moaning." We're not moaning. Okay. It's just another interesting facet of games that face of things that face game designs. Yeah. Uh Adam, uh were they all hi-fi prototypes from launch tabletop?
They weren't this year actually. Um mainly because um they they need very specific types of components. One of them uses card sleeves um which need to are going to need to be printed on um and so that was hard to prototype. Um, so that's just I made that myself with sleeves and acetate print sticky acetate to stick on the front of the sleeves and so on. Um, so I couldn't use launch tabletop for that. The other one is an abstract strategy game that needs very specific pieces. So for that I just bought a bunch of uh like cheap old games like charity shop type games and used the components from that to to throw the the prototypes together. So, I'm a huge fan of Launch Tabletop and what they [clears throat] make, but um it only really works if you're making something that uses fairly generic components, um tokens, cards, dice, you know, um standard wooden pieces. It's great. They can do customsiz boards. You can make whatever size board you like.
You can adjust it as much as you like. The box you can adjust as you. So, there is a lot of flexibility there. There's a lot of different sizes of cards and stuff like that, but it doesn't work so much if you're going for something which has a a unique component in it.
Um,
and you made how many uh copies of each prototype did you bring?
I tend to bring um well, I usually would aim for uh 50%. So, if I've got 10 meetings, I'll bring five prototypes. That's usually what I do. I work on the basis that 50% of the publishers are going to take a prototype. was a bit overconfident this time. So maybe I had I think I've got 10 meetings for one of the games and I think I bought eight prototypes. I still think I might get rid of them all.
Okay, [snorts]
fingers crossed. Um uh but I had I just have a feeling that the game's
interesting enough that they're going to want to look at it at least. Yeah,
that's my gut feeling. Um the other one I brought three prototypes, but I only really had maybe five companies I wanted to show it to. Something like that. I don't think I'll get rid of all three of those.
Um, but we'll see.
Okay. Interesting. No, I don't I don't I used to make more copies of prototypes of of a single game to possibly give out, but I've really gone towards just making one copy now and then I either mail them out after the fair or I send print and play files. Um, because I think I got to some point where it just felt like I was making lots of copies and even just carrying them around and and all this sort of thing was getting too much. And most publishers are pretty happy, like a good percentage of them are happy to print and play things now. I mean, of course, if you have a very specific component, then that's that's a different question, but my games tend to be pretty standard.
I just want to give the best possible chance that they're going to play it, you know, so just handing it to them,
you know, we've just had the meeting, there you go, take it. Sometimes they'll even get back to me and say, you know, the next day and say, I played it last night in the hotel. You know, it's it's it's that immediacy that I'm looking for, but it is an extra effort and it is a hassle transporting.
But if it if it works, then that that makes sense. Uh another question, what's the rate of offers you see from publishers taking a prototype? So like as a percentage of prototypes given how many uh result in a contract or an offer?
One in 10 maybe. Maybe a little more. Maybe. No, I'd say one in 10 seems fair on on on average. Um, you know, for Ember, I had several offers.
Um, uh, for Flip It Towers, I was heading that way. Um, but I took, obviously, you don't know how many offers you're going to get because you accept an offer and you don't know how many of the others that are interested would have offered, but you didn't give them the chance.
Do you not give the other publishers that you've given? So my way of doing it these days is that if I've given a prototype to multiple publishers and one gets back to me saying they want to publish the game, I'll let all the publishers who have a prototype know one publisher is interested in publishing it. You've got some specified period of time, two to four weeks to get back to me. And then
depends if the publisher that's offered is the publisher that I really really want to go with, then I'll just tell all the others, you know, I'm really sorry it's not available anymore. We've had an offer. And they're always veryant about it. you send a polite email to them, they send a polite email back. Um,
but in the case of where you're not quite sure or
if I'm not quite sure and there may be other offers, then yes, I might give them I might say, right, I'm going to make a final I'll say I'll send an email. I'll usually word it something like um you know, thank you very much for your interest in the game just to let you know I've had an offer on the game out of in out of um courtesy to all publishers that I've shown it to. I'm going to not make a decision on it for a month, but I'm going to make a decision on this date. Um, so if you would like to make, you know, progress with the game, please let me know by that date and then that's when I'll be making the decision. Um, so I try to give them a very firm deadline. Um, and yeah, I have done that with other games in the past.
And so you've you've had to make a decision between competing offers before for a game?
Yes, I have. Yeah. Yeah, definitely. The wor the worst one of the worst experiences was um it was my first signed game. It never came out but um it was signed. Was it ever signed? Yes, it was signed. That was it was signed signed to Liberia at one point and they didn't make it in the end. They were great. Liberia was fantastic. You know, there are ways of turning a designer down that are unpleasant and there are ways of turning a designer down that are great and Liberia could not have been better. You know, had a big advance paid um and they gave me loads of useful feedback. uh did development on the game, told me I could use that in the future, you know, and so on. They were great, but they did turn it down. But before that, um I was offered I showed the game to lots of publishers. It was my first time pitching. Um actually, if you go back in my channel, I I probably made a a video like this debriefing on it at the time and being all excited about it. The game was called City Rollers and um I had a really a meeting with a publisher that I really wanted to work with and they were really excited about it and then I had a meeting with another publisher I didn't really know and they offered very quickly um and I didn't really want to accept the offer because I wanted to wait for the other one and so I I sort of tried to put them off a little bit and they got really quite they weren't happy about me making them wait and so they declined then they said well yeah we won't make it then um at that point. So I lost it and then of course the ones that were really enthusiastic, they didn't want to make it either. And in the future then thankfully Liba did want to make it but
then that didn't work out either. So um yeah ultimately I lost all confidence in that game as a result of just a series of offers things turned down and so on. And I just in the end I thought I've spent so many months on this game I don't I I I think there's a a point where you're um what's the phrase where you're just you're cutting your losses. You know you're just [clears throat] like well I've put okay I've put a lot of time in but you don't want to completely sink more time into it.
Yeah. I mean reflecting back on that do you are you is there something you would have taken out of that whole experience?
That's where I we talked about it yesterday didn't we? Batch I I pitch in batches ever since then. So that was the real change. I definitely don't I I don't pitch I I pitch to the publishers I want. Then I pitch to the publishers that I know less, you know, and I'd still like to work with them.
But you're not waiting for someone else at that point.
No. So I don't get into that situation where I've got if if somebody makes an offer, I want to be in a position where I'm delighted. Not where I'm thinking, oh, I'm not sure not sure about this publisher.
Yeah. which is again why I never do um or very very rarely would I do designer speed dating things
um because those events are becoming more and more common I think actually yes and it didn't happen this year but they're quite common now at conventions I don't really like the idea of just putting my games out there for all the publishers to look at and then they come because I don't want to be in a position where I've got to turn down a publisher and say I'm sorry I didn't I'm not choosing you know I never wanted to show you the game in the first place that would be really awkward
so I like the idea that I pick which publisher as they show things to.
Yeah, of course, the other flip side of the coin is that you you can kind of never know and and actually showing it to as many pop publishers as pos possible of course increases your chance that you will get an offer. Um, so yeah, there's no I don't think there's any one right or wrong way to do things. Um, and you you end up having your own system and and
absolutely
and and the speed pitching I think if you're a beginning designer, I think the speed pitching can be really helpful because you potentially get to meet a lot of publishers, get a lot of contacts, especially if you've made a game which is good but maybe not a good fit for publishers. They at least see that you're, you know, you're a serious designer, you can make good games and that can put you in goodstead for future things.
For sure. I'm absolutely not saying that other people should do
I do at all.
I remember speaking to Sebastian Blesdale years ago. Sebastian's a a very good designer. He designed Keyflower um and and many other games. And he only ever pitches a game to one publisher at a time and then he'll wait for six months or a year to get the feedback before he pitches it to another publisher. So, it's a very slow process. But for exactly that reason, he doesn't want to get into any sort of conflict and have to choose between and so on. But that's a very slow process at that point. So I don't do that. Yes. But I do limit the pool of who I pitch to.
That makes sense. We're probably going to have to wrap it up soon. Um there's one last question. What's the rate of Oh, no. We've already done that.
We've done that one.
Okay. Well, I think that's it for for comments, but uh well, thank you everyone. Oh, so you it's your
my channel today.
Yeah. Sorry. I was
Thank you very much for watching everybody. Um, thank you, Matthew, for um, uh, giving up your apartment and suggesting that we do these uh, these live streams. So, um, yeah, we'll we'll we'll do it again tomorrow, I guess, and and we'll do it in on Matthew's channel. So, please do check out Matthew Dunston's YouTube channel,
link down below.
Very similar sort of um, uh, content in terms of the, you know, talking about different aspects of design, but obviously Matt's got his slant from his many, many experiences. So, he'll give you new takes that I haven't been able to offer. Um,
we'll have to do some video where we just disagree with each other, you know, like
I'm sure there must I'm sure there are things that we that we probably
No, I'm sure we do. I mean,
take the same approach on, but um
yeah,
and we've got different different situation. You fulltime, part time and and so on. Anyway, yeah, thank you all for watching. We will hopefully see some of you again tomorrow.
Have a great day, everyone.
Have a good day. Bye
bye. All right.