Skip to main content
Loading video...

10 Board Games Reviewed & Ranked - Episode 38

Transcript 17:18

hey everybody and welcome to another chairman of the board ranking video this is where I talk about the last 10 new to me board games that I've played and I rank them from my least favorite up to my most favorite now most of the games this episode are from last year as I'm trying to catch up on all of those but we do have some older games too and some hidden gems um as well but before I get started on these 10 games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor ker.com co.uk who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order at number 10 I have Sky of fire now this is a board game from the house of the Dragon Universe it's an area control game and to be honest it's pretty bad it's a a mass Market Style game where clearly little effort has gone into the design of this one um it's pretty much risk adjacent as you're moving your troops around fighting other people through dice rolls I did like a couple of the touches where a lot of the actions you're taking are card driven so um you can combine these cards together to get bigger turns by you know moving faster or sailing around the map or deploying more troops onto the map but all in all it just comes down to dice rolling and it becomes a bit of a chore and a bit of a grind because people can just keep on taking action until they run out things um to

do so again very much like Risk so I wanted to like this one because I like the IP uh so much but unfortunately it would need reworking from the ground up uh in order to be any good at number nine I have distilled now this is a pretty grandiose Euro Style game a resource management game as you are trying to kind of Brew these different alcoholic beverages um you're doing that by collecting cards and different bottles and things um and then I suppose the unique thing about this is that once you've committed to the different ingredients in your drink you are going to skim off the top card from your deck and also or from that particular hand of cards and the bottom one at random and then depending on what you have left is what you're going to brew so you can go in with the intention of making something but that card could be the one that you take out meaning that you might want to chck in more of the same ingredients to make sure that you have a a stronger guarantee of getting that particular drink made other than that is pretty standard stuff just collecting things cashing those things in for points um and stuff like that already some public objectives um and some a little bit of engine building as well now generally speaking these collect collect collect cash in games are a bit mundane for me they're not kind of my jam I suppose and this was another example of that I kind of find those games a little bit boring and I think this one was just that so um I can't really recommend this one it looks lovely you know lovely production but again that style of game just doesn't quite work work for me at number eight I

have King's Kilt now this is a small box card game with quite a cool mechanism as you are trying to manipulate these different Scots Clans up this pyramid up this hierarchy to get your different clowns in the most prevalent seats as in right at the top of the pyramid you can kind of shift things up you can kill these different cards as you go and everybody's got their kind of secret Clans that they're trying to work towards but there can be some crossover between you and the other players now I thought the game was fine but it does become pretty predictable about what people are going to go for um and you just want to hope that it works out in your favor and that maybe you're um you know collaborating with somebody who wants the same thing as you otherwise you you're probably going to be um you know out of luck so uh I thought the game has some promise I think with a few tweaks maybe a bit more of an interesting um theme or an interesting IP attached to it it could be there but as it stands it's pretty standard stuff it's nothing special and um you know I suppose in if anything it's pretty quick and it doesn't out State as welcome but I do feel like it's missing a magical ingredient or two to make it that much to make it actually enjoyable so that is a king's Kilt at number eight at number seven I have drop palter now this is a small box oink game so it comes in those tiny little square boxes I mean it's a dexterity game um that's if I read this one um from the rules alone if I rated this one from the rules alone I was expecting to maybe rate it a one or two

out of 10 but in practice it's actually quite fun as you have these kind of random little um components such as like rings and these little shells these cubes and things you're going to put them into the palm of your hand you're going to reveal a card and you're trying to drop a certain amount of these components without dropping other ones because if you do you're not going to win the round essentially if you're the first person to do that and grab this ghost figure then you are going to get a bell and the bells are going to be points but from then on you are going to have these bells in your palm as well which so you're essentially having the your points in the Palm your hand and if you drop those you're going to be losing points so this actually has a very clever catchup mechanism that I thought was great because if you have four bells and you're very close to winning that's a lot more you're going to have in the palm of your hand that you're potentially going to drop so in fun Factor alone this one could have actually rated higher but I suppose I have to be a little bit more objective about things that this is essentially having some plastic in your hand and trying to drop certain plits of plastic and not the other bits of plastic so I suppose I have to rain um rain my excitement in a little bit but it still it's way better than it had any right to be and it was pure fun to be honest so that is Drew palter at number s at number six I have Leaf so this is a game I've already um reviewed on the channel this is a family weight you know Gateway level tile placement game but the tiles you're placing are in the shapes of of different leaves and I love this idea that when you place these leaves all the

different kind of um tips of these leaves can connect to other other leaves and give you actions it's all about trying to place these leaves as optimally as possible and not to leave opportunities to the next player and these different actions are pretty basic in their own right things such as climbing a track collecting more cards um getting a bit of area control in terms of these mushrooms it's very basic stuff um and I to be honest I was a little um disappointed or underwhelmed with all those mini games but the main tall placement action with those leaves I think is fantastic and would lend itself perfectly to a more involved game so maybe an example of a game being good but one that's not quite right for me at this stage in my you know my gaming life I want more involved games um don't get me wrong I like simple games but they need to have some meat on the bones this one I think might be a little bit lackluster in terms of those meaningful decisions but a lovely production I'm certain a lot of people are going to like this one because it does have that fun factor and that tangible thing to hook on to and a great table presence through that leaf placement mechanism so that is leaf at number six at number five I have Kiri ey now this is a two player only simultaneous selection card game where you and your opponent are going to be jeweling samurai and you are going to be playing these cars in order to kind of move backwards forwards on this track uh you are going to be kind of striking your opponent or changing your stance and depending on which

stance you're in is going to limit the attacks that you can make so for example if you're in that lower stance you want to be attacking at close range where in the higher stance you can have a bit more range and it's all about trying to not really you know hit your opponent because if you hit your opponent twice you're going to to win but also get into the head of your opponent and block their attacks and I like this little twist where when you use a card um basically you're playing two cards per round but one of those cards is locked out of being an option for the next round so you need to use that quite carefully and again deduce what your opponent can do in the following round it can be a frustrating game because a lot of the time you are swinging and missing or when you actually do swing you're going to get blocks but when you hit that Landing blow or that killing blow it is quite um quite satisfying and I think the I think the theme actually comes through quite well because it does have that kind of mental chess um thing going on where you know the smallest mistake is going to be you know deadly so yeah this one I've only played it once so far so I do need to play it some more but it does have some promise I'm not quite sure if the maybe it is a bit too rigid or a bit too um luck dependent on just taking a wild shot or or is there actually that kind of mental gymnastics that I was that I'm hoping is in in this game so and I think the jwy is still out on a final verdict but right now it does have some promise and it could go either way at number four I have rafter 5 now this is a another dexterity game by oink and to be honest on fun Factor alone this one could have been at number one I think this is a

brilliant dexterity game and that is quite a weird thing for me to say because I generally don't like dexterity games but this one is just an absolute blast as you are basically building these this raft on top of the game box by placing these kind of strips of card and every time you're going to lift up one of these people on the raft and put a new stripper card down there and also a piece of treasure and all these different meeples come in different sizes so you have these huge meeples you have the little tiny ones and it's all about trying to use the kind of weight distribution to keep on placing things down and not to drop or not to make the raft collapse and drop your opponent's Treasure Chest because if you drop five opponent treasure chests then you're going to lose the game and everybody else is going to win essentially um I paid this back to back to back to back I think it is really addictive it's so much fun to teach um and it's yeah just a enjoy to play so this one I think is going to be um a forever Keeper in my collection because whoever I teach this to is going to enjoy it and I can pretty much Bank on that um it's just that much fun so that is a rafter five and a massive surprise for me to enjoy this one as much as I did um it's just it's just a brilliant game so that is rafter 5 at number four at number three I have Footprints so back to a traditional you chairman of the board style Euro this one is a kind of a Hybrid engine builder with a bit of racing a bit of resource management um some kind of contract fulfillment things going on at the same time as you're managing this hand of

cards quite a small hand of cards to Traverse this map reach different checkpoints check um kind of pick up resources cash them in get endgame objectives and of course race to the end of the board to get some bonus points as well I love this multi-use card system and each card can be either used to move on the map or it can be used to boost your stats on your player board to make you move faster in the future kind of a lot to do in a small amount of time because you can't get everything done uh in this game and I kind of like games like that because they they make me want to come back and better myself so I P this a few times now um and I think the the learning curve does come through because I think the first game I did terribly the second game I did much much better so um this one I'm not entirely sold it's going to be a forever keeper I'm not quite sure it's going to have the legs to really hold up um but I could be wrong on that because I think it's got that great kind of weights to complexity to strategy to tactics ratio going on it's you know really favorable so um yeah this one I like it I'm not sure if I love it yet um and I even think the uh cuz each each player in this game has a different unique power that they can use each round all of those are very very interesting as well so I do like that as an added touch so I think I'll play this a few times more before I make up my mind if it's going to be a you know a forever keeper but right now I think I'm going to give it a very soft

recommendation or even give it a commendation um but it could just fall on the wrong side of that with repeated place if it doesn't quite hold up but right now I'm enjoying it a lot and um yeah I think it's a nice clean design that feels you it feels it feels smooth but it's still feels engaging and it doesn't have tooo much bloat going on at the same time so that is Footprints at number three at number two I have marab buun which is the latest small boox card game by Dr ryia now this is a two-player ownly area control game that has the I split you choose mechanism but I love the way that in this game you are splitting these dice that are rolled each round and the dice all going to relate to the different regions on the map are going to have numbers in them and those numbers are going to be contribute towards your control in those regions so if you have the highest total value you'll get x amount of points but as the game progresses you as the players have some autonomy as to what um or the points each region is going to be worth there's also some additional little um engine building you can do or some Powers you can unlock on your player board um and yeah there some really cool little tactical decisions here as you block people off you invest in certain regions know when to give up on regions um and again I always love it when those um I split you choose games put a lot of pressure on you to make those tough decisions because of course you're dividing up those dice but your opponent picks before you do so you don't want to

give them too good of an option because they'll just grab it um but at the same time you don't want to give them a bad option because they're going to leave you with what you don't want so I love the way that that works it's a great kind of um visceral decision to be made there and the fact this offers a lot of game in a small box and a small amount of the time and I was very impressed um with this one so you know I always I generally love Rin Kia games uh this one is one of the best ones I've played in quite some time it's it's fantastic and for a new design um you know full full props to uh the doctor for that so wonderful two-play game definitely going to be a candidate for at least top three um two-player only game of of this year or of last year um but yeah an absolute well a wonderful design so that is Mara buun at number two and finally at number one I have cursed court now this is a bluffing game with a little bit of deduction kind of a bit of betting as well um as you are trying to work out which of these characters is active in the current round and you're going to have limited information in this game where you have knowledge of a character between you and your neighbor where nobody else can see but also some public information as well and you are going to be placing these chips these tokens on certain characters to say that you know I think this arrangement of characters or this particular character is in the mix this round but the cool thing about this game is that you can kick people off those spots by betting double the amount and as you can imagine because

the information is so limited you can actually throw in some kind of misleading information and force people to outbid you when you know that character was never there in the first place and force them to waste all of their betting chips very clean design um and this is one of those games that is truly a Hidden Gem because I think the um the fun factor is is high it scales you know this higher player counts um and this is one of those games that could easily be rebranded into kind of any IP Under the Sun you could do like a Pokémon version Harry Potter Lord of the Rings Marvel um because you know there's no theme in this game whatsoever but it does require a fixed amount of artwork in order to differentiate all the different spots you're betting on so I think there is really money left on the table with this design because it's accessible and the production quality is great all they need to do is just change that artwork depending on the market they're going for and again could make an absolute killing so I'm surprised this one isn't a clustal hit um it ticks so many boxes as in the kind of games that tend to blow up and be popular but for some reason this one has not done that and I'm not quite sure why maybe the artwork is a little bit too Niche it has that kind of weird fantasy look to it that feel looks generic but as I said if you Rebrand this it would be huge in my opinion cuz again it's it's so easy to play it's accessible but the choices are there and the fun factor is high so that is cursed caught at number one so there

we have it that's another 10 games hopefully something on here has caught your eye I understand that a lot of these games this time were from 2023 um but again it takes a little bit longer for those games to get over here um to the UK and of course for me as a a one man entity to get all these games um played but hopefully you've enjoyed the video if you have uh please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved