Best Storytelling Approach? | TableScraps #60
Transcript
on today's episode we'll input some questions and output some conversation welcome to table scraps short discussions about board card and tabletop gaming submitted by the viewing audience and discussed with the viewing audience hey there everyone and welcome to another episode of table scraps uh I'm your host Chaz Marler and on this show we discuss a topic about board card and tabletop gaming with the YouTube live streaming chat and not only do we discuss the topic with the chat but the topic itself comes from the chat and today is no exception because today's topic of discussion comes from viewer Peter Ellis who submits the following when talking about games with dice people will often distinguish between input Randomness roll dice and then make a decision on how to use them or output Randomness make a decision then roll dice to find out what happens I was wondering if there should be a simp SAR distinction between input storytelling games where players are often given a prompt and must make up a story such as fun employment or Rory story cubes versus output storytelling games where players take an action and then read what happens like in above and below or betrayal a house on the hill finally assuming that it's a reasonable distinction which one do most people prefer the input versus output of the storytelling narrative of a game I never
really thought about the distinction between games like fun employ fun employment or above and below so I really had to think about this one and I started backwards thinking oh okay which one do I prefer well both really I I'm kind of 5050 I I enjoy them both for different reasons but games like fun employment or snake oil where you're given uh something and then you run with it um I really enjoy that because it can leave leave you with a very interesting fun creative story but then like above and below petril the house on the hill the dead of winter you know the crossroad uh game system those are really fun too because you make your choice and then it's like what's going to happen based on what I did and how is this game going to Branch off and change because of that the main point for me is the level of enjoyment that I get out of either one depends on the quality of the story The experience not necessarily The Narrative of the game but the life experience that I'm left with at the end let's start today's discussion with meeple critic who says it seems like a useful distinction to me the more information the consumer gets the better if that can be done in a simple way that they can understand that I see no reason not to make it anytime that you get into trying to Define these abstract Concepts about games even with like gamer genres um it can really be like trying to push
down bubbles on wallpaper it can be a really difficult experience and I don't think that there's any definitive answer of how this terminology should be stated or what the concrete answers are so definitely agree that it's it's a useful distinction but I don't think it's a Beall and endall distinction let's continue on to Trevon who says does the average consumer understand that difference you know no one seems to understand the difference between deduction and induction for example that's a very valid point there uh trevan let let's continue on to to see if anyone in the chat does know that because I don't know the uh difference so let's continue on to Peter who says I think the difference is usually apparent when described but not sure how best to describe I personally prefer the output variety though output usually seems to make a longer lasting impression you play the game and tell the story which seems to lead to a longer shared experience sure I can see that I know that thinking back to my own experiences they seem to match that I think I mentioned just a few episodes ago uh the game of petray at house on the hill that I played where I even was the bad guy in it I turned out to be the traitor but uh at by the end of the game as this house was collapsing and this character was running down this Hall with the tiles collapsing behind them just trying to get out I started rooting for that character um I didn't even care about winning anymore I wanted to see the story play out I wanted to see this character make their Valiant uh care Rous escape and so yeah and I can vary of course you know but I I think there I
think my at least at this point my experience matches that um if it changes if I have a input storytelling game experience that just rocks and puts all my other stories um the shame I will be sure to let you guys know but the meantime I kind of agree with you there Peter second part of Peter's comment here is that the input types may have some memorable moments but they can get lost or forgotten as time passes and you try to beat that barring meta experiences that carry over from one game session to the next absolutely totally agree let's continue on to Kabuki who says personally I hate those quote unquote pitch games like fun employed or snake oil not just rifling stories doesn't feel much like a game to me I much prefer games with paragraph books I would imagine like above and below or the tales of Arabian Knights or or games like that that lead you more of a story experience I can totally see a difference between kind of the pitch games and kind of more of an ongoing narrative story element uh games that still have those similar Concepts so I can totally see that distinction there Jeremy mentions I don't play many storytelling games I like games that use cards like cat dragon games is I would fight the dragon this helps me make up my own story are games like this better received when that either whether input or output storytelling element is used more like for lack of a better word a crutch to help the players be creative uh rather than just putting them out
there uh Jeremy your your comment reminds me of the game I dark Overlord uh that was when I first got into gaming uh like 2012 2013 when I was getting back into it that was one of the first ones I picked up because the concept was no so new to me and I played it a couple times and I discovered I really don't like it uh it's just too open-ended there just wasn't enough of a rule set in a way not enough game not enough of the kind of game structure to it it was just a little too abstract a little too loose so I I can totally see what you're saying with like I would fight the dragon how using it to help assist the narrative rather than being a little too much I can totally see uh how I can see that point of view completely Keenan mentions would that info just on the boox description I like both types when implemented well um well based on what I was just talking about with I dark Overlord I think it's more than just an on thebox description I I I think that it has more to do with the actual game structure as dictated by The Game's rules so I think there's a little bit more meat in how it's handled a little a little more based on the game's design itself Nick joins us to say it is an interesting possibility to differentiate this way I think that even games like betrayal there's a story built independent of this as well so I'm not sure it's a clear distinction uh again
that's one of the things I really like about betrayal at house on the hill is it does give you this overall story um you know you are making the decisions it it's one that's a lot more structured in a way but then things can go off the rails really quick and the game it seems to me almost encourages the players to take it on almost as more of a role playing experience really get into it and and not necessarily follow the letter of the rules but more play the game in the spirit of the rules and if getting into more of a role playing aspect uh makes that happen that that's definitely uh I think something that the game encourages and that can actually be a lot of fun if the other players uh kind get into that Kabuki mentions I have learned that when you say storytelling games there are some people who think of snake oil and other PE people who think of Agents of Smur or Tales of Arabian Knights and again for anyone unfamiliar agents of Smur and tales of Arabian Knights are more of the games that have this like these pre pre-made big thick books that are almost like a little Choose Your Own Adventure story that based on your decisions will lead you through and actually have like a couple paragraphs of narrative to read to go through the experience whereas snake oil gives you a few key like Flags keywords or Flags or something and then it's up to the uh player to actually take that and be creative with it develop something creative with it and that certainly yes can be much more of a challenge depending on not only the type
of people that you're playing with their personality types and what they like to do but also just how the person's feeling that day uh you know I like to think that I'm someone that can uh come up with something creative to say or do but there are some days where I'm just I'm just not feeling it and a game like that from day to day can vary how much it goes over well or or or badly so it's another definitely another factor in this is just the person's you know kind of mood that given day accent trol joins us to say personally I don't really like most input storytelling I'm just not that creative I've I've heard that um argument against those type of games a lot of people saying I'm just not that creative I just don't think that way and I don't want to be put on the spot some people thrive on it some people love it some people love that sort of improv and being on the spot some people just detest it and it gives them anxiety so acual I can totally totally see that point of view Nick also mentions isn't it true that every game that implements theme would do some degree would to some degree cause players to build narrative and fall into the players making up the story uh definitely I definitely think to some extent that would be but again you know everyone's different um some people just want to play a game and they don't really want to get into the theme I've played with some people you know that if we're playing like a game set in the old west or something you know they'll kind of start swaggering and uh talking with a little bit of an accent
and kind of getting into that mindset a little bit and some people just don't care another quick example of that is a game the game time stories first time I played time stories I sat down and I played with uh four or five we had a full compliment I can't remember how many people the game plays but we had a full compliment of players and everyone playing that game was a YouTuber a content creator someone who gets up and makes narratives and does stuff and likes to be creative and put on a show so we got our characters for the charact the for the game of time stories and we started playing and everyone was in character and playing their part for about a round round and a half and after about a round and a half it just naturally people stopped doing the accents or playing a character or role playing at all and we were just playing the game trying to figure out the puzzle so it's not necessarily A Fault of the game sometimes it can be kind of just the uh the approach that the players are taking to the game and sometimes actually you know losing that element could mean that people are actually getting into the game even more in a weird way I suppose perhaps maybe Charlie mentions I love input storytelling games but I rarely play them because I found it hard to find others who do as well or feel as comfortable with them thank you Charlie for pointing that out and that underscores um the other things that I've heard in the past from other potential players of these games is that input storytelling games I think perhaps more than output storytelling games
require a certain mood or personality type for the person really to want to get into them so the the input storytelling games I think really uh are really are can be more hit or miss based on that I I totally agree there with what you're saying accent control says I feel like most input storytelling games are very very dependent on the players to decide who did it best I want to have a precise goal not just whatever the judge thinks is funniest oh that is a really good point there to Accent control um a that oh I absolutely totally agree I I think that that is one of the reasons why I no longer enjoy um the game Apples to Apples uh that was again back in 2012 uh discovering Hobby Games again going wow look at all these games are out there Apples to Apples was one of the first ones that was in my collection hit the table a lot and then after a while I realized if I just randomly draw a card out of my hand without even looking I scor just about the same number of points uh there's not a clearly defined goal and you know it kind of damaged my enjoyment of the game for myself and and I think that uh that lack of concrete objective concrete scoring mechanism just the who did it best or well I know that Bob over there Bob likes panda bears so I'm gonna if I have a card that mentioned panda bears no matter if it's a good fit or not I'm gonna throw that one out there because I
know he'll probably pick it because Bob loves pandas um that type of mentality definitely I think can can sour a game experience for some players but that again is just my opinion and just one of many that I would love to hear about this topic including yours if you have a an idea of which type of Storytelling input versus output storytelling you like better what your experiences have been share those experiences in the comments below I would love to read them and continue the discussion there but in the meantime we're gonna have to wrap this episode up and I've been Chaz Marler who along with the YouTube live streaming chat have been serving up some table scraps thanks I'll talk to you again soon and not only do we chat about the topic with the topic people and not only do we chat with the audience about the CH the chop about chopan we talk about mosart we talk about chopan we talk about we run the gamut but never never Beethoven because Beethoven is just over rot is just come on now