Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 26
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another edition of board games I got rid of and why so in this series I take a look at games that have previously been in my collection but for one reason or another no longer are but before I get started on these 10 games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go-to online retailer when it comes to purchasing board games here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order the first game I'm talking about today is the gardens which is essentially a tile placement Style game however it did use cards instead and what you're doing is you're laying these cards out in these three different rows which will create these kind of Pathways and fountains and benches and things which will all score in different ways but the Twist on this game was that on each of these rows there was a meeple and one of you placed a new card down the meeple will travel from its last location to the car that you've just placed and that will trigger certain scoring as you go like for example I might say for every type in these trees that it passes through you'll get a point and different things like that so I actually did quite like that idea in theory and I do still think that that mechanism has a lot of unexplored potential but I don't think this was the game to really showcase uh that mechanism because it's quite limited and it was tailored towards a kind of more Gateway entry-level audience um it worked five what it was I did think that the game had a bit of a glass ceiling on how many times you could play it and I think people are always kind of lean towards more widely known more
widely available games such as Carcassonne if you want this style of game so I think this one was kind of struggling to find its place in the market despite looking wonderful you know I really did like the visual appeal of this one as you had this kind of like classical poster look to it with these thick black lines you know it looked really lovely on the table but the gameplay was a little bit lacking for me next up I have switch and Signal which just so happened to be my favorite Co-op game that I played in 2022 so in this game you are of course working together if you try and manage the logistics of these different trains that are automatically moving um on the board and you're going to do that by playing these cards which will change the switches and signals on the board so for example there'll be these three-way or forward Junctions and you'd have to kind of um move these little tokens to show which root is active you'd have to divert trying to try and manage them as efficiently as possible and for every kind of piece of movement you'd waste by having trains kind of stalled at Junctions you'd suffer penalty points it actually works extremely well I tend to like pick up deliver games but I do tend to steer away from co-op games in general I don't know what it is but I do not really have that itch to explore co-op games and when I do get them to the table even though if I might um you know appreciate them mechanically I just don't get too much satisfaction out of working with others I don't know why um so if I was to own a co-op game I would probably choose to switch a signal because it does what it does extremely well and it is very underrated but because I'm not a fan of co-op games in general
um I didn't really see the need for me to own this one um which is a bit of shame because again it is so good and in fact for a solo game it works really well too so yeah it's a kind of a nearness for me it's just that I never get I never have that itch to play co-op games so therefore um I had to make the decision to curl switch and signal from The Collection next up I have tawantin sue you now this was a kind of a sister game to the T-Series of games by board and dice you know thinking thinking of games like teletube or tapanusi um and Sulkin however this one was not designed by Daniel this was designed by David turtsy and it's a worker placement game that is physically daunting you know this has a lot of work replacement spots here and the idea of this one was that when you went to these different spots by playing these cards um the more you kind of pack your workers together the stronger bonuses you'll get and also these meeples would be color-coded and which will give you independent or kind of unique abilities depending on the meeples that you played and mechanically it was actually quite interesting however it was a bit convoluted it was certainly not a um it wasn't a smooth game there were certainly rules upon rules and some things you'd forget some Fitness there which to be honest I did forgive because I thought every game I played with this was actually really enjoyable and it was rich in terms of the decision making um but I think this might be a a case of wrong wrong place wrong time that kind of thing um because generally speaking nowadays I want games that are a bit easier to put
off the shelf and get played straight away this one's a little bit longer than I would like it to be and the teach is again a little bit of work um and again it does have that real daunting table presence where there is so much symbology and that it is a bit of an obstacle to overcome when you're teaching it to new people and if I was to keep this in the collection I'd probably always play it with two players because I know that the two of us would know the rules and I think the game is slightly better when it comes to that three or four player count so I thought all those little things just made it a little bit problematic and a bit difficult to get it to the table which is ultimately why I decided to cut it from The Collection despite me not really having a bad experience with it but yeah I just I just kind of want games that are a bit smoother now and again I can put off the shelf without having to relearn all the rules so that's why I got rid of Taiwan tinsuyu next up I have renature which is a game that I've spoken very highly of in the past and I still do like this game a lot so it's an area control game as you're trying to control these different regions and by placing these bushes and trees um and of course Whoever has the most influence in this regions will score the more points but I like the key mechanism here where you would use dominoes in order to spread your influence so basically you'd have these very nice wooden chunky dominoes which would have these screen printed animals on them and you couldn't kind of spread out unless you matched uh these animals up and that's basically what you're doing you're just kind of adding these dominoes onto the board you're putting bushes down in the adjacent regions and trying to get score the majorities there and it works really well for what it does um but I think this was a matter of it
being directly replaced by another game in my collection so I had this before I picked up a game called Rumble mation which you might know that I speak about a lot and for me Rumble Nation fits this Niche a bit better for me where if you want that kind of Gateway level or introductory level um error control game with still some meaningful decisions but very little rules I think Rumble Nation does a better job of it than renature does um not much for better because I do like Marine nature a lot um but I think I have Rumble Nation to film that Niche and if I want something a little bit above that I'd probably play something like Mexico um by the the same designer so it kind of um it kind of bordered that line in between those two games and I owe these other two so I didn't really see the need to own this one as well so that's why I decided to part with renature next up I have the mind so the mind was a game that really did blow up in popularity um quite a few years back now so this is another Co-op game um where you are playing these cars down in your hand and you're trying to do them in numerical order without breaking that pattern um and the twist of this game is that you cannot actually communicate what each player has in their hand of course that would be very easy but so you have to kind of do this feeling out process of playing these cars down noticing who's stalling um and trying to try not to break that pattern to go from low to high you go through all these different levels getting more and more cards into your hand um and you know what this game works way better than it should do I've had tons of great games of this and the reason I
don't have this in my collection anymore is because I already did play this game to death with the same group you know we I think we went on a holiday together and we played this again and again and again and again until we've got extremely good at it and we actually managed to um complete the game and even go above that completion level and without making any mistakes and that was completely without cheating as well so normally when I play co-op games and we end up defeating the game I have very little desire to go back and explore anymore you know I felt the same way about and many other co-op games in the past where again so it's very difficult you then you win the game and then all of a sudden it's like well now I don't have that urge or that itch to to defeat it so that's kind of where I sit with the mind I have good memories of it I think sometimes it gets a little bit of unfair treatment saying it's not a game but you know what my enjoyment of that would contradict that statement because this game was actually a hell of a lot of fun and I would recommend it um if you are interested in a a really social and you know funny game so that is the mind um you know a good one but one that I've completed next up I have bear raid which was a game I was really excited um to play at the time because I remember at that time I was really in to my economic games and this one was being advertised to something straightforward in a very easy in terms of the rules overhead and that was the case because you know the rules was only like a single page a piece of paper so you could learn the game Ultra quickly but when it came to playing the game it was actually extremely confusing and I could not wrap my head around the way everything fit together and um I remember playing this one
with you know people I normally play these kind of games with and it just was not sinking in it was not clicking with them and we were really struggling to find where the fun was here and maybe I didn't give this one a fair shot um because yeah we did play it once or twice had a really bad experience both times and we're kind of moved swiftly on because of that well I think somewhere in there there was a good game but I was just really struggling to kind of extract it from it so with so much stuff out there now I'm not really willing to do deep Dives in the games I'm not enjoying straight from the get-go and I think bear raid was a victim of that so therefore it had to go um because it just did not kind of strike a chord with us from the offset so that is bear raid next up I have Spike which is a almost a pickup and deliver train game as you're building this track on this map trying to deliver Goods to different places based on this Dynamic market and trying to connect certain reasons to certain regions um I did have a few issues with the balancing of this game because it seems like the market could have purely by chance um benefited you because you're next to all the locations that have the highest Worth or the highest value um but my biggest issue with this game was the pure lack of excitement and the plodding pace of it because there was so much forward planning here you could literally look at the map you could see exactly what you needed to do based on the cars that you had and then you'd spend the whole game just kind of going through the motions and playing out what you'd thought of 20 minutes ago or 50 minutes ago so it almost had that feeling of frustration where you just
wanted to move faster and yeah it just it moved at a very slow pace considering you already knew what you're going to do several turns um in advance other game also had some pretty shocking and production of these little train pieces and the little um track pieces you put on the board were very cheap and light and just did not work and this did not fit together well and it's just a horrible kind of physical production um and the game itself was just boring it's just a matter of that really too too slow and too boring and obviously for that reason Spike had to go next up I have Aladdin's dragons the card game which I believe is almost identical to the board game version of the of the same name now this one you are kind of placing these workers down with these cards they come in different levels you can even put them together to have stronger workers you're collecting these gems from these different piles and scoring points essentially um I I didn't dislike the game but I did find it completely forgettable you know I'm either struggling to kind of hark back and think how I felt about this game and even I've even forgotten a lot of the mechanisms in it because it was so generic in the way it felt I think there's been so many workout pacing games out there since this one it really has been lost in the shuffle and I think it's even a bit dated so I don't really see the needle I wouldn't recommend this to anybody really because I even think if you're into lightable simple worker placement games there's loads better than this one so yeah I can't recommend it because it is so generic and so forgettable and that's ultimately why it went but I suppose the only redeeming
feature about this one was that it was like a full like a placement game but in a tiny box of cards so if storage space is a premium too then maybe look at this one if that outweighs the benefits of being a pretty generic game so um there we go that's my thoughts on Aladdin's dragons and why it left the collection next up is definitely the heavy hitter on this list uh this is early on so early on another game that I've spoken highly of throughout the years um a fantastic kind of bag building games you'll put these chips into the bag throwing them out to activate different spots on your player boards I have to climb tracks make you better at different things um works extremely well a lot of fun and actually really smooth um game now that's also one of those games that is ranked highly on my top 100 for many many years now so you might ask why did I get rid of it number one um I played it so much and each time I play it I kind of go through this go for the same thing um because that strategy has generally served me quite well um but I suppose the main reason is because my friend like one of my friends in my immediate gaming group has a copy so I do have immediate access to this game should I want to play it and I don't need to fill out my own shelf of something I played so many times so I do highly Advocate this game still especially with the trade and Intrigue expansion but you know do I need to own it anymore when I can play it anytime probably not I'm considering I have played it so much so that is why Alliance left the collection nothing bad um it's just a matter of me trying to free up some space and the final game I'm talking about today is Bristol
1350 which on paper had me highly interested because I love the idea of this one as you are trying to flee the City of Bristol without being infected by the back plate and the black plague would be kind of um represented by these cards in your hand they'd all be numbered and if you ever went above a certain number of um of these cards then you'd be infected for the rest of the game and you'll be essentially out of winning and the idea also you're trying to be the first out of the um out of the city without being infected and then you'd be the victor however this game was very unfriendly if you had dishonest people in your group because if you ever went above that plague limit you should be infected for the rest of the game however there were ways to kind of manipulate your hand to get rid of high cars get low carbs back in um meaning you'd be under that threshold and nobody could ever really um enforce or kind of verify that you were not ever infected so you could actually lie and say you know I was never infected and I've now won the game because I'm below the limit so that was one reason which is forgivable because you know if you are if you want to break the game that at least be done through you know cheating I suppose but the thing I really didn't like about this game was that once you were infected there was really no incentive to continue a new goal to aim towards yes you could try being a bit of a you know be a bit of a nightmare and try and affect everybody else and stop anybody else from winning but from a thematic standpoint why would you do that what's the point you may as well try and at least um let somebody else live on and continue so it did feel like
once you were over that limit and that could happen really early in the game it just felt like it was completely disengaged and you had no reason to continue but I do feel that with some House Rules and some reworking of it um this could be a good game here but I think they did miss the mark in terms of the design element of the game and you know from a production standpoint it looked wonderful um so yeah lots of potential here but I just think the uh the designers needed to go back to the drawing board and just tweak a few things to make it a solid game that was mechanically sound as well as a cool idea so that's why and Bristol had to go because it just did not work so that concludes the video hopefully you have enjoyed it if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too uh but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye