Skip to main content
Loading video...

Classic Old School Dungeon Crawlers Vs Modern Overcomplicated tabletop Designs

Transcript 10:27

And be sure to check out Trading Card Market, the very best in sports cards, trading cards, trading card supplies, LEGOs, and so much more. tradingcardmarket.com, the best in all your gaming needs. Hey everybody, it's your old pal Rod. Today we are starting off our our 64 Tuesdays and Thursdays. Because I I had to do it that way cuz so many videos. Uh consecutive Tuesdays and Thursdays of dungeon crawls. So, every Tuesday and Thursday we're going to do a video on dungeon crawls. Uh that way we would have the rest of the week to keep up with all the other stuff that's going on uh from Trading Card Market and and games that come in that that, you know, we get to review and everything like that.

Uh today I wanted to talk about to start things off. Uh as you watch this series, you're going to see a lot of older stuff and you're going to see some newer stuff that might take up more time. Um and it's the classic old-school dungeon crawlers versus kind of the modern over-the-top Kickstarter uh tabletop designs, which take up you know, mountains and mountains of room. You know, the thing is, which really hits home um with people. And and do the overcomplicated and and and and immense Kickstarters that we're seeing as far as dungeon crawls that come out today, which all the flashy flashy miniatures and stuff like that, really overpower what the old-school stuff did?

Um Now, this isn't saying that either one's bad because I love playing both. Okay? But what this does say is are we more attracted to you know, bigger designs, yet we don't get them to the table as much? And a perfect example of that is is you know, you know, when when when uh when uh certain companies brought back HeroQuest. HeroQuest is the the biggest beer and pretzels um dungeon crawl that you could ever have. Not overcomplicated rules, nothing nothing over the top. You could fit it, you know, the board sits right on your table. Everybody can gather around.

Doesn't matter if you have a coffee table or a gaming table. And you know, especially with first light, you could do it with standees, you could do it with miniatures. You know, of course, the old version had you know, those those uh Games Workshop type of feel uh miniatures, and it was a nice feel to it. And yet, it for a game that is as old as it is, it's still people are still drawn to it today. Where I feel that sometimes some and and you know, I don't want to name off any any, to be honest with you. Uh but, more today's designs. Well, I will. You know, the Gloomhavens and the the Frosthavens, you know, that that are just so intricate and these massive boxes.

Um and and you know, this Euro style and and and and billions and trillions of tokens and and endless fights and you know, you know, legacy and all these other type of things that kind of fit into today's modern complicated over overly complicated designs. You know, does does it does HeroQuest outshine Gloomhaven? Well, with a lot of true hearted uh dungeon crawl fans, yeah, it does. It really does. And they tend to gravitate more towards the old school stuff. You know, you have you you take people that that create things now, some of these small 10 games uh by Jason Glover, you know, old school feel to it.

Okay? People gravitate to that. Uh Martin Knight with D100, uh Andrea with Four Against uh Darkness, old school simple pen, paper uh and and an imagination. And you know, you're right back to that old school dungeon crawler design, which which works so well today. Where I think a lot of these more more modern and I think Gloomhaven's a bad example because it sticks. Um you know, there it really attracts the Euro crowd. But you know, some of these huge 9 10 15 box dungeon crawls, okay, that that that are Kickstarter and if you Kickstarter, you get the extra expansions and things like that. Instead of feeding it to us gradually, they get put on a shelf and sometimes they never see the light of day or maybe they're played once and they don't see any light of day. And I think you know, the more complicated, the more people look at it and go, "Well, I'm glad I got it cuz there's fear of missing out."

And maybe I'll get to it one day. But for the most part, it sits on the shelf of shame. Where it's easy to pull out a Dungeon Quest. It's easy to pull out a D100, to pull out a Hero Quest, uh a Hero Quest and an expansion maybe. Um you you know, um a Fighting Fantasy, you know, those type of games that are just or you know, a Warhammer Quest even. How easy it is to pull out and and just get set up because of the simplicity of rules. Um And I think and I think as we get more complicated and as board game designs uh have more technology to use and create things, we forget the very simple essence of it all. And that that these wonderful, fantastic dungeon crawls are just simple have a simple simple thing. It's a good story, a good premise, and replayability.

Okay, whether it's a pencil and paper, whether it is a smaller design, whether it's an old design from the '70s and '80s, sometimes just gathering people and creating adventure in an alternate um uh experience and something that changes and the unknown and the unexpected of fantasy will just always bring people together instead of you know, massive you know, gorgeous components and over-the-top everything. It looks beautiful, but can it play simplistically enough that people can get right into it, or is it a job?

I recently turned down reviewing a game because it was overly complicated. They sent me the prototype and I went, "No, I'm just not going to do this because it's too complicated." And uh I'm not going to name things cuz I don't want to hurt anybody's business, and that's not who I am. You know, it's a funny it's a uh a a a funny business, but that's uh another story. But you know, what's not for me may be for somebody else. Just like this whole subject. You know, some people may prefer the over top. Boy, you know, I wish I had this when I was a kid. Um but you know, and then there's people like me who maybe remember things more fondly from the past than if we brought it out today with the more cleaned up and and and nicer designs sometimes. But for but there you know, there's two sides to this. You know, again, with the mod- with the modern tabletop designs, you know, you have thematic when you look at things and the art and the the design and sometimes the miniatures.

How they just build an incredible theme and and things like that where you know, back in my day, stick figure or you had to use your imagination more. Which one really works? I think it you know, when we're talking about a subject like this, it really depends on what hits you right. For me, you know, I tend to lean to the older, but I am marveled over what they can do today. So, I would love to hear what you have to say and and you weigh in on this. As I said, this is the first of our 64 videos that you'll see on Tuesdays and Thursdays of dungeon crawls and I wanted to start off, you know, with a discussion.

Next, you know, we'll be talking about even more and also some play-throughs and many, many other things. Until next time, it is your old pal Rob. We'll see you soon, everybody. And thanks for watching the video. Be sure to head over to tradingcardmarket where you'll get the best in sports cards, trading cards, trading card supplies, LEGOs, and more. Tradingcardmarket.com.

Progress saved