Board Game Versus | 6 Games, 3 Matchups! | Ep. 2 | If you HAD to KEEP One and DITCH the Other!
Transcript
how's it going everyone i am dylan this is all you can board and this is another episode of my board game versus series we're going to change it up just a little bit i'm going to take some feedback i got in the comments and just some things i thought would make this a little bit extra fun instead of doing four pairings of just sort of games that i thought would pair uh well together i'm gonna do three pairings from now on in these videos but there's gonna be some criteria on the pairs that i select so one of the pairings is going to be that they have gameplay specific ties they play similar have similar gameplay mechanics it could be like you know having two worker placement games or you know uh two engine builders things like that or just something they share in common then we're gonna do a pairing that is a thematic tie they could play completely differently but there's something about the theme that is very very similar or you know it's something in that regard and then we're gonna do one random pair we're gonna take two games that have absolutely nothing in common in my collection and i'm gonna compare them again all of these uh the criteria of all these being that if i had no choice but to get rid of one of these games from my collection the other one would stay which one would i get rid of so this isn't just straight you know which is the better game this is all i'm looking at this as this is my collection going forward it's how i introduce games to people it's it's you know the games i have options for game nights it's the ones that i personally love or want to play more often so it might not just be you know if you watch my videos that were you know the games that would never leave my collection it doesn't necessarily mean that if one of those games pops up here that it is for sure gonna be the one i choose because that is based off the fact that i don't have you know these arbitrary rules of you have to choose to get rid of one of these it was just based on what i would uh you know never
get rid of in my collection this is specifically just for for fun if you you know are someone who wants to peer down your collection if if you're someone who wants to have a tight collection that's you know smaller but very effective or if you just want to have something that's you know entertainment value if you had to choose between these games which one would you choose that's sort of what this video and the series is for so i've picked six games total three pairings that i think are going to be some really interesting ones to discuss with some surprising results maybe on some of them so we're going to just jump right into it and the first one we're going to do this is the uh or the mechanical ties so these two games have a lot in common in the way they play from a gameplay perspective and they're two smaller games one is a lot older and one is a pretty brand new and that is going to be me comparing enchanted plumes with lost cities so again we're talking about these two games as a comparison on if i was forced right now to get rid of one of these games in my collection which one would go and which one would stay so this is a really interesting one because obviously i'm a huge writer canadian fan and obviously i'm a huge lost city fan it's ranked really high on my top 50 games of all time i played a ton of this game both the physical version but especially on board game arena for those who don't know and not that this is like you know i guess this is kind of like a low-key break now that i think of it but uh one of the months when i went really hard into lost cities during the pandemic on board game arena i actually was ranked second overall for the entire month and i made a push for first on the very last day that the ratings were accounted for i think there's like a three month period or something that accounts for it i made a huge push to try to get to first and that push
dropped me all the way to like 20 something or some some number far but had i just left myself there i would have finished second so i play a lot of lost cities and i don't say any of that to say that like i'm an expert on strategy but just for context i've definitely obviously played a lot more lost cities than i have enchanted plumes so comparing these games is very interesting because if you've heard me talk about enchanted plumes before you know that there is a lot going on in chandra plumes that is very reminiscent of lost cities but there are some key differences obviously one being lost cities only plays two players whereas enchanted plumes will play up to uh six players um and also kind of in all the play ranges i played enchanted plumes it's been very very good at multiple player counts so far it's not like it seems to be like it is a two-player game but they just found a way to accommodate it it tends to be a pretty effective game at all the player counts i've tried it at so far which obviously i haven't tried at six so i can't vouch for whether that's going to be you know a good experience with six people taking up that much table space around the table creating all their plumes um but basically the difference is here is then lost cities you have the the the five different colors that you're playing cards into and you're and you're all sort of um you know wondering you're wondering i should i say you're all you are wondering what your opponent has in their hand and you know what are their ho they're holding to uh potentially block you from from playing something or you know trying to hold a yellow eight because they know that you've already played the l07 and you're looking for that card so they're just taking up a spot on their hand to hold it back there's a lot of that stuff going on some of that is present for sure in enchanted plumes but i would say that that aspect of it is a little bit more
you know reeled in because you have more flexibility in what you're able to do in enchanted plumes with uh you know instead of it being these set colors that you're playing to you're basically able to create as many plumes as you want if you want to create a plume and just kind of cap it off and have you know a plume that is three and then two and then one card at the end you can do that or if you want to go for this massive plumage to score your points you can do that too the way that enchanted plumes really differentiates itself is that in scoring the top row of your plume which can be as long as you want you can have three cards across you could have five cards across whatever you want what to do there that is all going to score you negative points so the numbers on the cards come into play in the sense that you want your top row to be as low as possible but if you do have to put a high number there you're doing so thinking that the other cards you're going to put underneath it are going to make up for that and eventually end up with you having positive points at the end so you have to kind of keep in mind the cards are going for and the color of plumes are going for to have that to top row be as low as possible but also the colors of those plumes on that top row dictate the colors you're allowed to place for the rest of the rows so if i only place blue and red on the top row i can only place blue and red on the next row as well so it makes it really really interesting that way it takes the lost city's kind of essence and finds a new way to sort of ingest it into a game it it so much of it reminded me of lost his replay i think i said i said that to carl like two or three times but uh but yet it is very different at the same time so this is a very interesting comparison because again this is me personally personally my collection uh you know what would i do and the fact of the
matter is i have played a ton a ton of lost cities and lost cities i can only really play the physical version with certain people that like like carlo for instance uh like braden who who you know like that style of game and like that cut-throatness um a lot of my two-player games are often you know me and carlo play two-player games but i wouldn't say that we're always sitting down to play two-player only games that are like you know have been in our collection for a long time like lost cities um we're playing a lot of new games we're playing games that play up to four but we're just happening to play it at two things like that so um i have to look at it from the grander spectrum of you know what is going to get played more often and scratch that itch while also you know uh having me enjoy it as well and as much as i feel like you guys can tell that i'm doing all this to try to explain myself for the choice i'm about to make that is for sure gonna rattle some people carlo probably most of all um but i am actually going to choose to keep enchanted plumes and get rid of lost cities which i know i know it's probably blasphemy to some of you i'm getting rid of the kenitzy game for a brand new game that just came out somewhat recently but my reasoning here is is just the fact that i have way more flexibility with enchanted blooms two to six players it means that in multiple settings with people who don't often play a lot of board games for instance or just want to play something a little bit more uh simple with just you know that involves just a deck of cards but has that strategy element that they can play multiple times and sort of uh form a meta around it and grow with enchanted blooms has way more flexibility there lost cities i'm restricted to just two players and that other player has to be
very into that kind of style of cutthroat you know grueling card game but not only that because i've played so much lost cities unless i'm playing with carlo uh at this point i am going to have an unfair advantage no matter who no matter what the situation is to the point where i would almost have to like let's say for instance i'm going to be going on a date and i decide i'm going to introduce lost cities i there's a good chance that because of how much lost cities i've played and how much i understand the strategy and you know the whole flow of a game of lost cities that i'm probably going to crush that person not because i'm amazing at the game but just because they have not played it it's the same thing that can come into play with games like kingdom builder for instance where if i wouldn't sat down with three people who had never played kingdom builder before i'm gonna be at a huge advantage over them and that can sometimes be the barrier to entry to a lot of games you hear that a lot with a root as well lost cities has that for me and so while there are people i will play it with enchanted plumes is going to get way more plays because i still have a lot to explore with enchanted blues i don't have this super you know huge advantage and there's multiple people around the table potentially instead of just two that i could be playing with so i'm hoping i justified this uh well enough to not get too much flack for this i obviously love lost cities and if i my choice which is what's gonna happen is i'm gonna keep both i want these both of my collection but if i was forced if someone said you need to get rid of one of these games and you can never have it again in your collection you have to keep one get rid of the other at this point it just makes more sense for me to keep enchanted plumes than it does for me to keep lost cities because i'm gonna get more plays out of enchanted plumes and for someone who has this large
collection where you know a lot of games go unplayed a game getting more plays is really important to me and into my collection and just being able to introduce to more people to potentially bring more people into the hobby which in turn gets me more people to be able to play board games with it's the cycle of board game life so and chad blues is my choice uh let me hear it in the comments i'm sure you're gonna have some thoughts on that uh but i stand by it for this fictional you have to get rid of one game decision that i've made myself make so that is the first uh versus the next one is going to be the thematic verses and this one is one that was recommended in the comment section the first video and i agreed that this would be a really interesting one to discuss because even though these are different games and how they play the thematic tie to them and the niche they kind of fill in the hobby is very very similar so for that we're talking about wingspan versus everdell so this is the uh big heavy hitter one in terms of you know popularity i guess we'd say this isn't necessarily like you know not everyone agrees that these are phenomenal board games or even enjoys these games but i think that everyone would agree that their presence in the board game hobby and you know the the amount of times they are bringing people into the hobby that maybe normally wouldn't play a board game is solidifies them as you know having a special place in in this board game world and and i say that knowing many people who don't often play board games but when they look at my shelf and said oh i've played wingspan or oh i love everdel and things like that which always surprises me but it's always
it's really made me realize that there is something to be said for you know i could i could look at a game and not personally love it but if it's a game that is regularly bringing people into this hobby how could i ever really fault it and how could i not you know appreciate that aspect of what it's doing for us to bring more people into board games and make it a more inclusive space and and welcoming space and and having more people than just you know die hard enthusiasts in in the hobby for instance so both of these games i would say uh do that i've known people that love wingspan love everdell and don't really play any other board games they just love the the experiences they've had with these um these two games and on top of that they both have similar themes you know the animal inviting kind of cozy warm uh thematics like everedo with the woodland creatures and and the tree wingspan with just like the the calmness of the birds and like the bird watching atmosphere and the little eggs and everything so there's a lot connecting these two games but they obviously play very different uh wingspan is an engine builder we're on three different um you know ecosystems you're essentially creating this engine of cards that is going to always activate its abilities from right to left whereas everdell is a worker placement game that also involves this sort of tableau that you're creating with these cards that you're collecting but a lot of what you're doing is placing workers onto the board to be able to take different actions so very uh you know different styles of games but the thematic ties are there so you're probably wondering which of these games i would keep and which one i would get rid of this was a super super tough decision and and you might be thinking
well dylan you just said you would never get rid of wingspan and i that's correct i did say i would never get rid of wingspan in that video but i didn't say that thinking i would also have to get rid of everyday if i kept wingspan so both of these games right now stay in my collection um so much because i one enjoy playing them like i should just preface that i do enjoy both these games a lot um but two i can always introduce new people into the hobby with these games and have a good time at the at the same time and they kind of spawn people wanting to play like if i introduce wingspan to them then they want to play everedell and vice versa like it's sort of the snowball effect with them so i had to ask myself and way two different things which one do i enjoy playing more and which one do i think is gonna be more effective in in in bringing people into the hobby and getting to the table more often and the tough thing about that is that i think i enjoy everdel ever so slightly more than i enjoy wingspan and if not they're both very close it's probably one of those things that changes day by day which i like more but i would probably have more um success i think introducing people to the hobby or getting it to the table with wingspan than i would with everdell and even that i would say is very very close so there was so much to consider even just table presents i think the table presence of everdell is is nicer i think that there's now there's expansions for both these games so both can expand if i ever wanted to like really go heavy into just one because the other one didn't exist everedale has more interest in expansions that i would personally like to explore with like spirecrest and pearl brook that i think i would like to get one day whereas wingspan has the expansions i'm interested to explore but
they're not you know high on my list to get it i there's enough for me to see still in wingspan with the cards that are in there that i don't necessarily need more cards at this exact point in time so lots to to weigh both kind of i waffled back and forth on this i feel like even whatever decision i announced right now might change uh you know tomorrow for all i know but i am going to give the ever slight win to wingspan um this was like i said very tough um i could find reasons i've named reasons for both here but ultimately i think that i do enjoy wingspan just a little bit more and maybe even when i put it over the top is that every single time i play those damn little eggs remind me of cadbury mini eggs and make me super hungry and then i end up going and buying some cadbury mini eggs and then i ended up gorging on cadbury mini eggs which sounds like i'm really mad about that but future dylan is mad about me eating so many mini eggs but present dylan who's eating those mini eggs is having a hell of a good time so that's an extra little added bonus but on top of that like i said i really enjoy playing wingspan i haven't played it enough to you know exhaust everything out of the cards that i've seen and it is just a slightly more successful in my experience on a game that other people will ask to play or want to play and even want to play multiple times they play it once and now every time you know they're coming over for instance it's like hey do you want to throw down a game of wingspan they don't necessarily want to play a random board game specifically they specifically want to play wingspan and so much that is just they love the setup of it they love the way it looks they feel relaxed when playing it everyday it has that as well
it just ever so slightly doesn't have quite the same appeal that wingspan seems to have in my collection because i enjoy them both so much i'm giving the slight nod to wingspan so i am going i guess with the grain of my game that would never leave my collection but it was very close i honestly came into this video thinking i might have given the nod to evernote and i have to explain why i just did a video where i said i'd never get rid of wingspan and then and now it's immediately if i had to get rid of one i'd get rid of wingspan but uh nevertheless that is my choice both good options uh if you were put into the exact same position if you had both and you were forced to get rid of one let me know which one you'd get rid of i'm very curious if you have a different way a different criteria to look at than the criteria i used maybe you're not often introducing games to new people and it's just which one will gravitate more to your group very curious to hear that is my choice though all right and the very last one for today the third one this is the a very random choosing so with these i think in the future i'm actually gonna be running polls on patreon for people to choose two random games for my collection uh and then i'll have to pit them against each other with this criteria uh for this first one i just picked two games that could not be uh you know less alike in terms of thematics and even in gameplay mechanics so much different just for the fun of it if i had to get rid of one and i had to keep on what i would choose so what i've gone with is an interesting one that is going to be cat lady versus terraforming mars so you might be thinking depending on where you land on this side of the debate this is a ridiculous uh choice to make and why would you ever choose cat lady over terrifying mars maybe if you play it on catley you think
vice versa but again this isn't just which is the better game that's not the point of this this versus series we do versus videos and you know what we'll continue to do versus videos which where it's just a single verses like i've done with castle burgundy and and uh cast of tuscany and like we have some other ones coming up i've done the crew versions and those are you know which one we think is the better game this is if i was forced to get rid of one from my collection and keep one which would i choose and i based that off a lot of criteria and it's not just what i enjoy it's also what's going to get played the most and what other games i have in my collection that if i had to get rid of one are going to fill the niche that that one was filling so for instance if i choose to get rid of the cat lady do i have other games that play similar to cat lady that will make up for the fact that i no longer have in my collection that might sway my decision decision as well so terra for mars is obviously a very popular game it's in the top five i believe in in board game on burgundy's top 100 rankings talked about a lot has had numerous expansions i only own one of those which is prelude um and you know it's a a very very different game than gatlady you have this board in the center that you're sort of having a bit of an area control thing going on with your place in tiles that you're then putting your colored cubes onto to claim different spaces you have a ton of cards in in this game that you're having to pay for and play to be able to do a variety of different effects some that are targeting your opponents directly some that are creating you know extra actions that you're then able to do on future turns some that are you know getting you uh animals or other you know resources represented by cubes i can't remember what the other one is it's like not amoeba microbes or something like that there's animals and something else i haven't played in a
while so i'm trying to remember but you know the amount of those that you collect are going to score you different points or that they can sort of let you snowball into each other like when you do something here it's going to add an animal to this card so you're doing that as well uh you're again there's so much even extra stuff being manipulated on the board with you know uh having to change the oxygen level change the the planet temperature create oceans all those are going to give you points when you do them so you want to be the first one to do those things there's a lot going on this is like a two plus hour game usually every time i've played it um that has a lot to consider and is not going to be for everyone that's the one strike against tara from mars or off the bat is that i play games with a variety of gamers i play game games with people who this is the exact type of game they want to play all the time and and i enjoy them as well um where me and carlo are omni gamers we play everything from cat lady to territory of mars and enjoy them all but i will also be introducing games to people that are you know all over the spectrum so i have people that i am often introducing cat lady to and i will say right off the bat i have played cat lady way more times than i have played terraform mars obviously that's probably not too much of a surprise because of the length that the game takes to play but also just the people that i'm introducing games to often are having over this is just happening to hit the table more than terrifying mars that being said when terraforming mars hits the table i would say that my enjoyment level of a game of terrifying mars is worth probably you know two to three games of cat lady i i it's not that i don't enjoy this i love cat lady but i really do enjoy tara for mars a little bit more than i do or a decent amount more than i do cat ladies
so the idea is or the thought process here is if i had to get rid of one all these things that i'm weighing is not only which one do i enjoy more which is terrifying mars um not only that but also you know which one's hitting the table more often and who am i introducing games to there's a lot to consider in this really random pairing and ultimately as much as i would love love to not have to get rid of terraforming mars i'm actually going to give the nod to cat lady ever so slightly and get rid of terraforming mars and honestly some people are going to give me tons of flack for this and even more flak than get rid of lost cities but again the criteria here is not which one is the better game if that was the case i'd be given the nod to terrify mars in this case because i think it's it's a better game than cat lady even though they're both great but i had to weigh how much these games are getting played and again who i'm gonna be able to bring into the hobby with a new game like this and even more so than that the tipping factor for me was when i'm gonna sit down to play a big game a big invested experience like terrifying mars take cat lady out of the equation how much am i choosing terraforming mars out of other games in my collection over zulkin over teotihuacan over uh hauler tau or newsfjord or feast for odin or you know in batoku like all these games that i have that take a lot of time a lot of setup you know are a dedicated game sort of the main event of a game night like we're talking right now a filler game versus a main event in many ways out of all the main events i have i'm not choosing terraforming mars very
often and even beyond that people that are coming over and choosing games aren't choosing terrifying mars and my collection is the one that they want to play so i could keep terrifying mars and get rid of this and the fact of the matter is i'd be losing out on game sessions by getting rid of this more than i would by getting rid of this and i think that sort of was the tipping point it says if for me it was you know if i'm gonna have a game night which one am i going to miss more in the collection by not having it as an option to offer people uh and i weighed that more than which one i enjoy personally playing because terrifier mars is also popular enough that i am sure i can find some local all you can board fans in winnipeg or some you know as i start attending board games meetups and things like that locally and as the pandemic you know starts to wind down those are opening up a little bit more i can probably find a copy terraform marks that someone's offering up uh not to buy but like offering up to to play and to invite people into play more so than probably i can find cat lately and nor nor would i be seeking out a game of cat lady in that same way so that was ultimately my decision i know i'll get some flack for this i know people are going to go come into the comments somewhere and probably say i came in here looking for verses and i left here in a fury because someone just said they're keeping cat lady and get rid of terrifying mars but you know what that is my reasoning i think some people might understand it and if you don't just please know i am not saying terraformers is a bad game in fact i think it's a better game than cat lady but it's not the only thing i wait on that so that is my random period in my random pick which means that my choices for these three pairings were wingspan cat lady and enchanted plumes and the ones that would have to leave my collection but aren't actually in my
collection uh who was i who was i blocking this from i always do this and i'm thinking like am i stopping desmond from understanding what i'm saying uh and the games i'm getting rid of are terrifying mars lost cities at everedah which are three heavy heavy hitter games that i'm sure someone's gonna give me a lot of flack for so that is the versus this time i hope it was uh fun this little format i'm always looking for feedback in the comments for what you like what you don't like if you have other ideas my my thought process going forward as i do these videos it'll always be you know one thematic comparison one gameplay comparison and one random comparison i think that's a fun way to do it but if you have other ideas of cool pairings that aren't of those let me know because maybe i can switch one of those and say this week or this month we're not doing a gameplay pair and we're doing this pairing things that would be useful to you that you actually like want to decide in your collection what to do with or once you just think that would be super fun to hear dylan talk about you know if you want to you know hear me make the case first two of my favorite games then that's that's the reason they're paired let me let me have it i would love to uh to you know put myself through that grueling process so hope you enjoyed the video i realized i have my coffee here i don't even think i took a sip the whole time it's probably cold right now but i do like cold coffee so that's not too bad um but yeah if you if you enjoyed this video let me know in the comments if you have feedback let me know in the comments like the video subscribe to the channel if you haven't already tell a friend we love all the support and thank you so much for it on top of that if you haven't seen yet we are running a 24 hour charity live stream on may 28th all proceeds going to cereal an amazing mental health organization here locally that we are super pumped to support we
have 30 plus prize packages that all you have to do to be entered in to win any of them is donating five dollars five dollars will get you an entry into every single draw you can only win a max of one but we're gonna draw the best ones or the you know not the best ones first but the ones that have most value uh in terms of price point first when you do the draw so you always have the chance for those big ones first um and you can win all of them if you want more entries every five additional dollars can get you an additional entry into every prize package and there are some amazing amazing price packages head over to our website go to aliabor.com you can see everything that's been currently announced more being added all the time me and carlo have their own personal price factors on there that will be updated soon so hope you enjoyed this video thank you so much for watching and we will see you next time