The games I got rid of in 2025
Transcript
This video is brought to you by the 3minut board game patrons. Keep us independent by supporting us on Patreon. Kyoto and welcome to this very special video from 3minut board games. It's the video where I talk about the games I got rid of through the year. Now I can get rid of games for a multitude of reasons. Sometimes it's because they're not very good games. Sometimes it's because I've got a game in my collection that does much the same thing and I prefer that one. and other times they can be reasonably good games and they just take up way too much shelf space to justify their existence. So there's 60 games to get through in this video. So I'm not going to dwell on any particular game for too long and some I'm just going to blast right past. But the purpose of these videos is really katharsis for me.
It's to talk these games out of my collection to say goodbye to them. Sometimes that's with a tinge of sadness and other times it's with a giant middle finger. So sit down, relax, and enjoy my annual vent video. Now, the first game on this list is a bit of a fake out, and it's 51st State. I got rid of the 51st State Master Set because I found the uh 51st State Ultimate Edition on sale somewhere for a really affordable price. So, technically, it is a game I got rid of, but I also got it back at the same time. 51st State is a really fun engine building game. I love the post-apocalyptic theme, and I'm really happy to have gotten an ultimate edition of the game because I've never actually seen it in store until I purchased it. Next up, we have one of board gaming's old classic games, Acire, a Sid Saxon hit from the 1960s. I quite enjoy Aquire, but a lot of what it does, I feel that Dawn of Usos just does a little bit better. Dawn of Ulos is a bit of a reimagining of a choir, but instead of building a hotel chain, you're building out empires, and it's a fascinating, fun, and interesting game to play. I really like the sudden reversals and sudden shifts of power in Dawn of Ulos. And ultimately, I felt like there was only space for one of these games in my collection, and instead of choosing the venerated classic, I went with the new weirdness.
The next game is Aldara, which is a beautiful looking game. Well, the models are beautiful. The board's a bit fugly. It sets out to be a fast-paced 4X game, and for the most part, it succeeds at that. It's a game that really encourages you go out there and have a big fight. It's got fast mechanics, lots of dice chucking, and it's just generally a good, fun, brutal game. Uh, my problem with it is it is ginormous. Like, these boxes were absolutely massive. It has tons of really, really big, wonderful looking models. The thing is, the game is okay. It's It's good, but it's not great. And it's certainly not good enough to justify taking up, you know, two giant coffin boxes worth of shelf space. If I was going to take it on board as a painting project, maybe, but I just don't think the game was good enough for me to really warrant spending all that time painting all those models.
So, yeah, there's a lot to love in Alara, but it's also just a lot of game. It is absolutely cooking inside my game shed today. So, I'm going to do some segments outside as well. And the first game I'm going to talk about is Alltime Wrestling. All time wrestling is kind of fun. It's a wrestling fighting game that takes itself quite seriously. So, you are playing the characters as though they are in a real fight. It's not about creating a story or booking a wrestling. It's from start to finish, bell to bell, and you're trying to beat the hell out of your opponent and pin them, which is which is fine. But to me, that's almost the least interesting thing about wrestling. Uh for me, professional wrestling is about the characters. It's about the story. It's about the, you know, the pomp and ceremony and the overthe-top uh drama that comes with professional wrestling. And inside the ring, it's not about who wins, it's about the story that's told in the ring.
So, yeah, this was a wrestling game that feels like it's perfect for the sort of person who wants an actual wrestling fighting game. It does have some actual IP characters in it as well, but as I say, that's the least interesting part of wrestling to me, so I had to let that one go. Next up, we have a game called Arkham Ritual. Uh, one of the most confusing games I've ever played. It's a social deduction game of sorts, but it's just a nightmare to explain to people. I'm really not going to attempt to explain all the rules here because I'm still quite foggy on them, and it's been a while since I played it. But the short form is if you're playing a social deduction game and you spend 15 minutes explaining and everyone's still staring at you saying, "I I don't get it. What are we supposed to do?" It's probably not a good social deduction game. Social deduction is not necessarily my favorite subjre to start with, but this this is terrible. Uh just play something like coup or the resistance or secret Hitler, anything other than Arkham Ritual.
Next up is Arachus: Dawn of the Fman. Not to be confused with June War for Arachus. They're very, very different games. Arachus: Dawn of the Fman is not a new game either. It's a reskin of a game from 1982, and not a popular game from 1982, nor a very wellaclaimed game from 1982. And that game is Borderlands. I don't think there were large groups of people out there clamoring for this game to be remade again. It was remade. It's Gearlands. And it has another remake. It didn't need a fourth remake. It really didn't. So, I was quite excited to get a new June game, but when we unboxed it and started playing it, it felt dated and it felt kind of awful, and it also didn't really feel June like at all. This is a game I have zero regrets getting rid of. The next game on the list is Bardwood Grove, which is a game about being competing bards. Now, this could be quite a fun concept. Different bars could rock around the countryside seducing people, taming beasts, and attracting piles of weirdass groupies.
There's a good game in there somewhere. That game is not Bardwood Grove. Bardwood Grove doesn't quite know what it wants to be. It halfasses going into that kind of game, but then wants to also be a kind of Euro game as well. And it just fails at both of those things. It also has terrible pacing. You only get to take a real turn every three turns. The other turns you're kind of tuning up and you don't get to do much. Then you get to play these big action turns and as a result the game feels very uneven and just awfully paced. Bwood Grove seems to suffer from a lack of a clear version of what it wants to be and as a result I consider the game pretty much a failure. Next up we have Betrayal at House on the Hill. Now, this was the third edition of the game, and it's the fourth edition of Betrayal at House of the Hill. I've played because I've played the first three and Betrayal at Boulders's Gate, and all four editions that I've played have pretty much run the same way. The first half of the game, you're exploring the house, then at some point, the haunt is triggered and someone becomes the baddie. Now, Betrayal in House of the Hill is fine if you take it for what it is, a silly haunted house betrayal game with wacky stories. You can't take it too seriously. But for me in most of the groups I play with that first half of the game it's just padding. And if I wanted to play a haunted house game I'd probably play something more serious like Mansions of Madness. I like the idea of Betrayal House of the Hill but always that changeover period where you're reading the scenario is just such a drag. It honestly feels like a game that would be better off app driven
where you're exploring the house and things happen and they all build to a haunt that's been predetermined before you start exploring the house. So even the exploration would matter. But as it stands, yeah, it's a throwaway sort of game that I don't really care much for, and I've got rid of it for the fourth time. The next game up is Brew Crafters. Now, Brew Crafters is a pretty respectable sort of worker placement game. It's about building up a craft beer business. In a lot of ways, it feels a little bit like the bear version of Viculture. Brew Crafters is a perfectly good, acceptable game that is simply a casualty of being okay. If you're really into craft beer and the theme, I'd still recommend picking it up because it's it's okay. Next up is Katan New Energies. Now, I'm not the biggest fan of Katan, and I think Katana is fine. We have a copy of Katan mostly for people who want to play Katana, and that person is not me, but sometimes people come around. It's the game they want to play, so I'm happy to play it with them. Katan New Energies was just all kinds of awful. If you haven't played the game, it's like the green environmental version of Katan.
Well, at least that's what it's branded as. What it really is is katan with extra steps. It's katan with busy work. It's katan with a timer that's very hard to beat. It's katan when there's a whole bunch of mechanisms that just slow the game down to a grind. It's bad katan. Everything you would like about katan is kind of muted in katan new energies. And everything you hate about katan, well, that will be dialed up to 11. I loathed katan new energies. It was one of my least favorite games I played last year. And I was really happy to punt it to the curb. It was just kind of astounding that you could take such a simple formula and get it so wrong with so few rules additions. Absolutely mind-blowingly bad. Next up is Clash of Magic Schools, a new game by Ouaya Rosenberg. Or at least I thought it was a new game by Ouaya Rosenberg. Turns out it's a reskin of a game of hers from 20 odd years ago. And it's not a particularly interesting reskin as well. It's a Harry Potter-esque magical college reskin, and all the art's done in that NFT monkey style where it's like the same core picture and then they just change like the hair color or an eye patch on them.
I honestly can't remember much about the gameplay of Clash of Magic Schools. It did not leave a lasting impression on me. Next up is Cosmopus. A cute little engine building game where you're woriing an extradimensional horror. The Cosmopus. I love everything about the packaging of this game, about its presentation, its name, the little octopus in the middle, the victory conditions of getting its tentacles, all that kind of stuff. Absolutely love it. I just thought the gameplay was a bit of a janky, busted mess. I'd really like to see another game using the elements of Cosmocus, the the look and feel, the art direction and stuff, but the actual game, the the engine building stuff, it just seemed very very chaotic to me. So, yeah, for me, it wasn't so much that it's a bad game or anything. It's just that when you won, it just felt so unearned. It's because you got onto like a certain combo of cards and you just got that initial momentum and you were hard to bring down at that point. It's a game where you can really steamroll and you can start steamrolling very early.
And you know, some people absolutely love that about it. But to me, when I was winning, I felt like I was running up the score on people. And when I was losing, I was sitting there going, "When is this game going to end? We already know who's won." Next up is Defenders of the Wild, which is a follow-up game by the same publisher who did BlockbyBlock Uprising. Now, as you might know from the channel, Blockby is one of my favorite games. I love everything about it. I love its take on co-op gameplay. It's sort of like a pandemic game that feels like a war game. I love the theme of the insurrection of these different struggling groups trying to overthrow and occupy a city. It's a game that will always be topical in that regard. And I just love the blocks. They're cute. They're adorable. They set fire to things. Uh they're very angry. It's a neat game. And I was really looking forward to Defenders of the Wild, and it just did not click with me at all.
Nothing about the game appealed. I kept playing it, thinking, "These are the same guys who did Blockby. I love Blockby. Why am I just bouncing off this game so hard?" And I can't put a finger on it. There's just something about the game that didn't work for me. Whether it was the art, whether it was the theme, whether it was the gameplay mechanics, it just slid off me and I did not care for it one shot, which is really sad because I really wanted that publisher to do well with their second title. But I couldn't bring myself to say this is an amazing game and I just felt very flat after playing it. So yeah, I was actually quite sad to get rid of that one because I'd put a lot of hope into it being something better than it was. Well, being something better than it was to me. Next, we have Dungeons, Dice, and Danger. I don't want to yuck other people's yums, but most rolling rights are not for me, and this one was very much a buy the numbers roll and write. I gave it the good old college try and played it like four or five times, but it just wasn't for me at all. If I was going to play a game like this, I would probably just play Cgraphers. It's simpler and ultimately more fun and rewarding. Or I'd play one of the big rolling rides like Hrien's Wall or the Anarchy. But yeah, by and large, rolling rights are just not my thing.
If there's one game I got rid of this year that I might regret, it might be Earth. That's because Earth is exactly my type of game. It's a card- driven engine builder where you get given a bunch of cards and you have to make the best out of them. And the best is normally building an interconnecting engine that scores you a lot of points. It does a whole bunch of things. Earth was pretty good at that. If anything though, Earth was a little too open, a little chaotic, and it felt a little bit like a hodgepodge of a game in some ways. I also have other games like Terraforming Mars and Ark Nova that kind of fill a similar gap or It's a Wonderful World, games that I really, really like. Earth was competing for those spots. Still, if there's one game in this video I could see myself getting back in the future, especially if there's some fun expansions that do some interesting things with it, it would be Earth. It's definitely a very good game, and it was on the cusp of me keeping it.
It's also a game featured in my book, 101 Board Games to Play Before You Die of Boredom. You can check out my views on Earth and 101 other games in that book. Next up is Eclipse Second Dawn. While this appears in the E section of the video, this is the last segment of actually recorded for the video. And that's because as I was filming this video, I got rid of Eclipse Second Edition. Now, Eclipse is a fantastic game. It's very, very good. I love the ship building part of it. It's a neat 4X. The production values are off the charts. It's just a game that doesn't hit the table very often. and someone came up with a trade offer for me that was really good. Now, I wasn't looking at selling this. I hadn't advertised it. Someone popped up online and said, "Hey, does anyone have a copy of Eclipse second edition they're not using? I can buy or trade." So, I reached out to them and they offered me a copy of uh this uh Mechs versus Minions, a game I had not played before. I'd heard a lot of good things about Mech versus Minions, but I'd never had the opportunity to buy a copy myself. So, this was a straight swap. One good game for another. Eclipse is a game I would happily play again, but I felt like the opportunity to swap it for a game like Mix vs versus Minions, which I haven't played before, seemed like a really good one. And also, Mix Versus Minions is something I definitely don't have in my collection.
So, yeah, looked like a mutually beneficial trade there. Next up, we have a very tragic story, and that is Europe Flame. Now, Europe of Flame was a game I got when I was 11 or 12. It's a game I played at intermediate and all the way through high school. It's a World War II game and it is very much a product of the 80s. Unfortunately, over time, the box got absolutely destroyed with various house moves and as a result of where it was stored when we moved house there, the whole thing got a bit water damaged as well. So, as formative a game as Europe Flame was for me, I kind of had to just let it go. It was just a bit too much. Knowing I was getting rid of this part of board gaming history for me personally, I did pick up Europe Engulfed, which is a more modern and similar type of game. So, I do have a game that fits this exact niche in my collection again. So, yeah, most of the neglect that happened to this game happened when I was a teenager and in my 20s and just wasn't taking care of my board games as much. And sometimes you just got to put a board game down and let it go.
Next up is Evolution: Another World, another game in the Evolution series. Now, this series seems to have gone on divergent paths, and there's a whole bunch of different games here, including evolution, evolution, climate, evolution in another world, which is this game, and nature, which just came out this year. Of all of these games, oceans is by far my favorite one. All of the evolution games are about building up animals, giving them traits, and having them interact with other players in a shared environment. So, you'd have to cannally develop your creatures in order to maximize your points. I think Oceans does this better than any other game in the series and definitely better than Evolution Another World, which relied on its alien gimmick a little too much. And here's a hot take. There's a 99% chance you'll see nature in the next year's video in this category, cuz I'm pretty sure I'm going to get rid of it. Oceans just it's just a far more interesting game, and it takes up about 1/8 of the space.
The next game I got rid of was Expeditions, and it was the Ironclad edition. Now, I really like Scythe. I have a fully painted version of Scythe. And here is my Wii Stonem games nook here. Now, Expeditions was a reasonably solid game and certainly a worthy sequel to Scythe. It wasn't a game I raved about and not a game that I felt enamored with, and it came in a massive box as well. So, while it's the kind of game I'd happily play at someone else's house, I didn't feel the need to own it myself, especially not the Ironclad edition. That thing's quite rare in New Zealand. So, I let that one go so someone else could enjoy it. I tell you what, the bigger the game boxes are, the easier they are to get rid of. It's when a game fits into a very small box that I have a very hard time getting rid of it. The next game up is Fractured Sky, and it's a funny thing. There is so much work and effort went into making this game a deluxe product. It has so many fancy components. All these magnets and stuff, the the boards are really detailed. There's all this wonderful work and effort went into making this game in every department other than the game itself. It is a beautiful product.
And that to me is the problem with this game because the gameplay is absolutely mid, absolutely run-of-the-mill area control blind bidding stuff. It's just got a lot of guff on top of it. And you know, I go on about art and games having presentation and all that kind of stuff quite a bit, but it's never enough for me to keep a game if it's got mediocre or poor gameplay. And Fracturous Sky is definitely on the mediocre end. It's also a comparatively big box and a whole bunch of setup time for what is a really, really simple game. So, it's a mid kind of game, but it's not worth it at that price point, and it's certainly not worth it at that size point as well. Next up is Gloom Haven and Gloom Haven Jaws of the Lion. And I got rid of these for a very simple reason. They sent me Gloom Haven second edition. That's it.
That That's the reason. Oh, and Gloom Haven Buttons and Bugs. I did get rid of that as well. Uh for an entirely different reason. Uh I really have a hard time reading it. Like it's the pieces are very small and I have big hands and I just found it a faf. I found it just a pain to play with, to look at. Had to wear my glasses the whole time, is squinting down at things, moving them around. And, you know, it's cool that they managed to fit all that game into that small box, but I've got a big table. Uh, if I'm going somewhere, I'll take a game that I find more functional. Uh, Gloom Haven, Buttons, and Bugs just wasn't for me at all. I admire the hell out of the design and everything they did to get the game down to that size, so it just had that much content in such a small box. But then I also just didn't care for the gameplay at all or just or just the user interface for one of a better word. It just it felt almost hostile to me as a player playing this very fiddly game. I even gave up trying to do a review of it because all the stopotion photography, everything was just too fiddly. So yeah.
So yeah, that's the reason I got rid of Gloom Haven buttons and bugs. It just didn't feel ergonomically compatible with me as a human being. Next up is Godspeed. Godspeed is a Cold War game set in an alternate history where we've discovered faster than light travel and the various Cold War powers are competing over a new planet. I really like the look of God speed. I like the idea of it and I even like the bidding mechanic that it's got in the game for using your different characters and how they all interact. I especially like the bit where there's a crisis drawing each turn and you secretly choose if you're going to commit resources to it. And if everyone commits resources, you do okay. But if someone opts out, well then the whole thing falls over. That's my kind of dirty semi-ooperative gameplay. Thing is, no one else in my group cared for it whatsoever. I'd bring it out and go, "Hey, let's give this one a go." And people would be just like, "Nah, something else." So, while I kind of wanted to play the game a lot more, no one I knew really cared for it one bit.
So, that's why I eventually got rid of it. It just wasn't getting played. So, you might hear some hooting and hollering behind me from the local kindergarten. Uh, our house was right beside a park. And in that park is the local kindergarten and that's where my daughter goes to kindi. So I can be sitting here working on videos and playing games and stuff and hear her making a whole bunch of noise just over the fence. They can't catch me.
It does make it a little challenging recording videos on occasion, but I wouldn't trade it for the world. Being able to walk my daughter to kindergarten in like 2 minutes and be here if there's an accident or an emergency is just it's the best. And I have to thank my patrons and everyone who watches these videos for giving me this opportunity as well. Uh being able to stay home while Ann's been little and do the channel and design board games and stuff. That's that's such a beautiful wonderful thing and I wouldn't trade it for the world. So yeah, uh a little bit of noise from kindergarteners shrieking behind me. Absolutely totally worth it to be here for her as much as I have been. Thank you everyone who's watched the channel. Anyway, back to the games.
Next up, we have Guilty Gear, which was a really neat game. I enjoyed this game immensely. It was a back and forth beat him up game, and I really liked that. I enjoyed it quite a bit. It was something I didn't really have in my collection and I didn't really know anything about the Guilty Gear characters. I probably would have liked the game more if it had been a Mortal Kombat or a Street Fighter that I knew the characters a little bit better from or even Tekken. And I really did want to find a space for this one in my collection. But it's the kind of game you really need to have people invested in playing. You can't just sort of pick it up and just play one game of it. People need to find characters they like and really enjoy the system. And the real big problem with it was it had the biggest box of any game in my collection. like bigger than Gloom Haven, bigger than Oath Swarm, bigger than Galactic Cruise, bigger than any of those games. Guilty Gear was massive.
And for what was essentially a card game with some perspect standes, it didn't justify taking up enough space for like five or six other good games. I mean, yeah, I could have thrown the game box out and restacked it in a shoe box, but that just felt dirty to me. And also, I knew it was a game that someone out there would get a lot of fun playing, so I happily sold that one on. The next game on the list is Healthy Heart Hospital Third Edition. I had been bugging Scott, the designer of Healthy Heart Hospital, for years to get a new edition printed. See, Healthy Heart Hospital used to belong to Victory Point Games, and they were acquired by Staling Games some years ago. They put out such titles as Nemo's War and Dawn of the Zed's Third Edition, and I was hoping they had to do a similar treatment for Healthy Heart Hospital. What they did instead was utterly gut the game and put out the most tepid, incippid looking version of the game possible. They did no marketing for this game. They just kind of dumped it on their site and let it die. And I can't for the life of me fathom why you would redesign a game, get all the art assets done, and just plop it out and go, "Eh, who cares?"
What was the damn point? Second Edition of Healthy Hound Hospital is one of my all-time most played solo games. I absolutely love it despite its flaws and it has big flaws, but it's got this bag manipulation system I really enjoy and it's a game that I feel clever when I win a game of it. What the new edition did was just gut all of that, all of the bag manipulation stuff you could do throughout the course of the game. They just kind of got rid of because, you know, that makes it more complex. They took out all of the rough edges and what you were left with was a smoothrained game. I have heard though that Scott has the rights to the game back. So hopefully we'll see a fourth edition that comes back with some more warts on it cuz I'd love to see that. This third edition from Staling Games absolutely stunk.
Next up is Hijgemony. A very popular heavy game that attempts to simulate the inner workings of a state. In Hijgemony, you'll be playing one of three different classes. The upper class, working class, or middle classes, or the state itself. Now, there's two things I could do here. One is to leave a long and wordy essay about why I think he is a deeply flawed game, and while the model they use is complete and utter nonsense, and therefore any lessons you might learn from playing this game are fruit of the poisonous tree and will do nothing more than misinform you about the state and how classes actually work. Or I could just say that the game wasn't for me and leave it at that. And as this video is looking like it's going to be around an hour in length, I think I'll just leave it there. Next up is Hidden Leaders. And I'm not going to say much about this one because I can barely remember playing it. What I do remember is moving markers back and forth on a board and hoping that they were going the right direction you wanted because you wanted them to be in a certain place and your opponents wanted them to be in another place because each of you had a secret hidden leader that was trying to score a certain way. You know, that sounds like a fun enough premise for a game, but if I'm struggling to remember what the game was about six months on, uh, it's probably not a good sign because I have a pretty good memory for games. And Hidden Leaders, yeah, all I can remember is there's card play, you're moving the sliders up and down, and if they land where you want them, great. It really depends a lot on what your opponent's goals are as well, because if they align, you can do really well. If they don't, well, you two players can end up fighting and the third player can profit, which I guess happens quite a
bit in hidden information games. Uh, War of Whispers was like this as well. I don't really care much for that one either. The next game up is Inventors of the South Tigers. The final game in Garfield Games South Tigers trilogy. Now, I have had a lot of Garfield games in my collection over the years, and I still have eight games of theirs in my collection. I didn't feel like I needed 14 or 15 of their games, so I got rid of the ones I didn't play quite so much. And Inventors was definitely top of that list. It's a lot of a game. There's there's a heck of a lot happening. To give you an idea of how big and complex the game is, there's a dice version of Wingspan that is just in the game. It's just a very small part of the game. But you got this whole version of Wingspan just sitting there as a subset of one board on the game. It's a lot. It's super busy. Inventors of the South Tigers is a lot to teach new players.
And I just couldn't see a scenario where I'd want to play Inventors over uh Scholars of the South Tigers, which is my favorite game from that trilogy. So, I decided to keep Scholars and get rid of Inventors. Next up is ISS Vanguard, a game that had been in my top 100 a couple of times. Now, the reason I'm getting rid of ISS Vanguard is very straightforward and very simple. I finished it and I have no interest in playing it through again. Like, I enjoyed ISS Vanguard a lot. I really enjoyed the story. There were a couple of weird parts to the game and places where there was some very unusual decisions where it didn't really feel like decisions. You're like, "Hey, do you want to be a Hitler or okay human being?" It's like, "Okay, yeah, I'll I'll take the non- Hitler option." And the dice system started to grate on me by the end of the campaign. I was a little bit over the mechanics of the game and just wanted to get to the end of the story after about, you know, a year of playing it. Still a very enjoyable experience and a game I am very happy I played through. Getting all the way through it though, I got to see all of the warts of the game and I don't really want to go back through and experience that again. I don't think there's enough changes in the story or other things I'd experience in the story that I haven't already done. Might there might be little things, but that's certainly not worth the effort of going all the way back through the campaign.
So, I figured, hey, someone else might get a really good experience out of this as well. So that's why I set this one on. Next up, we have K2, a perfectly fine mountaineering game. It's got some very clever stuff in it about how you acclimatize as you go up the mountain and how you use your two different climbers. Thing is, K2 is really a racing game, and for racing games, I'd much rather play something like Formula D or Heat than I would K2. It's not really a knock on K2. It just didn't really have a place in my collection anymore. But it's a perfectly fine, serviceable game. The next game I got rid of is Legendary Encounters the Matrix. Now, I really enjoyed that game. It's probably the second best game in the Legendary Encounter series. I preferred it to Firefly and I preferred it to Predator and I definitely preferred it to XFiles.
What I didn't prefer it to was Legendary Encounters Alien, and I have everything for that game. I have all of the expansions. So, I'd played through all the encounters in Legendary Matrix and all of the characters, and I'd had a pretty good go at it. And, you know, it was a rockolid adaption of those films. But playing it, I kept thinking, you know what? Alien Alien's just better. Just better. It's the same but better. And so, I just kept going back to Legendary Encounters Alien. I certainly don't need both of them in my collection. So, yeah, one had to go. And it was clearly going to be The Matrix. If you're a fan of The Matrix, definitely give it a try. It is a legitimately good Matrix board game. The next game I got rid of is The Manhattan Project, the original Manhattan Project. And the reason for that is I have two of its sequels. uh Energy Empire, which is a very different game to Manhattan Project and an amazing game at that. And then there's Two Minutes to Midnight, which is sort of like a second edition of Manhattan Project. It does a lot of what the original does, but I think it's a better tuned game. All three games are very good worker placement games with fascinating Cold War themes. I just think these two are better than the original. And out of these two, I'm most inclined to get rid of this one first.
Energy Empire is an absolute banger, and I'm totally keeping that for a very long time. Next on the list is Marvel United, a game I think's pretty damn good. Thing is, this game also has like a gazillion expansions, and I know multiple people who have basically everything for the game. If I ever really want to play Marvel United, I can just either borrow their copy or go around to their houses and play it. Just having the X-Men starter box, it just felt like a pretty empty game in comparison to what they've got. And it's one of those games where I kind of felt you either need to really get into it or you just get out of it. So I opted to get out of it instead of getting all of that damn extra content because it would be really easy for the completionist in me to just go, "Oh yeah, I'll get that box. I'll get that box. I'll get that box." And all of a sudden it's a whole wall dedicated to one game.
Next up is the Mass Effect board game Priority Hog. Mass Effect the board game priority hugalas. Okay, I'm a fan of Mass Effect. I'm not a massive fan. I only played the first two games and I really need to get round to playing the third game at some point. And I think Mass Effect is a fantastic setting for a board game. I just don't think this was the right game to be the first Mass Effect board game. It's a co-op skirmish game. You pick four characters and you play through a series of missions and it's just battling away on a little board. I personally think something like ISS Vanguard would have been much better suited to be a Mass Effect game than this. Also, as a skirmish game, I found it quite lacking. I did not care for the dice system remotely. At the start of turn, you have like 12 dice and then the first character gets to pick three of them and then that descends down. It's just it's a clunky sort of system. So, in the same year that I finished ISS Vanguard and I played Undaunted Kalisto, Mass Effect just didn't have much to offer me. And if you're looking for a game that feels like Mass Effect, I'd recommend those two over this one.
Next up, we have MetroRunner. Metro Runner is a game where you move around a rond on the board trying to collect bits of data so you can complete assignments. It's got a cyberpunk theme, and the core gameplay is perfectly fine. It's perfectly acceptable. The reason it tripped us up is in the middle of the board, there is a simple puzzle that you can solve multiple times during the game and then reset and move it about. The problem is when we were playing it is that every time that puzzle was moved or altered, everyone would focus in on it. It was like the hypnoad drawing our attention all the time. And I and the people I was playing with just found the central puzzle incredibly distracting. I almost wanted to drape a tea towel over it until people were using it because as soon as it changed, everyone would stop what they're doing and look up and go and figure out how to solve it. Now, I know this puzzle is meant to be the centerpiece of the game, but it wasn't a particularly complex puzzle, but it was just enough to draw you in and make you do it. Like just having a sodoko square pop up in front of you and you're like, "Oh, yeah, solve that." And then go back to playing the game. So, yeah, it was a very distracting and weird feature in the game that meant my attention was always being dragged away from what I was supposed to do. Very unusual experience.
Next up, we have Montipython's Quest for the Holy Grail, the board game. I was approached by the publisher of this game to do a review of it. Stephanie and I are both really big fans of that film and she actually wanted to do the review for this particular game. She noted it down on her to-do list for this year. Do the MontiPython review. Then I cracked open the box and played a test game of it and it's awful. This is the kind of board game you could describe as exploitative. There's absolutely nothing here. It is just, hey, remember that thing from the film? You remember that thing thing from the film? You love that thing from the film. The game play is absolute rubbish. It's just it's got the stuff from that thing you like in it. It's pap. It's pulp. It's nonsense. And it's just it's not a very good game at all. And I feel fans of an IP deserve something better than what this game was. Frankly, I thought it was quite insulting and that's why we never did a formal review of it. And we are a long way from where every IP game used to be rubbish like this. We've had great IP games over the years. things like Battlestar Galactica, This War of Mine, Star Wars Rebellion, X-Wing, great IPbased games. And then someone has to fart out a monstrosity like this.
There's only one thing I can say to the designers and publishers of this game. The next game up is Nations, a game I quite enjoyed. The problem with Nations is it's a civilization game, and I have a ton of games in that kind of niche. Even in very straight up and down Civilization games, I have Mosaic, I have Sidmire Civilization, and I have the original Civilization as well. So, Nations was kind of the fourth game existing in this space at least. So, while I did enjoy the game, it was never hitting the table. Mosaic was clearly ahead of it, and I've played that a lot more than I have Nations over the last three or four years. So yeah, Mosaic Ate Nations Lunch a little and there's not much point keeping a game you're just not going to play, especially if there's something you vastly prefer in a similar game space. And it's not like I had a big emotional attachment to Nations either.
The next game up is Pandemic Legacy, and I actually chucked out two copies of Pandemic Legacy uh this year. Uh I had two separate groups who uh played it through or almost through or halfway through, and neither of those groups have played it in three or four years. So, what's the point in keeping it? We're not going to finish it off. Uh, one group got up to a certain changeover point, they went, "M, yeah, that's that's cheesy." And they didn't want to continue for that point, and I can't really blame them. Uh, it's a point where people have played the campaign where you find out what the disease really is, and they were like, "No, I'm not playing this game." And and I respect that for them cuz I was kind of like, "Eh, it's a it's a this has been done." I don't think legacy games are for me. I like getting skilled at a game. I like playing a game over and over and getting better and better at it. And legacy games are constant rugpulls. And I found that with Pandemic Legacy. I found it with Ticket to Ride Legacy and a bunch of other legacy games I've played where you play the game and you just start to get comfortable what's going on and they add in a new mechanism. They add in a new challenge and it throws you back to the learning stage. Now, if you're one of those people who loves discovering new games and loves being exposed to new systems and mechanics, this sounds wonderful.
But if you're the kind of person like me who likes learning a game and optimizing and like focusing in your skill set on the game until you feel like you're very good and focused on being excellent at that game. Legacy games just knock you back to that start spot. So you constantly feel like you're you're a newbie every single time you play the game. And I know that's a very particular character trait of mine that I like to master games. I like to get very good at them. But it is one of the things that makes me feel like legacy games just aren't designed with me in mind. So yeah, two copies of Pandemic Legacy sheltered away. Next up is Planet of the Apes, a cooperative game that I almost entirely played as a solo game. It's a Kevin Wilson designed game, and he's probably most famous to people for being the designer of Arkham Horror Second Edition. Planet of the Apes is fine.
It's a reasonably robust game, but it's Planet of the Apes. And every time I suggested playing this game to other people, they were like, "Nah, it's Planet of the Apes." If you're a Planet of the Apes fan, this is actually a really good thematic game based on that original movie with Charlton H. The second Garfield Games game I got rid of was Raiders of Cyia. And the main reason I got rid of that one is I haven't played it that much lately. I also have the app version of Raiders of the North Sea. So, if I had the urge to play the game, I'll just go play it on the app. Raiders was also competing with Architects and Ciccadians First Light. And while I think Raiders is a rockolid game, it just wasn't getting played on the table anymore. And I didn't feel the strong connection to it that I do for a game like Architects or Paladins. So, yeah, Raiders are a perfectly good game, but I found myself getting rid of quite a few perfectly good games this year.
Next game on the list is Rim Racers. I was really excited to get this game. Uh the publisher makes this war game called Infinity and they have amazing models in world building. I have friends of mine who play Infinity and they say it's an exceptional skirmish game and it's one I've always wanted to get into but just never had the time to commit to yet another skirmish game. So yeah, when they said they were getting into board games, I was like absolutely send me the game and they sent me REM Races and it's junk. It's it's just junk. It is a bad racing game. The components are kind of mid and it came out around about the same time as Heat and it's it feels embarrassingly dated in comparison. Like we set it up, we went to play it. We did a couple of rounds and was like, "Yeah, this is going back in the box. I'm not even going to review this one. I'm not going to waste time on it." And apparently very few other people seem to care about this game either cuz it doesn't appear to have many owners on BG and it doesn't look like it's fired up the sales. Very flat, very disappointing game.
The next game on the list is Ruins of Mars. Now, Ruins of Mars is a classic example of me getting a game because it's called Ruins of Mars. When I was designing Red Dust Rebellion, I basically played every single game that had Mars in the title. Anything I could find Mars related, I'd pick it up and have a look at what people were doing. And Ruins of Mars deals with one of my least favorite things, and that's the idea of ancient civilizations on Mars. That that just isn't a thing for me. Mars is a dead rock. It may have had life a long time ago, but it certainly wasn't sentient life, and it certainly wasn't leaving behind relics for us to discover. I should have known that based on the name Ruins of Mars going into it, but I still picked it up anyway. But then the game itself was just kind of boring. Felt like it could have been a good 45minute game, but the game ended up being 90 minutes or longer when we played it. Now, that may have come down with a lot more play experience, but it just felt padded, like the game hadn't been properly tuned or tested enough, or whoever was in charge of the game just kept too many of their darlings and their ideas in the bucket instead of trimming them down to find what the essence of the game really was. Yeah, Ruins of Mars, despite being a Mars game, just totally wasn't for me.
The next game on our list is Scorpius Freighter. And Scorpius Freighter isn't necessarily a terrible game. It's not a bad game at all. It's just not the game you think it is when you set it up originally. It looks like a space trading game where you're flying your ship around and you're picking up cargo and dropping it off places. And that's kind of what it is, but it's really a rondle game with these three different uh rdles moving around. The great betrayal in this game, though, is you see these plastic ships and you go, "Oo, I can't wait to move one of those around and put cargo in it." And you're like, "No, that's that's not your ship. That's that's a marker that moves around each of these boards. You you don't get to play with those at all." And you're like, well, so where's our ship? Oh, your ship's sort of on this off the board, but it's kind of abstracted by the movement of other things. You're like, oh, oh, it's just got that extra level of abstraction that the game just doesn't need. And as a result, it's an incredibly disengaging sort of game. I feel like it could have been okay if it was made more abstract, like they didn't bother trying to make it into a frighter themed game. So, it's in this sort of halfway house between this very abstracted system along with trying to put all this theme on top of it, and it just doesn't work. So, yeah, not the worst game I've ever played, but just a bit of a mishmash of ideas.
Next up is Ship Rights of the North Sea Redux. Now, there are very few games that I have a pang of regret getting rid of, and this is one of them. Ship Rights is a really good drafting game. It's lightweight, it's fast. It sort of goes against the convention of a lot of Garfield's later titles because it's fast playing and it's not a heavyweight Euro game. It's also pretty easy to teach. Problem is, it's in the same niche as something like It's a Wonderful World and I absolutely love It's a Wonderful World. It had to go headto-head with a game I absolutely adore for game space in my collection and it just simply wasn't going to win that battle. So yeah, Ship Rights Redux is a really good game, but I personally much prefer It's a Wonderful World when it comes to lightweight drafting games. Oh, and 51st State. This is one game on this list of games I'm getting rid of that I do hardly recommend people try because you might prefer it to those other titles I mentioned.
Next up, we have Sky Team. One of the most popular games of the last year. Now, I have seen people rave about Sky Team and sing its praises, and frankly, I do not get it. It seems to other people there's a lot of excitement and tension in this game because you don't know what your partner is going to do. Now, when Stephanie and I played this game, we would discuss our strategies beforehand. We'd roll our dice and then we take our actions. And we kind of trust each other to do the right thing. If one of us didn't have the right dice, it's because we didn't have the right dice. There's nothing we could really do to change that aside from, you know, getting a copy and re-rolling it. There wasn't any tension because I wasn't expecting Stephanie to make a drastic mistake that was going to screw us. And if what screwed us was just that she rolled all sixes and we needed some ones that turn, then to us that wasn't particularly thrilling. That was just oh well that the game beat us, that's that's not exciting at all. Now, I know a lot of people's experience with this game is very different to ours. But to us, it literally felt like we were sitting down in silence during the round trying to collectively finish off a game of tic-tac-toe to a draw. I'm not even exaggerating there. That's how dull and procedural we found the game of Sky Team. So yeah, I'm not entirely too sure why this is, but we experienced zero of the drama, tension, and excitement that other people talk about in this game, and we were quite happy to get rid of it. I'm still very confused as to how the game makes people feel these feelings, cuz we certainly did not.
Next up is Spectre, a James Bond game. Now, this is a competitive game with a semi-ooperative element to it. You're all various masterminds competing to be number one of the organization Spectre and James Bond is out there wrecking your schemes. Spectre is fine. It looks a little cheap. The game play is reasonably good and it does end up feeling like a limited version of the game Disney Villainous when you play it. Like you've got your own schemes you're trying to complete on your boards while everyone else is trying to do theirs. But instead of the other players actively trying to follow your schemes like Villainous, it's Bond. It's the board is trying to screw you over. This is a perfectly okay game and I am a big James Bond fan, but that wasn't enough for me to keep the game in my collection. And the idea of being James Bond villains is way cooler than actually playing them in the game itself.
Next up, we have Star Trek Buffer Time: The Lower Decks or Star Trek: The Lower Decks Buffer Time. Honestly, it doesn't matter. This is a push your luck game that doesn't really seem to have any meaningful decisions in it. It's the kind of game you make when you just want to slap an IP on something to make some money off people you think are gullible and stupid. It's a sort of trashy game that feels exploitative, like it's trying to milk money out of Star Trek fans, and in particular lower deck fans. It just feels like they pick up a random game mechanic, slap it on, and just put it out and don't bother testing it or playing it or seeing if it's remotely fun. Star Trek: The Loadex Buffer Time might be the most disappointing game I've played in the last 12 months. absolutely like zero stars, zero out of 10. Whatever the scoring mechanism is, uh this is a this is a rubbish game and I was pretty glad to see the back of it.
Next up is Star Tycoon. Now, Star Tycoon really intrigued me and I enjoyed playing it, but it was one of those games where I felt like this is a great first iteration of this idea or an early iteration of this idea and I felt like there could have been so much more done to the game to turn it into something great. What you get in the Star Tune box is quite a good game. It's certainly better than average, but it's got a lot of busy work and awkward mechanics in it as well. And I just felt like the next like a second edition of this game is going to be really good. If this game gets a second edition and it's just tuned and refined just a little bit, it could be something very special. So, I'm going to keep an eye out for this game to see if they do do a second edition and if they do do some revisions to the game because the core idea is cool, the core mechanics are pretty cool. It's just a bit flabby and wobbly around the edges. I could really do with someone like Shim Phillips or Sam McDonald from Garfield Games taking the game and just sort of refining it a little bit and knocking off the the rough edges because I think a very polished version of Star Tycoon would be awesome. But until then, this version's kind of mid and I had to get rid of it.
The next game up is Tellywood Rally, a game that is just got the most bizarre theme imaginable. It's about halfling politics. Yeah, Halfling Politics done in a very US politics style kind of way with press secretaries and campaigns and stuff. I'm not sure who this game was for, but the company went bankrupt shortly after releasing it. It's one of those games that's probably going to end up being a rarity and an oddity because I don't think they ended up distributing all the copies of the game. Uh, I got a review copy uh bundled up with my copy of Bardwood Grove. So, it's the same publisher who did did that and Merchants Cove. Mechanically, it was very awkward. Thematically just a bit weird and artistically kind of offensive, which is a stunning combination of things to get wrong in a board game. So, if I gave out an award for most stunningly weird board game implementation of the year, Tellywood Rally would be a frontr runner for that game because it's just weird.
And not good weird, just bad weird, awkward, weird, confusing, weird, halfling politics weird. Next up, we have The Shadow Planet. A game that I got in a math trade solely because I like the look of the art style. And after playing it a couple of times, that's still the only thing I like about The Shadow Planet. It's a very ambitious game that tries to tell a story about paranoia and suspicion and alien takeovers on a spaceship crew that has landed on an alien planet. One's a monster trying to escape the planet. One's a guardian trying to destroy the ship and strand everyone on the planet so the monster doesn't escape. and the rest are humans just trying to escape without the monster on board. The problem is you don't really control your own character. And unlike Station 4, which does this really well, The Shadow Planet does it incredibly hamfistedly.
As a game, it's a wonderful experiment, but it just doesn't quite work, and you end up with people around the table getting very confused over what the hell is going on. Still, I really do like the art direction on the game, and I just wish the gameplay was a little bit tighter and a little less weird. Next up, we have Ticket to Ride Europe and Ticket to Ride Legacy. Well, we'll do Ticket to Ride Europe first. Uh, Ticket to Ride Europe I got rid of because I have Ticket to Ride. And I kind of made a judgment call. Which one am I going to keep? Ticket to Ride Europe or Ticket to Ride the original? And I figured because Europe's a little bit more complex and Ticket to Ride's more likely to be played with people who just want to come over and play Ticket to Ride, I'd keep that one. They're both fine. They're perfectly fine games. I'm not going to be critical of Ticket to Ride. It is what it is. a very solid foundation game that a lot of people love to play and I mostly keep a copy of my collection because other people want to play it. Now, Tickets to Ride Legacy on the other hand, that's a different kettle of fish. We played that one all the way through and I thought it was a bit of a hot mess. There was some interesting stuff in there, but yeah, overall it just probably wasn't worth the effort of playing through. I gave that one away to one of the players who played the game because he wanted to get the different engines, and I think he still might actually use the board as well.
Next up is a game called Unrest. Now, in the past, I've talked about a lot of games getting a solo mode when they really probably shouldn't have one. Some games just have a highle interaction or different things that you can't replicate with an AI or with a bot. And when you make a solo mode for those games, you're essentially making a new game using the components from the old game. The reverse is true in Unrest. Unrest is a two-player game that should have been a solo game. There's two sides here, just like Android Netrunner. One represents the rebels and the other represents the corporations. And the rebel player, they get to have fun. They get to make meaningful decisions during the game. The defending player just gets to defend stuff. And they don't have a lot of options. It could have been done with a card flip. So, Unrest is a very unusual game. It's one where I'd consider one player gets to have an okay game experience and the other player gets to facilitate that okay game experience. And to me, that's a terrible two-player game. So, I happily got rid of Unrest. I would have been the one teaching people, which probably meant I would have been the one playing the boring part. And I got much better things to do with my time than that.
Next up, we have Vampire the Masquerade Vendetta. This is a Vampire the Masquerade themed area control sort of bluffing gambling kind of game. It was a very polarizing art direction to it. I can see some groups really getting into this. Uh, but for me, it didn't really capture the vibe and feel of Vampire the Masquerade at all. I'm a very old school Vampire the Masquerade player. I played it all the way through the '9s and some of the early 2000s, and I've always been looking for a very good Vampire the Masquerade themed game. In fact, Shadowoon Syndicates, my own board game, started life as a Vampire the Masquerade themed game before we evolved it and turned it into something else. It started off from the idea of what would it be like if the prince died in the city and you tried taking over the city? And that's the kind of vibe I was hoping for from Vampire the Masquerade Vendetta, but I didn't get any of it.
It's a lot of card play, a lot of bluffing. Uh, but it's also a game with a lot of feel bad moments in it as well. So, yep. This is another one we sold and moved on. Next up, we have Wandering Galaxy. A game I really wanted to enjoy. For years, my friends had a role playing game that we used to run called Conveniently Far Future. It's a game about being a bunch of scumbags riding around the universe in a futurama type setting. And reading through the notes for Wondering Galaxy, it seemed like, holy heck, this is the conveniently far future game. And tonally, that's what it was. The storytelling in this game is a lot of fun. There's some wacky characters. You go around space. You meet a whole bunch of weird and interesting characters. The problem is the mechanics are trash. Like the game mechanics in Wandering Galaxy are from start to finish just awful. For a game that should be a light-hearted frolic through space. There's an awful lot of tedious ship maintenance. And then there's a card system for each character that feels incredibly arbitrary. There was a great fun world to explore here with some really interesting things to do, but the game just kept getting in its own way over and over again. And the group that I assembled to play it, the ones who played that conveniently far future role playing game before, seeing their enthusiasm just plummet during the first session, they were so excited at rolling up the characters and naming the ship and doing all this stuff. And then about an hour and a half in, they were like, "Yeah, tap out. I want to go." And I had to play test through the other scenarios by myself for a while because
no one wanted to come back to it. It was a game that felt tailor made to us in terms of content, but the mechanics absolutely let it down. The fourth and final Garfield game I got rid of this year was Wayf Farers of the South Tigris. And that's simply because Wayfairers does my head in. It's a game where you open up playing and you have so many options. You almost drown in your options. Now, for some players, this sounds like a dream. This is a perfect thing. You have so many open possibilities at the start of the game. But for me, I just never felt there was something I could latch on to or or grasp in my first couple of turns and my mind would wander throughout the game. There's something about Wayfairers that just doesn't click with me. it just bounces bounces off me and I just can't focus on the game and therefore I can't have a good time. It's probably the most unique and innovative game in the South Tigris series. But that came at the cost of me being completely out of my depths playing it. And yeah, once again, I kept Scholars because Scholars is my favorite in the South Tigris trilogy because while it is a complex game, it has patterns that make sense to me. It's all about translating things. So you have to get the documents, you have to translate them into a certain language, then you have to publish them. There's a logical path and a process to follow. Wayfairers is just a big blank canvas on which you have to paint what you're doing. And to me, it was just too much.
The next game up is Wise Guys from Gal Force 9. And this game is a reimagining or a retheing of their Sons of Anarchy game. Now, Gale Force 9 over the years have done a whole bunch of IP games. Star Trek stuff, Firefly, you name it, they've done it. And the Sons of Anaki game apparently was very, very good. Now, I played Wise Guys, and it's fine. It is a perfectly good game. There's quite a bit of back and forth. It is a game where you are fighting over territory and turf and stuff, but really it is just about making money. Doesn't matter if you blow away all your opponents as long as you're like making enough cash and and putting it aside. And I do like that in a criminal game. If you're running a criminal enterprise, you should be about enterprising and making money, and Wise Guys does a very good job of that. Thing is, I do not care for the mafia theme whatsoever. Uh, Sons of Anarchy theme really didn't grab me either, but I think Modern Bikers might be more interesting than the cliche 1930 gangster stuff. I've played so many games with a mafia theme, and each time it just it just doesn't do it for me whatsoever. So, if you are interested in designing a game that I will not care about, pick a theme like Western, Las Vegas, or Mafia, and I will just I will tune out almost immediately.
And that's what happened with Wise Guys. It's a perfectly fine rework of a pretty good game with a theme I just don't care for. And there you have it. There's a whole bunch of games I got rid of. Uh, which ones do you think I was a fool for getting rid of? And which ones do you think I was absolutely justified in doing so? Based on what I've said in this video, what games do you think I would like and would fit my collection? If you have questions or thoughts about this or anything else board game related, leave a comment in the video below. I try to respond to everyone who asks questions. And a reminder, Three Minute Board Games does not do paid content. If that wasn't glaringly obvious based on some of the comments in this video, uh, keep us independent by supporting us on Patreon. If you enjoy this video, come support us on Patreon or like, share, and subscribe to the channel.