"Tin Man" Top 100 Board games 20-11
Transcript
hi i'm adam porter and this is my board gaming vlog and we're looking at my top hundred board games uh card games tabletop games dice games all that sort of stuff and we're now down to number 20 so we're looking at number 20 through to number 11. and at number 20 on the list is the game yogi yogi uh started its life as a game called in a bind from a friend of mine called bez beirut shariari and bears created this game i remember playtesting it at the uk games expo many years ago before it was uh a finished game and uh it's it's just one of those ideas where um you just think i i wish i could have thought of that it's so obvious you know in in yogi what you do or in a bind what you do is you take a card and it tells you what to do with it so it'll say this card must be touching your ear or this card must be touching your elbow or you must have your right hand above your left hand or whatever it is you know so you get yourself into these weird positions with these cards sticking out all over the place and you must continue to obey those rules if at any point you fail to obey one of these rules you drop a card or you move into a position that doesn't obey all your rules then you're out of the game and that's essentially it you play until you know there's just one person standing at the end of the game who's i say standing this is a game you play sat around a table everything happens above the table top so essentially it's it's like um twister the card game such
a simple rule set so intuitive so clever so funny it's done extremely well i'm so pleased for bears how well this game has gone it's had a follow-up um yogi guru i think it's called i haven't tried that one yet um but it's just something i admire i admire games like this games that manage to to just such an obvious idea but but yet such a fun one and something that no one's yet thought of and and clearly creates so much fun for so many people so not all games have to be heavy euros do they heavy strategy games sometimes it's fun to just sit around and have a good laugh and yogi will give you that in spades it's also a really nice production from gigantic plastic cards aren't going to get damaged very easily a nice little container yeah good stuff all round number 19 is a classic card game from ryan ignitzia this is high society which is an auction game so a card is laid up and it's auctioned off to everybody so everybody has to try and purchase or maybe they don't want to purchase so we'll have an option to avoid purchasing a card they're either going to give you points or take away points depending on what the card is but the key thing here is that the cards that you're using as currency in order to buy this are in certain denominations and so and you can't break them down and make change or anything like that so you might only have some sort of high value cards left in your hand and you might want to bid on this card but you don't want to bid quite that much so i've only got a 20 but i don't i can't break this 20 down into fives you know but i only want to
bid you know seven or eight do i bid my 20 and lose my 20 or do i forgo the card and hold on to it that's the key decision in the game it's got a really nice twist at the end where the player you know even if they've got the most points if you've got the least money you can't win so so you've got to have a decent amount of money left over at the end so you can't go way ahead and spend far more than everybody else it's it's just a selection of really clever simple mechanisms that creates a whole load of tension and the production of the most recent version from osprey games is absolutely gorgeous osprey games i can't unders i don't understand how they managed to make these games so affordable their games are always cheap but with the most lavish production most care and attention and love put into them so high society extremely highly recommended this is an absolute classic card game now we're at the top rung here aren't we in our top 20 games my top 20 games that i've ever played and um we're now at number 18 and i can't separate this from high society high society and for sale for me sit very closely together totally different designers i think for sale is by stefan dora um but a similar sort of feel an auction game this is a game in two halves so the first half of the game we are we've got a bunch of properties that are laid out on the table with different values on them um and we're spending money uh in an auction in order to take these properties we collect up our properties and then in the second half of the game we're going to sell these properties
so essentially we're using the value of the property in a different type of auction in order to gain these checks that are worth money and at the end of the game we want to have the most money so so we're using money to buy properties and then we're using those properties selling those properties for more money and then seeing who's got the most at the very end so two sort of different halves you almost don't need to know the rules for the second half when you play in the first half you know but the two things do really impact the first half really does impact on that second half um both halves are equally fun and equally simple it's a game that works really well with three players four players five players or six players uh in a relatively small package um like high society i would say this is an absolute classic card game number 17 is the game barron park which is another game by phil walker harding we've had a couple of those on the list already um this is a polyamino game a tetris style game i remember at the time when baron park came out there weren't that many of these around and patchwork was the the real poster child for this style of game but patchwork was only for two players where baron park you can play with up to four it's a really satisfying game it's simpler than patchwork essentially you just place a tile and sometimes you'll cover a a particular icon which will uh get you another tile and then you place that tile and so on and you're trying to fill up your your boards um but each tile that you place will have points on it and you obviously want to get to the high scoring points before the other players so it's a bit of a race to get to those points
there are also if you play the advance rules which i would always recommend that you do there are certain objectives that you might want to achieve different sets that you want to achieve the expansion is fantastic bad news bears this one really raised the game um for me baron park was a game i could kind of take or leave it was so simple i i could kind of ignore it although i enjoyed it but once we brought in this expansion with monorails and um and and these big sort of grizzly areas that are really hard to place and you know it just made it a much more um complex game to get your head around not complex in terms of rules still very simple but but the decisions that you had to make became so much more difficult and suddenly i found this game a real challenge and i enjoyed that it became much more crunchy and became actually one of my favorite games so barron park um beautiful artwork really really cute from lookout uh lookout games um yeah it's it's uh it's been a bit of a slow burner i think but but i think now it's it's starting to be recognized as the classic that it is number 16 is double double is uh like yogi i fee i see these in in similar sort of regard okay double is just a clever idea one idea uh and and so beautifully done but you just you're looking at the cards any two cards will always have one thing that matches on the two cards i don't even know mathematically how that's possible but it is and when you play double with someone for the first time inevitably somebody you'll sit there and
you won't be able to see which two things are matching and somebody will go well this one it's it's obviously a flaw in the game you know they've they haven't they've messed it up there isn't something that matches on here and i always have to say no there definitely will be just keep looking at it and eventually you'll see it and there always is of course there is um loads of different versions of dobble are available i have the harry potter double and i think i've got a hollywood double but there's loads of different versions that you can get straight up double this fun you can buy this in supermarkets everywhere in the uk at least it's i think it's the the best selling card game of the last few years um so it's really gone mainstream this was originally a blue orange game but they sold it to azmoday a few years ago um i remember when i pitched a big bazaar to blue orange at the time they still had dobble and they were really telling me how double you know double's been this massive seller sold millions of copies and all this sort of thing how amazingly they're done and big bizarre is a speed game um in a similar sort of vein you know you're looking you're looking for patterns and trying to match things up and so on and and doing so at speed so yeah great game double just a brilliant idea brilliantly executed really simple great for children absolutely great for children and families number 15 on my list is quacks of quedlenberg which has been an enormous hit the last couple of years this is by wolfgang voorsch from smithspieler in the u.s it's from northstar games and that collaboration of those different companies i mentioned this previously with the games taverns and tiffantal
that artist dennis lowhausen this is uh it's just a great uh coming together to create this this this beautiful product kratz of quentin berg is a push your luck game um where you are it's it's a bag building game similar to a deck building game where you're you're buying different um ingredients for a potion they all go into your bag and then when it's your turn you're pulling them out and you've got to decide when am i going to stop because if you pull too many white ingredients out then your pot is going to explode and you're not going to get as good rewards you'll still get something that's quite nice in this game you still get something but you're not going to do as well as the other players so pulling stuff out the bag when do i stop am i going to go bust that's the key thing in the game and then the rewards that you get allow you to buy better ingredients to go into that bag and so then you're going to be pulling stuff out again but now you're getting better so each round in the game you're going to do better and better and i love that feeling of building an engine and improving throughout the game the other nice thing in this game is that you change up the rules every time you play you know the ingredients uh you've got the same tokens but they mean different things depending on the cards that you've got laid out on the table so every game you're you're working with a slightly different set and particularly once you bring in the expansion and the herb which is and i believe there's another expansion that's that's come out recently in germany and will be out in english soon um it's it's just a brilliant game i've played this a lot with my wife it's one of her favorites and so uh that's where it really connects with me um but it's connecting with a lot of people
isn't it this is a mega hit number 14 when i'm looking at my list and seeing what these numbers are now i'm getting excited because every one of these i want to go yes this is one of my favorite games and of course it is because it's number 14. this is cockroach poker where's cockroach poker here i've also got cockroach poker royal up there this is a game where you just get to lie that's all it is lying so i pass a card to you and i say it's a spider and you have to decide whether you think it is a spider or whether you think it's not a spider and so you might say i don't think it is a spider you turn it over if if you were wrong and it was a spider then you're going to take that card and put it down in front of you that's bad you don't want these cards in front of you if you say it's not a spider we flip it over and it wasn't a spider it was a grasshopper then it sits in front of me i don't want a grasshopper in front of me okay so lying is risky but telling the truth that's risky too because if they call you out and say yes i think you're telling the truth then you might have to take it so either way you're taking a risk whether you lie or whether you tell the truth or the player can say i don't want to make a decision on that and instead pass it on and it continues round the table with the other players having to make a decision such a simple rule set and so much fun just looking somebody in the eye and telling them a lie it's fun playing this with people who are really close to each other um because they they feel like they should be able to know whether somebody is lying or not so playing it with your wife or um one of my favorite games of this was playing it with a friend of mine and her children and specifically her daughter was playing it and right at the start of the game every time her daughter lied
she would giggle and it was so obvious that she she was lying to her mum and it you know she was losing every time and playing like this but by by a few you know a few turns in suddenly she was able to keep a straight face when she was lying to her mum and she got really good at it and you just the realization i've basically introduced this child to a game which teaches them to lie to their parents with a straight face and then walking away and leaving her mum to deal with this uh this new ability for her child um it's it's just so comical the whole thing i love this this ugly bugs sort of art style you can see i've got a bunch of these around here cackalack and salad cackalack and dance and this 20 and and so on um really good sort of range of games but cockroach poker is is the pinnacle of those games um by a brilliant designer jacques seimet i'm so impressed by everything that he produces so uh there we go cockroach poker one of my favorite games number 14.
number 13 on the list is dixit which is one of the most creative games on the list i mean we've previously talked about serrano that's probably the most creative the one where you have to write a bunch of poetry as a party game but here's another party game here we're looking at a bunch of beautiful images and you have to give this image uh or one of the images from your hand you have to give it a title and then everybody else has to use that title and select a card from their own hand which they could give that title to as well the cards are all shuffled up and laid out and then everybody has to use voting tokens to decide which one they think was my card the one that originally had that title and you want you don't want everyone to get it right you want some of the group to get it right and some to get it wrong and that's the genius of the game because you can't be too obvious if you've got a card that's got a whopping great elephant on it you can't give it the title big elephant because everybody's gonna know the answer and you're gonna get no points you need some people to get it right and some people not to so you're gonna have to give it some sort of obscure clue that you think might work for some members of the group and not for others that's where the creativity comes in i mean the most wonderful thing about the game is the amazing artwork and there's been numerous numerous different expansion sets for it which just have more and more cards with this lovely surreal artwork on from all sorts of different artists it's just one of the most beautiful games that i own but the gameplay is really good as well it's a great party game works well for kids and families works well for groups of adults works well for people who don't play many board games
um yeah just a just a great party game dixit number 12 on my list is dominant species now this is the heaviest game on my list it's probably the heaviest game heaviest strategy game that i own this is really quite complex it's a long game it can take two you know probably three hours or so to play um it's a worker placement game with a lot of area majority in it so it's got a nature theme you're sort of populating the planet with different species you control one particular uh type of animal whether that's birds or mammals or or reptiles or amphibious creatures or whatever and you're trying to get onto those various the the appropriate type of terrain that works for you with the appropriate sort of food source and the other players can manipulate that there's an ice age that comes in and starts to kill things off um but you want to be the best adapted to survive in these different territories these different terrain types um it's a cutthroat game as you'd expect in a game all about nature and and survival of the fittest um it it's it's got a lot of depth it's quite unforgiving if you're good at it then you're gonna race ahead and the other players are going to fall way behind it's thankfully it's not that difficult to learn okay the rule sets pretty um you know logical you follow logical sort of processes particularly if you're familiar with other worker placement games but games based around nature and ecosystems and and the interactions
in nature they really intrigue me there aren't that many of them around um but but this is one of the best this is a really good sort of simulation of of the way nature works um and and creatures sort of dominate in certain types of terrain and environments um so complex game heavy game but if you're looking for something a little bit more challenging than most of the things on this list then dominant species is the one to go for and number 11 on the list is harband goot habengut is my favorite stock market game that's all it is you're buying up shares and then you're you're selling them off and you're trying to sell them off for a profit the great thing in harban good is that you have information about the market you've got some cards to the left of you and the cards to the right of you and these cards will say that certain stocks are going to go up and certain stocks are going to go down and on your turn you select one card from the right and one card from the left and one of them you're gonna play at full power so if it says plus four you play it at plus four another card you're going to play at half power so if it says minus two you might play as minus one and so these stocks are going to um fluctuate uh as as as the game goes on and you're going to be buying more stocks and selling stocks off when you think they've hit a particular peak but the nice thing is you've got a good amount of information about what's going to happen but i can't see what's going on at the other side of the table so the player to the left of me yeah they've got some of the shared information with me because one of the one of the selections of cards is between us but they've also got another selection of cards between them and another player which i can't see
um there's a great mechanism in it where you have to give money to charity um and uh but but you don't you don't declare how much you're giving to charity and at the very end of the game uh if you've given the least money to charity you're eliminated from the game it doesn't matter whether you've won or not you're eliminated from the game you don't count for scoring and then ultimately the player with the most money at the end of the game wins and that's those two really nice mechanisms the shared information and that thing if i've got to give some to charity but i don't want to give too much or i won't have any money left at the end but if i don't give enough then i might be eliminated it just mixes together into a simple but really exciting really tense game this one's been out of print for a long time it only ever got a german release um which is a shame it's by carlo rossi who also made leglose which is a game that i i've talked about previously totally different style of gamer party game i believe habengud might be coming back in 2021 um from aries games i think they've got the rights to it they released a game a couple of years ago called divinity derby by the same designer which was a race game that used very similar mechanisms it was all right it was okay but it didn't sit there hit the same heights as hard and good for me looks much more boring than it is it would be nice to see it with a much more modern sort of approach to the art style and things like that there was a game a few years ago called stockpile that looked so much more inviting and i think carbon goot is a better game than stockpile um but
it could do with a a graphics sort of overhaul to to just to show how exciting it it really is um yeah one of the best games around haben good i've never regretted sort of searching out a german copy of this completely language independent so you can play this with a printout of english rules off the internet and you don't need to adjust the components or cards in any way so let's see what that's done to the list so what we had before between 21 and 100 zak verlag were out ahead of the publishers with rio grande and hans and gluck close behind and then a bit of a gap for matagot smithspeeler games workshop and lookout so can zok verlag hang on to that lead let's have a look yes they're still out ahead with six still rio grande with five and handsome glock with five then schmidt spieler and look out on four so that gap is closing a little bit as we get down towards the finish uh looking at designers we previously had ryan knitting wolfgang crammer ahead on four but again still a close run thing and now reiner kinetico is out ahead on five on his own out on five with wolfgang kramer and phil walker hiding on four andreas seafarth michael kiesling on three a piece so it still could go either way uh when we move on to that final ten in the next video looking at themes fantasy there were 10 games with fantasy in the first 80 games that we looked at in ancient world and anthropomorphic animals following up so moving on to today 10 games of
fantasy still ancient world on seven anthropomorphic animals on seven and for the first time if we add together the anthropomorphic animals and regular animals we're now beating the fantasy so so we would have 13. although i'm keeping them apart because i consider them separate things games about animals doing human-like things and games about animals just being animals moving on to game style then so previously tyler laying was way out ahead with 11. what seems to be an unsurmountable lead uh seven for time pressure and area majority so is that still the case is tyler laying still out ahead yes it is now is 13 games with tyler laying uh in those first 90 games we've looked at and then time pressure area majority and party games are following with network building stock holding an engine building behind so that takes us to number 11 which means we've only got the top 10 to go so we'll be covering that in our next video tomorrow so thanks very much for watching i'll see you then