Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Broken Meeple Show - Don't You Want Innovation? - Episode 38

Transcript 49:40

you're listening to the broken meeple show a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them my name's luke hector best known for the broken meeple youtube channel and i'm an everyday gamer just like you and i'll be talking about reviews top 10s and just about anything that connects me to board games as long as i have a tea or coffee in hand that is so grab a cup relax and enjoy and remember it's only a game hello everyone this is luke hector on the 20th of november 2021 for another podcast episode yes i'm recording this slightly earlier than before i'll still air it on sunday but i've just literally got back from a convention called marycon and i figured you know what i've got a couple of hours to kill before bed i figured i would just get it done and dusted now so i could get tomorrow free because let's face it gridcon is next week and i need to not only prepare for work monday and tuesday now but i need to figure out what games i'm taking i need to book some time slots for certain games i need to you know make certain my hotel sorted i need to learn uh how to play arc nova and weather machine before i go there i also need to know how to play well sorry i know i need to create a deck for arkham horror lcg to play the multiplayer blobby evening game and i still need to create the deck oh yeah i got a lot to uh do so i figured just to kill time it was easier to record the podcast tonight and i figured i'd do it

all right so what have i been doing well i mean health wise pretty good work is stressing me out like crazy but that's just normal but blog wise not too bad i've had an attack from a few trolls lately i think on some of the comments but uh you know not not too bad you know there was a little bit of a a few more lately than there should be but as i say you know you can't please everybody it seems you know opinions they're dangerous to some people but otherwise not pretty good i mean the blog has i certainly say you know as a big milestone past 15 000 subscribers which was a big you know big deal for me to get to a 15 000 mark onward to 20 000 i think but thank you for everybody who supports this show who watches it who gives me nice comments who says hi to me at conventions you know who basically gives me the confidence to actually keep this going because it's like i say with a day job as a tax accountant it's a slog but you know the blog wouldn't be possible without all of you including the loyal patreons as well if you want to support the channel a bit further then by all means check out patreon.com and search for the broken meeple and you'll find out more details there but yeah fifteen thousand and forty subscribers as i record this podcast so let's march on the twenty thousand shall we could blimey and i think i'd ever get that high i didn't even think i'd get to 15 000 granted it's taken me about three times longer and in some of the trending channels to get to this level but like i say opinionated it's it's dangerous to people therefore it takes a while to build this stuff up but yeah otherwise

what have i been doing well i've just been to a convention called mary actually should i yeah i'll do that first i'll cover the next bit in the news but i was at a place called merry con and this is nothing major it's a small convention very small uh like one day literally just this morning until this evening and it's you know it's just run by basically neil and abby a couple of you know a couple of people i know from various clubs and that very nice people little family thing and they just basically hired out a village hall and invite people for games basic tables free tea and coffee you know cheap entry and you just have fun you know and they bring his library along which is to be fair a pretty diverse collection of board games i will say but i've just basically been there with a couple of friends from southampton so if you know farnam if you're anywhere near farm and farnham in the uk then you know you'll know more about that it's close to guildford way and yeah you know i had a good bit of fun you know just basically me and two other mates are new from the southampton group we played well what do we play we played terraforming mars which yeah i know you're probably thinking luke terraforming mars you normally hate that game now i do not hate terraforming mars okay i find it average you know i find it average yeah look five out of ten i think it's average you know granted i used to hate it now i've kind of warmed up to it a bit but it is based on the fact that i think prelude is like one of the best expansions that was ever made for a game and there was three of us we'd prelude yes they threw in venus in colonies

anyway but like say venus makes no difference to the game it's a redundant expansion by this point and colonies i would rather have not played with colonies because colonies basically offsets the reduction in play time that prelude has but these two knew how to play the game they play it nearly every monday and i figured why not i know what i'm doing so i just went straight into it and that was fine but yeah we had a bit of fun with this one i played a corporation called lakefront i believe which basically was very good with oceans and in my first hand i got a card that let me put out oceans for cheap so i basically spammed the board with a ton of oceans and ended up creating basically a giant seaside resort it was pretty good fun unfortunately i was pipped at the post at the very end because unfortunately what i was doing which involved getting a lot of points for what was on the map and what was happening during the game and terraform rating didn't make up for the fact that none of the milestones and awards had anything to do with what i was doing so i didn't claim any of them but i did very well with cities being next to a bunch of trees i was only lost by a couple of points though so for someone who didn't get any milestones or any awards to lose my only two points i thought was pretty good going but yeah it still took too long for what i thought it would like to do but i had fun it was good and you know like i say terraforming is not a horrible game for me people it's just i have to play it with a certain group really as say it must have prelude and we go even more further with prelude i mean it's not just like what the rule book says they we basically have four prelude cards as normal but we get to choose one out of five corporations so

we really get to see all the different corpse and it was about high time i played somebody who wasn't from the base game but like i say good fun and also we kept it free players that's the thing free players max for this game and it will be reasonably enjoyable i'd just probably rather play it on online or something just to cut out some of the admin uh we also played glass road uh yes this is i don't want to give away too much here but this is one that uh now ignore this rating of a six okay this 6 rating is what i gave the game back in 2014 in june when i first really played the game that's a long time ago this was like when i first started maybe a year or two into board gaming like majorly blogging and stuff that's what i gave it all that time ago i have the reprint and i'm playing it now more detail more player counts and i'm giving it its fair shot and not to give away too much but suffice to say i'm enjoying it more than i did before it definitely has a different experience of different player accounts and i have played it through solo so you will be getting a review for this quite soon because i did a poll for games i had recently what people wanted to know about and people really wanted to know about seven wonders architects so i did that one first mobile markets well i needed to catch up some arcane wonder stuff so i did that but people really want to know about glass road so i will be doing that and then afterwards probably cascadia and not that many people are interested in the loop but like i say the loop will be coming soon to be honest i've got a lot of games ready for review at the moment i just need time to record them and that's not

helped by the fact that i got grid con this week so i'm tomorrow monday gonna have to try and crank out as much recording time as possible to get them recorded and hopefully edit a couple of reviews so that i can issue them during gridcom i'll do my best no promises but hopefully you can give me a break if need be but yeah we played glass road and this is an uri rosenberg if you don't know what glass road is from a wall back this is an early rosenberg game where you well let me guess you're farming in a sense you're building up your like forests and mines and ponds and that and you're using them to get resources which are measured out on this really cool clever rondelle wheel thing whereby as you level up the different resources automatically generates glass and bricks you use these to get buildings and get victory points and not that many victory points i mean scores tend to be somewhere between 15 to 25 you every point counts in this game but the cool thing with this is well cool ish i'll talk about this more in a review but the card system where you have to play a certain number of cards in a round and if you manage to play it and no one else does you get both actions and if you play it when someone else also has it you only get one that's the very basic version of how the rules work there's a bit more to it than that but that frustrated me a lot a long time ago when i played this game like oh my god i can't get to do anything because it always duplicates somebody it does taper quite a bit when you go from three to four players and i think that's something i'm gonna have to reflect in the review there's definitely a drop when it gets to the latter player

count but i enjoyed this at three players and i think it's even better with two and solo so like i say there is hope for this game yet but i had a good time with them i was teaching two new players and it took them a while to get used to the system but we had fun and i won with a giant food factory and then what else did we play we played a grickler and again you're thinking luke you hate agricola but well i don't hate it i think it's average above average even you know it's it's it's a theme i like and i just i just think cabernet and fields have all completely destroyed this game for me but here's the thing we're playing this with farmers of the moor this is an expansion for the game that basically means you now have to heat your home gives you a couple of sort of bonus actions that you can do during the game uh gives you horses of your extra cards and stuff like that so it doesn't really change up like what you're doing in the game that much it just gives you a couple more options and means that you've got more to worry about i guess you know heating your home as well but the cool thing with this people have been telling me for ages this improves the game luke try it with farmers in the more it makes a difference and i gotta say it does you start off with some forests and some peat mores and stuff and you can basically like chop those down to get some wood or to get some fuel to use for heating your home but there's also ways to kind of get food a little bit with it as well there's another animal or the horse that isn't capped for points and as it felt like it made things slightly easier to get stuff done like it almost makes the game

less punishing overall even though it's still restrictive now it definitely went on too long for what it was even with three of us like i say i'm by the end i'm like okay seriously i'm using the guy to just grab a random vegetable can we just like finish this now and certainly it's a bit of a mission before the game even starts to draft from 10 occupations and 10 ten minor minor improvements you know it just the game is too long for what it is but i still enjoyed it overall you know i almost won i think i was only three points off winning and i only basically had a tiny bit of everything on my map but i was able to renovate very quickly i had a very good set of occupations and i was able to buy a lot of bonus point scoring cards which made up for the fact that i wasn't scoring a ton for what was on my board but you know just you know adding a few extra cards adding horses adding fuel for you know getting very you know fueling your home which i ended up using on a pete boat to get me various resources you know that's uh interesting i've got a picture here with these like little candy looking uh animals here which is like jumbo sized animals sheep cows and that that looks really cool but yeah the game was fine i just think kaverner is a better version of agriculture personally that's why i much prefer cavernous but this is still fine and i give it props it's just a bit restrictive for my liking fields of art still beats out coverna though you know i love love fields of r you only have to check out my top 100 to know more about that so what else have i played uh let's say i'm gonna spend more time on what i've

played because i don't have much in the way of news but i also have played diamonds so i've been taking a while to get to this i found it at essen when i bought aries expedition and you know my thoughts on eric's expedition but yeah seven out of ten i've given diamonds so far i want to play it some more but i was actually quite impressed with this you know it only cost me 10 euro and that's a pretty good bargain actually 10 euro for a game especially at essen second edition of diamonds as well but this is a very standard trick taking game you're trying to collect diamonds actual diamonds and they're worth points based on whether they're in your showroom or your vault basically behind a hidden screen and you play it very much like a standard trick taking game you have cards from 1 to 15 in the four different suits so no king queen nonsense and you basically play a standard trick taking game where you highest you know person plays a card follow the suit highest wins the suit but there's a little twist each of the suits has an action associated with it whoever wins the trick gets to do the action based on the suit that won the trick and then if you win no tricks you get to perform the best of the actions the diamond one twice which i was actually able to do once in the last game i played it was quite impressive but also the when you get to the end of the round you look at how many cards everybody has won and if they have the most of a particular suit they get to do the action of that suit as well so it's this little extra bit of meat added on to a standard trick-taking game and i found it quite fun maybe it's a little long for a trick-taking game it definitely

takes a bit longer to get through i've probably kept this at four players i think any higher is probably does it go up to six i think it goes up to five or six yeah this isn't a game i would want to play with six players really it says best four to five i think four is good five might just take it a little bit long but yeah i was impressed with this you know the components are pretty good you've got you know chris you know cleared red and there's a plastic diamond so it looks nice it's easy rules if you know anything about trick taking uh i think these cards would look more like the first edition that the second edition looks a bit nicer but yeah the actions are very straightforward i mean the heart puts a diamond into your showroom the diamond puts it straight into your vault the spade puts it from your showroom into your vault you know very simplistic stuff like that but it just made for a very interesting twist on trick taking and i'm certainly getting more into trick taking games as we go along but yeah for 10 euros this was an absolute bargain for a trick taking game so i'm going to hang on to this one in my collection as a nice uh kind of gateway game to teach people who have only really sort of played with a deck of cards in their lives but yeah i was impressed diamonds preferably the second edition if you can get hold of it but it's a solid game definitely worth a look if you're into that and then finally i want to give a little advanced heads up of mortem so i am not ready to review this game yet because i want to play through all three scenarios in it but mortem is a game from arcane wonders and it's basically a detective style game so imagine what the portal detective was like mortum is a medieval

detective so there's no app it's all done with cards so but you lay out a map with the cards and you have different decks for like certain actions that you do like search or raid or like surveillance and the the cool thing with this it's kind of like a cross between time stories and detective you don't have to do loops or anything that's nonsense but you know this one you're just basically playing a kind of not even a murder mystery you're playing through a story with a plot you know an overarching plot that borders three scenarios the first one is kind of semi introduction scenario but there's still a fair bit in it for an introduction scenario but obviously the second and the third are a bit more advanced like they will take the longest and i was like hmm okay this sounds quite cool but very few people knew anything about this game now don't worry i'm not going to spoil anything but i have played only the introduction scenario and there's actually no images for this game so i can't really show you much apart from the cover here but yeah this game is a very interesting game because in detective it's basically like you're using the app with the web browser and you're doing a modern like murder mystery type thing here there's a bit more going on than just a straight up murder but let me tell you about a couple of mechanical twists you choose from several characters that started a game and they give you tokens much like in detective the tokens allow you to do different things but rather than just simply be oh i can flip a card if i have this token what you can also do with some of them is perform one of three different actions search raid and

surveillance i think or something like that basically scout you know scout a location and with these characters as well as going through the cards and flipping them over and reading the story saying i want to go to the stables and find out and talk to this person you can do those special actions and on the time track which monitors how long you've got before the scenario ends you place a token that shows at this particular time say three hours from now you are going to resolve this particular action you did like i want to search the ruins i want to raid the uh the farmhouse and when that time comes up three separate decks are already pre-set up with the cards that are in this pretty sizable box you know it's pretty sizable box for each scenario and the decks correspond to those actions so if you decided to raid the farmhouse when the time is up you go into the farmhouse sorry you go into the raid deck and you basically find the location number for where you want to raid 9 and it will give you the story excerpt for what happens as a result of doing that action at that location sometimes there's red herrings but other times it reveals something pretty neat and i think that's a really cool little twist it's different from the other games like detective in that so this one can stand on its own as something unique but familiar so a unique mechanism but with familiar storytelling and you know that kind of thing and so it means that replay values a little bit better here now granted you're gonna know the plot so certainly from the introduction scenario

i doubt you would play this through more than twice you know just to see what some of the other actions would do but and even then you would probably want to leave a bit of a gap between your first playthrough and your second playthrough so that you forget the plot but still i enjoyed my time with it it took me about what 90 minutes i think to get through the first scenario so low and that was on the basis of maybe 90 minutes or two hours probably 90 minutes but then that was solo and you know i was like getting into the story and i was trying to do a little bit of everything but the game is solid the next two scenarios are going to be bigger there's a lot more cards in the second and third scenario so i'm expecting them to take me a good two to three hours and it'll certainly take most people in groups like that and yeah and the one other good thing is that it you can learn the game from the deck there is no rule book in the box no rule book at all you literally open up the first box of cards and follow instructions that teaches you the game and apart from much i don't know for the most part there wasn't much in the way of ambiguity maybe one or two minor points but for the most part you were able to get in it and just straight up get into it without having to read rules in advance kudos that's really cool because even detective has a small rule book this one no rule book at all you just literally set up and say right let's play brilliant like that system i want to see that in more of these story games a slight negative i would have though is that the back says one to six players i can't imagine how high you would have to be to play this with more than two frankly because um well certainly from the introduction scenario there's not a lot for more than

two people to really do in this game apart from discuss stuff three and four i don't think would you know be able to utilize the time like that and five and six would just be completely pointless you don't even use that many characters so you wouldn't even have a character per person and even then it's mainly just for the tokens it's not like a specific character is needed for plot purposes so honestly this is basically a solo and two player game but as i say first impressions very good so i look forward to playing through the second and third scenario i don't know when i'll get around to it though this might be a bit of a late review but i will be reviewing it so you'll have to wait and say okie doke right let's get on to quickly to a bit of news now uh first of all i want to just talk quickly on my channel uh just to mention an upcoming video collaboration i'm doing with zatu so yes zatu and i have been kind of like collaborating for a bit and we did a discount code for a while now we can't really resume the discount code because the problem is people get copying it and putting it on websites and that didn't help at all so we had to discontinue it but we are going to do collaboration videos from time to time and the idea is is that on probably next week next week december probably something like uh friday no not next week um gridcon sorry about friday the 3rd of december is what i'm aiming for but basically around that time there's going to be a video top five list that i'm doing for stocking stuffers obviously we're preparing for christmas and i was going to do a stocking stuffer's top 10 anyway but this gives me the opportunity to kill two birds with one stone but you're thinking well okay it's the top five that's what it doesn't matter well firstly this is a top five list with me

and zatu game input so some of the staff at zatu and myself have collaborated on these five games but i'm also going to suggest alternatives to the five that i'm going to do the list on again what's the difference here the difference is that we're doing a giveaway i haven't done any giveaways before at least i don't think i have but no we are doing giveaways and this might be a thing in the future where i'll be able to you know you'll be able to request a game for me to review i could maybe get it off them and then we could do a giveaway for said game you know i'm trying to discuss this kind of stuff with them but there will be a giveaway the idea being that every single game i mentioned on the top five as well as some extra accessories will be doing a giveaway and it will be worldwide so regardless of where you live in the world zatu will ship it to you so you know and it won't involve like need to know any particular knowledge or anything it'll be one of those standard kind of like you know like comment subscribe and fill out a form which is literally just your name and address name and email address so that they can pick you out of a hat basically it's just going to be like a random draw but i will go through all the details instead video it will be pre-recorded it won't be live and it will air somewhere around the end of the week ending something like third of december friday kind of time and uh what about that time no wait a minute yeah it will be well whatever it'll be around that time and you'll have about a week while the video's up to get your entries in and then they'll decide on the winner are about like the 10th or 11th or so but yeah just a heads up keep an eye out for that top five stocking stuffers video in collaboration with zatu.codyk there will be a giveaway it

will be worldwide and there's some good games on that list so definitely worth checking that out okay now the one bit of news that is going to make me go on a bit of a rant here only one bit of news and unfortunately it seems to be taking facebook by storm at the moment cool many or not uh making a big deal about this 50th like anniversary uh what 50th kickstarter that they're doing and they're learning to go all out for it and they have basically teased by way of basically bribing other reviewers it seems like with this giant two-foot statue oh a miniature two-foot statue basically of galactus zombie yeah they are basically teasing the fact that they are going to be doing something along the lines of marvel zombicide now i love marvel i love marvel loads i've not really done much with the zombie saga of marvel apart from the what if episode which was a good episode but not one of the best of the series i gotta say but honestly this feels like the biggest cash grab ever i mean for crying out loud you do not need this two-foot thing i mean they did it with like cthulhu death may die i think had a similar deal with the cthulhu statue and it's like seriously you just don't this is ridiculous really ridiculous you know miniature is going out of control but all i am seeing on on facebook and that now is pictures of quackle open various other like well mainly quackalope actually and you know with like a little creators with this

giant statue going not saying but i go get this game oh my god they're going to do this they're going to do marvel's upper side oh my god yay i mean called blimey kudos to cool money or not they know their strategies well but this is such a sales tactic you know it's like right let's give the kickstarter previewers who basically never say anything good or bad about a game they just basically get the hype going and given this giant two-foot statue and basically do you think any of them are going to say a bad thing about the game when you are given a two-foot statue of zombie galactus i don't think so but the hype that this is generating now is ridiculous zombicide is not even that fun a game it's okay but that system is old and busted now the original zombicide i would not play anymore it had some stupid rules they had to bring out a whole new edition to correct then black plague was out and black played's okay but even that has some stupid dumb rules like the splitting rule and various other things like that it's okay but again you gotta play it with the full six players it takes too long you know it just wasn't really for me and then they've just basically recycled the whole cash cow with invader and all that lot so now oh look another zombicide game just using marble zombies now i will stay you know as much as i have an opinion strong opinion if this turns out to be amazing like if i get a chance to try the game and i think it's amazing and it completely does something unique with the system and it doesn't just rehash it i will be more than happy to eat my words as well

as that plushie um dice panda thing that i have or sorry i'll be happy to eat that on screen if this turns out to be a game i go oh my god this is amazing or something you know so i am more than happy to be proven wrong here but this whole thing with these giant statues i mean could they have not just given a copy of the game and had some people preview it even prototype no it had to be done with this two-foot statue and it's just come on and interestingly i think i've heard that uh the dice tower have a copy of this game but they weren't given the two the statue so mainly the kickstarter preview channels were being given this and it's like hmm so hang on the ones that don't say negative stuff about kickstarters will be given this giant statue but tom who can do negative reviews is given is not given statute hmm that just seems like a little bit of a coincidence maybe i'm wrong maybe my facts aren't quite correct there but as they i'm honestly i am not hyped about this at all i mean call me or not i'm not taking any more money from me with their kickstarters because it's just minis minis minis oh look here's more minis this game is too expensive go over it i mean i still regret rising sun all right i love the game it's in my other room but man i shouldn't have spent as much money as i did on it really i did not need to spend all that that was the last time they ever took money off me in a kickstarter you know i had no interest in ankh and the merge rule was sounds like garbage from what i've researched on it and i had no interest in marvel united i mean what a game that's practically for families and kids that cost you several hundred dollars to get the stupid amount

of miniatures uh yeah yeah yeah and now this is going to be the same i mean i'm predicting obscenely high pledge levels big statue and minis that aren't necessary stretch goals are plenty like you'll it'll basically be oh you don't get that much at the start but look stretch goals stretch goals stretch goals look at all this extra stuff they're giving us which they've already made and already factored in they just know it's going to generate millions of dollars and therefore they've already factored that in it's it's i mean it's give credit they know what they're doing i can't fault their business strategy i am an accountant i have to do business stuff it's solid it's a solid strategy i just wish it didn't work so well you know but all i'm saying is like i say temper your expectations people this could be really good and if it is great let it be great you know marvel was found marvel's such a lovely like lovely there's a bible such a cool series the zombie saga of it i'd say is intriguing i mean i enjoyed the what if episode on it and the new tv series that they're gonna bring out marvel zombies marvel zombies will obviously pique my interest but i'm not using that alone you can't buy me with marvel and you certainly can't buy me with a two-foot statue so we'll see how this pans out but like i say it's the hotness news at the moment so i couldn't not talk about it but that's just my thoughts on it not gonna get hyped about it i find it too much of a cash grab but maybe it could be good prove me wrong you know by all means try and

prove me wrong i'll gladly accept defeat if that's the case so uh that's it for news right let's talk briefly on the topic of the day you know this is incredibly shortish episode but drink my lovely chamomile tea first lovely lovely lovely right so topic of the day is based on something i saw on facebook and this one is an interesting topic because if you know me when it comes to games i like i am very much into the idea of having like big like changes innovation you know unique twists and games so for example you know i played runestones and i go on a lot about that and it was like okay this is a deck builder it doesn't seem too much like every other thing but then you've got the twist of how the cards work where you play two cards you do both abilities and then when the one with the higher value goes into your um disc sorry the one with the lower value goes into your discard pile the one with the higher value is trashed out of the game unique innovative twist okay and then i go on about games like whistle mountain and it's you know you turn engine together to get victory points that doesn't sound too different but the idea that the worker placements fight the worker placement aspect of the board is built up by the players so the players are building the board that you're doing the worker placement on your airships go in between all the scaffoldings to get resources as well as

go on the machines which can create all sorts of combos again different little twists on a cool thing but then we've even got stuff like the crew the crew again standard trick taking game but with and i'm giving a rating for mission deepsea i need to play a bit more of that but you know the idea of a trick taking game but co-op interesting i mean we have co-op games and we have trick taking games but the idea of mashing them together uh very unique very different very innovative and lo and behold it's one of the most popular trick taking games out there like probably the most popular trick taking game in recent years a really solid game and definitely one you should consider so what am i getting at here well basically the conversation was that somebody asked what do you prefer when it comes to games new right when when new games get released do you want to see new ideas innovation different things that you've not seen before but obviously that carries a risk of the game being bad or a higher risk of the game being bad or do you prefer to have games come out that use stuff you've seen before that you already know you enjoy so basically it's an argument between do you want innovation or not now you know me i am hard on the previous one so or the previous option full innovation you know because the problem is i am playing games where it's just too much the same and that is what i'm finding with 2021 it is too too much of the same a lot of stuff is rehashing old ideas and it's not like nothing is

really standing out which is a problem you know i mean there have been some good stuff imperium took a deck building concept but added some interesting twists to it made it thematic for a deck builder which is pretty good going again different twist on a thing you've already seen but then for example i've also played games like boon lake here which is you know for the most part a decent game i gave it a 7 out of 10 i think on my recent review but there is no unique bone in this body i mean everything is rehashed from something else half the game is his previous design maracaibo another part is puerto rico and there's a little bit of terra bistica in there nothing in this game is really that unique so yes i enjoy it it's got enough to stand on its own two legs but i play it and then i go yeah this is cool but how long before i forget it and just decide you know what why don't i just play some of the original ones or maybe like i get bored with it anyway so i i kind of like wanted this to give me a little bit more but then all the other games i've been playing this year like a lot of the big heavy euros that just seem to be repeating the same thing terraforming mars eric's expedition for example this one is pretty much just you know taking race for the galaxy and putting the air and terraforming mars theme on it nothing really new in the game it's just taking an aspect of terraforming mars mixing it with some race for the galaxy put the two together and see what happens and what did i get an average game no nothing new to sort of blow me away or anything so i definitely support the fact that i want more innovation in games now yes

there is a higher risk that these games could be worse like either you might try two ideas and it really doesn't work well like it turns out to be a really bad experience but then at least they're trying something new and that's what i want i want new ideas i want people to challenge themselves with board game design and publishers to really sort of push the envelope with stuff you know throw in some interesting twists to it i just mentioned mortem earlier and as i okay we've had this kind of a detective story based game before but then i mentioned the idea of the search and the raid and the surveillance decks in there that is different to what is in other games it kind of makes it a bit more choose-your-own-inventory-like again something a little different but most of the games that i really really love tend to take stuff that's familiar but combine them in such a way that it does feel different or just try something really completely different i mean for example like uh you know spirit island game i really love not a lot of games you could really compare spirit island to when you think about it i mean it is an awesome game it is a co-op it's one of the most thematic euro puzzle style games i've ever seen because you're not rolling dice or anything in it you are doing euro-based mechanics of right okay the invaders are going to like invade your lands and they're going to pop up explorers here based on these cards based and build towns based on where these are build cities based on where those towns you know to harm will act in a certain way

combat is deterministic you're drawing cards you're using your spirit's abilities you know to deal like damage back to them there's a lot of cool stuff you do in this game but i have never played a more thematic euro style game in my life this thing is just amazing and it feels different it feels truly unique to anything else that's in my collection so when you find the same stuff all the time i can't help but just kind of go ah you know and when i read the facebook thread there was definitely a lot of feedback kind of going both ways you know i thought there'd be more of a skew towards you know innovation i would have hoped but no it seemed to be more kind of 50 50. there's some people who just want to get a game that's like all right this is new but at least i already know i like this kind of thing so i know i should like this game that's fine but then that feels a little bit like cult of the new to me i mean like people just going mad on the new hotness as it comes out why go for the new stuff when the old one does it fine now sometimes a new game comes out that does replace an old one small islands for example uh that one replaced carcassonne for me the you know the it's a similar deal you're building the tile map but then you've got objectives for each round it's a communal map you're also like trying to collect symbols now it feels different to a lot of other tile lane games and again it just stands out that little bit more but not to a great deal extent i mean it's not the most innovative design in the world but like i say occasionally

you will get a game that just outright sort of replaces an old one that is starting to lose its edge but how many like patchwork style games have we seen you know when rosenberg started going mad with the polyamino stuff can you tell the difference between most of his like tile lane games patchwork to uh was it college garden to indian summer or whatever it was and uh what was the very average one or the new york zoo or something is that you compare those games there's barely a unique twist between them all it's the same shtick even it's farming games i mean i like farming games i like fields of island converter like i mentioned but noosefield helato man this guy can't like think up something original now it's like the same shtick every time right down to feeding your people come on you know we know it worked before but i have converter and fields of all let's see you take the farming theme and really do something different with it or maybe try something different do a game that is outside your wheelhouse you know and i can't remember did you do a i can't help but think he did a game that wasn't to do with anything to do with animals or farming at one point uh well he's done some abstract games i think nova luna was something different for him and again like i said it's a different style of game so at least i was intrigued by it but as i look around my collection definitely some of my favorite ones do throw in a bit more of a shall we say twist i mean comparing stuff to cosmic encounter there's quite a lot of unique stuff there but pretty porter actually you can see it on my camera here that one okay economic game

that's heavy we know the deal get the most money and win but fashion industry that's a theme that has never been done before not properly i mean rokoku does not count because that is a driest bones euro but this one is a very familic heavy economic game about the fashion industry nothing's done that before again a different theme thematic unique gets my attention and it could have bombed it you know i mean it's not the most popular game portal i've ever put out but to me it resonated for others it might not have it could have bombed like crazy but at least they tried something like first martians for example taking the concept of robinson crusoe and throwing in a an app to assist while giving you that story based narrative a legacy style experience and keeping it quite serious now i like first martians it is still on my shelf it was just in my top 100 and i enjoy the game but i do recognize as flaws it had problems at launch though most of those bugs have been sorted but again the rule book was bad at launch and there were just certain things that maybe irked a few people now fair enough those are all legit points the game didn't do as well as they'd hoped it was an experiment it was something different i respect it for it but i can understand why i didn't do too well but at least they tried they tried something different but let's have a look at other stuff now i'm not counting abstracts because let's face it abstract games are kind of similar anyway but then

well actually on the subject of abstracts something that really gets my goat the whole thing of i want to see more innovative designs how many abstract games have we seen spin-offs from like oh god let's milk this cash game already and not even abstracts just general game series that just do not know when to stop pandemic now we've got a pandemic based on a random expansion of the world of warcraft series seriously can you not put this thing to bed right now you cash cow hungry people and then azul azul now has well i know flower garden or whatever it's called now i have no interest in even trying it because frankly the base is all is still my favorite of the lot all these spin-offs have always got problems associated with them but again it doesn't matter which one of them you pick up it's still basically a zool you know it's like right uh how much design time do we need to think up this new result well um let's just copy and paste 75 of this original game and let's find a way to tweet this other 25 it's like come on something different you can't just tweak a little seti brass is another example everybody keeps like trying to defend that brass birmingham and brass lancashire are completely different games no they are not they are pretty much the same game is the equivalent of having a ticket to ride map pack you just basically removed ports from one and changed it to beer in the other okay that's it you tweaked a couple of building types that's easy to do with an expansion you could literally have done it in the base game and just had multiple building types and you chose which one you had in each game it's not that different okay birmingham and luxury are pretty much the same game

i don't like one miles more than the other and certainly i don't particularly like either of them so it doesn't matter but i say again it just didn't feel like it was innovating brass it's like oh well let's just basically make the same game tweak a few things and it'll sell like hotcakes i don't want something unique let's try and find another unique game on my list uh well i mean stuff like even party games detective club for example well even the dixit card mechanic is actually a pretty unique and innovative system so yes that system has now been used multiple times but in different ways so you took the dixit party game you then made it into a one versus all team like co-op game okay that's pretty sweet you made mysterium which managed to do cluedo with them okay that's something a little bit different and now detective club one of my favorite party games combined it with the spy 4 sort of mechanic and created a unique game in its own right that's really really cool now okay you could milk that system for too much at some point and maybe i'm probably going to be in a little bit er well not eric's a little bit worried about dixit stellar because yes i'll probably enjoy it but is it going to be feel different enough maybe that doesn't have enough of a unique twist to it you know we'll see uh which i think uh let's see uh what have i got sleeping gods near and far i mean using a euro game combined with story based narratives i mean that's something a little different although we have seen that a little bit before but you know it can go to themes like coffee roaster coffee roaster trying to make a

coffee as your little puzzle with bag building not something you would have expected to see but you know pretty good all the same come on there's going to be another example uh awkward guests yeah using the card based system with trading information to do a cluedo style game definitely pretty unique already mentioned the crew taken with co-op very unique uh um let's see but then you can argue that you know some of the stuff even i like is a rehash of old stuff i mean well i don't know well some deck builders i mean there's not a huge amount of variety in some of the deck builders but then what are some of my favorite deck builders valley of the kings which has the like the crumbling pyramid system and the idea that you only score what you take out of your deck which is quite cool dale of merchants you don't discard cards you have to refill your hand when you buy a card it goes straight to your hand and you play with all these different animal things and it's a race to get to a certain point not victory points okay different enough of a deck builder what's the other deck builder i really like well i mentioned runestones already again the unique two-card system it's just what am i trying to get at here i definitely want to see publishers and designers push the envelope go for it give me something different yes you might crash and burn whatever still go for it because if it succeeds you might just start a revolution in gaming i mean the crew is like a

revolution in its own right a co-op trick taking game nobody would have ever considered such an idea and look how much of a success it is you can really hit home hard with a decent unique idea the problem is playing it safe is usually a bigger guarantee of getting your money in and they are businesses after all so they do need to make money it's a safer bet to rehash an old idea i mean let's face it what you think ea games does with pretty much 99 of its entire in fact no 100 of ea games as catalogue is just rehashes of the same thing even blizzard activision are just as bad with that sort of thing rehashing old stuff and making them worse you know computer game publishers are struggling to do anything unique and different these days but yeah that's just the way it is with them you know easy money but i want board games to be different i want to see new cool interesting ideas i want to play them and i want to be surprised by them when i play a game that just sounds like oh this is just going to remind me of this game or more of this then it doesn't get me anywhere near as excited because then i'll play it and go yeah that was cool it's great more it's good but it just can't quite reach distinction level until you give me a reason to distinguish yourself and actually be distinct from the uh the rest of the crowd but when you do give me something truly different it's definitely got a good chance to resonate with me hard and in a good way yes you might crash and burn that's the risk you take but at least

it'll be an interesting crash and burn you know it'll be a case of comparing oh your car turned around the corner and hit a curb wall will be most boring crash ever compared to say the crash car flip that james bond does in casino royale when he flips the car about like 50 times in the space of like a few seconds or whatever that crash is like one of the best car crashes i've ever seen on on film definitely different definitely like wow we had to really go to town with this and it paid off and it's one of my favorite scenes in the james bond movie ever compared to i drove around the corridor and like my bumper hit a curb wall the difference between the two excitement factor that's kind of what it is anyway i've probably raved on a bit too much on that like i say i was just kind of interested in that topic where do you stand i want to hear what you have to say in the comments you know do you think a game you know do you prefer it when you see the same kind of mechanics brought to your attention that you already know you like so it's a safe bet you'll like the game or do you want to see something new and different and unique and and you're not too worried about whether it's uh you know going to be hard for you what's the reasoning for it you know is it a money thing you want to be careful where you spend your money is it just because you're not a huge fan of change perhaps you just like to see more of the same because you know it's good i mean you could argue that i watch a lot of superhero movies and they're kind of more of the same formula it's nice when they try something a little bit different but in all honesty most superhero movies play out the same i really like that formula so there are

certain things that to know it's nice to see unique and interesting stuff and other things where i'm just like you know what give me more of what i like i can certainly see the argument both ways i'd be curious to know what you have to say so that's it for me for this podcast episode i'm going to get on with um actually should i edit this now yeah i'll edit it tonight and then release it tomorrow that should give me a bit more time to do other things tomorrow like actually record some of the proper video reviews to go on youtube but yeah thank you for joining me for this episode i'll see you soon uh two weeks time when i do another podcast episode i'd love to think about what topic i'm doing but there's plenty of reviews to come we've got cascadia glass road uh more term uh possibly an only tamara expansion light and shadow come on there must be more than that i'm starting to forget which oh yeah messina i need to do a detailed review from that obviously the top five stocking stuffers i mentioned before i will get top 10 lists back up and running once i'm caught up with some of these reviews so i can just do normal top tens but of course some of those will be collaboration ideas in fact let me know your thoughts on this top 10 games that murdered other games that list has been done before by the dice tower do you reckon that would be fun for me to do with somebody but also what about the reverse of that top 5 top 10 games that weren't defeated by other games so i can talk about a game that replaced this game for me but then i could also talk about games that despite somebody trying to replace them it never did and i stuck with the older version you know would that be an interesting list i'm i'm more interested about it the more i talk about it

actually so uh yeah let me know your thoughts on that but then of course there will be a top 10 of 2021 at some stage but what am i gonna put on it honestly i'm a little bit concerned about that more so than the top 10 of 20 20. oh well i'll have to see if i can find 10 games but okay i'm sure most people have already got like 50 games of 2021 that they love but uh i'm not feeling it so far well enough to see anyway that's it for me on this episode if you like what you see please remember to leave a thumbs up and comment on the video it means the world to me to know you appreciate the content and i like to engage with you on a personal level uh don't forget the patreon campaign is running if you want to support the channel a little bit further but until next time you can check out my top 100 videos you can check out the more reviews that i've done recently on games like boon lake botoku and golem for examples and even 7 wonders architect and mobile markets recently but by all means the main thing is that you remember it's only a game and you have fun take care bye for now love you all

Progress saved