Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 17

Transcript 14:41

hey everyone and welcome to episode 17 of board games i got rid of and why so this is a series of videos where i talk about some games that were previously in my collection but for one reason or another unknown in my collection and i'll try to give some some rationale as to why i came to that decision so let's get started with the first game so the first game that i want to talk about is a game called shikoku which is a strange small box game where you're trying to climb this huge flight of stairs but you want to be the person who is either in second place or second to last place you don't want to be the first player to reach the top and the way you move up these stairs is going to be drafting these cards which has this quite an obtuse drafting system but as i said you're constantly trying to stay in between the players not be last but not be first either and just keep a nice balance between the two and the problem with this game i found was well first off it was quite boring and samey from start to finish but i felt like the almost like the first three quarters of the game were almost void you didn't really have to really concentrate that much until it came to the end because it was all about that kind of position where you were when the game finished so again it felt like you're going through the motions of it it felt a bit arbitrary for the first half three quarters but yeah so ultimately i didn't find the gameplay very satisfying i thought it was just a bit boring and just not a very good game at all to be honest so that is shikoku the next game i want to talk about is called get out of colditz so i actually recently released a review on this game quite negatively because i think this is actually probably one of the worst games i played in recent memory so this one is a pretty random and wild game as you are trying to collect these cards and then play these cards of a

matching type with the aim of trying to help these prisoners escape from cold it's of course so you'll play like a couple of ropes or maybe a couple of tunnels in a row and once you've done this a certain amount of times you're going to win the game but as this is going on your opponent is trying to sabotage you you know they're trying to cut your ropes off and stuff like this it's constantly back and forth it's very frustrating there's no strategy at all there's no depth of this game it's just a chaotic mess and whoever draws the best cards at the right time is going to win and it drags on too long it's tedious and it's just a terrible design that is uh get out of coldness obviously that one left the collection the next game is hafid's grand bazaar um and to be upfront this game is actually quite decent it's not a bad game at all it's quite well ironed out and quite well thought out it has some good mechanisms going on it's got some bidding it's got some set collection it's even got some negotiation and the way this game works is that each player is going to have a bunch of these action cubes and then in turn order you're going to be using these action cubes to bid on different spots on the board to either collect new cards because you're going to be collecting them and trying to sell them in sets either all different types are all the same type that kind of thing but additionally you can go to other spots which will kind of let you peek at the cards or let you trade with other players and all this different stuff um so yeah on paper it worked perfectly fine and to be completely upfront we did play this game wrong when we played it so we did have a few of the rules wrong but i don't think it would have changed my lasting impression of this one but i thought this game did feel like it was a bit scripted in what you'd do so depending on the player order it would always kind of be the first or the same spots getting gobbled up in the exact same way every single time so it was kind of just going through the motions

each time the decisions you had to make weren't terribly um interesting or kind of agonizing it's always pretty obvious what you do and i'm just just getting just collect cards trade them in collect cards trade them and hopefully you draw the best ones so yeah i thought the replay value wasn't quite there despite this one being pretty promising um it was just um competing with too many other better games i think so that's why happy's grand bazaar uh left like left the collection the next game is called hit the silk so talk about games that are absolutely awful this one was probably the worst game i played last year so this one is a pretty chaotic game as you are trying to collect money by collecting these cards and then collect a parachute because the theme of this game is that we are supposed to be i'm in this um airplane that's plummeting to the ground and we're trying to basically settle this debt i think we've got and then there's only a certain amount of parachutes to go amongst the players so if there's like a six player game there might only be three parachutes so only three people can potentially win um but is this constant back and forth of you know drawing cards um just stealing cards from other people even eliminating people when they have no control over it whatsoever and i tend to really dislike games like this anyway and i thought this one really did kind of rely on its theme and setting to try and get people involved um but mechanically it was so weak there was often times where you'd have a perfect bunch of cards in your hand you didn't really want to do anything else you just sit back sit by just pass and pass and pass and wait until the kind of um the altitude drop to a certain point where they're getting good ends so you'd often spend several times just not doing

anything um some take that just for the sake of it and your games just don't land for me at all and this was an absolute calamity of a game that i'd highly recommend you avoid so that is hit the silk the next game i want to talk about is called papua which was a game i wasn't expecting much from at all and it actually did impress me quite a lot for that reason and i think that was probably one of the reasons why this one offered kind of diminishing returns for me so the first time i played it i thought it was really good because again i wasn't expecting much the second time i thought it was okay but not quite as good as i remembered it and then it kind of went down and down from there but that being said this game did do a good job of involving quite a few mechanisms in quite a simple simple package it had some work replacement it had some kind of blind bidding and resource management even some good set collection mechanisms as well um and it had a quite a unique approach as well because you'd actually roll this bunch of um dice at the start of the game you'd allocate what all the different placement spots did um as you went on so like all the ones would correspond to this certain spot and that could change from round to round which i thought was quite interesting um but ultimately i think this game was competing with quite a few other games in the same kind of genre of games so that kind of medium light work replacement thing going on and there are some just better ones out there which meant this one was just sitting on the shelf never being brought out it was reasonably quick to play you know anything about hours 75 minutes to play but again there's some other games offer i think a slightly richer experience and a slightly more polished experience in that time and that one kept us from getting from getting onto the table and um kicked it from my collection

ultimately so that is papua the next game is kanagawa by bruno cathala so this one is one of those games where i think there's nothing really wrong with it but there's nothing about it that excited me despite this one being very beautiful in the way it looked on the table so this one is a game where you're trying to almost paint this panoramic watercolor painting and you're going to be trying to collect these sets of buildings or characters on them um and you're also using these cards in two different ways not only for the panoramic picture itself but also for this kind of workshop which would mean that you could paint certain pictures so you kind of build two certain parts of the game not only the painting of the set collection also the workshop in order to paint the paintings in the first place and it worked nice and smoothly it was pretty quick it hasn't that's cool this cool chicken mechanism where you could go for certain objectives but once you've cashed out on that objective you could no longer do it anymore so you kind of push for the really high points and gamble that way but kind of forsake the ones before it or just play it safe and go and kind of bite the bullet early which i did really like but ultimately another a bit like papawa there was just too many games out there that you could play at half an hour that i think were a bit more exciting a bit more interesting than this game despite being nothing wrong with it at all and i know it is reasonably popular it had a good drafting system as you build up these rows of cards a bit like coloretto and you could choose to kind of stop and take one of the rows or columns before it you know before they're ultimately all filled out so had that you know keep pushing your luck and stopping where you're happy or kind of pushing further

and being a bit greedy but potentially risking somebody else taking it so again another well ironed out game but one that was just a bit generic for me and felt a bit just mediocre so that is kanagawa next up is probably the highest rated game on this list this is yellow and yangtze and this game i really enjoy i think it's a fantastic design and the only reason this one isn't my collection anymore is because it has like a a sister game basically called tigris and euphrates which is kind of 90 of the same game um i bought them both because i wanted to see which one i preferred and i just slightly prefer the um the tigers euphrates version which is the actual original version um the only differences between the two was that in yellow and yangtze you would have hexes instead of squares and additionally all the different colors had their own kind of unique power and associated with them which thai christian freighties didn't have and for me i think i prefer that slightly simpler version of playground euphrates and i prefer the way the combat worked i thought was a bit more intuitive and but that being said you know i'm there's very minor differences between the two if the typewriters didn't exist i would still have this in my collection it's an absolute classic unique confrontational game by ryan kenicia with that really cool scoring system where you're trying to collect all the different sets of or different sets of colors but only your lowest set amongst those colors is going to be your final score so it's this really cool balancing act as the game goes on but um yeah no negative no nothing nothing negative to say about this game at all it's fantastic but there's no point in having two games that are pretty much identical in my collection so therefore

one had to go and that one was yellow and yangtze the next game that left my collection was kubitos which surprised me actually because i thought that i would enjoy this game because on paper it sounds fantastic as you are drafting these dice and then you're rolling these dice and almost like a pushy luck mechanism where you're trying to not roll all blanks um but you can keep rolling and rolling and rolling until you you know until you drop like a potentially good bust but the idea is that all these dice work in different ways and they have different unique powers and you're using them to try and race around this track to be the first to reach the finish line maybe collecting bonuses along the way um and you know again on paper it sounds fantastic i thought i'd love this one but it fell very flat for me i thought all the dice worked in ways that weren't terribly interesting sometimes they were quite convoluted um i never really kind of got excited in this game it just got a completely flat line for me and i always felt like i'd rather be playing quack sequoia rather than this one and i thought this one did kind of try to capitalize on the success of quacks quarterback and failed in the process now i think i might be in the minority of this one i know this one is quite well received but for me when you're thinking of a pushy luck dice rolling um racing game with a bunch of unique dice you think you know this has all the recipe or the recipe to be a fantastic game when ultimately it was just okay at best which i thought was quite disappointing and quite deflating and um yeah ultimately i didn't enjoy it too much so that is why kubitos left the collection the penultimate game i want to talk about is by stefan feld actually this is

a game called arena roma 2. so this one is actually a very different approach to a steffenfeld game it's a it's a dueling style card game but the way you resolve or trigger these cards is based on dice rolls so you're gonna roll these dice and depending on the pit values they're gonna trigger cards corresponding to certain spots on this row and you're gonna be kind of stealing points of each other you're gonna be eliminating cards and things um which i really like i love the clean mechanism of this game the problem with this game was that it had the potential to go on very long it was a very simple game not terribly strategic um but yeah sometimes you get into these long drawn out war of attrition where you're just trying to bleed points from each other rather than being a quick snappy game so normally when i play a quick simple filler game i want to have that kind of confidence that it's going to fall in a certain time frame like sometimes you play this game in 15 minutes no problem but then sometimes you play play for 45 minutes when you're playing the same game and it kind of felt like that unpredictability on how long this is going to take really did kind of dampen the effect this game had on me i felt like um it had its it had a glass signal on how many times you could play it as well because the same cards would come out time and time again but that being said it was a real fresh approach on a dueling style game and it was kind of like a hybrid of that confrontational style of game but with a euro kind of flare to it so it was unique in that feel but ultimately again that the potential for it to take too long was too strong for me to ignore and therefore it would not hit the table and

therefore it had to leave the collection but i still like this one i would recommend it to the right people but it wasn't quite right for me myself so therefore arena rumor two left the collection and the final game i'm talking about this episode is santa maria which is actually by far my favorite game from this set of games this one is a dice drafting a dice placement a tar placement and even an engine building style game just got a lot going on here but it's such a smooth and precise little game as you're drafting these tiles and placing them on your player board with the idea of placing dice in the future to trigger every building in that row or column and getting resources and trading those resources into other resources with the idea fulfilling these contracts which will give you engine building benefits climbing tracks and things so all the euro goodness you'd expect and you know what objectively there's not really much i can criticize from this game at all i think it's fantastic very well polished and it's very smooth it plays in about an hour so it has so many positive things going on the only reason this one left my collection is the replayability i felt like every time i played this one it felt very similar from the previous time and i think i would have really loved to have tried it with the expansion but i think the expansion is like gold dust and i could not get a hold of it and that paired with the fact that i have so many other dice drafting games in my collection this one was just again it kind of met its end ready i really enjoyed my time with it i left on a high with it and i kind of wanted to leave that impression rather than playing it more and more and maybe

starting to come become bored of it so i wanted to leave this one where it was a game that i still recommend people check out if you do like dice drafting and do like engine building and even that little puzzly element of tile placement as well this one has so it gets so much going on for it to its benefit but again that replayability just wasn't quite there for me to be a long stay in my collection and it was kind of with a heavy high i decided to um you know remove this from my collection you know despite me having a lot of things saying don't do it so who knows maybe one day i will get this one back with the um with the expansion if that opportunity arises so that is santa maria so there we go that concludes another 10 games that left my collection i hope you enjoyed this one and i hope it's been useful to you as usual be sure to you know hit like subscribe to the channel all that good stuff and also be sure to check out the other 16 episodes up to this point because that's 160 games there i've talked about um that have left my collection for one reason or another and you know who knows you might extract a bit of information from those and for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye now

Progress saved