Skip to main content
Loading video...

Games that Left Our Collections | July-December 2024

Transcript 47:15

hey I'm Ryan this is my brother Daniel and this is rolls in the family and we are getting into the holiday season here what better way to celebrate the holidays by getting rid of board games get rid of more games got to get rid of games got to make room room for actually I wouldn't even say that's the motivation um you know as far as like making room uh but over time we tend to be pretty uh I think we've used the word Relentless in our brutal our trimming down of the collection you know and and not keeping games around without a good reason for keeping them around yeah it's true um you know and sometimes it's we got a game and it just wasn't what we thought it was you know it just didn't land as well as we wanted to sometimes it's a game that we've enjoyed for a long time it's had a great stay in the collection but for whatever reason we're just like I think it's time to move on um and so twice a year we we like to come talk about it and uh talk about the ones that left we actually have a pretty short list this time maybe we're not as Relentless as we used to be I don't know Ryan there's going to be some tear shed on this I will say we got some heavier hitters than maybe normal some of these hurt some of these hurt but yeah I think we got six games between us to talk through we'll also include our ratings for all of them I'm kind of counting from the lowest rated up to the highest rated we'll have links in the description below always funny to be um you know you can check out any of the games that we're saying that didn't work for us but that doesn't mean they won't work for you I would there's a lot of these that I might check out after the

video yeah dango's actually making some huge mistakes looking at his there's a lot of regret in this video um you can also feel free to drop in the comments any games you've gotten rid of recently or have decided to uh trim from The Collection honestly it often times is more helpful to people to hear the reasons why someone a game didn't work for them than reasons why it did in terms of trimming season seeing trimming season just shaved this morning actually that ra Ryan on theme for the video love it yeah I was like oh we got that cold video got to get get the shave in love it okay enough banter let's hit it off uh looks like I'm starting off here um if there is something that has been a trend there there's Trends in the board game industry like if you go back 10 years a little over 10 years ago when Dominion came out it was like man deck builders were just like blowing up everywhere and then it was probably like five years ago that everybody and their mother was making a rolling right game or a fliping right game it just is like there's like hundreds of them now and then a game called The Crew came out that kind of put a Twist on trick taking games and I swear since then there have been so many trick taking games and clever twists on it and they must be you know selling or at least everybody's trying to jump on the bandwagon of these uh trick-taking games right um and this was one that caught my eye um I enjoy trick taking games so a lot of these intrigued me but there's also like how many trick taking games do I need in my collection uh this was one that was very

intriguing to me it just had a very clever concept um and I'm really glad that I got to try it this is Cat in the Box specifically the deluxe edition um which I ultimately giving a 7.5 out of 10 I know very little about this R very little yeah I was going to say 7.5 that's a pretty good starting point for the lowest of our rating we're just actually talking about good games like favorite game so cat in the box is a fascinating Twist on trick taking because all the cards have numbers but none of them have suits so they're all just like you know don't have any color or anything and when you play a card you get to just decide what suit it is like you can just say whatever you want but if I play the four and I say this is the red four then we I like mark the red four on the shared board to show that the red four has been played so like now that I've played the red that's truth now in our system um and so it's kind of playing on like the shinger cat thing or whatever of like it is alive or is it dead in the box like it isn't decid the suit isn't decided until you play the card yeah and so there's this element of you're trying to you know get rid of your cards it's kind of normal trick taking where you lead following suit um unless you don't have the suit um which is a very interesting thing cuz how do you know if you don't have the suit when your cards don't have suits well you can just decide you don't you can say this is I'm playing Green cuz I'm

out of Reds but you then on your little board have to mark that you're out of Reds you can never say that you are playing a red cuz you already said you don't have any Reds this sounds like a great game R um and so it's very fascinating CU part of what you're trying to do is avoid a paradox cuz if you ever get to a point where cuz the longer the round goes out out all the spot on that main board are being taken up so that it limits what cards could be declared like there's only these cards left in the deck and if you ever get to a point where you know I only have a four and a six and the only four and a six is like in a suit that I've said I don't have any more of I have a paradox I can't legally play and anytime someone does a paradox it completely ends the round and like you score negative and it actually can be very interesting cuz cuz it's one of these games where at the beginning betting how many tricks you're going to take and trying to take that amount so when someone has a paradox and it prematurely ends the round that can really affect people that were like maybe counting on additional tricks um so all very clever and then it has this added piece of on that main board where it's a grid of all the numbers from like I forget if it's 2 to 10 or something um across the the rows or the four different suits you put your little tokens out whenever you declare a card that you're playing and then at the end you want to have tokens connected almost like a little area control thing because

I think it's if you meet your it's been a little while since I've played it but if you meet your bid I think you get bonus points based on like the size of your largest connect so there this extra weird thing of like I want to also like declare cards that you know are going to put them next to each other on the board yeah so it all comes together really well and I had I had a lot of fun playing with it really the killer for me was I just don't think it was a game that was going to be an evergreen for me that I was going to want it it's one of those like kind of fun little experiment games that's like kind of fun and then it was like okay I could keep it around as that my collection of like this is just a fun little experiment game to bring out with people that like trick ticking games to be a nice twist um but I found like when you get your hand of cards and Cat In The Box because the cards don't have suits your hands feel really similar every time you know you're going to get some distribution of the cards and yes you might have higher cards it might have lower cards but the breadth of like variance in your hand is so much lower I feel like it'd be really hard to like even analyze your hand to know like is it is this good I don't know it basically goils down to like do I have high cards CU that's the only thing you really have to go off of um and so I found like one of my favorite things in these types of games whether it be t or the crew or these different things is how you get that hand and it's like okay how am I going to work with

this like there's a lot that the hand informs me and I felt like cat in the Box was Mi missing that a little bit it was more like oh it's interesting as the round goes on to see how it plays out and but like yeah it made it made me feel like it maybe wasn't one I was going to want to come back to again and again and again but like I said earlier I'm really glad I got to try it and and part of that's from like the uh game designer side of my brain I just like fascinating I appreciate this design it's very clever it it was some very just fun situations with a group that like knows trick taking games and I I think it could work really well for a lot of people that that enjoy trick- taking games I just so often I'm looking through the lens of is this a game I'm going to want to play 50 times where something like the crew something like tiu I mean I've played T over a hundred times um I do feel that way about those games and being in the same category means it's competing for table time with some of those games I really love so ultimately cat in the Box didn't stick around they apparently kickstarted some like giant edition of this game that like which made like very little sense to me I was like I don't know of games to decide to make The Bard you can Kickstart a giant edition of anything of anything yeah giant twister where you can't even like get off of a single red circle yeah yeah and you play you play in you have a team and your team is one unit yep it's a legacy game too this is

actually not a bad idea you all have to hold on to each other and you make one larger organism on a giant twister board Ryan hey don't steal this idea if any of you steal this I'm putting that away in my uh so Health my uh board game design I'll help you play test that yeah got to get a few more people that's more of a game for a 100 people okay let's get back on the rails here it looks like it's me again Dango I've got kind of some of the lower ones on this list because Dango like we said is getting rid of good games like that's how it feels man big mistakes honestly so um my second entry here is one that I had had a it looked like a game that looked good but it falls in a very competitive category of kind of like medium tohey strategy Euro type games um so it never was one I really thought I was going to get until an un irresistible uh local deal came up on the old Facebook Marketplace um where I was able to get this game and another game for like I mean probably 20% of what they would be new yeah um this is endless winter and so I believe I got endless winter which is a big like very premium it was a Kickstarter game like it it's very good components and stuff and then I got inish and I think the two of them together it was like $30 which

like both of those are like you know 50 $60 games at some point any price you'll uh so ultimately now that I sold endless winter I sold it I think for as much as I bought both for so I basically got inish for free which you know it's a goodal that's a good way to come out but endless winter um is very much a it feels kind of like a kitchen sink Euro design it's like let's throw in deck building and let's throw in some area control and let's throw in this little like mini game over here where we're making these this like megalith monolith thing um and so there's a lot going on I did like how it was powered by this very kind of simplified worker placement thing where you're sending your workers to one of four spots and then you there's like something an action you can do there any number of times there's an action you can do there once and then there's like a bonus if you're the first one to have gone to that and so one of the actions is all about like hunting and you can like hunt animals which is good to get because you can turn them into food or you could uh um they have like scoring at the end of the game if you hold on to them there's another one that lets you do like build your little tents and explore on the map which is like this um it's almost kind of like Twilight Imperium like a bunch of hex's together yeah yeah I I hesitated to say that cuz that's the only way it's similar the shape and the individual shapes um of hexagons and you're wanting

to expand on that map and ultimately if you get like three1 together you can put out a Hut at like the intersection and there's like bonuses that you get from certain things that are out there um and then you're there's ways to get more cards into your deck because you're recruiting these cards because it has this whole system that you're drawing cards and the cards both have like a labor value that like you can apply like when you're doing some of those actions you can do any number of times it's like you can spend a certain amount of Labor so it's got kind of a multi-use card thing so do I use these for labor so a lot going on um and honestly really really uh sharp design like it it works it works really wellp um for me and I I played it one time and I just came away yeah these days it's it's hard to when you when already feel like like this probably isn't sticking around it just isn't like the old days where it's like well we can play this 10 times in the next three days and then then we can decide like um it's it's taking away table time from other games I love yeah so I just the more I thought about the more I felt pretty confident um it definitely is like for the amount of complexity I didn't feel like the payoff was quite where I wanted it to be like it's not an easy teach cuz like it's just a lot of different things going on that um and none of it there weren't like a lot of wow moments for me in the game or like the types of kind of big exciting

moments I was looking for it was just like everything was solid and everything worked good and was solid the thing that probably was my biggest Downer on the game was the last like 20 minutes of the game because it's one of these games where everybody's trying to squeeze out points right it's like okay in this last turn what gives me the most points and because it's so sprawling there's a lot of different things you could do so to go through the checklist of like all the different ways I could maybe get some points kind of takes a while um and so like you know it kind of bogs down is you try to figure out all the different trade-offs of what you could get for points but what I found is at the end of the game a lot of those paths like came out to like the exact same point value so I would I there were a couple times I sat there and I like took like 5 minutes to like run through all these different things and it basically came to this conclusion of like I can get like three points three points three points Four Points Four Points you know th those are like the different options and it's like well that doesn't even that almost feels like it wasn't worth the effort of me like figuring all that out there wasn't like one that was like oh my gosh if I combo this I can really do something that's so much more now maybe I just wasn't good at the game but it that is a possibility Ry yeah it felt almost like the game is was so kind of like balanced across all those things that it was almost whichever route I decided to go effectively into I was almost coming out with the same points as if I did somewhere else that's interesting um which yeah it just made the uh like

evaluation less satisfying and less like feeling like it was worth it yeah cuz I think something we I think something we love in games is obviously I mean obviously we want balanced but games that have Opportunities For What feels like almost like gamebreaking moves or something that's like oh my gosh that was sweet you know those yeah it's like given the things I have given the unique situation I've put myself in the game with what I have oh like I can figure something out that really works well with what I have where even though in this game I like you know over the game you differentiate in things you're getting you get these cool like I forget what they're called like Eclipse tiles that you put out that then like trigger in each equips phase so you almost are kind of like customizing your scoring conditions and so there's a lot of cool stuff there that you're kind of like differentiating but then when you're actually going into the actions and stuff it still kind of felt like that differentiation wasn't pushing me strongly in One Direction or another as much as I maybe would have liked um and I think it was hard cuz it already felt like the game was outstaying it's welcome a little bit I'm trying to remember if we had I want to say we had three players um it already felt like okay this is going a little longer than it feels like the game kind of earned so then it's hard for that last stretch to feel like it even slowed down a little bit more as everybody you know it's just hard to justify like these long turns that had almost no impact on the game right

because like the long turn wasn't to discover something that really impacted the winner it was like I got like almost the same outcome as if I hadn't thought through everything at all right like if I just gone with my G put all the effort in and then be like that wasn't rewarded yeah so it was one I just I didn't see myself kind like I said it's in a very competitive category so it was like I mean you have to I I don't know if I said I I rated this a 7.5 I probably forgot Daniel will lament in editing when I'm going to be raging and editing Ry he didn't say you're rating um rated 7.5 and quite frankly games in this demographic like almost need to be like a nine to St stick around that's like that's significant L lower than the than the cut off it feels like so good game you know I'd be happy to play it it's just like I'm always going to pick a number of other games over it makes sense okay Ryan over to me I get my turn my turn uh this is a a game that uh we owned originally way back I had originally yeah I already C this like a decade ago dang what you I got it got a cold again yeah owned it way back and then uh came out with a collector's edition which Daniel's always enticed enticed by good Collector's Edition no but it honly I'm much more enticed than I I'm much less enticed Than I Used to Be by um but actually it was really great in terms of like oh my gosh like all the you know it's a game where the

you know having more content just sounded like it would be so great um this is going to go to Suburbia collectors edition uh which I'm going to be giving an eight out of of 10 there is a lot I really like about this game um I mean one just the on the collector's edition I think they did a really nice job from a presentation standpoint I mean the tiles just look beautiful it's one of those games that as you're as you're kind of building your city out in front of you um it just looks wonderful um but the mechanics of the game are are super fun because it's a game where you know you're um you're drafting these City tiles that you're kind of placing into your city but all of your tiles kind of are interacting with one another and one of the things I love about this game is that they interact with one another in ways that thematically kind of make sense uh which is really cool so like oh you there's a penalty if you put housing right next to like a huge like indust landfill or something you know what I mean so like I think the game does a really great job at thematic connection to where it's like as you're building your city you're not just doing things randomly to get points but you're doing things to get points and it also is like oh yeah like that that kind of makes sense like why a city would be constructed that way um and I love the mechanics of this game I mean it's I I think it's such an interesting uh tension in the game because you kind of have these two

tracks your you've got your income which is obviously critical because you need money to buy more more tiles um but then you also have your um uh reput which is what gives you more population population is essentially victory points it's how you win the game but as you go up on the population track on the victory Point track you cross these lines that every time you cross them you bump down on your income and reputation and so the tension that that causes is if you just go like hard reputation right away your income's going to get decimated I actually think the last game I played of this I went way too aggressive on reputation and I was like in the negatives of income like at the end way too many people you didn't know how to manage I had no no managing of them but so oh like mechanically I love Suburbia uh I really do um and I thought the collector's edition was going to be like the definitive version of this um the reason it's leaving my collection it's several things um I I've talked about with like a key thing with a collector's edition is it can't feel like a burden a bigger burden to pull the game out I think dungeon fighter did a really good job of this of yeah it doesn't feel like more of this like burden like the setup is way longer

it's just you just have a bunch more like when things come out you just have more things to pull and you kind of pull out the trays and set them to the side and you're pretty much ready to get the other content whereas in this game you have tons of content but you're not using all the content every game and so you kind of have to decide but then you also have to shuffle everything and so you're like okay I want to maybe play with this one and this one and so then you're shuffling all the things together which that's like taking a good amount of time and then after the game you're having to sort everything and like it was one of those things that's like oh man all this content sounds great except now I just don't want to play the game cuz it it significantly increased the barrier to getting it the table sometimes that's like not even like a really conscious thing it's not that you like really feel like you don't want to play it but it's this subconscious thing that like you just don't end up pulling it off the shelf yeah and it it is one of these things like over time you like have a realization of like we haven't played that you know in so long oh I think it partly is just cuz it is a little bit harder now than it used to be yeah it was it it just really made made bringing it out um um more difficult uh so I think that was um that was something that was kind of yeah just made it not get to the not get to the table as much I think the other thing I I didn't love about this game was like

in core Suburbia you know the distribution of tiles is key like in terms of the ratio of you know like if like if for example there's like you know you could play an airport and an airport scores more points based off the another the number of airports that other people have played yeah so the problem I was facing is like ideally I would love a game where it's like you get a ton of content and you can just kind of Shuffle it all together and take a random stack and play with that well you can't do that in this game cuz if that random stack has one airport and you don't know yeah it's a horrible tile or you might have like seven airports in the stack and it's an amazing tile and so it's a game that's so critically relies on a balanced distribution and they do they tell you how to do that in the rule book but again that just goes back to the setup is really uh time consuming because you have to make sure you have that you know if you want a balanced game you got to make sure everything kind of uh and so it just became too much and there's like like there was like part of me it's like gosh I wish I just had like the base game you know just even though it looked a lot worse but uh but yeah and but even the base game I mean it was a game that I think was a little heavier than I wanted it to be cuz like playing this game I mean it's it's this isn't like a

a short game per se it hits closer to maybe 90 minutes like it's starting to bump kind of into that 90 minutes if you're playing with four players I mean you're you might even be pushing close to that 2hour and like that again like you talked about with endless winner I mean that's a you're starting to really hit competitive competitive gaming territory there so a game that like I love mechanically and I seriously like if you ask if you ask me right now like the game's already set up I'll set it up for you you know maybe I just need to get like the digital version of it or something like that cuz I I do really enjoy uh everything about it um but man it just was was not getting to the table so yeah yeah I I forget like when I got rid of it like the main reasons but I I think it was one of those ones that just wasn't quite it it was like close to being a keeper yeah um but for whatever reason just you know there were other games in that that I enjoyed more but good game it's a good one uh another good game and one that's going to make me sound like an IM immediate hypocrite within this video I cannot believe you Ryan is uh is the crew the Quest for Planet n you know that game that three entries ago I said is one that I could play 50 sometimes are unbelievable uh but before you're up in Arms This has a very specific reason that it's leaving the collection I rate this an eight out of 10 I think the crew is a great game so good that uh I am actually replacing

it with a different addition of the crew uh which is the crew Mission deep sea um and really the big thing here I actually have still not played Mission deep sea um this is it is a game that I don't often have the group that's the right group for this hey um I'm going to be out there in a few weeks but yeah and and as you discovered our our mother apparently likes this game so she does maybe I just need to drive over to her house at the crew and show up at the door like please play this there you go um but yeah the the mission deep sea so the crew is a Cooper trick taking and that was really the big innovation was making a trick taking game fully Cooperative with very limited communication the crew had the original Edition had all these missions that did different twists and it's very fun to like go to the next mission and like what's the different restraint or goals that we need to do in this one what mission deep SE does is it adds more of a mission generation system into it of like there's a deck of goals that are very different things um and it still has like mission that have you assemble it but they're much more variable like the missions are going to be more different every time and it kind of opens the door to kind of doing more just like oneoff games and still have it be like variable and not just like picking a certain one right and so that really really appealed to me um that's definitely something that I felt would make I say make it easier to get this game to the table after I just said that I haven't been able to get it to the table but I do think in the long run

it's going to make it easier to get hypothetically is easier yeah all we're all dealing on we don't actually play these games it's all just Haven play board game in years yeah um but yeah it just was pretty clear that it was the one I was going to want in my collection and I couldn't really justify having both especially with how infrequently I play them um so ended up getting rid of the crew had had a very good time um with it and I'm I'm looking forward to playing the New Edition more yeah that one's interesting I definitely have my on it as well honestly so right now cuz I have the crew the question for Planet 9 and right now it's kind of become the uh me my wife and our mom whenever she comes out and visit it's like our little game that we did you guys play it again when she cuz she was just out there Rec yes we did yeah yeah and so for now I'm like let's just keep playing this you we're having a fun time we got the same group um well that's actually a good point because I with the original crew I think I had three different uh groups that had like I had made progress with campaigns in and I think all three of them yeah all three of them had some a member move out of state so maybe because of that Ron you one of them maybe that's the common denominator they hated the game man me playing the crew with people is getting them to leave um but obviously that was a big reason why the crew wasn't getting played because you felt more with that addition of the game that like I really do want to get the same group together so that is something I'm hoping with

Mission deep sea is I can feel a little bit more a to like hey we might not be committing to a campaign together here but let's play a few hands you know and mix it up um so I'll have to report back later if that serves that purpose the way I hope it does there you go okay Ryan okay okay this is where Daniel just laments um this is a game that is a great game uh it's a big game uh we both you still own it and I mean I I think I got it in my top 10 games of all time yeah and it and it was pretty high in in in my rankings um but there are reasons reasons that it's left it Grieves my heart to say that A Feast for Odin has left the collection Ryan I think is a little disappointed in me to be honest I I sense some I sense some shame n it's it's a bummer I mean I think we would both say that it was a little bit bit of a surprise that your wife didn't over time didn't enjoy this one as much as we thought she might yeah so I'm going to give this a give us an 8.5 out of 10 um this is a fantastic game um it's uh gosh I mean talk about a game where there's just um lots of huge worker placement um it's just such an interesting game in terms of the kind of having your

personal board and you're doing this like little Tetris type thing of you know and that's also controlling your income and your surround I mean there's just a lot of things honestly in A Feast for Odin that feel uh very different maybe than what a normal just traditional you know worker placement game is you know you talk about with like endless winner winner maybe feeling very uh standard I would say the that whole just manipulating your personal board that's a very unique an exhilarating thing in in A Feast for Odin um and so yeah it's it's a great game I think the here's here are the things that it came down to like you mentioned um my wife didn't love it as much as uh I was originally originally for the record she loves heavy tight I mean like AG gria for example agria is her favorite game and she also loves tight uh like polyomino puzzly games or tends to enjoy those types of which is part of why this felt like it would be a I thought it I thought it would um honestly and and thinking about kind of her her Reflections and and I honestly I share a little bit of this um the game is is not tight in terms of in Terms it's a very sandbox feel and I've realized with my wife that is she doesn't like that because it it kind of sometimes leaves you in this

place of like well I could do a bunch of different things and who knows what the best thing to do is and I'm not going to get blocked regardless or you know um and I would agree I don't like that feeling when I go into a game of like oh well what am I going to try this game and and I do feel that a little bit at the Feast for Odin of like okay well there's like a hundred actions um do I going be mying do I want to go wailing this time do I want to um and and you know so they have cards in the game I I really don't love the cards they they they're they just feel very kind of kind of more of a like oh I can kind of do this to get this little thing versus I think if the cards were more substantial and maybe could help drive a direction for where to go on the board maybe that would that would a little bit or or maybe there's you know and I'm trying to even remember if they if there was anything like this in the expansion but like something at this you know a unique setup at the start that would they added a little bit you now get your starting card and you also get the like Hut or whatever yeah um but it's not like a huge Direction defining thing cuz I think for both of us like what we would love is something where it's like I okay I'm starting like like this or I even think about like foring Mars like the

Prelude stuff and it's like okay of all the options this is the route I'm going because I've kind of been given this um and so I I think it just was a little too sandboxy it's it's a beast I mean this is a this is I would say even a notch I don't know like in my maybe it's not actually but in my mind it feels like it's even just a notch heavier than like your Agricola terraforming Mars like it's add complexity yeah it's it's this is a hard one to teach it's long and so you just add some of those things where it's like man I personally really love this game I I think part of it also is like you still own it and so it's like okay well maybe there's a world where I can you know if I do want to play it again that we know how hard it is to it's true yeah I'm never I'm never I'm never playing this game again um so a great game but just again it it's in that spot with length complexity heaviness we like there can't be much wrong with it yeah they're like the the line of like and you add just like okay my wife doesn't love it h it's a little too sandboxy uh the cards aren't quite and like amidst amazing stuff so the fact that your wife doesn't love it is I feel like one of the biggest things cuz that would be your most likely scenario to play it she

was who I played it with yeah um and so I mean if you if you turned it and like said what if your wife had loved it or even just like liked it like it would 100 any board game that she loves I don't care if I hate it like um yeah so it's interesting because everything you said I like 100% agree with I don't love I don't love the sand coming on Ryan I wish there was more upfront that you gave got more variable setup that felt like it was driving more I wish the cards felt kind of more impactful I don't love what they did in the expansion the expansion's amazing but they did a thing with the cards to try to mitigate Bad Card draws where now you can discard for points and it's like okay that made it more fair but it's also incentivizing doing the less fun thing which is not playing the Cs like I want to play these abilities and feel like it's part of my strategy I think when I play Feast froden I kind of choose to lean into the direction of of my initial like cards even if it's not because like oh this is like really telling me that this is going to be the most effective and more of like this is a suggestion of how I should maybe go in this sandboxy game for me it's one of these games that despite some of those kind of red flags that tend to be red flags in games for me when I play Feast for Odin it's just so dang fun like the the other stuff around it my experience playing it like elevates above and there are going to be

some things that are going to keep it from being in the the top top tier for me but I mean it's been in my top 10 games kind of despite those things um and it does feel very unique like like you said um and so that's kept it around for me um and I'm not in the same situation of you this would be one of the last games my wife would want to play my wife a lot lot lighter with thep of games she enjoys um so you know I'm usually looking to my more strategic groups that like these types of games anyway and I have some friends that do like it quite a bit yeah um but yeah it it is a sad sad day to see it see it leaving your collection honestly like it's also one that I just think I maybe even just needed to play a lot more cuz I even think about just like strategy-wise I just didn't even feel like I was at the point where like I most effectively knew how to use like the islands and so they were still at the place where they kind of just felt like this extra thing I was like I think I should be kind of using those but I don't know I'm when do I go get them well there's definitely the feeling a little bit like people who you know play Feast FR all the time they like know the islands and they're like oh like I'm going to be going after this one I'm like over there I look at a couple of them and it's like yeah this one looks like I'll be able to scale my come I don't even really want to think about what all the other islands are like I don't want to like crunch whether all of these would um so yeah like of games in my top 10 Feast fra might be the one that I can like critique the most like I

have the most things that I actually don't like about it but it just like speaks to how much the things I do like are just so fun in again yeah I mean that if a game is fun enough you know yeah can ignore those speaking of uh fun games speaking of fun games uh yeah this game is uh a fantastic game it is one of my favorite games of all time um and there's a very specific reason and you need to you're trying to practice the little more self-control so you're like needs to leave the collection so that you don't uh neglect your family and other such things that's right that's right um no there's a very specific reason this game is leaving my collection and that is because there is a new edition coming hopefully soon yeah dang's betting on this new edition let me tell you I am putting a lot I'm putting all my eggs in one basket on this one this goes to Nemesis so I give Nemesis a 9.5 out of 10 uh Nemesis is one of my favorite games of all time and I think about the first time I played Nemesis and I was just absolutely Blown Away by the Thematic feeling that it gave me during the game it really was unlike more more of a thematic feeling than I think I've really had an in another board game in the sense of you are you know on this like you know ship or whatever

and you feel like the you feel the the terror of there's aliens in here and the aliens are terrifying and I got to try to sneak around and the the terror of like I can't fully trust can I trust you can I not like this game it you know I think going back you know we enjoyed uh like Battle Star Galactica we've enjoyed um dead of winter um so we've enjoyed some of the kind of games that have you know so this kind of betrayer element I think in those games I never felt there were a couple things I never felt this deep thematic like deeply drawn into it like dead of winter you know you like you maybe even more so in Battle Star Galactica you maybe did feel that but in DEA winter I don't know you it kind of just felt like we we don't know the Battle Star Galactica IP so we're going completely blind into this from a thematic perspective but but I don't know man just Nemesis it's like I just you you're and you're sharing this experience with the group of of oh my goodness this is just absolutely absolutely terrifying but then um I find the game just it's delivers a lot of incredible moments the way just things work between uh the tension of the different objectives you know you you

have two objectives and you got to commit to one and uh and and so you're all trying to kind of like who's who's doing what are you know are you good are you bad and uh you usually kind of go off in in pairs and and whatnot um the whole like noise thing you know is is really interesting um I love thematic games and this one I think is probably my favorite of thematic games and so uh that's why it's jumped all the way to the top for me um I am so excited for Nemesis retaliation um normally I would say it is a horrible idea to sell one of your favorite games before a new addition comes out and I might still think that afterwards we'll see um but the changes just to me like it's it was one of those things where it's like it felt like there's no way I'm I'm not going to like this more um they add a variable map that is so great on multiple levels one it it I think it's going to create an even more thematic experience of you don't know this this you know place that you're you're walking into you know and and you're discovering it as you go that's incredible from a variability perspective of playing game to game that's incredible cuz you know the original game you the rooms were variable but you kind of knew you always knew the you know the head of the ship was was here the the you know back here

and and all that so there was a lot of consistency it feels like the modular map is going to amp up just the kind of different stories that can get told like the like there's just more room in the system for different things to happen and then I think just on top of that there's now variability with the aliens you know part of that was I you know backed a little bit where now I I'm not even sure what I backed at this point isn't this the great thing you back it so far back which there may have even been variability with the aliens in the previous Edition for people that actually like you got the stretch the stretch stuff but I think there was just a lot injected into the variability of it I I know they made a change to the um to the objectives where you know in the original game you would as soon as the first alien came out you have to choose which sometimes that would happen in like very quickly and you're like well I have no information that helps me decide and that wasn't a great feeling whereas now you can basically choose to keep both objectives um for as long as you want but there's like kind of a negative you know you there's there's an incentive intive to commit earlier which I think is really cool that's a fun kind of that it that it creates so a lot of things that that I just look at and I'm like man I I think this is going to be the one I think this is this is going to deliver take everything I loved about

Nemesis and and and make it even better which is saying a lot given that it already was was one of my favorite games so you also have this one on uh on I do have this one on the way I I really enjoyed my I've only played Nemesis once enjoyed my play of it felt like that game system could have a nice place in my collection um a big thematic game that gives kind of that like semi Co-op feel yeah um so yeah it'll beting to see because like I haven't played as many times as you so I haven't as formed as complete of an opinion on it um but I agree with what you're saying that like the new addition feels to me like the one yeah um that's going to be best for me and this I you know I've a little bit struggled with semi-cooperative games like my big complaint with like dead of winter was it felt the game was already really hard like if it was just Cooperative game it was hard but it felt like well if we have a you know someone who's a betrayer zombie or whatever um were just hosed like yeah and it also what you didn't know if you did or not which I actually found that I liked it better in Battle Star cuz battle Gala you always know that there's going to be these s on by the end of the game and so you always know you're going to get kind of this dramatic Arc of the Game ending in like a team versus te and the game's balanced around that reality that there's going to be two and three good two bad whereas dead of winter you didn't know sometimes there's everyone's good sometimes someone's totally and the

problem is how do you make a game that is balanced for yeah they definitely leaned into Randomness more I mean thaten has the die that like there's one side that just like I can't remember it's been a long time but it's like a really bad result with the zombies um which there there's some new said I mean we're fans of games where that Randomness can make very memorable moments um but yeah it was one that just like never quite was worked as well or as was fun as the idea of it was I agree I agree yeah so I excited I hope it get delivered soon I think it's supposed to but uh I mean I I I think it was originally like April 2025 so it oh my God so yeah oh jeez what am I I think the uh I think the reprints of the first two so sad our delivering yeah dang's been reading all the emails getting all excited o it's coming it's coming no not your version okay fine fine but yes hopefully we can report back in hopefully less than a year you never know what these kickstarters but hopefully we we can uh chat a little bit in the future about our thoughts on uh Nemesis retaliation hey thanks for watching uh if you felt like we were a little too positive about all of these games these were a lot of really good games uh we've got a whole playlist of games that we have gotten rid of and some of them are quite uh quite more negative than than this one so you can click there if you want to check that out we've got another

video here as well and we'll see you in the next one

Progress saved