10 Board Games Ranked - Episode 30
Transcript
hi everyone and welcome to another ranking video so in this series I take a look at the last 10 new to me board games that I played and I ranked them from my least favorite up to my most favorite now before I get started on the 10 games I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order at number 10 I have Ave Caesar now this is a racing game dating back to 1989. it's very simple as every player has an identical deck of cards you're gonna have three of those cards at random in your hand at any time and you're going to use them to move around at this race track now it's a chariots racing game so I do like the theme of this one you know I tend to like Roman themed games and typically all you're going to do on your turn you're going to play one of these cards and move that many spaces now there are kind of inner side you know the Fast Lanes and slower Lanes but the I suppose the trick on this one is that you need to move the full amount of spaces on those cards otherwise you cannot move at all so you know you need to bear that in mind and the decks are quite finely balanced where if you uh if you waste too much movement or if you're not moving quick enough then you're not you're not actually going to make it around the whole track at all because you know your deck only kind of get just about gets you around the whole uh track itself now there are a few little additional rules such as
attacking other players as you'd expect in a chariot racing game but for me that didn't really come through enough I think that should have been a lot more kind of barging into each other I'm kind of sabotaging each other throwing stuff on the track you know a bit more chaos and Carnage which was what I'd like to see from uh you know a chariot racing game I also found this game very frustrating at times as if you get kind of stuck in the pack and you weren't at the front then you would often get blocked and not be able to move at all and it never feels good if you spend your whole time not being able to do anything you do kind of have to use these proxy um you know AI chariots on the game but it's very simple to manage um and you know what it for me this does feel like a product of its time I don't think it's aged particularly well and I think you know such a simple game with a simple framework could have had so many little um bits of bits of spice to make it a bit more interesting where I think it missed an opportunity now I'm sure there are a ton of kind of fan made modules or rules you could add in because again that rules structure is so easy but but from the rules alone in the box and that's what I have to rate it on I think it isn't quite good enough to hold up to Modern racing games such as you know flam Rouge or heat or even games like downforce I think all of those are better than Abby Caesar at number nine I have Black Friday now this is an economic game by friederman fries uh actually again it's getting reprinted this year with revised rules and sadly I can see why this game needs revised
rules and because this game is far too chaotic for my liking so as you'd expect with an economic gain you are trying to buy low sell high and through this ever-changing Market the market is changing based on these kind of briefcases you're putting into this bag drawing them out at random which will you know if you draw loads of the same type of bag it'll really increase that stock price but if you draw these black briefcases out it can potentially crash the market for a particular um you know stocks that you're trying to buy you know you do have to go on a hunch here you can have a little bit of control by you know investing heavily in a particular stock putting it in the bag therefore you've got a better idea about what's going to come out but ultimately is again you have to roll with the punches and just hopefully get the timing right or when to buy and when to sell I thought there's a little bit overwrought a little bit confusing again too chaotic for my liking and I think there are better economic games out there for me therefore I cannot really recommend Black Friday but who knows the revised version could fix some of those problems for me but I can't really see how you change it without completely kind of reworking this game from the ground up eight I have mysterium park now this is essentially a bare bones and simplistic version of the original mysterium it got rid of a lot of the fiddly rules of the original Mysterion which I definitely think works to the benefits of mysterium park it makes up this makes the setting up of the game so much faster which was another huge Obstacle of the original
mysterium but this game kept all the core gameplay experience with the ghost player trying to give out Clues to the other players to help signpost them to pick up their card on this kind of central display now although I like the setting of this one being kind of a haunted theme park Carnival I actually think it did work against the game because all of the visual aesthetic of the cars look similar making it more difficult to kind of cherry pick features on those cards especially when it comes to the location cards and that definitely did get us stuck into a bit of a corner where we couldn't really differentiate all the different location cards because they were so similar and all based on a Carnival so it would have been you know although I like what they're going for here I think it's definitely um backed itself into a corner with what you could do with the artwork here so I think mysterium is fine I think um there are other games of the same genre that I prefer so much more games like Dixit games like detective Club this one I think is just Fallen below this one so far to me that I wouldn't really want to play this one above those so for that reason I can't really recommend it but I definitely think it's done a good job of fixing that Philly nature of the original mysterium at number seven I have Marvel remix now this is the Marvel themed version of the popular card game fantasy Realms a game where you're collecting an optimal hand of cards which synergize with each other to get as many points as you can now this game did make a few changes although the the gameplay is essentially the same that's what I think did a good job of reading the world scoring back to make
it a bit more approachable and a bit more a bit more welcoming to more introductory Gamers because you're not scoring you know 100 cup hundred points for a single card you're scoring you know a lot less than that to make it a bit more controlled and there's another few restrictions as you can I think every single handle card you have you need to have at least one good guy either like a hero or like an ally and if you've got these kind of villains which will score in different ways you know the items that they've got to um to wear all these different stuff which will synergize with each other some giving you negative points I'm giving you positive points trying to get the optimal bunch of cards in your hand by the time the game finishes now I'm sure if you're watching this one this video you know what fantasy Rams is all about so there's no point really talking about it much further but for me I would rather choose a fancy Browns over this one because I enjoy that wild nature of those high high scoring cards for me that makes it a bit more exciting and although it's harder to calculate your final score the original Fantasy Realms does have a very good scoring app to work out your scores for you so for those reasons I'd rather score fantasy Realms so rather play Fantasy Realms over a Marvel remix but I can certainly see why especially if you're a Marvel fan why you would choose remix over the original I have East India companies now this is an economic Euro based on the supply and demand mechanism uh it has a little bit of worker placement which I think is kind of Superfluous it doesn't really help the game much because you kind of know what you're doing anyway and if it was a bit rinse and repeat as you are
you know originally start with a very a bunch of basic ships then with the worker place in actions you're upgrading them maybe buying an extra spot for a new ship you're going to do that anyway so there's no real there's no real acts to get to those ones because you know what you're going to do before the game even begins then you're visiting these different locations loading your ship with these different goods and then trying to sell them based on this initiative order based on supply and demand so if you've got a particular resource where there's none left in the market you're gonna get a ton of money by refilling that particular resource type now I did find the game pretty predictable um you would kind of go through the same motions again and again it was a very procedural game where you do this then you do this then you do this then you do this then you do this and for me it did feel a little bit on on the rails and the scoring itself felt very incremental um there were a few little ways you when you could amplify your scoring um but for me it was too dependent on the initiative order where you the faster ships would fill up the markets quick quicker and get the high scoring um you know Goods or money for the goods you've delivered whereas if you're slower you get a much smaller amount of money which is you know the whole point of the game but for me it just didn't have those levels of excitement it did feel very much on the rails it actually reminded me of a game called Francis Drake which I think did everything this game does but better and I wasn't even a huge fan of the original Francis Drake because it was too long but
this one yeah I I just don't feel like it had a spark um I think it was a little bit too I don't know I just think it was too small and what it did it didn't have any exciting moments at all and that's sad already because I was quite excited to play this one because on paper it has a lot of things that I enjoy um but in practice I feel very much going through through the motions and um yeah it didn't really do it for me sadly so that is East India companies at number six at number five I have a black Shad weep now this is a two player only tile placement game as you are both building a map of these islands together trying to score based on the different elements on those tiles so you have these kind of fish markets where you will get random points by depending on where you place them tried to have the hotels that you're trying to build based on the amount of people on these different Islands um trying to build houses based on a sliding scale set collection benefit and whoever's got the most Coral of their color on the whole board will get a fixed amount of points and so on so very simple set collection benefits and ways to score points here but the Twist on this game is that when you're drafting these tiles to place onto the board um what's on one side will be reversed on the other side so say on one side there was um you know the purple players coral and the orange players Hotel you flip it the other way then it would be the orange players coral and the purple players Hotel so it's quite nice how you know for one pair a person it would be the
opposite on the other side and then you try to place them optimally trying to get as most points as you can by The Game's end now for me although I liked that kind of reverse tile mechanism and the idea of it for me it was quite obvious on how to optimally place each tile um for me some of the different scoring elements weren't as strong as the others for example I completely ignored that Coral each time I played this one and it really served me because in relation to all the other scoring mechanisms that was pretty much pretty minor I suppose of course they've got an island with a ton of people on it you've got to put a hotel on there to get the most points and so on so yeah it was always quite obvious about what to choose to get the most points but the game did flow very nicely it's a good introductory game um for tile placement if you want to play with younger children um but for me at this point it's not really what I'm looking for it didn't give me the highs it didn't give me anything to wrap my brains over and any real good decision space so that's why although I like the game I definitely would be playing it much more that is black shadow weep at number five at number four I have the Golden Ages now this is a euro civilization game by quinnid it came out quite a few years ago to very little Fanfare not many people know about this one but it does have quite a few redeeming this one way more than I thought I was going to I think it was a very nice game and definitely had more things develop and start to unravel the more I played it and thinking you know what what first
wasn't a parent did become apparent by the end but this one you are essentially building up this map trying to visit these different locations um tapping your exhausting your workers based on different things such as collecting wonders which will give you kind of ongoing powers or instant benefits um the same goes for these buildings and upgrading these Technologies on your player board to make you move faster or get you points based on different things you're controlling um making you more efficient attacking other players and so on now the whole Twist on this game is the timing element because generally if you want to do one thing something else is going to go to your opponent so there's very few options available to you there's very few buildings there's um a very few wonders available to you and there's a race to get your kind of buildings built on the map itself and again if you are going for this certain Wonder then that best building is going to go if you want to move this worker then that wonder is going to go so it's all about knowing you know what to prioritize I suppose now this game also had a very cool mechanism where if you are the first player to pass as in step out of the round then you get to choose a certain scoring criteria that will score for the end of the round so it might say um if I if I pass first I could say well I'll choose this tile here that's going to give me two points for every technology that I've unlocked and knowing that I'm way ahead of my opponent um I think that's going to suit me better because if they pass they're going to choose a different card and that's not going to help me at all that's going to help them way more than it's going to help me so sometimes you
have to give up um even actions to solidify the scoring criteria that you want and I also had some other wrinkles in the game where each round you get given a new kind of leader and you can choose to keep your existing one or or kind of commit to the new one which will give you new game breaking powers that can align with your overall strategy and sometimes it's worth you holding on to individual which happened in this game that we played um so I quite like the kind of micro decisions here that do build up to a bigger picture and again a game that you probably have to wait till halfway through the game to understand how everything fits together and understand all the moving parts so I was quite impressed by this one I'm not sure if I'm going to go back to it but at face value it was a very solid game one that I think is overlooked and underrated and I enjoyed it way more than I was expecting to so that is the Golden Ages at number four so let's get into the top three games now and this is where my accommodations will begin so at number three I have first Contact now I was very much on the fence with giving this one accommodation or not and that's not because I didn't enjoy the game immensely which I certainly did but it's because I think this game in the house is audience and some people are going to bounce off it hard because it's not the easiest game to teach and to internalize but this is a kind of semi-corruptive game as some people are going to be aliens some players are going to be the humans and you are trying to establish a
means of contacting um each other or talking through communicating with each other through this Unwritten language so you are as a game develops you are learning what certain words mean and the symbols correlating to those particular words and you're going to do that by kind of a code name system where the human players are going to tap a bunch of these cards in this Central area and the alien player is going to give a symbol um relating or linking all those particular cards together and then you know say you've got a bunch of animals for example you might give a symbol for animal therefore the players from now on know what animal means and then what the alien player is trying to do is he's trying to find a certain number of these items on the board and he wants the human players to give those items to to the alien so it's not the easiest game to explain verbally you do have to play maybe a ton or two to understand how the game works but once it flows it does flow nicely no the human players asking for word words mean and then the alien players asking for an artifact but it's very cool how you can start using symbols that haven't even been used yet or been asked for yet then the other place can kind of deduce what those words might mean and by the end of it you are just communicating with each other using a complete gibberish language which is quite fascinating so although there are some definitely um kind of teething issues here and there is a steep learning curve and some frustration at times when it clicks it is very satisfying and you can end up kind of talking with each other up and
get through this completely fabricated language so very um very different definitely a unique game one of the strangest games I've played at this last year and I think this game is very interesting um I I enjoyed it so much and it'll be interesting to see if it holds up to repeated plays once that novelty Factor has gone so that's why I'm on the fence with giving it a commendation so maybe it'll fall maybe the repeater plays will increase my enjoyment of it I think it might be a game that I have to play sparingly not too often um but when it hits the table I'm pretty sure it's going to hit so is is you know I think you're either Gonna Love it or you are going to find it frustrating I think but I personally fall into that former camp and right now I think it's a fantastic game so that is first Contact at number three at number two I have oligaranja now this is kind of more of my traditional um the type of games I enjoy a mid-weight Euro and with some multi-use card play and one of the best examples of multi-use carplay that I've seen to be honest as you are either kind of using these cards as contracts to try and put resources on them to get coverage on this area control part of the board you can use them as ongoing player Powers you can use them to harvest more Goods you can use them to fulfill more orders and you know if you don't want them you're going to give up on something else so I love that tension and then you go to a bit of a dice drafting phase and where you're getting kind of the option to play more cards to collect more resources
um and then you essentially trying to fulfill as many orders as you can you've got these again your personal contracts which will let you compete in that area control part of the game or you have these public contracts which if you complete them you'll get ongoing incomes such as getting these really cool commodity bonuses or getting you more resources each round getting more money each round a money in this game is extremely tight so again more traditional Europe there here I think that standout part of the game is definitely the multi-use card system but the rest of it I think it all harmonizes quite well despite initially being a little bit procedural um you know it goes to this phase to this phase to this phase but I think after a whole term structure through the game things start to resonate pretty quickly and then it flows very organically so I put this one a few times now it's gone down well each time I haven't tried any of the additional modules that come with the deluxe Master set of the game so that's kind of my next Port of Call is to try and introduce some of those modules to see how it adds some variety and some interest to that core gameplay which I enjoy a lot so definitely a strong recommendation from me um this is one of those games that was never really a huge Euro game out there but now it's got a uh you know it's been reintroduced with this new Deluxe theme on YouTube new Deluxe production um it's nice that more people have their hands on it and can enjoy solid well put together well-rounded Euro games like this one so that is like around her at number two and finally at number one I
have War chest so War chest is a kind of a pure abstract strategy game almost in their vein of Chess but much different than chess as you are using these military units to navigate around the map trying to control these different regions as soon as you have a certain amount of control markers on the board you will win instantly but the kind of coin system that you use in this game is so interesting and so well executed as you are kind of building up this bag full of these tokens and drawing three out of each round then you have to decide how to use those particular units are you going to deploy them onto the map are you going to use them to control existing units are you going to boost their strength to give them more Health points are you going to use their tactics because all of these different units have unique abilities for example The Archers can shoot at range though the Lancers can charge at you and you've got these Scouts that can spawn out in places and it's all about trying to exploit the small but hugely different abilities of each of these different units and because this game is so well balanced kind of every micro decision in this game is so important now the turnout is important now the how much you're adding into your bags bearing in mind that you can have a stronger unit on the board but if you have a stronger unit in the board that means there's fewer tokens in the bag to move and use that unit so many layers of the gameplay here that you know I can't even scratch the surface in a little summary like this and I think this game is genius and objectively Brilliant you know there's not many games out there that I think are objectively great
because you know this is such a subjective hobby but I think you'd have to go quite far to pick fault with this one it might not be your cup of tea but the game design is close to perfect especially when you add in the nobility expansion which not only added more units to play with but it adds another way to add new tactics and strategy into the gameplay as well to make it an even richer experience I'm absolutely mind blown by this one another game it's one of the best games I've played this year for sure and I think it is absolutely amazingly designed so if you like your abstract strategy games um then this one is a no-brainer but even if you don't traditionally like those games like I don't this one is still worth a look because although it does have that chest like feel to it because of that random nature of the token draws it's not perfect perfect information so you still have those moments of excitement and it's not so rigid as say a game of chess but that is war chest in love with this one for sure so that concludes the video hopefully you have enjoyed it and found it useful if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye