Top Ten Board Games of 2017
Transcript
hi I'm Adam Porter and this is my board gaming vlog and today I'm talking about 2017 so there's going to be a top 10 games of the year I want to briefly talk about my favorite expansions of the year but I'm gonna start off with my highlight of the year which predictably enough was this those are my two games that have been published this year doodle Russian Big Bazaar I'm gonna say nothing more about them because you can look up reviews for them online that'd be lots of good reviews from the prominent sort of reviewers in there in the board game world and you can find out more about them by looking back at my channel but how exciting to get my first two games out onto the market I also signed games with multiple other publishers so I've got other games coming out in 2018 2019 all signed and sort of ready to go now so it's an exciting time for me as a designer let's get on to the games that will run finally so the first thing is the the expansions my favorite expansions of the year so you can see on the table there are three expansions and they're three expansions for games that I really enjoy the most essential of those three expansions is undoubtedly the many many expansion for Sheriff of Nottingham and I'm not overstating it when I say that that is an essential expansion I would never play without it okay Sheriff of Nottingham started out as a great game for me I loved it and then you'd get a player who would twig that actually they
could often win the game by not really playing the game and what I mean by that is Sheriff of Nottingham is a game all about lying to your mates trying to sneak little bits of contraband past them in order to get the most valuable cards into your collection for endgame scoring but if you just told the truth for the whole game you could often win that way and I've seen people trying to help this as a positive but what it really means is that people just aren't playing the game and it became such a frustrating experience to be trying to engage with all that lying and bribery while another player just doesn't engage with it at all and then they go on and win serve I'm not in a Merry Men expansion changes all of that it introduces these special orders blackmarket sort of orders where you've got to get the elite goods in you got a lie you've got a cheat in order to win the game it's got some nice little thematic touches like sneaking a merry man into your sack and then getting them past the sheriff revealing them and then their special power happens you know and you get all this great sort of come back from it so it's a really nice little expansion with several different modules and you can pick and choose which of those modules you want to use the dream home expansion I'm not going to talk too much about that's a very simple one adds a nice little element of set collection to the game not really adding any complexity but that game didn't need it it's a nice family game from last year and it's nice to just have some extra stuff to do in the game the journeyman expansion for Isle of Skye adds a lot of complexity to the game I love scopes a fantastic game from a couple of years ago and it was sort of mid weighted you know it was it wasn't
for beginners but it wasn't a complex game well now it is a fairly complex game a lot of strategy a lot of thinking involved I must admit I haven't actually played this one yet I'm struggling to get it to the table just because it is that it's a bit heavier than the sort of games I would normally play but it looks really clever and really fun and so I'm looking forward to getting to playing it so let's get on to the top 10 games of the year from my point of view and I'm gonna say here my tastes are light okay they're lighter than the majority of the other youtubers that I watch I tend towards party games light games family games dice games trick-taking games this sort of thing what I do not like is episodic games I don't like scenarios based games where I have to play with the same group over and over again and commit to playing that game over a long period so you're not going to see pandemic legacy season 2 on this list and you're not gonna see gloom Haven or anything of its ilk I don't play long games or not very often I tend to play things that are fairly short fairly simple where we can get a few games done in an afternoon or an evening I like playing with you know might make my friends and their kids and their partners and and and keep it really light and and sort of simple sort of stuff that said I think there's some really interesting games in my top 10 games I haven't by any means played all the games that came out this year in fact I haven't played that many compared to previous years but that's because I've been getting a little bit more selective and I can spot now that's a game that wouldn't interest me now it doesn't mean it wouldn't interest you or anybody else but some of the
heaviest strategy type games I just haven't really considered them for this list so with all that said let's get stuck into my top 10 games of 2017 each round in cortex challenge one play will turn over the top card from the deck and all players try and solve the puzzle indicated on the card when a player has found the answer they put their hand onto the card and then they give their answer if they're correct they take the card for scoring but if they're incorrect they lose the card and they cannot give an answer in the next round when a player has got two cards of the same puzzle type in front of them they gain a brain piece and the first player to collect four brain pieces wins the game the puzzles are memory so the first one is a player has to describe all the items on the card without looking the second one is maze a player must declare which exit is the way out of the maze number three is color a player must state which word is written in its own color number four is coordination so a player must place the indicated fingers on to the indicated part of their face number five is duplicates where the player must declare which of the illustrations on the card is repeated number six is frequency where a player must declare which side of the dice appears most often on the card number seven reasoning the player must declare which shape fits into the missing slot and then number eight is the touch challenge where a player must feel a raised texture onto a card without looking at it and then declare what picture they think they're feeling now
this is one of those very simple little games where I played it and I thought I wish I'd thought of that I get that every now and then particularly when I'm playing these super light speed type games why didn't I think that is such an obvious idea so accessible everybody can understand it everybody can join in you're not going to be playing this over and over again for all you know you're gonna get through those puzzles pretty pretty quickly you can get a bit tired of them but what they've done since is brought out multiple new versions of brain Tokyo or cortex challenged with different themes for different age groups and things like this for me I've still only got that basic set and so it's something that I'll pull off the shelf every you know a few months or so just as a little warm up just to play for 10 minutes while we're waiting for people to arrive that sort of thing but it's a really good one I love that tactile thing where we have to we have to rub the card to sort of to sort of see you know see if you can work out which card it is just by feeling it all the different puzzles some people are good at the memory ones some people are good at that Stroop effect one where you've got to say the color but but but but not the you know you've us say which color is written in the correct color and they're mind-bending sort of stuff and but but it's really good it's really well produced and and I like it a lot
in crosswalk the players separate into two teams each team will have a clue giver for each round of the game and the two clue givers draw a card and determine a shared keyword which they will both try and put across to their teams a team wins the round if they guess the keyword before the other team each clue giver writes a private one-word clue and they pass it secretly to their own teammates the clue givers then alternate giving public clues which both teams can see the twist here that is that after a clue given gives a public clue the opposing team gets the first guess at the answer so the clues should really relate to the previously given private clue in order to hopefully throw your opponents off the scent experienced players will want to also use the hint board where once per round the clue giver can give a selection of hints to their team telling them to ignore certain clues or combine certain clues or to look for a synonym for the word they've given etc and when one team achieves 5 correct guesses they win the whole game so my number nine is crosstalk now crosstalk is an interesting party game and I think that's the best way to describe it it's really interesting it's not as accessible as some of the other party games like code names and the other big sort of successes it's it's quieter it's more cerebral and code names was always best with six players because there you've got one clue Giver and then you've got the two team members
who could discuss their ideas between themselves you can't even do that in crosstalk you can't discuss between yourselves because the other team would hear and they're trying to guess the same word as you so instead we resort to writing on little boards and showing them to each other now that is fun but it is quiet and it is a bit thinkI the other thing is that this is a game that swings massively you can have a really good round where it goes on for a while and people are really liking each other out and the two crew givers are trying to sort of play in this mental game of chess with each other and everyone's trying to read each other and that's fantastic when it happens but you also get these rounds where first clue somebody gets it and the round sort of falls apart and basically one of the clue givers hasn't really had Peugeot because the other team have got it too quickly just because the the clues that have been given usually the secret Clues by the to clue givers have got such synergy there's such similar sort of clues that the boat that you know that you give one clue and the other team gets it basically because they've got all the information available to them so there's some frustrations in the game but it is a very clever idea it's nicely produced and I'm very happy to play it every now and then it's I don't think it's going to be a classic party game that's gonna be remembered for years and years and years like code names appears to be but it's well worth taking a look at if you're all getting a little bit you know you've kind of done code names and you're looking for something similar it's different enough that it is well worth playing and owning both in Yamatai
each player is trying to score victory points on a pretty board honestly there's some backstory in the rulebook but this is basically what it amounts to on a player's turn they first select a tile which will give them a reward and determine player order for the next round they can then buy or sell a single boat the third thing a player may do on their turn is place boats onto the board in an uninterrupted chain the first vote in a chain must match the color of the adjacent boat or be placed on a designated starting spot thereafter the color of the boats is not limited a player must then collect tokens from the islands on the board one token per adjacent ship that you've placed or billed placing a building requires the island that you're building on to be surrounded by a specified selection of colored boats when a building is placed the player gains points or coins depending on what it's adjacent to and they take a tile that endgame scoring finally a player may spend their tokens to recruit a specialist which gives them rule-breaking abilities the game ends when a player places their last building or boats of one color of run out or the specialist or building decks have run out and a player with the most points from coins tokens buildings and special abilities wins number eight on the list is a very different sort of game this is Yamatai yamete is bruno khatallah and there's another designer as well who's the other designer mark mark pack Wien I'm not a
I'm not familiar with that designer this was sort of touted as a follow up to five tribes which was another days of wonder game by Bruno Katara a heavier sort of one often got criticized for thought that the change in the board state happening so much cut every turn so much would change that you really couldn't plan ahead so it was a game that was prone to play a sitting and reading the board for minutes at a time on their turn so ran very very slow and very very long if you played it with that sort of player now Yamatai has done nothing to address that Yamatai the decision space is enormous yeah you've got so many different options that you can do so much to read on the board and work out that it can really bog down and slow down there's also a weird turn order thing where you're selecting turn order which means that you could go first in one-one round and then go you know forth in another round which means that you've then got essentially eight turns before it gets back round to you so there's quite a lot of downtime potentially in the game the theme doesn't really come into it at all these are all criticisms that I could aim at the game and yet I really really enjoy it and that's because the puzzle just kind of makes sense to me it's one of those ones so all those things where a game just clicks with you where you can kind of you just it just feels right it just feels like a puzzle that I can work with I understand the mechanics of the game I can win the game not every time but I can win the game I can't say that for every game had a similar experience with a game called Grand Austria Hotel last
year a game that really clicked with me but not with every group that I played with and funnily enough another game with a weird turn order thing with loads of downtime but Yamatai hasn't clicked with everybody that I've played it with and it hasn't clicked with everybody I've seen talking about it online but I love it and I've played it with other players who have really enjoyed it too so it's not what I'd recommend to everybody but if you like the aesthetics of it if you like Bruno Katara's other games and the overview looks interesting to you I would recommend trying it out I think it's gone a little bit under the radar in London on a player's turn they first draw one city card either from the board or from the deck they then take one action the first action they could take is to place one or more cards in front of them to develop their city in order to add a card they first got to discard a card of the same color from their hand onto the board and sometimes they pay an additional cost if that's indicated on the card the second action available to them is to instead buy land this means taking one of the three face-up borough cards and paying its cost this gives you an immediate benefit and often it gives you an ongoing ability the third available action is to run your city this means you pay the activation cost of each card in the city that you wish to use you gain its benefits and its effects many cards will often then flip facedown so they can't be used again but
some remain face-up the player then receives poverty tokens for each stack of cards in their city for each loan they've taken out and for each card that they have in their hand the final available action for a player is to instead simply draw three cards the game ends when the city deck runs out and players then gain poverty for each card they have left in their hand they then score points from the cards in their cities pay back any loans if possible and lose points for unpaid loans and then they compare their poverty levels to each other and all except the player with the fewest poverty lose points the player with the most points wins number seven on my list is a bit of a cheat because it's a second edition it's London's second edition and the reason I've allowed it onto the list is because it's so different to the earlier version of London from what I've read there are significant changes to it and not just in terms of the aesthetics which are hugely overhauled and very very beautiful but also in terms of the gameplay itself now this is the first time I've played the game I haven't played it previously and Martin Wallace is is hitting on all cylinders for me it's he had an amazing year last year I really loved hits the road hits Zed Road and I really liked via nebula which was my game of the year lastly my number one of my top games of 2016 well the London's second edition feels every bit as current as those games even
though it's based on a much much older system it is a thinkI a heavier sort of strategy game there's some complexity there it's punishing the poverty system where you're constantly gaining poverty I mean constantly gaining poverty and trying to deal with it some players aren't going to like that if you don't like the system in Agricola which you probably a lot of people will have played where you've got to feed your workers all the time and if you don't you take great penalties in terms of points then you're not going to like the poverty system in London it's brutal I don't mind that sort of stress in games I like to know I've got to keep on top of that it gives me something to drive towards and I know what my strategies are cut back on the poverty pull back on the poverty don't let it get out of hand or ignore the poverty and work on something else I think it gives me some sort of something to drive for and so I've really enjoyed London it's got some interesting unique mechanism things that haven't seen before in games yeah it's a great one to check out if you like sort of medium to heavier strategy euro games
in Star Wars destiny each player selects a team of characters from their collection they're limited to 30 points which generally means using two to four characters per team each character has a card with special abilities and a custom die the different sides of the die generally show things like melee damage ranged damage forcing an opponent to discard a card or to lose a resource or to allow you to manipulate your own dice or to gain resources for yourself once the player has their team of characters sorted they need to construct a deck again using cards from their collection there are some limitations of what can go into your deck based on the color of the characters you've chosen and the allegiance of the characters so are they good or are they evil in each round of the game all players have 5 cards in their hand on their turn they can take one action this might be to activate a character there by rolling all of their dice note that the dice don't resolve automatically that would require another action this delay allows the opponent time to disrupt your plans removing orally rolling your dice through their own actions another common action is to play a card which can have all manner of different effects bolstering existing powers introducing new support dice weapons or abilities or simply manipulating the current state of play each card has a resource cost to play so resources need to be managed carefully a player can
always discard cards from their hand in order to reroll their own dice but care must be taken because running out of cards in your deck is one way to lose the game but the more common route to victory is by reducing your opponent's characters to zero hit points of course the game features an endless supply of rule baking cards dice and characters number 6 if you've watched my channel before you may well find this a bit of a surprising inclusion on the list and it's the first time I've ever dealt at delved into a collectible game with random boosters I've never played magic the gathering or yugioh or pokemon or anything like that but star wars destiny i got dragged in by my friend is I think it's fair to say that'll obsessed with Star Wars he wanted someone to play it with it was a dice game I love dice games it was a fairly cheap starter set we played it together I liked it I said yeah I'll buy it I'll get some of it I never intended to get as much as I ended up with so when I say I've never delved into a collectible game with random boosters before I now see what it's all about it's addictive isn't it buying that stuff opening it what am I going to get am I going to get the thing that I want if I don't get the thing that I want am I going to go out buy more boosters and open more packets or am I going to go online and pay an absolute fortune just to buy a dice and a card no I'll open some more boosters so you open some more boosters and now there's five things that you want because this would go really well with this and this would go really well with
this so I go and I o buy some more boosters and every time I walk into the board game shop I'm going to buy something else I'm going to look around the shelves maybe do you know those boosters 33 quid I could probably buy one of those but one's not much fun is it so that's by two or three or four and so the collection balloons blossoms grows and explodes and that I don't know whether I can recommend that to people it feels irresponsible the amount of money that I've spent on it that my friend has spent on it I mean it's not that I can't afford to do it it's just I don't know I spend more money on that game this year than on any other game and probably there's not many games that I've spent how much money on and is it good enough to warrant that well it is a really really good game it's a really good dice game I don't generally like games with lots of conflict I don't like games where I'm building something and another people break it down but I don't mind that if it's a head-to-head if that's the whole point of the game I don't mind it in my favorite game evolution which has a similar sort of feel actually to Star Wars destiny that idea of having your basic starting point adding cards and abilities to it attacking each other trying to take their abilities off them I think it's a good game really good I think it's I mean a lot of the game is played on your own building your deck before you even meet up with your mates that bit I find difficult I'm not sure I'm terribly good at it but there are
ways around that I mean my friend and I have started now playing that after we play a game we swap decks and we play with the other person's characters to see how we get on so that there's no longer that sort of limitation of all he's better at building a deck than me or he's got better cards than me and his collection because we're going to play at both ways and as it turns out he beats me both ways which suggests that my deck building isn't the problem it's actually how I play the game but it's a nice game if you like dice games and if you like Star Wars it I mean it's fun just the theme of it isn't it looking at those pictures which characters do you get you know the characters the iconography is good it's a fairly simple system I really like it Star Wars destiny in the two-player game Tokyo Highway each player has a collection of roads pillars junctions and cars the aim of the game is to be the first to get rid of all of your cars on a player's turn they place a new road they do this by first positioning a pillar it must have a height either one above their previous pillar or one below it they may never touch the opponent's roads or pillars if a player's Road crosses their opponents road and importantly no other roads are already crossing it then the player can place a car onto the road and equally if a player places their Road under an opponent's road and no other roads are under it then they can place a car with really clever positioning sometimes a
player can place two or three cars in a single turn by putting their road under and over several of the opponent's roads in a single move junctions allow you to vary the height of your pillars without restriction and they also allow you to branch off in different directions but you only have three of these so use them sparingly if any roads are knocked over during construction they're rebuilt and the careless player gives pillars to their opponent as a penalty the game ends when one player uses their final car in this case they win or the game could also end when one player runs two pillars and in this case they lose number five on my list is probably the most obscure game on the list the one that's going to be hard to get hold of it's called Tokyo highway and it is a Strangelove dexterity game with aspects of sort of abstract strategy positioning aspects to it so it's not just about do you have steady hands it's also about if I position there will he position there and then maybe I could go there so planning a few moves ahead and that sort of out and maneuvering each other working out when you're going to come in and try and cut over the roads or under the roads it's quite a thinkI quite a quiet abstract strategy game it's compared to the dexterity games this is by far the most thinkI quiet one that I own but you build such a beautiful structure when you're playing the game the whole thing looks great and then
when it collapses it has that the hilarity of a simple game like super rhino and yet the decisions in it are meteor there are two actual decisions you know real thought that goes into it I think it's a clever game the rules are simple but there are strategies in there it looks great it's a nice package attractively produced I think if you can get hold of a copy I think it's a really good two-player game again not for everybody some people are going to find this frustrating people with big clumsy hands frustrating people who don't like that sort of thinking several turns ahead they're going to find it frustrating so it's not going to be for everybody but for that small subset of people who like abstract strategy and attractive games and dexterity games this is a perfect one
in Barron Park each player is building their own Zoo which is populated only by bears and koalas which are not bears on a player's turn they place a tile from their supply onto their own player board if this covers an icon they then collect a tile from the central board corresponding to that icon and place it into their supply if they cover several icons they will gain several tiles on their turn no tile can be placed over the pit and if a board is entirely filled except for the pit then a bear statue is placed into it scoring points and the statues reduce in value is more at Eichen so there's a race to get the board's filled quickly and score the highest points if a construction crew is covered then a new board is added to a player's park and what's four boards are completely filled in a single players park then the game ends and points are counted the players score points for each tile on their board and for achieving variable goals for example having three polar bear tiles or six green areas etc the deck for each tile type is limited and the highest-scoring tiles sit at the top so the entire game is based around beating your opponents in the race for highest scoring tiles and before on the list and this is the first of the games there are four games on this list which I would say are instant classics I think these games will be around for years talked about for years I mean I can't say that they're games that everybody should have in their collection necessarily and I'll come on
to that with some of the later entries but I think they're brilliant brilliant designs and the first of these is Barron Park Barron Park takes everything that was fun about Hoover Rosenberg's patchwork patchwork being a two-player tire laying game with Tetris type pieces and turns it into a four player game in doing so it actually manages to make the game simpler the gameplay is so simple there's barely any rules to it and yet really interesting decisions every turn about positioning about racing to beat the other players to the best piece is the game looks beautiful it's got a quite a difficult sort of setup you know it is a game that takes a little while to set up and that's quite frustrating but this is really a game you can play with anybody and endlessly expandable I hope there'll be expansions for this I think it's a really clever sweet intelligent game I mean Phil Walker Harding who designed this is hitting on you know he's really doing a good job over the last few years with Imhotep and sushi go and cacao and now this this is a designer that anything he produces I'm gonna look out for so Baron Park I can't speak highly enough about it I think it's a it's a great great game
in dice Forge each player has two dice and an inventory where they can keep track of any resources gold and points they've gathered on a player's turn all players roll their two dice simultaneously and add any resources or points rolled on to their inventories the player whose turn it is now purchases cards from the display which cost resources but gives special abilities and victory points or they can purchase new sides for their dice the dice are adjusted immediately by clicking off the existing sides and replacing them with new improved sides purchasing new sides for dice costs gold if a player decides to purchase cards from the display they place their porn into the space by their chosen card and if a pawn is already there that pawn is returned to its owner who then receives a reward basically they get to immediately re-roll their two dice and gather the appropriate resources the game ends after nine or ten rounds depending on player count by which time players are going to be generating massive amounts of resources each turn from their improved dice and purchasing the high-scoring cards which cost many resources the highest score at the end of the game wins number three on the list is dice Forge so dice Forge is a strange game it's is innovative it's not the first game that has done this idea of snapping new sights onto onto different dice other games have done it the Lego games have done it before and the game what was it called was it
rattle bones I can't remember there's a game previously that that had a similar sort of mechanism but this is the first one that's really made it work and made it into an interesting strategy game it feels very much like a deck building game a deck building game being a game where you collect cards and you create a deck throughout the game and your deck gets better and better the difference here is that if you're adding sides onto a dice so let's say I have a regular dice and I add an extra six on it so now it's got two sixes on it well there's still a chance that I'm never going to roll that six so unlike a deck building game where I'm always gonna work all my way through that deck at some point that special card expensive card that I bought is going to come out that's not the case in dice Forge my six might never come out or it might come out every single turn for the rest of the game so this is a game that feels a little bit more luck-based than those deck builders it's it's there is strategy in it there certainly is but it is quite suing you it is quite luck based I don't mind that I enjoy it I enjoy dice rolling I love the aesthetic of the game and love the tactile nature of clipping the pieces onto the side and there are clever luck mitigation aspects in it the insert in the game is the best insert I've ever seen and the game is very affordable for what you get in the box I think it's a very very clever interesting beautiful starting point for a system and I hope that it sells well
enough that it will start to get expansions because I think with expansions it could get really interesting as a game system it's going to turn some people off because of the swing enos of it because of the fiddle enos of of kind of you know flicking these pieces off and losing these pieces and everything like that it does feel like something that when you get it out you're like on edge like oh these things gonna get lost as they sort of fly across the room but I would I would recommend this to I've played this with fairly with kids of about eight or nine up to you know and certainly adults can have fun with the game it's not a complex thing but there are nice decisions in there and it plays in a fairly short time frame - so dice Forge another fantastic game from live alert
in the cooperative game magic maze the players are trying to get a team of heroes out of a shopping mall although there are four heroes they're not owned by any specific player any player can move any hero instead each player has a limitation on how they can move the heroes so one player can only move heroes north one player can only move them south one player moves west and one moves east one player can open doors and reveal new tiles another player can use escalators a timer is flipped over and players start moving heroes freely as often as they wish bearing in mind their limitations of movement they're attempting to get the heroes onto a matching colored symbol and then get out of a matching colored exit and this isn't easy the difficulty is compounded by the fact that the players are not allowed to speak to each other that's right the game is played in silence players may however indicate to another player that they need their help by placing a large red wooden pawn in front of them they cannot say what they need them to do the red pawn just means do something there are areas of the board where the team can flip the timer over and discuss strategy but generally the game lasts for a frantic 15 minutes after which players will have all won together or all lost together number 2 on the list is the spirit of Yara's nominee for last year magic maze now this one really took
me by surprise it's it's a real-time cooperative game and I don't GN really like real-time cooperative games the ones that I've played before I struggled a bit with but this one the rules are so simple it can be frustrating for some players people can get shut out of it you've got to be confident getting it again and getting in there people are gonna get you're not allowed to talk to each other but people will be tapping tapping the the pawn their to try and that that wooden piece to try and get you to take an action and and people can get quite aggressive with that which can pop your were lang on hang on you know you'll because you're not allowed to speak you feel you have to right I'm really going to emphasize this now which means banging that piece on the table so it can get a little raucous it can get a little bit frenzied but the game is so clever the fact that I don't control the heroes that are on the board I can control any of them everybody can control any of them but I'm only allowed to move in one certain direction and actually as you continue through the game that changes which direction I can move them in switches up throughout the game so the whole thing is constantly in flux and then there's like 20 different scenarios in the rulebook just to increase the complexity of the game and I haven't even got the expansion yet so I don't even know what that adds it's a brilliant design and really really unique and interesting and I would say at this point is the best real time
cooperative game that I've played I would say it beats escape curse of the temple in in that which was previously you know the big sort of poster child for this genre of game so magic maze if you don't mind something very frantic very short then then I think this is this is a lot of fun and I can I can definitely recommend magic maze
in untold adventures await players work together to tell a story in a 5 act structure inspired by rollin story cubes these are dice with icons which can be interpreted however you wish players begin by answering a few questions about their chosen setting and writing some notes they need to decide things like is this past present or future where does the story take place and what is the tone is it comedy fantasy or high drama a tile is flipped to represent a dangerous dilemma players select story cubes to place onto the tile inspiring a location and a threat the tile dictates whether the threat is attacking or capturing or pursuing or accusing someone or something players now create their characters again they're filling out a short sheet and they're answering some questions they reroll and use the cubes to inspire them in this the board indicates that players can now collectively ask for questions about the scene and take four actions if they ask a question they take a question token they reroll the cubes and they use them to answer the question if a player takes an action they take an action token and they declare what they're trying to achieve they then turn over a card to indicate yes a success no a failure yes and which is an incredible success yes but which is success but with a price no and which
is disastrous failure or no but which is unsuccessful but with an upside they may also be required to turn over a reaction card which shows the emotional impact on any one character of their choice and what's all actions and question tokens have been taken players turn over the next tile called the plot thickens the cubes are placed to represent an evil ally or an evil master or a terrible secret or a dark agenda and the tiles indicate whether this is linked to the previous threat or to the previous personal thing that was under threat players now ask questions and they take tokens and then they move on to act 3 which is called an unheroic undertaking act for which is the truth revealed and then finally they wrap the story up in act 5 the final showdown each time they're selecting cubes they're asking questions and they're taking actions throughout the game each player can play tokens from their own supply to add an idea to another player's suggestion or to modify a role of a cube or to describe a flashback in time they can also flip their play pause card to force a timeout where all players discuss the direction of the story and whether they feel engaged with it when the story is complete players write some notes and decide whether this is a one-off adventure or whether the characters and settings they've created will become part of a bigger campaign a number one on the list I've raved about in my recent Essen 2017
review and that's the game untold adventures await easily the best storytelling game that I've that I've played and I really want to like storytelling games but I've struggled to find ones that really satisfy me I don't like games that tell me a story I'm not really interested in a narrative that is driven by the game itself I'm not interested in reading flavor text and being told all about my character in great passages of text I don't really care for that sort of narrative in games but I do like narrative that is created by the players and that's what untold has in spades untold you can create a story in any setting with any characters and those Rory Story cubes are a strange little component there there so in some ways they're so limiting because although I've got what have I got 9 dice in a set of Rory story cubes with six images on them so 54 different images in actual fact if I roll the Sheep I'm never going to be able to roll the magnifying glass because it's on the same dice as the Sheep and so actually the combinations aren't that great so you do see the same things over and over again when you're using Rory story cubes as opposed to a deck of picture cards but the great thing about untold is that it forces you to reincorporate these jeez but also a sheep doesn't always mean a sheep if you're playing untold at the beginning of the game before you even roll any dice you decide on a setting so you might decide on the Wild
West or you might decide that we're setting on Mars or on a movie set or in a tolkien-esque fantasy world in which case that sheep in icon is going to mean something different in every different setting and that's where the game really comes into its own you really can create worlds with this game and I mean you can play it as a single one-off game which is probably realistically what I'm going to do because I've said before I don't really like episodic games but you can actually use this as like an RPG system where the same characters come back in multiple stories and you keep track of stuff and yet it's so simple it's simple enough for children and families to play it's beautifully produced I can't rave enough about untold adventures await it's not going to be for everybody it requires a lot of creativity and imagination and if you're not skilled at sort of reining things in you can still end up telling these big meandering stories and where the problems with games like a dark overlord things and once upon a time is that the stories can become really convoluted and we start to step outside of we're not the incorporating anything and ideas just get lost and thrown away and suddenly we've got you know a we're on Mars but suddenly there's a football World Cup happening or something completely you know original which doesn't actually fit the setting people don't understand to kind of stay within that term I'm getting into improv speak here because I've got a bit of a history of doing improvised storytelling but that circle of expectation where you
know if we're on Mars what we want to be dealing with is craters and meteors and aliens and robots and Space Station's not you know doughnuts and armchairs and you know it's that's the sort of problem that can happen with storytelling is that people go off on these flights of fancy and and I'm told there's nothing really to deal with that okay you still need players to rein it in keep it tight I'm hoping that I'll make a future video where I talk a little bit about improvised storytelling and try and give some tips and advice on how to manage that stuff but with the players that I've played it with we've had an absolute fantastic time I love the game I think it's by all but certainly the best game of 2017 is untold adventures await okay so thanks very much for watching my video if you enjoyed it please watch some of my other videos please subscribe to my channel I'm on board game geek I'm Adam 78 on YouTube I'm Adams board game Wales on Twitter I'm at board game Wales have a look at my games as well I'd really like it if people took you know have a look at doodle rush and Big Bazaar and if you're interested pick up a copy Big Bazaar in particular is available everywhere I think doodle rush is is getting that way I think it'll be a little bit more available in the early parts of 2018 in some areas but either of them is a fantastic Christmas gift if you want to pick one up anyway thank you very much for watching and all the best