London (Second Edition) Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About London (Second Edition)
Reviewers consistently describe London (Second Edition) as a serious, rewarding strategy game that rewards careful planning, though they are clear that its heavier edges will not suit everyone. Martin Wallace designed the game, and in this set of reviews the common thread is admiration for how its theme, card play, and economic pressure fit together. Adam Porter, Board Game Wales ranked it seventh in their 2017 year-end list, noting that although it is built on a much older system, it feels "every bit as current" as the newer releases they rated highly. Adam Porter was also the first to say that they had only just played it for the first time, which made their enthusiasm stand out.
Foster the Meeple placed the game sixteenth on a top 50 countdown after a single play, predicting that it would climb as the group explored it. The hosts were drawn to its theme and strategy in equal measure, and they described it as a game that "really clicked" in a way few others had. The Brothers Murph, The Brothers Murph, joked during a trivia segment that London was their least favorite game on the planet, then conceded that it is in fact a great game. Watch Review, in a separate countdown, went further and said that London is one of the games they most want to recommend, placing it thirty-fifth.
Core Mechanics That Define London (Second Edition)
Tableau Building
Tableau building sits at the center of the experience. Each turn, a player draws a city card, then takes one of several actions, and the most common is to develop the city by placing new cards in front of them. Adam Porter explained that a card can only enter the city after the player discards a card of the same color from their hand, and some cards add a further cost. Players can also buy land from one of three face-up borough cards, which gives an immediate benefit and often an ongoing ability. Foster the Meeple described the game as a "tableau builder," and the layout of the city is central to how each player's plan takes shape over the game.
Engine Building
The engine element emerges from how those city cards are used. Players eventually take a "run the city" action, paying the activation cost of each card they want to use to gain its benefits and effects, and many cards then flip face down so they cannot be used again until later. Foster the Meeple said that the game is "a bit of an engine build," where early investments generate victory points and income that trigger one another as the city grows. Watch Review described the result as a card-driven economic game in which players build routes and structures that feed each other, which is why the reviewers return to the idea of engines when they describe the middle and late stages of play.
The London (Second Edition) Experience
Relentless Pressure From Poverty
The most discussed feeling in these reviews is the constant pressure of poverty. Players accumulate poverty tokens for each stack of cards in their city, each loan they have taken out, and each card left in their hand, and the game ends with players comparing their poverty levels. Adam Porter described this system as brutal and was candid that some players will dislike it, but they valued the stress it creates. Adam Porter said that they do not mind this sort of pressure because it gives them "something to drive towards," and that the central task is to balance the need to pull back on poverty against the rewards of scoring cards.
Engine Building Through Shared Information
Foster the Meeple highlighted the way that London (Second Edition) lets every player see the same cards on offer, so the table can read one another's intentions. That openness creates a sense of quiet competition, because a player who sees a rival building toward a particular type of structure can choose to draft around it or pick away at their engine. The reviewers present this as a deliberate and enjoyable tension rather than a flaw, and they describe it as a game where the best moves often come from reading what others are doing.
What Makes London (Second Edition) Stand Out
A Theme Brought to Life
Reviewers repeatedly return to the theme of rebuilding London after the Great Fire, and they feel that the game delivers it. Watch Review noted that players take loans, build residences, workplaces, and schools, and gradually shape the city in a way that makes the subject feel present on the table. Adam Porter pointed out that the second edition is a substantial overhaul, with aesthetics that are "hugely overhauled and very, very beautiful," as well as meaningful changes to the gameplay itself. Osprey Games publishes the new edition, and Watch Review contrasted it with Martin Wallace's earlier release under Wallace's own Treefrog Games label, praising the improvements made in the revision.
Accessible Depth
Despite its reputation for tough decisions, London (Second Edition) is described as easier to teach than its weight suggests. Watch Review said that it is relatively easy to get into and to explain, and that its complexity sits above a traditional Monopoly style game without becoming overwhelming. Foster the Meeple described the experience of playing it for the first time as surprisingly fast to grasp, and the reviewers agree that a few plays are enough to start building a meaningful plan. That combination of approachable rules and layered decision making is a key reason why the game earned a place on several lists.
Potential Drawbacks
Setup and Teardown
The most common practical complaint is the time required to set up and put away the game. Watch Review called setup and teardown the biggest issue with London (Second Edition), describing it as a real pain in the neck, though they felt the payoff was worth the effort. The game also has no solo mode as far as Watch Review knows, which limits the number of occasions it can be played. Players who want a quick, low-effort game on a weeknight may find that the preparation discourages them from reaching for it.
A Punishing Poverty System
The poverty system is also the feature most likely to divide players. Adam Porter argued that anyone who dislikes the constant feeding demands of Agricola will find the poverty pressure in London harder to enjoy, because the game makes poverty a steady drain on every decision. Adam Porter said the system is "brutal," and while they personally welcomed that stress, they acknowledged it will be off-putting for players who prefer lighter, more forgiving economies. Watch Review offered a more measured view, saying that Martin Wallace games can be brutal and that this one is "semi-brutal" rather than extreme, but the message from both reviewers is consistent: the difficulty is part of the design and should be expected.
If You Enjoy London (Second Edition)
The reviewers offered several recommendations that line up with the particular pleasures of London (Second Edition). Adam Porter linked London's poverty pressure to the feeding demands of Agricola, so players who enjoy keeping a difficult resource system in check will likely appreciate the same tension in London. Watch Review grouped London with San Juan, Race for the Galaxy, and Glory to Rome as games that share a similar card-driven economic feel, while each keeps its own identity.
The card-based engine and the sense of building a tableau that produces income and victory points connect Race for the Galaxy to London's core loop, which is why it is a natural next step for fans of the city-building cards. Watch Review included Glory to Rome among the closest comparisons, and the shared focus on building a card-driven economy around a limited set of actions makes it a sensible choice for players who want more of the same style.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I don't mind that sort of stress in games. I like to know I've got to keep on top of that, and it gives me something to drive towards. I know what my strategies are: cut back on the poverty, pull back on the poverty, don't let it get out of hand, or ignore the poverty and work on something else."
— Adam Porter, Board Game Wales
"I really really enjoyed the theme and I really liked the strategy because it is open drafting, so everyone has access to the same cards and you can kind of see what people were trying to do. There's definitely a mean element to this, where you can start picking away at people's engine build."
— Foster the Meeple
"London, I cannot recommend it enough. It's just, it's brutal in a way, but it's not, that's not too brutal. I don't think so. I think you could be okay with that, because sometimes Martin Wallace games could be a little bit brutal, but this is sort of semi-brutal."
— Watch Review