Are These Board Games BROKEN?
Transcript
All right, made it. So, I had a lovely trip down a flight of stairs and as a result, I snapped couple ligaments in my ankle and so I've had to use a pair of crutches. Haven't been able to go out very much. Uh, so it's given me a lot of time to think and think about board games in particular. Hi, my name's Danny. I'm an avid modern board gamer from Australia who loves sharing my passion for this hobby with you, my friends, and my family. Let's have a look at what games have I been pondering about that I think could be potentially broken. Don't forget to subscribe for some more wholesome board game content. So, I injured my ankle about a week and a half ago, and basically what happened was I was heading down to this jetty. Uh, and there were these brick stairs that kind of were a little bit uneven. I was about to take a photo and I thought, "Oh, it'd be a great place to take a photo if I put my camera on one of the steps and then turn on the timer so that we could all take a nice photo of this beautiful location that I was in. I was there with a group of friends.
What happened was my eyes were concentrated on where I was going to place the camera that I wasn't watching where I was stepping. And so I thought there was a step, but there wasn't a step. In fact, there was a big drop. And then what happened was I actually missed about two steps, I think, as I tumbled down. And as I landed on my foot, I actually rolled my ankle and then I heard a couple of pops. kind of like you know when you crack your knuckles or you hear your knees click. It was like that but it was like a snapping sound and then I had this immense sharp pain that kind of was felt like a spear digging into the side of my ankle. I actually almost start well I think I started crying because of how sharp the pain was. We were whilst we were in in this beautiful location along the water I was like oh my goodness I'm not even at home. How am I supposed to get home? And um we're at the bottom of this hill. So, one of my friends and my hubby actually lifted me up and then I had to hop. And every time I hopped, oh my goodness, the pain was really intense. And then I looked down at my ankle and it had bloated or inflamed into this big ball.
Um and so obviously I realized at that point there was some damage. I didn't know if there was a fracture. I didn't know if I could walk on it in a few hours, but just based on how it felt and in the moment, I really couldn't do anything. And so that afternoon went to the doctor and the doctor said, "Okay, look, you've done something to your ankle. It's probably torn ligaments, could be a fracture. Uh, we won't know until you've done some x-rays and an ultrasound." So, couple of days later, I went and had the ultrasound and X-rays, and yep, I've torn a few ankle ligaments. And it turns out that in your ankle, there's actually a lot of ligaments um holding it together that help it to rotate and move the way it does. And basically was saying, you'll uh probably need to be on crutches for about 3 weeks. It's going to take 6 weeks to repair. You need to do physio.
And yeah, so I've been sitting around just pondering about, you know, board games and during my recovery, watching lots of uh board game content on YouTube. Uh yeah, if you've ever kind of injured your ankle, I'd love to know like what you did to pass the time. What did you do in order to help uh help your ankle repair itself or your leg repair itself? These things I think take 3 seconds. 3 seconds. it took to happen yet 6 8 weeks maybe 12 weeks to actually recover fully. Now, I found the deep dive of exploring different games that were labeled as broken quite an interesting one because when I think of something that's broken, I basically think this game is unplayable. Unless you're using this strategy, you might as well not try anything else. And so, I feel like when a game is labeled broken, it does taint that game a lot. and other people who hear the term broken think, well, I'm probably not going to give that game a try. And so, there's lots of different ways to kind of test for balancing in a game, and that's through thorough play testing and thorough feedback, especially when the game is at that kind of pre-publishing stage. But then if you've discovered a broken strategy post-publishing stage and I guess uh there are a lot of games especially when there's card combos involved, it's very easy to oversee some of those things.
And so it was really interesting to see uh what games were titled as broken or some games were in a category which were titled as having an overpowered strategy. And so a lot of games to try and combat that, they either remove a particular piece of the combo and ban it from play as an official rule or they release like a mini expansion to try and counter the combo that I think lots of people have discovered is quite a strong combo. And so it was interesting to discover what titles kind of addressed this idea of a game being broken in different ways. And suffice to say, there's not too many games that are considered to be broken. So you don't need to sell off half of your board game collection on your shelf. But and I guess it also comes down to interpretation and whether you recognize that as a powerful combo because there's a lot of counter strategies that can be brought into play. So one of the earliest games that I got that I and I've known about this broken combo for a long time and they've rectified it by actually removing the card from future editions or just slightly altering it.
And it's a game called Steampunk Rally. It's actually my hubby's favorite Euro game. And basically, you're building these machines and you're racing them across the Swiss Alps. And the machines have different parts to them where you can put uh different colored dice. There's steam dice, fire dice, and electric dice. And then you can use those to generate movement. Uh you can take damage. You can vent dice. You can get cogs. And cogs are particularly useful currency in the game because they help you to increase the pit value because once you place a die on a spot, it won't be able to be removed unless you kind of vent the dice and get it down to zero. And so the combo and synergies that are potentially in this uh engine building literal engine building game are quite numerous. The broken combo requires the combustion chamber, blast pipe, galvanic brakes, and theroup. Now, the first thing you'll need in this combo are the four machine parts plus some cogs and a red and yellow dye. You're then going to make sure you roll the dice, it doesn't really matter because when you place the red dye here, this star symbol means it doesn't matter what value it is, you'll still get this effect. So, you'll get a cog and you'll get a yellow dye, which I'm just going to roll. Then after that, you're going to go up to the combustion chamber. You're going to take one of the yellow dice that you've just acquired or had before. Doesn't matter what value it is cuz it's a star. You'll get a cog and you'll get two blue dice, which I'm
going to roll. The values don't really matter here. You'll see why. Then you're going to place one of the blue dice on the blast pipe, which doesn't matter what value cuz you got the star symbol. It allows you to lose one shield, but then you you can then take off one of each color dye. So, we'll take off the red, take off the blue, take off the yellow. And so this is what's still in my pool. And so because you've taken one here, you kind of want to balance it out. So you take your other yellow dye, place it on the galvanic brakes. Now, if your die value is say less than three, you can pay some of the cogs you've just acquired uh to pump it up to three. And then you'll be able to oh, you can pump it all the way up to six if you want because then you'll be able to take multiple red dice and restore health because this number in the game means that if you can double that number, you get double the effect. And so cuz I had a six, I'll get two red dice and also two life, restoring the health that I lost earlier. Now you want to use one of the red dice to power this thermouple, which will give you another cog and a yellow dye. You place the blue dye that you acquired before on the blast pipe, allowing you to take one life and also removing these through three different colored dice. When game designers create a game, especially if it's a card game, card synergy, card combo, and variability are high on the list of things to try and cover in a game. And
so when this game was announced, it was met with huge popularity and huge interest, mainly because of the forest theme. And the game is called Forest Shuffle. Now, this game is all about uh drafting trees, drafting insects, and different multi-use cards. And the cards can kind of be tucked above the tree, on the sides of the tree, and under the tree. And so, there's a butterfly strategy, there's a deer strategy, wolf strategy, there's also insect strategies that you can kind of pursue. And so the base game had one quite overpowering dominant strategy that if you knew what you were picking. And I guess upon a few plays, you can kind of discover this strategy pretty quickly, it was kind of exploited in a lot of future games. And a lot of people discussed that this strategy was quite a strong one if you had a lot of experience with this game.
The scoring power of collecting and going heavy into deers and wolves is really really powerful because of the multiplication strategy. Here you get three points for uh times every leaf icon that you have in your tableau. Here you get three times any of those icons. And then here with the wolves you get five times the number of deer icons in you have in your tableau. So if you just hoard all the deers and then have two or three wolves, that's going to be a really really big multiplier. And that's on top compounded on top of the multipliers the D's themselves also have with the other symbols. So very very powerful and potent card strategy. The um designers have released two mini expansions after the base game that have introduced cards that helps to rectify some of this uh balancing issue and stopping people from going down this really strong overpowering scoring strategy. Now, Uve Rosenberg is a game designer that I've started to become a little bit more fond of. Um, I've typically been like a Stefan Feld fan through and through, but more recently I think I've come to understand why a lot of people love Uve Rosenberg and I've really kept a lot of Uve Rosenbergs at a distance from me. I didn't really like Patchwork, wasn't really a big fan of a Gricola. And so I think the game that really lured me in was the game glass road. This was a game that really, I
guess, distilled some of the complexities and interest and the frills of a Uve Rosenberg game into a more digestablesized format. And so when I got Glass Road, I really loved it solo mode. I love the card play where you kind of try and pick an a worker action but not match with other players. Brilliant. Brilliant. And the point scores in this game are super low. So, you're really trying to milk everything that you can get. But the first edition of Glass Road actually came out with a four tile building combo. Now, in this game, getting buildings out is not particularly easy. Getting the resources is particularly hard cuz they have these little resource stars that when you have certain combination of resources, they convert to glass or they convert to brick, I think. And so there is there was a four building combo uh that was discovered in the original game that led to a situation where you could just max out on all your resources. I mean, how cool is that? In the original version of Glass Row, before this cool resource combo was found, the roofing company allowed you to pay one brick to get it to become two any two resources. Players could then use those resources on the hardware store, the sand screening plant, and the sandstone factory. It might be putting uh one brick, turning into two timber, two timber, then converting it into four clay. Then the four clay could then become eight sand.
And then the sand could then be returned into bricks. And that brick could then be reused in with the roofing company. And so the cycle of resource maximizing occurs again and again and again. So whilst it doesn't net you lots of uh points, I guess there are some kind of endgame building tiles in Glass Road that could exploit the use of the maximum resource strategy. But um in general, they had to end up removing the roofing company tile from future printings of Glass Road. Now, games that come with hundreds of different cards with different abilities are going to always encounter uh card balance issues, ones where some cards feel like they are underpowered, and some cards that feel like they're overpowered. I guess when you play collectible card games, they can kind of be ranked in ti. You got your common cards, your uncommon cards, and your like high standard, big budget, big tier cards. And so a game like Wingspan is just going to have that chance of because you've got so many so many different variations, so many permutations and combinations that different cards are going to flourish in different situations. And it's almost humanly impossible to test for those different situations. And it's not until you release the game and thousands of people play a game like Wingspan before these sorts of conversations and situations do emerge. Whilst they're not gamebreaking per se, they're not broken, they do mean that certain players have a
stronger advantage if they know what they're doing and what those cards can do to exploit uh the experience and enjoyment of a game, especially if they're versing players that aren't as well-versed in a game or experienced in a game. Here are some of the most OP cards from the game, Wingspan. You've got this raven, which when activated, you can discard one egg from any of your other birds and gain two of any resource from the supply. This one does the same, which is basically losing one resource, gaining two wild resources. Here, you can discard one egg and then gain one wild resource from the supply. These four cards, if you get them out very early in the game, are going to give you so much flexibility. Then you've got Franklin's Gull that when you activate, you discard one egg card to draw two cards from the bird deck, giving you a plethora of options. And the net gain that you're going to get from using any of these cards if in combination or on their own are really going to give you a big advantage in the game because they give you more flexibility, more resources that you can kind of use to pay for different types of birds, but also the extra card draw and the boosting of using that particular row plus getting this effect from that row too is exponentially really really powerful. Also wanted to mention that this one also has a very good exchange rate. Now, the next game is an evolution of another game called Evolution. Oceans is a game where you're building different sea creatures. You're placing
trait cards on your sea creatures to give them abilities to hopefully allow them to forage, survive, increase their population, and then hopefully expand over the course of the game. Now, Oceans is one of those games that gives players that feeling of trying to work out which traits go well together and how those traits interact with the other players at the table, but also amongst your species cuz there's certain cards that have adjacency effects. And so, on a deep dive into a possible overpowered combo in Oceans, uh there is a really cool combo that that nets you a lot of points per round. Typically in oceans, you're going to feed one of your uh fish species and then at the end all of your um species that you have are going to age and that's going to I guess allow you to tuck away one point per species that you have provided that there's population on those species. And so this combo has a way of increasing the amount of points that you can tuck away per turn, which gives you a more mathematical and numerical advantage over other players who don't really know this combo. Now, in a game of oceans, each fish species can have a maximum of three traits, which are represented by these cards. This is one species. This is a second species. This is a third species. And the species placement is going to be important for adjacency effects that you'll see in a few seconds. So this middle uh particular
species has filter feeder has a forage value of five and never overpop populates which means if you fill up your fish board if you have excess you kind of have to discard them uh which is not a good thing. And this one has schooling, which means it can't be attacked when it has five or more population, which is good because whenever this feeds, it's going to have a population of five or more. And when it ages, you'll score one extra fish behind your screen cuz each species will age. And basically, any uh species that are aged get stored behind your screen as endgame victory points. So, this will net you two victory points every time it's uh aging. Then these two species on the side are going to really be crucial for netting you extra. And this is an interesting combo. So not only does this age twice, but it can't be attacked and it never overpop populates. That's a powerful combo in itself. But this whale cleaner here goes. When a species with three or more, which is this filter feeder, foragages, this gains three uh population. If it if this is the closest well cleaner on either side, which means this species will gain three fish. And then because it's got the symbiosis, it will gain one uh extra fish whenever this uh particular species forages, which means it's a net plus four for this particular species. On the other side, it's mirrored. The same effects happen, which means it's a net plus four. So, you get plus four. Uh, probably maxed out with here, plus another four, meaning that you'll also
bank two for the middle, one for the two extras, and that's probably net four per turn. So doing the maths, that's a pretty powerful net gain of points that you're not only increasing the population for, but you've got this central protection for this species in the middle, which is netting you ongoing cumulative points. Have you ever wondered what modern Euro games looked like from the very beginning? Well, this is probably one of the first worker placement Euro games I was ever introduced to. So, it's interesting to see that there's actually been a lot of discussion in the past about some broken strategies in the game Stone Age. Stone Age is basically a worker placement game where you're expanding your tribe. You're sending your workers out to gather different resources like timber and gold, and then you're using those resources to uh craft tools, uh to buy buildings, to claim cards. and the cards has a set collection element to it where you're trying to collect a lot of different kind of little craft items. So at the end they become multipliers and so stone age is a great introduction into those heavier Euro games. There's a lot of maths involved in Stone Age in the background. If you ever go to like Google and you think, "Oh, I'll just type in my search and then you get all these search results." There's a lot of maths going on behind this beautiful dress of a game. Uh it all comes down to what strategy you pick. And one of the most common overpowered strategies which
I think in a further diving into can be countered quite easily is the starvation strategy. Cuz in this game you have to feed your people. And if you don't feed your people, you suffer a 10 victory point penalty. And you might be thinking, "Wow, that's a lot." But then when you think about the cost of getting the food to feed each of those people, especially if you've maxed out your tribe, the net value of taking the uh 10 points compared to the amount of energy and points and action wastage that you've put into getting the food uh doesn't seem to balance out very well. And so, uh, a lot of people, whilst thematically it doesn't really fit, uh, tend to just let their tribe starve, take the hit and then try and find other ways to compensate for that point deficit. And so in this game, because there's a lot of cards that help to multiply victory points at the end of the game, you can kind of neglect the 10 points or take the hit penalty every round and at the end of the game just really counter it by uh collecting all these uh cards. And so the population cards and the hut multiplier cards are going to really net you so many more points than wasting your turns trying to increase your agriculture to feed the people in your tribe. Especially at the four player count, there's going to be a lot of variability and forced movement in a game where the later players in turn order are going to be denied certain spaces that the players earlier in turn order are going to nab from
them. Especially right at the very first round of the game where the first player might take up the field space thereby preventing other players from increasing their agricultural power forcing other players to take a less optimal route and so you know the later players in turn might be forced to you know create and expand their family meaning getting an additional worker. In addition to that the actual value behind each of the four different resources is different. And so if you go to the forest to cut down timber, uh the number of people that you send there is the number of dice that you roll. And that total value that you roll is going to be divide by three. So getting timber is going to be a lot more easier and you're going to net a lot more of that compared to if you go for gold. And so players who might go down the starvation route uh may decide, you know what, I'm not even going to forage for food at all. I'm not going to waste my time there. I'm going to spend my time collecting timber. Timber is really good because you can use it to buy uh the civilization cards. And the civilization cards is where you're going to net a lot of points. All of the multiplication factors uh the people multiplying the number of tools you have, the population multiplying by the number of building cards you've made, the number of uh different items and sets that you can collect becomes a multiplication factor. The heart of where this strategy becomes overpowered is realizing the maths behind everything. And so that's what players have been able to explore. And in saying that, the strategy is not completely broken because other players can be
perceptively aware. You know, trigger the endgame really quickly by diminishing one of the building piles or nabbing up some of those multipliers from a player who might be clearly going down the starvation route. Set in an alternative historical timeline, this is a game where players are going to be taking mechs off their board, placing them out, putting workers out to gather resources in order to fulfill six different objectives, which will trigger the end of the game and hopefully score players the most points. It is a game called Scythe, a very popular game. Now, Scythe requires players to play a game where they control a leader, which is uh one of the factions that they're going to be leading, as well as taking an ability on a player mat. The combo in the game scythe requires a player to use the Resviet Union faction and the industrial player mat board in combination.
The Razviet Union board gives that player um the ability to choose the same section on their playmat as previous turns cuz usually in the game you have to choose a different particular section on your player mat every time you activate a particular action. So that uh this faction allows you to break that rule. So you just use the same section over and over again if you like. The combo requires that the player has a worker in the mountain area next to the faction's leader starting point and a player in the village. On this player's first turn, they're going to choose the produce action, which allows them to produce resources on two hex's that they currently have workers already on. So, the player gets one mountain ore resource. They get to remove one worker from their playerboard and add it here.
Now, as more workers are removed from this area, there'll be little printed costs underneath that players will have that the player will have to pay on this play's next turn. They're going to activate their ability a second time, allowing them to produce on two hex's where they have workers. This particular location will generate another ore, but now there's two workers here. They're going to allow this player to take two workers off. And now they've got four workers in that particular space. On this player's third turn, they'll take the produce action yet again. They'll produce a third or in this mountain space. And because there's four workers already there, they'll get to take the remaining workers off their playerboard area and place them out there on the map, not forgetting to pay the cost.
It's important to note that this particular section also allows you to deploy your mechs. And for three or you can actually deploy one of your mechs from this area, thereby activating an ability underneath. So by turn three, you can actually get rid of these three mountain ores. Choose one of these mechs. Uh the township mech is pretty powerful cuz it allows you to move between your village and the factory. And the factory is this central part of the board that allows you to draw these extra cards that can be used to expand your player action board. Or you can increase the speed of your mech so that you can access other resources like these encounter spaces that are here, which allows you to draw these encounter cards and then gain you net bonuses based on the option that you pick. In order for that encounter card to activate, this mech would have to move the leader into that space. So by turn four, this player has deployed all of their workers as well as at least one of their mechs, giving them a big advantage over the other players, considering how fast that combo actually breaks out, which makes it easily accessible straight away. So what did you think of some of those overpowered strategies? Do you think they're warranted? Do you think there's ways to counter those strategies? Are there any other board games that you've played where you might feel like that game is slightly broken?
Please let me know in the comment section below. I'd love to start a conversation with you. Now, if you found this super video super helpful or insightful, please consider liking and subscribing to my channel. And uh if you want to buy me a coffee a month, please head over to my Patreon page and support me over there. Otherwise, there's hundreds of other board game videos on my main YouTube page. Please consider checking them out. This is Danny Sun. I hope to see you again in the near future. See you soon.