Skip to main content
Loading video...

Keep or Cull? That is the question!

Transcript 22:22

Hello everyone, this is Johannes.

And this is Sarah-May. And you are watching Board Gaming Ramblings. And welcome back to Keep or Cull, where we play all the games and decide if we want to keep them or cull them.

Yes, we have I think 11 more games today, which means we play them and now we're going to think, are these games going to stay in the collection because as you know, we have too many games and we are trying to get rid of some of the games because we can't own them all. Some of these games are good and they might be culled. Yeah. Some of the games might not be good and they will be culled. Yeah. Some of the games might be good and also get kept. That is kind of the We're not keeping any bad games, right?

No, so if they're bad, we won't do the cull and then we will do the keep and maybe sometimes we'll do the cull even though it could be keep, but then it's not good enough to be keep so it's culled. If that is like a recap of the whole series, we've been doing it for five years.

Oh, yeah. Yes. If you enjoy this Keep or Cull episode and you haven't yet, you can

subscribe.

because it's 100% cool. Yay, banana. Banana. Yeah. Yeah, I should have said banana. Yes, so now we're going to do the games. Fry Factory. This is a trick-taking game. Are you ready? Yes. One. Two. One, two, three, boom. It's a cull for me, keep for you.

from me. It's a very interesting game if you don't like fun. Well, I did like it.

Yes. We like We already made it clear that we can't cull good games also. Oh, yeah, okay. Yes, no, yes. No, no, for the rules. Like the rules of the video. Yeah, so I'm allowed to cull it even though it's good. It is a trick-taking game and we already have like a lot of trick-taking games and I would like to keep this one, but it's so many of them. So but but the thing is about this one is that it's a little different. Ah, like I hopefully all trick-taking games are a little different.

No, but your when you get your hands in the beginning of the game of cards

Oh, I got my hands. Yeah, yeah, that. The the hand of cards, you will like bid two of them that decides how many tricks that will be like cards yeah, tricks that will be able to win of that color during the remainder of that round.

Yes.

Yes. And yep. And then you're bidding on how many you're going to get and it's that's clever. Yes. I hope you understood that. It's a very basically there's different suits and they will stop being able to win throughout the round.

When they're not and like thematically when they're not scary anymore.

it's the I like the theme because I enjoy the classic horror movies and also we're going to keep it because it's a fun one.

You are the keepers. You are the deciders. I'm the keeper. Next up is La Cuenta. We played this or we bought this in Spain when we were there in Spain. If you want to hear more about Spain, you can go watch our game of the month that we did for April. We spoke a bit about Spain. But this one is also in Spanish. And now we do the thing.

Yes. One, two, three, boom. It's a keep for me, a cull for you.

Yes, this was like like this.

Yeah. And because I think it's a fun one. It's more a party game where you are trying to you're going around. You start with so much money. Like everyone has a thousand euros. Yeah.

And they're going to go around in their pockets and go to restaurants and then one player will try to they will you will try to be the player who doesn't take the bill. And then when you take the bill, you pay off your all your money and then if you have no money left, you're out and the player who has the most of money then is going to be the winner. It's a fun one. And it's a clever cute game. The reason that I'm thinking this is good enough for me to keep is that we've been to Spain and eaten tapas and now it's more fun to have a game about tapas.

plays up to eight people which is great. And I think it would be fun with eight people.

Yeah. So we're going to keep it.

Yep.

Now our next game.

Oh, it's on my side. It's all in predicciones.

We also bought this. It's also actually predicciones. It's in It's in Spanish.

in Spanish. Uh so, we did also this one in Spanish. Are you ready? 1 2 3 Boom. It's a double keep.

Double keeping all the way across the sky. It's been a while. Yeah, I like this. It is a poker game where you're trying to get the best hand. You describe it.

Unlike in other poker games.

That's right, but you described it very well when you talked about it in the game of the month video where you said it feels like fantasy realms.

Yes. But with poker kind of.

yeah. So, the the cards that you are discarding, they will give you like a power or something that you're doing and to make your hand better. And also, when there's been enough cards play discarded, the game like the round ends and you're trying to get the best poker hand. And I thought it was fun. I agree. Yeah. We're going to keep it. Next up is Tolentino. This is a review copy, so thank you so much for that. Are you ready?

Yes. 1 2

[clears throat]

3 Boom.

It's a double cow.

Yes, I think I was way more on the edge maybe for this one than you were. This one is actually quite interesting. You are moving You're building up like a board of tiles and you are moving a chip around about to try to move tiles from place to place. It's like in the area majority where you are building out these tiles and then when you build it out, you can also then build into one of the things that is perpendicular. I think that's the word we learned while playing this game. So, if not anything else, we learned a new word. Uh it's a very beautiful game. This is one of those where I would have liked to play it more, but there is so many games. But there is There is like It We have We played it and it's been on the shelf for a while and I was like, "I want to play it more." And then the more we wait for playing it, I was like, "Okay, we need to go and do the Keeper Colonna." Yes.

Uh this felt like when we played this, I was thinking this could be a Knizia design because it's like

bit more communal than the Yeah, it because you have some like interesting scorings, you have this very like abstract but simple like way of placing pieces, but there's more depth to it.

Yeah. Um but uh we already have like games in the abstract genre that we also uh really don't find the time to play. The thing that I did like about this when we played it we we played it with four players is that I thought it worked very well at four players.

Not too long. Um not too long, but but for me it was maybe like I don't know, not meaty enough for me to be like in love with it.

Yeah. Yeah. But it's a solid design and I would have happily played again if somebody wanted to.

Yes.

Speaking about Reiner Knizia,

Yeah. did you plan that? No, I actually did not. Yeah.

I have to see like the name of the next designer. This could have been

Okay, I'm not even ready.

Yeah. Yeah. One, a review copy as well, I think. I also backed it, so it was like a double.

Are you ready? Yeah. One, two, three, boom. It's a double call for this one as well. This is a Reiner Knizia game. It is an abstract game. In this game you're trying to get majorities in rows and columns by placing your like tiles with different values on them. Um and you have also some different abilities on them that can change around the play other player player's pieces.

And some of them the the the columns you don't want to win. Mhm. Uh so you're trying to uh basically outmaneuver your opponent to get the pieces that you want to and avoid the pieces that you don't want to. So it feels like a it it absolutely like a very head-to-head kind of game.

Yeah, it's a two-player game, so it's it's usually is. As you like this abstract game, so I usually that way. It's a fun one, but again, it's it's on this pile. Next up is Night Soil. This is a game all about poop. You are a night watchman going around getting finding poop around the city of where are we here? We are in Uh where are we? I don't know. It's in London. It's in London. It's a very mature game. Oh. It's about manure. It's about poop. It's a very like if you like poop jokes Yeah. Yes. Are you ready for this thing? 1 2 3 boom. It's a double cow.

I enjoyed this game. I think it's fun. It's a it's a poopy game, but it's like a it's very weird because I would say 99.9% of games about poop are comedy games like party games like stupid games. I'm not being stupid at the few I they're not for me, but like if you enjoy them you be you. But Night Soil is like a an actual medium euro game about poop, which I think is fun. I think if you are sitting and saying poop jokes aren't fun, you're lying to yourself because they are. It's like a way of human nature. We like poop. We like farting. It's one of those things that are always going to be fun.

Never gets old.

No. It does if you let it like lay out in the sun. It will get old. But basically, you are trying to get these different guilds to like you because you're the best at poop and you will be trying to move the poop around and try to move get the poop be the person who puts the poop in the river. Yeah. Because then you will get your victory points. We got poop in the river, winner winner chicken dinner.

I really like the theme. Yes. What is the theme about? I didn't you just told us.

I'm joking. I want you to say it was about poop.

But I'm never well, it's not first hand experience with moving poop around in London, but I imagine it was a big problem like actually getting rid of people's poop back then. So, it's a cool theme and I I feel like it's kind of thematic. The thing is, the reason I'm calling it is because it's a very very mean game. You could like you have to be

about blocking. Yes, it's blocking the game. Blocking the poop. Yes, and it's kind of like a worker placement game. It is.

placement. Yeah, but it feels like also

worker and if he plays him, nobody else can go there. And then you have a small worker that are not that good at poop. And they will This is one of those I don't think you should make a like a

But but yeah, it will it I like the concept, but I I I think it's like too cutthroat for me personally. Yeah.

I enjoyed it. I don't need to own it. Next up is another game.

Rowdy Partners

was a review copy. I don't know if I said this is a review copy. Are you ready?

Yes.

1 2 3 poop. It's a double count.

Yes, I'm done with the poop now. Uh Rowdy Partners is another trick taking game.

to get the last poop out of my system.

Have we ever been this silly? I think we have. Just with less [clears throat] poop.

Rowdy Partners

Rowdy Partner Rowdy Partners is a trick taking game. Yes.

And it's you're playing in teams. Mhm.

And the teams are the same, but [clears throat] the um what do you call it? The player player order is different from round to round and you're trying to use your special abilities and that turn order kind of to to play your cards

cards, but also what's the opposite of opponent opponent? Your ally ally

partner Yes, to win tricks. But I thought it wasn't the best trick-taking game I've ever played and we have many. It's such a flooded market so you need to do something to really stand out or be in like a very small box. It's like a bigger box and didn't really stand out and then it ends up on the coal pile. Next up we have It's my turn, right? Yes. We have Thesaurus. Tessaurus. I don't know. One of those or none of them. Maybe it's Thesaurus or Thes aurus. Thesaurus.

Thesaurus.

It's not Thesaurus, it's Thesaurus. Okay. This was not a review copy. Bought it with cold hard cash. Yes. Thesaurus is a Euro game where you are diving. Oh, yeah. Sorry. 1 2 3 boom. It's a double kill. Yes. And That was I was It was good. Yeah, it was. Main Main thing was too long. Yeah. We played like a game and it was way too long. And also we didn't play the whole thing. They were like there There was two ways the game can end. And I feel like it might usually end earlier but if you play it all the way to the end of the time to the end of time, it will be too long. I think that what you are you're like I think you're like a fishing company that's hiding that they're looking for treasures and you are going out finding these treasures trying to not get killed by sharks, trying to get the right equipment. It is a worker placement game you're placing workers.

And then you are resolving them in an order. It's one of those where you place first and then you resolve in order so which I think it's interesting because then you can like plan Oh, I really need to go there but I also want to go there and that happens before that but I This is more important so I'm going to do that so it's going to be a worse action if I don't also get to go there. Those kind of things I really like. I enjoyed everything I was doing in the game but it ended up feeling basically just too long. Mhm. I and like it is a more or less pretty straightforward worker placement game. The biggest quirk of the game is that you have like five bank accounts that at the beginning of the round you get some income and you can put that in those bank accounts and depending on which action you take, you pay with different bank accounts. I like that and I also like that when you're getting money during the round, you can distribute those into the bank accounts of your liking. So that meant that I could plan for having too little in one bank. Uh-huh. But then I had to do some actions during the game the round that would [clears throat] give me the money that I was lacking and I I was taking the high road. I was not doing a lot of treasure stuff. I just like I'm actually doing honest fishing business here. It didn't work out great for me. No.

for that? No. But I got some honest earned money. Well, it's a cull. And also it has some of the worst looking meeples I've seen in a game. Well,

they they have like they have like a very big head because you're supposed to put this hat on them that is like this big so they just doesn't fit anywhere anymore. No, the the hats look ridiculous but it would be a cull even without the hats.

That's that the arrows. That's arrows. Next up is Gems of oh Irid- Irid- Irid- Irid- It's a another review copy. Yes. Are you ready? Yep. One, two, three, boom. Double cull. Uh Gems of Irid- [clears throat] Hm, okay. This one?

This one. Uh is a game about collecting gems and then it's like a stock market kind of game where your the gems are when they're low in value, it's easier to mine them and then they get more and more expensive and then that's when you want to sell them basically.

Like in real life, the more expensive the thing is, the harder it is to find. Which it is. But then sometimes it gets less expensive and then it's very easy to find. Yeah, and the market can crash. That means when they die is at six and you you get that gem and then it will go down to one and then they will be super cheap again. Yes. Uh so you're using gems to get more money because you need money for like equipment and also to actually be able to mine. But then the thing that you ultimately want to do is collect different colored gems to score like get these treasure Yeah, artifacts. So it's basically kind of like a recipe fulfillment game. Um and you're moving The thing is that you're all moving on like a map and you're you're moving upwards and sideways and you're you're you can then like only mine the the gems that are available where you're at.

Yeah. Yeah. It It had some luck. It didn't bother me as much as I thought it would. I thought it would be more bothersome. I also did roll some ones when that was the only thing I couldn't roll. So I got like zero stuff for four rounds. Which was not fun. But all in all, it was more fun than I thought it would be. Like it was a pleasant surprise, but still too much randomness for me to enjoy. The this like special edition is very nice. The thing is there's like this foil thing on the tiles that depending on your light where you play might be very hard to read. Because the colors get really like black they're they're they're gone. Oh, this is still in frame. I'm going to put it over here on your panel. Boom. Oh, it's my game. Yes, it's your turn.

the last game And it's Yeah, it's one over left over from mine.

This is Skin Fire Council. I'm already excited to show you pictures of this game because there's something different about that game, right? That you will see on the pictures. The thing about this game is that it was a review copy, and now we're going to do the paddle. Are you ready? Yes. 1 2 3 boom.

It's a double cow. Uh, we played King of Fire console a few times when we had a prototype, and remember really liking it.

Yeah. Uh, we played it now, and I didn't like it that much. I thought it was a fine game. I enjoy like the I enjoy the like political things and all of that, but all in all it just felt like a little bit of meh. Like it was there, I did the things, it was in fun enough, but it was nothing that would be like when I was done thinking, oh, I need to go back to this.

I agree. It was a kind of a let down because I remember liking it more than I liked it now. And the thing is I didn't feel like we're super excited because it is a worker placement game. So, a lot of the things is about placing those workers.

Workers. And you have like different tiers of the city that you

[clears throat]

if you want to get to the more like better worker placement spots, you need to pay some tax. And you have you have you have cool abilities and stuff that you can so you can make your workers more proficient in some skills, and they will get like a special ability. That was cool.

Mhm. But the things that you did when you place that worker was just like, okay. Yeah. Do I need to go there or there? I'm getting one stone or I'm getting a stone and a money or I'm getting a stone and a food or it's just like it felt a little kind of meh, but it is a cow for me. Yes. Next up, Lost Temple. What can it be? It is Tundra. Tundra is on the review copy. Are you ready?

Yes. 1 2 3 boom. It's a double cow. I like this game. Yeah. I like the first half the best.

Okay.

Because you're kind of building up. You want to It is a worker placement game where you have like dice as your workers, and you have your own worker placement kind of action selection tableau. And what value you have on the dice dictates what actions you can do. I like that and in the beginning you want to like upgrade your actions, you want to build towers out on a map to get like a bigger area that you can harvest the resources from like a lot of stuff to be done like building up. Then I felt like the last round I was kind of done with all the building up. I was kind of done with Yeah, so I felt like it was a one round too long. I like when the games are Stopping before you get everything? Yes.

So I can be like oh next time I'm going to do this and this and that instead. For me if I was to play this again, I would be like I've already done this. But other than that, I thought it was a really pleasant game that I would recommend. I think that it's one of those where it's better if you're not used to playing like optimizing optimizes optimal optimization games. Because it's a very it's a lighter game. One thing I really enjoy is the fact that everybody starts with the the same dice rolls. So one player is going to roll everyone is set up that. There are ways to mitigate or change that, but it's not like because usually not always but like a higher number is usually good. Of course if you only get sixes you have a problem because you're going to not be able to place all of them. But let's say one player roll only once and another player only five is going to be a big change in this game.

It is a fun game. I wouldn't say it's anything special. I would say that there's probably other games that does the same kind like in this kind of way. I can't come up with anything on the spot, but like the dust is in a better way for me. But it's a fine game for sure. Okay. These are the games we held most of them. I even had like a kill over here because there wasn't any space. So we killed like five, six, seven, eight games and we kept these three. And one of them I wanted to call and one that you wanted to call. So it was only only one game actually that we both wanted to keep. So what was your favorite and least favorite of these games? Um hm, oh my my favorite [clears throat] I think was playing La Quinta game. I really like that. And my least favorite I think maybe Robber Barons.

Yeah. Was like the least unique game of these.

Yes, I would say the same. I think maybe All In was my favorite. And that What was your favorite? If you're playing them, if you haven't played them, you don't know what was your favorite. Well, are any of these games you're interested to check out? You can let us know in the comments. If there's no one, you can still let us know. If you like the video, you can like it. If you didn't like it, you can still like it because it doesn't cost you anything and it's nice for us because we are putting stuff on the internet for people to see it. So it's nice if somebody likes it.

That's true. And subscribe because you can. And that's the end. Thank you so much for watching. I'm Johannes. I'm Sen War. And you've been watching Board Gaming Ramblings and bye-bye.

Progress saved