Top 5 Deeply Historical Games w/ Solitarius
Transcript
hey Gamers this is LZ Davids from beond soli and I'm here with a very special guest this is my friend Andrew also known as solitarius uh he is another solo gamer and also my colleague at work we're Latin teachers who game so how you doing today Andrew yes doing great how are you Liz uh I'm good we just saw each other but now we're in better settings y we had testing today for those of you who care and it was boring um so now we can have a great time making this video so in true true internet form uh Andrew and I have come together to make a list and our list is basically the top five games that really evoke history you know we're both game game Buffs history Buffs and uh we thought this list would just really kind of combine those things for us yeah absolutely I I put a lot of thought into mine um actually I I was looking over I was looking over the list that you did earlier this uh this year this this past year about the top historical war games and uh this this list is a response to that because a lot of my favorite ones didn't make it yeah you know actually mine either really on second thought you know but my my favorites always change you know moments to moment so I don't even know what order I actually want to go in so I'm gonna make you as my guest go first so what is your number five we'll go from five to one yes you get to go first okay well um I so I guess I'll start chronologically um historically well actually not really I have an older one we'll start we'll start really old so we're going to go all the way back to ancient Egypt now Liz if I were to ask you what is one thing
absolutely sounds super historical to me super historical fantastic so I think that my number five you know most of my stuff's a little older in time period because you know me I'm not really much of a modernist but you know this year I really got into a lot of hidden movement games so you know I really enjoyed Atlantic chase this year I thought it was a brilliant design um you know I played bismar solitier a bunch you know a nice little worthy te game book but you know just in terms of really voking looking for you your enemy in Uncharted Territory um and you know you especially in Naval Warfare I just really don't think anything's better than Battleship I think BH is definitely my number five how how have I overlooked Battleship no it's it's fantastic and it's just totally I mean it's just totally underestimated as you know a historical work I mean you know you really need to think about uh where on the grid your enemy could be and then working out from there if you got to hit which direction or alignment uh their craft might be in I mean that's really the struggle that um somebody in a battleship would have to deal with for sure I think so I mean I certainly wouldn't just be running around a duck screaming is is it as historical as the movie um you know I don't I've never actually never seen the movie so you'll have to comment on that movie was pretty movie got it movie nailed it I thought fantastic yes so this is a game and a
movie recommendation in one yes what what a great that' be a great date night play play some Battleship and then watch Battleship I mean actually would yeah you could do a lot worse for a date night yeah so um for your for your number four what do you what do you think oh my number four let me see here all right my number four um oh I'm gonna I'm going to read you the uh the flavor text on this one if you don't mind so I I'm gonna pull this up on board game gek close my window hang on because you get really got to feel the immersion um actually maybe you can you could probably guess from the description what game this is um so uh introduced by the Moors there's a certain kind of tile that was fully embraced by the Portuguese when King Emanuel the on his visit to to the alhamra Palace in southern Spain was mesmerized by the stunning beauty of the morish decorative tiles the king all struck by the interior beauty of the Alahambra immediately ordered that all of his own palaces in Portugal be decorated with simil similar tiles as a tile lating artist you you have been challenged to embellish the walls of the Royal Palace of Ivor so this game puts me right into the Palace of Ivor every time I play it and it is of course a Zool the even from the the tiling techniques of taking tiles from people and having to slide them and if you have too many tiles you don't get paid I mean
that was a real struggle for the merchants having too many tiles I heard that's actually how it worked yep that's how that economy worked it was rough it was rough trying to scrap by as a as a kle Artisan yeah you know I have a pretty limited budget uh but I'm going to Portugal with my parents this summer and you know I had a choice between getting a Lonely Planet guide or picking up aul and I really just felt like aul was better prep yeah like I'm going to know my way around Lisbon like a native yeah you will you you'll be able to interact with the natives you you will feel like you you are Portuguese when you're playing this game absolutely and like a real Mosaic expert 100% yes and not at all hungry because the pieces really like Starburst they do but that's how they did historically too that's actually where Starburst come from from those tiles really historical fact absolutely I mean you know it's just amazing the history you learn when you when you play games well I mean King Manuel the first his motto was his like Royal motto was taste the Rambo so I mean you see where it comes from now all right so I mean I just don't know that I can beat that but you know my number four is actually a favorite um used actually see me play in my classroom a lot it's a real classic from Ryan ksia who's already made the list truly a fantastic historical designer and um you know it's also uh a game from GMT which is of course you know the company for historical games but this one is my absolute favorite simulation of medieval tournament combat
and that is ivanow so if you haven't played ivanho uh basically you are playing tournaments that are colorcoded different styles of combat and each card has a number on it and you're just trying to get the highest number but there are of course a lot of cards like that let you Rost or that let you you know remove cards from other people's displays in a real punch out that abs absolutely simulates the different types of anal Weaponry that were in play at tournaments at the time fantastic that sounds amazing you mentioned color coding I mean I've been to Medieval Times they definitely did the color coding the green KN the red KN yeah I mean that's that's oh my God you soing now I know where they got it I don't know I don't know that's my mind is blunt right now well you just got to appreciate it when when somebody bothers to put that level historical immersion into even even a simple game yeah absolutely and you know nothing can beat those purple Jing tournaments you gotta have gotta have a little bit of jousting in your in your medieval tournaments got to absolutely yes with mating card is the most powerful supporter because I'm absolutely sure that's how it worked yeah absolutely oh that's a good that was a really good pick um
built their Huts primarily out of wood stone brick and gold really and gold and that and gold and that the most that the most precious and valuable buildings were made entirely out of gold did you know that this cavemen built golden Huts I mean this this game taught me all kinds of things that I had no idea were going on right so I mean are you saying that El Dorado could have really been an actual thing because people actually were making Cities of Gold even in the stoneage it could have been it could have been and and I also learned that that this NE Neolithic culture like to collect stuff they like to collect sets of stuff but not the same things just different things who knew I mean people have always been collectors but true I mean I would be so interested in seeing how the game reflects what they collected as just a true reflection of who they were yeah little little Trinkets and canoes and little statues and having and collecting them all apparently makes you the chief or something it was it was quite a culture fantastic yeah I mean this sounds like something to be paired with a museum visit to see what the how the collection in the uh in the museum and the Muse and the game pieces actually match up yeah amazing yeah I I bet I I it just seems like a lot of um a lot of careful research went into this game it's just amazing how immersive it is absolutely uh so I think that my number three um is actually you know it's got some stuff in common I guess with your with your number four um this one however uh takes us to a different time
period uh in which everyone is a gem Merchant and you know you are really struggling to collect gem mines and then to refine your gems more and more uh and then you have contact with these really amazing historical figures like Mary Stewart um Charles i f Makia Ai and like even Henry the E is in there yeah so I mean you know meet and like oh this is Splendor oh one what that was Splender was my number six oh yeah you know it's I can see how it could be a close call everything on your list has been really solid yeah it's close but uh yeah I I really think that um you know just really getting that contact with important figures of History um through What mattered the most to them which is your gemstones because clearly they weren't inheriting large amounts of their own um you know it just it's just really like a really special way to you know interact with great figures of the past oh I absolutely I was going to say it's a little known fact that that on the on the cards on the Aristocrat cards each of those like types of gems that they want were were actual historical favorite gems of theirs if you if you look it up those are those are actually their favorite gem yeah they put a lot of work into that the paintings and stuff yeah that's impressive if you check it out and I guess the a lot of those types of gems and I guess the numbers must reflect like their relative wealth in terms of types of assets they owned
absolutely absolutely that's the it's the um it's the universal um ancient Aristocrat wealth scale system that's a real thing yeah I totally heard of that I think that came up in one of our my seminars one time you know yeah yeah well my number two we're we're um we're back into the uh medieval period or maybe the Renaissance depending on how you look at it um this is another one that um I I think people don't people might miss some of the historical immersion by not reading the back of the box um so this is a game again I'm going to have you see if you can guess which game this is uh let me pull this up here okay you are a monarch like your parents before you a ruler of a pleasant Kingdom of rivers and Evergreens unlike your parents however your hopes you have hopes and dream dreams you want a bigger and more pleasant Kingdom with more rivers and a wider variety of trees you want a Dominion of course Dominion yeah now here's the best part of dominion this is the part that people Miss read the this is actually from the back of the box but wait it must be something in the air several other monarchs have the exact same idea you must race to get as much of the unclaimed land as possible fend them off along the way to do this you'll hire minions construct buildings spruce up
your castle and fill your Coffer fill the coffers of your treasury listen to this your parents would have been wouldn't be proud but your grandparents on your mother's side would be delighted so when you're playing Dominion you're not only trying to get more um property more power more more victory points represented by the land that you own but you're also trying to please your maternal grandparents that's not a historical problem I don't know what is I know well that's what these that's what these ancient um dukes and and duchesses would do they would grab some new land and then say they then they would say this is for you Mima this is for you that's how they would do it so I'm really just fascinated by who these grandparents are that you're supposed to be trying to trying to win over it's just it it it actually sheds light on a fascinating historical mystery you are so right yeah I I've always found it intriguing yes and no wonder and now now that I think about it all those different configurations of cards that you can play with in Dominion just really reflect real cultural shifts at different times throughout this period I mean the the Smithy you get more cards uh there's that guy that turns your small money into bigger money I mean that's not economics I don't know what is exactly and you know that careful calculation of how many of each card you need and then what order buy them in truly reflects the economic conundrums of the Middle Ages yeah or the
Renaissance or both I mean they're really the same yeah I mean it's most historic most historians would say that exactly I mean come on although that said you know my number two is also a game set in the Middle Ages um and definitely not in the earlier Egyptian period where I prefer to study this topic um but you know there's just nothing more historical um and not fictional at all than you know really tring to solve a murder mystery among monks uh you know especially when you're trying to solve that mystery by like ringing a little bell searching at their cells going to the scriptorium to do things other than like write and copy stuff for hours and so obviously I'm talking about the mystery of the Abby oh fantastic yes exactly you know that map looks like the layout of so many abies that I've studied over the years I i' I've heard that it was based on a real historical ABY yeah and you know it's just really amazing even the relative sizes of the individual monastic Chambers uh compared with the scriptorium uh the library um you know the ability to listen in at the confessional Booth yeah well they all they all had like those secret spy places right absolutely yeah I mean you know I think it really captures the the essentials of of the monastic day yeah especially the murder part it was dangerous yeah and also like of course it' be dangerous with all those different monastic orders all crammed into one place oh yeah it was a blood
bath yeah I really don't know how they did it it's it's incredible that we even still have monks today after after such a a brutal tradition you could just play ivanho it' be the same thing well that's interesting you get the you get the like the Royal um side the secular side of the culture and then you got the uh religious side yeah I mean you know it's just where murder happens in a more shadowy way that you have to investigate as opposed to WR out there on the field exactly fantastic no that's a that's a great historical simulation uh but that leads us to number one on our list all right so now I I feel like a historical um list would would not be complete um without because I'm a more ancient ancient history guy but I mean one of the most common um themes in in war gaming and historical Gam it was World War II U World War II was obviously an enormous an enormous conflict there are so many battles so many things so many generals so many Maneuvers things to focus on land sea Europe South Pacific all over the world so my favorite game is the one that tries to Encompass the entire conflict in a single game that's played in a very short reasonable amount of time and that is risk I think risk how did I not think of that for my list I think risk um I I I think you could actually just teach a
course on World War II and just have your students play Risk I mean I don't think there's it it is a it is a master class um playing through it you will learn you will learn all the names you'll learn all the strategies um you will learn all about the All About the Australia problem where you can just hold you could just gather your troops in Australia and grow and grow and grow I mean that's what happened that's where the Allies you know had their stronghold um so yeah it's just uh you just learned so much from that game absolutely yeah I mean you know I remember in in class you know we talked about things like the Zimmerman Telegram Battle of the Bulge but really you know Australia is the true Lynch pin of any world war I'm really surprised more Napoleonic games don't include it I I know and there that you can even reenact famous things like when raml invaded Brazil I I mean all kinds of stuff can be simulated um with with risk oh it's amazing and I you know I really wish that they had something like that for the Romans I mean I really I really think that um you know pandemic fall of Rome isn't cutting it we need something that is is more like Risk well and um what's great about risk is if you actually play Risk from beginning to end it lasts roughly the same length as World War II so it's a pretty close simulation yeah you know actually I think I have a game of Risk that's still going yeah well it everybody does um if you know nobody's actually ever finished a game before um but it doesn't mean that you can't learn a lot from
it absolutely you know there's there are small games like the campaign for North Africa and then there are truly epic games like Risk exactly exactly absolutely you know I got a friend who's playing uh world in Flames right now and he said man this is the second biggest game I've played compared to risk compared to risk I I'm telling you yeah risk is um risk is life absolutely you know if you don't take risks what are you uh what are you really doing with yourself and your time on this Earth so I've got a much more boring pick for number one but you know I'm hoping as a class assist you'll appreciate it and you know I always want more tactile ways to teach our students about Rome and how to get around the city you know there's so many amazing monuments there The Forum and you know there's even like the doas ARA now the Coliseum so you know I really decided that the best way to teach about this has to be if you can afford it foundations of Rome truly an incredible representation of architectural growth in in a major ancient city yeah absolutely and um yeah and uh it's it's it's it's roughly the same size as ancient Rome too from what I from what I believe yeah I mean you know it's it's not even a room for ants it's got to be a room for at least hamsters or something yeah exactly but exactly you know it's really amazing how you can build the whole city up in a grid system um where people actually you know had steady Deeds to the land were able to
negotiate that in different shapes um you know those buildings actually made people money instead of like being the Public Works projects we think of them as so often and also you know people really seem to think that Rome contained housing and poor people um but you know the subur is kind of a myth no I I hadn't I hadn't thought about about it but I can't I can't think of a better more historical ancient Roman game I know and like aesthetically it just really you know the the perfect pristine I I prefer I prefer to play it unpainted uh because I just think that that that evokes the very plain white marble look uh of ancient Rome yeah which is exactly what Rome was it was all white marble and no color absolutely no tackiness for these people not at all no uh but yeah you know I just I really think that on my next trip to Rome I'm going to I'm going to prepare by playing foundations of Rome and just really seeing if I can reconstruct the real ancient city but you you will run into the foundations of Rome problem which is when people play it to prepare to go to Rome they don't even want to go to Rome anymore they just rather play foundations of Rome yeah I mean it is pretty nice to play the version that you know uh doesn't showcase every single Hill I guess it is a hilly Place R yeah except that we now know that it's not because it's perfectly flat when you Foundation there were there were no the the hills were a myth the hills were a myth for sure oh yeah absolutely especially the eighth
one um but with that said you know it's just so fun you know to get together and and do a list uh Andrew I've really appreciated your incredible historical sensitivity as you come up with entries for yours oh this is this is a blast Liz this is a blast thank you so much so if you're out there looking for games that are really going to teach you something about history uh we hope that you feel free to refer to these lists in seriousness they are all very fun games to play and uh for those of you out there if you haven't gone to Andrew's Channel yet he's called solitarius and he has awesome videos they are definitely better than mine he knows he's doing and I do not um and I can of course be found here at Beyond Soler of course well thank you so much for this opportunity it was super fun I never thought I was been watching Beyond soliter for like eight years so I never thought I'd actually be on the show so this was this was great fun yeah actually um you know I I'm just so glad that I've gotten to spend my last year with a neighbor who actually plays games this has been awesome especially especially with your incredible historical understanding yes that's I I I am history or nothing if it's not historically immersive it's not on my shelf as you can see absolutely uh so for those of you who out there please like like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy
gaming