Top 10 Games That "Killed" Other Games
Transcript
hi everybody i'm luke hector from the broken meatball and if you like what you see please remember to thumbs up the video and comment in the chat and if you want to help the channel a little bit further the patreon campaign is always running where you can donate a little bit of cash to keep the channel flowing as well as get some early insight into top 10 list ideas and q a segments i'm going to do in the future so it's a beautiful sunny day outside and i'm here recording videos yeah that's kind of my life in a nutshell really but this is a top 10 list that obviously i want to do more top 10s because let's face it the reviews don't get a huge amount of buzz but top 10 lists are always more fun to do but this one is one i wanted to do for a long time i've had this on the plate for a good two months now now it's not the most original list although i would argue that the list that's going to follow this one is entirely original and no one else has done it to my knowledge somebody could prove me wrong but this is my top 10 games that have killed other games and the reverse will be the following list which will be top 10 games that have defended themselves from other games and i really don't think anybody else has done that second list but prove me wrong i'd like to watch it if they have but this one is essentially where a game has come out and it's been so good yet so similar to another game that's similar that's like it that it's killed it off like i will play this new game rather than this new game and as a result you know this is always a very divisive topic because you know you say this game kills this game and then the people who love this game will rise up and say no this game's rubbish compared to the old one the new one's not as good and to be fair usually i'm in the old crowd because i tend to
prefer the older well i say the old again it's not cultly old but i don't get hyped up on the brand new hotness all the time so when a new game comes out and people quickly say this kills another game i'm usually like are you sure i don't know and like i say next week i think it's going to be a very interesting list although to be fair it was harder to make that listen that was this one because i think there have been more examples of games killing other games but yeah you know it'd be interesting to hear your thoughts as to whether you agree with this and there were a few on the short list so in terms of a caveat to whittle down my list a bit i had to at least say look okay did i at least enjoy the game at some point before it's no good saying oh yeah you know cluedo was killed by awkward guests well yes clearly awkward guess is a better game but who plays cluedo seriously it's like goliath stepping on david it really doesn't seem like much of a up really so yeah you'll see that as we go through but i'm certain that i'm going to get some comments on some of these both in favor and against so this should be quite interesting to see but i gave a bunch of list ideas to my patreons and thank you to everyone who supports this channel but i gave a load of lists and said come up your own ideas but in the poll this one and the one that's following on were clearly the top two voted so uh like i say patrons have spoken let's get on with it get on with it my number 10 is probably gonna be one of the more divisive ones on this list well other than my number one uh but but this this one is kind of weird because i will pretty much never play the physical version of this game even though i give it respect but i haven't
really played the physical version that's followed it that much lately apart from once a few months ago but also an app has come out to make the old one better than the physical version of the other one so it's kind of like weird how to tie these two up but having technology on your side is a bit of an unfair advantage so i still got to put it on the list but i thought i would stick it at 10. this is nations nations is a civilization building game that's for me killed through the ages we have found a witch may we burn fruity ages another civ building game very popular higher up on the board game rankings not that i give much care for that but especially with the amount of additions it has seriously sort your list out but the idea with this is that in through the ages you built up a little civilization you got like co you've got minds and you've got uh founders and universities and libraries and you've got advisors and you went to war with other people and that and it was a really fun complex game but i hated the amount of admin and bookkeeping in it it was ridiculous and a two-player game that could go on for three to four hours way too long seriously keep your game lengths down a bit now nations gave you the exact same feel but i could get a four-player game of it done in less time than it took me to do a two-player of the through the ages one so why would i play footy ages nations granted does not have anywhere near the aesthetic quality that through the aegis fourth edition has that one is gorgeous nations does look vomit inducing but you still get advisors you go get you go to war with other players you still get the buildings and
the resource management but i like the idea that you're putting the meeples on the buildings to dictate how much resource they're producing and with the expansion dynasties you can now get all these different player powers and different board setups so for me the physical version just really beat out through the ages but as i said the app for fruity ages is one of the best apparent implementations that exist out there at like top five easily and honestly it's like well if it takes out the bookkeeping then maybe i'd rather play through the ages than nations it is weird but technology is a little bit unfair so for the physical board game aside nations kill through the ages
my number nine is also going to be a little bit on the controversial side because a it's very recent and b some people are a little bit like are you sure it's similar to this one i'm not sure myself but it's definitely one that i thought does deserve to be on the list because i have warmed up to the previous one like i don't hate it anymore i actually thought you know what you put a certain expansion in this game and i will play it but when i consider the similarities between this and the recent game that i have gone gugu gaga for which is arc nova arkanova does for me kill terraforming mars now i get that the action selection mechanic has nothing to do with terraforming mars and i get that the map in terraform mars is communal whereas arc nova isn't but you can't deny that the card system is pretty much bang on the same it is the idea that you have the smorgasbord of cards that you will get so many of them in the game but barely you know anything that's like the total amount there and you have to do the best you can the most efficient way of getting points in that with these cards in terraforming mars you're getting resources in arc nova you're getting money and animals and setting up enclosures and sponsors you know the theme is different but it's still a fundamentally all about those cards and also the milestones are similar as well in terraforming mars you've got the milestone things where if somebody has certain criteria met they can go get extra points on a milestone and it's beating out other players um hello conservation projects not know for anybody it's the same system
exactly the same so even though there are some differences between the two yeah if you were going to put two in front of me granted terraforming mars is kind of more lukewarm on my system whereas arc nova is like up to 12 but still if i was comparing the two and somebody said which one should i get for those card systems i'd say get arc nova and a heartbeat i just much prefer it now i get that some people are probably sick and tired of hearing about it right now because like wordle it's one of the most like talked about things on social media right now when it comes to board gamers now i'm not saying everybody needs to earn a copy of our nova i love it to bits it was my favorite game from last year and it's easily like a top 20 game for me at this point but you know not everybody needs to own this quite heavy hard to find two to three hour game about building a zoo okay so don't give in to the hype too much go check out my review and find out more and see if it's the game for you now my number eight is on the list because this one probably i would still play the old version because the old game is much quicker you can get it done in about eight minutes whereas this one's gonna probably take you a good 45 minutes to an hour but the feeling of being like the odd one out in a group and being asked questions and you've got to try and lie your way out of the situation was originally done in spyfall and spyfall is a really cool social deduction game but i'm kind of like burnt out on what questions you can really ask people and you know it's hard
to teach new players because the new player gets put on the spot and they're not comfortable with it and it's like now this problem still arises in the new one but i think the zaniness of it is just that little bit easier to get across but even then i roll out my chair laughing talking about detective club detective club is the same deal you are put on the spot there is one odd one out in the group as everybody is giving all these dixit picture cards and a single word clue in secret but one person doesn't know what the clue word is so as the clue the cards come out the person who doesn't know has to come up with similar pictures to go with what's been put out but then as soon as the clue is revealed they've got to then backtrack and sort of bluff their way out of the situation same with spyfall when they're trying to figure out what location they're at but detective club hands down that game has me rolling out my chair laughing every single game it's never gone down badly for me at least not in a group perspective occasionally the old person has been a bit uncomfortable but for most part i'm just having a blast as everybody's coming up with the most zany reasons why their dixit cards relate to the clue that's been said even if you actually know what the clue word was your cards can still suck it's just that much fun i think i've done a review of this probably a couple of years ago definitely worth checking that out but yeah i think it was my number 10 in my top 100 as well you could always check that out but yeah i love this game anything you put with the dixit cards i'm gonna look at and this one for me has not made me want to care much about spyfl
for my number seven now i was only kind of lukewarm on the previous title but yeah it's another recent one from last year but and to be fair the one that it replaced is probably only a year before i think they've come out pretty recently at least since 2020 but honestly i can't see why you would play calico when cascadia exists cascadia's infinitely the better game the idea of putting tiles on your little tableau or board or whatever in this case and like trying to make the best use of those tiles put them in the right places manage a resource in which case you know you've got the cats in one you've got the animals in the other but in calico you've only got three to pick from it's very chaotic how that like those three get picked and even then it's mostly push your luck because you essentially like hope that certain tiles are going to appear and then they do or they don't and even if they do somebody else might take them in which case you can't really plan ahead at all so it's it just kind of fell flat for me but cascadia again you have four to pick from so better than three but you have other things that go along with them so it's a pair like it's four pairs because you're getting the tile and an animal token but you can mitigate those for those four if like too many of the same animal come out you have the choice and even then even if the perfect setup doesn't come out for you you should be able to make good use of something else it never felt like that i really had the worst turn possible in cascadia like very rarely compared to calico where i
just felt like i'm taking tiles for the sake of it and everything's just going a pot you know cats are cute i love cats you know cats are amazing but yeah cascadia just it's just better it doesn't take that much longer to play cascadia both of them might as well better be solo two-player games really than three or four but cascadia looks just as good it's just as good a theme but the mechanics just work better in cascadia i just will not play calico ever again when this one exists cascadia is on my shelf i'm taking it tomorrow actually to portsmouth guild fest in fact was it called gamer fest retro games fest i'm taking cascadia as one of the games in order to teach new gamers i wouldn't take calico honestly now i'm not saying calico is a horrible game it just didn't really sit well with me and then as soon as cascadia came out like less than a year later it's just like poof dead yeah not gonna happen
now for the number six you might think well maybe this is a little similar to a different game that it's killing but to be honest it kind of works for both but whenever i play the great little card game san juan why would i play puerto rico again puerto rico was this euro game where you were like choosing a role each round and depending on when you pick the role you got a bonus and other people got uh you know other parts but it was all of a case of like who picks the role and when as you're building up a little city and trying to like you know do fairy traffic i forget exactly what happens in puerto rico but as i say it was you know a nice euro game but now it's got to the point where you've got puerto rico sharks who basically are like oh i'm going to sit next to you this guy's new isn't he um do you mind if i sit over there i don't really want to be screwed over by this guy it's like you know and that just sucks when that happens but san juan takes that feeling of building the puerto rico city with the whole oh i'm trading indigo and coco and you know coffee and stuff like that and just delves it down to a 45-minute card game if that you can get it done in 30 minutes if you're really quick but it's just super fast i mean why would i play puerto rico puerto rico could take me a couple of hours or more it could be like i say very bad with puerto rico sharks and if you are doing badly to begin with from puerto rico you're done like you have no way to catch up in that game san juan you can kind of pull it back but it still retains that cool thing of oh i pick a role and i get a little bonus whereas other people get other things you know
and you could argue that this might be more similar to race for the galaxy than puerto rico and i could certainly see the argument but honestly it works either way it kills puerto rico for me and honestly i'd rather play san juan and roll for the galaxy so honestly pick whichever one of the two you think fits best and san juan for me still comes out on top it's a great card game doesn't get enough love anymore these days but seriously it's just so cool and simple and the idea that the entire deck of cards is everything your currency your hand the buildings the resources everything it's just such a cool neat system i'd love to see more buildings for this or like a like a re-implementation of this done with something else but for now sand one still on the shelf and i still really enjoy it
now my number five is similar well you might have argued that a recent review i did should already be part of this but honestly i recently reviewed now or never i don't think now or never re replaced near and far i think near and far kind of held on really but you'll have to check out my review video for more details but originally near and far totally killed above and below yes and there are still some people who are more fans of above and below which is interesting to say the least i mean i've got no problem where they hit different strokes but i'm curious as to why near and far didn't replace above and below for you because both of these games from red raven games and brian lockett are you know essentially euro games for the story based things sort of well not pasted you know woven into it but in near and far the story and the euro game mechanics are kind of side by side 50 50. they work in great unison with each other whereas in above and below the story aspect kind of feels a bit tacked on you're playing the euro game but then occasionally you just might read a tiny little excerpt and that's about it there was no campaign in that one so it literally was just the single game and honestly i wasn't the biggest fan of the euro game part of above and below either it just seemed very basic or there was like some very you know clear ways not to play the game and better ways to play it it just didn't it felt like it was the well it was the first in the trilogy and it was like this is a good foundation let's iron out a little bit let's develop it more and then came near and far and once i had near and far there was no reason to ever play above and below again because near and far sat so much better
with my group now now or never has not replaced nero and far but again check out my review video for more details but for me they're similar it's a bureau game with story based mechanics but near and far just does it a lot more smoother there's still tension for spaces on your on the home board it just felt like a sort of better feeb i liked the fact that you walked out onto this atlas map and like did the little quests every now and again and that was just for a traditional mode but then you could play it in a free act uh story character campaign or an 11 act or something like that you know main campaign so you had your choices of what to do and even to be honest even the arcade mode in near and far i think beats out above and below so yeah this one was a clear kill but i wasn't exactly like screaming the praises of above and below anyway which is why it's not much higher but no say curious to know your faults if you think the other way around and you prefer above and below i'd be interested to know
my number four is kind of a bit heartbreaking actually because for ages i've been trying to defend whether i should have this game in my collection or not and it still is it's still on the shelf on the exact same publisher's shelf but honestly when did i last pull out imperial settlers when i got empires in the north and it just feels like empires and offices outright killed it you know imperial settlers is still a really great game i've got all the factions for it i've got all the expansions for it and i really enjoyed my time with it but then empires of the voip sorry the boy and paris of the north you can tell which one i've got on the brain uh came out and it just did it a lot smoother i've got all the expansions to empires in the north so i've got just about as much content but empires in the north is easier to play solo and to be honest i pretty much solely play the game solo but it's also just quicker to get out and play because with imperial set loads you've either got to have this massive deck of cards for each faction now or you have to go through a deck building process in order to get it streamlined down to 30 cards i can't be bothered with that ain't nobody got time for that i can't do deck building for things like the lcgs and that enough times i don't need it in a normal standalone card game but empires of the north basically said okay you don't have to deck build here's your deck and that's it that's it we don't add to it we never added to it this is your deck this is how your faction works go for it perfect nice and straightforward it's how i like to do things sentinels in the multiverse does something similar i like to have my own deck with my own character street masters another perfect
example again my own character my own deck that just works better for me without having to care about deck building in advance not to say i don't enjoy the lcgs i have to do that for but it's more time it's more hassle and so within personal north i get just as cool a set of gameplay as imperial settlers did although i would say empires are north actually i think the gameplay is better in that than imperial settlers especially with the scoring system being first to get to 25 or so many rounds as opposed to imperial settlers fixed round system which can drag on a bit yeah i just haven't pulled that imperial settlers in ages i don't know it really belongs on my shelf therefore i know if especially as empires and norse going to have an expansion coming out the wrath of the lighthouse i talked about in my anticipated expansions video it's just gonna like stick more nails and imperial set those coffin 51st state is now coming out with an ultimate edition and like i say empires of the north kind of kills that for me as well i don't know why i would have either it is too so it may be time to say goodbye to the imperial settlers like i say empires are north is just that good
for my number three man have i been singing the praises of this one and i don't know how many people have actually listened to me on this although to be fair i don't expect you to listen to me half the time it's just something that i've constantly been saying there is a gateway game that is regarded as one of the best gateway games to teach new players called carcassonne and i agree it is a really good gateway game and to be fair i'd rather play something like you know ticket to ride or a few other gateway games but carcassonne is still a great system it's still a great game i prefer the standalone ones to play in the original version now but i have been saying constantly that small islands uh i think it's from mushroom games having did it before maybe i've got that name wrong but i think lucky duck games has now brought it out i think it kills carcasso it's the same deal build up a map with very cute artwork building up islands in archipelago this time which is infinitely more pretty than french countryside i'm sorry it just is but the i like to say i know french countryside is beautiful but if you look at the artwork for carcassonne and then look at the pretty archipelago and small islands which ones do you prefer but here you're building up these islands with all these symbols on them and the idea is is that in between each round you choose an objective card which tells you right well i'm going to score points for having an island with a ton of lotus flowers on it or a ton of anchors or something and then what you do is that you as a group build up this communal map like in carcassonne but you're each trying to build up islands in such a way to benefit you and not other players but you don't know what their objectives are so you're kind of thinking well but this island's getting
pretty big maybe i should maybe cap it a little bit because i wonder if you're gunning for this but then also you need to have a spare house in order to put on the island and there's only so many slots the bigger the island the more slots there are but maybe the island's being built in such a way that there's not many slots on there and you can only go on an island once so you've got to pick the right time to score the most points from it not to mention that each player has a tile once in the game that they end the round with so you might give that up early and then for the rest of the game you're kind of at the mercy of the other players when the round ends it's a cool system and i know it sounds complicated i'm making it sound more complicated than it actually is it's still a very streamlined easy game to play with quite a neat little solo mode in it as well actually but yeah it's just a i just think it beats carcassonne out it's got a couple of extra rules to carcass arm but not many but i just think the thinkiness the the idea with those objectives and just the overall look of the game just as soon as i got it i just thought yeah why would i want to play carcassonne again not to say i won't play carcassore character is still a great gateway game but honestly if somebody said oh is there a towel laying game we could play i'd probably pull out small islands which i think is in the other room actually small islands first before carcassonne i really do
so for my number two this could be a slight little bit of a cheat because technically i've only played the prototype of it although to be fair it's a near finished prototype and it's fulfilling any time now actually i think in the next month or so it's going to fulfill to kickstarter backers and i'm expecting to get a full retail copy of the game obviously even deluxe version from alicat games as a result of doing the preview video last year but i stand by a comment that i made in that preview video and like i say i wasn't giving an opinion or a rating out of 10. i think i gave a first impressions rating and that was it of eight but this one eternal palace from any cat games coming out soon like next month killed kingsberg hands down these dice placement games are a dime a dozen now there's so many of them where you roll dice and like put them in places and do stuff with them well as much as i love alien frontiers indian frontiers is a bit more complex there's more to it it's a little bit more meaty and i still love it i still might prefer it to stuff like marco polo and out there but the the thing is there's not really been a simple really good gateway version of such a game other than kingsburg but kingsburg's a little bit bland and the second edition looked horrible aesthetic wise and i just never really got back into it i kind of burnt out on it but eternal palace is the replacement for kingsbury it is the go-to gateway level what gateway near gateway if not next step level of like it's an entry point for the dice placement system so simple sort of japanese style japanese chinese style film i forget what it was but the idea being that you get these dice and
put them on they just places to get the resources in order to build various landmarks but also to get these little arch panoramic like little pieces that you put on a little canvas in front of you and build up a picture now it's a gimmick through and through but man am i addicted to it constantly going yeah like this little picture and put the statue there put that hill there we could put a little sunset there and it's like luke it's your turn that quiet i get so wrapped up in that forgetting i'm supposed to be actually getting points but it's just very simple it looks beautiful and i stand by what i said in that preview video i just think that kingsborough can just move on now this one is just outright slaughtered it you know now not my number one because as i say it hasn't really come out yet so i thought it might be a bit unfair to put this at number one but still as i say you want an entry point into dice placement mechanics worker placement dice mechanics i can't think of anything better than the channel palace
and my number one is going to get me such flack it's gonna get me such flack although it's very divisive this one has it's like 50 share of like people who will agree with me and 50 people who get their pitchforks out literally in this case you know to kill me for this and if that wasn't a clue i don't know what is yeah for me it just stands around i am on the side that thinks that converter killed agriculture and it did and i have played agricola once recently i played it with a couple of friends from the southampton group and i did enjoy my time with it but again while i was playing agriculture it was still like i still feel restricted i have to get people to feed and all this stuff and you know it just felt like i have to play it this way everybody's gonna have a bit of everything by the end it you know if i make one mistake i'm screwed i must get kids like you have to get kids or you fall flat and yeah it just and it took a long time now i played it with farmers and the more and i admit it's better with farmers and the more but still i just rather play converter kaverner allows me to do what i want with the farming theme and granted fields of all i i don't think that kills kaverner because fieldsville is more of a solo thing whereas cavoner is more of a multiplayer thing but both of them allow me to do what i want you know i want to have all the sheep fine let me have all the sheep i want all the piggies i know all the piggies you know i want to just do nothing but grow pumpkins great i'll grow pumpkins i'm just going to go out adventuring all day you know what i don't want to go into my cave i'm going to be all outside or maybe i want to
stay in my cave and never go outside you know it's i can do whatever i like and it's still like an efficiency engine you still got to build up points and beat the other players but it's not like oh you didn't have this one like like little bit of corn in your field well yeah it's like right yes i take a little point a grickler is like that and that drives me nuts always having to think that's like well i don't really feel like i want a pumpkin go no you must have it and it just oh it drives me nuts in that one but not to say i hate agricola with a passion i give it respect i mean i you know i don't respect brass anymore i used to sort of give it a bit of respect now i'm just sick and tired of everybody talking about it but agriculture i still give respect and say look you know what this is still a fine game it's just not for me for me kaverner is what i wanted from a farming game and it's given me that love the expansion to it with the asymmetric actions that you can make and the idea that we're going to get this new expansion coming out later this year is now going to breathe more life into it so yeah i get it if you love it then great you're with me if you love a grickler and didn't like converter then i can entirely see why the arguments that they have to say that agriculture is better than coverner makes sense it's really just down to your personal preference and that's the great thing about board games but for me my number one kaverner slaughters agriculture in my opinion so there you go i'm gonna go about another minute and a half before this camera runs out of space on my little uh sd card but yeah hopefully you enjoyed
that top ten it was an interesting one to come up with but i'd be interested to know your thoughts in the comments let me know all your games that slaughtered well not all of them like pick out one of your favorite games and tell me what game it killed whether it's whether you agree with what disagreed with one on my list or something i didn't even talk about i want to hear your views because i did mention things like all good guests and stuff out in the past i even had a dominant species marine on the shortlist about replacing dominant species but i just felt like i don't enjoy dominant species enough to really worry it would probably be my 11 or 12. and there's other little things like that you know like manhattan project energy empire replacing manhattan project and i thought they're a bit different and then there's like you know boom lake replacing maracaibo but honestly both of those games i've kind of burnt out on and don't really care about anymore so what does it matter you know these were the 10 that i felt i could get more information on but that's it for me i'll see you on the next broken meatball video again remember to please thumb up and comment and let me know your thoughts it means the world to me you know you appreciate the content and like the stuff i do until next time you can check out some other top 10 lists i've done including my top 10 anticipated games and the follow up from that my top 10 anticipated expansions for what we're looking forward to in 2022 take care and remember as always whatever kills what it's still only a game bye for now