Player vs Player Combat: My Top 10 Favorite Games
Transcript
Hey, I'm Jamie with Stonemire Games and today I'm going to talk about my favorite player versus player combat mechanisms in games. Many of the examples I'll share today are games that are more than just dueling games, but there are some dueling games like 1v one head-to-head uh style games that I'll be talking about on this list. And notably, again, I'll emphasize this is player versus player. I have a previous combat video that includes some types of combat where you are fighting against the AI against the the the board game itself. Um, but in this case, this is specifically when players can deal damage to each other essentially. Um, I have uh some information from some of our panelists.
Actually, let's start with our ambassador picks. Our ambassadors picked these games at least twice when I asked them what their favorite game with player player versus player combat was. Andromeda's Edge, Arcs, Black Rose Wars, Cookie Run TCG, perhaps the most surprising game on this list. I have not heard of this game uh as far as I can recall and so I had to look it up how the Cookie Run trading card game works. And apparently it uses cards as hit points for other cards. So if you put a card on the table and it has three hit points, then you put three face down cards under that card, which is actually really clever. You don't need other tokens or or or uh yeah, any other tokens. And also when you it looks like when you defeat that card or when that card is defeated, the the hit point cards that were under it because they are just regular cards from your deck, they go to a separate zone where you can actually use those cards. So having a unit defeated doesn't necessarily feel bad in this game because you get access to these cards that you wouldn't have otherwise had access to. Actually pretty clever system for a game called Cookie Run TCG. Uh Dice Throne, June Imperium, Ironwood, Magic the Gathering, Misborn, Radlands, Robot Quest Arena, Root, Scythe, Star Wars Unlimited, The Witcher Old World, Thunder Road Vendetta, Undaunted, and Wonderlands War.
So, for the beginning of our top 10, I'm going to tap into our panelists here, and I'll share my other screen here. So, here is uh I think the only game on this list. No, there are two games that I have not played on this list. This pick is from our digital gamer, Caitlyn, and she picked Zenith or Zenith. I think someone corrected me on the pronunciation in the comments before, and I'm I feel like I'm saying it wrong as I say. I'll say Zenith just to hedge my bets. Caitlyn says, "Not sure if this one counts because I don't play combat games, but I had never played a game with a tugof-war mechanism before finding Zenith, and now I wish more games had this. I know it's probably not exactly combat, but it's player versus player and semi-aggressive similar to combat. I have not played Zenith. I need to play it on board game arena, but uh it does appear to have the tug-of-war mechanism is essentially combat. It can be themed in different ways, like in Hanami Koji, you're vying for influence.
here. I think it might be a little bit similar to that, but it has the tug-of-war mechanism inherently I think is a combative mechanism and I think I certainly think it does count for uh for a player versus player combat. Next up, we have the other game that I haven't quite played. I have played its predecessor um but I haven't played Andromeda's Edge. This is Dylan's pick. Dylan is our heavy gamer panelist. So, at number nine, we have Andromeda's Edge. Dylan says this. If combat is going to be present in the game, I personally prefer losses to not feel devastating. I resonate with that, Dylan. In Andromeda's Edge, there's sort of a there's a sort of consol consolation prize when you lose a combat and you can repair or recall units. They're not destroyed. I think this is key. This is crucial. I do this in one of the games that I designed that I'll talk about later. In some games, it could even help you to lose a unit on the board as it may let you go back to the space sooner than you otherwise could. And while I was actually okay with a dice system of Dwellings of Elder, that's the predecessor, Andromeda's Edge improves upon it by mitigating the dice rolls in a really elegant way. And that having more ships not only gives you more dice, but also more consistency while still leaving the possibility of underdog victories. So that is Andromeda's Edge at number nine from Dylan. Now we're getting to one of the games that would have been very high up on my list, I think, if I had if Skyler hadn't picked it. But our family gamer Skylar picked Star Wars the deck building game. Uh Skyler says this is a streamlined deck building game where you
try to eliminate your opponent's bases. So here's these opponents bases gathering uh damage as you play. It includes combat that is driven by a shared galaxy row where players attack opponents cards so they can't add them to their deck which often gives you a reward. This is the galaxy row here. Um, I also like the tugof-war force track as controlling it unlocks cool card abilities and bonuses. This game is a great start for families venturing into deck building and combat games. It's very rewarding and the she and the theme shines. I recommended it for ages 10 plus. And I'm really glad that Skyler mentioned this game because when I think about combat in this game, I think about fighting against your opponent's um units, like destroying their ships, which makes them go back to the deck. They're not permanently destroyed, but you destroy them temporarily. Um, but Skyler's right. There's actually three different types of combat in this game or really almost four types because you can destroy the ships. You try to destroy the the bases to win the game.
You can destroy uh cards in the combat row that you don't want your opponent to gain. And then the force track too is a tugof-war combat system. So there's three maybe three and a half forms of combat in Star Wars the deck building game. Um, when I was only thinking about one of them when I was thinking about this game. So, I'm glad that Skyler brought it up at our number eight pick here. My honorable mentions before we move on to the top seven. My honorable mentions were Kemet, Arcs, The King is Dead, Dead Reckoning, Unmatched, Wonderland's War, Adrenaline, Blood Rage, and Good Knuck. And let me talk about these, I guess, very briefly, some things that I probably won't mention in my top seven. I love that in arcs that only the attacker is rolling dice and the dice results can hurt the attacker and hurt the defender. Um, and the king is dead. I like that you only have you each player has a specific number of cards. It's like 12 cards you have for the entire game to use. Uh, and so you have perfect information from the start of the game. It's just your choice as to when to play a card or when to pass.
Dead Reckoning makes combat fun because it uses a big dice tower or a big cube tower. Um, and it's I'm sorry, I should pull myself. Here we go. And so in in Dead Reckoning, the cube tower, where the cubes land are good for potentially both players. So it's just fun to be in combat, even if you lose. Um, Wonderland's War lets other players who aren't involved in the combat bet on the combat, which is a lot of fun. Adrenaline increases the target on different players as they uh as one player pulls out into the lead. The it becomes more valuable to go after them and it also gives you some incentives to go after different players in the game. And uh Blood Rage is cool because Blood Rage makes it fun to lose combat. I think that's one of the things that I've noticed about a few of these games. Sometimes it can be fun to lose combat.
I think it's a clever idea in a combat themed game. And then last in good neck, uh this is a game where you can pile units on top of one another. Their units are cards. And so uh you can even if you lose the top unit of a pile, you still have another unit under it, which is important for the spatial aspect of good deck. All right, let's jump into the top seven. I included one Stonemire game on this list and that is Scythe. We have a few games that kind of have direct conflict. Uh, but I wanted to mention Scythe because Scythe was heavily influenced by Kemet, one of the other games on this list in that each player has a combat dial and when you enter combat with another player, you choose on that dial how much of your power you're going to spend up to seven.
That's this uh this power track over here. Um, so you can't spend if like the yellow players in combat, they have five power that they could spend. They don't need to spend all of it. And for each combat unit you have in the combat, you can tuck a combat card behind the dial uh making the total add up to a certain number, the amount of power that you spend plus the numbers on the uh the combat cards. So there's no element of randomness to it other than the card draw. So there are there's a range of between one and five values on the combat card. So you don't really know what value you have or the opponent has. You know which values you have. Also a little tweak for the combat is if you participate in combat just to encourage you even if you feel like you're going to lose to make you feel like you uh to to give you a reason to participate in the combat um you as long as you spend at least one power either on the power track or on a combat card then even if you lose you get to then draw a combat card as compensation at the end of the combat. So, for putting up a little bit of a fight, you get some compensation.
And this helps I feel like this helps encourage the attacker to actually attack rather than just paying the bare minimum because they never know if the opponent is actually going to spend at least a little bit or a little bit more than they expected um because they the opponent wants to put up a little bit of a fight to get that compensatory uh uh power card um or combat card. Anyway, I I I like how the combat system for sides worked out and so I wanted to put it on this list at number seven. At number six, we have another tugof-war game. I put Airland of Airland and Sea on this list. Airland and Sea almost definitely impacted the game Marvel Snap, which is not a tabletop game, but I wanted to give a little shout out to Marvel Snap. The idea is that you have little combat arenas or theaters that you are trying to have the highest total strength on.
Another game, Compile. There's a lot of the games in this like threelane combat system. Compile is a more recent one that does it well as too. Um, so you're playing cards that have a value on them and also an ability. And so, uh, you have a choice as to where are you going to play these cards? Uh, and, uh, how do the values add up so that you can have more you can win more theaters than your opponent. Ideally, you're trying to win two of the three. Um, and you have these abilities in the cards that influence them as well. And cleverly, I think Airline and C puts the number two on the back of every card. So you can play a card face down just for its two value. And there's even ways to flip cards. So you might play a card for a two value, kind of saying, you know, I just pretending that you're just playing it for the two, but really the backside of the card has a very very powerful ability that you actually want to flip um and get that uh get that power level on that card. So uh really really cool game, Airline Sea. At number six on this list, at number five, we have Marvel Dice Throne. This is generally a dueling game, but you can play at higher player counts. And one player is on their turn, they're going to be often attacking another player. They're going to roll their dice, and they're going to roll and reroll Yatsi style until they have hopefully a good combination of dice to activate one of their abilities, which they can upgrade over the course of the game. That's a neat combat mechanism, too. Making certain dice rolls worth more combat strength, basically. But then the opponent gets to respond because the opponent has at least one defensive ability. Usually these green cards are defensive abilities. They get
to roll their dice or a certain number of dice to defend against this incoming damage to try to deflect some of it. Some of the damage you can't actually deflect. So, really simple system of rolling dice and getting combos. Um, but really satisfying and and nice that both players get to participate, but also quickly. And that's something I I want to highlight in this system that player versus player combat, I think it works best when it's fast. Um I know there are some games that leaned deep into the combat systems and that's fine, but you unless the entire game is combat, and I guess in Dice Throne, arguably most of the game is combat. This is a game about reducing your opponent's health to zero. Um, but in other games where combat is just part of the game, player to player combat is just part of the game. Uh, if other players are just sitting there hanging out watching while combat happens and they don't even have the chance like in Wonderlands War to bet on the combat, I think it can drag on a little bit longer. So, I like when it's snappy in a game like Dice Throw.
That's Dice Throw at number five. At number four, we have The Witcher Oldw World, which does something really clever in that in The Witcher Old World, the the same combat mechanism is used to fight monsters as it is used to fight other Witchers, other players in the game. It uses this card linking linking system where you draw a hand of cards based on a certain based on your I think your life total at that at that moment. Um, and then you can play cards. It, as long as you can link them together. And the links, you can see some links here, give you additional bonuses. They might let you draw more cards. They might let they might increase your defense or your attack. Um, I think this is the draw card icon here. So, by linking the cards together, you get to play more cards, and you get these linking abilities that are really, really satisfying. So, I think the linking system is really clever. and also the fact that they use the same system for two types of combat in the game, including player versus player combat. That's the Witcher old world at number four.
At number three, we have this what I hope will be kind of a growing genre of um of combat mechanisms, which is auto battlers. Auto battlers is a a concept that came from uh mobile games, and now we find it in games like Challengers at number three. So, in Challengers, it's a tournament style game where you are going to be going head-to-head against all the other players and sometimes against bots if you have an odd number of players. And you in the kind of the downtime of the game, you're going to be crafting your deck. But when you actually have a duel, for the most part, you are not making any decisions. You are just flipping cards from the top of your deck. A little bit like the classic game War, but some of the cards do give you a little bit of a decision. and you were just trying to have um a higher sum on the table than the opponent. So right now my sum is six. So the opponent, if they want to capture the flag away from me, they need to keep flipping cards until the sum of their cards adds up to six. And actually this one says during the attack, this card has plus one for each trophy of your opponent. So this card might actually this combination might have more more strength than just six. Uh, and the idea is that you're trying to uh to have it to not run out of cards in your deck. And so if you need to play more cards or flip reveal more cards to uh to have a fighting chance to def to grab the flag from your opponent, then you are going through your deck faster than the opponent. Um, but it goes really really fast. Like combat and challengers is really snappy because of this auto battler system and
with only a very few decisions made on some of the cards. most of the cards do not have a decision for you to make. So, this auto battler concept in challengers puts it at number three on the list. Next up, we have June Imperium or June Imperium Uprising. Both use the same combat system with some tweaks regarding different types of units, but overall combat in Dune Imperium. I really really like that there's this that at the end of every round, you are going to have combat. You may not participate in it, but uh but you may. And in most cases, I think you may. There are multiple layers to the combat system that I like. A I like that there's a card on the table that tells you what you will win if you get first, second, or third in this particular combat. So that varies that kind of changes your decision as to when you decide to go into combat. There's different ways to get troops into the combat in the game. And uh the troops themselves are are different values. So you have the the troops I if I recall correctly I believe they're worth two com Yeah, they're worth two combat strength. Also the cards that in your hand that you don't play by the end of the round, many of them at the bottom of the card have uh combat strength that they are adding to the combat. So instead of using them to do kind of political maneuvering in the game, you are instead using them in the battle. So they're contributing to the battle itself. And you have intrigue cards, these cards over here that are sneaky.
Like they can be played, some of them can be played during combat to increase your combat strength in a non-visible way. So you have this visible strength of what you're going against with your opponents, but you also have the potential for sneakiness to change that number in such a way that you don't have full agency. So layers upon layers of decisions as you consider the combat in June Imperium. I think it's a very clever system that probably took a very long time to design and get right and I really like it. So, that's Junior Imperium at number two. These combat systems, honestly, I' I've talked about some combat systems. Um, so my number one is Misborn. Uh, I'm going to put No Misborn at number one, but it honestly it's one of the simpler systems of combat in the game. Uh, maybe even too simple to fully call it a combat system, but I think it's worth uh highlighting here because I think it's such a clever system that scales incredibly well at different player counts. The Misborn system is essentially the King of Tokyo system in which when you have the target, I don't see the target token on this particular photo, but when you have the target in this game, um it means that when any other player does damage, they are dealing damage to you. You are the target. You are taking damage from all of the other players.
So, at any other player count, uh any player count, you are taking the damage. However, if you have the target and you deal damage on your turn, you are dealing damage to all of the other players. Um, so if I deal five damage, I'm dealing five damage to player A, player B, and player C in a four-player game. So, and there's this decision at certain times when you take damage, you can decide to give up the target to give to other players. So, it's a really great decision there. Do I keep the target because I know on my next turn I'm going to be dealing damage to a lot of players, or do I just need to give it up right now? I I I can't afford to to take in more damage turn after turn until it gets to my turn. I love that decision space. I love that combat is super snappy. Like it really isn't there isn't back and forth in combat. It's I'm dealing five damage to you and maybe you can block some of that damage at best and you can just you just do it. Um there's no back and forth in combat.
It's very very fast. Um so in that way it's really really streamlined but it still has a lot of decisions in the game like do I do I gather cards that deal combat? Do I choose to use my resources on this particular turn to deal damage or do do I use them for something else? And do I choose to keep the target or give up the target based on how I'm how how much life I have at this time, how much damage I'm planning to deal elements like that. So, I really really like the combat mechanism in Misborn. And honestly, I think this system because it scales so well um would work in some other games as well. So, those are my top my top seven and then a total of top 10 using our panelist picks as well for favorite player versus player combat systems. I would love to hear what your favorite game is on this list. And if you have a favorite player versus player combat system that I didn't talk about today, let me know in the comments what it is.
Uh why you like that system and why it works for that particular game. I'd love to hear about it in the comments below. Thanks.