Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dexterity Game Mega Review - Alternatives to Jenga

Transcript 18:00

Did you know that in the Western world you're never more than 10 meters away from a copy of Jenga? That isn't true, but it doesn't need to be because this is just a YouTube video. Dexterity games have two key target audiences. Children, I win and people who like drinking games. Every time you take a block out, you have to drink. Every time you say the words Jenga, tower, block, fun, collapse, you have to drink. And obviously, international drinking rules apply. Welcome to actual lol. I'm John Perus. In this video, I'm going to review 12 dexterity games in the order I tried them and talk through my struggle, and it is a struggle to find the right dexterity games for me. I'm also giving away a copy of one of the games, Coconut. Keep watching to find out how you can win.

The first modern dexterity game I picked up was Click Clack Lumberjack in which players have to hit a plastic tree with an axe. On your turn, you hit the tree twice. You get a point for every piece of bark you manage to knock off. Hooray. But if you hit the tree too hard and knock off a trunk piece, it counts as minus five points. Oh no, you knocked off the trunk. Drink. Okay. I love what I click clack lumberjack is quick to play and it goes to seven players which is rare for a dexterity game but it's repetitive too often you achieve nothing on your turn and the point system encourages players who are behind to go for broke usually ending the game for everyone. I got minus eight points. I need this more than I need a kebab.

Never mind. Game's over. I bought it because I'd heard it was an improvement on Jenga, but I'd say it's a tie. I don't dislike the game, but I also can't get that excited about it either. The next game I tried was Bandu, a game of stacking wooden shapes. Oi, Timmy got wood. What? It's banter, mate. I don't get it. Instinctively, before even reading the rules, you just start playing with the blocks. The egg goes in the egg cup and the golf tea goes in the egg. This looks like my kidney after a night out. He gets it. He gets it. You're like a kid with a new toy. It's wonderfully tactile, and you can't wait to play a game that uses these pieces. The rules contain four different games. Most of the variants use gems for bidding, competing over blocks for your construction. And this is its downfall.

The auction becomes this pointless rigmarole, delaying the fun part of the game. Can I put a block on now? This process of auctioning off pieces means you rarely get the ones you need, which means you never end up building the incredible towers pictured on the front of the box. It won't fit. As an actress said to a bishop, "It's too big for the hole." That's what she said. I'd ask you to finish it off, but you're too drunk. Hold on, mate. They've never said that. There's probably a fun game in here somewhere, but I shouldn't have to design it myself. Next, I wanted to try a more involved dexterity game. Enter Terran Mele City, formerly known as Rampage. You're all monsters competing to destroy the city and eat its people. There are four different actions. You can flick the feet of your monster to move him. Drop your monster on a building to try and collapse it.

Flick a truck off your monster's head. And finally, the most unique part of this game. You can put your chin on the head of your monster and blow. This game is full of pedantic rules. You can only jump on the buildings if you're touching the curb. You can only eat the meeples that have landed in the region you're standing in, which never happens. I'm going to eat these people I knocked off the building. You can't. They didn't land in your region. But he's hungry. Here, monster, you can have this. And getting to other regions is slow and arduous. Your turn. Your turn. Your turn. Your turn. Then there's the cards, which unnecessarily complicate the game even further. They don't even say what they do on them. This drives me crazy. It's a family game, and you're expecting us to refer to a card reference sheet. And if all that wasn't enough, at the end of the game, you only get points from your meeples if you collect a set of all six colors. Look at how many meeples I ate.

Yeah, but you didn't get one in every color, Timmy. But I'm the best monster. I ate the most meeples. There are rules in life, Timmy. Sometimes they're pointless, but you've got to follow them anyway. But I'm a monster. Terror and Mele City does have the occasional fun moment. Flicking a vehicle at a rival monster or blowing down a building, but there's too many elements that suck the fun out to recommend it. At this point, I started to think that maybe dexterity games weren't for me. I needed something simple to get me back on track. Coconuts. Yay! Well done. In this game, each player has a monkey. I'm a monkey. And on their turn, they try and flick a coconut into one of the cups. It's like beer pong for kids. My mates are going to love this. Why do beer pong?

If you get one in, you win the cup and stack it on your board. The first person with a pyramid of six cups wins. You don't have to aim for the cups in the center. You can try to steal cups from your opponents. I got one of yours. Then you have to drink again. Yeah. Hold on. Finally, I'd found a game I like. Coconuts is pure silly fun. It's got a good difficulty level, and there's special cards which can do things like force a player to take a shot with their eyes closed. Coconuts only takes four players, but it can be extended to six with the standalone expansion, Coconuts Duo. And best of all, when you're finished, you can eat the coconut. I don't think I like coconuts. Thanks to the guys at Career Board Games, I'm giving away a new copy of Coconuts to one of you. If you want a chance of winning, simply subscribe to my channel and join the discussion below.

Animal upon animal is a kids game, which I'd heard a lot of people say works well for adults. In this game, you take turns stacking cute wooden animals until the tower falls. Unfortunately, the game is far too simple, and the die rolling system can have you constantly extending the playing field, making the game easier. I can imagine that it would work well for small children, but trying to introduce this to adults is just far too apparent it's a kids game. There are much more interesting stacking games for adults, which I talk about later on in this list. This is stupid. It ain't falling over once. When am I supposed to drink? I'm starting to remember things again. Need to get the washing machine fixed. I've been in a career I hate for 10 years. And I'm desperately lonely ever since Sarah left.

That's better. Beer and football. Beer and football. Beer and football. Riffraff is an eye-catching game. Players must load cargo onto a wooden ship that's balanced on a swinging pendulum. Be careful. It's walking all over the place. No, it ain't. Not the boat. Your hand. Players each select and reveal a numbered card that corresponds to a section of the boat. The highest card goes first. If after placing your cargo, any cargo falls off the boat, you have to try and catch it because if you don't, it's placed in front of you to try and get rid of later. Can anyone else taste acid? The first person to get rid of all their cargo wins. Riffraff is more than just a gimmick. It has plenty of tense moments.

Players pulling off audacious moves and calamitous failures when everything comes crashing down multiple times per game. Are you okay? Did you eat mommy's mango body butter as well? Never better. Nothing does more wonder than a tactical chunder. The cards ask you to outguess your opponents and you can sabotage too. You know where another player is placing next. Can you imbalance the boat enough so that they fail or will you push your luck and end up sabotaging yourself? Va pleti is a stacking game with strategy. In your player color, you have pillars worth varying amounts of points. The goal is to get the most amount of points on the top level of the building. This is a game for adults. It's not a kids game. Are you ready for that? Yes, I can be an adult. I want to be an adult.

You need to grow up. You can't have your hedgehog around anymore. Okay. Bye, Henry. On your turn, you remove any pillar of your choice from a lower level and place it on the highest level. The game even comes with a hook to retrieve pillars. I'm such a grown-up. But you've cut the way to play board games. You must remove all the pillars you can without collapsing the building. Then a new level is added, and you must try to get your pillars onto that level. The trick is to avoid your pillars being the ones left bearing the load and therefore trapped, not scoring you points. This is what adult life's like, Timmy. Competing to get to the top. What you don't realize until you get there is part of what you were has been left behind. And then when you think you're at the top, they introduce a new level.

And it goes on and on until one day without any warning, it all collapses. Everything you've built and there's nothing left. Villa Pleti makes you think. It achieves what Bandu wanted to, but without the hefty downtime. And the strategy is not at the cost of fun. It still has its own hairy moments and climactic downfall. This is definitely a step up from Jenga. A recent Dexterity success story is Rhino Hero. Rhino Hero, which is the new English title for a game previously known by the incomprehensible Super Rhino. Super Rhino. Super Rhino sounds like my dad. The concept is simple. Players are building a house of cards.

Great. Just like my life. On your turn, you place a folded card on the top of the building in the way shown on the card below. Then you place one of your roof cards on top for the next player to do the same. Yeah. Let's work together to build something we're expecting to fail. What are you, my ex-girlfriend? Oh, okay. If the roof card has a rhino symbol on it, you have to take the rhino from further down the building and place him in that room. The rhino's light enough to be held by the building, but he can unbalance things, causing the building to collapse. super wino wing all the time. Like Jenga, there's not much depth here. Often the winner is just the player who gets dealt the best cards. You hear that? It's all meaningless. This game, love, everything I've ever worked for.

But we were having fun. What about the drinking? This is why I'm drinking. But of course, no one is playing a 10-minute kids dexterity game looking for depth. It's dirt cheap, and it comes in a small box. Play for the spectacle. And don't worry about winning and you'll have a great time. You realize if a building of that size collapsed, the rhino dies every time. But he's a super rhino. There's nothing super about being crushed by 10 tons of brick and mortar. Stop living in Makebelie land and start talking like a normal person. It's time you grew up.

Timmy. Timmy. Come back, Timmy. We've got more dexterity game. Dexterity. A big part of playing dexterity games as an adult is the chance to relive being a kid again. Timmy. Timmy, you can come out now. It's like scalletwick. We used to love that. In Pitch Car, you take turns to flick a wooden disc around a racing track. The first to the finish wins. Sadly, Pitch Car is not a game that makes me feel like a kid again. It made me feel like a boring old adult who doesn't get it. There's nothing going on here. The decisions are vacant and the interaction is minimal. If a player races ahead, you couldn't even run them off the road if you wanted to. It's your turn, Timmy. I'm sure that at eight or more players, this game gets more interesting. But for an expensive game that takes up a lot of shell space, there's just not enough going on here to make it worthwhile.

I've had more excitement out of the tiny Rhino Hero box. Still looking for ways to reconnect with my inner child. I was excited by the concept of Flickup, a Wild West game with a boxload of impressive wooden pieces. It has the basic elements of a kids dexterity game with a more advanced adult game around it. This is it. I used to love playing cowboys. These pieces are brilliant. There's proper rules, scenarios. If this doesn't bring Timmy back, nothing will. It's a team game. You either play on the side of the outlaws or the sheriffs. You flick disc to move and shoot. Take that, you prick. This game does a lot of things right. It's got a cool theme and the rules are easy to grasp. But sadly, I don't really like it. And neither did my friends. It's had positive reviews from almost every board game reviewer. Isn't it more likely that rather than there being something wrong with the game, there's something wrong with you?

It's really long. A scenario will take over an hour, and the length amplifies its flaws. Having to flip the cowboy hats over after every turn gets old fast, and if one team is better than the other at flicking, they will always win. My findings suggest that the child inside you has long since died. You're simply unable to experience childish joy in the way most other board gamers can. No. Shut up. You don't know me. Timmy, if you can hear me, come back. I didn't mean it. You don't have to grow up. Being a grown-up is no fun. The biggest question I have with Flickup is when do you play it? It demands the same effort of setup, play length, and concentration of a normal board game. It works best with only two players, and it doesn't suit the relaxed party setting that I would normally play dexterity games in.

Goodbye, Timmy. I'd played 10 games. I was ready to make this video, but I couldn't let it go. I wasn't ready to give up on flicking games, so I took a punt on Cube Quest. You're stupid, Tim. This is never going to work. The boy's gone. Each player has a king to protect in their castle. You take turns flicking cubes at each other, trying to knock the opposing king off the board. The interesting part of the game are the cubes themselves. They represent different characters that work in different ways. At the start of the game, you're given 40 points to spend on troops, and that's where your strategy begins. You could spend big on a few tough strikers or buy lots of cheap but disposable grunts. It's like the difference between buying one expensive wooden chopping board or three cheap plastic ones. God, I'm so old. If a cube reaches the other side, you roll it to see if it survives. A striker has a greater chance of survival, whereas a grunt can die easily. Cube Quest has interesting decisions without fiddliness. the character traits, the cube placement, whether to fire off some kamicazi grunts early on or hunker down and avoid unnecessary casualties. I'd found the game I was looking for. This game is fun. Timmy, you're back. What about my back?

Nothing. Your turn, mate. That brief glimpse of the unbridled excitement of childhood when the weight of adult life lifts momentarily. That's what I've been looking for. My success with Cube Quest gave me hope for other flicking games, which led me to my final game, Targets. Players flick dice onto targets to win them. At the end of a round, if your dice have the highest value on the target, you win it, and it gets placed underneath your dice stack. In the next round, players can try and steal the targets from their opponents. As we've already seen in this video, some of the best dexterity experiences are the simplest, and target captures the pure fun of flicking. It's definitely not an easy feat getting your dice on those targets, and it's wonderfully interactive with players constantly trying to knock each other off or steal from each other.

Tim, when I become you, will I still get to play lots of games? Yeah, and they're even better now. Cool. It's great as a 15-minute filler, and it gives you a lot of simple fun in a small box. For that reason, I'll be keeping it in my collection. Tim, you can still have fun, can't you? Yeah, thanks to you. Growing up can't be that bad if I get to be like you. Ah, Timmy. Um, it's my understanding that this video is supposed to be a comedic look at dexterity games. But if you think about it, isn't life the greatest dexterity game of all? No, that doesn't make any sense. Of the 12 games I looked at, there's six I would recommend. Coconuts, if you want some silly interactive fun, riffraff for tense balancing. Villai is the thinking man's improvement on Jenga. Rhino Hero is the brainless man's Jenga. Cube Quest if you want a flicking game with a brain and Targets if you want pure flicking fun. Those are the ones I'll be keeping.

I've linked to all the games I've covered in this video in the description below. Thanks to Career Board Games, I'm giving away a copy of Coconuts to one lucky winner. If you want to be in with a chance, simply subscribe to my channel and join in the discussion below. If you like this video, please subscribe to my channel to see more of the same. I'd love to hear what your favorite dexterity games are in the comments. I'm actual lol on Facebook and Twitter. I'm John Peris. Thanks for watching.

Progress saved