Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Best and Worst of --- Stonemaier Games

Transcript 32:31

please put down your weapon you have 20 seconds to

comply hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple a show where I Rave and rant about board games usually more the latter this is a new series that I'm kind of traling for a bit I mean I know I tried to stop doing whole new show ideas because it does get a little bit too much workwise but I still want to dip my toe into other ideas from time to time and I've mentioned on my podcast I wanted to try kind of best and worst off Series so you know focusing on primarily uh designers and Publishers but occasionally delving into mechanics if they fit and basically just doing the best and worst from my own personal experience this isn't like a definitive subjective list it's purely from the games I have played from these particular examples these are my favorites and these are my least favorites does anyone want to get out now with this kind of idea comes its own fair share of problems for example designers designers occasionally co-design games so do you go after the ones that they design themselves or is it the fact that their names on the box good enough for you Publishers a publisher might come out with a game but then seven other Publishers might have also publish the same game at some point depending on region who' you go after the original person or is it fine that if your name is on the box therefore it counts and in mechanics oh boy you in for a world of hurt with that one you know put it this way go look up the on board game geek on the advanced search put it in network connection or rout connection or think of whatever it goes and you would think okay games like Ticket to Ride should be the Focus right and certainly they appear in the list but then so do a lot of other games that literally have a tiny aspect where you might connect a to be on some Euro game

with about six different mechanics is that what you think of when you play that game and same goes for ones where games have a lot of different mechanics I mean worker placement if you decide to do just worker placement you're going to get stuff like lost Runes of arac in there now lost ruins of RC does have two workers that you place down every turn is that enough to consider it worker placement when you've got the deck building part and you've got the you know the stuff you do on the board you've got the the research track you know it is it really worker placement or do you focus on something that is definitively all worker placement it's hard to do and so mechanics might feature a little bit less often than publisher and designer but you know it depends on what how people are flexible with the way I do this by all accounts it doesn't make sense so on today's episode we're talking about stonem games a publisher stonem games and this is a publisher who granted I've given a little bit of flack recently but they have been a very hit and miss publisher for me in terms of their games and certainly when it comes to marketing I don't think there's anybody better at Marketing in this world I mean you want to generate hype for a game talk to stonem because frankly they could they could basically take a little Pebble give it to you paint it blue and suddenly make this the most desirable board game in you know in the next year somehow they're able to do this with even the most like basic of ideas Kudos they know what they're doing on the marketing front with board games it's definitely more sort of H Hazard with me and uh but I do have enough to talk about my three least favorites and my three favorites and certainly for this series it's not always going to be three it depends it might be five it might be

two it really depends on how many examples there are five is right out so we'll start off with my least favorite and I am going to be ranking these so this will be the third least favorite second least favorite first least favorite and my third one is definitely a game and to be fair I think all but my number one my number one nobody's going to give me Flack four but these next two I'm probably going to get some Flack for but hey seriously Different Strokes different folks but my third least favorite is a sequel to another game that they published back in I think 2016 and it was a solid hit back then this new one got everybody hyped cuz they thought oh my God it's in the same universe we must have it I must have it now this is actually a great game I I want to own this game so even though Ryan had the negatives the dislikes he he wants to own this one and yeah this seems to be the way a lot of people do when these like different IPS get used again but this could have been its own thing it really has next to nothing to do with the original game that it came from and this is Scythe Expeditions expeditions has gone down well with a fair few people why these people are willing to play a five player game of this I have no idea I mean the game itself is a bone dry bone dry s of move around a bunch of hexes collect a few you know resources and cards go to another spot turn it in there go to another spot turn it in there it's one of these ones where you run around the map going from A to B to C to D to e to F in order to build up your engine as you go through but it's bone dry the

theme is barely there they try to invest some kind of story progression from the original Scythe but it barely fits the it barely even fits the universe it's in let alone the fact that it's just pasted on you know to whatever other dry game idea they had but it just gets very monotonous and boring I mean you've got a couple of paast of victory that you can do you know you can go really hard on uh forget what it is like a sort of quest type cards you can you know churn together these like you know special meteor rock cards that give you bonuses the more of them you play you know there's there's several ways can win but I find that doing that whole you know churning the metor cards I find that seems to be the most powerful way to do it every single time and the quest just should not be bothered with look let me go back in there and face the Peril no it's too perilous the game is just very dry very monotonous and stupidly long this one is crazy it goes up to five players and anytime a base game comes out with five players as a Euro game you should run for the hills when it comes to five because never is the game designed for five it's put on there to sell more cup or because there's some focus group out there who says I want the game to be paid with five because I don't know I got three kids and they're all Mentor students I don't know but it it really drags on with five frankly the game drags on with three three four or five this game easily eclipses 2 hours can go on to free maybe even longer than that I've seen five player games of this not even be finished in the space of a 4our game night this game just drags on and on and on with downtime that is

crazy now that being said the reason this is not higher on the list is because I do like it sort of average rating at one or two players two player is not too bad back and forth back and forth the game doesn't drag out too long I mean you don't really have much in the way of multiplay multiplayer interaction in this anyway so having two of you is better than having three four or five but solo it's not bad it's a relatively smooth AI you do what it is you do in a multiplayer game pretty much 99% and the AI gets in your way just as much as a multiplayer opponent in terms of like going to a hex you might have wanted to go to that is the limits of their interaction but at least you can get the game done nice and quick but when you factor in how big the box is it's a huge Behemoth if you got to store on your shelf for what is basically another dry engine builder like all the others and it's got you know it's overproduced again it's unbalanced which is a a thing that seems to be common in a lot of stone Mario games they can't seem to get game balance very well and the five mechs that you have in the base game they are wildly imbalanced you look at the you know Board Game Geek threads and stuff like that it is clearcut which the what ranking the five mechs are put in there are two that are easily the most powerful two that are easily garbage and then maybe one or two of them might just tussle out for the third middle spot but why is it so hard to get that right I mean if they claim they do so much play testing how do these things not actually come out in the play testing I don't get it but you know some people really like this game fair enough but I see a lot of people not like it as well I think this is quite a divisive one so I'll probably

get less Flack about this as I will get to my next one but uh you know again Different Strokes don't kill me kill him now my second one is a game which wow I mean remember what I talked about game balance this one takes The Chronic piss when it comes to game balance oh wow this is the poster child of how not to do game balance in your Euro games it just it's so bad that the game over its lifetime has had to come out with at least I think two to three different erators in order to try and balance out the initial game and it still isn't balanced this was incredibly over produced I mean you had these fantastic little buildings for sticking down on the map for no other reason than just simply to put them in little patterns it was a dry generic game and for those of you wanting the title it's tapestry and need I say more this game was the biggest BG bait and switch I've ever seen you tapestry basically gave you the idea of oh you're building up a civilization and there are these cards that you can really diversify the way that your civilization plays no firstly these civilizations as I said woefully imbalanced there's a lot of them and they play very differently great but they were not balanced at all some of them were just not fun some of them were way overpowered some of them were not even worth the cardboard they were printed on so they ared it probably within the first two weeks of its release two weeks I know it's not easy to balance a bunch

of factions maybe a you should keep the faction limit down so it's easier and B maybe just do more play testing generally because the release in AATA within the first two weeks is insane and they've done another one recently that you had to pay for you have to pay for this like DLC or whatever DLC equivalent in order to fix them again seriously why do people give this one a free pass and then the tapestry cards all it's called tapestries you think these are going to be a big deal it really isn't you get three of them in the game and you put one in like between these rounds you put one in front of you it does some effect could be instant could be ongoing whatever these again range from not worth the carboard there printed on to game breakingly overpowered and it's so clear which ones are better than others you could literally just take two out of the pack and instantly go this is fundamentally better than this one I didn't need play testing to do it I could literally see it with my own eyes and yet somehow this got past the quality assurance process again why but then once you get all the balance stuff out of the way what exactly is the game it's four tracks that you just spend time leveling up with a cube and they're supposed to be like military and economic and signs they don't feel like the things they are I mean military just lets you put bits on a little map uh you know building allows you to put like stuff on a a little pattern Grid in front of you which is like the most wasted potential for over production of buildings I mean the buildings in this are fantastic could you imagine if World Wonders by

Arcane wonders had these buildings in it oh my God would that be amazing and that's already a pretty well produced game but they're just so wasted here on this pointless little patent building thing and then on top of that you've got the sciencing which is die rolling for the most part there's a ton of dice rolling to dictate bonuses you get you don't want luck in a three hour Euro game how's that supposed to work and everything just felt like a bait and switch it's like here's a civilization game from Stone games nope here's a dry track leveler with fundamental balance issues and dice rolling I don't get why this one is popular I can see why some people might like Expeditions despite its time life tapestry I just see so many people give this a free pass or are so forgiving of it they acknowledge that it's unbalanced that it's basically just track living some dice and stuff but apparently that's fine and everybody's okay with this did I miss something demon Strokes for folks it just really didn't sit well with me so my worst one the worst game that they've done now you're probably already hating me for the last two I've talked about you ain't going to hate me on this one because I'm pretty B that there isn't anybody out there who a has played this game B who's heard of this game and C probably still owns it and likes it nobody like knows this game's existence for the most part and whenever I mention it whenever they say come on name me a bad game by stonem I mentioned this one first and they can't even remember it was a ston MRE game but oh boy yes it was pendulum pendulum was the only credit I can give pendulum like the one piece of credit I

can give this game is that it tried an Innovative new idea it tried to make a Euro game using egg timers where you could only do certain stuff on certain bits of the board if the egg timer was at a certain point and you had lots of them and you were turning them around and it was an interesting idea and I give props for them trying something relatively Innovative but Innovative doesn't necessarily always mean great I just respect it when I see it and hate it when I don't see it but this game was close to trash it was fundamentally boring it is literally the driest of Euro games ever whatever theme they tried to paste on makes no difference it wasn't even a looker it was ugly as Sin the egg timers turned out to be a really fiddly process I mean imagine four of you on this like EUR a boy trying to mess around with egg timers have you ever played kitchen rush or the doctor's version whatever it was called um I think AR tipia games did it or was a I can't remember but the those games you remember how chaotic those are and that's a co-op you ever tried doing it as a competitive game it gets insane but and at the end of the day all you do is level up a few tracks on your board and do Euro Victory Point stuff so what you're doing isn't interesting the way you do it is fiddly and annoying and this game just got no buzz I don't remember anybody coming out as a reviewer saying they love this game I think it's amazing every time I mention it nobody even nobody's even heard of its existence I'm pretty sure even ston Mar games are trying to erode this out your subconscious but I'm here to tell you it existed they made it and it was crap all right so that was easily my least favorite and I'm pretty sure for a

lot of people it's going to be the same for them so yeah I don't think I'll get too much Flack with this one okay well that's enough ranting let's now talk about positives so yes there are fre games from ston Mar games that I sing the Praises about all the time and think are fantastic now granted there does seem to be a bit of a trend that the best games that stone Mario have done are the older games the stuff they're doing recent ly is what's getting on my nerves so clearly there was a a Tipping Point where suddenly something went wrong and suddenly everything started crashing down but suffice to say I still love these threee games so my third favorite from them is this big box right here and I can actually get these out cuz I do own them here we go all here we go big legendary Scythe box Scythe used to be probably the number one that they did but nope this is my third favorite now it has dropped a little bit I don't get this one played very often and typically it's usually somebody else's copy but you know I have got every expansion in here so I've got sorry Fenris the encounters little subset which is quite cool I've got wind Gambit I've got the first one with the expansion factions there's a lot in here and certainly this box does contain a lot of stuff in here just to like really make it quite a fun experience but you know that being said it's got insert metal coins everything I think I've even got a playmat somewhere but probably not in this box but the the game Scythe is cool it's an engine builder through and through and you're trying to you know

you you've got a faction and you're trying to get these different goals achieved and the goals could be different especially if you throw in a Fus expansion to change up what they do but how you do it is going to depend a lot on your starting two boards you've got a Faction board and a kind of U Industry Board I guess you could call it and with that in place you then basically do one of the four actions on your board top and bottom but they're in different combination for different boards and different players and your faction will work differently and it's very much a race efficiency game where you're trying to achieve those goals quicker than other players but then even getting those goals finished first might not win you the game because you're going to score based on other stuff that you've done whether it's combat or economy or area control on the board you know there's a lot of different ways that you can play it now a problem that this game has is obviously with all this stuff in it does become a bit of a bug bear to set up and teach and all that you know it is a bit hard to get to the table uh it's not really a game that's really recommended solo either but the other thing is that a lot of your game is kind of dictated by those first two boards you can be the best Scythe player ever but if you've got a combination of your boards that is absolute trash you're at a fundamental disadvantages to anybody else that's in the game there are even again going back to the whole game balancing here some combos that are outright so broken that they are banned from competitive play yeah it went that bad so the game itself is still really fun though I like the efficiency puzzle it's smooth I mean if you play this with people who have played the game before this is definitely one of those I don't like to play with Noobs as you could

call it I want people who know what they're doing to play this and I want to play like a big five player game of this I have done six and seven I did one seven player 90 minutes before but that was because uh we all knew each other and the person hosting the game is brilliant at moderating I got to give him credit so we went around at a mass like really quick Pace but typically I would love to play this with five players you know on the reasonably regular basis with people who knew the game well so we could throw in some of these expansions not so much the airships I find the airships a bit of a waste I like the new goals that the airships expansion brought in obviously I like the two new factions I do think that the green and the purple are a bit underpowered compared to the other factions but they're still fun to play I seem to do better with green and a lot of other players too but I really like what came out of spoiler alert spoiler alert spoiler alert the fenders expansion threw in a module where you had basically interchangeable gold tiles that you could put as those end um end like the ones that end the game those are really cool to have and I love to throw those in pretty much every game I can okay spoiler alert DB so yeah Scythe still a solid game but just not one that gets to the table as much as I would like but I still really enjoy this one all right my number two favorite game at Stone Mar has ever done is again I seem to have them in very big crates for the most part but this one takes a theme that I really like in fact one of my other sort of Euro games also utiliz this theme it um introduced you know a really cool system of work of placement it had a lot of variety now it did need the expansion in order to make it as

good as it is as well as some of the other little extra mini expansions that came out so it wasn't perfect originally it got a lot better though I still love this here we go come on big crate here we go vid culture VI culture and I've got the wine crate here now not all the vi culture is great okay you know some of those mini card sets were not great by themselves they had some sort of balance issues but and also the expansion viticulture world was kind of coham check out my review for more details but the the marketing for it and the controversy that happened with that was complete what what was going on with that that made no sense either way and I still have suspicions about that but the you know the whole expansion itself not really that worth it you can play this Co-op it's not really a game I want played Co-op and even though the expansion is in this box I never play it anymore I am done with the expansion but the competitive game for Vi culture is still excellent I mean I have got you know metal coins with those leaves on it I have got all the expansions in here all the sideboards Tuscany the works and this one where you basically have you know a worker placement game where you go on these action spots in order to uh plant Fields plant the different grapes harvest the grapes and make different types of wine it's just a very it feels kind of Zen likee to me CU even though you have to be efficient and do well in order to get the right wines and victory points and you know timing and that is key I just find this such a pleasure to play

because I like wine and this kind of setting of a nice you know lush green field of grapes growing in the sunlight and making a nice wine even sipping a wine while playing this game is just really you know really nice to do now I pretty much use I think the same combination every time I always want to play with Tuscany you got to play this with Tuscany it just has to happen um but I like specifically to play with not only the mama and papa stuff but also the orange buildings the orange structure buildings and the and the Tuscany board like the big revamped board with different worker spots and the little map and stuff is pretty much Essential for this game I don't want to play vulture without those things included I mean you could pull my you could twist my wrist in order to get me to do it without the structures but You' got to have that tusy board if you don't don't have that I'm not playing it and also cards wise I like to use either the ones that are in the normal game because once you put in the new advanced stuff from the expansion it gets a lot better but also I quite like using the the uray Rosenberg set I find that one to be not only quite formatic but also probably one of the more balanced ones that was out there the one the visit from the Rind was fine but I did know there's something about that one it kind of gun hos you into a very specific type of play and I'm not sure it works as as well whereas Yuri Rosen word ones have a bit more variety but they kind of gear you more into the whole point of making wine which is well the whole point of the game is to make wine as much as I have won some games doing weird stuff like building up a cafe in a restaurant

and not actually making wine for actual competitors I'm just literally putting them in my restaurant it's cool that you can do that but you know those cards at least tried to gear you a little bit more to it but I still really enjoy this one I mean I would never play this with five or six waste of time you you got to play this with two three or four players uh four players is a very good amount actually for this but five and six is just way too much way too long too much downtime and really I know from the gameplay perspective the only thing that I can really fault is that I think that they put too much emphasis on having to get more workers worker placement game should be able to give you a good pro and con for getting more workers whereas this one is if you don't get more workers you will lose hands down you're just not going to win you cannot win this game not getting extra workers I mean I mean if you managed to do that somehow I can only imagine that your opponents were death dumb and blind because there's no way they should have like messed up in that regard but I do really enjoy this one a great theme great worker placement game VI culture still goes strong for me and my favorite my absolute favorite Stone marer game that they've ever done um do I really need to introduce it you kind of know it by now it's easily my favorite it's one I've played I think two or three times in the last fortnite actually and That's not including the occasional steam play you know Steam app I just really love this game do I need to say more I don't need dragons I want Birds wingspan which is not in the big nesting box crate that's in that cupboard over there

because that was a waste of money complete waste of money the nesting crate is not needed check out my review for the rant on that although when they release another expansion for this I'm sadly going to need that nesting crate because I've got everything up to Asia in here in this box with a folded space insert no problem now that does involve you having to Chuck away the sixth and seventh player boards because let's face it the flock mode in Asia who the hell requested that and who is insane enough to play this game with six or seven players I've got all the rule books I've got the well not all the rule books I've got the main upto-date Rule books in here the ones that sort of tell you a bit of everything but just to prove I'm not lying when I say this here we go go so I've got the Oceana boards because I will pretty much only play Wings B with the Oceana expansion in now but there you go folded space everything is in here and it is sleeved I have got all the cards and the bonus cards in here I've got these upgraded little birdhouse tokens I've got all the bonus things I've got the score pads the original Dice Tower which granted I would probably want to replace this with a wooden version at some point cuz it's starting to fall apart I've got the nectar tokens I've got all the eggs or as many eggs as you need I don't know if I've got every single egg that was ever produced but it all fits in here I'm telling you you can do it you just have to you know Chuck away some of the stuff you don't need I think I don't even know if I've got the um I have a feeling actually I might have also put in the

spares or in the nesting box the Asia one to2 player boards you know the new duet mode that they done because frankly this isn't really a game I play solo unless it's on Steam and I don't play this game two- player and even if I do I'd rather just play the normal Wings band game it's less to learn and less to deal with so with that being said you do have to make some minor sacrifices in order to fit it into one box but for me they're not particularly big sacrifices and everything oh actually I know I know there's a duet board so actually perhaps the duet stuff is in here I think I just got rid of the boards for the flock mode and that was it so and obviously the rule books that I didn't need but it all fits in here but that's aside from Storage yeah I love this game this game is fantastic An Elegant Tableau Builder where you have three different action um as well as being able to play Birds but you place them on the rows from left to right and as you do so when you activate that particular action the actions are stronger for having more birds in that habitat and then the birds themselves have got powers that when you play them at Round end at game end when they're activated uh when other players do something is that there's all sorts of them now because I've got everything up to Asia so I've got a ton of birds in here and it's just smooth elegant and yet gives you a lot of meaningful choices and a lot of different paths to vict especially with oceanana that fixes some of the balance issues that again balance issues notice a theme here with stonem that granted the base game of wings band had some balance issues but oceanana pretty much fixes those maybe not 100% entirely but they certainly

mitigate them a lot more and so that is pretty much the main reason I won't play this game without oceanana now but there's so many birds every time I play this game I come up with birds that I've not seen before that I don't recognize from some of the expansions particularly Asia you know that doesn't you know they don't see the the light of day too much cuz there's so many birds to get through and you're going to see so much so I've got endless Variety in here it is well produced the theme is fantastic I get like flavor text of all these nice looking birds the artwork is Sublime worms span tried to replace this or try to reimplement this check out my review for the reasons why it doesn't do that for me I don't want generic dragons with law made up that I don't need to know that's like pointless anyway with more fiddly faffy bits to contend with and a track to loop around I don't need that I want what wingspan had I love this game some people are sick and tired of hearing about this one all the time I totally get what you mean by that because I'm at the moment I'm getting sick and tired of people talking about a gentle rain all the time a game that I gain a three out of 10 to check out my old review for that that I didn't lockdown but seriously why the hell won't people shut up about gentle rain but you know I certainly hear from this one as well a lot of people are like well you guys just shut up about wings band right now and that's fair enough if you don't like wings band I'm not going to try and convince you otherwise you know you don't like it you don't like it but I still really love it it's one of those hyped up games that you won't stop hearing about that I actually latched on

to and went yes I agree with you I love it to bits as well if you don't fair enough but this one is probably going to be my favorite Stone Mar game like for life I don't think it's ever going to drop I don't think it's going to be topped the r Stone Mar going with their games there's no way they're going to put out anything that's going to top this so really the only thing I'm waiting for them to do is print out the other wingspan expansions I want to try Africa Birds I want to see if they can do like Arctic Circle and Antarctica Birds you know they've got the nesting box has room for other continents in it I want to see those birds now please can we have more of those and don't give me more mechanics I don't need more weird mechanics in the game I think it's perfect the way it is why did you just give me more more birds just give me more variety and I'm happy with that so Wings spam easily my number one favorite Stone Mar game so there you go that is my best free and worst free from Stone Mar games now you know some people will literally love to bit everything that they put out which is fair play good for you for me it's been a bit more of a downhill curve they started off putting out some fantastic games I love three games in a row that they did wingspan Scythe vid culture all three of them I think came out one after the other and I love them all still to this day I love them all but then something happened and then all the other games since have either been bad for me or mediocre I mean the mediocre ones are things like the libertalia reprint Red Rising as I said between two cities uh what was that other one the um a charter Stone you

know that was a very average mediocre game you know basically teach yourself a dull Euro in 10 games it's you know not enough to hit my worst free but it came close I did consider it so you they're they just they don't seem to be doing it for me right now and certainly they're focus on things like Expeditions and tapestry and that you know these are games I'm not a fan of I want them to stop doing that you've done all you need to do on VI culture leave it as that you've done all you need to do on Scythe leave it as that just give me more wingspan birds and if you're going to come up with a new idea then try and come up with a new idea because apiary was not that one for me I mean it just felt like a lot of other games and again AP was just average for me I've done a reval on that as well check out that one you know it had some bits I liked some bits I didn't and it just came together as a this is pretty forgettable but again everybody was hyped about it ston meire is the king when it comes to marketing games I don't know how they do it but when it you know maybe they're not the best at designing games but they are sure as hell the best at marketing them and I got to give them props for that from a corporate capitalism point of view so yeah they know what they're doing on that front even if I'm not falling for it a lot of other people certainly are getting into the hype and and if you love all their games then by all means do you know these best of free and worst free are not meant to be belit in anyone who like loves them all to bits we all like different stuff so if this is your favorite publisher in the whole world then let it be your favorite publisher you don't need to hear me say otherwise or anybody else for that

matter so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meble if you like what you see then please thumbs up on YouTube and let me know down in the comments what you think of these games do you have a different best free and worst free I'd quite like to see your list in the comments do you agree with my best free do you disagree with my worst free that kind of thing but also let me know what you think of this series in general I mean a lot of you are positive about the idea from a podcast this is kind of the sort of format I'll do it won't always be three it might only be two might be five it depends on how quickly I can do it I mean this video is already quite long for doing three of three so I'll probably stick to three but I may reduce it to two if there aren't that many examples of games that I can go from so it really does depend but if you like this idea of approaching Publishers designers and mechanics from a slightly more condensed version from a top 10 list which might be you know you know I don't know I hear top 10 lists are getting stale I'm kind of interested to know your thoughts on that as well do you really think that they're getting stale do you watch top 10 lists anymore I've noticed my top 10 lists don't seem to be quite as fruitful as they used to be so maybe there's time for a change but well let me know your thoughts it will be interesting to read them and of course don't forget to check out the reviews I've done on the channel for games I have mentioned here I mean I have done various wings spans one I've done viticulture world I've done scyth Expeditions I've done tap I don't think I did I review tapestry I can't remember I have to look that one up but I've certainly reviewed quite a lot of stone Mar games by all means check those out and see for yourself so take care and remember regardless of whether you sit truly level or completely out of balance it's still only a game so bye for now

Progress saved