Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Games I Got Rid of (And Why) - Episode 1

Transcript 15:52

hey everybody today i'm going to be starting a new series called games i got rid of and why now i think it's pretty suffix plans three what this um series is going to be about but i thought it would be interesting because there are a lot of reasons why i choose to get rid of games from my collection and almost always it's not because they're bad games i personally like to run a real tight ship and be quite cutthroat with the games i keep in my collection because for me if i'm not excited to play a game again even if it's really good um it will be gone um and that's because i you know there are so many games out there it's a real saturated market and i really do want to have the best of the best in my collection so i've got a lot of games to go through but i'm going to be breaking these into into 10 games per video and so there's probably going to be quite a few videos and i'll try to get them out maybe every couple of weeks or so so let's get started with this episode so my first game i'm going to talk about is 10 minute heist now this is a pretty simple set coaching game that takes probably about 10 minutes to play um and you are going to be having your little worker and these rows and columns of cards and the idea is you're trying to collect these different items um but you can never go back on yourself on up the tower and you're gonna try get to the exit and you get a few bonus points if you get out the exit and you're trying to collect different um different types of cars and whoever's got the majority of each type is going to score a number of points um from that explanation you'll probably understand why and this didn't stay in their collection it's very generic and it does what it does quite well um

but for me it didn't have that extra layer or extra layer of interest to make it different from a lot of the other games out there and ultimately there are a lot of a lot better filler games out there for me while there's nothing wrong with this one it just didn't excite me at all and um it never got played because of that uh the next game i'm going to talk about is 10 to kill or 10 minutes to kill this one i suppose it's not uh not a very popular game and not a very well known game but it's a game that takes place on this city um and you've got this kind of bird's eye view of the city made up of all these different tiles um and all those tiles you're gonna put these different standees of these really wacky and wild um kind of anthropomorphic animals and the idea is that we are these assassins and everybody's going to be given a a character which nobody else knows at the start of the game and you also get given two targets that you're gonna try and kill throughout the game um and on your turn it's gonna consist of i think it's two movements and you're either gonna try to move move a character you can move a police officer or you can choose to assassinate someone and you've got different options in which you can assassinate someone like for example you can you can shoot someone who's on a adjacent tower with you or you can use these sniper tiles which can shoot way across the board or you can stab someone who's on the same tile as you and the idea is you're trying to muddy the waters trying to not let people know who you are because they'll try and assassinate assassinate you but all that sounds awesome it looks really great great artwork and stuff like that but for me it wasn't a lot of fun um because number one it relied heavily

on memory because you needed to know who who all the different characters could have killed that person who was just assassinated um because you need to remember it for the next time that um that that someone's killed so who you know who's going to be the common denominator in those so you can actually work out who's done it in the first place so it had a really strong element of memory which generally i don't like and second of all i found what you do on each turn really restrictive because you can only ever do two one of two things and because of the way that you want to muddy the water so much everybody ends up kind of compiling in a certain area in the game um meaning that you because the police officers are there and they stop you from assassinating people you are constantly just moving things around and whenever it comes back around to your turn you it's almost like yes i'm nearly ready to kill somebody and then the person before you moves them back to where they were and it's so frustrating and you just end up going through the motions just moving them back into the places back and forth back and forth and never actually getting anything done so i found this way too restrictive and just each time being too just just too restrictive and not being able to do enough and for that i didn't enjoy it at all so um that's the reason why i got rid of tensor kill next up i have 13 clues now 13 clues is a pretty nice deduction game it's pretty standard fare um where you are trying to work out um the cards in front of you so you have cards like like a weapon a person and i think a location i haven't played this in a long time so forgive me if i'm a little bit wrong um and you are trying to ask questions

of your opponents um about what they can see basically because everybody can see everybody's pieces apart from your own which is cool in itself so i really like that idea um and is your it's your standard deduction game you're trying to work out you know how many items they can see and take things off and things but the reason why this one left the collection was because it simply got replaced um you know uh awkward guests came out and completely just smashed this one into the mud there was no reason to go back to this one when such a great deduction game came out there so no no ill reflection on 13 clues it did what it did really well enjoyed it i'd even play it again but ultimately there's way way better games out there now uh next up i've got five second rule uh this one was actually a game that my dad won in a raffle um awful party game where you are given a category and you've got to get to think of five things in that category in five seconds absolutely terrible um that's it i won't even talk about it it's just so so bad and that's why it's gone next up i have five two one one five two one one um came out a couple of years ago um and when i reviewed it i did review it quite positively and i still do think of it in quite positive light uh it's a game where you well it's self-explanatory by the box five two one one you always have a count of five cards you play two cards you play one card and then you play another card and the idea is that you are trying to play the most uh colors of cards to be the most

numerous because if you have the most numerous or whatever the most numerous colors amongst all the players are going to score you points at the end of the round but the the trick of this game is that when you played a certain amount of colors that got to a certain threshold then that color would go bust and then the next one down would score and if they would have a tie in colors then the next one down would score again so it's a game where being quite clever about what you play and try to shaft other players by making their colors go bust and basically try to tinker the game to your benefit but the reason i got rid of this one was not no okay no real bad reflection on the game it was just because i felt like i played it out i'd explored it there wasn't really any reason to go back to it there was this kind of trumping rule in this game where if you had a certain number of these cododo lizards out then that would be the all the lizard cars would score but i found that that never really happened and i don't really like it when kind of exceptions to the rules and kind of novelty things don't happen in games um it just didn't seem to work quite as well as i would have liked and i found that a lot of the times the the game would always play itself you know you always always be quite obvious about what to play and on top on top of that as well the idea of going bust it never really seemed to happen as often as i would have liked as well so i thought sometimes the thresholds were a little bit too high um where it would have been a bit of a tighter game and a bit more of an interesting game if the if the colors would have gone bust at a lower value and that's why i got rid of 521 ultimately because there's better for the games out there uh next up i have

abyss now abyss is an interesting one and um a game that i went through a bit of a journey with because when i first played it i thought it was so so and then i learned to really love it it's a really interesting pushy luck game where you are drawing these cards um all the different symbols then you're using those symbols to buy these character cards and then using those character cards for their cool abilities and ultimately to buy these different location cars to give you set collection bonuses a real unique game and i can't really think of too much like it beautiful to look at great aesthetic um flows really nicely um but for me there's probably two reasons why i got went went through the process of getting rid of this one number one is because i always found that the winning strategy was to rush the end of the game you know just to buy what you can when you can rather than trying to strategize and be a bit clever at what you clever about what you do and get synergies and things so that was one reason i thought the game really rewarded rushing and catching your opponents off guard number two was because my brother who i played most of my games with um wasn't too big of a fan of it so again i'm not gonna force somebody to play a game they don't really enjoy too much so um those two reasons um made it leave my collection but a game i'd have to go back and play but wouldn't really seek out again i feel like i've played it quite a few times now and um got what the game had to offer uh next up probably the one that pulled my heart on my heart strings the most to get rid of at least on this list this one is adventureland now this is a game by one of my favorite

designers um wolfgang kramer i think michael keising might have been involved in this one but don't quote me on that this one is a family weight gain where you have this huge grid of these different terrains and you are moving these meeples down trying to collect different swords and herbs and things and gold to get points and slaying these different monsters but it had a real cool idea where you have these three different scenarios based on the kind of level of complexity you want some would be like an area control game where you're trying to control these different castles by having those people in them but i love the idea that you would draw these cards off and they would things items would pop up all over the grid but you had to be the first to go there but you could never get back on yourself and up the grid so you've got to be worried about when you're going to commit and how far you're gonna travel down that board and i really can't say anything bad about this game the only thing for me was that the game only came with three scenarios and i think once you played them i i felt like i had no reason to play them again um and on top of that i think the expansion was is very hard to get hold of and i couldn't get a hold of a copy um but yeah a game that's very well-rounded extremely inviting and probably one of my most recommended family games it still holds my seal of quality um i do recommend it but for me personally i felt like a bit like some of these other games i felt like i had explored what it has to offer i'm satisfied with the amount of times i've played it nothing bad to say about it but ultimately i wouldn't have gone back to it at least not with any degree of excitement next up i have

um definitely the heaviest game on the list this one is alchemists now alchemists is one of the first games that implemented app use it's a worker placement and deduction game where you are trying to work out these different i don't know how to explain it you're trying to work out what all these different ingredients kind of chemical sign is and you're trying to use that to publish these theories and if you're right to be the first to publish theories you're going to get points and people can debunk your ideas and things i love the concept the idea of this game it's really cool but and there's a lot to go into and i can't really explain that in just in just a minute or so but for me the the level of complexity and fiddliness with this game stopped it from getting to the table and also kind of probably more two hours two and a half hour length in game as well which again stopped it from getting to the table as regular as regularly as we would have liked it to i can't really say much bad about it the worker placement element of the game didn't didn't kind of rock my world i thought it was quite standard and wasn't terribly exciting you know just getting your resources and things but that deduction part of the game was really well done uh extremely interesting um and very brain burnery um but ultimately it wasn't a game we were in the mood to play very often and a bit like 13 clues um in terms of being a deduction game it got replaced by awkward guests again it just completely kicked out of our collection and we know that well as soon as we got awkward guests we were

never going to go back and play um alchemist so a shame a really good design and um certainly um you know certainly requires some you know praise about how well this is put together but just those few little speed bumps and hurdles to go over i just stopped it getting paid uh next up i have a game from 2020 actually this one is alma mater now animator was actually one of my most anticipated games of last year um because it's by some of my favorite designers and um kind of touted as a spiritual successor to um coinbra which is one of my favorite games this one is a really great theme about being these i suppose these headmasters and these different universities uh you are it's a work replacement game um where you are trying to use these books ready and these books have kind of a changing value throughout the game and you are collecting these abilities and so on for me i was hugely disappointed with this one i couldn't even explain how let down i felt with this i didn't enjoy it at all i felt all the abilities you can get were really boring and stagnant i thought the game had a real um boring slow and churning way of collecting resources it just didn't feel like you were achieving much at all with this one looked gorgeous but the gameplay despite my you know trying to look at this through rose tinted glasses it just didn't shine for me it was dull boring and um just just no fun and um for me that's just inexcusable not no no good at all and um

the first game i've ever made that i didn't enjoy next up and finally in this episode the game i'm going to be talking about is architects of the west kingdom so architects of the west kingdom is immensely popular worker placement game a game that has a real nice flow to it because there's no turns or anything in this game you're collecting resources buying buildings you can choose to arrest other players it has a real nice um building a kind of compact compounding way of collecting resources where you if you place works on a certain spot you know the first person you place would get one resource then you get two resources and three resources per placement which is really good so it had a real nice um flow and kind of um trajectory in the game which i really liked i can't fault it at all for me though i i'm i'm a bit funny when it comes to worker placement games i i i need them to be something really special for me to enjoy them you know yeah i like your sulkins for example you know you've got the gears or your barrages where you've got the main boardwalk that's really interactive worker placement for me shouldn't be the the main focus on a game but i like the other stuff that goes around it and use the worker placement as a as a framework but for me this one was a bit too similar to those um mediocre work placement games that i used to get people into the hobby you know games like your stone ages your um your lords of water deeps it was a bit like that with a few extra layers in terms of the i said arresting the other players in terms of collecting the resources there's some tracks as well that are quite interesting ultimately a really

nice game that was very well designed and i can't fault it but my personal tastes didn't differentiate this from a lot of the other games on the market and after a few plays it didn't excite me anymore and that's the reason why i got rid of it glad i played it enjoyed my plays of it um but no reason to go back and revisit it so i hope you enjoyed this first episode of my um games i got rid of and and why um if you have enjoyed it please give me some feedback and let me know where i can improve things or and so on if you have please enjoy the video that is ah please hit like and subscribe to our channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved