Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 25
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another edition of board games I got rid of and why so in this series I take a look at some games that I've previously owned but for one reason or another no longer do and I tried to give some ration out as to why I came to that conclusion now before I get started on the video I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are by far the best online retailer here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order but let's get on with the games Okay so the first game I'm talking about today is Mercado de Lisboa by vitaliser now this is actually extracted from a larger and more complex game called Lisboa by the same designer so it's actually just a portion of that bigger game so it's an abstract Style game as you are putting out these different kind of shops to try and fit these customers needs to get points and bigger multipliers the more YouTube meets essentially and I actually found the game quite interesting at first but I think the more before I played it and the more I started to realize that this game wasn't as complex as I first thought or not as deep as I first thought so I actually thought the decisions were relatively uninteresting and pretty obvious uh once you've groked the game now that's a shame because the actual production and the visual aesthetic of the game was absolutely stunning this is a gorgeously produced game as you'd probably expect from Eagle Griffin but for me the gameplay itself was a little bit of lackluster and I think that's almost Hoodwinked slightly when I first
played this one because I think my initial review was pretty positive but the more I played it those diminishing returns certainly did become a factor so yeah no real desire to play this one anymore and I quickly I'm tired of it so that is Mercado de Lisboa next up we have the chronicles of crime which was very Innovative at the time so this is a Cooperative kind of murder mystery and crime solving game as you are interacting with these different components which are items no evidence characters and locations through the use of scanning QR codes and then you could ask these characters about the evidence you found you can visually scan crime scenes Etc a very novel concept now um this is a one and done Style game so once you've done one of the missions you've experienced it can't go play it again because of course you've uncovered all those um surprises and but I did enjoy my time with this one I think especially my first play of it was a really great experience and after that it kind of struggled to live up to that initial experience and I actually think that some of the expansion material is just as good if not better than the original base game stuff so for example there is this kind of film Noir gumshoe detective style um expansion which I thought was really cool because it added new elements into the gameplay such as you know um kind of intimidating people or beating them up Etc which was really cool and I think that there's a ton of different themes and Concepts that could be lent to this game design and framework which has been done but for me I think I'd I've had a good time with it I've had some great
missions and I think I've kind of ready to move on from it so I would actually recommend people to try this one if they are in to those murder mystery Cell games um and like to solve a pretty straightforward mystery now I will say that some of them are a little bit predictable for me I thought that you know not to give too much away but sometimes if there's a particularly scary looking character that just so happens to be the bad guy that kind of thing and there's some cliches and some things that clearly wouldn't work in real life and in the way you interact with people and that did slightly dampen The Experience um but overall I thought it does what it does very well but yeah just kind of played it and ready to move on so therefore that is why the chronicles of crime Chronicles of crime left the collection next up I have hamburgum which is actually a Mac Gertz design who happens to be a designer I love you know I love navigador I love Concordia um now hamburger is a great gamer this is a fantastic Euro game the reason why it left my collection is because there's other games I mentioned pretty much do everything hamburger does but slightly better so I think this was almost an inspiration for those other games and sometimes that's the case with designs where and one game is kind of a building block or a platform to lead to a better one and it kind of rendered this game a bit useless really I also thought this game didn't scale terribly well about two players I thought you were getting a weaker experience than at higher play accounts um so yeah this had a lot of um stuff that I love you know about tailorable scoring
um a great use of a rondelle um yeah I really did enjoy it and if there's other games I mentioned the Navigator and Concordia didn't exist I would no doubt still own this one but again those games rendered this game useless therefore it had to go so therefore Hamburg left the collection next up I have El Capitan which is a Wolfgang Kramer co-design with somebody other than Michael keisling now I forget the other guy's name but that doesn't really matter um now generally I love um Wolfgang Kramer games um I tend to like area control games and I tend to like dry Dusty Euros now this one is all of those things but it was a bit too dry even for me and this was a very rigid game a game of error control as you're trying to influence these influence these different kind of countries I believe I thought the money in this game particularly in the first half was extremely tight we have to waste kind of action economy to get loans and things I tend to struggle with games with loans and I just struggled to extract the fun from this one despite me really looking for it because you know I tend to love those you know older style Euros that have been lost in time but sadly I think there was much to recuperate from this one and it was a bit a bit of a strong example of a game of its time so I think this one has been surpassed and there are so many other great Euros that you can look at before this one so therefore El capadon had to go it wasn't bad at all but it wasn't great either next up I have hidden leaders so this is a gorgeous looking game I mean I love the
artwork and the art style of this one I mean it's a tug of war push and pull style game as you're using these characters to move these kind of communal pieces on this track now each player is going to have a hidden objective on what they want to achieve so some might say if you are the evil character you might want to push it all the way to the graveyard side of this track send them I wanted it to remain a bit more neutral some might want it to go to the other end Etc now what that meant for me was that it was pretty obvious by what people were doing what they wanted to achieve and if you had a polar opposite objective or somebody else it became a very tedious exercise of one's appeared back and forth and back and forth and back and forth and remove a few spots up move it a few spots back and I've really come to notice over the years that I do struggle to get enjoyment from push and pull or tug of war style games because I find that a lot of the time the first half or the first three quarters of the game is kind of pointless because the other player is going to spend their efforts to undo what you just did and that is what hidden leaders is all about now I do believe this game got quite a lot of praise and when it came out and I was kind of in the minority and what I thought about it um I'm not sure if that was a bit of much a bit of confirmation bias maybe people wanting to reaffirm that they backed a good game on Kickstarter but I really did struggle to find where the game lied with this one um despite looking fantastic so therefore hit leaders had to go the gameplay was simply too weak next up I have Hanabi I'm immensely popular Cooperative game
I'm a game where you are showing your cars to your teammates and trying to give them Clues on what's in their hand and they're trying to give you Clues to what's in your hand and you're trying to play these kind of firework displays um really cool concept um corruptive games are not my forte another thing much like the push and pull thing or the tug of war games corruptive games I tend to shy away from not deliberately I just tend to notice that I don't have many of them because I don't tend to enjoy them too much and I thought that once I'd learned how to play Hanabi um and you know did well for a round or two I thought okay that's cool that's novel um what's next so another game I'm in the minority of because I know this one blew up people are still playing this one um and I'm sure there are a lot of nuances and some things you can learn and uncover and unravel the more you play it um with the same group but sadly I wasn't really willing to put that time in because I wasn't that invested in the first place so therefore Hanabi left the collection next up I have Pasha which is a very simple dice game this is almost a yahtzee variant as you're rolling a bunch of dice trying to get the best combination of them and put a clay marker somewhere on this grid now the thing I liked about this game was this wagering mechanism where if you think you can beat somebody else's score you can play a higher point value card see I think if everybody's rolled relatively low then you might think well this is a good chance for me to try and roll higher and therefore I'm going to put my high card down and hopefully claim it for myself now that's pretty much the extent of the game there's no
depth here there's no complexity which is not always a bad thing of course I like simple dice games but I think there are better simple dice games than this out there and I think about games like the simple Rhino connected games like um Age of War or even something like high score I think I'd rather lean towards those games to do what this game did anyway and they're probably even a fraction faster than this one so I did like it it had a certain charm to it but it was a bit of a one-trick pony therefore Pasha had to go next up I have lost kingdoms which is almost an abstract top placement area majority game as you have this modular board which You're Building of course by placing these tiles as you go um these um these tiles are going to form Islands you're going to be wanting to pop into these islands with your dinosaurs even breeding your dinosaurs to create more of them Etc to try and dominate them in terms of you know majorities um there are a ton of games like this out there now I think this one was a little bit too abstract from my personal taste a little bit rigid and a little bit of zero sum in terms of what you could do a little bit plodding as well um because to kind of Reform these islands and slide these tiles around it would take a long time to do it and it didn't take a long time for you to move your dinosaurs around now I think this game really did shoot itself in the foot by putting too many abilities on these islands which would prevent you from doing things which would slow down and already slow game so sadly this um this cool concept didn't quite pay off me in fact it definitely didn't pay off
and you know the competition for good area control area majority of games is just a huge yeah there are a ton of them out there and you can play a really fun game in the same time you could play Lost Kingdom so it definitely couldn't even hold a candle to so many games already out there I think this one's going to get lost to obscurity unfortunately so that is at lost kingdoms one that had to go next up I have cue Birds which was a very near Miss for me not in terms of my enjoyment of it because I think this is a solid game but more in terms of it holding its own in my collection because I have a ton of pretty simple hand management set collection card games out there or in my collection and this is another one of those um and I did like a lot about it and there's some quite unique things about it as well so in this one you are basically playing or collecting these um Bird cars by drafting them but I like the fact you have to give up cars to get new ones by trapping them and they're trying to play these birds out in um or as many cats as you can to try and race to get a certain amount of birds play or even to go for an alternative scoring condition where I believe you want to play fewer different sets but stronger versions of them now I had a very cool flow to it as cars were constantly come in and out of your hand but ultimately I thought that the more I played this one I thought that I'd probably rather lean towards another card game I have and I think this is just one of those first world problems where we're so spoiled for choice that even great games like this or both solid games like this don't quite make the cuts so yeah I think this is just a victim of being a convoluted or a busy
area of the board game space at the moment so maybe a long term I might look at a real crime reacquiring this one because it is quick it is simple and it is kind of my jam really but um yeah at the moment I'd lean towards other games before playing Cuba's therefore I had to be a bit cut throat and remove it from my collection and the final game I'm talking about today is going to be the most controversial game on this list because this was a lot of your guys favorite game of 2022 now the game I'm talking about is Carnegie so this was actually one of my most anticipated games of last year because on paper it has everything I'm looking for it's a medium heavy economic Euro game by a great designer now I got the game played I did enjoy it I certainly thought it was solid or well Blended a bunch of mechanisms um but I could not help leave the game feeling somewhat underwhelmed because I felt like I'd seen everything this game did and before definitely had no unique identity nothing that made it stand out it's relatively complex I've had some good play interaction and it has some quite novel mechanisms especially when it came to the unique personal player boards where you could move your meeples around to different departments to trigger them now maybe this game was a victim of timing for me personally because this last year I've slightly started to kind of move the needle towards maybe lighter games more medium weight games that have depth but aren't so rules heavy or so rules intensive
where Carnegie was maybe slightly above my comfort zone or Comfort Range that I'm looking at right now so uh was I really prepared to keep teaching this game to new Gamers it's going to take about two hours to play um I just thought you know what this game's out there that I enjoy more that are faster they're a bit more succinct and basically have that unique identity because you know the more games I acquire I like my games to feel different in what they offer to my collection and I don't feel like Carnegie did that despite being a solid design so there we have it that concludes this episode of board games I got rid of and why I always enjoy making these videos and it's clear that you guys do too because it's probably one of my most popular uh series if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too uh but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye