Vault Wars Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Vault Wars
Vault Wars is a bidding and bluffing game from Floodgate Games, designed by John Gilmore and released in 2015. Players take on the role of aspiring heroes competing to claim the vaults of heroes who died in the line of duty. It plays three to five players in about an hour, and the pitch is simple: bid on vaults without knowing exactly what is inside, then finish with the most valuable haul.
Reviewers keep reaching for the same reference point. The game borrows the feel of the television show Storage Wars, where bidders buy storage lots without seeing everything inside, and most coverage treats that comparison as the hook. Actualol opens its entry on the game with exactly that framing, describing bidders who do not always know what they are going to get at the end of an auction, and noting that the game works the same way.
Board Games UnLocked makes the same link in its top 100 entry, describing the game as storage wars with a fantasy theme, where one player sets the starting price after seeing what is in the vault, and names the set collection alongside the bidding as the reason it stands out on a ranked list.
Core Mechanics That Define Vault Wars
Auction and Bidding
Each round, one player acts as the auction master for a vault. That player makes the opening bid and then drops out of bidding, so they cannot raise the price later. Everyone else bids back and forth until the highest bid claims the vault. Because the auction master cannot re-enter, they have to estimate what the table will pay for the items they can see. Meeple Mountain describes the core loop as bidding and bluffing, and that combination drives the game. Players use the money at their disposal to bid and bluff against their opponents, trying to claim the vault they believe has the best loot, while being warned that plenty of junk can hide inside the vaults as well.
Vault cards are built to keep bidders guessing. Each one shows how many items it holds and reveals some of them to the table, while a peek value lets one player secretly look at a face-down card. Bidders therefore know only part of what they are buying.
Compound Scoring
Winning a vault is only the start. Once the vaults are resolved, players total the points from the item cards they kept, then add any vault rewards and in-game bonuses their heroes have earned. Meeple Mountain describes this as tallying up everything gathered during play, so the scoring rewards both the big purchase and the way the items fit together. Set collection is part of that appeal, and Board Games UnLocked names it alongside the bidding when explaining why the game stands out.
The Vault Wars Experience
Bluffing Tension
The bluffing supplies most of the tension. The auction master sets the opening price while everyone else reads it, and players try to hide what they actually know about a vault. Meeple Mountain notes that players can play mind games with one another about whether a vault is really good or really bad, distilled down to a fun little auctioneering game built around that uncertainty.
Lighthearted Casual Fun
The tone stays light, and reviewers treat that as a feature. Groups that want to laugh and bluff more than plan a long strategy tend to get the most out of it. Meeple Mountain calls the game super fun and light-hearted, a travel-size title that fits a casual gathering or a trip to the pub, and says the low cost point makes it an easy addition to a collection. Board Games UnLocked describes it as a social game where everyone is sitting around the table, and the teaching is quick enough for a casual group.
What Makes Vault Wars Stand Out
Varied Vaults and Optional Workers
Each vault carries its own unique abilities, which players must track and build strategy around. Meeple Mountain points out that this keeps individual vaults interesting even when the core rules stay the same, so every auction can feel different from the last. The review also covers an optional workers rule, where individual characters costing between one and five gold enter play offering unique timing abilities, giving each player's approach a bit more asymmetry as a game goes on.
Relic Roadshow Expansion
Meeple Mountain covers the Relic Roadshow expansion, which adds cursed relic cards drawn from a separate deck. Relics keep a gold and victory point value like other items, but each one carries a transmute cost: a player has to give up a specific item, or several, to activate it before its larger, game-changing ability can be used. Meeple Mountain calls this one of the favorite additions in the box, saying it adds real strategic depth and new options for players willing to cycle their collection to unlock a relic's power.
Potential Drawbacks
Light on Strategy
Meeple Mountain is clear going in that this is a light game, and players expecting a deep strategy element will not find it in the base box. Even with the added depth of workers and relics, the bidding and bluffing still carry the experience over long-term planning or engine building.
Blind Bidding Can Feel Like Luck
The flip side of the theme is that winning a vault does not guarantee a win at the table. Meeple Mountain describes going in practically blind on a vault, paying good gold for it, and hoping to roll the dice into a full matching set rather than a pile of junk. For a group that wants its decisions to matter more than its luck, that gap between a confident bid and an empty vault is the game's rough edge.
If You Enjoy Vault Wars
Meeple Mountain compares Vault Wars directly to Bargain Quest, describing both as high fantasy auctioneering games with a shopkeeper feel. Players who enjoy the auction tension and the fantasy setting of Bargain Quest will find a familiar rhythm here.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Imagine the TV show Storage Wars where people are bidding on storage lots and they don't always know what they're going to get at the end of it. This game is a bit like that."
— Actualol
"You're going to use the money at your disposal to bid and bluff against your opponents to try and claim the vault that you believe has the best loot. Now be careful, there's a lot of junk that could be in these vaults as well."
— Meeple Mountain
"This is a super unique theme because it's storage wars with fantasy and you're doing set collection, everything, and you are auctioning off lockers and there's bluffing and all that stuff."
— Board Games UnLocked