Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 21

Transcript 18:39

hey everyone and welcome to another installment of board games i got rid of and why so in this series i talk through 10 board games that i used to own but for one reason or another no longer do and i tried to give some rationale as to why i came to that decision before i get talking about these 10 games i want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kianda dot co dot uk who are my go-to online retailer here in the uk and if you use my discount code in the show notes you can get five percent off your first order and help the channel when you do so but without further ado let's get started on the first game so the first game i'm talking about this episode is kariba which is a small box card game by doctor reiner kinicia this game is feather light it's probably one of the lightest games i've had in my collection for a long time or did have for a long time this game is a very simple game where you're trying to play these cards out and this wheel system so each of these cards represents a different animal and they all have a different number assigned to them so the bigger the animal the bigger the number essentially but what you're doing is you can play any number of cards of the same type on this wheel up in their pre-allocated space and as soon as a third animal of a type or three or more animals are played then you're going to take all the cards of the next smallest animal so if you say you played three eights you'll grab all the available sevens on that wheel um however if there were no sevens then you'd go and eat the sixes and so on so this is kind of a game we got to be very careful about what you leave your opponents because sometimes you'll play a couple of eights down and then they'll

eat the you know the next line go down and then somebody will play the ones which will loop background and eat all the eights so you want to be playing animals but not leaving too great of opportunities for your opponents to gobble the animals that you've just played as well so it has that constant back and forth that's pretty much what the game consists of every single animal you collect is going to be a victory point and this is definitely one of those games that depending on the player count the experience is vastly different so in a in a three or four player game it's a lot more chaotic you can't really predict about what people are going to do but in a two player game believe it or not this game is actually quite tactical and pretty interesting because it's this constant goading trying to lure people into trapping your animals so you can chop them with other ones and get these kinds of kind of chain reactions really to benefit yourself so actually more here than meets the eye when it comes to that two play account however if i am going to play a two-player game i'm probably going to play something you know especially designated for two players um because there are so many great ones out there which meant that kariba was kind of pushed to the wayside and again if i am looking for that three or four player account i want a very short snappy game then this one just isn't quite as good as some of the others just because of his chaotic nature the second game i'm talking about is new york zoo by oovey rosenberg and like a lot of rosenberg games this is a polyamino tetris style game if you're trying to fill up your board representing a zoo in this case with tiles representing the animal enclosures but the the kind of twist on this game was that you can actually acquire these animal meeples and put them on these

towels and if you ever have two of the same animal inside an enclosure when you reach these certain checkpoints on this rondelle where you're drafting the tiles from then they're going to breed and multiply and once one of these enclosures is filled with the same type of animal you get a bonus tool to fill up your board even quicker and then there's a race to complete your board by having every single square filled in so it does have that race aspect which i did like about the game to be honest um i did appreciate that other mechanism that tried to differentiate itself i.e you know the breeding mechanism but i didn't think it was enough to stand out on its own and in the kind of actuality of the game when you were physically playing it having so many meeples on your playboard became very fiddly it was certainly a um a busy game you know meekles everywhere um just very cluttered i suppose is what i'm trying to say and little things that do tend to great on me i don't really enjoy no fiddly style games um because again i find them quite annoying um but the gameplay was decent i did like the game i didn't love it that's for sure and you know if i'm completely honest a lot of other people i played this with enjoyed it way more than i do so maybe give it some you know give it some benefit the doubt in that respect the next game i'm talking about is tabanoosi builders of uh which at the time of this recording is the most recent game from the board and dice t series which included games such as taiwa tewa khan and to kenya tabanusi had the same kind of vibe it had the same visuals and aesthetic um however i thought the gameplay wasn't so intuitive

as the other design so in this one you were kind of placing tiles and buildings to try and get like arrow majorities and stuff like that um and i think the main focus of this game was to try and be more interactive than those other titles i mentioned were and i think at least you know in my personal um opinion this game did reach a bit too far to be different to the point where it was just a bit confusing the rules were a bit clunky and it just didn't all seem to kind of fit together it felt like a bit of a mishmash of mechanisms and it was a bit like putting a you know like a square peg in a round hole it was just again it just didn't click or resonate me i wanted to like it and there were certainly some redeemable features here but ultimately it was just a busy bunch of mechanisms that were just mashed together and it didn't flow very well and i don't think it quite reached the pedigree or the the standard of those other games i mentioned so definitely the first game of this series that was a big miss for me and it's a bit of a shame to do that because i'm not saying this is a you know a terrible game but compared to the great standard of those other games this one was just nowhere near that not even the same stratosphere if i'm completely honest so yeah sadly um i think this one doesn't really deserve your attention it's just um it's just too much going on and it's trying to be too different um not to its benefits the next game i'm talking about is progress evolution of technology which is a pretty streamlined and stripped back civilization style game as you are building up a nation from bare bones um trying to get more and more cars to get

your little sieve more sophisticated and getting points as you're doing so so this game has some pretty cool tech trees as you would um acquire basic cars maybe prerequisites for other cars and so on to the point where you're getting to you know basically um modern day technology such as the internet and stuff like that and it was quite cool to see that get that progress i suppose from those real basic um technologies now when i initially played this i was very impressed because i thought it flowed very nicely the car play was cool um that kind of multi-use card system where you'd spend cars to pay for other ones it'll work completely well and um as it should now i suppose why it's dropped off a bit for me since then is because the game arc was a bit lacking because essentially when you are in that third or fourth age where you are getting to the more you get more modern technologies you are essentially still playing the same game as if you were in the in the first stage so although the you know the thematics and the illustrations in the card are different and more modern you know if you're if you're if you know if you're being honest with yourself you are just playing the same game and doing the same mechanism so it would have been nice if they um started introducing more mechanisms as the game went on just to make it feel different and i don't think it did that to a high standard but despite that i did like the game you know if you want a very simple sieve game that place in about an hour this is definitely one to look at especially if you like do like car driven games but ultimately for me i think the replayability and the incentive to come back to it wasn't quite there for me the next game i'm talking about is four seasons which is a small box fellow game with an eye

split you choose mechanism which to be honest i don't really often see so this game you are going to have a hand of cards and these cards are absolutely gorgeous to look at you're going to put a pair of them in front of your opponent and then your opponent is going to pick one of those cards to put in front of them almost like a bid and they're going to put the other card in the center of the table which is going to show the amount of points that you're bidding for and all these cards are going to come in different suits so there's got this real kind of delicate balancing act where yeah i'm going to increase the um the worth of this type of card but i'm going to increase my bid in this type and it's all about how you're going to split that and how you're going to divide that out and as the game goes on and on and on your options are going to get more and more limited meaning that you have to be quite careful about what you're giving your opponent you have to give them um things that is going to be almost like the best of a bad choice if that makes sense it's all about damage mitigation and limitation i suppose um and i like pretty much everything about this game the setup was a little bit annoying but other than that the gameplay i thought was really solid so why have i got rid of this game simply because i have another game that i think does the i split you choose thing much better than for seasons dart the game i'm talking about is hana makoji so if you watch my content i've kind of really felt hanumakoji for years and years now i think it's one of the best two-player games out there and it's definitely the most refined um version of an ice split you choose mechanism i've ever seen and i can't really see anything anything else trumping it um at least you know anytime soon so when a game is kind of fighting for the same

niche no small fast two-player i split you choose games i don't really need two of them hanamikoji was better therefore four seasons had to go the next game i'm talking about is whirling witchcraft which was a game i actually really wanted to like because i thought the concept was cool and it's certainly a unique idea and something you know something different so in this game you are essentially trying to overwhelm your opponents by using these cubes to convert into other cubes chucking them into a cauldron and then passing them on however whenever you can't process cubes you're going to put them on your player board and once these um player sheets build up a certain amount of times the game is going to end and you're going to you know win by forcing an opponent not not to be able to deal with what you're giving them so i thought that was quite cool you know a different level of interaction just trying to flush things into your opponent's system that you know they can't process and the way you end up gaining these cards is through like a drafting system so you know if you're really struggling with blue cubes you want to try and get something that will get rid of those blue cubes and maybe convert them into other things so yeah i love the idea of this one however another one where in reality i thought that it was very um anti-climactic because you were only ever really dealing with the players you were left and to your right um and despite you know being a great thing you can cater to a higher player count in this game it felt like if um if the game was ended by somebody from the other side of the table it was like well that's completely out of your hands you have no control over that whatsoever and um it feels

very like underwhelming when it ends that way because you know there's nothing you could do about that so i thought that was a bit disengaging really and i felt like if you had somebody who wasn't so efficient i'm sat next to you you are going to be a significant advantage than if you're next to two really savvy players so i thought when a game is that dependent on who you're playing with it just felt a little bit weak for me and was certainly a negative point from the game that i wasn't quite willing to overcome the next game i'm talking about is micro macro crime city so this game did reach immense popularity when it came out and it continues to do really well with its follow-up expansions but this game you know we talk about games being unique this one truly is unique it did completely carve out a niche for itself um in the board game space as you are essentially playing a cooperative game of you know where's wally or where's waldo um however you are trying to solve a crime when doing so so you're going to play on this huge sheets of this kind of a cityscape i suppose and in the city you're going to have a bunch of these micro drawings where a bunch of crimes are going to be taking place you've got kidnappings you've got burglaries um you know robberies uh murders and you're trying to find these crime scenes and solve how all they've taken place you know who the culprits are by looking at the fine details of the drawings but the cool thing about these um images are that it's not like a snapshot in time it's basically a timeline of the um of the event so you can actually trace where these characters have been if you follow them up accordingly which i think is so

genius and this is a game that i thought was an absolute delight to play um played the whole thing from start to finish enjoyed pretty much every single mission some are better than others um but yeah they're all good and they're all a good experience um and the reason this one left the collection was simply because i've done it all you know i played every single mission i want no reason to keep it around anymore um create a bit of space for something new just you know leave with a very positive experience and move on to the next thing and to be completely honest i've not even had that massive desire to try any of the expansions because i don't want them to deteriorate in quality at all because i have such a good impression of this one the next game i'm talking about is deep sea adventure which is a pretty popular push your luck game by oink games and in this game you are a bunch of divers and you are trying to dive as deep as you can into the ocean to get to the best treasure because the best treasure has the most victory points assigned to it however as soon as anybody picks up a piece of treasure the shared air supply starts to run out and if you do not make it back to the submarine in time then you're gonna lose all that precious loot and leave with nothing so this is all about how far can you push not to be too greedy but be greedy enough so you get the best stuff um but all being kind of cognizant of the air supply running out and i tend to really enjoy pushy like games um you know i have my favorites i thought this was a good one i don't think it was a great one especially as i started to play it more and more times i thought you were a little bit too dependent on what the other players um do in this one because

as soon as anybody picks up a piece of treasure you're pretty much forced to um you know cut your losses and run it's not like there's that huge incentive to keep going because if you do you're pretty much guaranteed not to make it back in time because it you are so slow and plotting to make it back to the submarine um so yeah i love the concept of it it's definitely a fun game to explain to people and they're going to get it straight away because the theme and the mechanisms do work well together but ultimately i think there's better pushing up games where you can take the responsibility yourself rather than being so dependent on the other players so i thought while the um well that shared air supply works and it's definitely one of the cool things about this game i think the way it affected the actual gameplay was a bit limiting at times the next game i'm talking about is mafiosu by rudiger dawn so this game actually uses the mechanism that rudiger dawn is most known for used in games such as istanbul genoa and robert knights and where you normally have a stack of discs and then you are depositing them off in different locations to try and increase your influence and this one you're doing something very similar but you have these gems instead and you're using these gems to try and control these different characters because these characters will give you different rewards if you have the most gems of your color on them at the end of the round you're going to use those things or those use those rewards to claim these buildings which will give you little powers and end game points and of course everybody's trying to trump you by donating more gems than you do um i like the flow of this one i thought it had some cool concepts you know i love the idea of taking that traditional

dawn mechanism mixed with some area control um certainly felt like there was a lot of potential here um however i thought after a few plays i thought it was a bit disappointing the fact that this game was not modular in terms of the setup this was like could have easily been variable by having you know tiles that you could shift around each game but they were all just drawn directly onto the board so therefore every game was going to feel somewhat the same which i thought was a missed opportunity to be honest now i am aware that this game is a re-implementation of a another game called louis xiv which is one i actually still want to try because i think i might like that version more than this one simply because i believe it is variable i also did feel that there's a couple of mechanisms that didn't really need to be there in this game in the form of collecting these additional tokens where you're trying to build up these sets felt a little bit too lucky and a bit too swingy for me because most of the time you were just picking them up blindly but still almost there for me definitely a near miss some cool artwork um some good mechanisms but ultimately the final package wasn't quite strong enough for those negative reasons and the final game i'm talking about this episode is corrosion so corrosion is definitely one of those games i've had a strange relationship with um since knowing about it because i was very i'm keen to play this one because i love the idea of it um you know i love engine building games and this game is all about engine building and this idea that this engine you're building is not going to be permanent fascinated me because the more

you run things in this game you end up losing things from your machine meaning that you have to keep replenishing them to keep things ticking along most efficiently that for me just ticks a lot of boxes and it's pretty much exactly what i'm looking for and i have to say the game play in this game is fantastic there's so many cool things you can do little engines you can build not be able to put too strong of an engine because you need to replace things um yeah lots to like here um however there was one glaring issue with the game and that was the amount of time it took because this game wasn't exactly a heavy complex game you know you're talking medium weight here and this game took about two hours to play um and for me that was a bit too long from the experience you got from it you know you play probably 30 of the game past the point you were almost ready to pack up and for me that is like a big red flag it's something i try to stay away from as much as possible but initially i was kind of willing to look past that and forgive it because i did enjoy the gameplay that much um but the more i played it um that became harder and harder for me to ignore now the designer did come out um publicly and provide a variant on how to speed the game along and make it feel faster without altering the balance of the game and i did try that variant and even with that it still felt too long too slow and too plodding so it just it just didn't quite strike the balance of having the right end game trigger for the game in my opinion and it could have just used a little bit more development because i thought this game has a lot of potential and if there's ever a game out

that could do with a second edition then um corrosion would be right up there on that list for me um personally so there we have it those are another 10 games that have left my collection i hopefully you've enjoyed this video and found it useful if you have please be sure to hit like comment and subscribe my channel for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved