Solo Board Gaming: Designing Games for One Player or Solo Play Modes
Transcript
hi I'm Adam Porter and this is my board gaming vlog and today I'm talking about solitaire gaming so board games that you can play on your own and this seems to have been a recent something that has really blossomed over recent years I think when I first got into the Hobby there weren't that many solitaire games around and many of the games on my shelf older games don't have a solitaire mode in there what I'm noticing now is that games coming out very frequently do have a solitaire mode even where it wouldn't naturally be obvious that such a thing would fit for example recently I was looking at the game Goris maximus which is a multiplayer trick-taking game you know a normaly trick-taking games don't even play with two players let alone playing with one and yet gooris maximus has a very simple little single-player experience which you know you're not going to buy the game specifically to play Korus maximus one player but it's nice that it has that feature I incorporated a solo mode into my game Quizzle that came up with a happy puzzle company earlier this year now puzzle is a puzzle but it's a puzzle that you play against an opponent you race against an opponent and so when you take away that opponent of course you have to find some other way to incorporate tension into the game the great thing with crustle is that every puzzle is sort of randomly generated by laying out cards so you get a very variable sort of system but you're also racing against time and so that adds the tension where the other player wouldn't be the happy puzzle company has quite a lot of different puzzles which can be played solitaire so for example the
genius square and chroma cube and 30 cubed and face to face these are all good solo puzzles and actually I have a solitaire puzzle coming up with them later in the year or next year which is specifically designed for a single player and can't be played multiplayer I've also been dabbling with design of a solo mode in a much bigger strategy game so a sort of one to two hour strategy game can be played up to six players how do I get something like that same sort of experience with a solo player so really this video is looking at all those sort of factors that you consider when you're making a solitaire game whether that is something relatively simple whether it's something that's designed specifically for solitaire whether it's adding a solitaire mode into an otherwise multiplayer game or maybe something of a high degree of complexity and trying to sort of mimic and opponent through some sort of artificial intelligence system in the game so let's start off simple with solitaire puzzles there's a fantastic range of puzzles by a company called smart games these have predetermined puzzles usually in a small booklet and you work your way through them from easy difficulty to dip - to the most difficult - to sort of you know genius level and it can be extremely challenging smart games is a range of single-player puzzles with beautiful components and ingenious challenges which range from very simple for young children to extremely challenging even for the best adult puzzlers and the range is vast and most sets contain
between 60 and 120 puzzles in jump in the player has to get all of the rabbits into holes the rabbits can only move by jumping over obstacles the toadstools can't be moved in later puzzles foxes are introduced which can be slid around on the grid the board is cleverly designed so that the movement of the foxes is restricted and even in such a childish looking game the puzzles are very very hard when you reach the expert or master or the wizard level the game packages up neatly with a transparent plastic lid so moving away from totally solitaire puzzles to something that is a multiplayer game but can be played with a solo mode sometimes particularly with the very simple games that have a solitaire mode they can feel really quite puzzly okay despite not being a puzzle something about losing the social interaction of having other players around the table emphasizes or highlights the more abstract nature of these sort of games that we play suddenly you realize that actually what you're doing is moving cubes around on a board or little wooden pieces and and and raising your markers on various tracks or pulling various levers to make the game work and those things don't immediately leap out at you when you're having lots of social interaction and fun with other people but when you're very focused that really comes to the fore in Las Vegas each player competes to have the most dice of their color on a casino and win the money cards that are placed above on a player's turn they roll all eight dice in their own color they sort
these by number and add all dice showing one number to the corresponding casino the next player then takes their turn rolling all of their dice so the sequence continues with players re rolling each turn and occupying the casinos at the end of each round each casino is checked and wherever two or more players have an equal number of dice those results are ignored meaning that a player has fewer dice at that location can take the prize after four complete rounds the player with the most money wins the expansion Las Vegas Boulevard offers up a solo mode 64 dicey used so there's eight sets of eight dice each and the player chooses a color to be their own here I'm playing as white one color is rolled and positioned on the board and the remaining dice are split into two groups and then the game begins the solo player rolls one die of each color remaining in the pool using all dice from the first group as in the standard game they then place all dice of one number onto the casinos but unlike the regular game these dice will be of different colors this is repeated over and over until the entirety of the first group has been placed the player then moves on to the second group and repeats the sequence when all dice have been placed the casinos are scored as normal with tied colors being discounted just as you'd expect the solo player compares the money that they have gathered to the total money gathered by
all the other colors combined and if the solo player has more than they win the game now Las Vegas Boulevard I haven't played the solitaire mode before last week when I started thinking about this video and actually it was a real highlight of all the games that I've sort of explored over the last week and there's been a lot of them there's gonna be a lot of examples in this video Las Vegas Boulevard was one of the real highlights I thought that was a great solitaire mode it felt very much like the main game it was simple it was challenging there was a good degree of randomness and tension in there I really didn't know whether I was gonna win or lose so very satisfying game Las Vegas if you can get hold of the expansion Las Vegas move out is one of the best expansions I have for any of my games it doesn't just add a solo mode it adds so much to that game so many different modules all of which are really really fun another way of incorporating randomizer of course is to have a deck of cards and this is the way tiny towns which is another quite puzzle game does it in tiny towns every player is building their own town by placing wooden tokens and attempting to fill their grid each turn one player will call out a color and every player then takes one resource of that color and places it onto their own grid when a player has made a pattern as indicated on one of the building cards they declare it and place the building on one of the spaces occupied by one of those resources in that pattern the other cubes are then removed the game ends when no player can play because all grids are filled or blocked the players score according to the criteria on the
building cards which are different in every single game for example the bakery is worth three points if adjacent to a red or black building the inn scores three points if not in a row or column with another Inn etc the solo mode works exactly the same way except the resources not called out by a player instead three cards are drawn from a resource deck and the player chooses one of those to place at the end of the game you score as normal and then you compare to the rulebook to see how you've done so tiny towns is never a particularly interactive game even in its multiplayer version yes the other players they pick a color and everybody has to place that color so it's a little bit like a bingo type system but they can't directly influence what you're putting on your board all they can do really is is limit your choices and of course that limitation can be equally well achieved just by turning over cards from a deck and so tiny towns works quite well in a solitaire sort of system albeit it's a fairly sort of repetitive sort of puzzle when you play it more and more and when you lose that human interaction another factor that you need to think about in solitaire design is what are your win conditions because obviously in most games our win condition is we need to beat our opponent but we haven't got any opponent so what could I win condition B and in a lot of games it's as simple as beat your previous highest score this is particularly true in games which generally quite sort of multiplayer solitaire so I mean games where other players don't interact with you too much you see it in a lot of role and write
games so games where I'm writing on my own individual sheet and no one else can reach over and write on it they're writing on their own sheet doing their own thing so a really good example would be the game cartographers and this one I thought was particularly notable because it was a solo mode where there's no change to the components no added components everything needed for the solitaire mode is very carefully and subtly incorporated into the cards that you use in multiplayer which I thought was a really nice Church in cartographers players are creating maps under instruction of the Queen the player who discovers the most desirable lands and hence gains the most victory points wins each player has a blank sheet and a pencil and four cards are laid on the table representing special scoring opportunities so in this example players are trying to earn eight reputation points for each cluster of six or more village spaces for this one they're going to earn six points for each complete row or column they filled out on their grid here they've got one point for each forest adjacent to the edge of the grid and here they'll score points for having water or farms adjacent to mountains each turn one card has revealed indicating a terrain type and a shape that a player must draw on their map often there's a choice to be made ruins cards indicate that the shape must be drawn over a ruins icon on your sheet monster cards allow you to draw a shape in the most Awkward spot on your opponent sheet and if you surround a mountain you gain gold which gives you points at the end of each round around
ends when a set total is reached by adding up the numbers at the top of the revealed cards and at the end of the round representing a season the players score points according to two of the scoring cards laid out at the start of the game in spring the cards a and B score in summer cars B and C score in autumn it's C and D and in winter D and a score and players additionally lose points at the end of each round for any monsters that they have on their board which have not been totally surrounded after four seasons the players total their victory points in the highest scorer wins in the solo mode the only change to gameplay is when ambushes occur each ambush card has an icon in the top corner indicating where to start considering placing your monsters so you search from that spot around your grid looking for an appropriate space in a clockwise or anti-clockwise direction as indicated on the arrow at the bottom of the card when you score your map you subtract the numbers shown on the scoring cards to give your total and then you compare it to the rulebook to see how you've done of course I could have used many different roll and write games for this example I could have used welcome to your perfect home I could have used gang shown clever all of these have a system where you try and beat your previous highest score and often you achieve some sort of rank you know some sort of criteria and then if you can push your score up higher you get a better rank and so next time you try and get better and that's the way the game works but there's not much narrative involved
and actually one thing that I found is really fun in a solitaire game is if there is a little bit of an element of story so the game d-day dice was a particular highlight and actually d-day dice I played a number of years ago several times as a solitaire game which it's uncommon for me but recently I've got it out again and I still found this one really tense indeed a dice you're trying to beat the scenario you're not trying to beat your highest score so there's a whole range of scenarios in there I suppose its equivalent to something like those smart games where you've got that booklet of increasing difficulty so d-day dice has predetermined scenarios but there is randomness in tension air because we're rolling dice indeed a dice one to four players each represent a unit of soldiers advancing up a beach in World War two it's a cooperative game players select a map and place their dice to act as markers indicating their position on the beach the aim is to progress up the beach and into the bunker another players turn they roll six dice they lock two and then they get two more rolls for the remaining dice they can amass soldiers and stars which are spent to purchase specialists which have ongoing abilities or tools which are spent to purchase items which have one-off abilities and they collect courage which is spent to advance up the board getting a matching set of red white and blue dice gives additional rewards and skulls negate other results a full set of all six results gives a random award which is
drawn from the deck and at the end of each turn the unit loses soldiers equal to the defense value of the sector sometimes this is made worse by machine gun fire which adds a six sided dice roll to the defense value of that sector a different sectors have different effects they might award you specialists when you arrive or they might prevent you using items or moving through minefields might cause you to lose soldiers etc later scenarios introduce more advanced specialists more advanced items and even vehicles the solo mode is exactly the same as multiplayer except that the solo player gains rewards which would normally be allocated to their team mates the game also has a victory point system so that a solo player can replay the same beach over and over again and try to beat their previous score another way that you could add tension to your game and also have a different endgame condition is to race against the clock and this is particularly apparent in the solitaire mode for magic maze magic maze is an incredibly interactive game one of the most interactive games that I've got in its multiplayer mode so seeing that in solitaire mode is a bit of an odd experience let's take a look the players are trying to get a team of Heroes out of a shopping mall although there are four heroes they're not owned by any specific player any player can move any hero instead each player has a limitation on how they can move the
heroes so one player can only move heroes north one player can only move them south one player moves west and one moves east one player can open doors and reveal new tiles another player can use escalators a timer is flipped over and players start moving heroes freely as often as they wish bearing in mind there limitations of movement they're attempting to get the heroes onto a matching colored symbol and then get out of a matching colored exit and this isn't easy the difficulty is compounded by the fact that the players are not allowed to speak to each other that's right the game is played in silence players may however indicate to another player that they need their help by placing a large red wooden pawn in front of them they cannot say what they need them to do the red pawn just means do something there are areas of the board where the team can flip the timer over and discuss strategy but generally the game lasts for a frantic 15 minutes after which players will have all won together or all lost together so what the designer has done in magic maze is take out all of the social interaction clearly remove all of those mechanisms and instead incorporate a dexterity element where you've got to use one hand turn over though that deck go through that deck to find the card that you need use it and then repeat so so there's a dexterity element there's a racing element there's a memory element of the order of the cards and of course that is a perfectly
valid experience but it's a very different experience to play a multiplayer and it doesn't really replicate what people love about the multiplayer experience of magic maze so it's a bit of an oddity feels like you're playing a very different game in solo mode and probably not quite as fun a game that said you're probably not going to buy magic from a specifically to play it solitaire you're gonna be buying it for a multiplayer mode so it's quite nice that you've got this added little minigame in there that you can sort of dabble with if you want to explore it a lot of games do try and directly replace that human opponent by having an automated opponent some sort of artificial intelligence this is often called a bot sometimes it's called more Toma after viticulture there stone mire games introduced this term or Toma and there or Toma factory which is a group of designers or a single designer I'm not sure who produces a solo mode for each of stone mire games which is always now called an auto Mariette on word a good example of this sort of automated opponent is in architects of the West Kingdom which is quite a a meaty sort of strategy game to play in architects of the West Kingdom each player is an architect trying to impress the King by building various landmarks on the players turn they place a worker onto the main board to select an action so they might take wood or stone or silver they might convert resources to marble or donate resources to gain
virtue on the virtue track they might steal money from the tax stand and lose virtue as a result they might hire apprentices with special abilities or collect building cards which give immediate rewards or endgame scoring they might build buildings or contribute goods to help construct the cathedral but of which allow them a place in the guild hall players actions are stronger when they have more workers in any given slot so their first worker might give them one resource their second worker gives them two and so on and of course this means that large groups tend to congregate on action spaces players can use an action to arrest a large group of workers placing them onto their own player board and later they get paid in silver to send any captured workers to the prison and other players can use an action in order to take their workers back at the end of the game players earn points for buildings for their position on the cathedral and the virtue track and for resources and money and they lose points for unpaid debts and then the highest scorer wins in solo mode you play against an automated opponent called Constantine or you can play against Helena for higher difficulty you play as normal placing workers and gathering resources and building
landmarks but when the opponent plays they turn over a scheme card and this tells them where to place a worker and what reward they receive some cards had new more powerful scheme cards to the deck so the opponent gets stronger actions as the game progresses the opponent never gains silver or any resources except for marble which is only used for scoring and at the end of the game you compare your scores to the solo player and see who is the winner now the problem with these BOTS and October's is that they can be quite a lot of bookkeeping you've not only got to think about what you're doing you've also got to think about what your automated opponent is doing and so that can add quite a lot of bookkeeping quite a lot of things to be thinking about at any given time so a lot of games use a simplified but they don't really focus on the bots doesn't focus on doing all the things that you're doing it doesn't have the same strategies that you have what it mainly does is it acts to deprive you of options to take away pieces when you might need them the most so an example is the game ever dell which uses a simple dice roll just to take away cards that you might have wanted in ever dell each player creates a village by laying out cards on the table in front of them some represent buildings some represent characters and on a player's turn they can either place a worker to gather resources or complete an objective or play a card when playing a card this can be taken from the central display or played directly from a player's hand buildings always cost a
certain number of resources to play and characters cost berries but they can be played for free if the player has a suitable building to house them in all cards have special abilities one of powers permanent effects in game scoring or unique worker placement spots at the end of each season players gain additional workers and activate many of their cards so the game has a good sense of progression speeding up from round to round and after three complete seasons the players score victory points for the cards in their player area and the highest scorer wins in solo mode you play against an automated opponent called rug wart essentially in a game is played as normal but rug wart progressively blocks spaces on the board and collects cards for endgame scoring each time you play a card you then roll the die which tells you which of the meadow cards to give to rud wart rug wart never pays me resource costs and he can't use any of the card abilities when he prepare for the next season mugwort takes basic event tokens if he has enough cards of the relevant color and blocks certain parts of the meadow so fewer cards are available to you each round and at the end of the game rug Watts worker is moved to the three-point journey space and then rug wall also gains points for cards in his collection basic events that he's achieved and also for us any special events that you did not achieve and the highest scorer wins and another example is the gamed wings fan which doesn't use a dice wingspan uses a deck of cards and so it has some some added
sort of sophistication to that bot but still what those cards are acting to do really is to remove pieces that you might have wanted in wingspan each player starts with some birds and some food and in this video I'm using the lovely wooden food tokens I bought separately from meeple sauce players are attempting to fill their own personal boards with Birds and on a player's turn they may place a bird by feeding it with the required food type and in later spaces by also giving up one or two eggs and the birds must be placed into their favored habitats or the player may take food by selecting one of the visible dice results and taking a corresponding token or a player may lay eggs up the allowance indicated on each bird card or they could draw new cards into their hand so they have four actions available and for each action you get an increased benefit if you have several Birds already in that corresponding habitat often when you take an action the special abilities of the birds on your board will activate giving you resources or other game-changing effects after each player has used all their actions then the round ends and bonuses are scored for certain objectives for example having the most Birds or having the most eggs in a certain type of nest and after four rounds the game ends and players reveal whether they've completed any of their secret objective cards these points are added to the point shown on the birds
and they also gain one point per egg and then the highest scorer wins in solo mode you use a player board but the automo opponent does not your turns function as normal and on the auto Murs turn you turn over an l toma card and it takes the action indicated for the current round is actions get better and better as the rounds progress which is similar to a real player in an engine building game like wingspan the auto ma actions remove cards from the supply or remove food from the birdhouse or place markers on the end of the round goal board etc now at the end of a round the auto murres given a base value as indicated on the card and it adds the number of markers it has placed and if that beats your score then the auto Murr takes first place on that goal board at the end of the game of your toma scores for end of round goals for eggs for face down cards and for face up cards at they're marked value a new score is normal now we've touched on a couple of times here where games have taken a highly interactive mechanism and they've had to find a way to replace it so we talked about that with magic maze but there are a couple of really good examples in the game I love cats where there are specifically you know direct interaction between players but you can't get that in solitaire mode so instead the design of Frank West has has tried to incorporate games the mechanisms that give you a similar field in I love cats each player fills a ship with cats and
treasures of various shapes and sizes they're attempting to cover rats fill rooms and collect cats of similar colors and at the start of a player's turn they gain 20 fish they then draft a handful of seven cards taking one card each time and passing them on until the wall players have seven cards the players then choose which of their seven cards they want to keep and they pay for these with fish any blue cards are played immediately these are end game scoring objectives players then play green cards to establish turn order and gain baskets and players then take turns to take cats from the display paying fish the cats are placed onto the ship and each cat requires one available basket when its place some cards award treasures and special or shacks tiles which are essentially wild and counters any color as marked with a token after five complete rounds the ships are scored there are various scoring criteria matching cats filling rooms rare treasures etc along with the objective cards you played earlier in the solo mode a player plays against a randomizer deck of cards and each round the card is drawn which changes the turn order and determines how many tiles will be discarded from the display the drafting is altered so that the solo player now draws five cards keeps three repeats and then takes one final card from the deck to make up their hand of seven cards the opponent scores points for the cats that
are placed on the solo players board the cards are revealed gradually throughout the game indicating which cats are the most valuable to the opponent and there are three objectives placed at the start of the game which score just for the opponent the solo player competes against the opponent for the highest score after five rounds so the mechanisms I was talking about there were specifically card drafting so a card drafting system is where you take a card pass your hand of cards on take a card pass your hand of cards onto the card cycle around the table in a circle with you taking a card each time there's no solitaire mode in sushi go you know it's not an easy thing to replicate and in all of cats what Frank has done is a very simple system where you take five cards you keep three of them throw two away take another five keep three throw two away and then take one random one off the deck and that is a perfectly workable system to replace all of that card drafting that happens in the game and the game doesn't lose that much by doing so it's simple and quick and easy I remember a very convoluted sort of replacement for the drafting system in the solo mode of at the gates of law yang which I played many years ago and I can't remember the details but this is a nice simple system in I love cats another thing I love cats does is really tries to give you that sense of trying to deny your opponent so in a lot of games of course I'm focusing on what I'm doing but I'm also watching my opponents board and trying to make sure they don't get certain things because I
know it's going to benefit them so in I love cats your automated opponent has some objective cards and the things that I do on my player board might score points for my automated opponent so I've got to keep an eye not only on what I want to do but also avoiding the things that my opponent wants me to do and I must say I found this quite a lot to deal with quite a lot to think about and I found the thing that that was quite frustrating for me but I think that's because I don't really do this much in multiplayer games I'm tending to focus on what I'm doing and not worrying too much about what my opponent is doing and that's probably why I lose a lot of highly interactive type games and why maybe I favor the more sort of multiplayer solitaire games I'm not a mean player I don't want to I don't want to ruin someone else's experience I feel guilty if I do things to the opponent worried about it so you know this sense of denial it's certainly something that a lot of people enjoy and I think I love cats does manage to replicate that quite well in its solitaire mode one thing that I think is useful we talked about narrative but the sense of progression between games in solitaire mode so what I do in one game impacts on what I do in the next game a few years ago I played the game Pathfinder adventure card game I don't have a copy anymore so I can't show you but that game attempted to replicate playing a role-playing game but doing it by yourself I'm not sure it quite succeeded in that but you did get
the sense of characters that developed and got better and better you'd actually write on the cards and you'd meet various characters throughout the game and and get to know them a little bit it was a very sort of sophisticated simple system and I found it really enjoyable a bit like playing a sort of choose your own adventure book recently I tried to play the game Star Wars Imperial assault and and sort of explore the the developing sort of campaign in that over the years I played Imperial assault quite a lot but only really is a two-player skirmish game so me facing off against another opponent and usually my my friend Tom who I play against knows the game really well so if I get stuck on a rule you can explain it to me and playing this solitaire just highlights how many rules there are I was going from one rule book to another rule book there are multiple rule books in the game and then of course there's a whole other set of rules for playing solitaire it's all controlled by an app and so I downloaded this app and it's got a tutorial but the tutorial goes on forever and then once you get into the main game you can't easily get back into that tutorial I found the whole thing pretty baffling really and I mean it's great that that option exists and I know a lot of people love it and particularly people who are very experienced with the base game and really understand the rules in and out probably will find that app is really really intuitive but it must admit it wasn't for me I like the simple progression that you see in the game of Agricola in solitaire mode in Agricola each player represents a family of farmers in the 17th century you start
the game with two workers and on your turn you send one worker out to fulfill a task they might collect wood or they might go and get some clay or go fishing or plow a field which later can be used to grow grain or vegetables or they might build fences or stables so that when you collect farm animals you have somewhere to put them and when all workers have been placed they're returned and the action spaces restock so they can accumulate a lot of tokens over several turns if they're not taken make him for a better yields next time someone visits that spot at the end of the game you're gonna score points for having a good mixture of stuff and you can also pay resources to upgrade your house from woods to clay to stone or to increase the number of rooms and bigger houses mean more space for workers and more workers means more actions per round plus more points and each action space can only be occupied by one player so you have to take care not to get blocked out of a desired location but the number of available locations increases throughout the game and at the end of every two or three rounds there's a harvest you take one grain and one vegetable of each of your fields you feed your family to food each and you breed your animals and if you don't have enough food then you take a big in card which is
worth a lot of negative points players also have a hand of cards which complete played throughout the game these are called minor improvements and occupations and each one costs resources but gives a massive boost and gives you powers to help you build the best farm after 14 rounds the best farm wins in solo mode the rules are identical except that you start the game with no food and each worker eats three food instead of two during the harvest wood is also less abundant in solo mode only gathering two tokens each time it's restocked the goal for your first game is 50 points and once you've achieved that you get to keep one of the occupation cards that you used and retain it for the next game in your next game the points total goes up and you have to get a higher score at but you still get to keep cards each game that you play if you ever fail to reach the scoring objective as it keeps increasing then your unbroken run is ruined and you have to start again you complete the solo series by beating the scoring objective of your eighth game there you go some nice simple progression I enjoyed that special power car they had in that last round I'm going to keep that card and use it in my next game but the points that I need to achieve in my next game have gone up so although I've got a bonus from the previous game I now have to achieve more and then in our next game I can keep 2 cards but my points bonus has gone up again next game three cards but again the points bonus goes up and I have to have an unbroken run I can't afford to lose any of those
games that's a really nice system it feels like you know you can play this game over over days you know and and and and develop your strategies but there's no added complexity there another thing that solitaire game designers seem to struggle with is the concept of moving pieces moving pieces around a board you know actual movement of characters imperial assault was a particularly complex example of that so the app would tell me this piece is going to move to this position and it would have a whole load of caveats about which type of opponent it would move to which sort of terrain it was again baffling to me and there was this overarching rule of if you're stuck or if if there's two equally sort of valid places for it to move to it will always move to the place which is least beneficial to you as the human player which again loads a whole load of decisions on to me like how am I suppose I'm not good at this game how am I supposed to determine what is objectively the most beneficial position for my opponent to be in so I didn't get on with it the movement system and Imperial assault solitaire I want to have a look at the game side by stone Maya games I've mentioned before that stole my games is really innovating with their Auto Toma system and developing and incorporating it into every game scythe is a particularly complex or Toma let's have a look at how the game works in scythe each player is trying to gain coins and on a player's turn they take one of four actions the first action is
move this allows you to transport workers and resources across the map or you can produce this adds new resources or workers onto spaces that you already occupy or you may bolster this gives you more power for future combats and the fourth option is to trade and this gives you goods or popularity but you have to spend coins to get them you may not take the same action two turns in a row and each action that you take is associated with a second reaction so these are upgrade which allows you to move a cube to uncover an additional benefit on your board and cover up a different cost or you might deploy this allows you to purchase a mech which is great for transporting workers and resources and also useful in combat or you might choose to build and this allows you to purchase buildings which have different special abilities or maybe you will enlist this allows you to select a one-off bonus but also gives you an additional reward every time one of your neighbouring players takes a certain action when is tape mix they also uncover a special ability which now applies to them for the rest of the game the layout and special abilities are different for each player and they're very variable from game to game if a player wishes to move greater distances they can use tunnels either those illustrated on the board or using mines that they have built if a player's character lands on an encounter token
then they read the card text and choose a reward and if a player's character or mech lands on the space with an opponent's workers they retreat to their home base leaving their resources behind and you lose popularity as the attacker if a player's character or mech moves into the same space as an opponent's character or mech then combat ensues each player takes a combat dial and secretly selects how much power they wish to use they may add a combat card if they wish to bolster this power both dials and cards are revealed at the same time and the highest wins the combat the losing units all retreat leaving resources behind and the winner loses popularity throughout the game players gain stars for achieving certain goals for example moving six cubes to upgrade their boards or moving all four mechs onto the board or building all four of their buildings or having eight workers on the board or completing their personal objective cards or winning a combat or being extremely popular etc when one player has achieved six stars then the game ends and coins are awarded for various bonuses including those stars themself and the player with the most coins wins in solo mode the automa does not use a player matte or any upgrades or objectives it doesn't produce resources or pay costs or change its popularity at all you play as normal selecting an action placing resources moving pieces or upgrading your player board but on an automat earn you turn
over in your toma card the green section at the top indicates how the auto Murr is going to move this is pretty complex but it becomes easier with practice depending on the unit type they'll either move towards the spot with the most friendly units around in them or they'll move closer and closer to the factory or to the other player the or Toma then gains other bonuses as written on the card for example gaining coins or workers or mechs or power on the track and finally the solo player might gain a bonus if they've already uncovered the indicated symbol on their own player board your Toma card will indicate whether to move a cube on the auto m'as tracker cart and when the cube reaches a certain point your Toma will be able to ignore water from here on when it's moving when it reaches the first star on the tracker card the auto mccain's a star token and from here on the red part of the automic ours is used instead of the green section for all future turns if your Toma moves on to an encounter symbol it simply discards it but if you're not home a combat unit enters into combat then the solo player chooses their power level and combat cards first they then draw an auto mcard and this tells them what power and how many combat cards the auto me uses in the combat if the player ever beats your Toma units forcing them to retreat then the player looks at a Natoma card to see how many resources are generated and left on the space the
player gains star tokens as usual but the auto mccain's stars when it reaches certain points on the tracker card or when it reaches 16 power or when it wins combats after one player has achieved six stars the players add up their scores and the highest scorer wins so I found psy difficult reading through the rules I found it difficult to work out how it's supposed to be moving the opponent's pieces but to be honest after a few rounds I got it and it made sense it was it was actually relatively clear once you get the pieces moving on the board you know reading it in the rule books it sounds awful but once you're positioning the pieces and moving them around it is relatively clear how exactly these things are gonna go and there's no edge cases you don't get into the edge cases like you do with Imperial assault and have to rely on this sort of overarching well the player can decide if you're stuck I wonder whether stone Meier kind of recognized how difficult people found that movement mechanism in solitaire mode when they moved on to their my little scythe my little side is a much simplified streamlined version of site intended for families but they've not only streamlined the main game they've also incorporated noir Thoma into my little site and the auto mow is streamlined too specifically the movement system is much much easier to learn in my little site than it is inside in my little Sai each player has two seekers who move around a map gathering apples and gems in order to deliver them to the castle and complete objectives on the players turn they may move or seek or make on each subsequent
turn they must use a different action so they can never take the same action two turns in a row if a player chooses to move then they move both of their Seekers and gather tokens as they go they can also jump across the board using portals if they're near one of those and if they land on a quest token they reveal a quest card and choose one of the available rewards if they land on another player's piece they have a pie fight where each player selects a number of pies to throw using a dial they might add a magic card if they have one and they reveal simultaneously the player with the most pies wins the pie rack and friendship tracks of both adjusted accordingly because throwing pies is not a very friendly thing to do if a player seeks then they roll dice which determine where the new resources are placed around the board if a player chooses to make then they can convert apples into pies or gems into magic cards or a combination of both to upgrade one of the actions on their board for a permanent upgraded action when a player has completed an objective then they gain a trophy and examples of objectives are having a friendship or having two upgrades or three magic cards or two quest cards or delivering four gems or apples to the castle or winning a pie fight etc each player has a personality card which helps them
achieve one of these goals and the first player to gain for trophies wins in solo mode on an auto Mountie they turn over a cart and this will show where to position new resources or it might show where to move in addition it might give the auto mounting more pies and movement for the auto Mountie is based on the indicated paths both seekers will always move in the direction which gives them the most resources and if several paths are equally valuable then one seeker will choose their path by looking at the available options in a clockwise direction so A to F and the other seeker will look for the most valuable option in an anti-clockwise direction so f2 a if an auto Mountie is ever involved in a pie fight then you select your own number of pies and then turn over the top card of the auto Mountie deck to determine how many pies they throw at the start of the game you'll have chosen a difficulty level and this determines how many tokens the auto Mountie needs in order to win a trophy so for example on normal mode if the auto Mountie has four or more tokens at the start of its turn it gains a trophy instantly and loses the tokens for auto Mountie purposes quest tokens are treated just like apples and gems they're never resolved and the first player - for trophies wins as normal now having played all of these games over the last couple of weeks and thinking about my own strategy game and what sort of system aren't gonna put into place there
what's become apparent to me is that there is no kind of shared vocabulary among solitaire game designers everyone's kind of winging it making it up as they go along and trying out different things which means there's a huge space there for creativity and innovation I think in board games in general these games around me you know if you look at one game of a particular genre and then you look at another game of the same genre you'll find a lot of similarities designers have a shared vocabulary of mechanisms so if I want to do something specific let's say I want to incorporate a catch-up mechanism there's probably a mechanism that I can find in multiple games I can lift from those games and incorporate into mine because it is a recognized solution to that problem this is something which I don't think we've yet seen in solitaire game people there's not enough of them out there it's a new enough sort of thing that people are exploring and so there's there's a lot of room there and for that sort of innovation for that creativity for that exploration and to find new solutions to the problems I've got lots of games on my shelves that have solo modes and I have no concept of how those solo modes might work I haven't yet looked at the solo mode in the game role player which is a dice drafting game so how does dice drafting work if it's solo I don't know Rollo roll player has one answer I haven't yet found out what that is I don't know where else I could go does Sagrada have a sono mode I'm not sure maybe I can look there as well
so you're kind of training a nun walking an untrodden path when you're designing solitaire modes for for your board game so I think that's quite an exciting sort of thing and I'm enjoying doing it with my big strategy game anyway I hope you enjoyed the video if you did please watch some of my others I've got lots of videos about different mechanisms used in games top ten I don't know solutions to their runaway leader problem ten degrees of player interaction you know looking at the ways that games work on my channel Adams board game wails on Twitter you can follow me at board game wails and on board game geek I'm Adam 78 thank you very much for watching all the best