Expansions & derivative works | Board Game Contracts Explained: Part 4 *Board Game Design*
Transcript
you've been offered a contract to publish your board game but what if you want to make a spin-off or a new addition what if the publisher decides to do it without you what if they make a digital game or an app how do you make sure that you're included and properly remunerated i'm adam porter i'm a board game designer from wales and in this series of short videos i'm taking a look at licensing contracts between designers and publishers if you're finding these game design videos helpful please share them with other designers and don't forget to subscribe i'll preface this video by clarifying that i'm not a lawyer i have no expertise in contract law but i have signed a dozen or so board game contracts and i've rejected a few more so i've got a bit of a feel for what they tend to contain and things to look out for that said if you have any queries or concerns about a contract which has been proposed please do get appropriate legal advice before signing don't blindly follow my advice i've selected a few short passages from contracts which i've seen and i'm going to share them with you in this video i'm specifically focusing on expansions adaptations digital additions and improvements to your game the following exclusive rights of exploitation shall be included the commercial exploitation of large-scale games the publishing rights for books newspapers magazines and periodicals theater rights music rights film rights tv rights video rights cd cdi cd-rom rights audio and radio playwrights software rights versions for the internet merchandising rights etc
most contracts will have clauses along these lines big broad lists of different forms of media and physical forms often which feel like they couldn't possibly ever have any relevance to your particular product it's a generic clause and it's all-encompassing essentially the publisher retains the right to produce your game in whatever form they want i doubt the publishers even really know the specifics of what's written in this clause they just want the freedom to pursue whatever marketing strategy is likely to work for them and frankly they're putting in all the financial investment so why shouldn't they if you would like to know more about the balance of creative control between a designer and a publisher click on the link above the publisher will pay royalties on electronic versions of the work at five percent of net income received i talked about this in my previous video about royalties but consideration of digital editions is often not included in contracts and i think it's increasingly important often publishers will release a free version of your game on one of the online gaming platforms and how are you going to be recompensed for this maybe isn't necessary because it's advertising your game and driving sales of physical copies but what if your game's between print runs at that point the game is available for free and you're receiving nothing i think this should be discussed at the very least in every contract negotiation and in many cases i think a specific clause should be included the clause i showed you five percent of income from digital editions seems very low to me the costs
to the publisher are in many cases likely to be much much lower than a physical edition so i would hope to see a higher percentage that said a polished app-based implementation could be expensive to produce so as always negotiation should be constructive and respectful from both sides in order for the publisher to maintain a perfect coherence in the marketing of the game the author shall first submit to the publisher any add-on expansion or new version which he or she intends to develop many contracts discuss expansions and new iterations of games if you had created azul presumably you would have wanted the opportunity to develop summer pavilion queen's garden and stained glass of sintra this could be stated in the contract should the publisher refuse to publish the proposed derivative work this refusal does not entitle the author to propose the work to any third party as all derivative works based upon the game are hearing acquired by the publisher this is an important clause and it's pretty limiting for the designer in 2020 it was reported that bruno catala and sergio lagey were working on a re-implementation of their influential 2005 cooperative game shadows over camelot the new version shadows over brooklyn would be set in a steampunk world with several new mechanisms and in many ways improve upon the original days of wonder who published the original declined to offer to publish the new version and katala went public with his
disappointment katala noted that it left him and his co-designer with three options first option forego the publishing of shadows over brooklyn until shadows over camelot dies a natural death and is permanently retired from the marketplace second option decline to approve the next print run of the original by days of wonder effectively terminating their contract or third option license shadows over brooklyn to a new publisher regardless since this is a new game with new mechanisms and a new theme whatever the outcome it will depend on careful negotiation respectful communication and serious consideration of what constitutes a derivative work under the contract developments additions adaptations changes or other modifications that the publisher intends to make to the game will be suggested to the author in advance for the author to implement if applicable in collaboration with individuals indicated by the publisher if no such agreement is arrived at the modifications suggested will be made by the publisher or by any third party of the publisher's choice it's fairly common that a different designer will work on expansion material for an existing game tom lehmann is given co-credit with matt licock the original designer of pandemic on most of its expansions and reiterations reiner knizier is credited as designer on the two-player re-implementation of carcassonne called carcassonne the castle the original game is designed by klaus jurgen raider in these instances
you might want to check that the contract has a stipulation that you'll receive royalties for this expansion material whether you worked on it or not if the designer performs the work required to complete the expansion or iteration the designer will be owed the royalties stated if the designer declines he or she will be owed one percent royalty of revenues on these derivative works up to a maximum of sixty thousand us dollars in total for all such products the designer does not work on in my career thus far there have been two occasions where i've approached an existing publisher of one of my games with a suggestion for a derivative work when picoco was released it caught the attention of several toy companies as well as being nominated for prestigious toy awards i knew that pococco was really too complex a game for that market so during a conversation with publisher brain games i proposed that i develop a junior version of the game picoco kids with brain games agreement i went on to develop that concept which morphed into a new game now called zing azam a game for children and families which hopefully will be released to essence spiel next month after the release of quasal my co-designer rob fisher and i saw opportunities for new versions with a similar rule set but a totally new aesthetic and a twist on the central puzzle we pitched several of these new iterations to happy puzzle company and one of them was licensed again there was a process of development and quasal expert became the genius gems
so now you know how expansions and other derivative works are handled by publishing contracts if you want to know more about ownership of game concepts and how lights are handled when the game ceases publication click on the link