Top 10 PUNISHING Board Games
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm talking about my top 10 punishing ball games now what do I mean by punishing ball games what I mean is that these games go that extra mile to make your life that much more difficult because to be honest making this list wasn't the easiest um because of the Blurred Lines between say punishing games and just difficult games or mean games in general so but these ones are mostly driven by the game itself trying to again cause problems for the players and if you want a a list based purely on mean games then I have recorded a top 10 based on that so check out my channel for that video um but before I get started on these 10 punishing games and a few honorable mentions I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor k.c. who are my goto online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order at number 10 I'm going to start off with a small boox card game called archaeology the new Expedition now in theory this is a simple set collection game where you are collecting Cards into your hand and then trying to trade them in as sets and basically you got these different kind of Egyptian artifacts uh the more you collect of a certain set when you trade them in they're going to be worth more points but where the punishing part of this game comes in is in that main deck of artifacts there are going to be these Sandstorm cards and randomly those Sandstorm cards are going to come out
and they are going to force all the players to discard I believe half of their cards rounded up so there's this real kind of push your luck tension to the game of yes I want to build up these bigger sets but the more I'm building them up um the riskier it's going to get in terms of those sandstorms coming out and wasting all of my efforts and typically as you can imagine with these kind of games due to the random nature it feels like you get whacked really hard lose all your cards think it's going to be a while until the next Sandstorm comes out so let's build up my hand again and then all of a sudden you are blindsided Again by another sandstorm it's just the the typical way that these games seem to resolve but it's a lot of fun again very simple set collection stuff but with that extra Twist of those sandstorms coming out it just completely makes the game feel very punishing to be honest so that is archaeology the new Expedition at number 10 at number nine I have R Eco which is another small boox card game now this one's a little bit more driven by the players but the game itself is going to facilitate players making pretty you know nasty moves and forcing you to take cards that you do not want to take so this game is all about trying to um recycle these cards in your hand where you have I believe it's four different suits of goods and what you're trying to do is you're trying to build up these this hand of cards trade them in against these recycling plants in order to get victory points but the twist is that whenever you play next to these recycling plants then you have to pick
up cards that are deposited beneath them kind of every time an action is taken and on top of that you do have a very strict limit of cards in your hand I believe it's only five or six cards and whenever you are forced to pick up more cards then those cards are going to be added onto a pile of negative points and you know again SS law the way that the game works you're going to keep on getting sets into your hand that you're not quite ready to play yet but you're for to play and then when you play things you're forced to pick up a whole bunch more cards that again you do not want so it's a very tight Balancing Act sometimes you need to know when to kind of overcompensate by delivering Goods just so you can thin out your hand and getting through the game without getting punished by the the game itself is a very difficult thing uh to overcome so yeah almost inevitable that you're going to get some negative points at that way again it is a little bit more player driven because you can leave traps and kind of force your opponent to take cards that you you don't want yourself but there's no way around it and the game is going to make sure that happens that's why it made the list so that is our Eco at number nine at number eight I have Spirit Island which is an immensely complex Cooperative game where you are controlling these spirits to try and fight off these Invaders now a big portion of it making this list is probably because I am terrible at this game so um you know I'm really bad at it and that's probably why I find it so punishing um but I think the game itself
you know makes it difficult for you yeah it's a difficult game um but I think the way that the kind of colonist spread around the board just makes you feel like you are really fighting an uphill battle um at all times because you are kind of slowly making progress and then all of a sudden all that progress is just undone as these units just keep on spreading their influence and beating all your units down and so on so I definitely feel like I am again fighting that uphill battle at all times in this game and hence why you know a game like this you want it to be difficult but sometimes I personally thought it was a little bit too difficult but maybe that's my personal skills so that is Spirit Island at number eight and number seven I have a lesser known game called Michael strogoff now this is a game where you are trying to travel from the left side of the board to the right side of the board and as you travel you are going to go through these terrain types which you to draw cards and these cards are going to punish you in one way or another at least if you get these duplicate symbols on these cards so it acts like almost like a push your luck game where if you have single symbols revealed it's fine but as soon as you get a duplicate something bad is going to happen or several bad things are going to happen and it's all about managing this hand of cars to try and overcome these threats doing it in the right order knowing what you can take and knowing what you need to get rid of immediately um it really does feel like you can get stuck in the mud in this game because once something bad happens
it tends to be a slippery slope into being many bad things happening and again it does really make you feel like you're getting battered through the entire experience and you've even got some of these permanent deficits that you can't even overcome which makes it that much more difficult so um I like the game mechanically wise you know but the actual overall experience just made me feel pretty exhausted because it was just that hard going in terms of just being battered by the game itself but still a good game um but I think maybe a lot of people bounced off of it because of the almost the vibe of the game being so damn punishing so that is Michael strogoff at number seven at number six I have a pretty wacky game called Galaxy trucker so the idea of this game is very cool where you are frantically building this spaceship on this real time um basis grabbing these tiles trying to get everything you need on your ship such as these guns and like um kind of the the cockpits to hold your astronauts kind of speed boosters batteries you everything you need even like cargo holds so you can grab these Goods as you go on your journey um so you can plan as well as you like on this game but the problem is when it comes to the kind of second phase in the game all your plans are going to go out the window as you are traveling through these kind of meteor fields and fighting off of the space pirates and the interesting thing about this game is that these meteors are going to attack you based on this kind of somewhat randomized mechanism and
just completely pick your ship apart and I love the way that if those kind of meteors or asteroids hit those exact sweet spot on your spaceship then you can lose a whole wing of your spaceship in a single move all your batteries all your cargo you know all your crew just go completely Fade Into Oblivion and you'll not have them for the remainder of for your journey so again you can plan as well as you like but it's probably going to go ay um yes it's chaotic it's it's crazy but it is a lot of fun and that kind of punishing nature of the game is and built into the game I've had um several games of this where you know in the first couple of minutes of the second phase all your plans are out the window because you've just been battered in that exact spot you didn't want to be um so a lot of fun again it's not going to be for everybody because it is quite chaotic but no doubt is it punishing so that is Galaxy trucker at number six at number five I have palop which in theory is a pretty simple little bidding and resource management style game as you're trying to manage your population you feed your people get resources to buy new tiles and so on um but the game does have a pretty distinct twist where at the end of every phase in the game you're going to be revealing these tokens which will be a kind of a countdown mechanism until something very bad happens so you do have a little bit of forewarning as to when something bad could happen but because of the random nature in which these tiles come out um
you could get hit with a couple in a row which will just completely take you by surprise and these things can be um mechanisms such as losing a third of your food which of course you're going to need to feed your people and if you don't have the food at the right time all those people are going to die or you got got to have certain resources or lose tows that you've invested in lose um kind of excess goods uh even like um lose you know basically you can lose everything based on these um on these countdown mechanisms so it's all ingrained into the game and I suppose without that part of the game it's still a decent game but it's not as interesting and that kind of constant threat and Dread of something bad happening isn't quite there but I tend to like these punishing style games where that punishing aspect is a for kind of at the Forefront of the of the game experience and I think poopes is one of the strongest if that of that category and hence why it's at number five and number four I have Lord of the Rings The Living card game which is another Cooperative game this one you have kind of an ensemble of middlee characters that you're trying to overcome these different scenarios by working with not your own team but obviously your teammates teams as well now all of these characters have their own strengths and weaknesses like for example some of them are really good that kind of scouting out the mission some of them are really good at combat Etc and you need to know when to kind of tie them up on their different or different phases in the game because if you're if you're exploring then you're
not going to be fighting and so on now the difficulty is that when you go through these phases um if you don't kind of contribute enough into that particular effort then you're going to get pretty much battered by the game so for example if you're not exploring enough then you're threat Mark might go up which is one of the kind of barometers of when the game might end um and also you might get kind of new locations that come out which can give you horrible kind of burdens that you need to overcome and make your life more difficult and then on top of that you've got the combat phase of the game which I personally find very difficult and um you know I'm rub at it but I always struggle to overcome that phase because the the monsters you're fighting are generally quite powerful uh even without this extra mechanism of these shadow cards that come out that make your life that much more difficult because you could spend a lot of your efforts kind of boosting up your characters by equipping them with weapons and stuff and then these monsters come out and completely just say you know what you can't use your weapon this turn which you think when you're in that situation what can I do I'm going to take some heavy hits here and it's always going to be an uphill battle from them so it's a bit like Michael stro off in the sense that once things go bad they can become even worse in a quick fashion so you you can go in a very downward spiral um pattern in this game pretty rapidly but still wonderfully designed game very um very versatile in all the different scenarios you can play again if you love Lord of the Rings or Middle Earth in general then I definitely recommend
giving this game a go and particularly if you like clever card play and scenario story based gaming so again but be prepared for it to be very difficult and for the game to hit you pretty hard so that is Lord of the Rings The Living card game at number four and number three I have the grizzled this is another Cooperative game actually a very simple game in theory where you and your teammates which are kind of representing these troops in World War I I believe kind in the trenches trying to overcome these kind of traumatic things happening to you you're playing these cards in this row and these cards have several bits of information on them such as the kind of the weather type or the train type or these little symbols on them like these gas masks or like shells and what you're trying to do is that you're trying to play a sequence of these cards without trying to get I believe it's three of a kind whether that be the symbols on them or the you know the train types themselves because if you do that then something bad is going to happen um you get these kind of really horrible punishing cards that are difficult to shake off which can make your life get that much trickier to overcome the rest of the game so for example some might say you know when you Retreat from the round you might be forced to play another card which can hurt everybody else or it might say you can't even talk to your teammates for the rest of the game which of course for a Cooperative game makes it so much more difficult to overcome but I do like the
kind of game Mark in this game where sometimes it feels like you are in an unwinable situation but you might make some ground up by having a good round or two but the general overall experience of the game is that you are struggling and it's going to be very difficult to actually win the game so this one again it fits on that border of being just difficult or punishing I suppose but with the with all those added kind of punishment cards that come out and just the general nature of feeling like you're losing at all times that's what makes me feel it's a perfect fit for a list like this but it's quite a cool experience of a game I'd recommend it giving it a go or two or maybe keep playing it until you actually win it um but doing so might be a long process because it is extremely difficult to overcome so is the grizzled at number three at number two I have the newest game on the list which is Empires end now this is a game where you actually start with most of your points and you are trying to preserve those points as the game tries to snatch them from you so this game has a mechanism almost identical to a game called No than so if you're familiar with that game it's a game where you are bidding not to take punishment um so in this one basically there'll be uh cards that come out which will say um if you end up winning this card or losing this card essentially uh you are going to lose your fourth building in the row and that could be a really valuable building it could be one that you could maybe expend or not and the
way that you avoid taking them is by placing these tokens on them um and until somebody um kind of passes and say I'm not willing to pay any more tokens they will take that punishment but they'll also take all of the tokens that have been bid putting them in a stronger position for the remainder of the game now you do have some opportunities to repair the buildings that you've lost but those opportunities are few and far between and it's all about trying to weather the storm knowing when you can take a hit and leaving yourself enough time to repair uh the game does give you a little bit of a Lifeline sometimes by when you do take these punishments you get a bit of an engine up engine upgrade by having little Boon that tuck under your buildings of your remaining alive buildings basically um but again I love the general feel of the game where you again you start with your points intact and it's all about trying to keep hold of them rather than winning your points as you go and again that this one fits that Vibe of a game like poopes where the the whole feel of the game is more about trying to you know overcome those difficulties rather than being a game of prosperity so that is Empire's end at two and finally at number one I have in the year of the dragon by stepen Feld so this was immediately the the first game that jumped into my mind when I thought of constructing uh this list and I imagine if you played in the year of the dragon you would feel the same way so a
bit like Empire's end this is a game all about trying to weather the storm so from the get-go you are going to be bombarded by horrible things happening to you such as you know War famine um just general hunger you know starvation and it's all about trying to have the right skills in your Tableau at the right time you know or having enough food at the right time having enough money to pay your taxes at the right time so it's all about trying to again overcome these hardships um and what I like about this game though is that you do have such a a strong degree of of planning ahead because during setup you can see the order in which all these different threats are going to occur you you might think well yeah I've got to overcome famine I've got to overcome disease but the war I'm not going to be invaded for quite some time so maybe I don't need to focus on getting my military strength up yet I can maybe try and really focus on getting some medicine in my Camp Overcome those disease get rid of my doctors and then get the military guys in to try and overcome these later threats but the thing is you don't actually get points based on overcoming the threats you get points based on other things meaning that any single bit of leeway that you can get to squeeze a point or two out this game you need to take um but of course you have capacity in these pagodas that you're building you can't just PE House people in the thin air you need to make sure they have somewhere to live um money in this game
is extremely tight um and it can become know very um resource intensive to do the actions that you actually want to do meaning that you need to focus on being first player so you can go where you want to go which is all in your control but still this is one of my favorite games of all time despite how difficult it is to play and it's a true game of attrition and when you come out the other end of the game you feel like wow that was that was quite an experience and um we know we got through it but still I love this game and it's going to be polarizing some people are going to find it just that a little bit too punishing but it is the core DNA of a game like in the year of the dragon and I think is a wonderful wonderful design so that is in the year of the dragon at number one so that we have it that concludes the list hopefully you have enjoyed the video um just maybe one or two honorable mentions which happen to be other stefen Feld games um because they generally come with some kind of threat that you need to overcome or suffer a punishment they games like Amsterdam and knowing you need to build stuff before a certain time um comes around and games like notra Dam Amero Merlin aquasphere Tran they seem to be a running theme in Stephen Feld games um but I think in the year of the dragon is just so much a bigger step above those other ones I didn't want to have several stepf games on the on the same list so I'm really happy with the way this list has turned out again if you have enjoyed
the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel I'm also check out my other content too and keep an eye out for my new game Thalamus which will be available soon but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye