Skip to main content
Loading video...

BGGcon 2015 Wrap-up Vlog Part 1

Transcript 24:38

welcome to John gets games today I'm going to do a post-board game geekcon Wrap Up of a whole bunch of different games that I played at the convention I actually played 25 new games to me and in this two-part Vlog I'm going to be covering 20 of those games so 10 in this one and 10 in the next one I'll be going from the games I really liked to the games I did not like so much in each of these parts so there's going to be good stuff and not so good stuff in both of these videos so let's jump right into it the first game I want to talk about is Through the Ages a new story of civilization uh now I've talked about this many times on my channel before but at the convention cge was kind enough to actually give me a review copy of the brand new game and it was about four hours later after getting this copy of the game that we couldn't help but we sat down and we played a full game of it uh I played this with two of my best friends all of us are pretty experienced with Through the Ages I played the original about 18 times and both of my friends have played it about seven times and uh it's just so great we really really enjoyed it but that three-player game still took four hours so even though we're all somewhat experienced with the game it's still a pretty lengthy experience if you've seen the review I did for the original game of Through the Ages you'll know that it is one of my favorite games of all time but with a pretty big asterisk that I did not like the crazy militarization at the end of the game and I can happily say that instead of calling this game my favorite game but I can now say this is my favorite game with a big exclamation point at the end it it is an exceptional new version they've streamlined through tons of data usage and looking at thousands of games to just make this

great game exceptional and we really enjoyed playing it and I'm really glad to have a beautiful copy of it here and I look forward to playing this a couple times a year for pretty much ever game number two is actually one of the only two games I purchased at the convention it's right up here and it's called Royal Goods the Royal Goods is the German name for it even though it's in English the English printing that isn't out yet is gonna be called oh my goods and I talked about this in my uh games I was excited to play at board game geekcon and I bought this in the first 10 minutes of being at the convention I saw uh Suzanne posted on Twitter that they were selling it in the board game geek store and I just jumped right all over it I ran over there I bought a copy for 20 bucks and I played it a couple times and it is really great it's this tiny little game it's got just two decks of cards here but it's got a very strong Euro feel to it with multi-use cards it's kind of blown me away it's just such a neat little package because you are building this engine but the cool part is that you are building gears that then work with other gears so you build one particular building and it might make you uh brick so you turn clay into bricks but then you build another building that needs bricks in or to make I don't know houses or something like that so then you have to have this first piece before you can really make the second piece work better now you can always make every piece work without its um other pieces but getting the Synergy going just really boosts this awesome combo Synergy thing the game really looks somewhat dull when you look at the cartoony art of people like

in the Middle Ages making stuff but it's really fascinated me with the cool engine building and I very much look forward to playing this one a bunch of times it's pretty much multiplayer Solitaire in fact I played most of a game by myself a couple days ago just to see how it played by myself and I still had a good time playing it so I'm super glad I was able to pick up a copy of this one the third game I want to talk about is also on my shelf and I sort of bought it at the convention and that is Seven Wonders dual uh now this one sold out very quickly at Morgan geekcon and I did not get to get a copy of it but I did play The Hot Games version of it a couple times and while I was at the convention I went online and I bought it from Amazon because I was so blown away by it that I just really wanted to have a copy and I was worried that it was going to sell out because it seems like a lot of places are losing their inventory for it just because everybody's getting it and essentially I was super excited to play this game at board game geek on and it it did everything that I wanted it to uh it has this great two-player feel where you are just struggling back and forth with this tug of war with military and specifically the biggest thing is replacing the hand drafting with pool drafting where you're no longer looking at cards in your hand and picking one out and passing it to the person on your left you're now just grabbing cards from an open pool on the board some of them are face down and you don't want to unlock those for your opponent and there's just all sorts of good stuff going on but at the end of the day it's a great Pablo Builder you're making these great Little Engines you get to draft the different wonders at the very beginning of the game in another Pool style draft it just comes together very well and it usually plays in about 30 to 40 minutes so the box says 30 minutes

and I think that's very accurate I really enjoy this one in fact I'm hoping to do a review for this one quite soon because I've already played it four times and I've really enjoyed it all those times so uh you'll be seeing more from me on this one shortly the fourth game I want to talk about is gold West now this was my number one most excited game to play at the convention and I was able to get to it on my second or third day and I really enjoyed it it did pretty much everything that I was hoping for it to do in this game you are very simply doing things on your turn where you are putting down a Hut to take a certain amount of resources put them on a little Mancala track that lets you pick up resources and drop certain ones down and you get to make new buildings and it's very simple you were essentially just trying to mine copper silver and gold and you ship them out and you turn them into investment tracks and it's a medium light to medium weight Euro game and I really enjoyed it uh we played a four player game everybody around the table liked it I lost by like three points and I really felt like I had a shot at it uh and that was with getting pretty much none of the investment cards so it appears that there's several different ways that you can play the game and I think that there's a definitely a deeper layer of strategy there that none of us really got into because in the game when you take Reese sources you put them onto a man call a track as I mentioned before but the farther back you put it so the farther away from being able to utilize The Goods the more points you get and none of us really use that very much we pretty much always put it right near the front so we can just cash out those goods on the next turn and do cool stuff

but once the game is over we really look we really looked at it and I feel like next time I play I'm gonna try to plan a little bit more ahead be a little bit more strategic and cash in on those big points that are near the bottom of that track and see how I do so I really enjoyed this one I will say that near the end of the game it was a 10 round game because it was four players those last two turns got pretty slow because there is quite a bit to think about because of there's area majority with respect to the four different regions that you can grab stuff from and so those last two terms there's a lot of thinking well what am I winning what can I safely win throughout the rest of the game what do I need to defend and it seemed like analysis paralysis started creeping in there at the end but I feel like multiple plays will reduce that also potentially playing with three players instead of four will make it uh have a little bit less to analyze when you're comparing opponents to each other but I still really enjoy the four player game and I hope to have the opportunity to play this one several more times I'm not sure if it was for sale a board game econ but I was really trying to keep my purchases low so I didn't even look for it but maybe in the future I'll grab it the fifth game I played is sort of an unofficial variant to code names it was called the code names LARP and LARP stands for Live Action role-playing which is kind of what this game was about I went into it not really knowing anything uh Paul Grogan had been talking about it for quite a bit on uh Twitter he works with cge quite a bit and he had this idea to do a convention Style game of code names if you don't know how code names work simply put there are 25 code words out on the table and people try to

figure out um which words are what well in this convention version every single one of those code names those cards was given to a person so there were 28 or so people playing and I was one of those people uh and the way it worked it we didn't really know until we just jumped in and he said it's going to be about 15 minutes and it was was we all had our code name in a a badge around our neck and we were told clues for the red and blue side and we were all kind of collectively neutral we were trying to write down on a piece of paper who we thought was on the red side and who thought was on the blue side based off of these kind of General Clues so in the original game there are two different teams and there's one spy Master giving Clues just for their red team and once biomaster just giving clues for their blue team in this one there were two spy Masters but they pretty much colluded together to come up with good Clues and nobody really cared what team they were on they just tried to figure out who was on which team and at the end they read out all the people who were in which spot and you got to count up your score um I did very poorly I only got nine out of the I think 16 uh different options right which was definitely way below 50 but it was fun because essentially we all just ran around we were told a clue like um astronomy 2 and you're just running around looking at everybody's Badges and oh you over there and you were there it was much more memory based because you see a badge and that person wanders off and everybody's trying to look at each other but it was like 15 minutes and it was surprisingly fun I didn't have the opportunity to play uh the code names ARP again even though he did it every single night at the convention but I could see myself doing it again it was a good time

the next game is potion explosion this was one that was on my radar going into the convention mostly because of the images that I'd seen online it looked like this Goofy game with a crazy gimmick where you have this large cardboard contraption that you pour a bunch of different colored marbles into they'll fall down into these little tracks and all you do on your turn is pull marbles out and gravity kind of slides the other marbles down and if two marbles then Collide in the same color they explode and you pull those out and if that causes two more marbles to hit they're the same color those explode and you pull those out so you trying to create these chain reactions and ultimately you're trying to take these different color marbles so just put them onto little potions in a just kind of order management system you know this potion needs three blue and two red well you want to find a way to get those three blue and two red on there but the cool thing is once you create those those potions you put them to the side and you can drink them uh every single potion can be drunk once in the game and it gives you a powerful effect that you can use to fill more potion orders and the best part about it is you still get the victory points for that potion even though you drink it so you're very um you're you're motivated to drink all the potions you can and they've got great art and a great theme it was fun saying you know I'm drinking the potion of the Abyssal draft and all that kind of stuff it was a good time I ended up playing this one a couple times because just the visceral feel of pulling those marbles out and having to clacked together and explode and pulling them out and you might have a bum turn this time but next time it comes around you might end up with like 12 marbles in your hand and

you can't even do everything do um you can't even do everything you want with those you have to throw some of those back in the tray because it's more than you can even handle and it's just a fun game when it was on the table I'd say at least five or six people each time we played walking by it asked us what was going on there because it just looked interesting on the table and I will say that it seemed like there was a bit of a runaway leader problem with the game both games the person who won won by quite a large margin I think because as you successfully create these potions they give you abilities which help you create more potions and then vice versa you can kind of get a um a wheel really rolling in that respect you're not building an engine because they're all one shots but it still seemed like the rich got a little bit richer but the whole game lasted about half an hour and even people who lost entirely seem to be really enjoying it so I I already looked into this one it seems like it's pretty much sold out everywhere there was a little bit of a problem with the first printing run I think with the Contraption in fact I bumped into that where it didn't quite work perfectly but from what I've seen online they've already they're already printing out a fix for it and the next printing of the game will have all those fixes in it so I could see myself owning this one in the future it's just silly fun the rules take like a minute to teach and it was a good time so now let's talk about Luna this is not necessarily a new game in fact it was first printed about five years ago but it just got a new printing so it seemed like there was a bit of Buzz about it at the convention and I was able to pick up a copy out of the library and I want to play it it's a older Stephen Feld game that I've heard a lot about many people

have said online that this is one of his best uh designs and I just wanted to know what was going on this game I ended up playing it with Paul Grogan who bought it when it first came out many years ago and he taught it to us and we had a pretty good time with it although I will admit it was a little bit more obtuse than I was expecting especially from a failed game in this game there is a large Central um cardboard tile which is essentially a monastery and then around that are a bunch of smaller Islands which are little uh individual cardboard pieces that don't actually touch each other and the main aspect of the game really is you have workers that are placed down all these different islands that are around this main central island and in order to do a myriad of actions you got to spend those workers and you'll get to reuse them on the following turn the fun thing is when you spend them you pretty much always throw them into the ocean it's like this kind of pagan thematic thing going on it's like oh we need to uh build a boat well uh Bob and Larry go for a swim into the ocean and by swimming in the ocean maybe that makes a prayer or something like that and a boat appears or maybe you get a tidal wave or maybe a phantom ghost-like helper appears all from just jumping into the ocean it's uh definitely silly uh thematically there but the thing that well I enjoyed the game I almost won Paul beat me out by just a couple points but it took many turns to figure out what I was actually trying to do uh the basic idea is those people get used when they jump back on the island and then you use them next turn and they jump back on the different Islands but you can shift them all around to these different islands where you can get

power ups that let you do special things like getting those ships or um getting those Phantom people but ultimately what you're trying to do is send these people into the monastery which is in the center of the board and it is just a bunch of hexagons with little numbers on them apparently this mechanic was pretty much intentionally copied and put into La Granja which was a heavy Euro that came out last year and this part is is quite combative when you put a person in it boots anybody out that was around that person that had a lower value to their hex and so there's a lot of thinking you have to see which person you want to put down on which spot and where it's going to go and what is it adjacent to but then even just getting to that point you need to jump these people off the ocean here and these people off the ocean here and maybe use this token to shift things around and then there's also a little bit of area majority each turn a new one of the outer islands is going to score points if you have the most stuff on it and then another one of the islands is going to score you negative points if you have anybody there and wow there's just a lot to think about and it definitely felt a bit convoluted trying to figure out how to get to that end point of getting uh your acolytes into that Monastery you had to do this and then this and then this and then count this many islands around and then do that and do this I I could see myself playing it again because honestly I feel like I've invested some brain power into figuring out how to play the game so playing it a second time will be I'll be able to jump into what I want to do more rather than try to figure out how I do anything but I it did not really blow me away I definitely prefer most other stuff and failed games then I've played mostly because it was so hard to figure out how

to get from the beginning to the end and the process of just getting people into that Monastery and maybe this is because we were like four days in and this is like in the 16th or 17th hour of the day but but still I could tell that it was a bit more confident than I wanted and uh that was my experience with Luna the second to last game I'm going to cover in this video is Chronicles Origins now this was a demo of a beta for the game uh this game will not be coming out until sometime next year I think there's going to be a Kickstarter at some point in February but uh the idea of this game well first of all it's being designed by Dirk Niemeyer who runs artana Studios and they've made a whole bunch of games like Tesla versus Edison and tomorrow and um uh the new science well some of those well for from a different publisher but still the same author designer of the game but in Chronicles Origins Rob davio is also helping with a legacy style aspect to the game it's a really cool idea where you buy this box and you play the game several times and you essentially you are a pre-history creating these um hunter-gatherer tribes and trying to settle down a little bit but once you play the game a few times that apparently you could flip the game over the game board over and now you have a completely different game and I believe you can take those custom tribes that you've created through other games and maybe fight against each other I'm not positive about that but what I do know is in the future they're going to come out with more games like entire boxes called Chronicles I don't know Roman ages or something like that and you when you play that the things that you did in the prior game so in a whole nother box are going to affect how this

new game works so it's kind of like a new iterative level of Legacy mechanic in general Legacy means you're modifying this specific box so so every time you play it's gonna be slightly different this one goes farther out so the things you do in this game are going to Branch out into other entire boxes of components and games that they said they're going to be publishing for a bunch of years in the future so that's neat and we wanted to try a demo of it so this um Chronicles Origins which is the very very first thing you do it's like I said a pre-history type thing but really what it is is a semi-cooperative game where you are all in the same Village trying to build up this Village you're You're Building little buildings and you're exploring and you're becoming smarter like you get tags like you can be a savior or an Explorer specifically to your character and the thing is you can all collectively lose but at the end of the game if you don't collectively lose then the person who has got the most victory points I forget what the the specific name for it was it's a little token with a hand on it so I kept high-fiving people with this hand token uh the person who has the most of those wins and they become the chief to the tribe so you have the typical issues that somebody Cooper games have where you do want to collectively not tank the entire game but you still want to win and there is a blind bidding process where you can give up resources to keep your engines going uh your engines for getting you different types of resources in the game and if you're greedy well those engines are going to deplete down and not create much stuff and then you might all collectively fail the other thing I wasn't expecting about

this game is it has a storytelling aspect to it if you decide that you want to um forage in a spot and so you could build a building or you can just forge around and see what's going on you could see um you get a story like you literally get out a book and you say okay what's number 17 and then you read it in one of these I founded a religion by looking out across the ocean and feeling moved by the waves and and I named a religion and later on in that play session I tried to become the savior of that religion through other mechanics and so story wise that was pretty cool and it almost got to the point where we were motivated to do as much of the storytelling as we could instead of the engine building stuff so that's an interesting uh Balancing Act that's going on there ultimately we enjoyed it but I will admit it felt pretty rough around the edges still now this was a beta so the game is far from done yet like I said the kickstarter is coming out in I think they said February but it just seemed like some of the mechanics were clunkier than they wanted like the storytelling aspect and they'll that theme was very cool but ultimately when you're just like building the buildings and doing the bidding process it that felt a bit dry and uh not as interesting as I wanted so I can't give a strong opinion on it because obviously it's not done yet but it was an interesting demo the last game I'm going to talk about in this video is dojo Koon and it since I said in the beginning I'm going to be covering games I liked in games I didn't like this is the final one and I did not enjoy this one very much and that definitely surprised me there was quite a bit of hype about this game coming out of Essen in fact many people say this was the Hidden Gem of the convention

where no one was really talking about it going in there was no hype for that but there was quite a bit of rumbling for people said oh I played it and then everybody around the table loved it so much they all went out and bought a copy and they all played it and then other people bought copies and I said well that sounds interesting what's going on here and I looked into it and it did look cool the idea of this game is it's three quarters a um three quarters of the game is work replacement and the last quarter is a um a tournament a Martial Arts Tournament so those first three quarters you are building up your dojo you're training your people you're giving them special powers you're getting new people you're getting training equipment you're focusing your Chi and then after you do three turns of that you all go to a tournament you pit all of your people against each other in a bracket you know these people these people these people fight whoever wins then these two people fight and then whoever wins goes on to the grand finale and after you do that you reset it all back and you do another three turns of work replacement and then a final tournament so there are two tournaments in the game what a cool idea especially because the tournament it just involves throwing tons of dice when you're training your people you're just adding dice to the people and it's not that these dice are just one through six Pips now they got all sorts of stuff going on and they have holds and punches and kicks and jumps they have uh chi symbols on them there's just really cool stuff going on these custom Dice and I just really wanted to play it and the biggest problem that I had with this game is I spent almost the entire game session with my nose in the rulebook trying to figure out how to play the game I read the whole rule book on the plane ride over to the convention and I felt like I had a pretty good idea but it seemed like every five minutes we had

a rules question uh something just didn't quite work or something didn't make sense and then it would take us 10 minutes to find the answer in the rule book and then we kind of keep playing and then another five minutes we'd have another question and then 10 minutes trying to find the answer in the rule book it really killed the mood the whole game took well over two hours for a three player game and I just did not have fun with it I I felt like there was too much going on for what the payoff was now I feel like if somebody had just taught this game for us and knew everything about it I probably would have enjoyed it more but I don't know if I would have ultimately liked it even so because wow it just seemed like the worker placement part was okay it was typical work replacementy things it was kind of cool focusing Qi or um learning special moves but it still felt a little bit clunky because you have two different types of workers you have your master and then you have your your regular you know your athletes you know you specifically send them over here and they train which is kind of cool but the master can only do certain things and it seemed like if you want to get more people you have to expand your dojo and then once you expand your dojo then you can get new people but everybody only has one master and all of these actions that specifically the expanding Dojo action can only take one master and when there's only six work replacement sessions for the entire game and all three of us only get two shots of that thing but they want to be going elsewhere to train their people I get what they're saying is you can spend your whole game focusing on just a couple people and trying to have a couple really good Fighters or you can get a bunch of people but all your Fighters will be less good but ultimately it just kind of felt clicky and I didn't like it um and the other big issue was that the tournament took forever it seemed like I love the idea

of throwing all these Dice and having a bracketed structure fighting these people against these people and going up and then these people fight and they go up and the higher you go up in the rankings the more victory points you get but I mean we're rolling the dice and Counting and all these symbols are so tiny and then there's a hypothetically cool evaluation system where the number of jumps you get negates the number of holds and then the number of holds indicates the number of punches or there's three different three or four different types of things that go on there and they all kind of negate each other but what it ends up being is that each one of those fights takes like five minutes and then you do you do four of them down here then you do two more then you do a final one and it seemed like that tournament just took forever we were all collectively trying to count up all the little Pips on the dice it just felt fiddly and and I was expecting the tournament to be like a 10 minute process total and it seemed like it was at least twice that and honestly it was also pretty fire and forget there wasn't really any decisions to be made while you're playing that sure occasionally you could activate a special power with the chi that you were able to get on those dice that you rolled and the chi that you had focused during the first part of the game but it seemed very autoplay like you just if you got to that threshold you did it so this huge part of the game had pretty much no decisions in it and was fiddly and took a long time and ultimately I felt like the entire game of Dojo Koon was just it just I think it needed some stuff chopped off the edges it was too much too convoluted the rulebook was not great and all three of us really did not have a good time playing it and I don't anticipate playing this one ever again all right well that finishes the first half to my post board game gigcon

coverage uh feel free to click the link to jump over to the next video and see 10 more games and all the different thoughts I have about them uh if you'd like to see more stuff like this in the future please subscribe to my channel and you can also support my Channel at patreon.com John getsgames and I really appreciate it so thanks for watching

Progress saved