20 Board Games Ranked - Episode 9
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another edition of month in review so this is a series where i talk about all the new to me games i played in the month prior this one being january 2022 and i rank them from my least favorite to my most favorite now i think out of all the videos of these i've done this one might be the most diverse one diverse one so far ranging from games that dated us back as early as 1930 to 2021 games that are for kids and pretty heavy involved euros um but before i get started on the video i want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kianda dot co uk so if you if you live in the uk and you regularly purchase board games be sure to check out their great website but let's get started so first off at number 20 i have a dragon's breath so this is essentially a kids game where you have these rings that are stacked up upon each one another and then you've got a bunch of these little plastic gems that go inside and then you're basically trying to remove these rings to try and make a certain number of your gems fall out and make other people's shims fall out and fall down these holes to be lost forever that's pretty much the extent of the game i think this was so bad that it was good um you know for all the wrong reasons you know we laughed because it was so bad of course this isn't really tailored towards adults we played it just for a bit of fun um and you know i can't rate it any higher than the last place because it was just a terrible game and i couldn't even understand why kids would like it and funny enough the person who bought this bought it for their very young daughter and she hated it as well so there we go that is dragon's breath that one came
out in 2017. uh at number 19 i have monopoly deal so yeah the word monopoly has appeared on a chairman of the board episode there we go so this one is basically a set collection version of monopoly and a bit of take that as you're drawing cards you are trying to put out properties of certain colors in front of you and once you get i think it's two or three sets then the game ends and you win and you're basically trying to buy property of other people you could use these cards as money so that you can pay your fines and things um really basic stuff some pretty nasty take that stuff in it which i don't really tend to enjoy and i'm to be honest the game was pretty terrible um but i actually heard some good things about this one prior to um you know priced me playing it um but that one goes back to 2014 and yeah i would strongly um recommend you give that one a miss that is monopoly deal at number 18 i have a brand new game out 2021 release uh this is whirling witchcraft so i was actually expecting quite a lot from welding witchcraft so this is a weird game as you are essentially trying to convert cubes into other cubes almost like this engine building manner and then you put them into this cauldron and then this cauldron rotates each round to the person sitting next to you and they'll take all those cubes into their player board and stack them in rows and the idea is you're trying to overwhelm your opponents by giving them so many cubes that they can't contain them and then they overflow their cauldron and essentially lose the game so you're trying to force your opponents to lose the game in this one which generally is
a is a style of play that i don't like i thought this game had some really tacked on mechanisms that just did not need to be there and i think ultimately the thing i didn't like most about this one was how subject you are to the card draw so for example if you are really getting overwhelmed with blue cubes and then you don't have any cards to help you get rid of blue cubes then you're pretty much you're pretty much done for and that's how this game played out for me so very abrupt unsatisfying finishes um and i didn't like the game simple as that so that is whirling witchcraft at number 18. at number 17 i have a game called oh hell this is going back to 1930 and is pretty much a traditional you know classic trick taking game uh in this one you are basically given a hand of cards i think it fluctuates the game goes on so you start with a big range of cards going down to just a few and then you are betting on how many tricks you think you're going to win and if you get that right then you are going to get a boost of points very simple stuff you know very good a very classic traditional card game um but it works for what it is it's still trick taking isn't my style really i'm not a big fan of it but this one was okay and i'll happily play it again because it's quick it's simple and um you can teach it to anybody really so that is oh hell at number 17.
at number 16 i have the adventures of robin hood so this is a 2021 design and this one is to be honest the only reason this is lower on the list is because this just isn't my style of game i mean i generally actually really appreciate what this game achieves it's very ambitious have you as you have this big map probably the best looking board i've ever seen to be honest absolutely gorgeous michael menzel artwork yeah amongst the best board i think probably my top five boards i've ever seen but this one you have certain spots on the board where you flip them over almost like an advent calendar and they go to the other side you'll go through the story as you know robin hood and his merry men visiting different people talking to them feeling objectives and i had quite a cool initiative system as you're drawing things out the bag um you're constantly referring to this book where you're reading through different passages and things to you know develop the story and go on uh it's it's good for what it is i said if you have a family who likes story-driven games it's not really going to get much better than robin hood but for me personally it's not going to be a kind of game that i dive into nothing that really you know captures me too much because i'm you know i'm a mechanisms man this is very much a story and theme game but again if you like that stellar game i really recommend giving this one a look because it is i think it's quite special to be honest but just not for me so that is uh robin hood or the adventures of robin hood at number 16.
so moving on to number 15 we have a pretty um a pretty obscure game this one is hounded dating back to 2016. this is a two-player abstract game as one person is a basically a hunter and they have a bunch of their their hounds their hunting house with them and the other person is a fox and the idea is that as the fox you're trying to move around this grill of towels trying to find certain ones before the hunter traps you and you can't move anymore so it's got quite a bleak theme and one that you know i thought it was quite interesting that they went for it because you know fox hunting is quite taboo i suppose but i like you know i always like people when people you know don't care about that kind of thing but this one it was a pretty traditional standard abstract style game um but it works well i think it's slightly imbalanced in favor of the fox i think you're a bit too agile to outmaneuver the hunter um but again i like the theme i like the um i like the idea of it and i would play it again it's pretty quick but i think ultimately when games like this aren't too balanced and i have a bit of doubt in my mind that you know it's just not fair on one person then you know that time that tends to be a bit of a you know a bit a big negative for me but you know more plays might might you bounce that out so um we shall see that is hounded at number 14 i have lost kingdoms and pangaea in pieces this is a another 2021 release this was a i believe a backed on kickstarter this is an area control style game based on on dinosaurs so you're basically
have a bunch of these dinosaurs and you can kind of you can kind of breed with each other and expand your you know your pieces on the board you can move them around you have this dynamic board state where you're sliding these tiles from area to area you're trying to spread yourself as thin as possible but control those majorities very standard stuff in my opinion now this has been done a thousand times pretty much abstract in this game but because it's there's nothing really wrong with it there's just nothing terribly exciting about it and there's a million better placement games out there and better abstract games out there but this one just didn't really do anything new which i think is quite strange for a game like that to come out in 2021 which doesn't really try anything different at all so nothing wrong with it but just nothing nothing special about it whatsoever so that is lost kingdoms at number 14.
now at number 13 i have four seasons so this is a small box card game um it's a i pick also i split you choose mechanism which has been kind of made broader appealing in games such as um hana makoji this one predates hanumakoji by quite a while and you are essentially given a bunch of these cards that value in ranges you've got like a strength one strength two and strength three cards you have i think it's four different suits each to the um the seasons and then all you're doing is you're picking two cards from your hand giving them to your opponent they'll choose one of them to act as a kind of a bid and they'll use the other one to act to put in the in the points pool which you're both fighting for so it's all about you know how are you going to split those cars so that your opponent doesn't benefit too much from them and their choices aren't so easy for them to stop them running away from with the points it works perfectly fine no issues whatsoever with it and in fact it's quite a good game particularly when it comes to the second half of the game when things really ramp up and you know the kind of things you want to go for i thought the first half of the game was a bit too much going through the motions not really having much guidance what you want to do but again the second half the game really did come alive um but ultimately the game didn't really hit the higher peaks of this list because a game like kanamekoji does everything this game does better than it so therefore i can't warrant keeping it it's too similar but simply not as good in any way shape or form so a fine game in his own right you know if i played this one without knowing about hanamikoji this will probably fit higher
on the list but because that game exists this one has just been just rendered void for me so that is four seasons at number 13. at number 12 i have another 2021 design with watch so watch has come out with pretty little spotlight on it so this actually has a really cool theme as you are essentially working in this watch factory but secretly you are smuggling out these war munitions but you can be caught by the other players if they go to a certain spot and what's basically a rondelle so you're essentially gaining resources you can convert those resources into these crates which will give you more points the earlier you do them you can convert those crates into better crates and again you can go to that spot where you can kind of guess where other people are going to go in future rounds and if you if they go there then you can actually almost like tax them or blackmail them to pay you money and you have this kind of development board where you are constantly increasing things and making yourself better and more efficient and when you remove these discs from your personal player board you're putting them on a scoring track which will give you points in kind of three different strategies to go for and you know on the on the surface level of this game i thought it was quite clever but in reality i didn't think it really had any highs it was pretty standard fare i didn't find anything tremendously special about it despite sounding and looking different and being a fresh you know a fresh theme i thought the scoring was okay um as again you would invest in these different strategies on are you going to go through a money strategy are you going to go for a gear strategy are you
going to go for the munitions strategy um and you'd invest in these tracks which i thought was a bit too zero sum you can clearly see who was going to run run away with it if it went down that path and i thought also there was quite a lot of scope for analysis paralysis because when you'd invest in one of these tracks you would kind of hinder your ability to score another thing and it's always about kind of min-maxing that and how you're going to benefit the most so i wanted to like this one unfortunately it just felt a bit shy and um just didn't quite you know didn't quite hit that or scratched that itch that i wanted it to so yeah unfortunately couldn't quite recommend watch despite its best efforts next up at number 11 i have timeline so this one goes back to uh 2011 or i think there's several versions of this uh this version i played in particular was the historical events version this is probably one of the easiest games i've ever played where you are given a bunch of cards with different historical events on them and you are putting them on the on this queue of cards um one time at a time so you know you're going to play a card then somebody else is going to play a card and each time you play a card you have to get that event in chronological order so you know you don't want to play world war one after world war ii for example but i love this kind of thing i like i like history i like trivia so and because this one is completely accessible by anybody i mean you've learned the game just by my explanation there this one i think is a really good fit to play with again with anybody you play young you can play old and you can learn things as you go throughout this game so
it's educational and i know i i like it i'd love to trade all the different versions and mix them into one big thing and um just yeah i thought it was a great game and i would happily own this one so that is uh that is timeline that's the historical events edition at number 10 i have brian buru so this is a 2021 pierce sylvester design that is pretty damn unique to be honest so this one is a hybrid trick taking and area majority style game as you have a bunch of cards which you've drafted and then you are choosing a location on the board all of which have are broken into different regions and then further broken into i suppose towns or cities with different colors on them and then you are basically choosing a location and then the person who chose that location is leading the trick with a card from their hand and they although the cards have numbers on them they have bonuses on them if you win the trick they have bonuses or on them if you lose the trick as well so you do have to strike this bounce up you know do i want to win this region to put my control marker down there to score the majority bonus or do i want to lose that trick on purpose to get the really cool benefit from it and then on top of that you are climbing tracks to get ongoing benefits you are you can climb this kind of religion track or put these markers down where it will increase the influence of one of your pre-existing spaces on the board there was a lot about this game i liked it played in a very succinct amount of time i wasn't really expecting to like it and i did enjoy it quite a lot i thought one of the parts of the game
was weaker than the others where you'd have these viking tokens and if you have the most viking tokens you can essentially render another player's piece obsolete on the board which i thought was a bit yeah it didn't quite hit the spot for me um but the rest of it i enjoyed i'd play this one again it only takes about an hour to play for quite a thinking involved game again different um this one really did kind of bring back memories of a game like the king is dead where i really appreciate the game design but would i find myself ever ever requesting to play the game probably not at number nine i have welcome two so this is um going back to 2018 and it is a roll and right style game as you're building up this neighborhood i suppose um and i suppose this is regarded as one of the better one of the more famous role and write games um and this one certainly lived up to that expectation for me you know for some reason or another i hadn't played this one until this month and i really enjoyed it so you've got quite a lot to think about in this game as you are trying to build up again ascending numbers on these different rows of houses you can divide these houses up into blocks and then invest in the blocks that you've built um yeah lots of good stuff going on here agonizing decisions you know do you want to do this do you want to do this and i really enjoyed it so yeah just a solid well-rounded roll and right game and probably a top tier one um i would quite confidently say so yeah really enjoy this one play it happily play this one anytime nice fast game but still quite thinky quite involved but not too much where it's convoluted so yeah it's a really good niche for me and um just balances things just right for what this
game is supposed to do so yeah i really enjoyed welcome to and i think it's very worthy to be in the top 10 of the month so that is welcome too at number eight i have another 2021 design this one is picture perfect so this one i love the theme of this game as you are essentially getting a bunch of people together for a family photo or you know just a group photo um however all these different people in this shot want different needs so some might say you know i want to stand next to this chapel i don't want to be stood next to the table or i want my face to be hidden and as the game goes on you're gonna keep learning the information about what these people want in order to orientate your different people in different ways to try to get that optimal shot to get the most points possible um surprisingly i generally don't like games with memory in them but this game uses the memory aspect very well because you know you need to think you know why did i place this guy here because you don't get to look at the information you gained earlier so you know you might think why did i place that was it because they wanted to be stood next to them or or was it not should i am i able to move them is that going to hurt me or is it going to help me and i really enjoyed that so a very quick accessible game but with a really neat theme you know you can call it deduction i suppose and again that memory aspect comes through strongly and i thought it was a very very fresh um and fun game um that this one's got potential to fall into a shirt of quality should i play it more because i've only played some once so far but initial impressions are very positive again achieves what it's supposed to do very nice welcoming
gateway game that is that is picture perfect speaking of gateway games at number seven i have fantastic factories so this is a family friendly very accessible engine building style game as you are acquiring cards in this communal draft putting them well basically put them in a tableau and then you're rolling dice to either activate these buildings um you can use your own little headquarters where you're getting more cards and stuff like that getting resources and then using resources to get points essentially and that's that's basically what the game consists of just trying to be as efficient as you can and mitigate those nice roles by using different cards you've acquired before and this one just flows very nicely again very low barrier entry a ton of possibilities especially when you start introducing the expansion content i did play this one with with all the expansion content and i would say personally from now on i would always remove the kind of take that style cards where you could kind of steal resources and things and steal cards off each other that for me didn't quite fit the game and i generally don't like take that mechanisms anyway but the rest of it i thought was a joy to play can only play this one once but would um would happily um you know play it play it several more times because you get quite a rich experience in quite a succinct amount of time um but still again very easy to dive into so that is a fantastic factory it's a great intro to engine building to dice mitigation and card drafting so yeah like that one
at number seven now at number six another 2021 design with tabanusi uh builders of uh this one um yeah this one is a strange one to review for me because um check out my review because i've already should have uploaded that by the time this video comes out but this one is the latest game in the danielle t series by board and dice and which are amongst my favorite games of all time so you look at my shelf i've got tris magisters i've got zulkin i got total card i got to kenya i love them all they're all kind of top 20 games for me this one just didn't um just didn't land for me it was quite fiddly um very convoluted very esoteric and obtuse um don't get me wrong i did i did enjoy the game you know this is my number six best game of the month but because my expectations were so high for this one and i was expecting it to be as good as those other ones and i just don't think it was i think it might have reached a bit too far in order to inject player interaction into the game as you would kind of put these plans onto the board to get a bonus but when you put these plans onto the board you're basically inviting other people to build on your plans to get their own bonus from it and you can climb tracks and things you're multiplying your buildings by your tracks all that euro stuff i'm getting points galore in different ways but i think the game is so um you know so unintuitive that it's going to be a bit of a bug bear to teach anybody nude the game so i think if you have the right group who are really invested in the game and want to play again and again then this might be a good fit but if you
want to keep teaching this to new people then it's going to be a bit of a grinding um you know a bit of a grinding process and to be honest as time's developing as i'm getting more and more experienced with board games these kind of um more fiddly and convoluted games are kind of becoming a bit more uh or i'm starting to stand up a bit more from them and i really do appreciate simplicity and elegance more and more and i think maybe a game like tabanosi is the polar opposite of that despite me again i don't want to sound overly negative it's a good game you know this is a this is a very solid game but is it going to be one that i'm going to request and pull off amongst all these others absolutely not so therefore um it just missed out on getting a recommendation so that is tabernucci builds the ball a very very sad um disappointment for me but despite being good so let's get into the top five then and this is where my recommendations begin so this game so the games from here have a commendation be starting with a shield of quality so the first game with a shield of quality believe it or not at number five is nova luna so ashley and uv rosenberg i enjoy and this one is a pretty accessible one going back to 2019 as you are going around this rondelle collecting towels in a very patchwork style fashion um you know going one to three spaces around there on dell these tiles are going to have different criteria on them so they might say you know this tile wants to go next to two blues tiles and a yellow tile and you're basically building up this little tableau in front of you trying to trigger all these
objectives as quick as you can because you're going to put these little discs on them to say that that objective is complete and once you've got all your disks complete then you're going to win the game so it's a racing style game but i love the fact that it introduces that patchwork time track system where the best tiles cost you more time where you're going to go to the front of this kind of rondelle and all the other players are going to keep taking turns until they catch up with you so you really do need to weigh up you know is this good tile worth all that time it's going to sink or am i going to keep acquiring smaller tiles and i'm getting more mileage out of my turn basically take more turns than my opponent so yeah a very well streamlined smooth game i love the puzzle of this one as you're mapping things out trying to trace roots for other things trying to trigger as many things as you can with a single placement very satisfying only takes 30 minutes to play and um yeah this one's gone straight in my into my collection and i'm going to get quite a few more plays out of this one so yeah not normally the biggest ube fan but his lighter games seem to hit that spot for me a lot better than his more involved ones and that is why sorry nova luna is another example of that at number four i have corrosion so corrosion a more involved euro style game another one from 2021 and this is basically engine building the board game but this game has a slight twist in it where none of your engines are permanent so you're constantly trying to basically acquire these or pla you're paying cards playing cards to acquire the little machines you're putting on your personal player board which are going to trigger whenever you rotate your engine or when
you hit certain spots you can get these chrome chrome machines as well which give you really powerful benefits i mean you can use them and exploit them as much as you can some machines are going to completely corrode and just basically depreciate as the game goes on and you're going to discard them when they hit certain spots so it's all about trying to extract as much out as you can out of these machines before they go away and i like that efficiency puzzle i think that this game actually works really well i did have a few problems with it which could quite easily be fixed which i think the designer is addressing at number one the game is too long um it went about 25 too long and the end of the game you feel like you're just wanting to hurry the game to finish because it just it just outstanding welcome that little bit um and number two i suppose the game arc isn't quite as satisfying as a lot of the other engine builders so you're pretty much doing the same thing from start to finish in this game you know you're never really building up a huge engine to a big crescendo where at the end of the game your machine is much different than the one at the beginning but it's always kind of spinning those plates keeping the game keeping the machine in your engine ticking along rather than amplifying it which i think maybe slightly worked against the game but other than that i thought it was a really good first design by um this designer stefan bauer i think he's called um yeah very very impressive for our first design i enjoyed it quite a lot definitely got more play plays in it for me and i happily recommend this one because if you like engine building i really suggest you give this one a play so that is corrosion at number four
uh top three now so at number three i have a small box card game going back to 2020 with stella so stella only two players this one you are going to basically build up a tableau of cards or basically two tables of cards which work hand in hand with each other you're going to be building one in this telescope which is basically this puzzly style thing is you're trying to put cards in them the same types going in touch with each other you're trying to control majorities because this telescope is basically divided into three parts and if you get the highest numbers in them other more than your opponent you're going to get a big injection of points but you're also trying to get stars in that telescope because the other tableau you're going to be trying to build runs of cards so you know your ones two threes fours fives or you know three four five and your biggest run of cards in each suit is going to multiply by the same suit stars in your telescope and that's basically how the game works but the thing this game does differently than anything else is how you draft the cards in the first place so essentially your the first draft is very easy you're going to pick a card from the row put it in your hand of three cards and then play one of them in your telescope or your or your notebook which is your other tableau but the second draft is really interesting because the card that you played first you have to take the remaining card from the from the um from the pool of cards with the same number as the one you've just played because every single card in that row has a number assigned to it so it does kind of ramp up that complexity but it really does work well for the game it makes it feel different so i
love clever little card games and this one is very clever very succinct very restrictive but in a very good way so i think this game is fantastic and um definitely um cemented yourself in my you know small card game collection love games like this and this one is a really good example of those clever finky card games that um are going to really stand the test of time so that is stella uh really big pleasant surprise for me that is uh number three at number two i'm going all the way back to 1998 with el caballero so this is by wolfgang kramer um and basically is a sister game to el grande which is my favorite game of all time but to be honest the only shared mechanism this game has with el grande is this card initiative system as you are playing a card to basically draft a tile first and then also the higher numbers give you um give you smaller amount of caviaris which are basically your your influence to be put onto the board so are you gonna go last but take a big intake of these caballeros to increase your influence or are you gonna do the vice versa and timing that is very very important and all you're trying to do is build up these regions you're putting these markers down which are essentially your investment tokens which have different numbers on them on each end of this edge of this square tile and you can increase them by rotating this rotating this tile and um you know increase your investment in these different regions to score more points um but i love some of the twists on this game as you can control the the c's or you can
place these grande tokens on them which means that your um that your investment token is gonna really um dive into all the different regions rather than just one that it touches um i'll try to get a review out of this one quickly because i think this one has a lot of things to like about it and when games that this comments can you come to my attention we're talking you know 24 years old now and this game is probably one of the best tile placement games i've played um you know staying in my collection i think it's fantastic some really cool mechanisms that i've never seen before and i love it when games do that and you know wolfgang kramer is a master of his field and um you know why this game isn't talked about is baffling to me it should still be out there this one should be up there with the carcassonnes it should be up there with the isle of skies but for one reason or not it isn't but i think it's that good so that is el caballero at number two and finally the only game this month to get a an elite shield so this is my highest commendation is goa by rudiger dawn this one goes back to 2004 so another older game i went this was a real classic euro style game as you're auctioning for these tiles but the way you auction these tiles is very different to anything else as you have this big rid of a grid of towels and each time you are starting with this first player token on either the edge or the parameter of the board or on an empty space and then from then on each player in a round robin fashion are going to point or put one of their tokens on a on an adjacent tile which shows that they are kind of in the
position of power when that particular tile comes up for auction in the next phase because they get to acquire that for one cheaper than the highest bid amongst the other players um and that's really cool so all you're trying to do on top of that is you're trying to gain these ships you're trying to gain resources to upgrade your personal player boards you're trying to colonize these different um islands resort you know resource management upgrading things to get victory points becoming more efficient as the game goes on um you know the the flow of cash is great in this one because when you are auctioning a tile off or when you win again when you've got your token on that tile then if somebody else wins that tower you're going to get that money so i love the management of resources in this game now are you going to award people too much money by bidding a tile on them building a tile that you want which is going to put them in a really strong position for future tens all that stuff is what i love about board gaming and goa is just a great example and a great just a great piece to showcase how good euros were back in the day so yeah very simple to learn but a ton of depth here really good one of my favorite designers ever and goa probably maybe even my favorite game of his i've played yet so um yeah go up an absolute triumph for me a huge grail game that i wanted to play for a long long time and this one lived up to that expectation so that concludes this list of 20 games i try to get through them as quickly as i can of course i will get reviews out of all of these if i can over the next probably the next couple of months so i'm keeping out for those and some of these are already reviewed but um i hope you enjoyed the video if you have please hit like and subscribe to the channel and
check out my other content too additionally if you want to go that extra step i do have a patreon campaign where you can keep the channel going for as little as two pounds per month so i've really invited you to do that and support me and keep me going so for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board