Skip to main content
Loading video...

My Top 100 Board Games (2025) — Episode 1 (100–91)

Transcript 17:26

How's it going party people? Karen Dan from Gaming Caravan. Do me a favor and tell me what you gave away for Christmas this year or any um December traditions. I want to hear about the generosity you had in your soul. Uh today we're going to start off my first official top 100 list. Yes, I know I did a top 100 list. That wasn't my top 100 list. That was what the Pub Mele gave me, which was so off. I'm not going to lie. That was not very accurate. It Now I made my own list. Out of the 500 games I played, over 250 or 250 of them are ranked on this list. And these are the top 100. I like every single one of these games. I could speak all of these games with my chest. To give you some context of how I rank games, it's about the amount of fun the game has uh over the time and the length of the game. So, the game's pretty fun, but it takes like 6 hours, the game's ranked super low. Um, if the game's super fun and super short, the game's ranked pretty high. Um, so it's really about how much fun do I have with the game and how long is the game? Um, now keep in mind just cuz I said the game can be really fun and really short.

I need a game that like uses my energy, my mental strength usually to score very high. Um, so time to get into it. Just a heads up, Sock Pile is not on here. The game I designed this year barely managed to not make on this list. It made it to 103 out of 100. So, if anything, that is my honorable mention. Um, the game I released this year. So, let's go ahead and get started with my uh bottom 10 games at top 100. So, without further ado, let's go ahead and get started with my bottom 10 games number 100 to 91. Starting off, we have Clank Catacombs, which is a B rank game at number 100. Very solid game, very good game. It's enjoyable. I have not played Clank, only Catacombs, so this is the only Clank game on this list. Um, played this game this year actually. It was a very cool deck builder. I enjoyed dungeon crawling experiences. I enjoyed deck building. Uh, it was a very interesting style of gameplay where you actually have to use your deck building for combat and maneuvering and managing through the tile placement game. Um, it was fun. It was cool. However, I now understand why people say that this game takes like four hours or two hours minimum even at two players. This game took us almost four hours um with four people. It was fun. Um interesting. Grab finding the artifacts, grabbing the artifacts a lot more difficult. However, I found it a little bit too um you know, luck based deck builders don't typically require you to have the perfect hand to do anything in the game. Um at the start of the game, it can be more it can be less frustrating or more frustrating actually because you don't have the what's in your deck that you want yet. But later in the game, as you build the deck towards what you need, it can be still more frustrating because what, let's say you built your deck around combat because you really had a strong challenge you you had to overcome and kill, but now you need maneuvering, but

your deck's full of combat. So, it's kind of a wonky way to go about it. Um, still a good game overall, but yeah, it's just a long game, which is why it's so low on my top 100 list. Coming up next at number nine, we have Nar, uh, which is a Viking themed game. It's a B rank game as well. All these games have been B ranked for a long time. Um, Nar is a cheap $25, $30 game you can get from Pandasaurus. Pandasaur is another small box game. Same people who did um Sea Salt and Paper, they've been killing it with their small box games to be fully honest. Um in Nar, you are a Viking going expeditions. You're building up your ships and you're utilizing your engine that you're building uh to destroy it to cash in on more points. Uh whenever you get certain amount of points, I believe it's 40. Uh the game's going to end. Whoever has the most amount of points will win the game. Um I think it's a cool game. The main issue and the reason why it's lower on my list is because of the fact that you're doing more so there's like an overarching stronger strategy. you should always go for the lure or the lear, the liar, whatever that's the musical instrument um by building your songs and and praising your praises. Uh it's a cool game. I like it a lot. I like how you have to manage what you currently have available to you with what you're going for. Maybe you want a certain amount a certain color. Maybe you want a certain amount of a certain color. Maybe you want like a nice um fleshed out area cuz when you play a card from your hand, you're going to trigger the abilities um of that column.

Or whenever you cash in, you're going to uh destroy your engine to grab a card on top. Sometimes it gives you uh better reoccurring effects. Sometimes it gives you like really strong points but nothing else in the game. So it really depends on the engine you're going for. I like the multiaceted nature to this. And also I think it's really interesting and revolutionary that you have only three of each currency max. So you already have them with you and when you gain them you just slot onto your board. When you spend them you slot it out of your board. I think that's really really dope. So again NAR is a fantastic game. Number 99 out of my you know 100 games. Going to number 98 we have the Great Split. The Great Splits, you know, we have B- rank game. Um I like this game. It's it the first time I played it, I actually could not stand it. When I played it a second time and I actually understood it, that's whenever it really spoke to me and it made sense to me. And the great split, it's the most track bumping game I've ever seen in my entire life cuz your whole board is just like 10 different tracks. When you bump one track, you can sometimes bump another track, let you bump another track, another track, another track. Um, and all these tracks have different purposes. Some tracks are multipliers, some tracks you're messing with the main board, some tracks you're messing with other like uh other things on your board. So, it really just depends uh what you're going for and what you want and you're making deals cuz it's the only game, one of the first games I play that's I split, you choose where I'm going to put a card in the middle to split my card, my hand of like four or five cards and pass it to the player on my left and then they're going to choose which side they want and give me the rest of those cards. So, I can make a really good deal for them. Sometimes I can look in their board and say like, "What are you going for?" Build something that's strong for them that also gives me something good. But sometimes they will hate draft. They'll take what you want to give you what you don't want. But regardless, if you plan it well and you play with the player on

your left to a decent amount, you can really have some good strong um turns in this game. But my main issue in this game is you're always playing with the player on your left. Even in like games like between two castles, you're playing with people on your left and right. But only playing with the player on your left gives you a very limited game and a very kind of fixed game where you're playing with someone who's having the exact same strategy as you. You have to like, you know, you have to adjust. You have to change it up a bit. you really have to like it can be a little wonky um only playing with the exact same player throughout the entire game depending on especially like the type of player next to you and all that stuff. So just keep that in mind, but it still is a very strong game and I I do enjoy it a good amount. Going to number 97. The only game that's a solo game on my entire top 100 list, we have uh number 97, Super Hot the Card Game. Yes, it's an IP game and yes, that's a little bit of why it's on this top 100, but additionally it's such a unique, strong solo card game. Um not solo card game, uh single-handed hand management game. It's very unique in that aspect because whatever you destroy on your lineup isn't is actually what you're buying. Uh so whatever you spend actually goes into the main deck.

The main deck is what's attacking you. So when you spend a card, you know that card is going to come back and and and attack you um eventually. Sometime you have to wait for the deck to be shuffled a bit. So it could take a little time, but if you spend a really really strong card, yes, you're able to like clear the entire wave. However, now you know that super strong card is going to come back to try to kill you. There's different currencies in the game coming from uh different kind of combats. There are melee combat uh points. There are agility combat points. Some you have to like attack. Some you have to block and dodge from. The bullets you want to not take. If you ever take a bullet, if you take a certain amount of bullets, you die. Um you have to do the objectives by the end of the game. I believe you have to do one objective and then two objectives and three objectives and the objectives get harder uh as the game goes along. I've only beaten it one time after playing like 10 times probably. Very interesting game. Very unique hand management system. Um, but yeah, the main issue I have with this game is it's a more fixed game play. Uh, just because like you know, you're going to buy what you can. It's kind of like legendary where like you're going to buy the strongest thing almost every single time. Um, cuz why would you buy two smaller things? The only time you do that is if you need to clear out the beginning of your wave, which is again a fixed situation because the closest thing um that's hopping off the board is what's going to attack you. Uh, so just know like the game's kind of fixed, but I want to play in the two and three player modes. I think that's going to be more interesting for sure. Uh, but yeah, it's a good game. It's a solid game and the IP is pretty great. It's video game IP as well if you're into that kind of stuff. Moving on to 96, we have Formage and Formagio. They're they're kind of just an expansion or standalone expansion to the same game. So, I'm counting them in the same category. Both B rank games. Um, Forage and Foragio is

a unique simultaneous worker placement recipe fulfillment game where what you're doing is whatever the boards you have slotted for. Forage gave you four simultaneous games to work with. Uh, for Mage gave you four more and then you combine them. You can mix and match to be whatever kind of game you want. possible and there's enough area control in this game to actually combine to make a fully area control gameplay. It's very interesting. Um, it's fun. It doesn't take too long. The game ends whenever someone runs out of cheese, which definitely depends on the people you're playing with. Sometimes they stall their time and buy their time and skip action. Sometimes people just drop as much cheese as possible, which is like me. But yeah, I think it's cool. The main issue I have with this game, the reason it's not high on this list, is just because of the fact that the boards are asymmetric and they change. Um, it really depends on the board you have. and some boards objectively better than others. I don't know why they did it that way. Um I'm not sure if it just wasn't caught in play testing. I wasn't sure. Maybe they didn't see the strategies, but when you talk to people who play this game a lot, um they can definitely tell you that this game has an objectively better board, especially if it's a strategy that you that you want to go with cuz then you lean into it a lot earlier on. Um you can still work with the board you have. Um and yeah, it it's a fun game. It's a good time no matter what, which is why it's my top 100 games of all time. I really do like Fromage Faggio. Going to number 95. We have Merchants of Andromeda. Game I really want to play a second time.

I've only played this game once. Great game. I want to do a review on it, but I didn't get enough I didn't get any content when I played it first. So engrossed in the game. It's a game you really want to play with even if it's not your current turn. Um Vers Andromeda is one of those games kind of like endless winter where there's a bunch of mini games going on and you have to do your best you can in all these mini games. You want to go hard on one of them as opposed to all of them. Uh but it does reward you and give you the opportunity to actually nail down on all of them at the consequence of not having enough money and you're spending the money because the money I believe is actually your points by the end of the game. But yeah, Merchant of Drama is a good time. The only issue I had with this game was the fact that there's a slight dexterity element to this cuz it's a reverse auction I believe it's called where everyone has their hands on a phone and then people say the phone will say like okay starting at $20 and count downwards. Whoever removes their finger from the phone uh buys the bid at that price. um if they can't afford it, there's like a detriment of some kind that really sucks. So, just make sure you can afford it first. But, it kind of sucks if you both want to buy at 15.

It's really about whoever moves their finger first. And sometimes, you know, they get lucky. I don't know. It's just it's not bad. It's definely part of the game. Um it's just it can be very frustrating, but it's also a lot of the fun cuz whenever I remove my finger, someone else does at the same time. We both like scream and go crazy. It's part of the hype of the game and I I can't say it's a bad feature. I can only say like be aware there is a slight dexter dexterity element to this game. Um but it's a fun time. It's a great It's a great time. I want to play it more for sure. Coming up next, we have Marvel United. Marvel United is an IP game. Yes, it's an IP game, but it's a game where it's a uh cooperative game. The first one on this list we've had so far. Um it's a cooperative game where you all take on a character of the Marvel United universe, um whether it's a hero, anti-hero, um or sometimes even a villain depending how the game works.

And you're going to try to defeat the villain together, or if you are the villain, you're trying to defeat all the heroes together depending on the mode you're playing as. And there's a bunch of different base kits for this game, which is why like, yeah, I'm not going to count all them as standalone games. They're all just under the Marvel United system. Very simple. You're going to play a card for your hand to move around. You want to clear threats. You want to uh beat up the bad guys. You want to rescue civilians. And then after you do two of those three objectives and clear them out from the game, you can fight the bad guy in the face. Different modules will have different ways to do each of these individual factions. I know Green Dobbin starts off with no threats in the board. I know that Thanos has a whole campaign you have to get to before we even beat him, which took us like four to six hours. I don't remember how long that game was. It was a very long game. Um, so overall, just just just it's a good game. Very versatile, able to be played with any amount of people. It's great to be played as a filler game if you do it quick enough. Great to play as like a full kind of campaign game. As I said, some of these modules have campaigns. There's also fan-made campaign maps if you want to do it that way with all the all-in pledges.

Um, there's just so many base boxes. So you even if you play one box too many times, one box typically comes with like two to six or sorry two to four villains about four characters and if you buy a second box now you can mix and match. That's a completely different experience. I suggest you buy about three boxes which should only be about 50 bucks and then you mix and match all of those. That way you don't get overplay any of the one any boxes from one specific characters. If you want the best bang for your buck, I would say go for the Spiderden one there. It's more of advanced gameplay. There's like five or six heroes to it. There's two villains, two anti-heroes, and anti-heroes. You can play as heroes or villains. So, it's very interesting. Overall, I think it's a great gameplay that that everyone should try at least once. Um, and it's very simple, which is why it's not high on this list because it's too simple. At number 93, we have our first and only, I think, like party game of all time. Um, party game at number 93 is Thunder Road Vendetta. I know it's not like party party game, but the six player game that you just roll dice and you laugh at and you don't really care who wins or loses.

It's really just like have fun, do your best, so you can be kind of facitious in this game and be aggressive and no one really takes it too personally. Um, in Thunder Road Vendetta, you have like a biker gang or a car gang. It's kind of like Mad Max the board game. Uh, we're all just you're shooting each other, you're rolling dice, you it's a dice placement game. So, if you want to learn how to use dice placement, you roll dice and use the numbers as actions you can do. Um, you can definitely get screwed up by having bad rolls, which happens a lot. Kind of like in Quacks where like the nature of there being a random random element to the game. There will be games where you just have very very bad roles the whole time. You kind of just got to accept it. Um, we have Thunder Road. It's a fun time. I would just say remove the Earthquake card cuz the Earthquake card in every single game I've ever played this besides one ends the game immediately. When you play the game, you roll the direction die and everyone moves like two or three spaces in that direction. Typically, everyone ends up either off the map or collide into a wall or exploded and that's just the game and there's only one player left standing and they win. Um, so it's a good time if you like just dice rolling fun times and shooting your your opponents with a little bit of play elimination. Uh, check out Thunderbird Vendetta for sure. Maximum Chrome if you can't even find it. At number 92, we have Stranger Things Upside Down. Uh, this game is another cooperative in this list and yeah, it's another IP game, but I don't care about this IP whatsoever. I actually didn't want to play it because of Stranger Things cuz I very much did not like the first season. I watched the full season to make sure I didn't like it. Um, and this game is a the only pusher cooperative game I've ever played. Uh, if you want to see more information, like a full in-depth analysis of this, we have a before you buy video uh on our channel right now.

But just know that this game's fun. You really you really have to push your luck and you really have to use like uh analytical elements to deduce where the right numbers might be cuz in a stack it could be all zeros or it could be all fives. So maybe you need to drop an average of six to win, but maybe you want to push it with a four and see if you can still beat that um that that area cuz you're using your cards in your hand to attack certain areas. And if you have a lower value, you take fear and a lot of times that causes you to lose the game. The only reason it's on higher on this list is because it takes a long time. Our two-player game of this always takes like 90 minutes to two hours. And that's not even with like a lot of talking. That's what a lot of us try to play the game, get it over with. This game also comes with two chapters cuz you play season one and then you play season two in the back half of the game. I'd be very interested if they do another version of season 3 and four. Again, I don't care about the IP, but I really, really like this game. So, if they make more of this game, I'd like to play this game. I won't probably play it once I beat it again cuz I played we beat the first map. We haven't beat the second map. Even though we came one reveal away from winning, but um once I beat it, I probably won't play it again.

But the fact that it's so difficult, challenging, it makes it very very worthwhile. I like a challenging co-op. And last but not least on this list, we have number 91, Junk Drawer. Junk Drawer is a very rewarding satisfying polyamino a multi- area placement game. So the way it works, everyone has four different quadrants of a 5x5 I believe. And what happens is you flip over a card in the middle of the table and when you flip over the card, everyone grabs a tile of that cuz we all have our own piles. It's a very symmetric game. So it's really about what you do with the tiles versus what your opponents do with the tile. Uh in the middle of the board as well before the set game set up, you also have a scoring objective for every single tile. Uh sometimes it is the biggest group of biggest group of empty spaces in the top left and maybe the right top right one will say the most connected pieces in that area. Maybe the bottom right says whoever has the least amount of uh pieces in this area will get like five points. Maybe the bottom right will say or bottom left to say whoever has the most amount of tiles in here. So it's all about like different scoring objectives and you want to see which one you want to go for the best.

It's about maneuvering uh the spatial reasoning of the tiles you have in play. It's about making sure that you you plan for the future and what might pop up in there. And the fun of it is uh when a when a card is flipped over, you all grab that card or you all grab that tile and you put it somewhere in one of those four areas. And then the next one, you have to make sure to place some of the other three remaining areas and then the other two remaining areas and the other remaining area. And after you do it four times, you then are able to replay it into replay the next tile into any areas. And you just keep that cycle going till one player is not allowed to play a tile. Once they have no space to play the tile whatsoever legally, then the game ends automatically and then you start scoring. And it's a very unique game. The only issue I have with it, and the reason it's not higher, is the fact that it is very replayable. You know, the same thing's happening. You're really just fitting things inside of a junk drawer. You're fitting junk in a junk drawer, which is the way it says.

Um, it's basically, you know, abstract almost. Um, but, you know, it's a good game. I like it a lot. When a game has a very similar like Sudoku, you're just doing the same thing over and over again without any kind of like change in the pace, then I'm less inclined to like it because like it's very kind of bland tasting. Um, but yeah, it's a good game. It's it's a good game. Very good game. That's why it's ranked on this list, you know. That's everything for today. I'll be doing a video of this every single day until all uh 100 games are ranked. So, we have nine more days of this. If you like this video, make sure to like the video, drop a comment below of your favorite games, uh, and subscribe to the channel to see our future videos. Um, we just did a giveaway, uh, of 200 board games. You want to see that, go ahead and go to the channel to watch that right now. But until next time, peace. Have a great day. God, bless. I hope to see you at a table soon.

Progress saved