Q&A Vlog June '19 - Paid vs Unpaid reviews & 5 more questions!
Transcript
welcome to Jung its games in this video I will be covering some questions and answers and specifically I have six questions that were sent in that I'll be covering today now I did talk about potentially doing a live Q&A in the month of June but due to logistics that did not end up happening which is why I'm making this video instead and Before we jump into those questions I would like to mention that well I guess ask that if you enjoy this video you please click the like button for it down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel also if you would like to directly support this channel and the creation of future videos like this one and all the other stuff that I make then please go to junkets Gamescom slash support you'll find a variety of ways with which you can support the channel and there are some pretty cool perks that come along with some of those levels including things like voting on some of the videos that I make each month alright let's now jump into the questions and answers and the first one is probably the biggest and hardest one to answer this one comes in from a cura Sona and they asked what did I think about Rodney's video about paid and unpaid previews and reviews now for context here this person is talking about Rodney Smith who runs the watch it played YouTube channel that specializes in making tutorials or I guess rules videos for for games teaching people how to play games but Rodney also works with BoardGameGeek and makes a variety of vlog style content for the BoardGameGeek youtube channel and one of them is called Table Talk in this series he essentially brings up a topic talks about his opinion and then he asked for people's opinion back and then he makes a follow-up episode called Table Talk back where he discusses those the feedback that he got about that one specific thing now he did one of these Table Talk and Table Talk back things
for the idea of paid reviews in board-gaming that went on a few weeks ago and I think the reasons body made that is because well this keeps coming up and up over again in various social medias like Twitter and reddit and whatnot where people get very concerned about this idea that certain people are being paid to make subjective review content for board games and it's definitely a wide topic but specifically what Rodney was talking about in this video had to do with the kind of the general things like you know the ethics of being paid to give an opinion and you know are people going to skew their opinion that they talk about because they won't they were getting paid or because they want to get paid more in the future but then Rodney also brought up an interesting point that does not get talked very much and he really focused in on well is it a problem that people are expected to take no money at all for making review content for subjective review content for board games everybody else within the board gaming ecosphere gets paid for the work that they do and making reviews is work it takes a lot of time so why do we expect that those people are going to be doing all of that work for free now this is there's there's definitely some angles to this I think essentially everyone who starts making board game reviews does it as a passion project as a hobby on the side that they're probably not even expecting will turn into a cash flow thing for them at all I know that's where I started doing this a little over five years ago I began by just making reviews because I was bored and I had time and I like to talk about board games and I think that probably aligns with almost everyone who starts
making reviews now at a certain point if you really get into making reviews which I did for a long time I know I don't make reviews anymore but um if you really get into the stuff you start to say well you know I'm foregoing doing other things to actually make this content like maybe fun things or maybe even work things maybe I'm taking time off work to make this content because making board game media content specifically video content takes a lot of time you know just the act of playing the games enough time to review them actually filming and coming up with scripts and all that takes a lot of time editing takes time even once you have published this video people comment and then it takes time to come back and respond to those comments like there's just a huge time commitment when it comes into this whole video thing that so many people so many of us are doing and so there's this the ronny was bringing up this question like you know why do we expect the certain subset of people spending all of this time making very important content to consumers why do we expect them to not make any money now obviously you know you can he didn't really have a solution to that he was just posing the question and I guess from my perspective obviously if you are just a pure hobbyist and whatnot then you know that's fine like this is something of a way that you want to enjoy spending your time you make you enjoy doing this kind of thing but if you really want to take this stuff more seriously and make a lot more of it then I feel like compensation makes sense you know I started a patreon campaign after I can't remove the specifics but it was like maybe two two and a half years or something like that into making my junkies games channel which was much focused on making reviews way back at that point and so my feeling was well
hopefully people will enjoy my content enough to support the patreon campaign and that will keep me going to make it make sense for me to spend all of this extra time in my life to keep making this stuff so that people get it you know it's a back scratching type of thing like you pay me I keep making this thing that makes you happy hey look everybody's happy now I guess the issue with this with patreon specifically is that well it's not a gigantic platform at this point and it's been growing over the years and a couple people have been able to make a solid living off of it and obviously for me my patreon campaign has gotten to the point where it's been just a little over a thousand dollars a month which seems like a lot of money until you realize that this is a very big professional endeavor for me now and I'm you know I'm only working a couple days a week at my old job which used to be my full-time job and anyway long story short what I'm trying to say is it's very hard to make these campaigns work pretty much everyone who starts these maybe gets an initial bump and then it kind of stays there maybe it goes a little bit oftentimes it goes a little bit down and it for pretty much everyone who's trying to make this into like a professional endeavor they're not making enough money to really make it actually a legit professional endeavor now a lot of people a lot of content creators have used Kickstarter in the past to try and run annual Kickstarter campaigns or even a six month chunk Kickstarter campaigns to keep things going but then a lot of them actually get promo content from publishers for free that they then essentially sell as options for the Kickstarter essentially like you know donate to me and I'll give you this perk with this promo but then you found yourself coming post full circle back because that publisher gave that reviewer something for free that that
reviewers then going to sell for money so they're kind of giving compensation there and then the whole thing comes back into play like oh well are they're just gonna say favorable things about that specific company's products because that specific company is giving them free promo content which they can then monetize so it's just sticky and I think that's the reason why many content creators don't do the Kickstarter route or some like my friends over the no pun included a YouTube channel think they do a Kickstarter and they don't sell any promos like everything that they give as items are just things that are just within their house you know like just within their content that they specifically make so they are isolated from that question of you know ethics in some subjectivity they're very rare most people seem to do promos my not so I guess I'm talking a lot about this there's a lot to say and it's hard to be really focused on it but to me I guess I'm saying that the issue here is that board-gaming maybe as a overall hobby is just not big enough to support people in this way like through patreon and whatnot like you know many people need to have getting a lot more than $500 or $1,000 a month and in order to do this kind of stuff full-time and many of them are trying to make that happen and then they burn out and then they stop making content and then everybody loses because that person had a dream that dream failed because they burned out and then everybody else to enjoy that content well they don't get the content anymore because that person you know they burned out they're not making this stuff anymore and so lose-lose situation so I guess I don't know this is kind of a way of saying if you want to support these people and if they have specifically even patreon campaigns or you know Kickstarter's support those as well but but specifically patreon campaigns which are a way to directly support people trying
to make fully subjective content and not being attached to to publishers then then give them a little bit of money you know if you're gonna be spending $100 a year on board games or a couple hundred dollars a year on board games then you know I like to think that it makes sense to throw one two five to ten dollars or whatever to people whose opinions you really value because of the amount of time they put into it so I guess I found myself over here in the conversation asking for support again but realistically I'm saying I'm asking for your support of everyone who's making YouTube or not even just YouTube just like general purpose board game content you know there's people who do photography there's people who do rules there's people who do so many different things that do not get maybe the kind of financial support that we all feel like maybe they should but then again I'm within the echo chamber of people who make all of this stuff so yeah I guess to kind of bring this thing full circle that's that's my my opinion specifically about the question that Rodney posed about whether it's a good thing or not to actually expect reviewers to not be making any money and I think to briefly glance over at the general issue of paid content I think as long as you are fully transparent about being paid it pretty much doesn't matter what kind of content you're making I'm sure there's some side edge case where it would matter but in general even if you are being paid to make boardgame content that is subjective where you're giving your opinion to say I like this I don't like that and you're being paid by the publisher who gave that to you I personally think that's okay as long as it's very clear that you were paid for that content as long as
it's on screen as it's in the description you click the little button within a YouTube UI that pops up a thing that said this includes pay promotion I think that's fine just be transparent make the content that you want to make and as long as people don't feel like they're being duped I think that's fine and if people have a problem of that they can you know just watch other content there's so many people making boardgame YouTube content that you can very easily hone in and consume the stuff that you like but I guess to bring back what I said before if you've honed in on the people that are making stuff that you like then support those people and that is the best way to get around this kind of conundrum of you know people being paid to make boardgame content I think pretty much everyone would prefer to be paid specifically by the people who enjoy the content versus the people who make the games that actually make the content you know if I was making enough money on patreon to fully make all the stuff makes sense then I would seriously consider not making any sponsored content with publishers at all because that would be a much easier delineation to go and I would have to find myself not trying to you know go out and like kind of sell my stuff to publishers obviously the stuff that I get paid to make is all completely objective like I don't give my opinion about any of these games or if I do in like an oppression vlog I always mention I'm about to tell you what I think about this game but I was paid to make a playthrough for it because I tried to aim for as much transparency as possible either way I think I should probably wrap up this gigantic topic from this very small question thank you for sending it in and I'm curious to hear your opinion if you have any thoughts about what I'm saying here if you think I'm wrong I'd love to hear why and I should definitely stop talking about this question so
let's now move on to the second question this one comes from Brian Brazil and they asked what are your thoughts on trick-taking games what are some of your favorites he says that as favorite is wizard which is a pretty straightforward but to them it's hard to beat now the idea of trick-taking games as just a mechanic from my personal perspective as not an expert trick-taking person is this is a style of game of a card game where in general you are going to play a single card in player order and then once everybody has played a single car you check to see who played the best card for that given setting I think very simple ones essentially just use like a standard 52 deck of cards usually in trick taking games there is a trump suit which is better than all of the other suits and if somebody plays the Trump suit then other people oftentimes have to play a card that matches that same suit there are so many different tricks making games but in general that's the kind of environment that trick-taking as a mechanic I think lives now for my personal perspective I have not played that many trick-taking games kind of think about them off the top of my head I did not do my research beforehand to see exactly which ones I have but you know there are some basic trick taking games to certain extent I think you could probably say that like hearts is a trick-taking game spades that's another one of those kind of basic ones I played moon which came out or moons came out a couple years ago which was a trick-taking game with like asteroids and moons and all that kind of stuff and honestly I can't really speak to it a whole lot more than that oh I played bridge once bridge is a very but one of
the more complicated trick-taking games and I at one point somebody who's really into bridge and in a within our board gaming group this is like nine years ago I said they wanted to teach a bunch of people he made a flyer and he's like okay next Thursday it's Bridge night and I'm gonna teach all of you guys how to play bridge you're all gonna fall in love with bridge because I love bridge and so I went to it and he taught like alan i probably eight to ten of us and we played through about a full game and i think my perspective was similar to pretty much everyone else where we were like okay that was interesting but oh my gosh she's just such an overwhelming amount of subtle communication all these kind of like rules that that come into play with how you're communicating various things it seems like there's a lot of crazy depth there but i never found myself coming back to it now at this point i feel like i should briefly mention the fact that I've played teach you well over a hundred times and if you're familiar with teach you and trick taking games you might already be yelling at your screen saying teacher is not a trick-taking game John that is a climbing game now a big difference between those two mechanics as best as I know is that the intrigue taking games you're normally just playing a single card trying to make the best the best single card for that given moment even if you were trying to dump a card that you don't want to be in a strong position later whereas climbing games in general involve playing most cards into an overall trick you could call just like an overall round teach you lets you play like a pair or like a full house or consecutive pairs or even big straights and that kind of thing now in trick taking games it's very much about trying to win tricks and many games actually involve bidding where you say I'm gonna win a specific number of
tricks like three so if you win four tricks that's actually a bad thing whereas a game like teach you is a climbing game and a card shedding game or you're just trying to get rid of your cards in general as quickly as possible so the reason I'm bringing up teach you is because I have played that game over a hundred times and in general teacher takes between 60 and 90 minutes to play depending on how crazy things can get so that's a pretty big life commitment that I put in to teach you and I love teaching so I think from my perspective my answer to this question a very long-winded way of getting back to it is that I think I prefer climbing style games specifically I just really love teach you and I think because we got so into teach you in my overall gaming group we never really delve much into treating games oh I just remembered I have played euchre a few times and I could really quite enjoyed that one that's a very lightweight trick-taking game in fact it only uses I believe 9 10 Jack Queen King ace don't get mad if I'm wrong it's it I think it just uses those specific cards so it's a very small deck and it's a pretty lightweight trick-taking game that I really enjoyed I can't remember any of the rules anymore this is like seven years ago I played it at a camping trip and we probably played it like seven or eight times throughout that camping trip and I had a really good time with it so I would not mind playing euchre again I think because the complexity of the communication and all that is very low it's very simple streamlined game that I did enjoy but so I guess euchre is probably the trick taking game that I've actually enjoyed the most now that I've remembered that I played that one a bunch and I hope that answers your question Brian alright next up we have question number three and this one also comes in from Brian Brazil and they asked have you ever built a print and
play game or extra content for a game that you have if not do you have any inclination to do so they say that they have made tons of prints and play games and fan made content for games they already own and there are some really quality fan made components and expansions from published games that are really worth the effort now my quick answer to this is no not really I have not done that that much print and play creation pretty much all of the print play stuff that I have done has either been because I have done a little bit of development work for publishers so obviously they sent me the files I printed up and I do a little bit of playing with it for a development perspective and then I have done a couple print and plays actually for my youtube channel for playthroughs specifically I remember when I did a playthrough four tiny epic Western I was I had a light week at my old job this is long before I was doing this professionally and I was like what game am I gonna film this week I should do a playthrough for you know what's hot right now and then I looked over and I saw that tiny epic western had just gone on to Kickstarter like two days before so I was like people like tiny Epic Games I should make a video for that so that one cool thing about gameland games that do these tiny epic games is they I think still but they certainly used to put up the full print play files for games that went up on Kickstarter so I printed it out and I filmed a full thing and actually sent it to the publisher and I said did I make any mistakes you know please let me know before I publish this thing and they were they really liked it and they ended up putting that video on the Kickstarter page and that's actually the reason I've made so many videos for tiny epic games since then because they're so impressed by that video that I made for tenía my question
which was kind of on my own now part of that is because I was intrigued I had really enjoyed tiny epic galaxies before that so I believe tiny epic question was the next one to come out there so I was curious to see how the game played and it also seemed to make sense to make that print play for content for the YouTube channel now as far as print and play content for other stuff it sounds weird to say but most of the print play stuff that I've done has been English translations for games that I have imported from Europe and so I guess that's kind of like components you know the rules are components and you know play raids and stuff like that because some of the games that I just cannot wait until they get English printing swirl you know by um six or nine or months or a year beforehand you know get them and they'll have cards with print with text on them and that's in the wrong language and then have Rubik that don't make sense so I spent a not unreasonable amount of time trying to print out some nice quality rule books from translations that I found on BoardGameGeek and then sometimes even paste ups which I've like you know slipped into sleeves with the wrong language cards and all that kind of stuff so I guess the the short answer not that I really know how to do short answers the short I haven't really done much as far as print play for extra content but I've done a decent amount of customizing to make games a little bit easier to play if they're the wrong language and of course a little bit of content for the YouTube channel so that's kind of been my overall focus I suppose I have been falling plummeting down the rabbit hole of board game passion and obsession for well I guess about 11 years now and because of that and because you know
especially in my old job I had a decent enough income to be able to afford to buy board games and also I didn't really have any other hobbies there really spent money I've always had enough games around me so I haven't needed to spend much time and attention to print and play content when there's been so many fully published games that I have been around even long before I was even starting to think about making a YouTube channel alright let's now move on to the fourth question and in fact the fourth fifth and sixth questions all came from Matthias Whitlock now the fourth question they asked is kind of a general one they said how are you doing is the stress manageable and are you getting some downtime now I'm pretty sure Matthias is talking about the fact that in a couple of the variety vlogs that I put out specifically one about a month ago and then you know another one that was happened a few months before that I talked about the general struggles of making YouTube content and you know keeping motivation up to you know be spending all this work how it can be kind of lonesome and it can be sometimes not as rewarding as I want and so I think that's kind of where Mattias is coming here and I'd say how am i doing well I'm doing pretty good I think that's that vlog that I posted about the struggles you know about six months six weeks ago or so connected with a lot more people than I expected and I know I talked about that and another vlog that I made after that another update vlog but I can say that the month of June has been pretty hectic I thought I was planning ahead well enough I knew I was going to origins which was gonna take a week so I tried to get videos done enough to kind of patch some holes but then some some of the copies of games kind of came in late so I found myself just doing so a bunch of last-minute
rush rush rush super stressful content creation before I jumped on a plane to go to Columbus and then I got back from origins and immediately got really sick like a legit flu for a couple days I was hovering at around one hundred and 2.5 degrees and I was just miserable and if I'm being honest maybe you've noticed in my voice maybe you haven't well that was two and half weeks ago and I'm still struggling with a cough I have had to do a lot of retakes even within this QA vlog that we are watching right now because I start coughing and it was two and a half freakin weeks ago that I got sick so that's been a bit frustrating I guess I'm doing okay overall but there's been a little bit more stress over the last four weeks than I expected and a big part of that has to do with well going away for a week getting sick and then getting just barely well enough to film two last-minute videos to match up for some commitments that I made it just it's been a bit crazy and looking forward to July I have quite a bit of content to make out here as well and I don't think it's gonna be as crazy and I've been doing a reasonably good job of forcing myself to take two days off a week that was I think another thing that mattias has been talking about here is you know that I've talked about how I've accidentally gone like a year and a half of working six days a week and I'm trying to maybe just work five days a week and I've done a moderately okay job of that and I'm trying to make that happen go forward going forward this week in particular I took Monday off to play a ton of new games I played five new games so that I can cover those in my impressions vlog which is kind of like work but also I like playing games so that kind of counted that as a bit of a day off so in general I think things have been doing going a little bit
better incrementally and I'm you know definitely not actively burning out right now I'm just trying to continue to navigate all of the stuff and I'm gonna do a variety vlog next week and I'll probably discuss some of the stuff again right there so either way let's now move on to the next question from Matthias and they asked that with all of the games that I add to my watch list on bgg how do I keep track of why I'm watching them now what Matthias is talking about here is that about I don't know eight months ago or so I started doing a segment within my variety vlogs which I'm now going to be splitting off into its own vlog where I talk about the new games that I've learned about and the way I track these is I click the subscribe button on BoardGameGeek for all of those new games now I have been doing that for about a decade but specifically about eight months ago I got a little bit more concerned about it I figured out how to get the RSS feed to find every single new game that got added into BoardGameGeek and now I'm paying attention to that RSS feed to be much more proactive with trying to learn about these games now the short answer to Mattias is question here of how do I track of why I'm paying attention to these is I don't really have a good way of doing that yet and I don't really i subscribe to so many games because i'm interested in learning a little bit more about them and then i might talk about them and you know one of these vlogs where I talk about the new games I learn about and then maybe a month or two goes by and my subscription feed a game will pop up and I'll be like what is that I have no recollection of that I'll click on it and I'll read through the description I'll be like that's right now I remember why I'm paying attention to this so I suppose the answer to your question is the way I keep track of it is I forget and then when I become curious about what this random thing is
on my subscription feed I once again to read the description to learn about it again I'm sure there's probably a better way to do that maybe I'm subscribing to too many games but you know there's so much interesting stuff that comes out and I'm I'm actively always interested in learning more about them so I kind of can't help myself from clicking to subscribe on many games that honestly I have no intention of ever playing I'm just like for one reason or another there may be the mechanics or the designer or the theme I'm like I want to learn a little bit more I want to see some photos of that and then you know three months later when the photos start rolling out I'm like what the heck is this and why do I care so yeah I'm still figuring that one out Mattias alright let's now move on to the last question from Mattias and of the vlog and this one they asked how does my game selection work when I'm presented with a brand new big collection like if I'm going to a new board game cafe to myself or like a convention like maybe BoardGameGeek on well I think the way I usually approach these things is I take some time to absorb the collection I mean I like I imagine many people who are really into board games kind of can't help but get drawn like a moth to a flame when it comes to a new collection like if I go to a friend's house that I haven't been to before or a new friend or something like that and they have a collection the first beeline right over to the collection then I just read the whole thing and you know just like oh wow you have this so that's rare and why do you have this over this and I used to own that and oh I have this like it just you know sparks conversations in my head and then out of my mouth where I'd talk with these things but the people who own them so I guess when it comes to cafe is obviously the cafe overall owns it but in general I just I just look at the whole collection and sometimes it takes
a while I can tell you that at BoardGameGeek on which I've now gone to for the last five years they've got a immense collection I don't actually know the specific number but it wraps around this and tired gigantic room and whenever I go to that convention the first thing I do is I look to the new game section although if I'm being honest I have already looked at that section because board game eco is posts a list of all of the games that will be in the new game selection and in fact they have a list of all of the games they have in their broader selection but that's a bit crazy so I'll just scan through and look at all of those and then I usually also scan through the greater collection just kind of looking for things that jump out to me one thing I do try to do I've not done a very good job of it lately but one thing I try to do is I try to keep a list of new games that come out that I'm interested in playing that I don't have easy access to so that by the time I get over to like BoardGameGeek on in November I have a list of games where I'm like these are all the games that I have wanted to play but I've missed because I don't know the publisher didn't send me a copy nobody I know actually owns it and I try to build out those lists before I actually go to these things and fortunately specifically for BoardGameGeek con I can check my list to the online list of the games that they hypothetically have although sometimes it's actually kind of hard to find them so the short answer is whenever I find myself faced with a new gigantic collection I just get really giddy and I just look through all of it and I just see if anything really jumps out to me often times you know I've been doing this long enough that often times I'll see a game and and it'll jump out to me and I'm not even sure why and I'll baby got my phone and I'll punch it in and be like oh that's right that's this and that and you know it'll it'll jump
me into the memory track to remember all of the reasons I was interested in trying that one specific game so I hope that's been a decent answer to your question specifically that question and all of these I feel like I've been somewhat rambly today but I guess I have a lot to say when it comes to board games in general and yeah I'm not sure if I'm gonna be doing more of these pre-recorded questions and answers' vlogs into the future part of me would really like to try and do a live Q&A in July but there are also some pretty wacko logistical things happening in July so it's something I'm hoping to make happen I've only done a live Q&A once and it was like almost two years ago or so and so I'm not exactly super familiar with the technology and everything that you have to do so I'm not feeling super-confident to just jump on but I should probably try to make it happen I'm certainly gonna try to make it happen within the next couple months if it doesn't happen to in July and I think at this point I can bring this one to a close