Designing Board Games Which Break the Rules
Transcript
the year was 1966 Johnny Carson was bringing in an average of 12 million viewers for his late night talk show on the 3rd of May Carson's guest on The Tonight Show was Eva Gabor star of popular American sitcom Green Acres this Edition one of 4,500 with Carson as host was memorable for one particular segment Carson Gabor and the entire studio audience falling about laughing as they played a board game the game was twisted and the image of the beautiful Gabor in full evening attire contorting herself around the popular TV host caught the attention of the millions watching even at the peak of The Swinging 60s conservative values from earlier decades lingered glamorous television stars didn't usually Cort with each other on mainstream TV it just wasn't the done thing but far from complaining the viewers flocked to toy stores to buy their own copies of the game the day after the show aired New York's FAO Schwarz reported a deluge of customers at their famous store other TV shows ran similar promotional spots and publisher Milton Bradley started running newspaper ads for The Sensational new party game seen by Millions on TV Twister's critics labeled the game disparagingly as sex in a box an unofficial tagline which only worked in the game's favor as twister became the party game of the 60s a staple at college parties and kids parties alike 12 month later Milton Bradley had sold
over 3 million copies and 50 years on twister has sold many many more Millions than that the game was developed from a very simple premise designers Ruben Foley and Gaia set about creating a game where the players constitute the game pieces one of the best hooks in the history of the industry I'm Adam Porter I'm a game designer from the UK and on this channel I discuss board games from the perspective of a Creator often with a focus on games as products so if you like what I do please leave me a comment four decades after Milton Bradley made a selling point of breaking societal rules another group of designers used exactly the same strategy in their new party game except in 2011 Society was considerably more liberal than it was in 1966 and if you wanted the shock Factor you needed to go a lot further than giggling over fully clothed adults rubbing up against each other and Cards Against Humanity was the party game where players get to say the unsayable another incredible Hook once again it was showcased on American talk shows notably The Ellen De janiro show and it sold an absolute ton I noticed a shift somewhere between 2011 and 2015 when I told people I like to play board games no longer did they ask me what like Monopoly now they were asking me what Like Cards Against Humanity there's something extremely powerful about
allowing players to do stuff which is usually forbidden 3 years after he launched twister rain guia introduced his new product the Nerf ball with the slogan throw it indoors you can't damage lamps or break Windows you can't hurt babies or old people these days the Nerf range of phone-based Weaponry brings in hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue for Hasbro but the core concept is not a million miles from Twisters when Society says You must not throw stuff indoors our product lets you do exactly that on this channel I repeatedly come back to the topic of hooks in game design now a hook is the aspect of a game which draws people in piques their interest and motivates them to stick around to learn more it's often said that if you cannot describe your concept for a product in under 30 seconds it's too complex or obscure game Publishers retailers and most importantly players look for hooks when de deciding which games deserve their attention and it turns out breaking the rules is a very strong hook indeed so twister was certainly not the first game to take this approach Hasbro has another massive selling taboo breaker in its Arsenal one that predates twister by 80 years the Ouija board appears to have emerged from American spiritualist camps in the 1880s Baltimore based entrepreneur Charles Kennard patented the talking board as a toy game and built a company off of it the product
occupied a strange space appealing to a family audience as a fun parlor game but also invoking the supernatural the game's popularity surged throughout the two world wars and when the Ouija board finally landed in the Parker Brothers stable in 1967 one year after twister found massive success with competitors Milton Bradley the Ouija board sold 2 million copies in a single year out selling Monopoly in 1973 the Ouija board's reputation was forever changed when it was featured in the film The Exorcist as the conduit by which a demon possessed a child religious groups denounced the game as a tool of Satan and it became a forbidden fruit Parker Brothers and later Hasbro continued to sell hundreds of thousands of units each year but the audience was different darker more edgy in the decade following card against Humanity's enormous success there have been countless similarly purle vulgar games released often using the acronym NSFW or not safe for work these games have seen diminishing returns for their creators presumably because once a taboo has been broken you can't really do it again because the taboo no longer really exists qua Nerf and the Ouija board were extremely strong products because they allowed players to do forbidden things Cards Against Humanity allows players to say forbidden things and that's the hook and it's the same hook for all the other games in the genre just presented in slightly different packaging now I must
admit Cards Against Humanity is not to my taste at all but I can't deny it strength as a product it's the reason that every popular party game now has to have an after Dark Edition in the UK right now there's a TV show taking the country by storm a TV show where members of the public compete for a large sum of money by accusing lying betraying and eliminating each other the traitors is all but identical to the public domain game werewolf also known as Mafia Which is popular in board game circles the TV show is compelling to watch because the contestants are permitted to behave awfully to backstab each other gleefully to manipulate and deceive it's a safe space to indulge some of the darker aspects of human interaction and of course if it's compelling to watch it's even more compelling to play social deduction games flooded the market a decade ago following the success of da sces the resistance a reworking of the mafia system without the need for a non-player to act as Arbiter similarly to the many NSFW games which followed Cards Against Humanity few of the social deduction games which followed the resistance achieved the same notoriety the taboo had already been broken a game existed which allowed you to team up and make wild accusations against your friends without falling out and that's a great hook big potatoes don't get got goes for a similar premise with players attempted to complete silly secret missions without their opponents
noticing the difference with this game is that it runs in the background of any social event missions include things like getting someone to compliment your hair or making up a word and getting another player to ask what it means basically being sneaky children love to break rules so taboo breaking is a strong hook to pursue when designing for that audience cockroach poker is a game which encourages families to lie to each other while trying to keep a poker face cheating goth is a game where players try to rid their hands of cards by placing them legitimately onto a central Pile in numerical order but players are allowed to cheat dropping or hiding cards and accuse each other of cheating if they catch someone in the ACT I think there's still some design space to explore here it's a great hook the game where you get to cheat and as fun as cheating moth is it hasn't achieved twister or Cards Against Humanity levels of success Hasbro clearly sees the potential in this too as indicating by their release of Monopoly cheatah Edition in 2018 the kids game shelf in Mass Market stores have been filled with games about dog poo bogeys and farts for years now as with the NSFW games for adults it's a Deo which has long since been broken and now feels a bit tired the kids really still feel naughty picking up a game centered around bodily functions or has it become normalized and strategic games are playing with alternative themes too the success of the the villainous Series in all its incarnations Disney Marvel Star Wars
demonstrates how badly people want to play the bad guy I think pushing boundaries is a challenging area for game designers but a potentially very fruitful design space to explore what boundaries are left in 2024 which haven't yet been broken clearly there are many things that we cannot and would never want to represent or endorse in board game form but are there any activities which sit just on the cusp of acceptability safe enough not to get us arrested or cause any harm but risque a enough to generate a frison of nervous excitement Rob davio presented one such gamery answer with a game where you rip up cards and write on the board an act which prior to 2011 would have been Unthinkable to board game enthusiasts Risk Legacy introduced a new genre of games several of which were extraordinarily successful the hook for the Legacy system is a game where you you permanently alter the game as you play but the strength of these products is that the Legacy aspect is a secondary hook most of these games have a really solid game at their core with its own hook its own appeal pandemic Clank Ticket to Ride these are strong systems in their own right so my challenge to you game designers watching this video is to identify something in life which we'd like to do but we're not really allowed something naughty but not harmful and package it capture it in board game form allow your players to be
bad to be the antihero there's a market for that