Skip to main content
Loading video...

Marty's Musings - LCGs vs Other Card Game Expansions

Transcript 5:21

on the June thirtieth 2015 edition of board game breakfast Chaz marler of paradise paradise was asked this question from a viewer many card games like Dominion or Dixit have expansions but aren't called a living or expendable card game I can't figure out why do you know why this is perhaps it could be a topic for head in the clouds my first thought is why is he trying to sound like a Bond villain my second thought is where can I get a sweet khaki vest my third thought is I wonder what he thought about this other topic a three-minute diatribe on thrift stores that shrink wrapped their used board games but my for thought was I can't wait to hear how chess answers these questions about Elsie jeez and what I thought Chaz did a good job of answering the question I think there are a couple more key points that could be made and it's those additional points I'll share with you in this installment of marty's musings

living card games are expandable car games are games such as netrunner Warhammer 40k conquest Lord of the Rings dune town and ash's these are constructible deck building games that are received lots of popularity over the past several years so what is the first distinction Chazz gives when comparing these games two expansions of Dixit or dominion fix it for example it's primarily marketed as a party game and while several additional card sets have been released for it you know those new cards don't introduce new mechanisms or rules instead they just add more interesting pictures to the game in order to increase its replayability Chazz makes a valid point dixit expansions provide additional cards to use the base game that really doesn't modify gameplay meanwhile LC GS are meant to provide new mechanics and new types of cards to expand upon its core game when comparing LC G's to dominion expansions Chazz says this and even though like an expandable card game Dominion has had multiple expansions those expenses have been staggered out over the course of six years by comparison expansions for living and expandable card games typically include fewer cards and are released more frequently such as quarterly or even monthly again very true lcg expansions tend to come out every six to eight weeks meanwhile dominion expansions come

out maybe once or twice a year however I think there are a few more key points that distinguish LC GS and other card game expansions first and foremost LC GS are a variant of collectible card games they have regular expansions and beg building mechanics like CCGs but they do not have the blind by business model C ccg booster packs are randomized with various scarcity of cards included meanwhile LCG expansions have fixed cards in them you know exactly what you're getting and typically you only have to buy one of them another distinction between LC GS and games such as the men and is that the cards and the expansions for games like Dominion are used by all players so for example there's a common market or new mechanics that everyone gets to take advantage of in LC geez expansions are used to modify your own deck there are something that will be shared by other players in fact other players don't even need to buy that expansion to play with you and for me that really is the main distinction which goes back to the fact that LC gs-r CCGs with fixed expansions and CCGs are all about building tweaking and modifying your gameplay experience before you ever get to the table and independent of what other players are going to do with their decks so a big thanks to Chazz for letting me ride his coattails on this subject you're welcome Marty anytime okay that's just creepy yes yes it is

oh oh and let's get back to the shrink-wrap issue I got more examples of that okay your game of the state's completely shrink-wrapped from my local thrift store how am I supposed to be able to tell what state this game is in hmm I can't ah it's frustrating Oh worse yet though glad this Harry Potter game supposedly comes with these really cool little wizard's hat you can't tell though because the glare from the shrink wrap on it you have to be a wizard or something to tell what's inside of this box oh oh then there is the whale game which i'd love to see what's in here but whale game oh even worse than the shrink-wrap though is the packing tape they've started to actually put packet pit hey wait where you going I'm not done with my rat got ahold like nine puns about packing tape can I at least have a moon pie

Progress saved