Top 10 Euro Games for 4 Players
Transcript
hi everyone I'm L Hector this is the broken me a show where I devote my time to ranting and raving about board games but usually more the ranting part we'll get on with the show in just a second but first my sponsor would like a quick word as Gamers we find it hard to deal with empty shelves some worse than others you therefore want the supplier that has what you need at affordable prices and delivers on time for me that supplier is Kender they offer a discount on bulk purchases as well as a point scheme for future Acquisitions down the line if there's a hot title you're after chances are Kendra's got it Wings man mine Arc no mine Eclipse actually hate that game it's terrible but you might like it if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get 5% discount on your first order over £60 so let's make gaps in your collection a ft of the past get down to Kender and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it we're overdue for a top 10 list aren't we yes I spent all this time with a bunch of reviews from Essen a bunch of reviews following Essen some recent releases like crazy you know fin span and everything else and then also the top 50 so a lot has been taking up my time and we haven't really sat down and just done an ordinary top 10 list well there's a few top 10 lists I think I need to you know update as time has gone by we'll see if we can get round to those in the next few months but uh this is one that i' been wanting to do for a while because I have talked about different versions of this at other times but no one's really sat down that often to deal with this particular account CU I usually say that free players is the sweet spot for any Euro game it's the good mix of having a
little bit of interaction with other players but the game not taking forever because you got to wait for more people to take their turns and five players well that's just a nightmare when it comes to most Euro games so I've done a list on that I think ages ago in the past you know what games were I play with five to do what games I'd play with free would just literally be about everything in existence cuz free is typically the Fantastic player count but four is typically a good player count usually but most of the time four just ends up Crossing that line with oh yeah you know it it's great but I'd rather play it with free and as long as that is the case then I'd rather play it with free rather than four because four tends to add more length to the game and not much else on top four sh th not count neither count out too so that's what this list is about these are Euro games specifically Euro games we're not dealing with co-ops we're not dealing with social deduction or anything like that you know we are dealing pure normal Euro games that we' that we used to that I would rather played with four players out of all the player accounts and trust me this list was that easy I tried to come up with a list and there was some which are like oh yeah definitely definitely definitely what the hell do I do with the rest it's like it really was quite tough hello hello anybody home and I've got 10 games that fit here but when I thought about all the games in my collection and other games I'd like to play I'm like free free free free free free free it just became problematic trying to think of some that are like yeah do I prefer this with four I like
it with four but then I rather to have it with three and it's like ah it's surprisingly very difficult and believe me I'll be very interested to hear your comments at the end of this as to which games you find that are great with four over all the other player accounts aren't on this list and there are some on here that some of you have got to agree with like hands down I don't expect this one to be a particularly controversial list but I'll be interested to know your thoughts so without further Ado let's tackle into one of the hardest lists I've had to do in recent years top 10 games for four players yes get over it so for my number 10 I can actually show you in this case I'm not going to get out every game for all of these it's just when I need to illustrate a point but this is essentially a side effect to carcassone you know carcassone is no longer in the collection and I've now got something called small Islands which I like to play instead but this is kind of like a spin-off from that whole T and create a little map in front of you but with an element of bidding with other players and this is a of sky from Chief the king and the primary reason for this comes sort of in twofold firstly the the player scaling with this dictates the length of the game and how many rounds you have but also you've got this big phase where you put out tiles in front of you with a certain amount of money on which is how much money you want other people to pay you for the tile and you got to think well I want to sell this tile but I want people to actually not be put off with the market but then there might be a tile that you really want to keep but you need to put some money on it so you price it really high and the idea with this is that there's
two things that come from playing it with different players because you can technically play this with up to five players and I do not recommend five firstly the round amount you get six rounds in a in a two to four player game so you've got different scoring as each round goes on so a then B then A and C then B and D then DAC and then DBC you know they they spread out quite nicely and six rounds allows you to get quite a bit done soon as you play with five players though you lose a round and some stuff scores like quicker than it should do the problem is some of these objectives are not easy to score in your game they're better for later and so you end up wasting some of those objectives and even when you do have one round knocked off five players does take a while to get through that bidding phase I find so I much rather go through six rounds with four or less players then go through five rounds with five on top of that you've also got the bidding phase itself you put out two tiles in front of you and one you chop off well if you get to five players you have more tiles out great but maybe just too many maybe a few too many for you to look at but with four you get quite a nice amount of tiles and you can easily kind of see which tiles are out but when you play with less players there's not as many tiles to pick from I mean if you play with two there's very few Tiles at all but if you play with threee you've only got really four tiles to look at and they could just all be garbage at least with four of you you get a reasonable amount out there so it's those couple of reasons I just find a of Sky I think works best at for I mean I will play it
with three players and if I must I'll play it with five but honestly if I've got four and we just need something light that's into tole Lane I'll probably try and pull this one out it varies from moment to moment for my number nine this is basically down to player scaling in terms of the worker placement aspect of it this is one of the few games from stonem that I actually still give a decent amount of Buzz to because it is still in my collection and still going strong I'm not going to get it out specifically but it is vidic culture VI culture I think works best at four now yes the game takes a little bit less time with free but a lot of it is down to the way the board scale because it's worker placement you put workers out on the table and there were so many spaces for everybody but it goes in sets of two so you've got first you've got solo and two player and then you've got a new set for three and four and then you got a new set for five and six in terms of how many spaces open up and the problem I find is that if you play with three rather than four it's a little bit too easy to go to the spaces you want I think four is a really good number for having a decent amount of tension for those spaces particularly with the Tuscany board that has the different seasons it's kind of less apparent when you play with just a base set but with the Tuscany improved board four players is very tight and very cool so you're probably thinking well why don't you just play with six then because six players is ridiculous you want to ever finish this wretched game okay you know
five and six is too many players I don't like playing it with that and the thing is if you go up to five all you're doing is extending the length for the game and freeing up the spaces because as soon as you go to the next bracket you have more spaces than you need for the number of players it's the same with free you know you have the same amount of spaces available with four as you do with threee so free just makes for a much more free roaming game whereas four keeps it a bit more Tighter and I think the balance with this one is definitely keyed into to four players I just think that's a really good number to play it with and I will play it with free this is not to say that four is the only count but yeah you're going to be hard pressed make me want to play this with five or six it's definitely not a count I like haven't even really played it Solo in a while you know VI culture has gone down in my list over time but as a three to four player game I still really enjoy it and at four I think for work and placement scaling it is the best at that count and everyone's ttty much brly fit
Chas number eight isn't even in my collection I like the game and I respect it but when I considered this list I thought well I can't just go with games that are in my collection all the time there has to be some exceptions to the rule but it also depends on how much I enjoy the game I mean there are some games that are going to be prevalent at four players and I will mention them in honorable mentions but they're none on my list because I don't enjoy them as much this one I didn't keep in my collection but I still like it it's a pure abstract strategy game but if you play it with less than four players it just isn't quite as cool as uh you know you don't butt heads as often and that is tigress and Euphrates or you can have yellow and Yanks whatever pick your poison they're both pretty much the same game but with tigers and Euphrates you've got the same layout on the board no matter how many players you have so if you have two players you just kind of at opposite ends and you do your own thing and eventually your buttheads three you might have two people going up against each other and one gets left out four is perfect for tigers and new fredes you know you are all on this map multiple players will butt heads possibly even free at once and it makes for a tighter board where people have to start butting heads you know you you kind of feel like you can sit in your own corner with less players and it's not anywhere near as fun this is probably going to be one of the least controversial picks on this list I think everybody who's a Tigers and eup fres fan is always into four players you know nothing John snow when I had this game in my collection I only wanted to bring
it out with four I just didn't feel like it was as good at two and three for me to you know go through the whole like teaching process but yeah it does lead to some pretty tense matches and some you know insane crazy you know combats where you go right I put this tile down and now three of us are fighting in this right you two are going to resolve first right resolve your thing d right well that breaks up and now that means this needs to resolve right okay we'll do our thing right well that that breaks up in boy that escalated quickly it causes some good little Chain Reaction pieces to occur there's a lot more interaction and it just it's it's infinitely better at four players I mean is there anybody out there who doesn't agree with that your
mother now when it comes to my seven we are talking about area control now I'm not the biggest area control fan it must be said you know it's definitely one of my lower mechanics that I go for and so when I like an area control game it's got to be one that I particularly like now with area control you would might argue that more players is kind of key for them because you want a lot of people going at each other's throats which is actually not an untrue statement really I mean it does make some of them take a little bit too long and maybe some of them a little bit make them a little bit too chaotic in that front but with this particular one I think four is The Sweet Spot because it's a mean game therefore you want it at its meanest and I still really enjoy it at three even you know I'll play this at two or three even but dominant species particularly dominant species marine and that's the one I'm going for in this case I think does work at it's maximum player count at for the best and you know the game is not a short game anyway it's going to take you a while to finish it but you know you are you're making up your species the map is building out it will build out a lot more with four of you and you're constantly at each other's throats trying to like dominate another species or grab the little token markers or you know get area control on the things before you score them and that and you really do I mean like I say works great at free I played it at three recently and I still really enjoy it but with four of you called blam me it turns into a massive like you know carnivorous meat Fest at that point where everybody is just out to eat the other players for
everything they've got you know you can't play Mr Nice Guy in dominant species it just does not work no apologizing for me for like I'm sorry I got to do this I know this is going to hurt but I need to do this and it's like no you've got to take Glee what you're doing here because let's face it it's just going to come back at you in tfold you know when you get into that situation so yeah you know area control games in general can be good at their max player count but a lot of those area control games take a long time with them or maybe I just don't enjoy the games as much this is probably one of the few area control games in my collection period it's none of a cck I go for generally with this one I think a lot of it is down to the theme I like the theme of you know building up your little creatures evolving them and you know trying to survive with the different food and stuff and the cards are a cool element they can be a little bit SNY at times I wish there was a way for the game to fix that problem it's it's one floor it does have but otherwise I do enjoy this one a lot more than I enjoy the the previous version because Marine has you do the actions one at a time work a placement style but with some restrictions whereas the original dominant species a it goes up to six which is just way too long five and six play is way too much but it also requires you to program all your actions at the time and that means you could spend half an hour on a round planning stuff stuff just happens your whole round is a waste of space and that just deflates you like crazy so I really I'm not the biggest fan of the original
dominant species this is the one I gun for and if I can play it with four then fantastic long live the king for number six we are going to a big heavy Euro in fact we're going to a heavier Euro than most and the thing with this one is one problem that you get in a lot of big Euros is downtime so you're sitting there and you're thinking with four of you I've got to wait for three people to take their Mammoth turns before it gets round to me and you may have a situation even with this game where you could have a bit of downtime in between but if you're playing the game properly managing your influence and all that you should be involved quite often but it also makes for a much more tense work of placement aspect because youve only got four spaces in this entire game and then there's four of you playing so you're going to trigger a lot of what's called kicked out actions on a regular basis I'm talking of course now about the gallerist on my shelf the gallerist has this rule where you go to a worker placement spot you can leave agents behind or you've just got your sort of big porn there and if somebody kicks you out of the action when they're done doing their thing you can either do a bonus executive action you know bonus Action for free or you can spend influence up to a certain point to do one action at the spot you got kicked out of now this does make it a bit of a nightmare to track who's turn it is at times and certainly you might have a situation where you're sat waiting for about three to four turns to happen
before it comes around to you but if you're managing your spots carefully and doing what you need to do with your influence you should be doing a bit of that yourself and you know it means that you are deliberately trying to get people to kick you out so you're interested in whether a player might go to a particular spot in which case you might try and well can I go to that spot first cuz then I get to do something then you get to kick me out and I get to do more you know there's things like that to consider but with only four spaces on the board four of you are kicking each other out like left right and center it's just constantly happening there's rarely a time where somebody isn't being kicked out and you're not necessarily going to spend influence every single time but even just doing the bonus actions will at least keep you engaged in the game and not just sitting around twiddling your thumbs waiting for something to do I certainly probably wouldn't suggest doing that maximum player account with all of Thea games I mean on Mars no U bzbo I'm happy enough playing that with free Vinos I'm happy playing that with free kban h kar's a tricky one I quite like that with free you but I also quite like it with four but then I've also played it with two you know the two-player mode works right that's the solo so kban was a consideration you know but I can play it with three or four and get about equal sort of going for it but galleris has a specific reason why I want to play it with more you know you play it with free you're not getting kicked out as often even though the game is taking less time I quite like having all those different kicked out actions happen on a regular basis just make sure you can keep track of whose turn it is how could I have
been unthawed in the '90s and traveled back to oh no I've gone crosseyed my number five has had a Resurgence lately not just because it was on my top 50 but because since my top 50 I've actually played this game a few times by teach at the people and I've remembered just how much I love this game in fact this rate I wouldn't be surprised if it went up in my list for next year I also need to check out the solo mode for it now that I've actually printed out all the components for it God that took me a while but this one at four players has more of you on the map more of you getting each other's faces more rules more chances for diplomatic uh visits by using your Caravans and that but it certainly does make a difference when you play Civilization and New Dawn with four or rden 2 to four in fact I don't think this is a game I would want to play with two ever two just seems way too few and you know free is good but when you set up the map you have four tiles on the board at the start if you have four or five players this is not a game I want to play with five trust me and you can only do five with the expansion but we know when you've got two or three you only have two tiles in the middle and then you put stuff around the outside so you might think well why didn't you play this with free well the main reason is because a i like to have a bigger map on these things I mean when you when you play a civilization game I want a big sprawling map to explore I don't want just like two tiles and that's it you know I found that was the case with um a what was it called Brazil uh yeah Brazil the map in that just felt very small and
not that interesting for a Civ game whereas here you can expand and explore with the terror incognit expansion which let's face it is essential for this it's like a 10 out of 10 expansion um and and so when you've got four of you you've got more tiles out but you've also got more people to visit pleasure to be meeting you quite a pleasure cuz you can send your Caravans out to city states and each other to get those diplomatic cards off each other and if there's two of you that you're playing against then well that's not as interesting as having three other players that you're playing against it just makes for a more sprawling experience and a bigger map and you know lately I have been playing this with predominantly four players I think I've played three games of this since uh you know doing my top 50 and two of them were at four and one of them was at three and all three games were enjoyable but the fours the fours just felt like there was more going on more stuff happening more interesting you know twists happening with the board and the barbarians and that because obviously having more tiles means more chance for barbarians more spots to go to more opportunities and it just seems to yeah I think four is a a sweet spot for this and it kind of works the same with the original civilization the 2010 one I've still got down there go blame me that's going to be a fun one to try and learn the rules to at some point cuz I've forgotten them all by now but yeah I think Civ games just benefit from having a lot of players that is Civ games with a map and a spraing civilization uh something like Fruity ages kind of going in the opposite direction on that one solo or two player I'll stick with fruity ages but yeah with s new dawn I've just been really
enjoying it for it just seems to work you concur right I don't think anybody should be disagreeing with these next four these next four are definitely best at four just has to be now it may not include some obvious ones but we'll get on to those with the honorable mentions but this one is a game I've not played in my collection for quite some time it's uh certainly again going down that whole area control thing which yeah funny enough after I did dominant species Marine this one is definitely uh a game that really needs four like pretty much Golden Rule needs four when you're playing with this and that is a game that is pretty much out of print out of sight out of phase basic basically with the known universe like nobody is playing this anymore but I refuse to get rid of it because if I do I'll never see it again that is here we go chaos in the Old World Part of Me Now wants to really get this out again and yeah some people might recognize this uh I think this is one of the older covers actually I think they redid the cover at one point but this one I have expanded with the horned rat and playing it with five is quite a long event filled game and a bit complicated and not to mention that the the horns rat as a faction is decent but it's definitely different in power level to like like balance in the other four the original four factions felt quite balanced you know some of them are May been a little bit harder to grock than others I mean what you do is
corn you go out and kill things it's pretty straightforward you know compared to something like sesh or zenich which were a little bit more H fiddly to do but the four factions in the original game just kind of felt like they were made to go up against each other horn rat feels like this fifth one just thrown into the mix that kind of upsets the balance even so I don't often play with the horn rat as a faction but if people want to play this with four players and they leave out one and use horn rat I I can't remember actually can you do that or do you have to have five I forget but with this game it is a really solid one you know I mean I have not played it in a while I admit but then I can say that about a few old games in the collection still got some uh player AIDS in there but I think I even pinned up slightly yeah I got like special bags for it and everything so it's a solid game you know you are at each other's throats but the balance for this I think just works so much better with having the original four factions have those four chaos Gods nurgle K zenich and sones you know have have those four and you've got a pretty decent game I mean very few people without the expansion let's say the horned rat wasn't in your collection because let's face it that's harder thein it this is but let's say you've just got the base game how many of you felt like you really wanted to play it with two I mean two really or even three because if you're missing one of the four Gods you feel like the game's kind of missing a component there like you you know you've got the three Gods going against each other and it's like well you know if we had this God it would kind of counteract the one that you're doing there a little bit more so you
need all four of them in the game to really achieve that true balance the port is quite good yeah quite good indeed most certainly what here is it 51 ah delectable indeed yes now I've not played this well pseudo sequel to this whatever Kulu Wars I've not actually played that one I wouldn't mind trying it out but I don't know I would just find myself drawn back to the good old classic original chaos in the old world with that board that looks like it's made out of skin and the Warhammer license I think I'd just rather play that but yeah I'm never going to get rid of it because I'll never see it again but uh yeah at some point I think this one needs to come off the resurrection pile as I call it uh the pile of games which have not been played in ages that seriously need playing again you this is definitely one of those and and hopefully that time will come soon I admire it
Purity my number three was mentioned on my top 50 quite late it was actually in my top 10 of all time and this one is a light game it's a light generally very pretty Euro game and I've had it since like I think the dawn of time it's one of Bruno Cal's best games and I think with four players Abyss just works that bit better especially much better than two player two player is just not worth it with ayss and even three with ayss is fine but I feel like I want four because the game doesn't take that long even with four players the turns are very quick I mean you you do the bidding with pearls and Alli cards or you take a stack of cards or you buy a lord it really doesn't equate to a lot of downtime but the main reason you want to play this with four is because predominantly that Ally bidding phase because when you take the depths action you are flipping a card over and other players get to buy it off you in increasing amount of cost when there's four of you there's a lot more people potentially buying off each other there's a bit more turn angs you know you think right I'm third in order he's going to flip a card oh are you likely to spend the pro on it please don't please don't please don't yes good I'm buying it instead and it's like ah crap now I can't afford it yeah so you get a bit more interaction with the players in that phase and that's kind of the main reason why actually I mean it's I know it's high up on this list but you know by being high on the list it's got to be not only like really good at this player count but it's also got to be the player count that I specifically aim for with
the game and with this one I think that bidding phase works now chaos in the old world needed balancing with the factions to play it with four but then it does make for a longer game nonetheless because you're playing with more people here abys doesn't take much longer with four with four of you compared to three it really isn't that long a game but when you play with two or three you do notice that little bit less interaction with the Pearl phase than to normal and it just makes the game suffer a little bit more four of you are going to be populating the stacks and the council row a lot more so there's going to be more stuff to choose there there's going to be more variety in the Lords because more will get bought you know there's there's just more going on and given that the main emphasis of the game is the whole the more you look at the more you give your opponents it's much better when you've got more opponents to actually give to but potentially gain from it just kind of works in that neat little balance
like right my number two and my number one are Paramount choices like you cannot dispute that these games are best with for I mean well could you I don't know I'm sure there's some of you out there that could but this again was in my top 10 of all time it is a game that I probably shouldn't like but for some reason do and it is one of my favorite games of all time it is a theme that again I never expected to grab on to and yet it works so well with this but this is an asymmetric big 4H hour Euro and if you want to get the full experience of this game you need to play with the working class the capitalist the middle class and the state you got to play with the four classes of hegemony hegemony is perfectly good at threee I'm not saying it's terrible at the other player counts although two it's a little lacking solo is fine you get to play with as many Bots as you like so you could technically have a three player experience as solo two-player I don't think works as well with hegemony I mean it's decent fine but you're missing out on having no middle class and no state with three of you not having the state is not the end of the world you've got the three main classes in there but the state is a class I quite like to have in a game I even quite like playing as a state they get less actions to do so it's not quite as involved as the other but the state has to watch the other players they have to gauge what's going on they have to perceive their whole game and think who's who's likely to be in the situation where they can run away with the game here you are I need to
start helping you guys out more how can I do that you know how can I curb you and help these but then soon sooner later that that whole balance might switch and then you've got to go right well I've been helping them enough so capitalist let's talk you know it's and it's it's such a fun little faction to play but when you've got four of you in hegemony you have everything the game can offer you've got all the different classes you've got all the companies all the like the policies going left right middle and Center like crazy you've got the state trying to manipulate the game I never get involved in politics you've got the state benefits that they provide which is great for the other free the events which can give those players other bonuses because that's kind of how the state that's like the influence of the state cuz otherwise you just buy off the state as normal and there's not much else going on but with an actual State player they can really really influence uh you know setting up some policy changes that are going to benefit certain players and getting support but they're also doing the events that say you know what capitalist you can have a little bit of extra money this turn I need to do this event and workingclass you can have some more Healthcare there you go it's available you just got to buy it from me and the state benefits you know right everybody's going to get a couple of you know couple of extra education there you go come on please take it you're kind of Gooding all the players still works great at three perfectly fine to play hemony at three when it happens some times but when I set this up at a convention typically the whole four players will get used up and I find a few players are unwilling to play the state as much mainly because they don't have as many actions to pick
from but I quite like the state I think I'm pretty good with the state and just enjoy I get a kick out of it so if I want the state I've got to play it with four but even then I think just to get the full experience of the game all the interaction at it's most glorious that hegemony provides you want all four come and see violence inherent in the system help help I'm being repressed bloody
peasant oh yeah this number one when me and a few mates play it we are adamant we play it with four we have to play this with four it is got the most tension for worker placement spots at four the game takes a while with four it has to be said but the biggest reason is that the two and free player rules with the neutral player and how it works are really weird they're badly written and they're quite janky they just don't they don't work as much it is far better to have four of you playing so you don't have any of those rules to contend with you still have a ton of tension for the spaces because there really isn't that many to go around with four of you despite the fact there's a lot of spaces on the board it's quite surprising how tight it can still be but you've also got a bit more interaction with players you know thinking right well I've got a bit of combat I can kick you off I can go share this space with you you know that kind of thing race each other down the Caravan track you along the river if you don't recognize this game I'm not surprised because a lot of people don't know this one and that is Terror Mara Tera Mara is a quined games uh Edition which came out a few years ago at Essen I played it really enjoyed it and then I grabbed it it's one of my favorite work of basement games and nobody talks about this game I mean nobody at all I forget I think it was in my top 50 and if it was it was probably in the lower end of it but still really enjoy this one and and it just never got any Buzz very few people went to it and I think some of it was down to a qued games just doing a piss job of actually advertising it but
also the fact that nobody really wants to play this game at two and three because of the janky neutral player rules you know it just doesn't it's weird because a lot of Euro games have these sort of neutral player rules for two and three but for some reason this one just feels like it really lessens the game compared to a lot of those other ones and most of the time you don't expect to play with a neutral player or like you know neutral spaces taken up in a free player game normally you just flip the board over and have a little bit of a different board or something but to have to go through this additional setup process to you know mess around with spaces and then having to do that on like you know subsequent rounds as well it just feels like extra effort and extra work you know basically slavery with extra steps to for not much game really you know I we just always adamantly played this with four you know when we're thinking like what get how many of us we got three well that's teramar out then we just pretty much don't even consider it and so for that reason it's going to be high up on this list but you know I can play a giny with free and I'll still be fine the fact is this one pretty much never gets played with less than four you know and that's got to make a difference here you know all the other games on this list they are best at four but I could still play them with free or a different player count terramara pretty much never hits the table or even consider duration at less than four it just it always has to be four and for that reason it's going to be my number
one all right well there you go that is my 10 through one of the top Euro games I like to play with four players and I say four players is typically good for a lot of games but with Euros you got to balance out that length that interaction and so I find a lot of times I'd still rather play with three not to say I will never play with four but there's always that limitation but there's a lot of honorable mentions here and I know some of you are basically kicking your monitor screens wondering why some of these have not been mentioned don't worry they're going to get mentioned here so why don't we just kick off with the big obvious one that everybody's going to get on my case for where is root yes I get it root is definitely best played with a full player count of four I know you can probably have more with the expansions but I think with the base game you had four and it definitely works best out four the problem is I have given rot as many chances as I can and I don't mind it that much but at best I can give it an average above average rating I've just never managed to get enough enjoyment from the game to consider it for a seal of endorsement it just the problem is is it's too fragile when you play with people who don't know the game it upsets the balance considerably and the factions that they brought in from expansions have got severe power creep compared to some of the others or power creep or power diminishing I don't know cuz you've got ones like the crocodile cult which sounded like great on paper to play and they turned out to be one of the worst factions I've ever played they're like they're just so powerless they're crap but then a friend of mine plays like the rat faction you know the ones who just
go and invade with rats they're stupidly powerful it's ridiculous you have to like curb them at the very start otherwise they would just overrun the board with all their abilities and stuff the problem is if you got new players to the game how I supposed to do that it I mean I digress you could have a whole conversation about this but this is the thing root has never impressed me enough to be worth you know considering for my collection or like I say this list it's an honorable mention because I totally agree with you that it's best played at the four player count with the base set that is and it's probably most balanced at that State you know so totally with you on that it's just not a game I enjoy as much as I like I even tried the app I might even still have the app it's one of the best apps out there I'll give it that you know I give the game a lot of respect and credit but it's way too fragile for my liking it's just ah it it it's not it doesn't sit with me as well but I could not mention it because I would have my head taken off if I didn't all right um inis I considered um inis not been in the collection for a while it's hard to teach it needs the expansion to you know curb the game length issue but yeah within this you really wanted to play this with the max player counter 4 didn't you you know I think it was Max 4 I don't maybe the expansion added another one I'm not sure but you know generally you didn't want to play this area control game with a twist with two and not even as much with three you wanted a lot of people on the board going at each other's throats and so in just worked better at four uh empires of the Void two are kind of consider because you can play this with five but I think five is a little bit
too long but the thing is is that the board scales by replacing a bunch of the planets with these generic neutral foes that are stupidly hard to kill that the only way you can possibly kill them is to go heavy into combat so it basically just notifies a bunch of the board so when you play with less players You' got less cool stuff to look at four is the sweet spot where you've got a decent amount of the board to look at you know one or two neutral planets that you can potentially go for and it not taking quite as long as a five player game which goes a little bit ridiculous um architects of the West Kingdom I put it as an honorable mention but in all fairness maybe this one isn't as much of an honorable mention because yes it's definitely great with four but with the expansions it's actually pretty decent at five and six you know you actually can get through the game reasonably quick even with five six players cuz the turns are just so Snappy and fast and when you got lots of you putting each other in prison and God knows what else five and six actually does become quite fun but certainly if you've only got the base game you play it with four really um uh let's see the king is dead uh quick little well I say quick it takes ages cuz everyone gets analysis paralysis with this game but it's a cool quirky game it's area control with cubes you know limited rounds limited cards and stuff but yeah you really want four don't you you want four of you on this map going at each other cuz because the you know again it's area control and I think area control games tend to benefit more from having more players I just don't enjoy the mechanic as much but I was kind of surprised about the K is's dead it's actually still on my shelf downstairs you know it's a game that's
it's clever it's really clever and you don't realize it at first but you know definitely you want four players when you're playing it uh the war of the Ring card game I just played this last Tuesday in fact actually and uh it has problems I do wish it wasn't skewed to the evil players and terms of a power level you know it's much easier to win with the evil players than it is to win with the good players but it's still a great game and you want to play it with four really I mean you can play it with three but that's kind of weird you could play it with two and it works fine at two but you really want to play two-handed because one deck against one deck I know it's just not as interesting you really want all four of the decks in play and for that I just rather have four of you at the table a little bit of teamwork with each other you know two different Minds you know talking about what they want to do the game doesn't take that much longer really it's it just feels like the 2v2 is the way to play not to say the 1 V one is bad it's still pretty damn decent at One V one but yeah I don't really want to play this with free having the 2v one thing is just I don't know it's kind of weird it's extra rules it's more jankiness you got to learn this is definitely a two or four player game uh Scythe Scythe you can go up to five six or seven players now for just seems to be a good little sweet spot of having enough people on the board and not having the game take forever that being said I had played a seven player game of cphon 90 minutes before but that's with people who knew how to play the game and with a friend of mine who I haven't seen in ages who uh you know basically is the ultimate moderator for a game this guy can get
you to play a Twilight Imperium four game in three hours with like max player count he could because he just has this Knack of being able to get people to make their moves and get the game ticking and going like no just sitting around no thin flam it's uh pretty impressive and the last one is a cerebria the inside world it's since left the collection it's a bit too hard to get to the table and part of that is because you really want to play it 2v2 it's a lot to comprehend by yourself with 1 V one but when you got 2v2 that teamwork aspect with the two different emotions that you play on light side and two on the dark side you know it it just has a lot a much better Dynamic the problem is it's a nightmare to find for of you that can play a game that is made by mine clash with a decent amount of reli ability it's just a lot of rules to teach and way too impractical so I had to get rid of it despite the fact I enjoy it but yeah it definitely was a consideration for four players and there you go now I'd be very interested to know if there's any games that you would like to play with four that I did not mention on the list now I'd be interested to know the reasons why I mean for example some of you might go you know what about brass Birmingham well a I can't stand brass but B really I mean it's you know it might make the board a little bit tighter but you're just adding to the length for the game and and at the end of the day I don't like brass so it was never going to be a consideration but yeah by all means let me know which games you prefer to play it for and you must stick to Euro games I don't want co-op games I don't want social deduction I don't want like aera
frash skirmish games miniature games that kind of thing you know I mean you might argue that something like War the ring the card game is a little bit weird out of that region but then I didn't put it on my list so what you're worried about but yeah if it wasn't on my honorable mentions or it wasn't in my 10 let me know your thoughts and give me the reasons why so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and by all means consider subscribing to the channel to be notified about other videos or subscribe to the patreon to help keep this channel running because it is a side hobby it is not my day job and so I've got to find time and of course funds in order to keep it running and for those of you who are subscribed to it thank you very much your support is always appreciated and in some ways essential uh by all means let me know your thoughts down below as I've mentioned and until next time remember regardless of whether with the holy hand grenade you refuse to count to four it's still only a game so bye for now