Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Board Games That Need A Second Edition - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 24:45

hey everybody today i'm talking about 10 ball games that i feel need a second edition now whether that's because i feel some rules of these games are a little bit off or at least a bit unnecessary whether it has some production issues or maybe it needs an artwork overhaul i'll talk through all of these things as i go through these games but as a general i like these games i like the concept of these games and i feel like there's something that it's just a little bit off and needs a little bit of a fix in order to make it amazing so let's get started at number 10. so at number 10 i have xi'an the terracotta army now this is a game i still recommend i think this is a lovely game this is a a kind of a hand management style games you're taking a a bunch of cards and you're dividing them into two piles of two and one of those cards is going to determine the action you can take and the other one is going to determine the initiative of taking that action which can be very important i'm not going to kind of show which resources you're going to take in and then you're going to basically place a worker on one of these four worker placement spots which will either let you build a build a statue and get an instant reward as you place it on this board you're going to paint the statue of your color for area control bonuses you're going to either collect different items and artifacts in order to get set collection bonuses and you can also climb this separate track to get these bonus powers now that's that third thing i mentioned that bonus track is where i think this game could be improved because i always felt that that's that section of the board or that strategy wasn't quite as strong as the other two so i'd have loved to see that be balanced out a bit more

to make it a lot more kind of make a bigger incentive to go there and to make those powers a little bit more juicy and a little bit more powerful um so again people will want to go there and divert their strategies from the normal tried and tested ways of getting a bunch of points um additionally i feel like the game could do with a few a few component upgrades now generally the production is pretty good as you have these plastic statues in your color and even in neutral colors but i feel the card stock in this game was a little bit flimsy could be improved and the artwork as well is a little bit soulless and could be revamped but the thing that i think needs improving the most is the player board so on the main board you have these uh kind of three different sections where you put this paper uh basically this bit of paper which shows the different setup from game to game and the different incentives you get from placing your statues and i would love to see that be just wrapped up into a really nice thick cardboard stock just to make the game feel a bit more deluxe and a bit more polished because it just felt a little bit flimsy and a little bit cheap so yeah i thought the the components in its entirety were a bit of a mishmash of different quality components or quality types so with a revamp a new lick of paint i think this game could really blow up because the gameplay is so accessible it's fun it's pretty crunchy and just has a lot of interesting decisions from start to finish so uh those few fixes for xi'an could take this from a seven up to an eight and eight and a half or uh even beyond that so yeah at number 10 i have xi'an

at number nine i have burano now burano is a pretty heavy complex euro style game as you are building this tower of these um these cubes of different colors and then you are taking those cubes off from top to bottom in this like revealing system so whenever you reveal a or use a cube you're revealing a bunch of others and those cubes all determine a different type of action you can take um and those actions are pretty simple such as you are going to be collecting cards you're going to to sell them off as that collection bonuses you're trying to build these blocks on this central board and then you can build roofs on those blocks to get points and additionally you can choose to do this lace work mechanism which which will get you points in in like area control manner this game has a lot to like about it it's gorgeous to look at has some really nice production um however i feel like the designers didn't know when to stop on this one they just added a few too many kind of finicky rules a few fiddly rules and stuff that's not so intuitive and i thought that was quite a big hurdle in getting this one to the table because that that core mechanism of pulling the blocks off and building them onto that main town was great it had a great table presence it would definitely appeal to a lot of people and people want to check this one out based on that table presence alone the set collection was okay as you're sending from ireland to ireland but again there was a other mechanism based on your player board which would have to line up colors you'd get points on different ways and

it just became a bit too confusing and a bit too unnecessary whereas if that was stripped out i think the game would be would benefit from that so i always feel it's a bit of a shame when game when designs don't know when to call it quits i know this game has a lot of fans and people who like that additional um that additional layer of complexity but for me personally i feel it's a little bit unnecessary and if that's stripped out the game will be better for it so at number nine i have burano at number eight i have bring out your dead now this is a pretty unknown game i think it was upper deck who published this one quite a few years back a nice looking game as a cartoony art and it's quite a quite uh a bleak theme a bit depressing as you are trying to offload these coffins into these different grave sites scoring points not only by placing them but also by controlling those regions by having the most uh coffins there and i like this core mechanism where you would basically simultaneously play cards and with initiative values on them and then you would load these cuts up of your coffins but if you if you wanted to be a bit greedy and load too many then you could risk losing them into the river which will score you negative points at the end of the game that was really cool this game had some real big issues mainly with the rule book so number one the rule book was absolutely shocking and one of the worst rule books i've ever seen uh number two the symbology on this game was confusing so the the symbology was was pretty simple in itself but there was a lot of

symbology that was very similar to one another and if you couldn't differentiate them which i couldn't because i'm colorblind and some of the differences between them were so minute that i just could not tell the difference between those symbols which was a big part of the game so that was a massive pain in the ass uh and additionally there was some rules in this game that just didn't did not add up so for example if you played a certain card you could collect these uh additional cards where the more cards you collect the more points you'd get however if you played those cards for their benefit rather than collecting them for a set collection you would get more points than if you were to collect them um as as as a set collection so the incentive to actually collect these cards was just void and that was just a complete broken rule that must have been just just not not caught out in play testing and this was a victim of just being underdeveloped not being played enough and just not being scrutinized enough and it's a shame because it's a pretty accessible and pretty fun uh kind of area control style game that was a little bit different so it would have been nice just to see those uh things ironed out and just improved upon and to see what the game would be like if it actually did have enough time in the oven to cook and to be ready to be put on the shelves so just a victim of not being developed enough and some small production issues and just didn't take color blindness into consideration so that is bring out your dead at number eight uh number seven this is a bit of a cheat because this is actually a third edition this is stronghold so stronghold

is um a pretty involved game this is a completely asymmetric two-player game as it represents a siege of a castle so one person's going to be the defender the other one is going to be these hordes of goblins and orcs trying to invade this castle trying to climb in and just overthrow the castle so i love the theme you know i love big fantasy huge battles your battles the backwaters your helm's deeps i love this kind of thing and so i'm always looking forward to a board game that represents that well this one was so close to being that and the the reasons that stopped this one being as great as i think it could be was the asymmetry was a bit too much in my opinion so you're always teaching two completely different games where one side of the game was alien to the other and you know you might say that's fine you know if you're playing with the same person again and again but if you want to switch roles you've got to learn the whole game again and a bit like a bit like burano i think this game just had a little bit too much fiddliness a little bit too much going on and could benefit from some things being taken out of it just to keep it hitting the table um on top of that i thought the game went on a bit too long you know venturing on that two to two and a half hours to play which just is a bit too long for me and it's going to be an obstacle to get this one to the table and all of these things added up just meant to sat on my shelf just collecting dust when it should have been being played because it is such a cool concept and i know you know from the first edition to the second edition a lot of things were improved but i still feel like there's an extra

an extra step to be taken just to make it that much more streamlined and that much more fun so uh at number seven i have stronghold at number six i have venice so venice is actually the most recent game on this list it only came out in 2020 this is a pick up and deliver style game as you're traveling these canals of venice and visiting these different shops collecting resources trying to fulfill contracts by delivering goods from one side of the city to the other you have your own little um your own little gondola as you're collecting cubes on them and you have a kind of a capacity all this stuff was great i love the idea and the concept of this game it looks nice however the main issue with this game in fact the key problem with this game was production so this game you have a lot going on on the board you have gondolas from all the different players traveling around which are quite big chunky pieces and the board was just not adequate and not big enough to fit those pieces on the board so if more than one person was on the same spot on the board you'd have to kind of veer onto the buildings and go off the board and that was just so so kind of convoluted and so congested that it was just a massive burden to getting this game played additionally there was these rules where some buildings you would kind of invest your workers in and the more you go there the more you boost your kind of rewards you take from them but you represent that by putting these meeples on these different locations and moving them up on this um on this track however when you put the meeple on

them they'd cover up the symbology below it which again was just a more uh just a nightmare to be played and all these things just became such a burden that it really did uh it really hindered the gameplay and i think that's such a shame when there's a good game here where and all these things could have been avoided by making the board you know 20 30 bigger and it was just a massive oversight that should have been ironed out and it's just a shame that it didn't get addressed because it's a good game and i feel like just improving that board would make this game even better um but the rules themselves were decent i do think the rules could have been a bit uh there could have been some ceilings that that could have been kept by doing certain actions so when you travel for example you trigger everything you you pass on the way whether that's passing other players whether that's passing buildings and that remembering everything you have to do on the way could be a bit fiddly and a bit annoying as well whereas if it was kept at maybe only doing a couple of actions on the way then um that would be a bit more streamlined and a bit more easy to digest so shane and for one being so recently you know it's probably highly unlikely this this game will be rectified that is venice at number six uh at number five i have shadows over camelot so this is a uh quite a popular and uh kind of a almost a nostalgic cooperative game one of the first cooperative games out there actually as you are these uh the knights of the round table you are working together so it's a pure cooperative game as you are trying to collect these cars

basically fulfill these different objectives by building these poker hands um i thought the concept of this game is x and i love the theme i love this kind of medieval arthurian theme it's one of my favorite kind of skins out there and this game had a lot to like it was i had a certain charm about it um however i do feel that there were some issues with the gameplay number one is that you'd only get two actions on your turn and those actions would often be quite unsatisfying you'd have to wait a lot of times before it got back to your turn where you take another pretty pretty boring action such as you know healing up or um you know do something very simple and i feel like you know if you did more of your turn it would be a bit more a bit more engaging additionally there was some murkiness in the communication you could have with other players you know you'd have your hand of cards and you'd have to try and uh argue your case on whether you're going to go here or there but without being precise in the cards you had and i find when when rules are that murky where you can communicate but you don't know how much you can communicate i find that it's just a massive uh kind of free-for-all for breaking the rules and cheating and you may as well just not have that rule at all so i'd like to see that be limited and have that kind of alpha gaminess and that rules bending just eliminated from the game whatsoever um so yeah it's more of an issue of that because i i think this is more of a thing where i want a game where you have to do all these things you have to search for the holy grail you have to fight off all the different invading tribes you have to fight off the trebuchets on

camelot all this thing is just absolutely fantastic but yeah that those few rules issues i had just didn't quite make this game be a keeper for me where as i really wanted it to be so if there was ever a game that i wanted to like more than i actually did i think shadows of camelot was an example of that now i have heard rumors that they are trying to reimplement this into a new kind of modern theme but to be honest i'm not that interested in that i'd like to see this theme be used again but to have those rules uh things just just just improved upon i i appreciate this is more of a personal taste thing because i know this is a popular game out there so at number five i have shadows of camelot shadows over camelot at number four i have genoa so genoa is i think one of the first board games designed by one of my favorite designers uh rudiger dawn uh this is a negotiation style game that if you're familiar with istanbul this game has some similar mechanisms as you have this stack of disks and you are dropping these disks as you as you travel one at a time and visiting these different locations and the idea of this game is that you when you take your movement other people can kind of choose to pay you to do certain things that they might say you know if you visit this merchant then i'll give you x amount of coins for example and it's all about weighing up whether you want to kind of forsake your actions in order to uh take money off the other players so they can get their actions done

and it's just a little economy of what you're going to do and what's going to benefit you the most i love that i think that's that's wonderful so theme theme and the concept brilliant the issues i had with this game was number one it was too long so there was too many rounds in this game that seemed to outstay its welcome and just it just dragged on and on and on second is that there was just i think there's enough variety in these different contracts and things that you had to do you could pretty much quite clearly math out how much you're going to benefit more than the other players or if they're going to benefit off you whereas if there's a bit more added into the game such as games like chinatown for example you have that speculation a bit more and you have that just kind of potential to strike more interesting deals and this one i felt that was capped bit it just had a bit of a glass ceiling there and if that was uh rectified and you still had that idea of you know some players turn you can move around people are putting you in one direction people are putting you in the other direction you got to decide what you want to do um i love that so i'd love to see this be proved upon improved upon if there's a second edition i would undoubtedly check this one out because it was so so close to being a keeper but it just didn't quite do it for me for those issues so and number four i have genoa and number three i have francis drake so this is a game where i certainly can't complain about the production it's a wonderfully produced game a gorgeous looking game as you have this huge map and you are basically traveling down

this pier in plymouth collecting these different resources and you have that really cool mechanism where you can go as far as you want but you can never go back on yourself that was fantastic and once you've got to the sea you would choose to kind of go off on your little voyage visiting these different locations trying to have little battles to get these gems and rewards and you'd program it blindly so you didn't quite know where other people were going you could take a guess you tried to prioritize the regions that you think other people would want you'd have to invest in different resources you would have to invest in cannons in order to fight these pirates off you'd have to invest in uh kind of resources in order to travel further on the map all that was fantastic the issues i had with this game were that they were the game arc was pretty much non-existent there was three phases or three rounds of the game that were pretty much carbon copies of one another and any investment you made in the earlier rounds didn't stick around in the future round so it was pretty much wipe a new surface clean and start again from scratch three times over and i think that kind of gameplay doesn't quite land nowadays um and additionally i thought the game was a bit too long uh it did take probably around two hours to play where as it should have been maybe 75 to 90 minutes and if they managed to add that gay mark in managed to add a bit of an engine into the game as well as shaving some time off this could be fantastic because it has a real fun factor for a pretty simple euro

and it did that kind of uh that one-way system mechanism really well so yeah it had a lot to like and another really near-miss for me uh that was francis drake so i would love to see a second edition of that game at number two i have lancaster though lancaster an amazing game you know i'll stay straight out front you know this is a great work placement game one of the best worker placement games out there as you are placing these knights onto the board of different values when people go to that certain spot you can choose to raise the power of that knight and kick them back off that spot so it has a real nice level of player interaction and a real tension of getting the best spots to get different rewards such as collecting these different nobles to come to your to come to your dining hall and those nobles would give you uh would give you influence cubes which would let you kind of manipulate the game state and rules in the game it had a lot a lot i loved about the game it was so clever really fresh and different ideas and different concepts of a work placement game the reason why i put this on this list is because like number one i think the the visuals of the game were a bit polarizing it wasn't as inviting as it could have been it could have been a bit more vibrant a bit more a bit less stale looking and don't get me wrong i do like a dry dusty looking euro but this one just seems a little bit soulless in a little bit the artwork was a bit too computer generated and it just didn't quite look right to me some of the production

choices in this game were fantastic as all your different workers had different thicknesses on them like they're basically these big chunky wooden blocks and they would the kind of thicker they were the stronger the knight was that that was fantastic additionally to get the most out of this game i felt like you had to inject a lot of the expansion material into it otherwise it was a pretty decent work placement game but not a great one but with the additional expansion content i thought it was a great work placement game however with that expansion content there was a bit too much um stop and start in terms of the housekeeping so you do this phase you resolve it you do this then this and this and this and it would be a bit jarring and a bit too much downtime as you very kind of meticulously go through phase after phase after phase resolving each one whereas if that was ironed out and we had a definitive version of the game where all the best parts of these expansions were put into the core experience i think that could be fixed and i would love to see that because that to be honest that was the main reason why this left my collection was because it was a bit fiddly in choose picking and choosing the expansion material you would want and knowing which order to resolve them whereas if it was a bit more clear-cut and just a you know a one optimal experience then this game would no doubt come back into my collection with with no hesitation whatsoever because i think the game is marvelous so at number two lancaster

and finally at number one the game that i'd most like to see a second edition being made is alchemists now alchemists is a pretty involved hybrid of deduction and worker placement as you take the role of these alchemists you're trying to collect these different materials and see what happens when you combine them and the idea is we're trying to work out how to make these different potions and then publish your theories before the other players do you can try out these potions on these different kind of apprentices you can collect these bonus artifacts you can sell these potions to traveling kind of adventurers i love the theme of this game i love the concept and the premise i think it's wonderful there are however some pretty big obstacles that stop this one getting to the table and i think those obstacles could be improved now this game is actually really popular i think this is it might even still be in the top 100 on bgg if not maybe slightly out with that top 100 and because there is so much like about it however it is confusing there is quite a lot of fiddly symbology in things in terms of how you work out these materials combined with one another and explaining that to someone for the first time is like talking an alien language and um so it's one of those games where once you teach it to someone you want to pretty much keep it with that person and it feels like a lot of work to teach it to someone else so i thought that was a bit of a shame i think it could be improved upon by

making it maybe making the symbology a bit easier to understand um additionally i think the production could be improved from quite a bit for example you would have this pretty big structure of this big deduction board as you're plugging these cards in you're using an app to scan these cards in and how they combine with with one another i think that could have been a bit sturdier sometimes you would find these little tokens would get trapped in the board they'd fall off and you'd forget where they would be um additionally the actual work replacement board itself was a bit it seemed a bit novich like novice like it wasn't polished the pieces of the ball were these little kind of transparent cubes which felt cheap the artwork i i think didn't quite look right it looked a bit it looked a bit rushed and i think if it was more deluxified and kind of revamped i think there'll be a whole new market for this game because i know deduction is always uh enjoyed and it's always a popular mechanism and this is probably one of the best deduction games i've ever played if you can get your head around that those obstacles and get your head around that symbology that awful teach that steep learning curve but the actual core mechanism here the core idea about being these alchemists is great you know the theme is so uh it's logical and you can understand what you're trying to do in this game whereas a lot of games you can't do that and considering this is a it's pretty eurofied um you know it does a good job of still making that theme connect

with the mechanism so i would love to see a revamped version of version two or a second edition of alchemists so i hope you've enjoyed this video if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too additionally if you want to keep the channel going you can choose to back me on patreon and i'll leave the links below to to those so for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved