Skip to main content
Loading video...

"The Return of the Europhile" Top 100 Board Games 30-21

Transcript 22:46

hi i'm adam porter and this is my board gaming vlog and we're looking at my top 100 tabletop games dice games card games board games i'm not including any of my own games in this list but we're looking at games that i have found an emotional connection to games where i get an emotional reaction when i look at them games that fill me with joy or have a place in my heart or where i have really fond memories of them whether they are good games or bad games doesn't really matter the key thing is do i love these games and so number 30 on the list today we're looking at 30 to 21 and number 30 is my number one game of the year for 2020 and that's isle of cats so isle of cats is a polyamino game a tetra game where you're placing tetris-type pieces representing cute little cats onto a ship uh in order to transport them off this island it's got card drafting in it where you're picking up cards and then passing them on to the other players and then you've got to pay for these cards using fish um so you've got a little bit of currency going on and then you're placing them into your ship to try and cover up certain areas fill out rooms you you want to cover up rats which are going to be worth negative points but also the cards that you've drafted are going to give you scoring opportunities at the end of the game for gathering certain types of sets and things like that and also they're going to give you special actions that you can play so there's a good deal going on in isle of cats and lots of tetris type games around this is not the easiest of the bunch you know we've talked previously about the game patchwork that's a really easy polyamino game

this one's got a little bit more going on um and i think it's it's it's delightful it's so beautifully illustrated such a nice production um i i've played this a lot with my wife through lockdown you know that that early lockdown in march april may sort of time in 2020 we played isle of cats a lot we'd sit out in the garden and play it on the garden table and it really helped getting through those early sort of weeks so so i have a real fondness for the game and i think we'll continue to play it for a long time to come it's certainly one of my wife's very favorite games at this point number 29 is an unusual game this is the game serrano which is a a party game from repos and i don't think serrano will ever get produced again that's my gut feeling serrano is a a rhyming game so it's a game where you've got to write poems so i mean that sounds awful doesn't it but you get that is essentially what you have to do you get given a rhyme scheme so each time it'll say first line has to end with this second line has to end with this particular sound and then it'll give you a topic and then you've got to write a little ditty a little sort of four line poem so everyone sits down and writes it quietly and then you all reveal your poems and read them out to each other and you're looking for obscure words you score for having words at the end of your end of the sentences which no one else has used but you also score for writing good poems you will vote on which are the best poems um and i honestly think this game is hilarious it's it's obviously not for everybody

not everybody wants to sit around and write silly poems um but if you can find a group that is not um you know who is not inhibited in that way who is happy to make a fool of themselves happy to to do it badly because inevitably of course we're all going to write terrible poems if we just sitting around uh writing them under under pressure knowing that you're competing with other people and trying to use obscure words they're going to be weird poems but they are hilarious they are inevitably end up being really rude and silly i love to keep the poems that have been written um i can't see that this is a marketable game i can't see that there's this is ever going to sell a ton and so i that's why i say i don't think it'll probably ever see the light of day again um but it's a perfect game for me i really enjoy that sort of thing sitting down and writing a silly poem and then and then reading it out to everyone else and listening to what they've come up with just great great fun so that's serrano number 28 on the list is cusco which used to be called java in a previous edition i think cusco was the original name and theme that the designer wanted but it was changed by rio grande to java and so now it's with super meeple and it's gone back to the name cusco this is an action point game it's in the same series as the game tikal which we've talked about previously from wolfgang kramer and michael keisling there's quite a lot going on in cusco you're layering up the board i love that the different layers as you lay tiles on top of each other and you create these hills and and valleys in there and you're trying

to get your your people high up on those hills and they're gonna score um better for you if they're if they're in the higher positions but you've also got to control majorities around these various sort of um i can't remember what they are now are they temples or cities or something like that you have festivals in the game it's a bit more complex than tikal it's quite cut throat lots of scope in this for what we call analysis paralysis where players sit around and take ages to think about their turn while everyone else just sits and thinks get on with it you know lots of scope for that so you want to pick your players carefully when you're playing games of cusco or indeed decal but this is a game that really connected with me quite early in my in its jar original java edition um it really connected with me quite early in my sort of hobby experience you know of collecting these sort of games i i thought it was great you know and now this cusco edition from super meeple again just fantastic components and it just looks brilliant um so i've got a huge fondness for the entire trilogy but cuzco is my favorite um of the mask trilogy from wolfgang kramer and michael kiesling number 27 is lost cities a two-player card game where we have a series of different colors and each player is going to play cards against the different colors so you're attempting missions by going to these colors adventures um and you're using a shared deck of cards so if i'm scoring quite well in one color by placing different colored cards of different values on there then it's likely

that the other player has not got many of that cards so they're going to have to decide is it worth them going on that adventure at all because if you score low you actually get negative points you've got to score at least 20 points before you get into positive scoring so it's better actually to to not bother at all because then you'll get zero points um zero points is fine but as soon as you put a single card down there let's say i put down a five well now i'm scoring minus 15 points because i've got to get to 20 before i get into the positives so it's better not to go on that mission at all and that's the really intriguing bit about lost cities is deciding how how thinly do i spread myself over those missions or do i just focus on one or two of them where i know i can score really high but leave all the others at zero it's a really nice head-to-head it's quite a lot of luck in it in terms of the card draw and things like that but it doesn't matter it's a quick um a quick sort of card game it's a bit of a classic list from ryan iknitzia other good ones in this genre are shot and totten or battle line also by reinikunitzia and hannah makoji which we've talked about previously this genre of games and particularly lost cities um and battleline are the inspiration for my game compromat which is a blackjack game where you're playing hands of blackjack against another player two player card game where you're competing on various different missions so i'm really fond of this genre of games and there aren't that many entries into this into this style of game and there's there's a handful of them that you can get but lost cities is

right at the top of that list number 26 is the pirate game uh libertalia this in this game each player has a uh hand of cards which is each round and it's going to be identical for every player you take the same characters from the deck and every player gets those same characters and you're going to choose one of those characters and play it simultaneously with everybody else and then depending on what you've picked your actions are going to occur in a specific order so you're going to steal things from other players you're going to take the loot in the middle of the board and do various different things based on those simultaneously chosen cards but at the end of the round you can have a few left over and then they're going to be topped up the same cards topped up for every player so going into the second round you might have a slightly different hand to everybody else because you'll have kept slightly different characters to the ones that other people because you've chosen to use different ones and so gradually you start to diverge from the other players as you go through the game this really is um one of the best if not the best simultaneous action selection games uh games where we all sort of play a card together and then reveal at the same time those games can be quite frustrating because obviously if you through no fault of your own you choose the same as somebody else and then nobody gets it or you have to share the loot while somebody else goes off and gets loads it never feels particularly fair but libitalia gets away with that quite well everybody seems to get something do quite well and the powers on the cards are really intriguing and fun every game's different because you're using different characters in each round

and so it's it's a really good game it got quite a buzz when it came out i think it was 2012 something like that but it was only with a small publisher and it's kind of disappeared over the years since this is uh it absolutely you know desperately needs a reboot you know to be re-released with another publisher um because it could be really big it's a fantastic game it could do with expansions and all that sort of stuff but for now it might be a bit tricky to find but if you can get hold of a copy it's well worth it that's libitalia number 25 is saint petersburg now saint petersburg is um a card game a card drafting game you're buying cards um and then these these cards are going to continue continuously give you stuff so every um every round there's a certain thing that generates stuff so some rounds will generate um your production cards will generate and they'll give you whatever they give you victory points or money or whatever others your characters will generate whatever they generate or your locations will generate and this goes on predictably from round to round and you're going to gather up those cards and try and buy better and better cards from the display before the other players and ultimately you're trying to attract all these noble characters who are going to score you loads of points of having sets of different types of nobles it's paced a bit like a deck builder this is an engine builder through and through so you're buying up these cards and your rounds are getting better and better you're generating better and better income that allows you to buy better and better cards and so on and so forth the original

edition of the game has this really weird art style it looks almost like you know slightly childish the way that the pictures have been drawn um but it's very very charming uh there's an expansion which makes things just that little bit more interesting and then uh there was a big reboot a sort of crowdfunded reboot with you know fancy new artwork and loads of little mini expansions and things and i got all excited and backed it uh then when this arrived i had actually i sold off my while i was waiting for i sold off my old copy with this this weird artwork and when the new one arrived actually i didn't like it at all the artwork was really generic and boring it looked like loads of other games but it wasn't even that well done when you looked really closely to it and i really wished i had my old quirky version so i ended up having to go out and spend a lot of money to get a copy of this now long out of print original version of some petersburg but i'm really pleased that i did because i love that game i love that copy of that game and that edition of that game but even in the new edition if you can get past this slightly dull artwork it's it's a fantastic game and all actually some of those little mini expansions and things that were included uh were quite interesting i like the basic game but but you could do worse than picking up a copy of whichever edition you can get hold of number 24 is the game bandu or sometimes it's called bowzak now bandu and bowzak is essentially a game where you stack up a whole bunch of blocks of different shapes and it's originally from zok verlag

this game uh it's got tons of different interesting shapes i really like these wooden shapes but they do just feel like they've picked up a bunch of pieces off the floor of a carpenter's workshop and stuck them in a box um it's very similar to the game junk art which came much later and bandu to be honest i don't even play it with its original rule set i play it with an ultra simple rule set that i found online because to me the most fun thing in this game is just stacking up the pieces bandu's got a whole auction thing where you've got to you you select a piece and then you auction it off to the various different players um and and i can imagine that works fine junk art very similar game and this one's full of lots of different variant rules so every every round you play with a different rule set you draw a card and it tells you how to play the game um but i like the simplicity of just one rule set a simple rule set and and that's how i play i play bandu i tend to go for bandu over junkat i i think the pieces are just a bit bigger and chunkier um and and it feels all just a little bit more dramatic but i i can't really fault junk art i like the big wooden box that it comes in this is from the same uh publishers and design uh same publishers as flick them up i don't think it's the same designers um but it's again a sort of toy box full of building blocks um to play with um yeah i mean i mean that's it i'm not i i i shouldn't criticize the the rule set in bandu actually there are

multiple different rule sets in the game bandu as well and and the simplest rule set in there is very similar to the rules that i play so i suppose i'm playing with house rules really but it is a game that uh i've never seen go over badly i've everybody's always enjoyed it and it's a game where everyone always ends up getting their mobile phones out and taking photos of these towers that they've created i don't know why they do it as if anyone else is going to be interested in looking at their photograph of a tower um i do it myself though i always end up going wow look what i've built snap snap snap take pictures it's weird why people do that um but but it is something where you build something and you feel so proud you know of what you've achieved um i really like that i i found this game always goes over well so bandu or junk art doesn't matter which one you get but my my preferred option is bandu you'll get it cheaper um it's sort of become a bit of a bargain basement game i guess because junk art has kind of superseded it really number 23 is the game grand austria hotel this is a proper euro game i haven't had many of them on the list have i so far so this is a proper strategy game where you're um you're you're trying to draft cards you're you're having to supply them with various things whether that's coffee or wine or cake or whatever in order to persuade them to stay in your hotel and you're having to allocate them to a certain room and you're trying to build up sets and and things like this there's a dice drafting heavy dice drafting element to

it so selecting dice in order to take actions and the numbers on the dice and the number of dice in the space dictates what type of action you can achieve and so on the theme is not hugely interwoven into the game as you'd expect in a strategy sort of euro style game but it is it's a nice theme i really like the idea of running a hotel and the characters that come into it it's all nicely drawn by clemens franz it's a game with an odd turn order structure where you know if you play first then you're also going to play eighth which means you've got to wait seven turns before your next turn uh in a four player game and so with larger player counts if you're playing with slow players it can drag a little bit but actually it's a game that works really really well with two players or three players i don't mind playing it with four as long as i'm playing with the right people i've found it's a puzzle that just works with my brain something about my brain just clicks with it that doesn't mean i always win but it means i understand what's going on i know what levers i need to pull what strategies i need to try um and i just think it's a lovely um example of eurogames it fits in well with all that if you like games by uber rosenberg and those sort of things then you'll you'll you'll probably enjoy this one this is from the same designers as the designers of salkin and or some of them at least there's a big pool of designers um who've designed these games um zulkin and marco polo and you know a bunch of really popular um designs

that have come out over recent years um so i have a lot of fondness for grand austria hotel number 22 is another euro game this is bruges from stefan feld um this is a game that is full of different characters every card has a different character on it and every carat has a different ability uh the cards are multi-use you can use them to in all sorts of different ways discard them to get new um little people to use them to flip them over to become a building or spend money to make them a character but you've got to put them into a building some of them have straight up actions that happen the moment you play them others will have an action that happens every single round or or something that's an effect that's always um an ability that you now have as a player some of them are for end game scoring there's a whole bunch of little clearly with a stefan feld game it's always going to be like there's loads of different inter woven mechanisms and you can generate points all over the place but i just find this game has so much personality um and and so much variety because every single card is unique it's one of my very favorite euro games uh i i've been to the city bruges so so on a couple of occasions um so i have some fondness for it because of that although really this could be any city anywhere um there's a good degree of take that in the game if you want to play it like that if you choose to use those cards but you might choose not to um so yeah just just loads of variety i i i just find it's another one a bit

like grand austria hotel it's another one that just works for me the puzzle just makes sense and i enjoy the options that it provides me with number 21 couldn't be much more different this is rock paper wizard from whiz kids this is a pure take that game okay this is just a game of um essentially it's a simultaneous action game we talked about live italia earlier here we're casting spells on each other and the way you do it is by going rock paper wizard and then do some sort of motion with your hand uh and and you'll have various different spells that are laid out on the table in any given round with hand gestures associated with them and these spells are either going to push you ahead or push other players back and you want to be at the front of the pack to get some of that gold it's a game that plays really quickly it looks fantastic when players are all pointing at each other and doing different motions and different spells and some spells you do will counter other people's spells it's total chaos silly silly fun um simple rule set it just makes everybody laugh this was another one i talked previously about my experience with wizkids because i haven't i haven't played a huge number of wiz kids games but they created my game throne which is also quite a chaotic take that style game where you're you're you can you can really attack the other players and and there's loads of variety different cards laid out every round which makes every round slightly different and rock paper wizard is very much like that too it's a simpler rule set than thrown it takes a little bit less to learn

to play rock paper wizard but i love that chaotic sort of fun i've seen recently that there is a um a wrestling retheme of rock paper wizard a wwe i think it is a retheme of rock paper wizard that came out uh earlier this year so i'll certainly be looking up that one and trying to get hold of a copy okay so let's see what that's done to the leaderboard so starting with the publishers what we know is that between 31 and 100 rio grande and zok verlag were in the lead with five games each and then matako hansen gluck and schmitchspieler were following so what's happened now uh well that's changed a little bit zok verlag has pulled ahead with six games rio grande and hansen gluck now equal on five matagot smith speed have been met by games workshop and lookout who would have thought games workshop would be on my top 100 games uh to be honest i wouldn't even have guessed that but i was a big games workshop fan when i was a teenager and so so some of that nostalgia is coming back um i guess then with regards to designers uh so now moving down to 31 to 100 phil walker harding andreas seyfarth ryan kenitzy and wolfgang kramer and now at 21 to 100 reina kenitzia and wolfgang kramer route ahead with phil walker harding andreas safarth and michael kiesling following on three apiece uh so looking at themes well we had fantasy out ahead with nine then anthropomorphic animals with six uh ancient world with five and actually if you're looking at the

numbers 31 to 100 you can see that if we add together regular animals and anthropomorphic animals into one category then they're matching that fantasy uh i've kept them apart because they're different things really animals doing silly things and and just animals living as animals you know um but let's see what happens between 21 and 100 well fantasy is ahead still with 10 games um and then we've got the ancient world with seven anthropomorphic animals with six if we add them up with the regular animals then we're still at ten we're still matching fantasy but i've separated them out here so we've got fantasy out ahead with 10 games looking at game styles between 31 and 100 we had tyre laying ahead with nine games then time pressure with seven um so there's still space there for that to change let's see what happens thailand pushes further ahead tylene is now at 11 games in the 80 that we've looked at so far and then time pressure and area majority at seven apiece very different games aren't they time pressure and area majority uh you know playing games at speed that's more of a party type thing area majority really suggests sitting down and strategic thinking competitive type gameplay serious gameplay same with network building and engine building so it is quite an eclectic mix of games that we have here uh okay well thanks very much for watching the next video will be numbers 11 to 20.

Progress saved