Skip to main content
Loading video...

Broken Meeple Podcast - Episode 119 - BOARDGAMEGEEK TOP 100 (25-1)

Transcript 1:07:12

You're listening to the Broken Mele Show, a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them. My name's Luke Hector, best known for the Broken Mele YouTube channel, and I'm an everyday gamer just like you. And I'll be talking about reviews, top 10s, and just about anything that connects me to board games, as long as I have a tea or coffee in hand, that is. So, grab a cup, relax, and enjoy. And remember, it's only a game. Hi everyone, Luke Hector here. Yep. Not going to spend too long with updates and stuff because I a it's quite warm in this room again. It's uh we're in September. It's getting cooler, but it's not quite out of the sweaty weather yet. And also I know how long it takes to go through this particular topic, but uh yeah, things generally fine. But the main updates obviously I will be going to Essen um and shake battle and roll next month. I don't know about Handycon yet because Handycon's a little bit too close to Gridcon and Essen for my liking. So, I might have to skip that one, but we'll have to see. I have to play that one by ear. Maybe do it at the last minute if I decide to do it. But, I'll definitely be doing Essen. I'll do a preview episode maybe early next month. Uh, because Essen's not till late October and Shape B and Roll is just a nice small convention in Southampton anyway. So, I'll be there. That's not a problem. Uh but the main sort of update is that I will be taking a break at the end of this month to go to Prague. Yeah.

So I needed to use up some annual leave and I couldn't find a decent cruise. So I decided fine, let's do a city break. Let's take the week off, go away for about four nights, you know, Sunday to Thursday and just go somewhere, you know, go somewhere. So I decided Prague because I've been meaning to give Prague a visit. You know, everyone keeps raving about it. It's supposedly relatively cheap for food and drink. Um I'm not a history buff, so I'm not too interested in that side of things, but it looks like there's plenty more to do. Besides, look at museums. So, I'm totally down for that. And yeah, already got me flight, got me hotel and that sorted. And I'm trying to book excursions. So, I'm gonna go to Prague Zoo. Really looking forward to that. I've got a day out to the Bohemian border. So, we get to like we get a tour on boats and hiking and stuff to go look at really nice sites on the Swiss border. That's going to be good. Um I there's a medieval dinner that I'm going to go to.

Obviously, I know there's one or two board game cafes in the region, so I'll go pay them a visit. and I'll just do stuff, you know, I will just do stuff and tours and use up my days as much as I can as a solo traveler. Looking forward to it. That's at the end of the month. So, yeah, looking forward to that. But obviously, while I'm away, no recording. Um, if I've got videos done in advance, I'll release them because I won't be completely devoid of the internet over there, I'm sure. But, yeah, I'm not going to be recording anything while I'm over there. So, that will be a nice little break. Uh, other than that, I mean, games are incoming. Um, I've got a lot, you know, we've had a quiet period now. I'm actually getting stuff sent to me. So, you know, I've had Shallow Sea from Bad Comet, same people who did Amazonia and Wonders Creatures that I've got to look at. Uh, my table is currently set up with Don't Starve the Board Game. Uh, a preview copy from Glass Cannon Unplugged. So, I've had a demo of it already. I'm now going to give it the beans today and see how my thoughts are. And I'll do a preview video for that in the upcoming uh, weeks before the Kickstarter at the end of the month. Uh, what else has been sent to me? Um, well, the Garfield Games stuff still hasn't arrived. I think I'm getting that on Tuesday. It's the last time I order from the Garfield Games website. I mean, I should have if I just waited a week, I could have got it from Kiender, you know, and got it literally the next day or something, but I've had to wait ages for them. And they It's not like it came from New Zealand. It came from Greece, you know. So, end of August, I think I put the order in and we're already on the 7th of August. I'm not getting it for another couple of days. and all it had to do was come from Greece. You know, granted the prices

were fine, but I think um their delivery times could be somewhat improved when you've got a European hub, but oh well, chalk that down to experience. But that means that Anarchy and Scar Bray will be incoming very soon. And I'm also being sent AR's Dream by uh Alicat Games. So, this one was on Kickstarter. It's coming out at Essen. Uh, I'm quite interested to play more of this cuz I was impressed by the demo. So, Ador's Dream is incoming as well. So, yeah, there's quite a few games on the horizon for me to do some content on, you know, some of it Essence, some of it Kickstarter related. So, some new new stuff. So, by all means, uh, look forward to my videos on that. But other than that, on the channel, there has been some extra content since the last one. So, the Beyond the Base game videos for the Moon South Tigers have now wrapped up with the somewhat disappointing Moon Saga, but then I also did a a cheeky little review for an accessory called pickup, which let's just say it's neither particularly good. And yes, I am aware, you know, it's a weird little accessory that lets you pick up cards off the table with like an air suction tool.

Yes, I know there's a button on the top of the thing, but it's not the most obvious thing when you're using it. But even then, I mean, even if you take that into account, the thing is still a bit of a gimmick and not that useful. So, you know, check out the video if you want to see me go like crazy and have a little like minor meltdown trying to get this thing to actually do what it says it would. But yeah, I mean, it's an overhyped gimmick and not worth your money. Um, on top of that though, I've also done a review for Fate of the Fellowship. So, the big hyped game, the pandemic Lord of the Rings one, you know, not too bad. 4 and a half thousand views. You know, we can get that up, I think, for something like Fate of the Fellowship. But it's good to see that a lot of people have seen that one. That took me a long time to do. I mean, that's a nearly a 50minute vid. That's a 50-minute video. So, yeah, took me a long time to record that one, but there was a lot to talk about. And I've just recently put up a top 10 list. Although, it's not really top 10, it's more a list of 10, but it's 10 games I want to play right now. So, 10 games that I've been like, you know, I'd like to try these games for whatever daft crazy reason I have. And some of you have been like, "No, don't get out of there." And some of you have been like, "Yes, you must.

Yes, come precious." So, it's it's good to get your um interesting comments on those ones. But that's another top 10 list. So, you can have a look at that one. Uh so far, not doing too badly. You know, only came out yesterday and it's already on four and a half thousand. So, let's see if we can get that one up higher. But, yeah, generally quite a bit of stuff happening. So, holidays, conventions, games, you know, it's all happening. Oh, yeah. And I think I still need to do a a playthrough digital video for uh Canvas. Yeah, I've got the Steam key for that one and I haven't got around to doing the Canvas one. So uh yes, I will try to figure out how to do that one at some point soon. Just time time's a bit of a problem. September is usually quite a busy work month for me and it's not helped by the fact that yes, we are working from home a lot lately because they're doing some refurbishments around the uh side of the office building, but it does when you work from home. Yeah, I don't know.

Productivity kind of goes out the window when you work from home, but I do my best. So, yeah, that's stuff to come. Uh, that's about it. I don't think there's really anything else to talk about updates. Uh, my throat only lasts so long and these videos have taken forever to do. So, I think we're just going to be intelligent and go straight to the point of the video, which is we need to wrap up this uh top 100 BG. I mean, what I thought was only going to be one video turned out to be three now. So, we did 50 to begin with, then we did another 25 when I realized, wow, it takes me a while to talk about these games. So, I was like, fine, we're going to do it in three. So, we're going to wrap it up 25 to one. And I promise you, we are doing 25 to one. All right, we are getting this done. All right, so let's go to the list and have a look and see what we got. So, 25. Has it changed since last week? Nope. I believe I remember talking about the the god awful Concordia trigger. Um but we'll see what else we got now. So Clank Legacy Acquisitions Incorporated. I've not played this. It's it's a legacy game of a game that I'm not exactly a massive fan of anyway. I mean I don't mind Clank. I just don't particularly care about it. I hear this is a good legacy game for it though. Uh but other than that, I can't really tell you anything and I don't want to click on too many pictures because obviously that will spoil things. But yeah, just can't really say much about it. But I haven't got time for long campaign legacy games now. So I don't think this one will be one that I'll ever get a chance to play.

But if I don't get to play it, I'm not exactly going to lose sleep over it. All right. N sorry 24. A Feast for Odin. This is still on my shelf with the Norwegians expansion, but it has not been played in a long time. So much so that I don't think it's even in my top 100 anymore. Uh but it's The thing is though is I do like the game, but it's a bit of a chore to set the thing up even with the trays. I mean, you got all these different tiles and all these different pieces. I've got to relearn the rules a h 100 times every time I play it because it's got a lot of different rules in it or all these little things. And it's a bit of a chore to teach new players. I mean, if you play this three or four player, the game is going to take forever to finish. It needs the expansion and all to balance it out. Otherwise, it, you know, has fundamental balance issues. It's it's I mean it's a decent game, but I find myself I only want to play this solo because it's got a good solo mode in it and you don't have to put up with the AP of everybody else. But then if I want to get out a big U Rosenberg solo game, I would even play Civer solo before this one and even and Civer is not the best of solo modes, but I've got Fields of Al and Fields of Als like like curb stomps this thing. So, if I'm going to play one of their big ones, I'm just going to play Feast um sorry, not Feast, uh Fields of Ar. And if that's the case, Feast of Odin is just not getting played. But I don't want to sell it because it is a decent game when you actually get it to the table. It's just a case of getting it to the

freaking table because I just don't want to play it with multiplayer. It's too long and too drawn out. So, what to do with it? Do I hang on to it or do I get rid of it? It's a a decision that I am going to have to make at some point or another. Uh, and I say the game is fine, but I think people are a bit too forgiving of certain aspects of it. I mean, the occupations in it, you know, those cards are just not worth the money they're print the cardboard they're printed on. Even with the expansion, immigration is still a pretty strong strategy. It needed the expansion to make animals even remotely worth doing. It it say it's got some issues, but I still like it overall. It's just a bit drawn out. Okay. Uh 23 Nemesis. Some people love this to bits. I I I mean, I get it. I I get it why you why you love it, but I just can't. I can't. It's I tried. I even bought the entire set on Kickstarter to see if just having all the stuff would make me love it. And I mean, I appreciated it a little bit more, but I still got rid of that lot. I mean, I love Aliens and Adunion. I mean, I'm actually watching Alien Earth at the moment, trying to catch up with that series. But the, you know, the game Nemesis is basically Adunion the board game and, you know, great. And the new one, Retaliation, being like, Aliens the board game could be really good. I mean, I'm intrigued. But this game has some major major major problems. It's a massively long game for what it is, you know, which is basically an exploratory luck fest. Um, you could end the game in

three hours, you could end it in five minutes, depending entirely on luck of the dice rolling um with what what the aliens do. The secret agenda stuff is probably the best part of the game. Um, the exploratory part is kind of rinse and repeat, repetitive, and I say, you're trying to find stuff that's important for you, and you just can't seem to find it, you know, but somebody else can get exactly what they want. I mean, it doesn't feel very fair. Uh, but it's, yeah, I say it's got a ton of rules to teach. You might get knocked out of the game. I mean, there's actual player elimination in this game. I mean, imagine getting taught this for like 45 minutes and then suddenly playing the game for 10, 15 minutes and suddenly you're out because an alien queen showed up on your doorstep and killed you. I mean, it that sort of thing just, you know, rubs people the wrong way and it rubs me the wrong way. And and that's the problem I have. It's like it can be fun. and it has created some very good memorable games for me. But it's few and far between. It's too fragile. You you may get a really great game, but most of the time you will get a mediocre or ruined game. And I can't put up with that level of, you know, unreliability with regards to this. And I've played the other one, the what you call it, the the one that's basically taking the parodying Doom uh the red one. Um I forget what that's called, but it's the one set on Mars or something. And that one is fine. I mean, I think that one's a slight improvement over the original Nemesis, but that's it. I just I don't know. I can't get into it as much as everyone else, but not surprised it's up here. Frost Haven. So, basically, Gloom

Haven with uh white bits. I mean, that's kind of what it is. I mean, yes, there's a couple of extra mechanics in. I think you can do more building and stuff in here, but I never got into Gloom Haven. Gloom Haven was, you know, o massively overrated game for me. I mean, I tried it. I tried it multiple times, but scenarios would take forever to play in a group. I didn't like the whole hidden initiative system where I've got these moves, but I have to like guess whether you've got a 49 versus my 65. It's like, what what kind of co-op is this? Um the the the deck for die rolls, which is basically just a long-winded way of just doing a custom die mechanic. It's, you know, all these different uh like effects you've got to deal with. You know, a lot of rules, a lot of stuff. It's It's okay, but I just never really got into it, you know, the original Gloom Haven. So, I've not played Frost Haven, but I've no intention to cuz if I didn't like Gloom Haven, Frost Haven's hardly going to win me over and suddenly convert me. You know, there's a ton of stuff. You end up with this massive crate with all this stuff in it. You know, I mean, yeah, you're getting your money's worth, fair enough. But, you know, unless you've got the best insert in the world for it, and you have like a encyclopedic knowledge for how this thing works, it's just too much of a faf to get to the table. And I have no desire to get this something this long and this something this long, big, and over the top to the table to then commit to it for days, weeks, months on end. I just haven't got the time or the patience for it. Uh, so yeah, I was

never a Haven fan. And that's not really going to change. Uh 21 Seven Wonders Duel. It's an it's a fantastic two-player game. What more do you need to know? I mean, I think I talked about the uh Lord of the Rings version earlier. I like that one because it's 90% the same game, but I think the changes they made for the Lord of the Rings one with the exception of the science tokens is better than the original Duel. I I find the original better, so I've kept that one. With Pantheon, uh the expansion makes Duel fantastic. I can see that they're releasing Allies Essen this year, which is basically just 90% copying Pantheon, but there's a couple of extra bits in there as well. So, yeah, then they're naturally going to try and bring this on par with that one. But, doesn't matter what you do. I personally prefer Seven Wonders Duel. I think the uh the sort of military and the science and like, you know, how the game plays, it's just smoother and just, you know, is is more enjoyable in duel than it is in the Lord of the Rings version. But both are fantastic games. I just personally prefer this one. But in terms of two-player only games, this is just up there with, you know, the alltime greats. It is just that good, that cool.

I like playing it on BGA with a friend of mine quite often. I play it on the app um when I travel. It's just an amazing game. What more is there to say? Uh Brass Lancashier. You know what? I'm going to talk about this later, okay? Because we're going to get we're going to get to the other one as we already know. So, the fact that there's two on the same list, again, we're going back to this whole thing of the BGG system being broken. We'll talk about this one later because I'm not going to have it be anticlimatic. 19. Scythe. Scythe. I still have it on my shelf and I still enjoy it, but this one has definitely gone down over the years. It's just not as fun as it used to be. Um, it's still good. I mean, I still enjoy playing it, but I never seem to want to bring it out to the table. Uh, it it's it feels a kind of rinse repeat now. like it's got nothing more to show me in terms of its variety. Yes, I could add more of the Fenrris stuff to it. But when you play this game, typically you're playing with people who don't play the game very often, which means you can't throw in all that fenous stuff and expect people to get it. So, you've got I mean, you're lucky if you can throw in the first expansions with the, you know, the airship and stuff.

So, a lot of the times this gets played, it's the base set because people are being taught how to play it and all the stuff that can add more variety to this game never gets used. So, you're just playing the barebones game. And the barebones game is fine, but it does get a little bit sy. And uh out of the three original um Stonemar games, the ones where Stonear was actually making good games, um I mean, Vantage was fine, but it still has problems. Um you know, right when they were at their peak, this is the weakest of the three. I still prefer to play Viticulture over this with the expansion stuff. And obviously, I still prefer Wingspan. This is the one that is definitely kind of showing its age. Like it's it's good, but I don't think it can keep up because when you get a combination of the two boards, you kind of set yourself a game plan and then you just follow that game plan and see if it works.

There's no real sense of flexibility in your strategy or anything. You just get your faction, you get your boards and you realize, right, this is what I can do well, therefore I do that bit. Like there's no other flexibility. You can't do, you know, if I get this set up, for example, with the blues. I mean, what have we got here? So, uh, let's see. We got the blues with the, uh, what type of board is that? I can't read it. Engineering board. So, okay. So, building mechs is expensive and not very rewarding. So, I'm not going to build mechs. All right. You've got the trade on there, though, which is a nice action to have, but clearly it likes you to build. Okay. So, it wants me to build and it wants me to upgrade. Well, I think they are close to um oil um in the blue section. So, yes, I would probably do a ton of upgrading. And if I can move across the water and get to somewhere that does wood, it would be good to build the wooden buildings as well. So, there you go. There's my two things I'm aiming for. Pretty much going to try and survive without building mechs. Uh, get them by other means and not desperate to enlist. Okay. Well, there you go. Boom.

I mean, that's it. And I can't really flex anything. It's It's too rigid. So, I do like it still, but whereas I think I gave it a 10 out of 10 in its early day and obviously liked a lot of the sort of expansion content for it, this is dropping quite fast. It's, you know, I think we're down to something like probably an eight out of 10 at the moment. It's dropped at least a couple of points since its time and it's starting to show its age. Ah, sweating like crazy, so I desperately need a nice drink. Oh, but yeah, starting to show your age, Scythe. I'm sorry. Uh, this one's not showing its age. It's just god awful and I hate it. And that is Eclipse second. I don't care what the tagline is. Second dawn for the galaxy or whatever it it's it's Eclipse. I hate Eclipse. I've tried it. I've tried it six players. I've tried it lower players. I've tried first edition.

Granted, I've not tried it second edition, but I I mean, yes, I know Great Western Trail slightly converted me, but even then, I prefer to play the spin-off version of Great Western Trail, the New Zealand one. This isn't a spin-off. This is just the same game that still looks as garbage aesthetic-wise than it did in the past. I mean, look at this cluster. Can't swear. But yeah, look at this. Just like uninspired board with all this stuff on it. It's all over the place. Cubes, cubes, cubes. Your board being just a layer of cubes to deal with your income tracks. I mean, it's not doesn't even feel like a space exploration game. It feels more like a balance your checkbook in space, you know, the the game. And I just hate it. It takes forever. The technology appears randomly and you may or may not get it again by random chance. It takes forever to play.

It looks horrible. It's got all these fiddly pieces you got to do. I mean, I don't recognize what this dial is. This must be a second edition thing with these free dials. But, you know, you've got all these little cubes that you got to deal with. You've got all this stuff on the board. You can barely tell what's going on. There's not enough space for all the pieces and it's just a mess. But, I mean, that's from an aesthetic perspective. I find it's too long. I find it boring. The AP in this game and the downtime is off the chain. I hate it. I can't find a redeeming feature of this game. I would sooner play Twilight Imperium and I have problems with that game, you know? I just I I'll play Empires of the Void 2 long before I play something like this. It's just not a fun game. I don't like it at all. And there are people I know, even like Mark Danger, who love this game. like they will play it every chance they get and I don't get it. This is one of those games where I'm just like why do you like this piece of trash, you know, so much. I mean, it's so bad for me, you know, that it definitely would be in like my top 10 worst games. It's so bad that my intro video for the Kienda promo actually uses Eclipse Second Dawn as a scapegoat for basically a running gag. You know, say like, "Oh, they've got this in stock.

Oh, it's pretty terrible, but you might like it." You know, it's that sort of thing. So yeah, you like it, go play it. But for me, this doesn't deserve to be anywhere close to the top 100. Not even in the same galactic sector. Go away, Eclipse. Uh the original Great Western Trail. I think I've already talked about uh the other Great Western Trail on here somewhere. Uh I'd be surprised if I hadn't. Yeah, New Zealand. I'm not going to belabor this one too much. It I like it fine with in its second edition form. I hated it in its first edition form, but I still think um you need the expansion to it and even then it kind of pigeon holes you a bit into one strategy. But it's fine. I just much prefer New Zealand. You know, it this one I will play if need be. But New Zealand is long but knows how to end the game. This one kind of just takes forever to um like finish. Like it doesn't know if it wants to end it really quickly or end it really like long into the future. And you've only got three characters to pick from. two of them are kind of linked to each other. So, you're kind of like really only choosing between two sort of strategies or you're just doing a hybrid. I mean, it's fine. I don't mind the original Great Western Trail, but it doesn't hold a candle to New Zealand.

So, you know, if you're going to say, "Oh, which one do you have in your collection? Which one you going to play on a moment's notice?" I'm going to play New Zealand without any stretch of the imagination. All right. Uh, Castles of Burgundy. Loads of people love this game. I don't get why this is a Stefan Veil game and Stefan games don't exactly do well for me anyway. I have played the fancy new version. It is way too overproduced. That was a Why Awaken Realms did you decide to blame up the castles of Burgundy? It just doesn't warrant it. You know, way too expensive and way too much fast setting that one up. But I don't know. I just find this game kind of meh. I mean, you roll dice, you get tiles, you put them on hex's, and then, you know, you hope you've got enough luck with the dice to get what you need, and then the rest of it is just euro mechanics of, oh yeah, if I put this tile here, I get this little bonus, and if I put this on the main board, I level up a track, and there's just no there's no flavor in it.

There's no real theme. There's no, you know, sense of like progression or game arc or anything like that. It's just, you know, well, I roll some dice and I'll try to get little tiles and, you know, a nice little color on here and put this color next to this color and this color next to this color. And some of the colors are way too similar to each other in this game, which makes color blind people go off the like go nuts. It's just I don't know. It's just I don't get much out of it. It just feels dull, you know? I don't like hate it or anything. It's just so underwhelming. You know, people say, "Oh, it's amazing." Or, "I love it, and it's like number 16 on Board Game Geek." But I just don't really get it. It I mean, where's the Yeah, they came out with a new version, which turned out to make me rubbish. They had this um weird special version or whatever it was, um which didn't do very well either. And I can't find a separate listing for the Awakening Realms version, which is good cuz it shouldn't be like that. Um but yeah, this one just got blinged out like crazy. And I just don't get it. I don't get what the thing is because it's not even simple enough that it's like, oh yeah, this is a gateway entry game for like people. It's like, no, there's still a fair bit going on in this game that I would never throw this to a new a person new to gaming. There's way better titles to pick. Um, it takes way too long with three to four players. I think it's pretty much a two-player and community agrees with me on this. Look, it's a two-player best here. So, you got these ones here. So, what we got? Uh, forget solo. So, majority of people say best at two. A few people are fine with

it at three and then that drops quite dramatically for um you know four, but still I can't see why anybody would think it was best at four. That's just insane. It's definitely better at two players, but even then it's just not fun enough for me. All right, 15. Fruity ages. I I wasn't originally a fan of this game, but I've warmed up to it more. The fourth edition, I think, did a pretty good job of streamlining certain aspects of it, but I don't play it in its physical version. I only play this in the app version because Check Game Editions kind of shot themselves in the foot a little bit with this. You know, they created the game, which is fun. I do like this game. It's a fun card-based civilization game. I kind of prefer Nations as a tabletop version, but I still think this one's a solid game.

Now, this one is, you know, still good fun. Uh, but the problem is is that it takes a long time to set up. It's quite fiddly and has problems when you play it multiplayer um in the physical version, but they made themselves an app for this game which is so damn good that there is no reason to own a physical copy. The game is perfectly represented. It has a very good tutorial. It takes out a lot of the faffy bookkeeping with the whole um corrupted uh the corruption mechanic or whatever it is, you know, takes that out. Everything's calculated for you. There's challenge modes and stuff like that, even though I'm not that great at this game. So, I tend to play this on relatively low difficulties. And um is it was it who's this weirdo here? Um but the other than that, it's just like yeah, it's a good game. I like it. But I I do it on airflights a lot. You know, you you try to fly to somewhere like Iceland or somewhere in Europe. You set up a game of through the ages on your phone and then you basically finish by the time you land. you know, it's it's quite good because I don't play this at rocket speed. All right. Um cool. I'm sweating like crazy. Um so it's got like, you know, problems like that. It's it's interesting. It's it's definitely quite interesting, but the thing is is that the app is so good. There is no reason to sell physical copy. So you never see anybody play this in physical form. The app is too good. And if you are interested in trying out this game, I highly recommend you get the app because it solves all the problems with the game, leaving you with a good fun civ card game. But yeah. Wow. Talk about

destroying your own physical product with your own genius. I guess that's kind of like a weird way of going about it. All right. 14. I'm not a big fan of Twilight Struggle. Twilight Struggle. I mean, some people like it, but I I tried it. I've tried it, but it's just I find it boring. Um, it's not a theme that I'm particularly that interested in. I mean, obviously, it's GMT game, so nothing about their games looks aesthetically pleasing. I don't like the fact that you use a dice mechanic to deal with the space race as to whether you do well on it. I mean, what kind of you've got this very thinky two-player Euro game and then you throw in this weird dice mechanic for one of the key aspects of the game. Um, but the other thing is is that you can't play this against somebody who knows what they're doing if you don't know what you're doing because you need to know what these cards do in response to each other. And if one person knows them and the other person doesn't, that person is going to get creamed. There's nothing they can do about it. And so this thing requires very specific two people to play the game and I'm not one of them because I played it and just found it boring. Um it's not Yeah. And that's this is what worries me about the new um world order that's coming out from the creators of a tried it. It felt like it was just Twilight Struggle with extra steps and you know yeah you're just putting cubes on a map and doing this little back and forth tug of war political thing and it's like I don't know this one isn't as interesting to me as say Hijgemony was.

both in theme and gameplay. Well, this one again just isn't that interesting to me. You know, it's it's a product of its time. And let's face it, who the hell plays this right now? Uh you because some of these another problem with the BGG top 100. It's so out of date with a lot of this stuff. You know, Twilight Struggle, yes, was number one for ages. Why? Who the hell was playing this game that decided it needed to be the best game of all time? Because it wasn't being played by everybody. Most people won't have even heard of this game even now. It's just a game that was played to death by a small niche group of people who loved it so much that it ranks stupidly high. This is how exploitative the BGG top 100 list is. I mean, you know, I mean, you look at some of these, yeah, it's got like 51,000 ratings, which is a lot, but for crying out loud, that's been out since 2005. You know, some of these games have barely been out for like a couple of years and they've like you already got as many ratings or something like that. You know, this has built up over time, but I don't believe for a second that 50,000 people have played this and rated this as eight or above. No way. Loads of people haven't even played it. And who else is playing it now? I've never seen it played.

Haven't seen anybody get this to the table and play at a convention or anything. So, where people are actually playing Twilight Struggle, I don't know. Maybe there's an app version for this that's really good. But in physical form, far as I'm aware, it's fallen off the face of the planet. Uh 13. Guyia project. Uh Guyia Project. I mean, I already talked about Terabista. So, this one I do prefer it to Terrammystica, but I find that moving around the map is a bit confusing to see where you sort of got to go from A to B sometimes. But the problem is is that it's too much like Terrammystica. I mean, yes, it improves on certain things. Like the tech tracks are definitely an improvement. I do like that. But again, it's just I don't know. I just don't get much fun out of it. It's it's another one of these dry euros where the setting means nothing. I mean, for crying out loud, this used to be a fantasy setting with dwarfs and elves and hobbits and stuff. Now, it's space with various alien powers, and yet it's 90% the same game. I mean, for crying out loud, that it means that the theme literally means nothing and it's just an efficiency puzzle of tiles and victory points, which is okay, but that doesn't win me over as much, especially when the mechanics of the game aren't that interesting to me. I mean, it's very tight, very punishing. If you're in a bad spot at the start, like you can't share spots next to other players to get cheap buildings or uh if you don't, you know, level up as fast as other players, then you're going to lose. There's no catch-up mechanic in this. If you start off bad, you'll lose. End of story.

There's no, "Oh, I'm playing the long game. It will all be fine later." It's like, no. Did you do well at the start? No. Then you've lost. Have fun playing this for the next two to three hours, you know, or probably 3 hours plus easily. So, you know, this one just it just doesn't impress me. Um, the Terrammystica series, I get that some people love it, and I'm fine with one of them being on the top 100 because it is popular. Although, one of them being on the top 100. I mean, for crying out loud. I mean, what we got here? So, we've got Guaia Project. Oh, yeah. Eclipse. I can't believe it. I raved I ranted about Eclipse, forgetting that the first one was already on this list. This is how stupid the bloody list is. All right. Okay. Uh, where is it? I'm pretty sure Terabistic was on here somewhere. Maybe even Age of Innovation. That's what I'm kind of looking for.

Surely it was on. Yeah. So, here we go. So, we got Age of Innovation on this list, right? Okay. Uh, we have Terrammystica and we have Gaia Project. So basically, three iterations of the same game and it's on the top 100. Those are two slots that could be taken up by other good games. I hate the way this list is done. I just hate it. And I know I am sound like a broken record at this point, but I when I see people defend this list as being like a robust system, I do have to question what level the quaudes are on because they just clearly have no idea how this list should be run. They've got to be like BGG fanboys or something to, you know, defend the way this list is done. They cannot look at the same game being on the top 100 games three times over and call it fair. It's just not.

We've got two Gloom Havens, we got three Gu, we got three Terror Mistiggers, we've got two Eclipses, the same bloody game, we've got two brasses. And this works for me if I end up with three Great Western Trails or at least two of them. Um, you know, and it works the same for me. But the thing is, I look at the games I love on here. Notice one thing in common. They don't have a lot of duplicates all over the list, you know. They're all just one game, you know. Cool. Go figure. You know, and is there any is there any game that I love that's uh I mean, a Grippler is on here twice. I don't love it, but it's fine. All right. The Crew. Crew is a good example. Yeah, I think The Crew is on here twice. Yeah, that shouldn't be on here twice. I totally agree. It shouldn't be on here twice. They should just be Mission Deep Sea and that's it.

So, it's not like my games don't fall victim to this problem, but more often than not, it's games I dislike that fall on this problem. All right. Okay. Enough with ranting about those. Gloom Haven draws the line. Not much to say. I don't really care. I mean, this was like a mini version of Gloom Haven. Another small campaign, smaller box. It was popular because it was a smaller box, therefore it didn't require you to spend so much money in that, but I didn't like original Gloom Haven, so don't particularly care about Chaws of the Line either. Uh 11, right, we're almost on the top 10. 11. Sad to say, and this is definitely unfair here. Spirit Island. Spirit Island definitely be in the top 10 games of all time. Still love it. I haven't played it in a long time, though, I must admit. I just haven't had the time. Um, but I can play it on Steam. I can play it in board game version or TTS version even. And it's just a solid game. Really do enjoy it.

Uh, you know, hang on. I seem to have uh lost the picture. What's going on? Oh, no. Things just went in the wrong order for some reason. Uh, there we go. So, yeah, Spirit Island, the co-op game of taking a really cool spirit and, you know, going up against the invaders. Super puzzly, but super fanatic as well. like all the spirits function as they should from a theme perspective. It's tough. I only played this on lower difficulties because I frankly do not get how people beat this on things like difficulty 6 cuz it just throws so much rubbish at you. like the the stars have to align for you in every way to beat this on the higher difficulties or you've got to use the right combo of spirits or you have to play like your you have to do your progression in the exact same manner like and you've got to hope that you get like the best cards ever to get you past those high difficulties and that to me just isn't fun. Some people really like to decorate their mushrooms and that. So, I mean, the next expansion, I think that's still going to get released fine, despite the problems that have happened with Greater than game since the tariffs came into play. I mean, it'd be nice to get another expansion, although I don't think it's desperate for one cuz there's already a ton of content in it as it is.

But, it's still just a game that I love. It's a fantastic co-op game. It's in my top 10. I really enjoy it. I like playing it multiplayer with people who know what they're doing, but aren't complete trolls over it. But, I like playing it solo, true solo, one spirit. Just have good fun. And it's the fact that I got taught this so badly in the past which put me off playing it for years and then I thought, okay, I've got to return to this. And I did a massive I did a video like on why I returned to Spirit Island or whatever, you know, why I like Spirit Island or something ages ago when I when I went back into it and realized, damn, that bad teacher ruined like the chance for me to get into this game a lot earlier in life than I did. And it's just a really good game. Really solid.

I am sweating buckets down here. I'm going to need another shower after this. Yikes. Um, all right. So, the top 10 top 10 of the BGG list. And let's already get started on a rant here. We're going to cover these two. Um, no, we'll cover the we'll cover this later on um in terms of the main game, but um Dune Dune Imperium Uprising is at 10. Dune Imperium is at five. BGG, your list is so stupid. It I mean, for crying out loud, most people are playing the original one anyway because they've got that with the expansions, but Dune Imperion Uprising is the same game. It's literally Dune Imperium 1.3. There's like a couple of tweaks to the game and that's it. Anything else that's different is so minor, inconsequential, it doesn't matter. And yet, this gets to take up two spots on the top 10.

You cannot look at that and call it fair without being the most biased individual in the world. You know, if you want Dune Imperium to be at the top five, then fine, leave the first one there at five. This is an expansion effectively. It's effectively a standalone expansion. So, why don't we just have its own like why can't these sort of games be NA, you know, or why can't they just be folded into the same listing as Dune Imperium and just have them both basically register as five rather than a five and a 10? It It's just so unfair. And look at this. It's only got 13,000 people even voted on it. I mean, the original one's got 54 by comparison. So 13,000 people voted for this Imperium Uprising and somehow it's 10 in the top 100. I mean that is not even like, oh yeah, this game is so revolutionary and innovative. No, this is just Dune Imperium fanboys up, you know, rating this a 10 because they like Dune Imperium, you know, that's not exactly a fair consideration. I don't believe for a second. I have played Dune Imperium Uprising. Okay. And it's, like I say, it is the same game. And I think it's even weaker than the original game, which I don't I'm not a massive lover of Doom Imperium. I mean, I totally rated it too high when I first reviewed it, but you know, now it's a six out of 10 if it's lucky. More a five out of 10. I find it average at best. I mean, the game your gameplay is solely dependent on your your deck. I mean, you will not win this game if the cards just don't come out of the deck in the order you want them to.

The deck building feels like a afterthought because it's more about the work of placement and you know the first expansion just made it too combat heavy or was already combat heavy. The second expansion I thought was fine. It made the card system better which is the bit I wanted to be better but then doing Imperial Uprising comes out and it just basically goes, "Oh, did you think it was too combat heavy? Well, now combat is so damn important that you will not win this game if you don't get involved in combat. Get those sand worms." You know, it's it's insane. And I don't like the fact that there's two of them on the top 10. That just really irks me. But doing Imperium, look, if you love it, fine. But it's average for me. I don't think it should be the top 10. You want to put in the top 100, fine. But top 10, no. This is overrated like crazy. I don't even like the Dune movies. Dune movies, boring, take too long, drag out.

I mean, it doesn't start getting remotely interesting in those f recent two movies until about twothirds of the way into the second movie when uh uh the trades or whatever his name is um uh starts going through his little transformation period. That's when it starts getting a bit more intriguing. But everything before then it's like could we have wrapped this up in an hour and a half because this is taking forever. You know, it's just so drawn out. All right, nine. Star Wars Rebellion. I do like Star Wars Rebellion. is on my shelf. I've not managed to play it very often because it is a massive game. But I did play it a couple of times, you know, a few times recently at Handycon and a local club because somebody else wanted to play it. So, I did have to relearn the game effectively. But when we played it, I remembered why this is a great fun game.

Now, should it be nine in the BG top 100? Hell no. Because most people are never going to play this game. It's too much for a lot of people. Plus, it's two-player only. you know, if there's a solo mode, it's unofficial and probably not worth it, but um you know, yeah, that you need two players ideally going at each other for this. Well, not an easy setup to get with this one. So, it's a very great fun game, but it's also not very practical, you know, to get it played, but it is good fun. I mean, it's Star Wars in a box. You've got all the different characters, all the different events. You tell your own story. It's uh great little bluffy tactics from the Rebel Alliance and the sheer overwhelming strength of the Empire and you know trying to capture each other's leaders and sabotage the others. It's just a really good two-player back and forth. Although does need the expansion. The expansion is kind of essential for this one. I don't know if I'd want to play it without it.

You need to get Rise of the Empire because not only does it add more variety, but it also revamps the combat system. And the combat system in the original is not the best. I mean, I'm kind of surprised that this is rated nine out of like the BG forever when the combat system was as weird and clunky as it used to be. You know, this expansion completely revamped it. Always use the expansion version of the combat and don't look back. But it does mean you need to acquire both before you can really get into this game. But I've had good fun with it. You know, it's on the shelf. I don't want to sell it. It's a great game. It's just one that's not going to hit the table very often, but when it does, boy is it fun. War of the Ring Second Edition at number eight. I like it, but No, no, wrong page. Well, I mean, I tried it. I bought it so that I could try it. And yes, I get why a lot of people like it. It's a two-player back and forth big epic Lord of the Rings, you know, card play, you know, strategy, tactics. There's a lot of good stuff to like in here, even if it's aesthetically a bit of a dog's dinner. Um, but the problem is is that it's just too much.

Wow. I mean, you know, I played the second edition of it. It takes forever to play this game. Like, the game is like a 3 to four hour slugfest. The rules are quite expansive. There's no way to learn this game easily. I mean, you are just floundering around the place because you don't know what you're supposed to do in order to do well. It's got a huge learning curve. And so a person who knows what they're doing versus somebody who doesn't know what they're doing is just going to absolutely m Yeah, there's two kids there. Those two kids are not playing water. All right, this is lit. There's no way they are playing this and having any idea what's going on. That's just setup. But like I said, it's it's good. It's a good game. I have no problems with the game. It's just incredibly impractical. Like there was no way I was ever going to get this played. played it a couple of times and just found it, wow, this is long. This is impractical.

Never going to get this played. What am I supposed to do? And I just gave up on it, you know? I decided, look, get rid of this. I get why people like it. It's just never going to get played if I hung on to it. So, I just decided, you know what, let other people enjoy it, you know? So, I give this one respect. I just don't find it personally a top 10 worthy contender or one that I would ever really be able to play myself. Like I say, like it if you like it, though, because I get why you like it. Okay. Uh, number seven, Terraforming Mars. I didn't like this one at first. I now find it above average. You know, it's I warmed up to it over time, and it's a decent enough game, but games like Ark Nova and a few others just do what this one does better, honestly. Um, you know, you've got all the different expansion maps and all that lot, but it doesn't really change the game up that much. It's just, oh, the objectives are slightly different in this game. And oh, the map layout. Oh, there's a little ice glacier over there. Yay. I may or may not care about that. Oh, the oceans are organized in this pattern rather than this pattern. Yay. You know, it's like big deal. The expansions, Venus just adds more cards and another track. I don't mind Venus, but the problem is is that if people concentrate a lot on the Venus stuff, you're not accelerating the game end. So, it takes longer. So, then the expansion not turmoil. Turmoil was a garbage fest.

What was the Prelude? So, Prelude came out and fixed a few problems. It gave you starting setups and quickened the game because you got going faster. But then Colonies came out and undid all the goodwill that Prelude had because as much as the Colony stuff is fine, it's easily exploited. Um it's it's more table space, it's more FAF, more rules. Sometimes you will get planets that just don't work together. Sometimes you get the best planets ever that just become, you know, exploited to the max. And I a lot of the times I'll just ignore the colonies. You know, when it's there, it's like I can't be bothered to do colonies because it's just another bit of faf. I'll just carry on doing other things in this game. So really, my preferred way to play this game is uh normal plus prelude. Um I'm happy to throw in Venus. And to be fair, a few of us play this. When I get to play this, typically I'm playing it on the app, the Steam app. So, when two friends of mine play this with me, we play Prelude and Venus, and that I think works fine. I think that's enough variety and enough stuff to keep us going back to this game every now and again. Certainly, if it froze in Prelude 2, not going to complain. But I just don't particularly care about the Colonies expansion. It just makes the game longer and more faffy, and I don't really need that. And Turmoil.

Turmoil, what a stupid idea. here. I mean, turmoil basically adds at least a good 40 minutes to your play time and adds this side mechanic that isn't even relevant to the thing that you're doing in this game. It's like h I don't know. It's trying to insert cor like the actual corporation voting boards and stuff. It's just not needed. I say I like it okay now. But top 10 ever? No. I mean, it's popular enough to be in the top 10 of all time, but for me, it's not enjoyable enough to be in the top 10 of all time. This has been supplanted by the games. We'll get to one very soon. But yeah, I've warmed up a bit more over time. Uh, Twilight Imperium. I mean, Twilight Imperium is what it is. It's a big grandiose giant game that I'm pretty much never going to play. It's, you know, it's it's fine. It is what it is.

It's a big space epic game. Um, you know, there's a reasonable amount of, you know, luck involved at times. Uh, it's bit of a balance issue when you have players who know what they're doing versus players who don't know what they're doing. There's a ton of rules. There's a lot of downtime, a lot of AP that will take place. The game basically involves you getting into a massive cluster into the middle of the board at which point there's not enough pieces, not enough space to put all the pieces on. Um, you know, I mean, all this stuff just looks a mess when you look at these photos. It's just like you can't tell what's what at all. Uh, the technologies are range from not worth the cardboard they're printed on to stupidly overpowered. You need them all the time. Some of the factions are definitely more powerful than others. It and it takes like 6 to 8 hours to play the freaking game. I mean, this whole thing of, oh yeah, you can play in three to four hours tops if you play the fourth edition. Yeah, good luck trying that.

All right. You know, super rare does that ever happen. It's it's okay. Hey, I mean, I've got the Twilight Imperium rolling right on my shelf. And to be honest, I'd rather play that. I'll get it done in a short space of time and I can play it solo and still get the feel of, oh yeah, I've got all this stuff I can do with a space alien faction and stuff. But again, if I'm going to play some space epic game that involves dudes on a map going out into space or whatever, then I'm just going to play Empires of the Void. Frankly, I much prefer that one. I don't know what's going on in this game. How did the purple manage to get all the way to the middle and hold it with such a force when everybody else is just doing nothing? that doesn't make any sense. But, you know, it's it is what it is. It's just a game that's not for me. I'm not saying the game is bad. I'm not saying it's a a terrible game or anything. I get why it's popular, and I get why people like it, but it's just another one of those games that's just too big, too long, and too. And it's not like, oh, you don't like heavy games. I like heavy games, but it's not so much that it's a heavy game. It's just that there's a, you know, bunch of fiddly rules in it. And then you've got to play this for a like 480 minutes. I mean, this is 4 to6. What's this? This is uh 480. So 240. So I mean 180 is 3 hours.

So 24. Yeah. So 4 hours. 4 hours to about 5 and a half hours or something, right? I mean, for crying out loud, the game does not need to take that long. And for the time length you play this, you could easily condense this down to a 90minute 2-hour game if you trimmed some of the fat and made it in quicker or something because frankly there's not enough like mechanics or stuff happening in the game to warrant it taking so long. A lot of it is just downtime waiting for stuff to happen. And again, if you are caught at the back early and you have no stuff compared to everybody else, you will lose and you are just sitting there in pseudo knockout mode just going with the flow with no desire to do anything because you know that what you do isn't going to matter.

That's not good game design. All right. Uh Dune Imperium. I've already said my piece. I' Whatever I've said my piece on that Gloom Haven, I've already talked about Gloom Haven, you know. So, you know, five for Dune Imperium, four for Gloom Haven. I'm just not interested in Gloom Haven. I said my piece on that when we were talking about Frost Haven. Right now, for a game that I I mean, should it be in the top 10 of all time? I mean, I love it to bits. It's my favorite game at the moment. I just play it continuously on BGA with friends and in person. Like, I've played this a good 170 times. And given someone like me who has to play a lot of different games and you know has full-time job and lives alone and stuff to play a game that many times as big as Ark Nova is saying something. But if any game I'm going to love being in the top 10 of all time, it's going to be this one. U I don't like the fact that it says reimplemented by Sanctuary on there. Sanctuary is a very different game if you look at how it's played or something. So I'm not gonna go saying that that is reimplemented by anything. But I still yet to try Sanctuary. But the reviews have not been great for it. So, uh, I'm a little bit hesitant to really get hyped for it. But I will try it. I will I'll try to grab a copy of Essen. I will play it and I'll do a fair honest review for you. So, if it turns out to be rubbish, I will tell you it's rubbish.

So, that's how I roll. Um, but yeah, Art Nova, I love this game. I just love it. I just can't say enough good things about it. I play this all the time. It's got a great BGA implementation with Marine Worlds. The Steam app really good. It's just a shame that the Steam app doesn't have marine worlds, and it probably won't for ages. So, that is holding the Steam app back. But being able to play against the AI and do the challenge modes and stuff on the Steam app is still really good. I mean, I've done playthroughs on it, so you can watch my videos to show how the app works. I just love this game. I like nature themed games. I love zoos. I mean, I said I was going to Prague. I'm going to go to Prague Zoo, and I'm really looking forward to that. You know, go see lots of different animals. But I love the mechanics in this game. I mean, it's a card tableau game, but it's also got this typewriter mechanic with the action cards. Like, I need to let this action card build up. Is there any way that I can do shenanigans to try and flip one card over and move it over down? I love that mechanic, but there's a lot of different ways to play the game strategy-wise. You know, the objectives that you get are certainly going to gear you into certain ways, but you don't have to aim for the green objectives that are there. Sure, it helps, but I've won the game plenty of times without going for any of those green starter objectives. If you found other green starter object um green objectives in the deck that work better for you, go down that route. And you know, there's a lot of different little nuances to think about. And I actually do care what the opponent's doing because I need to know if they're likely to snipe animals of the display I want. I need to know if they're likely to cause coffee breaks

when I don't want them to. You I need to see how many points they've got. You know, are they likely to trigger the end of the game before I do, in which case, how many turns do I think I got left? It's there's a lot of stuff I actually do care about what the opponent's doing in here. It's I like I love the sort of photography artwork for all the Yeah, the photography stuff for all the um animals and stuff. It's it it's got a good theme. I just love this game. I love it. I I It's difficult to sort of say anything else about it in terms of praise. I just get a kick. Like this is a game that despite being a good two to three hours long, if you're playing it with more players than that, I will gladly say, "Right, we've uh done this. Shall we reset and go again, chaps?" I could play this game three, four times in a row, and I think I have played it three times in a row before um and be perfectly content. I would gladly play this multiple times in a row, and the game has to be a 10 out of 10 for me to do that. And it has to be one of my favorite games of all time for me to want to do that. It's just so convenient to get this one played. And that does help. You know, it's a long game and it's not one that I particularly like to teach players because it's just a bit too uh shall we say um uh you know, a bit too much at the moment, you know, like to try and teach new players. I much prefer to play it with people who sort of know what they're doing. But I can play this with people at my club. I can play this on BGA with friends I know. I can play this on the Steam app.

I can play the solo mode if I wanted to on the app or in physical in person. It's the fact that this is a game that I enjoy that I can play as often as I want. Now, the whole 3D edition thing, I'm not interested. It's too much. Too much money, too unnecessary. It's just going to get in the way. More storage. I love the game to bits and I play it a lot, but I play it more in computerized form at the moment than I do in physical form. So, again, that factors into the money cost, but it's just too much money for unnecessary acrylic and 3D buildings. Now, I do probably want those um uh the BGA maps, the the variants of the normal maps. I'm probably going to get those. And I certainly would like those player boards. Those player boards look pretty sweet for this game. So, I am definitely down for that. But apart from buying some of the add-ons in that Kickstarter, I don't think I'm going to buy any of the 3D stuff. I'm just like, it's too much money. It's unnecessary.

You don't need it, you know? So, I'm I'm done with that. But oh man, I love this game so much. This should be number one on Board Game Geek. Okay, probably it shouldn't be. Something like Ticket to Ride should be number one on Board Game Geek because yeah, you might think, "Why Ticket to Ride? That's not the best game ever." Yeah, it's not the best game that I want to play ever. But think about a game that has stood the test of time. It's still played to this day. Still gets spin-offs. It's still a great Christmas present to buy people. Still gets played by my family and friends. Still gets played at game clubs. Something like Ticket to Ride is the sort of game you should have on a ranking list like this. Unfortunately, BGG is, as people are going to point out, and I know this, I'm not blind. It's a gamers list. It is purely based on diehard dedicated board gamers who make this list what it is. And this is coupled with the brokenness of the system itself. So, it's it is what it is. There's not much we can really do about it. Uh, but you know, Art Nova being at number three, happy, but I would like to see it creep up a little bit more because Pandemic Legacy Season 1 at um, I'm not going to I need to open it in a new tab. That would be better.

Yeah. Number two, Pandemic Legacy Season 1. It's definitely the best of the Pandemic Legacies. I mean, the second one was fine. It was something different, and I didn't particularly like season zero. I've done reviews on them all, so by all means, go check them out. Um, but number one was definitely the best of them. It did it first. It had the best of the stories. It was streamlined as much as it could still have the added bits added in, you know, like thrown in. And, you know, I won't spoil too much or anything like that. You know, you got these little guys. I won't say much more. I mean, to be fair, I'm not really that fussed about spoilers here. I mean, for crying out loud, if you haven't played Pandemic Legacy by now and it's been out since 2015, then you've kind of only got yourself to blame at this point. But it's, you know, it's a it's say it's a good game. I enjoyed my time with it, but I am done with these legacy games now. I don't think there's going to be a legacy game where I'm going to be that interested in playing it. Uh, you know, I think the fad is now died. You know, very few legacy games are coming out at the moment, as far as I'm aware. And if they do, they're ridiculously overpriced nonsense like Aridia and stuff like that. Was that a legacy game? I don't know. But like I say, big, expensive, and unnecessary. Um, so this one was great at the time, but I wouldn't play through it again. I'm not going to play any of the others. I'm kind of done with Legacy. So, it's had its time. I can see why it would be high on the top 100 because it did have such a big splash. I mean, a lot of people have played this.

You know, there's no surprise about that. I mean, you know, 56,000 people have rated it. So, it's it's definitely a solid game. You know, should it be number two? No. But at the end of the day, I enjoyed it and it was very popular. So, it's no surprise that it's there. But I'm done with Legacy. And then Brass Brass at number one. I have tried to give this game a chance, people. And I don't hate it, hate it, hate it, hate it. But I just generally don't like it either. It's I don't like the brass games. I mean, the new artwork version is definitely the way to play it. Okay. They definitely streamlined some aspects of it from the god. I would say I hate the original version. the original one that was in yellow or whatever. Like the mustard brass or whatever that was. Yeah, that that one. No. Um, this new version is definitely the way to play it. And I would probably rather play Birmingham than Lancaster overall. I think I think the flexibility of the uh booze, the beer that you can make gives you something else to aim for rather than just coal and iron again, you know, and focusing on that sort of thing. So, it's a bit more flexibility in Birmingham. Should Birmingham and Lancaster be on the same top 100 list?

No, because other than a few tweaks, they are essentially the same game. Again, this is the Dune Imperium argument. So, if you want Brass to be at number one, if you really must like, you know, force me to accept that Brass is at number one, then at least put both of them at number one and don't have Lancasher taking up a spot. But the problem is is that I just don't I just don't like this game. It's It's not a theme I care about. I'm done with Industrial Revolution. Yeah. Yeah. Transporting coal and iron on little canal tracks and trains. Ain't trains so much fun. No, trains aren't fun. They're not fun in real life. They're not interesting. And I don't like them in games. So why on earth are we like, you know, caring so much? Yes, I know. I like Ticket a Ride, but you could make Ticket a ride about buses and it would still work. It doesn't need to be trains. And let's face it, you don't really play that for the theme of trains when you play Ticket to Ride. But, you know, with this one, I mean, I don't know. It looks cool on the table, though. I mean, I do think the artist deserves a raise for how they managed to make something as dreary as the 1800s actually look beautiful on the table. So, I'll give you that. I'll give you that as a visual splendor, but it's it's very punishing. I mean, people can just completely alienate you out of the game like that and you get put in that pseudo knockout situation where you just can't do anything. In which case, why are you even bothering playing? In terms of strategies, particularly in Birmingham, I find that the only thing that's worth doing is the beer and maybe or alternatively focusing on coal or iron, you know, as like this is the main

things you build. I don't find the cotton mills to do very much in Birmingham. I certainly don't think the manufactured goods do anything in Birmingham. I think the manufactured goods are actually really terrible. You know, you just don't get enough stuff for building the things. Um, when you know, the amount of stuff that's required to build them, you just don't get enough back in return. I find that beer seems to always do me well. Like if I ever win this game, it's because I've invested heavily in beer because, you know, you need like other players need to buy beer at times to do stuff. And same with coal and iron. I mean, if you focus on one of those three things, that tends to be how you do well in this game for me because people need to buy it off you. So, you make money, you make points and stuff by people utilizing the thing that you've built. Um, so it just seems to work better for me. But I don't know.

It's I just I've tried it a few I've tried it multiple times and friends of mine love this game so they love playing it. I do love the poker chips. I use them for over and stuff. So the clay chips are fantastic but I don't know. The gameplay itself just doesn't interest me. I I mean it doesn't take too long to play. It's a two to two and a half hour game. So at least it doesn't outstay its welcome too much but it will outstay its welcome if you get into a situation where you just can't do anything. I don't like these middle buildings. you know, it's the cotton millings, but really it's just build build coal or iron or beer. That is what I do in this game, and it seems to that seems to be always the way it works. I don't like the fact that the card system um dictates a lot of what you're allowed to do, and that's just luck of the draw. So, he's like, "Oh, I really need to build this in this situ in this city right now, otherwise I'm toast. I should totally do that, and I have the means to do it. I have the resources. Oh, but I didn't draw the card that allows me to do it. I am dead." you know, it's like that that just rubs me the wrong way as well. So, it's it's it is what it is. I love how it looks. It's a beautiful looking game despite its theme. I love the covers and stuff like that. And I know they're doing another brass as if, you know, that's going to be the same game with extra. I mean, that would be interesting. Could they pull like a New Zealand and make a brass that I love to bits and suddenly I'm like, "Oh, I'm fine with brass now. This spin-off fixed all the problems I have with the game."

Doubtful. I very much doubt it. Uh I can't see brass doing that for me, but you know, it's it is what it is. It's a game that I think is overrated. I don't hate its guts. I just I mean, I I remember reviewing it and giving it a six. Like I thought this is above average. You know, I can say some good stuff about it, but that that rating has now dropped. It's probably a four now for me. It's below average. You know, it's it's not a game I can get into. It's not a game I ever want to play. Whenever I'm the one who has to when four of us get together and play on Fridays, um if I have to be away on holiday or doing something else on a Friday, that's the time when they tend to get me up as a free and pull out brass because they know that I don't want to play it. So, yeah, they get to play brass when I'm not around. Perfectly fine. We get to play good games when I'm around. Um but sometimes depends. Um but the this one Oh, yeah. Was it Pittsburgh?

So, this is going to be a new one. And I mean, it's a nice cover. I give you that. But that's all I really have to say in it. And the thing is, what's going to drive my like do my head in with brass Pittsburgh? You just wait. You just faking wait, right? We've already got Brass Lancasher at 20. We have Brass Birmingham at one. Watch Pittsburgh get to number one. Watch it get to number one and push Brass Birmingham down to two. Watch there be two brass games in the top 10. Watch there be free brass games in the top 100 and top 50, top 25. I kid you not. This is what this system is going to do. I guarantee it will happen. You can quote me on that right now. You know, that is my prediction. We're going to get three brass games in the top 25 and it's just going to highlight even more how broken this list is.

Anyway, rant over. So, yeah, there we go chaps after another hour. That is with a lot of sweat and tears. That is the Board Game Geek top 100. That is my views on a lot of the games in it. And I say there's a lot of games I like in the board game top um 100, but there's a lot of games I don't like at all. And obviously these are the games that are going to be overrated or you don't want to play as much and stuff like that, you know, just generally. Uh so there is that. But yeah, the the system itself is what drives me nuts. The fact that the system is so broken. I mean, I use Board Game Geek a lot, but mainly as a database for files, rule books, um, insert designs, uh, you know, dividers, that kind of thing, and also as a database to find out information about a game, you know, and it's useful online.

I do not think it is a robust ranking system. I do not think it's a good forum for talking about stuff because the I mean, as we know, you know, BG is privately run. So when you look at board game geek, it is entirely biased to not only the same board game creators. I mean when you look at the explore bit and you know you look at like the featured videos, it's all brothers murf and game night. That is basically what it is. It's just always like those two practically you know so they are it is run by a biased group. Okay. And with the controversies that have happened in recent uh months and stuff, if you go onto the forums on this uh site, you will notice that uh there is censorship and uh deletion of comments and stuff if you don't vote the same way that the makers of the site do. So they do actively have a bias with stuff, which is a problem. That is not a fair forum to meet if that is the case. So, there are problems with this site as much as I use it. It's it's kind of the fact that if you don't use it as a database, how the hell are you going to find out about games? It's, you know, it's and they know it because it's the monopoly, you know, you have no other means to find out about this stuff reliably. So, if you don't use it, what else are you going to do? You're caught in the trap one way or the other. But as say it's fun to talk about those hundred games.

So hopefully you've got some insights into what I think of them and what I think of the list in general and what games I like and dislike. Uh so all good there. But I'm hot. I'm sweaty. Uh it's time to wrap up this video. So we'll talk about something different on the next video. We'll talk about some other types of games and eventually we'll get on to prepping for Essen. So take care and remember as always, regardless of my blood, sweat, and tears, it's still only a game. So, bye for now and I'll see you on the next brokerble podcast.

Progress saved