Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Games of 2024 Revisited - with Mike DiLisio

Transcript 9:50

Hey there everybody, it's Mike Delissio and as we get closer to the end of 2025, one of the things that several of us at the Dice Tower like to do is look back on what our top 10 games of 2024 were, revisit them, now and kind of see where they line up as of today. One of the things that I like about these types of list is that they reinforce this notion that reviews, rankings, lists are really snapshots in time. And at the time that we make these lists, at the time that we film these reviews, that's how we feel at that moment. But throughout time, things can change. And they have changed. In my case, um, in in my list, there were three games off my top 10 of 2024 that dropped off. I'll mention them briefly. I like all three of these games that fell off the list. I still like them a lot. They'd still be, you know, high up there uh for last year's list, but they fell off for one reason or another. Number one is Nova Roma, a terrific uh Euro game. Uh, number eight is Cascadero, which is another wonderful Euro game. And number six is yet another wonderful Euro game. Ezra and Nehemiah.

Well, if they're so wonderful, why did they fall off? Any number of reasons. I'll explain some of the reasons as we go through, but let's just get right back into 2024 through the lens of late 2025. At number 10 is Tidal Blades 2. This was number nine last year, so very little change. I think the only reason it may have gone back one spot is that it's unlikely that it's going to be coming back to the table very often as I've played through the campaign, but still just a really ter terrific cooperative um campaign game where there's just it's not it's not like many of these kind of campaign style games. Has a beautiful world building. Number nine is new to the list and this is Rebirth. This is probably the reason why Cascadero fell off. there by the same designer, Reinher Canitzia. And Rebirth is had its uh kind of jump into this list because it is really so approachable. I've taught it to so many people. It's a very simple game. It's a tile laying game, which uh this designer is well known for. But the way it works is that you've got a random stack of tiles that are all face down.

On your turn, you pick one of them, you look at it, and you play it immediately, and you score immediately. It's a point salad type of a game where every turn you're going to be getting some points. It's incredibly satisfying. It's such a smooth and elegant design. Two sides of a map, one side being more basic, the other side being more advanced that you can kind of tailor to your play groups. Number eight is Kelp, which was number five the year before. So, still a terrific game, a twoplayer asymmetric game where one player is playing a shark, the other player is playing an octopus. They both have different win loss conditions and mechanically they play very different, but they're both on the same shared board and the things that they're doing obviously are going to impact the other player. Uh really still a very impressive design, very clever game that is Kelp. Number seven is new to my list and that's because I had not played it. It came out kind of right at the end of last year and that is Endeavor Deep Sea. This is a wonderful uh Euro game with a theme that I really like of kind of deep sea exploration. I love that theme. It's not done not often enough. I think in my mind, this is a game where you've got kind of a modular board setup because the spaces or the board I guess is made up of tiles that are going to come out and it'll be different uh depending on which game you play. And it's just a really clever system. It's an iteration of a game I never did play called Endeavor: Age of Sale, but I like the

theme on this one so much more. So, I'm not sure I even need to check out that other one because I like this one so much. [snorts] Number five is down a couple of spots. It was number four the year before and that is unconscious mind which is a really heavy crunchy euro game where you are kind of in the world of uh psychiatry and and um Carl Jung and Freud and uh it it really that's the theme and the theme I think is there more than maybe some people think it is but it's really a really crunchy heavy Euro game still really solid just it's harder to get that one to the Number five was number three and this is Atlas Lost. A terrific terrific uh Euro style game that is built around technology trees uh where you are going to be sending out your agents onto the board and you've got kind of branching paths that they're going to be following to gain uh technologies that are going to eventually allow you to score points.

But just a really clever game, a theme I really love. It is kind of this cyberpunk theme. Um, I like the fact that it's somewhat modular, too, because there are five different kind of styles or or modules, and you're playing with three of those five, and depending upon which three of the five you have in, it's going to impact the style of game you have. So, really still like Atlas Lost. At number four was my number two last year, and that is Harrow County. A fantastic, fantastic asymmetric style game from Off-the- Page Games. This publisher is known for taking uh graphic novels or comics and building board games within those worlds. And this is no exception. Um this was another game uh from this publisher that I kind of was introduced to the graphic novel uh from it. I love the the comic. I think the game is fantastic. It really only went down just because a couple other games kind of shot in front of it. I mean, that makes sense, right? Still a terrific game. Number three is actually my number one from last year and that is Arcs. Still a tremendous tremendous design. It's a little bit tough to get to the table. Um that that has a part of it. Um but it's still just such a clever game. It uses trick taking um as a action selection system. It's not purely uh trick although definitely it has a lot of the conceits of that but there's also area majority. There's combat in the game. It's a very largecale game.

Bit esoteric, which is part of the reasons why it's hard to get to the table, but man, what a fantastic game. Number two is where I feel like I am writing a wrong from last year. It's new to the list, and this is Andromeda's Edge. I made a decision last year to keep Andromeda's Edge out of the 2024 lists. And I did that because I was having to make this decision or I felt I was having to make this decision between uh is this just strictly a re-implementation of Dwellings of Eldervil or isn't it? And I think I got maybe a little too precious about it last year if I'm being honest. I think that it stands apart enough now after playing it uh many many times. It's just a fantastic game. This one is based in space. The previous game was a fantasy game. The theme, sure, your mileage may vary. Um, I'm kind of ambivalent about the space theme, but I'm not ambivalent about this game. Just a fantastic kind of hybrid style game where it's a Euro game at heart, but it has some of the trappings of uh kind of the uh the more American style games. There's some, you know, elements of combat going on and and dice rolling and things along those lines, but just a fantastic game. And and yes, I'm going to write some wrongs.

And Edge really probably deserved to be there last year. Number one jumped all the way from number seven and uh this is Wondrous Creatures. This is a game that I just played so many times last year and this year I should say uh really more this year. It came out towards the end of last year and so I hadn't played it as much and so it was seven. It was still a very impressive game to me but throughout 2025 I have played it so many times, taught it to so many people. It's a a Euro style game where you are placing a worker onto a board to gather resources. You're usually using those resources to purchase cards. Those cards allow you to take special actions. There's a tremendous amount of comboic type of turns in the game where you can do several things that kind of branch and trigger off of each other. So, it's very satisfying in that way. It's a great worker placement game. It's a great tableau building game. It's a great point sality type of game. Um, and the production is through the roof. I can say that about many of the games on this list. I am a shallow gamer. Uh, but this certainly fits that bill. It is a beautiful production, a fantastic game, and my number one, if you ask me now from 2024, that is Wondrous Creatures.

All right. Well, that's going to do it for this list. As I said, a snapshot in time. And who knows, these things could even shift around if I were to do this again this time next year. I imagine there might even be some more changes on there. But that's going to do it for this one. I'm Mike Delisio and I'll see you next time.

Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Hour YouTube channel.

Progress saved