Skip to main content
Loading video...

Curating My Collection (Ep. 1) | 8 Games On Their Way Out

Transcript 22:26

hey how's it going everyone carlo here from aycb and welcome to episode 1 of what will hopefully be an ongoing series here called curating my collection so this is where i'm going to talk about every once in a while i'm going to be getting rid of let's say probably five to ten games from my collection uh just either they've been played too much or i found something else that kind of replaces it and i'm just going to describe why i either do or don't like this game and why i'm moving on from it part of the reason for this is as our channel's been growing you know a lot of the time we do videos where we go really deep into one specific game and this is kind of an opportunity to for you guys to get an idea of what kind of games either we do or don't like and for us to be able to talk about more games so you've probably seen videos like this before especially if you watch a lot of uh board game stuff on youtube and i'll be completely honest this series was inspired by alex radcliff who runs a channel called board game co and he does a series called board games leaving my collection so uh shout out to alex it's a fantastic youtube channel and uh yeah i thank him for uh i guess i didn't specifically ask his permission but i have heard him say that he likes it when other people do these kind of videos and he likes hearing why people have games leaving their collection so yeah thanks in advance alex appreciate it um i will say going forward just for my criteria here heavy or more complex games i tend to hold to a bit of a higher standard when i'm deciding what games to keep in my collection just because a game that either any combination if it takes up more room on my shelf if it's rules that are hard to remember or if it's not going to get played as often i just find it harder to justify keeping those games around long term so you might see me getting rid of some heavier games that you think are really good and i might hold on to some

lighter games that aren't as good at times but that's the reason why so um anyways let's uh get right into it before i talk about the games i'm currently getting rid of but a year ago or so i got rid of five games they're the only five games i've gotten rid of so far which were settlers of catan which was uh you know obviously it's kind of a classic but i've just played it like hundreds of times i also got rid of seven wonders alhambra a lot of these kind of older classic games that i feel there's just newer versions that kind of do the same thing better i also got rid of between two cities just because i have between two castles and mad king ludwig now which to me is is my preferred version and i also got rid of lanterns which was a simple kind of tile laying game that i just i just have too many other tiling games i prefer so now we're going to go into the ones that i'm getting rid of now that i have here with me starting with merchants and marauders uh this was one of the very first games i owned probably one of the first 10 games in my collection i'm also getting rid of the seas of glory expansion which i'll lay down here for now if you're not familiar with this it's basically a game where you're uh in the caribbean and you're trying to decide whether you want to be basically a merchant or a pirate so everyone gets a captain with a bunch of stats at the start of the game like you've got scouting and influence and all this and you start with your ship and you can basically be a merchant and go around buying and selling goods and trying to seek out rumors to see if they're true or you can be a pirate and you can kind of go attack other people's ships and go steal from merchants and do that kind of thing and depending what direction you go you either have non-player pirates coming

after you if you're a merchant or you've got you know naval ships coming after you if you're a pirate it's a really involved game probably takes it says right on the box 180 minutes i think this came out about 10 years ago it kind of has that crossover feel between the more classic style like north american games and like more modern euro games where there's a lot like the resource management and stuff but it also has a lot of dice rolling a lot of randomness and to me what has kept the reason why this is leaving my collection is that i've probably played it about 10 to 12 times now over the last seven eight years that i've owned it like i said it takes about three hours and every time i go more than like six months without playing this i forget a bunch of the rules hard to get back to the table and again it goes back to what i said at the intro because it's such a heavy game it's competing with a lot of other heavy games in my collection that don't get played often and at this point i've played this enough times that it just it's not going to get played as much as something else it's not going to be at the top of my list so i'm kind of ready to move on and just have someone else be able to enjoy it if you are at all considering merchants and marauders i do highly recommend the sees of glory expansion with it it comes with i think 10 or 12 little modules that you can pick which ones you add in some make the game shorter or longer or make it less random or more random so you can really tailor the game to how you want it again i've had a lot of fun with merchants from routers over the years but i'm just sort of ready to move on so that's one that will be leaving my collection but i'll definitely have some fond memories of that one for sure next up is a much newer game and this is forum treyjanum so this is by stefan

feld who has designed castles of burgundy amongst well more recently castles of tuscany and bonfire he's been around for a long time he's designed tons of games and i'll be honest i think i've only played three of his games i've played this castle's burgundy and castles of tuscany there's a bunch of others i've wanted to try ultimately so he's known as kind of this a lot of his games are are often referred to as kind of point salad where it's like no matter what you're doing whether you're getting three points or four points or one point here you're always getting points somewhere on your turn i didn't find this to be quite as point solid-y as some of his other games but there's a couple things that held me back from really enjoying this fully one of them is i think it's an issue with a lot of his games for me is the theme kind of feels very abstracted um even in like of the three games i have tried of is i like castles burgundy and tuscany much more than this but even in those the theme kind of feels a little obscure like it feels like other themes could have been paced on the same way and the game would have still made sense kind of thing forum trey janum i'm also not like super into roman history and what caught my eye about this game why i bought it in the first place was what happens on your personal player board so in this game you're basically it's a political game you're sending envoys um to to basically build this giant forum but you have your own player board where you're doing stuff with them and everything you have on your own player board where you're flipping these little uh tiles to reveal abilities that allow you to upgrade stuff i really like that part but the part with the central board that everyone's kind of playing on it felt so kind of disconnected and i

felt like after we played it even a month later i was like i don't remember any of the rules basically like it wasn't one of those games where you learn a rule and it's like oh thematically this rule makes sense because of this so it's going to stick so i don't know what it was i i enjoyed it enough but i felt like it's not going to be i haven't really had the desire to go back to it all that much and again for a game that's going to take probably you know hour and a half two hours to play uh with a few players it just uh yeah loses out some better games in my collection so that's forum trade jam okay next up this was a really tough one imperial settlers this is designed by ignaci trichebechek and published by portal games uh so ignacy i believe he's actually the owner and ceo of the company this game came out about five or six years ago he's been designing games for about 10 years um i had really high hopes for this one and of all the games i'm getting rid of this time this is one of the ones that i was most on the fence about i got this and imperial settlers empires of the north which was came out a couple years ago at the same time and i thought i'll get them both i'll see which one i like more i'll keep one and get rid of the other so it's basically a tableau building game uh everyone gets a faction at the start there's like the romans the barbarians the egyptians and the japanese and you get a unique deck of cards uh and basically you get a hand of cards and you're putting you know spending resources to build buildings you can use those buildings to generate more resources you can convert resources to points you can you know attack other players and that sort of thing you're basically settling but you have to be aware of everyone around you

because people can basically raise your buildings with these tokens that make you your buildings get destroyed and stuff there's a few things i didn't really like about the game one was the cards have such small text with a bunch of empty space around them okay this is where you got to be keeping track of not only your own buildings but other people's buildings so if i'm looking across the table and i can't see what someone else is building does but i have all these things i can do to either destroy people's buildings i found a lot of the game was what does that card do again okay and what is that one okay okay and that one your car okay okay okay and then you can't really see what stuff what what's going on and then you're trying to decide well how do i know which building to raise or what to even be aware of that was one of my issues with it another issue was they had this big deck of common cards that you're drawing through that everyone gets a lot of the time is going to pick out the same cards um and even just the raising buildings like it felt like there was it was offering you the player interaction with the opportunity to raise the building but the games that i played it felt like a lot of the time i didn't see the value in it like there was a better move that would give me more points if i just left my opponent alone and worked on my own stuff so i don't know it felt like there was um you know and even some of the factions there were certain cards where like there's only one copy of this card in your deck and it's such an important card that if it's near the bottom and you don't get it this game it can really hurt you whereas if it's in your starting hand that might be a big difference maker so there are all these little things that i really enjoyed it it's got a great solo mode too but i thought you know what i'm probably going to enjoy imperial settlers empires the north more so i thought i would set this aside and try

playing that one so this is one that's going to be leaving my collection um but it is a great game that i would recommend which brings me to my next pick or the next game leaving my collection which is imperial settlers empires of the north another sad one another tough one um one that even as i'm talking about it right now i'm wondering if i'm making a mistake getting rid of this and or the original imperial settlers so this promised i mean it's same designer same company i mean you can see the artwork is fantastic in this so this looked like a nicer looking game it's got six factions right in the base box compared to four everything seemed a little more thematic like in the original imperial settlers you just have this automatic production that happens between phases where you get a bunch of goods automatically in this game you have to actually go use a harvest action to get goods uh and there's other things where you have to you can like sail to an island in this game to visit an island and then you can get those cards added into your tableau so everything seemed more thematic and the extra two factions and then being a little more asymmetrical or at least that's what it seemed like really drew me in i've played this now solo a bunch of times probably six times i've played it two players a couple times and i did get a chance to play the three players once and every time it felt a little bit short for me i feel like when a game promises asymmetric factions it was my fault for expecting too much i was thinking of a game like i played not too long ago the voyages of marco polo where you get this crazy feels like game breaking power at the start where like you're playing the game a specific way based on the power

you have and with empires of the north i felt like the promise of that was there but it didn't quite feel like it lived up to it there's one or two of the factions maybe where it did feel more unique it felt like what you were doing kind of pointed you in a different direction and made you play the game differently but for some of them it felt like whether i'm changing this resource into points or a different faction is converting a different resource into points or i'm doing this to this a lot of the time i felt like you know even though i'm using different resources or a different path the start and the net result ended up kind of being similar the other thing was i mentioned the sailing before so you sail to these islands you get these cards but the island cards are pretty much the same as the buildings you're building they don't have too much variety in how they work every building every island you have in front of you at the end of the game is worth a point so yeah you're sailing and it might be more thematic but whether i sail to get an island or someone just uses you know a wood and a stone to build something it might have a similar effect anyway i don't know there was a lot about this game that i was i was hoping for a bit more but every time i just felt like um the other thing i want to mention actually sorry quickly about empires north and both that and imperial settlers is they're games that i think work best at solo were two players they're the type of games i don't know if i'd ever even want to play them with four part of it is again that looking at cards what does your card do what does your card do kind of thing even with three it might slow down a bit um but i don't want to sound too negative about either of these games or the designer or the company because i really do respect the designer and the company the way they operate portal games supports the heck out of their games there's tons of expansions for both of these games still ongoing

if these are games that you like and you're going to get into them you'll be playing them for a long time and i think for me if i'd had a more dedicated group who was playing these maybe a bit more regularly delving into the factions and stuff maybe it would have stuck a little bit more but when it comes to a tableau builder these ones do take a little longer usually hour and a half to two hours and for me it's just it's it's competing with tough um it's got tough competition i mean i love race for the galaxy and innovation and res arcana and all these other tableau builders that play quicker and that to me offer offer maybe more interesting decisions um but i'm told i should maybe be considering 51st state because it's a similar game to this and imperial settlers with a different theme so i mean let me know in the comments below what do you think of these two or if you've played 51st state do you think that's a much better game not really sure but and this might be one i might regret down the line but sadly i will be saying goodbye to empires of the north now we're getting into some shorter somewhat lighter games next up here is kingdom builder so this is by donald x vacarino who has also designed dominion uh this actually won the spielberg's yard in 2012.

it's a really great game i've probably played this i mean the physical version i've maybe only played 20 30 times but i've played the app probably like 50 to 70 times or something like that and that's part of the reason i'm getting rid of this the other thing is i feel like this i mean i said this designer has also designed dominion and i feel like this falls victim to the same thing where for its time it was amazing and if i had played this i'm sure in 2012 when it first came out i would have probably had my mind blown by this i probably played it for the first time 2015-16 i loved it for a few years but it just feels a little bit dated now compared to some of the other games that are out there um it's basically you know an abstract game where you there's a different types of land it looks kind of like a settlers of catan type map and on your turn you flip over a card and it tells you where you're pla placing your settlements on land somewhere there's a bit of randomness in the sense that you have to build whatever the land tells you you have to build um there's just other games that i've played for example in my collection blue lagoon is kind of what has replaced this because it has a similar thing where you're building out from somewhere there's networking you're cutting off people's roots and stuff like that and kingdom builder felt like one of those ones where even though the rules felt simple enough it still felt like a game that you'd never fully understood what you were doing or what the strategy was until you played it once before and i just found that it wasn't particularly welcoming to new players and again it's just one that i haven't played in a few years now and i've played so much of it in the past i really like it it's a great game but just one that i don't have much desire

to play anymore these days so i probably wouldn't turn down a game of it and the other thing is if i was going to get into this anymore there's a whole bunch of expansions out there so if i was going to keep this i would instead just like get rid of this and go buy the big box and they're also coming out with one called winter kingdom at some point this year i believe which is an updated version on this so i will be keeping an eye out for that great game if you haven't tried it yet highly recommend it that is kingdom builder next up we've got magic maze so this was a 2017 uh spiel of the yards nominee it lost out to uh king domino i believe it was it's designed by casper lapp you might be familiar because he designed god's love dinosaurs which came out i believe last year from panda source games this is a there's been kind of a bit of a trend with these games these past few years and i think this was maybe not the first i think hanabi would have been the first as far as i know but in terms of these cooperative games with limited communication or no communication so if you've played hanabi that's the one where you have the cards that you're looking at the back and everyone else can see the front of the cards but you can't communicate where there's limited communication this one is for one to eight players it's a real time cooperative game the idea is your adventurer's stuck inside some sort like a mall or something like that and basically everyone has a role and a power sort of thing and everyone has you're basically moving through this dungeon but each player can only move this pawn in one direction so let's say i can only move this thing forward the player on my left can only move things

to the right but you can't talk or say when someone else is supposed to go or when you're going there's just sort of an action pawn you move this thing in front of someone and it's supposed to be a kind of a hey do something so it ends up being a game of everyone's sitting there in silence putting this pawn in front of someone else kind of nudging them to do something and you're kind of like well i don't know what they want me to do like i guess i'll move this thing forward and when we tried playing i found there were a couple times where and this happens with a lot of these games it happens with the mind as well where people sometimes will bend the rules of the game in a way where they'll be like no no don't do that and you're like well you're not supposed to say that and it's like well but you're not going to restart the whole scenario just because someone kind of said so you just keep playing and then you do sing and someone goes oh no don't do that don't and then so you kind of have to be on the same page with everyone you're playing with you have to sort of agree like let's all just like it's going to be more fun if we obey the rules if we're if we're losing and we're just going to try and cheat to win then like it kind of defeats the purpose you know like that's not the intention of the game and what it comes down to for me with getting rid of this is it's been unplayed on my shelf for a couple years i'm not i don't play a ton of cooperative games but when i do like the crew the quest for planet nine which recently uh came out is just an amazing cooperative game with that limited communication that i love this is just it's never gonna beat out that it would probably never beat out the mind for me either it just feels kind of random with like why is it that i can only move one direction i don't know it was an interesting idea and i think again it sort of paved the way for this genre a lot and it is a fun game it's just not one that i've played much and i don't see myself playing again anytime soon so i

will be getting rid of magic maze next up we've got one night ultimate werewolf by bezier games uh this one i've had for at least six seven years but i haven't played it in probably three or four years at least it's a social deduction game where everyone gets a roll dealt out at the start of the game or the round the rounds usually take like five or ten minutes if you've played that uh mafia it's similar to that you basically are either like a werewolf or a villager you look at your roll card you put them down and then everyone kind of closes their eyes you can play the game with one person kind of leading the way as like the moderator or you can play with an app that kind of does it for you um it's a really interesting game it can create like it's one of those games where at its best the best moments can be incredible it can be so rewarding when you pulled off you know tricking someone and around where you pulled off this perfect play but when it falls flat it can kind of be like oh whatever you know it's it's not disappointing or anything but i feel like it's a game you're only going to get to the maximum enjoyment level of this if you have people who are used to it and are playing it regularly anytime i've introduced it to new players we've kind of played a couple rounds then it's gone back on the shelf and i haven't ever gotten really into it with a group the other thing is i'm not personally crazy about social deduction games um i'm never gonna be the person who's like hey should we pull that game off the shelf where we see who's best at lying to each other like i'm not saying there's like i know you agree to that it's sort of a contract you're getting into in this game i'm not saying that playing games with your friends where

you lie to each other is bad not by any means i've played a lot of those and there's definitely a time and place but for me it's never going to be my favorite genre and there's just been other social deduction games i've played since that i've enjoyed more um actually on the shelf behind me dylan somewhere here has uh uh deception murder murder in hong kong um there's some other ones i want to try so it's just a game that doesn't get much play for me these days and i will be getting rid of it that's one night ultimate werewolf and last on my list for this round is welcome to the dungeon this is one of these small box games from yellow i think it was like 10 or 12 bucks totally worth it i've gotten tons of play out of this over the years but it's one that i haven't come back to in probably two three years now just because i think i i kind of saw all it had all it had to offer very interesting little game it's just a simple deck of cards um and you're basically it's a push your luck game where you're going around the table there's a deck of cards with these little like monsters and you pick a hero with these stats that you lay out in front and the idea is it's sort of a game of chicken we're going to be going around the table and on your turn you're either going to pass and stay out of the round or you're gonna draw a card from the dungeon to look at and you're gonna put it i camera if it's in the dungeon or out you can do one of two things i think and basically once all the players have passed whoever is the last player left has to take the hero with whatever items are left and go into the dungeon and defeat these monsters so you're basically on your turn either making the dungeon harder by putting stuff in or you're taking items away from the hero but you

might be the one who gets stuck if everyone else passes you might be the one stuck taking that hero and going into the dungeon and then you basically have to see if you can survive all the monsters in the dungeon with your items or they might defeat you and it's the certain player to win a first player win a certain number of rounds wins so very cool game i enjoyed it a lot if you're looking for kind of just like another light easy kind of family weight game to have on your shelf it's a great option they even did welcome back to the dungeon which i think came out with a few more uh classes and some new monsters that kind of refreshed it a little bit so it's a great little game it's just now over the years i've kind of acquired a lot of these small box games and it's just it's got tough competition and it's not one that i see coming back to the table anytime soon so i will be getting rid of welcome to the dungeon so that is it for this time um let me know what you think am i making any big mistakes here are there any of these games that i am going to regret later um i really am curious to hear what you think or if you see one that i've gotten rid of if you know a similar game out there that you think oh if you you know you didn't like this for this reason you might like this game instead let me know in the comments below also let me know what you thought i mean again we don't want to be spending our time making videos that you guys don't want to see so let me know do you want me to spend more time talking about how the game is played or why dare didn't like it any feedback at all is welcome so thank you for watching and we'll see you next time on episode 2 of curating my collection whenever that is hopefully in a couple months thanks take care

Progress saved