10 Board Games Ranked - Episode 20
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another month in review so in this series of videos I talk about all of the new to me board games that I played during the previous month this month covering December 2022 and I rank those games for my least favorite all the way up to my most favorite now as usual I have a big variety of games here we've got old games we've got new games we've got very light games and we've got pretty heavy games as well now before I get started on the 10 games I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer when it comes to purchasing board games here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order at number 10 I have the first of the 2022 releases with theology so theory is an Airy majority game that's quite different to a lot of the other titles of that genre out there and it reminded me a little bit of dominant species as in this one you have these are two priests pieces moving around this much to the grid trying to convert people into your cult or your religion and you're going to do that by taking one of four actions so I did quite like the way on your turn you had quite a simple turn structure activate one of the actions and you cannot do the same action back to back now you're going to be putting these presence tokens down on the borders of these different hexes and triggering a conversion and trying to convert them to your colors based on those majorities you can summon monsters into play you're trying to establish these different kind of temples I suppose and it's going to be a race to get to a certain amount of
temples on the board based on different conditions now there is some kind of unpredictability with this one maybe a bit too much for my comfort level Comfort level where you have some take that cards or some aha moment cards where there's no way you could predict what other people are going to do there's monsters that can come into play which you know throw the rules on its when it's siding you know changed core rules which are quite hard to remember and generally I found the board state to be very busy you know there's pieces everywhere there's tokens everywhere it's hard to remember what each player can do and what each God can do and those style of games are a bit of a deterrent for me and I tend to find them a little bit overwhelming and not enjoyable and sadly that's how I felt about theology now I did quite like some of the production choices as normally these styles of games come with tons of plastic whereas this one all the monsters were more like traditional wooden meeples which I thought was quite a cool touch but other than that the gameplay is just not my style so therefore you know it's not for me hence why it's number 10. at number nine I have Zuli so Zuli is definitely a family-friendly almost child-like drafting game something in the vein of sushi go as each round you are gonna have a hand of cards you're going to be closed drafting these cards in a pass and trash fashion taking either animals out or taking these enclosures out and eventually once everyone's drafted all their cards you're going to be building a zoo with those cars trying to get the right animals in the right enclosures some of these animals will combo with each other some of them will take up more room than others so you need to make sure you have the right sized enclosures and you have these kind
of tacked on abilities as well where you can end up breaking rules like normally you wouldn't be able to put dangerous animals together or you cannot mix dangerous and friendly animals together whereas some cars can let you break those rules there's quite a cool balancing aspect of the game where you need to be making sure that you not only have the animals which are going to score your points of course but you need to make sure you have the enclosures for those animals because any animal that you can't kind of cage it's going to be worth negative points at the end of the round and I also quite like the forward trajectory of this one where you know each round you keep the animals in your hand draft more of them and then you can rebuild your zoo each time so you're always getting more and more points okay it was definitely nothing negative about this game it's just not quite what I'm looking for you know for my collection but I passed this one on to a friend of mine who's got you know younger children and I'm sure they're going to be having a great time with it so for what it does I think it does extremely well but just not for me personally at number eight I have project l so this is a pulliamino Style game mixed with a degree of engine building as essentially you are going to have these really nice tactile plastic pieces and you're trying to slot them in at these cardboard tiles which I've almost dual layered and trying to fill up those shapes perfectly with these different kind of you know Tetris style pieces um but I like the engine building aspect of this one because every time you complete one of these tiles not only are you going to add that tile to your scoring pal and which of course is the objective of the game but you're also going to get rewarded with a new shape so the more you complete these tiles the more shapes you
are going to get which lets you complete the more ambitious tasks out there which will score you more points of course so it has this cool forward momentum again another game that I like the tan structure of where on your on your turn you get to take three actions which are going to be either take a new shape upgrade an existing shape to a bigger one or a better one take new tiles or even Place one polyominate piece on each of your tiles as a mast action which again you can really play that quite efficiently by adding up or collecting the tiles you need or the tokens you need take a wood mass action and completing several tiles in one time that always feels satisfying when you do that so I don't think this game did anything tremendously new it felt like a hybrid of a bunch of different games almost a bit like silver and gold if you're familiar with that one but that extra layer of engine building you know I did like that and it's definitely a game that I'm not going to object to play despite not setting my world on fire it definitely does what it does quite well so that is Project L at number eight at number seven I have hot lead which is a new card game by Dr Reina kanitzia this one is featherweight lights you know extremely easy to play and it's a simultaneous card selection game as each round you're going to reveal a number of scoring cards equal to the number of players and then to obtain those scoring cards everybody is going to select one of their numbered cards reveal them at the same time whoever's paid the highest number will take their leftmost card whoever's played the you know the lowest number is going to take the rightmost card and so on and you're trying to collect these different sets of these different crimes I suppose but you don't want to collect too many of the same type because you can go bust
if you collect four of the same this additional twist as well where if you collect one of each type you get bonus points or if you have exactly three of any type you get some bonus points as well so you want to be on that real fine line of what you're trying to collect now I did like how Breezy this game is you know extremely easy to play takes around 10 to 15 minutes I do feel like the random distribution of the numbered cars can be a bit swing at times because you know sometimes just by sheer luck somebody might get a bunch of like middling cars or someone might get all the low valued cars which might make it difficult for them to get a you know a well-balanced variety of the different cards available but you know it doesn't try to be anything it's not in that like factor I think made the game better and for a 15 minute game you could do a lot worse than hot lead at number six I have lacrimosa which was one of my most anticipated games for 2022 and you can see here this game definitely didn't inspire me tremendously I thought it was a solid world well-rounded game probably rank it back now six six and a half out of ten but I was wanting you know a nine or a 10 out of ten here because I love the theme and the setting so much now I'm a big classical music fan but sadly the game itself despite being solid and nothing glaringly obviously wrong with it it just didn't do anything new or anything exciting it was very much middle of the road Euro mechanisms the only thing I did like was the way that you did have a small deck of cards and you're managing that deck of cards to take to take actions and to improve your income for the following rounds so this kind of system where you have to tuck these cards in was cool because to get
one thing you're gonna have to sacrifice something else and you're even upgrading those cards as you go to get more powerful action so even get double or triple actions so I did like that it had a good it had a good degree of full progression as you know the deck would get better and better as you go but all the different aspects of the game were solid but they were just nothing there to yeah really aspire to hook me to come back and explore further I felt like once I played this a couple of times I'd seen everything the game had to offer and if you are a more seasoned Euro gamer and played a ton of them this game isn't going to offer anything new at all at number five I have Galileo project which is another 2022 release now this is a medium lightweight Tableau engine building Style game as you are drafting these cards from this communal board and these cards are going to come in the form of these characters which will either give you instant abilities or endgame scoring by tucking them under your player board then you are using influence those characters give you in order to acquire these robots and these robots are going to allow you to climb these tracks Associated to the planets that they're assigned to and those tracks will not only give you end game points but they'll also give you um you'll increase your capacity to do things in the game by allowing you to tuck more cards on your board or scoring your points based on certain types of robots you've collected and you've also got some public objectives that you're trying to race towards a very nice tone structure in this game you'll either take a character card buy a robot card or buy a technology card which will give you again a one-off or ongoing ability great for momentum you know there's no pulling
teeth in this game Everything feels like you're moving forward only takes 100 hours of play and another game where if you are looking for a Gateway Plus or something to bridge the gap between a Gateway and a Midway Euro this is a fantastic option for that because it introduces a lot of well Blended mechanisms so that is Galileo project at number five okay so let's get into the top four games now and this is where my commendations begin so at number four I have municipium which is an older Rhino kenitzia title that has very much flown under the radar definitely nobody's talking about this one but this is a pretty quirky almost an area majority game as you are trying to control these different buildings in Rome and you're going to do that by moving your little player pawns around and controlling these regions is useful for a number of different reasons so number one you want to be a majority for when this kind of um prefect piece moves around the back and when it lands in these certain locations if you have the majority there then you collect these kind of bonus tokens which is the uh you know the aim of the game is to collect different sets of meeples all these bonus tokens which can proxy any of the meeples and for every set you get you're going to gain a coin and then it's going to be a race to get to four or five coins depending on how long you want the game to be but also controlling these regions is useful for the fact that each of these locations has a unique ability assigned to it which can give you a lot of stroke and a lot of power during the game and those things can be things such as only needing three to complete a set rather than just the the four one could
be B2 um you know beat the priority in terms of initiative order which can be very important uh in this game one could be to you know just deploy more meeples on the board to give you the ability to get the ones that you really want um it's actually a game with some Nuance involved when I was teaching this to you know two new people hadn't played before I know I haven't played it before either of course but once I taught this to people I'm thinking I'm not sure how this is going to go because it sounds very dry I think it's not going to you know not going to bring out a lot of fun and people aren't going to enjoy it but when we got to that half point in the game I think that a switch just triggered in everybody's head and think you know what this is actually a very clever game there's more here than we initially thought and again really starts to come alive as you start to try and block people getting from certain people that they want and so on it is actually a very interesting design and I'm quite excited to show you guys more about it at number three I have trombone which is a two-player only game that brings back memories or has a lot of similarities to a game called Lost Cities but to slightly you know saying that I do think that these games are different enough to warrant only both but this one is another card game where you are trying to create runs of cars from low to high you can have gaps if you like you can create you know ones threes fives sevens tens so on or you can create every Gap in between if you if you manage to pull that off but I like in this one every round you are forced to play um at least one card on these different rows of colored cards and that is going to be a countdown timer as to when that type of card is going to cash out
and as soon as you play that fourth card then every single say red card is going to cash out and that can benefit you or benefit your opponent so you want to be making sure that you are at least competing under different fields because if your opponent keeps on playing red cards and they had a great red run then they're going to keep on scoring those red cards and you're not so you've got to be very careful of that but the game's done a great job of you know making sure that if you want to keep on spanning the same um color then you're not building any more runs of it so you're going to have to give up one thing in order to do another and this game is very tight in terms of the way you manage your money because in order to actually build the runs in the first place you have to invest in these station cards which will increase your multipliers and the bigger multiplier you want the more expensive it becomes so sometimes you have to give up a bunch of costs that you can potentially use for your runs just in order to convert it to money because it has that kind of multi-use card system a very well designed two-player game one that I think should be on or should be more appreciated more talked about in the Realms of you know two-player only games because you know when people talk about two-player games they normally talk about the same few titles this one is Rock Solid it could definitely hold its own with those classic two-player games and again it should be in print but sadly uh it's not so that is tram Barn at number three at number two I have Amsterdam which is a reprint of Macau by Stefan Feld so this is a weird game it's a kind of a Resource Management pickup and deliver Style game
with a bit of engine building as well as you are acquiring these cards or in fact you're forced to take these cards um however if you can't get these cars built in time then they can end up acquiring you negative points but what you're trying to do is you're trying to collect resources to move your little boat around the dock do a little pickup and deliver game going on try to increase your presence on the main map itself but I love love the way that you have to manage your resources in this game as you are drafting resources or you're taking resources through a dice draft and basically the higher value dice are great because they will mean you get more resources so if you say take five black resources or pick the five black dice then you're going to get five black resources however you are not going to get those resources until five turns time so it has this longer term planning thing going on here where you can take fewer resources but get them sooner or take loads of resources that have to wait a while what a cool twist I've never seen it before and I remember reading it in the rubric for the first time thinking you know what that's a very cool mechanism and I've not seen that before and I'm sure I'm going to like it and I'm very happy to say that in practice that mechanism works as well as it reads now as with Stephen fell games this is pretty you know it's very mechanical it's a bunch of mechanism put together there's no real thematic ties here but it does pick up and deliver well I tend to like pick up and deliver games there's some good planning there as well um quite brain burnery um it can be quite punishing at times and sometimes you can have great grandiose turns sometimes you can have pretty pathetic turns because you might
only have one or two resources to play with but that's all part of the game and it's definitely one of those games where the more you play it the better you're going to get at it because right now I'm terrible at this one but I'm really intrigued to get better at it which is always a good sign so that is Amsterdam at number two and finally at number one and my favorite game for December 2022 is first class now first class is essentially the card game version of Russian railroads which just so happens to be one of my favorite games of all time now of course there are a lot of similarities between the two but there are some differences as well this one is more streamlined it's easier to get to the table and easier to teach now this one as I mentioned it is a card game and it's a card drafting game as all the actions you could take are displayed out each round in three rows of cards now of course you're going to draft those cards and take the corresponding action but as soon as a certain number of cars from each row is taken that are made of this card is going to get wiped from the round so you need to be very careful about how you prioritize the things you're taking and much like Russian railroads you are trying to improve and upgrade your Railway line to increase the yield of points it pays out during scoring phases you're trying to build a separate track as well to give you instant at instant points and ongoing engine building benefits every time it comes to a scoring phase might let you you know upgrade more cars or let you move your train even further and everything in this game feels good and I really really love the money mechanism in this game as when you acquire coins you add them onto your
player board in a particular order and you have a strict capacity as to how many coins you can keep but as you fill up your board you always have to go from lowest to highest but you can actually pull those coins off to take a bonus action in any order you want and those and the more coins you get the more powerful the actions get as well which will let you upgrade any card or that you can move your conductor or move your train it will let you go put new zero cards out there to increase your Railway Network or increase the length of it again everything in this game feels good it it has a great form of momentum where in the first round you really don't gain too much you know you probably get 10 points here all there and then the phone around you're getting you know dozens and dozens of points quite easily so again it always feels very satisfying much like the original Russian railroads a great implementation of the game is how you do a proper card game and do I you know if I'm completely honest with myself do I need both of them in the collection I'm not quite sure long term but for right now I'm enjoying having both of them and you know I think they're both great or Russian Rarities right up there for me but first class is not far off considering it is so similar but different in a lot of ways as well and some modularity here so if you want to spice the game up a little bit you can pick and choose which parts of the game you want to include again that adds a bit more life in to the game so there we have it that's my number one game first class so there we have it those are all the games that I've played throughout December 2022 hopefully you've enjoyed the video if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel and please do let me know what game has been the best for you during December 2022 because I'd love to
hear it but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye